Porcupine Tree - Shesmovedon (Deadwing ver.)

[@femkilmer2909]

Fun fact: According to Gavin Harrison, this re-recording only happened because some DJ in America told their then label at the time (Lava/Atlantic) he would play Shesmovedon on the radio all the time if they re-recorded it w/Gavin cause it was his favorite song ever. He never did.

[@planetboondock2383]

That is not a fun fact at all.

[@Dilly137]

It's because hesmovedon

[@Archived0]

@@Dilly137 haha

[@ThOutRider2]

@@Dilly137 lmfao

[@user-mz9ig5id3o]

The trolling was worth anyway tho

[@bhootnath858]

Doesnt matter which version of this song I listen to, the guitar solo in this song drives me wild!!!!

[@trashface123]

Jugantor Chetia you and me both man

[@subhratanusarkar8993]

Hey dont forget me

[@emmawatson2224]

Me too :)

[@NimavatCR]

I am little late at the party but count me please!

[@Cygnusx1977]

Best guitar solo

[@markcusblakc8615]

most underrated song in the history of music industry, Steven W. deserves a grammy!!

[@mynameis.6808]

ahhh there are to many ''most underated songs out there''

[@9899187239]

Steven Wilson is above the commercialized bullshit of Grammy. He doesn't even strive for that.

[@blackhorse3544]

Steven hunger is for something else not for shit Grammy

[@SnipeFuzionzZ]

Jitendra Vishal You say that yet he has “Grammy nominated” artist on the front page of his website.

[@markcusblakc8615]

@@SnipeFuzionzZ you also realize this comment is from 3 years ago

[@sicilian2010]

This jam will never ever ever get old. Deadwing is one phenomenal album.

[@KrugerGesagt]

To think I'd find this song after a relationship dissolved into nothing, this really helped me. Thank you.

[@psychonaut13]

It made it worse for me lol 😆

[@debayanmetalcoreghosh]

@@psychonaut13 same same

[@sabyasachisenapati3619]

My girlfriend back in my school days used to tell me stories of her train travels. I explored it and found it truly fascinating too. We got separated and she moved on, still her memories make me long for her. J

[@jannedbal958]

Dig this

[@sonricssss]

I really like how the voice gets saturated at 1:50 in this and the lightbulb sun version. It's a nice touch

[@lelekoJumboJet]

It's nice indeed. Seem to be a megaphone being used, just like Muse's "Feeling Good"

[@triyambakam5807]

Ocean of emotions in that solo

[@karlsnook976]

Seriously... What a song. Every version has its charm.

[@mazrio128]

Gavin. Gavin Harrison in da house!!!!

[@PlaceboPlease]

drummer here. can confirm.

[@LamziLamziLamzi]

another drummer here. can confirm.

[@emilianooviedo270]

@Marcus Graham another drummer here confirms

[@dinokatdrummer]

Another drummer here boys, confirming

[@sentihcn]

Not a drummer. Can still confirm, even all these years later.

[@scatteredstars80AD]

THIS ENTIRE ALBUM IS MAGGIICCCC!!!!!!

[@hladankrompir]

I just bumped onto this song, doesn't listening to PT a lot. But this, this song blowed my mind away. The Solo is just incredible. Sorry for my bad english, it's not my mother tongue.

[@ricardomauricioaraya7625]

There is something about this song that gives me chills, it's just such an amazing song

[@cfarinaaz]

I think Deadwing may be my favorite album by them...

[@Dehangus]

This is a Lightbulb Sun song

[@Chuixupu]

This is a re-recording of the song that was released on Deadwing, though.

[@toprak3479]

I can't decide between In Absentia, Deadwing and Fear of a Blank Planet

[@kunalkumar8217]

It used to be my favourite but then The Incident surpassed it for me!

[@lofabred]

Deadwing has been loaded into my car CD changer for probably a year now. Still not tired of it.

[@OneOfTheLostOnes]

I know right.... it's not the most elaborate solo in the wold but it's so heartfelt.... it's incredible. it's perfect for the song.

[@primozstamcar4111]

why can't i ever get through the guitar solos in both versions without crying?

[@The3DP]

oh gavin...even the simplest of his fills always blows my mind.

[@oaspe]

Love the chords so simple yet the voice harmony so beautiful. "She changes every time you look....."

[@iloveNgany]

This version has the proper drum fill before the solo. Best part of the song IMHO.

[@touhouguyII]

Brings tears to my eyes.

[@MartinovKofeel]

3:18 just just perfect

[@onthedocks8796]

Damned! All voices in the chorus is like a heaven.

