predebut NINGNING singing《Father 爸爸》on Let's SIng Kid 2015

닝닝✨ 宁艺卓 NINGNING
Predebut ningning
#닝닝 #宁艺卓 #NINGNING

[@jeff1234c]

寧寧 唱得真好~~

[@jesslynwinatang7964]

I grew up watching this show, but i didn’t know that ningning was a contestant in this show😱 wow!

[@rozhin6055]

Could you please translate the lyrics or tell me what she's singing about? Thank you.

[@zyc870]

@@rozhin6055 this lyrics mainly tells about her thanks for what her father did,including leaving a light for her late at night、sending her away from home with tears in his eyes…Her father described a beautiful dream for her,and she wants to sing his favorite songs while showing her love for him.

[@revemiluv]

@@zyc870 Wow, is Ningning who wrote the lyrics ??

[@bdstudios6088]

right

[@mufidhatululliya3033]

When aespa debute, ningning face look familiar for me. And then this video come again to my explore, now I know and remember 😢❤❤

[@ChitaChaewon]

8 years ago who would've thought this girl would be the member of one of the most dominant gg in 4th gen Aespa

[@dreamsteddybearsmaster]

Her voice has barely changed from this pitch OMG, it's amazing! If anything she just got even more amazing!

[@yakultbae]

ningning has some of the best and most stable vocals

[@rupu4833]

I don't understand a word here but the song, the voice, the atmosphere everything made me cry💗🦋

[@IL0VEM1NH0]

I still don't believe that she had 13 years here, I really wish to have 13 years and have that vocal stability

[@yyatarajpn4639]

가사 내용은 모르겠지만 그냥 감동이다.. 닝닝 어릴때부터 영재였구나..

[@casamera4063]

Her agility? And just 12years old woah😭

[@vickirobert1156]

12 years old at that shows

[@ssunniieh6994]

13

[@NEILLO75]

닝닝 진짜 이쁘다. 아이들 민니 느낌도 있고.

[@kittykitty5899]

Sm really good in finding talented singer, go ningning

[@zatyfarhani8145]

I don't know why this song alway make me cry

[@junpark8667]

중국어 몰라도....목소리가♡♡♡사랑스럽네

[@lovy3003]

I didn't understand a single word of her but the precense and the beauty of her vocals and the emotions she put it in it's just so beautiful it made me cry🥺🤍

[@bdstudios6088]

It really is a beautiful song too, about fate and love

[@makeupbypierrejean]

Ningning's heavenly voice 💘 even tho I don't understand the song but i am crying 😭 the power ✨

[@chinwenduopara284]

Her voice is immaculate

[@nctzenlovenct5091]

She never change tbh

[@Vazahaoui]

Her voice always has been beautiful wow! So proud of her❤️❤️❤️

[@cerealbeforemilk8976]

So talented

[@_momo_lyshrm4311]

From India aespa ningning voice is incredible 💜💜💜

[@yifangLiang-hu9cj]

India?😂

[@wingmik5724]

Main Vocal Ning!!! 🔥

[@yifangLiang-hu9cj]

好感动啊❤❤❤，她当年唱歌的情绪比现在更饱满❤❤❤

[@syarifahnadiahamran9466]

I didn't know this was Ning Ning, until jul 31 2022, knowing that I always hear this song and aespa every day, SM really changes Ning Ning voice.

[@ahyeonnieee]

No! Good singers can change their voice for a minute too... she's a Queen Vocalist

[@AI_00]

Sometimes raw voice is really better than the trained one. More soulful 🥲🥲

[@quickstar9839]

@@AI_00 un verdadero cantante, lo hace mejor en vivo que de estudio

[@blackpearlyuri1880]

My baby Ningning is always pretty & talented and omg her dad is good looking tho no wonder ningning is so pretty😻❤

[@angel_from_heaven5378]

Who could imagine that she'll have a glow up like this😍

[@mymiv]

12살 닝닝이네

[@sabrinaleedance]

Really interesting how much Kpop industry makes ppl change their natural skin tone. She looks stunning here

[@alexfine3105]

But a lot of east asians also get a lot lighter as we get older. Not everyone keeps the same skin tone for their entire life. Also, the lighting is not that great. Look at how dark Kim Yuna when she was younger.

