Putin is Desecrating the Memory of the Holocaust | Into Context | War in Ukraine 02

[@TimeGhost]

Support Ukraine: u24.gov.ua/ Join the TimeGhost Army and our continued effort to enable understanding of our present by explaining its historical context. bit.ly/ICU_02_PI As we cover Ukrainian history, many of its darkest moments are once again in headlines. Babi Yar, the site where over 30,000 Jews were murdered in 1941, was once again the backdrop to violence as the Russian Armed Forces struck a television transmitter in that area. This series is here to put the present bloodshed in Ukraine into its historical context, and few things are more tragically fitting to that goal than this attack. Read our community guidelines before commenting: community.timeghost.tv/t/rules-of-conduct/4518

[@quetzalcube]

Will you do a chapter comparing todays situation with the Cuban missile crisis?

[@DimensionalWanderer]

I'm sure you know this, but this video got age-restricted. Sad to see KZbin still trying to hide the reality of history from younger audiences

[@archstanton6102]

@@stevemuir5384 When you say last week, you actually mean June 2018 when the story was actually in the international press and online? This story is correct but almost 4 years old.

[@slcpunk2740]

@@stevemuir5384 Every country has a left and a right, a far left and a far right. People are different and countries are full of them. That doesn't mean they don't deserve to live without war, they chose their government and are on the road to getting better. Aren't we all just trying to be better than we were yesterday? Are you so perfect? Is your country perfect? You're just another voice in the peanut gallery of the internet throwing stones from your glass house. 🤮🤡

[@TimeGhost]

@@joshuacondell1686 you're right - but there is unfortunately a parallel in nuclear saber rattling. So we might.

[@justinreilly6619]

I was vaguely aware of how badly the Ukranians had suffered under Nazi rule, but I was completely unaware of how much they contributed to the Russians in the war against the Nazi's. Thank-you for highlighting this. Never forget.

[@oLii96x]

And now they are being called collaboraters

[@Shmidtk]

@@oLii96x the insanity of the narrative is that true Ukrainians are still anti-Nazi and now Ukraine has elected somehow the Nazi anti-Russian government and the current "special operation" is only against that nazi government. So Russia is a kind of liberator...

[@oLii96x]

@@Shmidtk There is no "Nazi anti-Russian" government in Ukraine. Nazis in Ukraine are irrelevant

[@TimeGhost]

@@oLii96x we think that he was pointing out the absurdity of the claim... at least we hope so

[@odonovan]

@@Shmidtk, you ARE aware the Ukrainian president is Jewish, right, and that they recently (23 September 2021) passed a law outlawing antisemitism in Ukraine. You are ALSO aware the Russian "special operation" (INVASION) has been indiscriminately targeting Ukrainian civilians, aren't you? Your statements are those of a complete FOOL.

[@mnkybndit]

Even though I'd seen this episode before, it doesn't make it any easier to watch. It must have been even harder to research and produce. Thank you.

[@desert_jin6281]

"This content may be inappropriate" - damn right it is. It is also of absolute importance to teach history unfiltered. You go time ghost. Stellar job and I thank you for it.

[@PiscatorLager]

Thank you! And the time set on the clock is so fitting!

[@ajc-ff5cm]

The doomsday clock?

[@freetolook3727]

I wonder what it's set at right now.

[@charlesgrybosky1916]

Two Minutes to Midnight...

[@michimatsch5862]

Piscator? Not surprising all things considered.

[@MrYossarianuk]

@@charlesgrybosky1916 100 seconds since 2020

[@sergey147]

My grandfather, who was Russian (married my grandmother, from Ukraine) and also a history teacher in the USSR took me to Babyn Yar when I was only 9 years old. There was a small memorial there (in the 1980s), nothing like it is now. He told me the story of what happened on that ground and made sure I would never forget.

[@TimeGhost]

@Serge Y Thank you for sharing your story from there.

[@silenceofdoom]

Memories and scars tends to remain even when people burn history books.

[@andriichub8742]

As a Ukrainian currently in Ukraine I thank you for bringing awareness of the current war and the context behind it to your audience (which I have been apart of ever since the Great War coverage started) and beyond! Ukraine and all of her people will continue to stand strong and protect our land, families and freedom until the invaders are beaten. To victory! Glory to Ukraine! Слава Україні!

