PTFS vs Project Flight - Which is Better?

[@dezznutts3768]

PROJECT FLIGHT | PTFS Planes - PTFS Plane models- Project flight Map - contested physics - Project flight sounds - Project flight Liveries - Project flight UI - Project flight Graphics - project flight Controls - PTFS Gamepasses(number of) - PTFS ATC - project flight Updates - PTFS Customization (weather, etc.) - Project flight Airports - PTFS WINNER Project flight - 8 PTFS - 5

[@GeoFrituurpan]

Its not good to have more gamepasses💀

[@footy_editz4146]

Controls are defiantly project flight its way more realistic whereas PTFS is just so easy and unrealistic.

[@Axlshort367]

To be honest pts has a lot of game pass

[@adam632]

Since PTFS is free, they're capitalising on the game passes​@@GeoFrituurpan

[@Ichdoo]

they both have different porposes, pf is supposed to be a realistic game, on the other hand ptfs is supposed to be arcardey and for players with low and pcs

[@AviationIsCool-5kt]

Yeah but it’s supposed to be *training*

[@HoangDuongViet-ct4zn]

Let me clear this up: PF is a true flight sim, nothing else. On the other hand PTFS has many aspects of popular games like RP so kids obv liked it but that doesnt mean its a better flight sim

[@Ichdoo]

@@HoangDuongViet-ct4zn you just repeated what i said and removed some things....

[@pandasonic1294]

​@@HoangDuongViet-ct4znPF ain't a true flight "Sim", none are as far as we know on Roblox, The physics may be good but ain't that good. They're just What I call "Aviation games".

[@lukasletadla27336]

2:42 Lion Air 610 flashback

[@jasperow0250]

1:50 English Electric Lightning got a remodel somewhere in august 2024 and it now looks clean

[@codeoffical]

I just switched over to project flight, I’m just wondering why the plane steering is delayed a lot while puts has good steering

[@NotProRBX]

Actually a very fair and unbiased comparison! Good job

[@SierraAviation]

Thank you!

[@dmronk]

@@SierraAviation he is being sarcastic

[@SierraAviation]

That’s what I thought but I said thank you in case he wasn’t

[@bashbl00d]

@@SierraAviationwow. ptfs is worse than pf?

[@jerikalvarado6187]

People should start with PTFS, understand ATC, Controls, have fun then go to PF, where its more advanced

[@Moto_Mower]

exacly what I did

[@kostaslikegaming]

1:30 The quality is the reason why there is 21 aircrafts.

[@Bi111ionairebacon]

How do you even move around in the plane chooser in project flight?

[@SierraAviation]

Shift+P for free cam

[@Табурет-р4п]

Hydrogen bomb VS coughing baby

[@leakatrinvillareal4680]

PTFS is no. 1. It supports every device. Run perfect for my device. Fun to rp. Easy to navigate. Alot of gamepasses. And it’s free.

[@SierraAviation]

Yeah, PTFS is more of a sandbox, which can be a lot more fun. If I compared more factors like that, PTFS would’ve won

[@丁日光]

PTFS is a game, while Project Flight is more like a simulator.

[@SpottinPlanesForLife]

​@@丁日光ok then what about flightline

[@Test.Unknown]

@@丁日光”Pilot training flight *simulator* “

[@Saturnian_sfs]

​@@丁日光Pilot training flight SIMULATOR

[@Sally-yg7bi]

You forgot popularity and secrets.

[@Azmeyofficial]

One thing about comparing is to compare the exact same kind, PTFS is focusing on fun and arcade, not realism, while Project Flight does

[@EKMODELS-du6xs]

U said project flight doesn’t have much on the islands, but I don’t remember a second airport on the Menorca island irl, it’s supposed to look like real Menorca as best as it can

[@EKMODELS-du6xs]

No hate 😄

[@lobotomizedmumblingidiot]

honestly in terms of accesability id give that to ptfs, because the most expensive gamepass is the AN 225 costing, you guessed it, 225 R$ but other than there is still 79 aircraft to choose from

[@gerryabrasia3298]

I still prefer PTFS it’s free easy to navigate fun to rp but pay to win there are too many Gamepasses but it’s supports almost every device!

