Princess Peach Showtime VS. Super Princess Peach- Which DESERVES To Be A Franchise?

Princess Peach Showtime released back in March and hasn't exactly been seen as a great game. Many prefer the first Princess Peach game, Super Princess Peach that released on the Nintendo DS. Has Super Princess Peach held up well? Are either of the games BAD? And which is BETTER? Princess Peach Showtime OR Super Princess Peach?
Hopefully, Princess Peach will get a series on the Nintendo Switch 2. The June Nintendo Direct could even have some DLC for Princess Peach Showtime and Super Mario Bros. Wonder.

[@CuteRedPanda64]

Super Princess peach is really a decent game and it actually have her use her abilities and her parasol. Really sad that Perry's story was left on a cliff hanger.

[@aiden1586]

Nintendo would be cancelled if they brought the emotion ability back

[@GamingtheOtter]

Super Princess Peach helped me deal with my emotions. ❤

[@JGr2000]

I haven’t played either game but I’d rather play Super Princess Peach. I played the Showtime demo, but I never was interested in buying Showtime anyway

[@ranpan6082]

I had a feeling Super Princess Peach would be the victor, when it comes to fun alone, that game is just more fun to play. But I would like a sequel to Showtime where they address the flaws, also make the game more fun, and Good Feel can improve on optimizing games for the Unreal Engine going into the next system. Now to sit back, relax, and await the greatest game of all time coming out in less than one week and the inevitable Demeech video "Why Paper Mario The Thousand-Year Door Is the Greatest Video Game of Time and The Best Thing to Ever Happen to Mankind, Featuring Blue Boy Arlo."

[@Demeech]

LMAO! I don't think that latter video is coming. But I agree. A Showtime sequel with better more fun gameplay would be great

[@CaptainCat101]

Super Princess Peach is a comfort game for me, something I play to just relax. I might play Showtime, if it's on sale

[@awesomeocelot7475]

And toad. Don’t forget he was captured with Mario and Luigi too. Heck Army Hammer Bro specifically mentions he’s a “mushroom headed loudmouth”

[@firenze6478]

You just called out Arlo, lol. I have to agree though, what an odd reason to avoid a game.

[@JGr2000]

6:21 I knew you would bring up what a certain blue muppet said about Super Princess Peach

[@jimmysouders5640]

They should put super princess Peach on the Nintendo online

[@viviennemorgan7217]

agreed.

[@siyahseeker]

Then all the other DS games would have to be on there.

[@viviennemorgan7217]

super peach deserves a franchise we need a sequel to super princess peach because perry is a better sidekick for her, but in showtime this looks like a dress up game and grape doesn't have a backstory of how she's jealous of peach.

[@viviennemorgan7217]

we need to see more of this.

[@EBTheOriginalMaster]

Amazing video Demeech. I really do need to invest on checking your community posts more often so I can keep up on when you release videos, since I had no idea this was coming out.

[@siyahseeker]

Speaking of bosses in Super Princess Peach, this game was Gooper Blooper’s final appearance in a Mario game ever (not counting spin-offs, remakes, and the Paper Mario series).

[@bluephoenix4241]

I still don't get why people think that specific King Boo is the fake one when it is the same one from Luigi's Mansion based on the voice clips. If it were the one from Sunshine, then I'd get it. But if not for Mario 64 DS, in the stage where you rescue Luigi from him, and how he specifically captured Luigi out of revenge from the first Luigi's Mansion, then I'd get it.

[@Harrymation-productions]

5:00 nikocado jumpscare lol.

[@AprilTeniente-eu1mj]

Both games featured Princess Peach!!

[@DavidDumbedDown]

This video was uploaded at 17:00

[@DavidDumbedDown]

17:29

[@wizarddudereborn457]

Both games are good, and each has their own strengths and weaknesses. I consider this a tie.

[@LuigiMario-ni3rj]

In the era of "vibes" being one of the most overused words in people's vocabularies, it astounds me that people still make the "It'S a ViBrAtOr, HeE hEe" comments about the Vibe Scepter... That was idiotic then, it's still idiotic now. Also, Showtime is complete garbage.

[@fightfutures2432]

BOTH

[@M.N.9]

I believe no one? Peach is honestly a really flat character in general. Tho Princess Peach ShowTime is more of a child game, while Super Princess Peach is more of an actual game.

[@viviennemorgan7217]

yeah love super peach.

[@joopvanhedel1372]

Super princess peach technically won. But Princess Peach Showtime has much more potential and sold much better, so I am convinced that Princess Peach Showtime will get a sequel and not Super Princess Peach