[@TimeGhost]

@Andrii Chub Good luck to you

[@odonovan]

@Andrii Chub, love, respect, and prayers from the USA. 💙🇺🇦💛 Slava Ukraini! Heroiam slava! 💛🇺🇦💙

[@shawnr771]

I hope you, your family and friends are safe. Be careful.

[@NightStalkerSoC]

This episode is still one of the hardest to watch. And I think it's a good thing. In a few years, when I'll re-watch WAH, I will most likely have to take some breaks between each episodes.

[@firingallcylinders2949]

YT makes you confirm 3x to watch the video.

[@changeshifter4852]

FYI I am in Canada and was able to view without age verification or answering if I was sure I wanted to watch. #TimeGhostArmy

[@JamesTobiasStewart]

Absolutely, this was extremely hard to watch and I wouldn't want to be the kind of person who could watch this without feeling sickened. These sorts of atrocities should sicken anyone.

[@kiancuratolo903]

I can not put into words how much i apricate you all, I am doubling my pledge to the timeghost army never forget, not in the past, not now

[@tyskbulle]

You read about a massacre in history and you think This was a long time ago in a less civilized time But this happened just one lifetime ago That is the most sickening part of it

[@LotharLive]

Very important work you guys are doing. I can't imagine what goes through all of your heads as yet another European war unfolds. You are all greatly appreciated

[@gianniverschueren870]

I can't for the life of me do the reviews on these videos. Thanks for taking the time to do this

[@mykhaylovarvarin9078]

To add some context, first of all, execution in Babyn Yar continued throughout German occupation, with Roma, and members of both communist and Ukrainian nationalist resistance being killed. And, after the war, Soviets tried to hide the existence of the site, by building houses and infrastructure there, a lot of the time, basically on top of bodies

[@JLAvey]

There's a book called Bloodlands that should be required reading in school. It covers this massacre as well all the other events in Ukraine and Poland between 1933-45 and puts things in perspective. Reading/hearing about this nightmare world makes you appreciate what you have and decide that the time and place where you live isn't such a bad place after all. Einstatgruppe are the worst of them all; they strip people of dignity and then of their lives.

[@KuroNekoExMachina]

Anything by Prof. Timothy Snyder is an excellent read & learning experience.

[@wellhellothere1976]

The symbolism of Spartacus' setting and clothing speaks volumes. This format is so important right now and highlights why history matters so much.

[@johnnada9028]

Thank you for your tireless work educating people about the atrocities mankind has wrought upon one another. This video has surfaced emotions I haven't felt since reading This Way for the Gas, Ladies and Gentlemen. It is a disgrace, the denialism of the existence or intensity of the acts we have committed against one another, which aims to wear down our natural aversion to these acts. I fear what the future holds for us, we are not so different from those who just generations ago committed horrific acts of inhumanity. Today massacres and ethnic oppression occur around the world, from the Hutus and Tutsis, Srebrenica, and apartheid South Africa of the latter part of the last century to Daesh, the ongoing atrocity in Yemen, the war in Tigray and Ethiopia and too many more to list in the 21st century. May we find peace.

[@wanderingfool6312]

Thank you, for having the strength to do this. It may seem weak but I had to take breaks just to get through this. I have no words, but just to say, never again.

[@FengshenNL]

I had tears in my eyes the first time Spartacus told this story and I have tears in my eyes again today. The sheer scope of this is baffling and deeply unsettling. I live in a village with 50.000 people and the mere thought of 2/3 of the amount of people that live here getting shot over a matter of days is incomprehensible. Putin desecrating the memory of this abomination, as Stalin desecrated the Ukrainian people in 1932, is telling for the sociapathic world view he has. This needs to end now.

[@dominicvucic8654]

It is very depressing to see the grandsons of men who stood shoulder to shoulder against the nazis now fight each other

[@1701enter]

A question for the presenters and editors... Do all the stupid comments and bs in the comments dishearten you? I for one am extremely grateful for your care with presentations

[@TimeGhost]

It's part of the job - but these videos are especially taxing as we deal with professionals paid by the FSB - and no that's not paranoia, that's a well documented fact. It's disheartening because we have to remove them, and we live with the constant stone in our stomachs that we are also removing people just asking legitimate questions, or expressing ill informed opinions. We are democratic citizens, and while our forum is our forum, we do want discussion, debate, and questions asked - the FSB is destroying that possibility.