[@DrewThatMonkey]

My quest 3 is crying in the corner rn (it can’t play it)

[@gerryabrasia3298]

Oh

[@wildpysicfr]

It is not p2win it has better graphics ur broke to buy it thats whu ur saying it

[@firstclass000]

​@@wildpysicfrsir, how does ptsf have better graphics?

[@torgo1968]

I think ptfs is better for me or project flight because ptfs is free and project flight is not because ptfs suports every device but I think project flight is better for me because physics are better than ptfs Edit: project flight is better

[@AmericanTrainRailfan]

Now this is completely my opinion but PF has a lot more detail then PTFS which is why it’s better. Once again, my opinion.

[@SierraAviation]

Yes, the aircraft and airports have tons of detail, but the rest of the map is lacking in it

[@jackbritain]

@@SierraAviation Well PTFS is literally blocky mountains, the rendering is absolutely horrible

[@md-hassan-gi3mo]

@@SierraAviation ptfs has literally blocky models, buildings and the graphics are horrible

[@JounEditz]

can you do flight line vs pilot training flight sim?

[@thekillerofthemars]

Also did i mention that pf is developed by a team and ptfs is only by 2 people

[@Nzgoldentree1985]

That’s why pf is more realistic and better

[@coloradoalarms]

At first i thought this was like putting a german sheepard against a poodle, was not suprised PF took the cake! Both awesome games by the way :>

[@Robloxgamerhm15]

Is really your choice if you want some for realism and high end devies thank go for project - filghtline if you want something to do rp, fun, trolling, messing around, no lag, cool gamepasses, easy to navigate, then go for pfts and other stuff.

[@thehunkin1132]

nice video! i did a video in november like this and it got over 50k views and 100+ subs. hope that happens to you and u get lots or views and subs!! :)

[@SierraAviation]

Update: I got 100+ subs from this

[@Freezer_Yz-vn5gz]

Idk what yall are saying like project flight is still in Early Acess, so if u guys are yapping about Ptfs being better like u guys dont have point even Project that is still in Early Acess is way better.

[@MyulMang]

I think its gomna become free later so i do hope that the ones that bought the game with 50 robux get something special

[@Morecreativemind]

I hope too lol​@@MyulMang

[@editptpm3405]

​@@Morecreativemindyea like some advantages like being able to see updates earlier or even getting any one of the new planes that comes in an update for free (any 1)

[@peyton18943]

@@MyulMangyes i bought it early like last year

[@MyulMang]

@@peyton18943 Maybe they should give some cool stuff for example badges and getting early access to plane

[@PolandTrains]

Even Orange said PF is better.

[@SHUNNREVILOFRANCISCO]

You forgot the category:aircraft handling

[@MrJoepham]

Tbh both games are like airplane seats economy-seats give you basics stuff just a chair tray table some leg room and safety card and menu but project flight is business class or first class where it is more expensive but better quality than ecomny seats but because ptfs is free that’s why it is low class

[@jasonberko]

What do you use to record content?

[@SierraAviation]

I use the built in Xbox game-bar on my computer, but I might switch to something else soon

[@APie357]

@@SierraAviation use obs

[@ALIFZGaming-t1x]

Since Project Flight is realistic it will take a long time to update

[@md-hassan-gi3mo]

This is like comparing a Potato to a Gaming PC

[@Moto_Mower]

Remember that PF is 1 or 2 y.o. so it can’t have too many aircraft and its aircrafts are way more detailed

[@hanmingsstudio2910]

Project flight devs are busy learning how to fly an actual plane so it will take long for updates

[@therathergoodengineer9285]

I love PF and play it alot too, but PTFS is way better. Its free, easy to run, is easy to understand, its very simple, its great fun with friends (compared to pf most of the time) I would rather play PF but i would recommend PTFS to others for the reasons above.