[@eduardmead]

How has it taken me 10 years after first hearing PT to discover this track??

[@Chuixupu]

This version of the song was released as a hidden track on the US release of Deadwing. I actually forgot about it because it's not listed, it's one of those tracks that starts after some dead space.

[@AYURBHATTA]

I'm lucky to have discovered PT at an early age! 🙏 Gods.

[@baconrocks1720]

+Ayur Bhatta u are lucky. like i was lucky to discover pink floyd at an early age! my two faves!

[@nolbertopalma30]

baconrocks 1

[@subigyabikramthapa5198]

I'm lucky to have met a lucky person who introduced me to the Gods lol. Forever thankful mate :)

[@omairsh8]

That SOLO fucking hell. Steven is such a gifted guitar player. One of my favourites

[@fuzzylogiceire]

Incredible intricate fill 30 seconds in.

[@omairsh8]

That's the beauty of Gavin. My favourite drummer for sure

[@StefBelgium]

There you go with the sticking: L RR L KK L R LL R LL R LL RL K+crash Orchestration: 1 accent snare left hand, 2 ghost notes on the snare right hand, Hi hat left hand, kick, kick, 1 ghost note on the snare left hand, 1 accent low tom right hand, 2 ghost notes on snare left hand, 1 accent medium tom right hand, 2 ghost notes on snare left hand, 1 accent high tom right hand, 2 accent on the snare right then left hand, kick + crash.

[@FACEL1FT]

@@StefBelgiumCrazy to see such fresh comments on Porcupine Tree videos, but as a drummer I’ll have to try that out

[@suprotuffboy]

You move in waves You never retrace Your newest craze Straight out of the Face by the bed unread I'm left behind Like all the others Some fall for you It doesn't make much difference if they do She changes every time you look By summer it was all gone, now she's moved on She called you every other day So savior it it's all gone, now she's moved on So for a while Everything seemed new Did we connect? Or was it all just biding time for you? She changes every time you look By summer it was all gone, now she's moved on She called you every other day So savior it it's all gone, now she's moved on she's moved on she's moved on she's moved on She changes every time you look By summer it was all gone, now she's moved on She called you every other day So savior it it's all gone, now she's moved on Called other day She's moved on Called other day She's moved on

[@Stringer13ell]

No

[@rayhanmorshed535]

Thanks to her for moving on. Otherwise, we wouldnt get this masterpiece out of SW and PT. I hope she listened to this song and saw what she left behind.

[@l3mp3]

Gavin’s golden touch to an already amazing piece

[@mandyfulton9854]

This is one of the best songs ever

[@WolfenSteed]

That guitar is simply amazing. i'd love to be able to do that, but just glad to be able to enjoy and appreciate it!

[@ItsMeSonakshi]

Those 9 people seem to dislike eargasmic music. Pity.

[@undertaker4751]

Or prefer the original one.

[@RoflcoptersaurusRex]

The guitar work on the entire deadwing album is fucking insane... My favorite. Nothing comes close

[@TylerFlemingON]

Only version I need. Deadwing is the masterpiece for me

[@davidgrube4188]

I aways hoped i wouldn’t relate to this song. Thanks PT for putting words to how i feel!

[@moonfool4042]

Mikael Akerfeldt with the harmony vocals!! :)

[@sanzzywaiba3790]

She called you every other days so saviour it, its all gone now she's moved on.. I felt it !!

[@michalsirotek9766]

Sooo good! And the guitar solo absolutely perfect :) Great!

[@kuroyama1]

No reason to downvote an opinion man. I'm partial to this version but Lightbulb Sun is amazing in its own right.

[@precisiontime]

This is the perfect song for summer sadnesses

[@jannedbal958]

Including winter;

[@ribhubhattacharya78]

@@jannedbal958 theres russia on ice for winters

[@pabloo2018]

Lyrics : You move in waves You never retrace Your newest craze Straight out of the face by the bed unread I'm left behind Like all the others Some fall for you It doesn't make much difference if they do She changes every time you look By summer it was all gone - now she's moved on She called you every other day So savior it it's all gone - now she's moved on So for a while Everything seemed new Did we connect? Or was it all just biding time for you? She changes every time you look (All gone away) By summer it was all gone - now she's moved on (She's moving on) She called you every other day (All gone away) So savior it it's all gone - now she's moved on (She's moving on) She's moved on She's moved on She's moved on She changes every time you look By summer it was all gone - now she's moved on She called you every other day (All gone away) So savior it it's all gone - now she's moved on (She's moving on) All gone away She's moving on All gone away She's moving on All gone away She's moving on All gone away She's moving on

[@planetboondock2383]

Thanks, friend

[@cheldom723]

How on earth can someone be so genius?