[@vaclavrout1297]

Your work Is too important, do as you feel so you can continue, thanks for your work and someone give box of kittens to Spartacus for cuddle after every war againts humanity

[@InquisitorThomas]

@@vaclavrout1297 fuck we’re going to need a lot of Kittens.

[@TuomoKalliokoski]

@@TimeGhost IIRC The FSB is mainly internal service while SVR is the foreign service and GRU is the military service. The latter two are the main funders for the trolls.

[@TimeGhost]

@@TuomoKalliokoski yes, you're right we're being flippant about who does what over there, but at this point...

[@faded_ink3545]

Very proud of you guys to comment on this; history is impartial and the best way to challenge the Kremlin’s disinformation machine. Slava ukraini 🇺🇦

[@DotepenecPL]

A little issue I have with the numbers mentioned in the beginning of the material is that the Ukrainians seem to prefer to commemorate this minority who collaborated rather than the majority that fought the Germans. Ватутин's streets are being renamed (like in Użhorod), while Bandera or Шухевич are getting their steets and monuments. So, yes, of course, plenty of the Ukrainians opposed the Germans; I am just not sure if that many of them identify with those who opposed. Also, I believe many of them were sort of forced to take part in the war on the Soviet side. Through conscription, evacuations etc. The same way their ancestors were forced to take part in the wars fought by the Russian Empire, by the Habsburgs, by Poland.

[@hamishneilson7140]

I absolutely love the professionalism with which all of you on your channel have been handling this conflict. Keep up the incredible work. You are bringing much needed context to global events.

[@padawanmage71]

I was so close to crying at the sheer desperation those people must’ve gone through when they were literally at the precipice of death. Putin seems to want to erase memorials like that, even the President of Ukraine has stated ‘We Will Rebuild.’ Please keep these videos coming. They are hard to watch, but that makes history harder to repeat. Never Forget.

[@TimeGhost]

@Padawanmage71 Thank you for your support. Never forget.

[@grottenolm8514]

I don‘t know how I landed on your channel. But I am really happy that I am here. Awesome content and presentation. And btw: your germany pronouncation is spot on. Greetings from a german viewer.

[@TimeGhost]

Glad you found us @Grotten Olm, welcome!

[@andrealongwith9741]

Thank you All for what you do!!!

[@TimeGhost]

@Andrea Longwith Thank you very much for your support

[@inferioraim]

Thank you for reminding the world of these crimes.

[@TimeGhost]

@Willem Blom Thank you for watching

[@grrlpurpleable]

Tears... no words... just tears. My heart is with Ukraine and her people right now. If Putin is not stopped another country will be next. :'(

[@humboldthammer]

Putin has been PUT IN charge of his own Christian Nationalist Beast -- Daniel 7: 5 -- Arise devour much flesh. Xi becomes the Dragon of Xionn -- the new ASEAN 10. "W" Bush -- Born Again Christian President with TWO FAILED WARS, based on lies. Trump -- Chosen by God to rebuild the Temple? Epochal Eclipse April 8th 2024. Matthew 16: 4 Jonah 3: 4-5, 8 Less than 7% are expected to "SEE" anything besides an eclipse. That's NORMAL. It has always been this way.

[@yaoyaohorse7742]

thank you all for sharing us the history

[@TimeGhost]

Thanks for watching with us @Yaoyao Horse

[@alexh1249]

Thank you guys deeply for the work you are doing; bringing light to the atrocities of the past and reflecting them against the current horrific situation in The Ukraine 🇺🇦. I would like to ask if there is a way we, the fans, can support you outside of the usual financial avenues, as I do not have much money to give but would love to support the work you are doing. I wish yourselfs, the staff behind you and the Ukrainian people the best of health and I would like to say, Slava Ukanani

[@WinnyJ1]

Guess I need notification on from you guys 🙁 For this one I did get in my feed. You guys are doing amazing s Work. Gonna have a stab at the shop this weekend

[@TimeGhost]

@WinnyJ1 KZbin's age and content warnings/restrictions play havoc with people's notifications, you may have to check in with the channel manually every now and then to make sure you are catching our content. Thanks for watching with us!

[@L0Lza1]

Heartbreaking. The depravity leaves me speechless. How could you ever comply with orders like that, or even go beyond that (rape etc.).

[@balrog262]

Either they are just evil, or, they are terrified of being executed themselves.

[@desert_jin6281]

And this leaves every one of us with the question : What will you do ? When will you comply, run, fight back ? I hope we don't have to answer it. But history repeats itself.