[@himankmaheshwari2097]

@@alexfine3105dont be stupid,skin change do not occurs wid puberty😂😂

[@zhuzhu7317]

i love ningning's voice!!

[@pruitv2]

She makes me cry, i proud of you Ningning 🥺💜

[@heidi4329]

Crazily talented

[@Todayisna]

Nangiiis.. udah keren banget ni anak dari bocil.. ikut nangis.. terharu liat ningning yg bener² ngejar impiannya dari kecil

[@andikaanwar6724]

Ini ningning aespa ya?

[@Todayisna]

@@andikaanwar6724 iya

[@luisasousapaes4303]

My baby Ningning 😭✊🏻

[@choumoong]

Ningning is AMAZING wow

[@junchenzhou757]

她声音可以啊！！

[@shoiharexx]

Ning is an angel😢😢

[@phni1018]

Her voice and the lyrics made me cry😭

[@CL-bz9zx]

Wahh suaran6a ningning emang keren

[@itzelmontalvo6645]

BRO SHE WAS 13!! SOME ADULTS CANT EVEN REACH THIS LEVEL OF STABILITY AND GOOD BREATH TECHNIQUE

[@borbeamsmorrisinghs1973]

Except for Filipinos

[@CringePatrol]

Could you perhaps provide a few of example on your claim?

[@ever389]

@@CringePatrolwhole lessarafim tbh

[@iCrestfalleN]

you can praise someone without bringing others down

[@beamuah]

@@iCrestfalleNshe didn’t even name anyone

[@aespapavedtheway7680]

Woww que hermoso canta Ning Ning, su voz llegó a lo más profundo de mi corazón 😍

[@sarahl9398]

This made me so emotional. Even at such a tender age, NingNing had unreal potential.

[@mohamadhusaini1974]

Ningtouchable from aespa 👑

[@zzz.lattie5265]

cutie ningie

[@blurry1467]

That is ningning 😭

[@jakef2654]

Always blow me away Ningning 😍 you're amazing

[@azurazura540]

Best vocal

[@minwoo-w5n]

so pretty and amazing singer

[@zhixinliu2202]

English translation: No one loves you more than I do I can't forget the last light you kept on for me late at night That moment lit up my devoted heart How many times have you seen me leave with red eyes, all alone? Turning around, your figure with graying hair Under the blue sky, there's little me Singing your favorite song with all my heart, loud and clear Even though the world is different from the dreams you once gave me I believe that the best moments will fall into place in the next moment Ah... ah... When I was young, I could never lift you up in those passionate times But this time, I think I can definitely do it So many years, some words have lingered on my lips but I never said them clearly But now, I'm singing this song for you Under the blue sky, there's little me Singing your favorite song with all my heart, loud and clear Even though the world is different from the dreams you once gave me As long as you're here with me, even if I cry or laugh a lot Your laughter is the bookmark of my life Capturing an eternal moment of you But I'm afraid of watching your quietly changing face Being deeply etched by the silent passage of time Under the blue sky, there's little me Singing your favorite song with all my heart, loud and clear Even though the world is different from the dreams you once gave me I believe that the best moments will fall into place in the next moment Even though the world is different from the dreams you once gave me I believe that the best moments will fall into place in the next moment

[@imthebest11881]

Whenever I watch this video it makes me cry 😭❤️✨

[@Zafiro_Anejo]

ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 지금 목소리랑 똑같아서 겁나귀엽네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@ytbtuser22]

She was talented from birth😮😮

[@moosemoochie8462]

she look so tall here

[@btsismyoxyjin2013]

😂

[@demoras5806]

이게 데뷔전 실력이 맞나.?? 가창력이랑 음색 무슨일이야

[@bernhard9902]

Awww smol bean ningning

[@aedoaa902]

my angel

[@winter8474]

ニンニン

[@Sweden040]

귀엽다

[@maxchau6973]

Wow, oh wow!