[@kleadguitarist]

I loved this cover of shemoved on. It mixes 3-4 versions of the taking the best part from each ,making it sound so much better. kzbin.info/www/bejne/jpKxq3SMpKarpas

[@DipayanBhui]

Takes my breath away, this song. Sometimes I feel, is this the best song ever written? For someone who's heartbroken?

[@touhouguyII]

This is my favorite version. I love 1:29 when they say the title then the note that is held in the background sounds. It makes me think of a sky right after a sunset.

[@rankest2390]

That guitar solo is sooo damn sexy!!

[@yigitkabaday3179]

Let's be honest, it's a fuckin masterpiece of a song.

[@mohantysumit]

I suspect there is Åkerfeldt in the backing, although no evidence on the web, this was a remake of the original track.

[@ufukgulecoglu2154]

+Sumit Mohanty Åkerfeldt sings backing vocals on "Deadwing", "Lazarus", "Shesmovedon" and "Arriving Somewhere But Not Here" and plays a guitar solo on "Arriving Somewhere But Not Here" on the 2005 album Deadwing.

[@ryanmcbride368]

The drum solo in this song at around 3:20 is orgasmic. So fucking good.

[@lesclaypool0727]

Yeah!

[@MRorPA]

Actually it's quite simple, knowing what Gavin is capable of. But yeah, it is right on point, and sounds great!

[@costacesar1]

Ryan McBride More like guitar solo, which is orgasmic to say the very least.

[@MRorPA]

Still, you need to apply this simplicity correctly... And Gavin...well, we all know he's a superhuman...

[@kin3tic0n39]

Samrath Singh Rajawat The perfect song is framed with silence

[@168stevie]

many thx! great piece of excellent music!

[@neoex100]

best version of this song, thanks for uploading it.

[@S2mppa]

Dat chorus. Goosebumps, I love PT!

[@thevamsi]

the people who dislike all these amazing videos are definitely IS members.Nothing can make you hate this kind of music,unless you choose to hate it.

[@MantiaRyche]

They have been fed terrible pop music since birth, they are brainwashed.

[@BeholdTheAshes]

such beautiful and true lyrics.

[@longfortune7911]

Jesus this solo makes me cry......

[@LiquidShadows71]

yes THANK YOU ! I prefer this version to the others I've heard ~ just seems more refined to me !!

[@88omair]

Favourite version. That solo is the climax

[@planetboondock2383]

The Lightbulb Sun version will always be close to my heart, but there's no arguing with this guitar solo. Here are the lyrics: You move in waves You never retrace Your newest craze Straight out of the face by the bed unread I'm left behind Like all the others Some fall for you It doesn't make much difference if they do She changes every time you look By summer it was all gone -- now she's moved on She called you every other day So savor it, it's all gone -- now she's moved on So for a while Everything seemed new Did we connect? Or was it all just biding time for you? She changes every time you look (All gone away) By summer it was all gone -- now she's moved on (She's moving on) She called you every other day (All gone away) So savor it, it's all gone -- now she's moved on (She's moving on) She's moved on She's moved on She's moved on She changes every time you look By summer it was all gone -- now she's moved on She called you every other day (All gone away) So savor it, it's all gone -- now she's moved on (She's moving on) All gone away She's moving on All gone away She's moving on All gone away She's moving on All gone away She's moving on

[@ricardomontecino9002]

Masterpiece

[@KiKeoLiVa]

This is F- GREAT!

[@Luckzzz]

I'm in the precious time when you are discovering new song (I downloaded 40 yet).. I wish I was this way with Led Zeppelin

[@So-Be-It_890]

This is my favorite song. I moved on:)

[@QweffL]

Rare case when I like a re-recording better than original

[@OneOfTheLostOnes]

Yes. Same thing here.

[@mattborgeson1360]

it's forsure better than the original version from 'lightbulb sun'

[@metallicarocks911]

Gavin Harrison's drumming is magical.

[@Dehangus]

Same with the new version of Don't Hate Me

[@Dehangus]

Abhishek Bansal I assume your asking that to me. There is a new version of Don't Hate Me on Steven Wilson's solo EP 4 1/2.

[@sharitox]

The best version.

[@DeathMetalheadish]

Amazing solo.