[@SierraAviation]

Yeah I agree

[@aviationgeeks8231]

PF is objectively better as a simulator than PTFS

[@msfs.flights.]

@@aviationgeeks8231 Yes

[@HoangDuongViet-ct4zn]

Let me clear this up ptfs is the better overall game bc it has many aspects like rp which kids like on roblox so thats why theyre saying ptfs is better, but pf is the king of flight sim

[@HoangDuongViet-ct4zn]

Its obvious bc the most popular game on rblx is literally an rp game lmao

[@krxzy2544]

The thing is with project flight is it is a kind of new game so they are still adding more

[@edcola6671]

Graphics: Project Flight no contest. PTFS looks like it came from the Nintendo 64. Aircraft selection: PTFS is absolutely stacked. Nowhere near Aeronautica in terms of variety but still a respectable roster. Liveries: Project Flight. There’s so many to choose from (and they don’t have silly names!) Map: PTFS. It creatively adapts existing airports (for better or worse) while having many nooks and crannies to explore. PF basically has nothing to do aside from a couple easter eggs. I will say that PF has better island spacing, making flights longer. PTFS’s islands are all crammed together making journey times incredibly short. Gameplay: Project Flight has working failures, animated flaps and gear, time shifting without the need for private servers, landing ratings and server hopping. PTFS feels more like a ‘pilot roleplay’ game rather than a proper flight simulator. There’s a lot planned for the future, too, including a career mode and ground crew. Cost: PTFS is free, but sadly comes stacked with gamepasses. Project Flight costs 50 Robux upfront with gamepass prices that will make your eyes water. (because it’s still in early stages of development and will likely go free eventually) Overall: Tie. PF and PTFS simply are in different leagues and have their own niches they fill.

[@nathanlembke9026]

What is this your only looking at the refurbished aircraft not the original old aircraft nice try 1:39

[@BloxyAviation]

Why did they actually remove boa vista

[@SierraAviation]

It wasn’t optimized well

[@BloxyAviation]

Oh ok

[@BloxyAviation]

Oh ok

[@CarloBarlo55]

Banger vid keep it up 🗣️🔥🔥

[@maverickgaming7834]

Great vid. It’s the same comparison as WarThunder to Dcs

[@greymelonreal]

Obviously DCS

[@manaphygames]

why PTFS isn’t better: “free” PF is 50 robux, that is $1 USD “easy to play” that isn’t the point of a flight sim “too laggy” can be played on a decent laptop or somewhat high end phone

[@Sharknado225]

People are arguing about roblox flight simulators bro just play msfs if you want a good flight simulator

[@manaphygames]

@@Sharknado225 the reason ppl play on roblox is because they do not have money for msfs

[@0-RB]

ERM actually🤓☝️ 2nd reason: for any avnoobs, ptfs is good. It has simple gui so any new players can understand 3rd reason: it's not too laggy. It uses low poly shapes so it won't be very laggy. Yes its a bit slow on mobile but it's still playable (pls take this politely, not hate intended)

[@BloxyAviation]

Can you do project flight vs flight line?

[@SierraAviation]

Yeah

[@BloxyAviation]

Thx

[@camileshakakeesic4421]

PTFS still has old April fools update when all aircraft on that game weird named they should’ve switched back to southwest

[@bean9005]

I think your talking about how they have to use weird names to go around copyright

[@DogeAviation23]

if yk orange (dev of ptfs) he only uses studio which is harder to make planes unlike blender for example and orange is the only popular fs on roblox that uses studio not only that he dosent make the game super realistic because he cares abt low end devices unlike other games yes pf may be better but they should be treated equally yk

[@TransportNCL]

You have to remember that ur not paying for PTFS tho

[@katcana1]

its only 50 robux? thats barely anything

[@TransportNCL]

@@katcana1 true, but it can make a difference to people

[@juanleon3875]

@@katcana1 50 robux? Costs for hind end device Cost for passes Can wait for full release That’s already like 10k wasted on a pc, robux, and other stuff, in ptfs you don’t need the super mega cool 500 million dollar gaming pc, and if you are buying a pc don’t get a gamer one with all the lights and stuff, just get one that actually works.