[@eternity_aespa1117]

닝닝아 사랑해❤

[@papcujeans30]

Slay baby

[@youngyoung7333]

mukanya ningning dulu Indonesia banget hitam manis 😍

[@emiliazagal]

PORQUE ME HACE QUERER LLORAR SU VOZ Y LA CANCIÓN?😭😭

[@deb_bts]

🦋

[@kokosita]

wow I almost cried 😢

[@ssunniieh6994]

😍😍😍🦋🦋🦋

[@tahsiningning]

Ningning's mother is a singer and her father is an engineer. They both are good looking and talent. no wonder Ningning is so ggod looking and talented. Talent runs in Ningning's blood now she is the best vocal among 4th gen kpop idols

[@poopstinky2547]

She’s had plastic surgery lol

[@bangtanboys69]

Good looking?

[@abeerchimchim1688]

this is INSANE.

[@Seisana25]

Dari dulu kalo nyanyi pake hati banget sih ning❤

[@Babytugarehmama]

Diş telli Ningning

[@JisooVGaeulYeriShuhuaJujingyi]

NingNing ❤😢

[@GoncalvesLeilaConceicao]

Omg omg OMaGoD

[@nishamaitreya9450]

I thought she korean😂 So talented

[@phuongloan2127]

Hay vchg

[@useeeeeeee]

유일하게 멤버들 중 과거랑 제일 얼굴이 똑같음

[@michaelhawk8297]

Welp, I see why they chose her. The company needs to let them sing live more often!

[@gigi58258]

🤧🤧🤧

[@Katarina_ae]

Wey se le cayeron lagrimas

[@mahmudajasmeen9907]

What’s the song name?

[@sarielsalim9439]

Ga ngerti artinya tapi nangis

[@edeIweiss_]

Does anyone know who the original singer is?

[@rc77777]

Chyi chin

[@PicoUkkonen]

炎亚纶 我晕😂

[@FCocomilano2019]

not bad

[@r-jin6677]

Shes so pretty, why the whitewashing

[@Clare2233]

From Aespa? I love Ningning but is she Ningning from Aespa..cause i cannot connect with the present face

[@notmyname3556]

She gained weight, she was so skinny here. Her facial structure is of a child. But if you match her face here and the times they made her have bangs these days, she didn't look that different.

[@TheJoeyNovember]

on this video she's just a 12-13 year old skinny child with braces and now she's a blooming young adult. what is this illogical comparison? there's not a single drastic change in her face, be so ffr

[@Clare2233]

@@TheJoeyNovember yes i know.. But now her face looks little and cute, that time she looked more mature its shocking

[@Patricia-xz1vz]

Surgery

[@jagarharahap615]

Itu ningning??

[@neoneet373]

yes

[@kimtamanna1362]

Song name?

[@yosrbengarfa211]

How did her skintone change?

[@blabbla-jp2sn]

A lot of east asian people’s skins changes color in the summer and winter. During the winter, our skin usually gets lighter, and if you use sunscreen during the summer - your skin will stay lighter. Also makeup + editing from sm

[@minwoo-w5n]

east asian skin tans but is naturally pale

[@heart9474]

what song?

[@colorfullyhaerinx]

its in the title it says "father 爸爸"

[@mightyobserver12]

LoL her facE is so diff now

[@sallyenki4440]

How did she went from brown to white?

[@rodrigoe.gordillo2617]

I can go brown

[@alalani_r3i]

I'm brown too when I was a kid because I'm always playing outside under the sun but after I hit puberty stage my skin got pale a bit

[@ebba25]

@@alalani_r3i me too.. i was quite surprise of my own photo back then 🤣

[@trintr1853]

lighting and going out in the sun less

[@userj793]

Woah!!Seems like SM invested big amount for her surgery lol😂😂girlie face became whole different person now.