[@kevinhentze1909]

I am crying, as i pen this. When i was young my Bubbe would recount stories of our family members, friends & members of the shtetls (whom she had known, or was told about) who perished during the Shoah. She was such an intelligent, witty, loving & perceptive woman, my Bubbe. I have never forgotten these moments, her tales nor my wondrous Grandmother, herself - i never shall. President Zelensky said it best, in a tweet, he asks “what is the point of saying 'never again' for 80 years, if the world stays silent when a bomb drops on the same site of Babyn Yar?” I am crying, yet. You, TimeGhost do NOT forget. Thank You Spartacus, Indy, Astrid & Anna (And, your entire incredible group of compatriots) for ALL that you do; it is greatly appreciated & much respected. Shalom, daniel diner

[@TimeGhost]

@Kevin Hentze Thank you for sharing about your Grandmother's life and the story of your family. It is touching to me when I read such personal accounts, and it simply makes me take stock of how lucky I am. Thanks for watching & helping us remember & reflect about humanity's collective past, so that our future can be better.

[@richardmoore5347]

I consider myself to be of a more sterner constitution than most. I can handle vomit, blood, injuries, crying, and emergencies without batting an eye, but this,... listening to your narration of these events made me feel physically ill. Never Again.

[@firingallcylinders2949]

Have you gone through Dan Carlin's "Supernova in the East" man listening to the Japanese atrocities in China....unreal.

[@EJ_Red]

@@firingallcylinders2949 I remember reading the journal entries of the American emissary (Ashamed to say I forgot her name) who volunteered to stay in the safe zone and take care of refugees, only to suffer a mental breakdown and flown back to the States before committing suicide. Never will I ever forget the last journal entry she wrote. "If I had ten perfect lifetimes, I would give them all to the people of Nanking."

[@alexandercaires5921]

That's the reason why I can't watch the War Against Humanity series. It's so tragic, sad, depressing, horrifying, etc. I tried, but it's far worse than you could ever imagine.

[@SunshineMix101]

'Sadly, a much-needed video. Thanks for sharing. Even today, many people are unfamiliar with this particular atrocity. For the sake of clarification, it is estimated that 33,771 were murdered here and not the 33,171 mentioned in the video. Even that figure is believed to be a conservative figure, and that does not include the other murderous atrocities carried out at the Babi Yar site.

[@stanbrekston]

@SunshineMix101, sir, you are correct.

[@cobbler9113]

I remember watching the Babyn Yar massacre WAH video when it came out and it was absolutely harrowing. It leaves a vile taste in the mouth so to speak as you think of 30,000+ men, women and children being shot just for being the “wrong” ethnic group. Thank you for doing this and whatever happens, at least Ukraine will live on through these videos and those who watch them.

[@balrog262]

Oh, this video is sickening.

[@brettpeacock9116]

The book "Babi Yar" by A. Anatoly (A pseudonym for the author as it was illegally smuggled out of Soviet Russia and published in full in the west) gives a vivid picture of both the Nazi Occupation, the Crimes at Babi Yar (Crimes by the Germans AND later by the Soviets and the post war consequences of both.) Once the author escaped the USSR, he had the book reformatted. Ordinary print indicated the original, censored Soviet edition, BOLD print was all the excision made and Italis were notes added with new information. Try to find that edition. Almost half the book is in bold type. (Often the deletion of the bold words in sentences changes the meaning 180 degrees & some chapters are entirely in bold type.) The author was a young child of about 10 or 11 in 1941 and a witness to much of the horror.ù

[@jacobcline7076]

Thank you for the work you do.

[@TimeGhost]

@Jacob Cline Thank you for watching. Y'all in the TimeGhost Army audience are why we do what we do. Stay tuned

[@jonathanpowell613]

As a history student at Missouri State University, it REALLY pisses me off that Putin is desecrating all this history.

[@xanthosparashis8819]

Knowing all this, it is beyond disturbing to think that some would land bombs on such a place 80 years later.

[@DanTheYoutubeAddict]

I know that this is not on topic, but for this video and your previous two videos I have not received a notification until about a half hour after they premiered. I have not had these issues with your videos before or with videos on other channels. I just wanted to let you know since other people might be having these issues too.

[@TimeGhost]

I have had a few subscribers complain about this issue. We will look into it.