[@manaphygames]

⁠@@juanleon3875you can play PF on a decent laptop

[@mryapperton5000]

​@@juanleon3875pf has mobile

[@leafext]

punta cana is not the island’s name. the island is based off of the dominican republic and haiti, while punta cana is just the name of the city. same thing applies to gatwick, which is great britain (uk and ireland), and every other island though all of them dint have official names

[@Zenvoik]

bro hes talking about in game

[@theresahoang5339]

project flight only has 21 aircraft, but it is highly detailed PTFS has 85, but it is not very realistic. even though project flight only has a few updates, they are mostly better than ptfs

[@TheFatDumpling]

You cant compare a game like ptfs with many planes to pf which is still in early acess

[@Azmeyofficial]

2:11 Bro wdym there’s not much of variety on ptfs they have more airlines than project flight

[@SierraAviation]

Thats not true, project flight has a ton of unique airlines that ptfs doesn’t

[@mryapperton5000]

Did you not see?

[@HoangDuongViet-ct4zn]

Atleast we dont have SINGADOORS AIRLINES LOL

[@HDMlCord]

Do project flight VS FlightLine.

[@SierraAviation]

I’m working on that right now

[@HDMlCord]

@@SierraAviation nice!

[@HDMlCord]

@@SierraAviation I just saw an A380 at JFK. Never seen one before and I got a picture.

[@HDMlCord]

Just landed in NY

[@Eren_GD]

project flight has kind of a bit of aircraft while ptfs has more because some players don't like realistic flight games so they go for project flight in so is a arcade game although is popular in roblox and ptfs supports every device and rp easy to control heavy planes

[@FrostyGamer160]

Project flight on the last one should of got the the point reason is they took 9 months for update 7 IS BECAUSE OF THE COCKPIT

[@icegamingsupreme]

an idea for the next video is making microsoft flight simulator vs X-plane

[@SierraAviation]

I don’t have Microsoft flight simulator, sorry

[@HazardousOfficiel]

I have a suggestion for your vid. You can make AIRLINE VLOG REVIEW ! AND COMPARE 2 AIRLINES ! COOL HUH ?

[@SierraAviation]

Maaaaybe

[@Pheunomical]

Project flight looks so real i thought u were comparing flight simulator on microsoft vs the roblox version

[@safaqjarar]

I love ptfs and project flight they have good physics my fav physics is crosswinds

[@safaqjarar]

Pls do flightline vs project flight

[@SierraAviation]

Alright, will do!

[@MasterPatatas]

Little kids with no robux and a sht Ipad from their parents about to cry in the comments because they can’t accept PF is better:

[@Billyplaysflagwars]

It’s not fair to compare project flight with ptfs in how much planes it had cause project flight is in its alpha stages and the developers put a lot of care into the planes other than ptfs which it is like outdated models for the 777 and a350 and the models don’t have as much detail

[@SierraAviation]

So? Ptfs still has more planes.

[@Billyplaysflagwars]

Ptfs is older though so it isn’t really fair to compare the 2 games

[@Billyplaysflagwars]

Since project flight is still in early alpha

[@SierraAviation]

Yeah but I did and project flight still won idk what you’re complaining about

[@Billyplaysflagwars]

I’m not complaining about your vid infact it was great but someone said project flight is for people who never heard of geofs

[@blaisepascal3804]

does aeronautica vs PF

[@SierraAviation]

I don’t really play aeronautica, so it wouldn’t be fair coming from a new player

[@Elliotplays-1]

quality over quantity pf prefects that

[@Checkitout-gi8nc]

Project flight does not have cockpit models

[@SierraAviation]

It’s got the 737 one which is great

[@erikafrmn]

Ptfs is the one I play the most project flight doesn’t get a lot of updates so in my opinion ptfs is best for mobile

[@1nterst3llar_07]

PF also has ORIGINAL liveries

[@1nterst3llar_07]

ohhh hello there butter landing

[@SierraAviation]

What up Hey by the way can you give me a dare to do in Roblox flight simulators?