[@alien_fairy1973]

She didn't do anything, be real , you don't even have your photo on your profile incel and miserable hater

[@Clare2233]

Yes is this from Aespa? Cause i just cannot compare with the present face? I cannot connect

[@alien_fairy1973]

@@Clare2233 yes, it's Ningning, she looks the same, all of you are just racist

[@btsismyoxyjin2013]

​@@Clare2233yes she is Aespa Ningning

[@notusedtmind]

Her facial features literally look the same 💀 she was just whitewashed, the only natural member of aespa.

[@bobbylim1971]

Is this that little Thai girl Ning Ning who grew up all these years?

[@grandghosty]

She is chinese

[@gorillaofjohn15]

Bobby she is from China

[@sugarcube1111]

She completely looks like a different person now after surgeries

[@yurif4n]

Ningning is natural, the only thing difference is lighter skin from not tanning.

[@indahaprianti-oy4bb]

Wajahnya beda sama sekarang ,sekarang wajahny morip jennie apa ningning oplas biar wajahnya mirip jennie

[@chocopie3255]

Idih ngarep bgt ya wak dimiripin idolnya, liat dah predebut ning lain, oplas2, muka lu noh benerin

[@noname-st2br]

Jennie jg pas predebut jg beda,semua idol beda pas predebut krn pas jd idol itu butuh wjaah yg sempurna

[@NikenmeiLia-yo6ct]

Operasi nya berhasil

[@이밤-b1f]

뭐래 원래 예쁜데

[@everydaybetter5885]

i think this is not Ningning of aespa... this is a different girl right? the nose, the jaw, eyes are different,,, come on guys

[@quickstar9839]

si es ella xd, el maquillaje hace la magia y los tratamientos de belleza, pero como dije lo que el kpop no hace es el talento gigante que tiene Ningning, para mi la mejor voz del Kpop de esta nueva generación y de lejos.

[@everydaybetter5885]

@@quickstar9839 I do agree Ningning has great vocal, enjoy to watch and fit to any genre of song so does Lily from NMIXX, but KPOP nowadays in Gen 4 is all about look, talent somehow is number 5

[@quickstar9839]

@@everydaybetter5885 gracias ya la escuche, umm si Lily es buena cantando, pero le falta mejores matices de voz y un color mejor de voz, tiene buenos quiebres pero igual siento que son un poco forzados, y sobre el vibrato esta bien pero aun le falta mejorar, sigo pensando que Ningning de lejos tiene un mejor color de voz, y en los matices es mas natural y en los quiebres igualmente, la voz de Ningning es mas dulce y armoniosa, y eso si es talento innato, pero tengo que reconocerlo Lily si se defiende cantando.

[@quickstar9839]

@@everydaybetter5885 lo vuelvo a repetir viendo los performances de ambas, Ningning es mas natural y mas armoniosa, Lily tiene que esforzarse mucho para hacerlo eso no le quita merito porque canta bien pero ahí pierde un poco la interpretacion, y el color de voz se vuelve inestable. Por lo tanto para mi como Vocal Coach sigue siendo Ningning de lejos mejor que Lily por tener talento innato.

[@JasmineCurie]

indeed the same person

[@koiue.g8709]

She was so dark😂

[@notmyname3556]

Good to see someone who is loudly colorist lol

[@noname-st2br]

Is not dark

[@real4life335]

That’s ningning? Of aespa?! Damn! Plastic surgery level: max!

[@rad3886]

She doesnt even look any different, she just got paler. The moment i saw her i knew it was ningning same w many others. Looks like she just went through puberty..

[@rinaaa_a]

She was literally 13 here??

[@ggnumber15one85]

Are you stupid or what? Ups I mean "are you stupid or crazy

[@han_js598]

Ps?? She was just skinny at during this age

[@alishakhisa6427]

Are you crazy? Are you still same when you are a child?

[@ryuseitokusatsu70]

Ningning aespa

[@urmom-se1rh]

i love this comment section

[@Next_gerber_A.O]

整容