[@xq0011]

i love this song in 2022🤩

[@l3mp3]

I love it more on 2024

[@mrflibble1259]

Ok so I definitely prefer the lightbulb sun version, I like the less distorted solo, this one is a little hard to distinguish the notes. But, I must say the drumming is fantastic

[@MichaelKissingerTODAY]

have always preferred this version

[@TheAndreseao]

Thanks man

[@AntyAnty1000]

Wilson is Genie

[@tiny9398]

Steven "I'm not a guitarist" Wilson

[@ralphus555]

I love when he said that... Couldn't stop laughing.

[@ChovixXxX]

Been looking for this version since 2014 xD Hahaha... I still want the version from the XIII album, But I'm happy for now xD

[@SammyMakepeace]

that drum fill at 0:30 haunts me

[@rumpelpumpel7687]

xD so subtle and ghost-notey in its dynamics, the untrained ear could almost miss it ;)

[@SammyMakepeace]

@@rumpelpumpel7687 hahaha I don't know about subtle, I just love the signature "up the toms" orchestration

[@Bloomiinn]

Great one! This song's just awsome :) I still can't find the version I fell in love with, though :/

[@ekassake]

Dhyana Manzana That would be the XMII version!

[@MiguelHernandez-bn2il]

Tan sólo dejen que esa guitarra llore suavemente en la distancia !!!!

[@Jesusthedinosaurs]

Exactly what I was thinking.

[@pineapplepeanuts]

The solo is better on this version. Cool that they redid it with Harrison.

[@ralphus555]

If I could pick one song for them to do live on the upcoming tour...

[@radomirstanev3203]

What an amazing guitar solo, did Steve play that one or the other guitar player in the band??? Cheers from Bulgaria :))))

[@rakibulalamsamrat6311]

Wilson did!

[@angelaguerrero3808]

So... Where i can find this version on deezer because the other one being a linked song with thext one cut so abruptly 😢

[@gustavoarce278]

Genial cada dia q pasa me gustan mas!!

[@quinnmitchel4075]

Im annoyed that they’re arent a band anymore. If they did new music Id be so happy to hear it.

[@CityofButterfly]

Lol guess what.

[@quinnmitchel4075]

@@CityofButterfly Yes Ik lol. I follow them on everything. Stoked

[@UnforgiveToBlack]

That solo.. Wow.

[@abhisheksharma6617]

that solo. that fucking solo, y'all!!!

[@lecksofthebyr]

thumbs up!

[@Soloworth]

Replace she with he and this is my current life. Why do I insist on listening to this on repeat... torturing myself with memories

[@Sephiroth25TC]

Listening to sad music makes our own sadness feel better. Not sure if that's how to best explain it, but hopefully you'll understand. I'm on the same boat. Very suicidal and shit. I feel loads better now that I started listening to Porcupine Tree/Steven's solo thingy, despite talking about breakups, being ignored by the people we love and sorrow for mistakes made. Here's to you bouncing back to the happy side of life! Cheers.

[@ekassake]

Hope you are better now 😊

[@nksp]

The chorus!

[@eromrevenessej4572]

Nice

[@daniellawrenceamram2059]

this song gives goosepimples ...

[@ognjenmilenkovic3050]

Some strong Pink Floyd vibes here. The lyrics are amazing and sad

[@BeholdTheAshes]

i feel your pain bro

[@ale8n]

Yeah! I'm trying to find this deadwing US version with shesmovedon, but I can't find anywhere!! =(

[@samconni380]

Agustín León It's on the DVD as an EasterEgg song#13

[@josefvickers]

I know I'm gonna get downthumbed for this but I actually prefer the Lightbulb Sun version. I think it's purer and less muffled. Sorry.

[@cemalak]

I listened to the original version so much I can't listen to that new version. It's not that bad but I'm deeply in love with the older one.

[@Firex00]

I think the solo is much better in the original. New one has better synths and gavin lol

[@josefvickers]

@@Firex00 Gavin is never a bad thing.

[@SamGHLR]

Relatable

[@DevashishMulye]

MAN DAT SOLOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO OOOOOO OOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

[@Aj_-]

3:20

[@iluvmyjill]

Miss you blaze

[@sanilbobhate3096]

Is this version on Spotify?

[@yongwoolee9264]

Gavin Harrison. Steven's Wah Wah...

[@gaia38ant]

Isn't that song from Stupid Dream ?

[@OneOfTheLostOnes]

The original is from LIghtbulb Sun. They re-recorded it with a different lineup and released it as a bonus track on some editions of Deadwing. This is that version, which I like better than the original.

[@KynetykPower]

I agree it's horrible logic, yet I still somehow prefer Lightbulb version. This solo is better than LBS one, though.

[@AlbertoAstorga98]

Que buena canción