[@DanTheYoutubeAddict]

@@TimeGhost thank you. It is not a major issue for me, but I did want to let you know. Good luck and please keep making such great content.

[@akademiker23]

Actualy, they hit the future location of the holocaust memorial museum, not the memorial itself

[@mjirvin010]

I struggle to find words to catagorize this. A cacophony of emotions taken to their extremes. The bistander, executioner, and victim all ex;eriencing this horror in their individual, and wildly varied own ways. Though it's difficult to admit, perhaps the most apt english word to summarize this patchwork quilt of extreme cruelty and incomprehensible love and sadness is simply "us" - humanity,.the individual. I hated the entire video, yet, can't thank the TimeGhost team enough for this masterpiece of an episode. Thank you.

[@TimeGhost]

@mirv thanks for your kind words, and for watching with us in these difficult times

[@mammuchan8923]

No words 😶😶😶😶

[@shawnr771]

Share this video. More people need to know this. Never Forget.

[@TimeGhost]

@Shawn R Thank you for your support

[@salty4496]

I am leaving a comment to show my support for the channel.

[@felwinter5528]

The day we forget we will lose. when I was watching this I was thinking of this quote "My Pa used to say you stare into the fire long enough, you can see the whole world pass by" when I see what the Germans and Russians did in the interwar years and ww2 makes me think I'm looking into a fire of unimaginable horror, and seeing the irreplaceable life's go by with nothing I can do but remember. Never forget

[@seanpoore2428]

Y'all are amazing

[@TimeGhost]

Thanks @Sean Poore, thanks for supporting us!

[@ocudagledam]

Hi TimeGhost team. I am a little bit split about this episode. On one hand, the current events at Babyn Yar must not be overlooked and, in order to properly draw attention to them, people need to understand why that place is so significant. On the other, the way it was done here puts the viewer in such an emotional state that any rational evaluation becomes nearly impossible. The invasion of Ukraine is unjust. The victims of the Babyn Yar massacre deserve to be allowed to rest in peace. Yet a video like this one, which will maximize the emotional response to the point that some of the commentators have stated that they feel like the victims are being murdered all over again, when (as you said yourself at the beginning) the memorial itself was neither the intended target nor was it damaged in the attack, is verging on being a propaganda piece. Calling Putin's aggression what it is and aiding Ukraine in any way we can is one thing. Whipping ourselves into a frenzy of rage is not. Yesterday I heard eyewitness accounts of shops in Prague putting up signs "Russians not welcome". The fact that not nearly all Russians support what is going on aside, it is a symptom of the "us and them" way of thinking against which your videos have been warning us over and over again. In times like these, we need to make a conscious effort to not fall into it, as the events that are unfolding are objectively bad and angering enough, without adding any additional emotional stimuli on top. Having said all that, I would like to finish on a different note. I haven't done that nearly enough times in the past, so I wish to take the opportunity to thank you for all of your hard work and all of the excellent content that you are producing. Astrid, Anna, Sparty, Indy and all of you (mostly) behind the scenes people, you have created an incredible body of work and it is greatly appreciated.

[@ajc-ff5cm]

Finally a TG Army member! This is hard to watch, but is absolutely necessary with the events of the past few weeks and not knowing what is to come for the people of Ukraine.

[@TimeGhost]

@ajc 2990 Welcome aboard the TimeGhost Army, and thank you so much for your support.

[@ajc-ff5cm]

@@TimeGhost same photo, different name on patreon! See you on the airwaves!

[@raybarron316]

It is hard to fathom humans doing this to other humans. But even now we see the horrors of war.

[@Spartan596]

Would you guys consider upgrading Indy's microphone while he is in that office?

[@douglaspennell2688]

Thankyou for the background again of this evil massacre. For me the anti Jewish hate talk coming from Russia (and some of my Russian friends) is the reality of 1930's Germany in 2022 Russia. If you shout something often enough, even if it is a lie, some of it will sadly stick. My heart goes out to those in the Ukraine, both the Ukrainians who are hopelessly outnumbered as well as those poor Russian kids who didn't even know where there were going and being drafted to die to satisfy Putin's grasp on power. Both sides are sadly fighting Nato's war because Nato is too scared to do what it was created for - there was strength in having the deterrent in place during the cold war - where exactly has that gone?