[@1nterst3llar_07]

@@SierraAviation sure thing! try to butter or do a smooth landing at saint berthalemy in ptfs with a boeing 747 haha :) if u require more tell me

[@1nterst3llar_07]

@@SierraAviation also, u got a subscriber

[@1nterst3llar_07]

@@SierraAviation also, try Novus flight simulator. its an amazing roblox fs with GREAT physics and its in early alpha stage

[@KancsuraMate]

Planes: easily PF Map: just barely PF Airports: PTFS Interiors: airports: no question PTFS / Planes: PF, the only 737 cockpit beats every else blocky unusable ptfs cockpit Updates: PTFS = Many small updates (1-2 planes added / remodeled, rarely islands), PF = few very big updates (a cockpit, new liveries, new plane, whole new island, a new cockpit, plane remodel) so this goes to PF Physics: PF easily wins it PF is way better, but people like PTFS more, and i respect that, now you may go on with ur day

[@SierraAviation]

I hearted it but then I unhearted it because you’re glazing Project Flight

[@shakenector]

@@SierraAviation He is not, project flight is just so much better than pdfs

[@HoangDuongViet-ct4zn]

@@SierraAviation hes saying facts bro whats wrong with you

[@Azmeyofficial]

1:49 They reworked it now

[@M1lksh4k3_0]

I DIDNT KNOW BOA VISTA GOT DELETED

[@M1lksh4k3_0]

thanks for hearting mybcomment

[@SierraAviation]

@M1lksh4k3_0 no problem

[@The_miku_enjoyer]

Ptfs is more of a sandbox plane sim pf is more of a realistic flight sim

[@boing650]

I would love to see Project flight and Flight line

[@SierraAviation]

You’re in luck, because I already did that

[@nicholasbartas2065]

Pls do MSFS2020 vs. X-Plane 12

[@SierraAviation]

I don’t have msfs unfortunately

[@CalumMacdonald-l2m]

@@SierraAviation sad

[@DarioROB]

It took 9 months but for good quality not to slap some boring feautures

[@Timoteo-qwerty]

These angry ptfs kids 💀

[@adillaadilla-sq1dh]

pls try aeronautia!

[@SierraAviation]

Fine

[@FazbearEntertainmentChannel]

Project Flight shouldnt be compared with updates, As look at the models and graphics and pyshics of project flight, that seems like something really hard to make.

[@Crabonoe]

Me when your opinion isn’t biased 🥶

[@Paganiavgeeks]

The jet in ptfs was old and in the in he ptfs update it got updated

[@SierraAviation]

Yeah, but the project flight models are still better

[@galaxiestockman]

DO FLIGHTLINE VS PF

[@SierraAviation]

Already did

[@SaulGoodmanyes]

as a person who played a lot of project flight and ptfs. ptfs is great for beginners

[@Mip.Z]

If physics wasnt on there it wouldve been a tie but yk anhthing to let a diffrent roblox flight sim that focuses on the rlight sim otion then a game that doesn't

[@WaterWaver-fy8de]

I had a stroke reading this bro

[@halitruzgar]

But PF not free 4-4

[@Ka_Nyaw_Gaming]

PTFS is TOP 1 PF is TOP 2 (I guess) PF plane are good model. Ptfs are good to but Ptfs plane are make with Roblox Studio IS hard to build But I like more Ptfs And Is my fav game too is has More visit Pf is have low visit cuz is cost Robux ( I think)

[@saamthepuffer4336]

PTFS planes only take a day if you know how to model, PF has mesh-imported planes that take many days

[@SierraAviation]

@saamthepuffer4336 ptfs planes take much more than a day

[@Aviat0rAKA]

PTFS does have transitions between screens 💀

[@SierraAviation]

Nuh uh

[@Billyplaysflagwars]

In my opinion project flight is better

[@Billyplaysflagwars]

And the reason why project flight updates take long is cause the developers are still. In school and the quality of the planes look really good

[@Barney_the_Pufferfish]

not to be that guy but both games are good none of them is better som and i think both games are really great made project flight goes more for the realistic and PTFS goes more for the arcade style game so it wouldnt be fair to choose a better one

[@SierraAviation]

Yeah that’s true

[@0-RB]

Yessss, both are good in their own ways

[@manleyeugenio5624]

they are both good aviation game but pf is more realistic and ptfs is for low pc so if you want pf just buy pf or you want ptfs just play ptfs its free : ]

[@Planey_747]

Aero flights vs PTFS next

[@a_pianist_1]

try roblox's flightline compared to project flight, this would be insane for a comparision, as both of them are meant to be ultra realistic

[@SierraAviation]

Will do, thanks for the suggestion!

[@Batsprodigy5234]

Hello sir. I believe parts of my video has been taken and I would like you to take it off. Please reply me before I take it to the officials

[@SierraAviation]

What do you mean?

[@Batsprodigy5234]

It's technically my second channel

[@SierraAviation]

I assure you I didn’t steal any clips

[@Batsprodigy5234]

@@SierraAviation I will check out the exact details, after confirmation I will submit a report to the officials

[@Batsprodigy5234]

0:45

[@Avrgeek_user]

I sure only guy don't have robux couldn't accept it😂😂😂

[@Nomar2007_NWDE_WRESTLING]

there is one thing that i hate about Project Flight, want to know what it is, I'll tell ya, *NO JETBLUE A320 LIVERY!!!!* 😡🔥

[@leslyperez3638]

One big thing ptfs is free

[@Norbit2000]

Egyptair mentioned raahhhhhh

[@Norcalweather2024]

Bro you got Southampton

[@TA-M-AS]

project flight won 🎊🎉🥳

[@AviationLv246]

One also costs 50 robux And one is free so…

[@StockSavvy3]

Nah ptfs better every day of the week you know it

[@SierraAviation]

Is this REALLY Roblox⁉️

[@JD_Bootytickler]

Ptfs looks like it came out of nintento while PF looks like a roblox Microsoft flight simulator

[@0-RB]

​@@JD_Bootyticklernah Nintendo wouldn't even make a flight sim that ######

[@Timoteo-qwerty]

Pf is better, ptfs looks like a flight sim made in 2007

[@S.S635]

Project Flight is technically better

[@AceAirlinesOfficial]

For robux people

[@bella_someroblox150]

@@AceAirlinesOfficial Its going to be free on beta but it will take like more than 9-12 months

[@Alena-wc5md]

No Have Robux... I'M GOING PTFS

[@RickVideosAI]

You cannot compare pf to ptfs PF is made to made to be realistic and working on high or medium end which cannot be changeable ptfs is made for any end devices. Ptfs and pf are both good games and have different and similar purpose like: Project Flight 1.It cannot be played on low end devices 2. It is made to feel like Realistic and is trying replicate it Ptfs 1. It can be played on any end devices 2. It is just a fun made to have fun and not having realism dosent matter

[@HoangDuongViet-ct4zn]

Yeah ur correct, many toddlers keeps saying that ptfs is better cuz it has an rp aspect but that doesnt make it a better flight sim

[@Korean_kimao]

Pf is robux while ptfs is free and all the Planes and liverys are to!

[@R142A8]

Bro the only thing I want is ptfs is the og game then that over heated games.