[@MarcosElMalo2]

NATO wasn’t created to defend nations that are not members of the alliance. It is true that they have on occasion exceeded their stated mission. However, attacking Russia now would in fact be against their own charter, due to the close proximity of the conflict to actual NATO members. AFAIK, Ukraine hasn’t asked to be in NATO over the past 10 years, nor has it asked to join in the last week. It’s Finland and Sweden that are asking right now. And who could blame them?

[@martijn9568]

@@MarcosElMalo2 To be fair with the size NATO is currently the rules may well be defined by the borders of Europe. Not the borders of separate countries.

[@balrog262]

Putin is no Nazi. As far as I know there is no anti semtism in Russia in the mainstream. Ukraine has Neo-Nazis, but for Putin to make blanket statements lumping all Ukrainians with them is ridiculous.

[@jimmyhill9743]

It so hard to believe how all this happened. What’s even crazier are those who want to believe it never happened.

[@aethismo]

I have nothing to add, this video just deserves the comment.

[@TimeGhost]

@Barry Octopus-Abalone thanks for helping with the algorithm, it is greatly appreciated!

[@ernestbatiy1070]

My grandfather was one of them

[@gunman47]

Thank you for the video, it must have been not easy to do this like the War Against Humanity series.

[@dawnpalmby5100]

The numbers are hard to comprehend. My heart is breaking, but lest we forget

[@feliks7359]

Age restriction for learning about what's going on just across the fence right now

[@OldieBugger]

Never forget... I wish I could.

[@bastisonnenkind]

Never forget!

[@TimeGhost]

@bastisonnenkind Thank you for watching. Never forget

[@RamSkirata]

I nknow he lives in German,y but Spartacus pronouncing German Names still was surprising to me! Congrats!

[@eldorados_lost_searcher]

Haven't watched yet, just commenting to increase engagement. Keep up the great work, Team!

[@eldorados_lost_searcher]

Never forget.

[@michimatsch5862]

Boost for the algorithm.

[@TimeGhost]

@michimatsch Thank you!

[@daleeladakus1966]

Again, thank you very much for bringing this to us. I already commented a little bit on the You Tube content restricted video. Keep up the great work that you and your team is doing! I know that one member of your team is Ukrainian. How is she doing? Is her family safe? Thanks again.

[@evancrum6811]

As always...thank you

[@mindwarp42]

Watching this reminds me of my own luck. Both sets of my paternal great grandparents emigrated from the Pale of Settlement, the Jewish area of what is now Ukraine. My late father was the youngest of his siblings, born in 1937 in NYC. If my great grandparents hadn't left when they did, there's a decent chance I would have never been born. Considering that Ukraine is led by a Jew, a child of survivors, the accusations of a neo-Nazi Ukranian government only make sense as the Russian government trying to whip up support for their invasion as the accusations fall apart when examined. Attacks desecrating part of a site memorializing those killed by Nazis wouldn't necessarily upset neo-Nazis, adding more tools to use to counter misinformation. I apologize if this is rambling and/or disjointed. It is hard to express how I feel hearing about this recent attack. May aid and strength be given to those in both Ukraine and Russia, as well as elsewhere, who condemn this invasion and shine a light on the lies behind it.

[@stanbrekston]

no need to apologize whatsoever. your emotional state is quite understandable. & it is normal to wonder, 'what if'. had your ancestors not emmigrated, it is very likely you would have never existed. but God intended for you to exist. so it was He, who urged your Great Grandparents to depart the Pale of Settlement. so, Glory be to God.

[@Dimich1993]

Thank you guys

[@TimeGhost]

@Dima Iholkin Thank you for watching

[@colinmcdonald2499]

Thank you for covering this.

[@TimeGhost]

@Colin McDonald Thank you for watching

[@utbb57]

Okay, I gotta admit, that was hard to watch. Thank You for doing this.

[@_Steve_W]

Keep it up time ghost!

[@TimeGhost]

@Steven Watson Thank you very much for your support, we definitely will.

[@cazarilolsen4630]

Keep up the great work!

[@bremnesen]

Explain Wolyn massacre of a hundred thousand Poles by the same people who carried out Babij Yar. You know, the Ukrainians - not the Germans who gave the order.

[@MaciejBogdanStepien]

Thank you.

[@RickinBaltimore]

Good God. I'm beyond words.

[@stephenalexander6721]

You tube may censor you, however at least 36,000 have seen this. Please keep up the good work.

[@TimeGhost]

@Stephen Alexander Thank you very much, please share, like, subscribe, and join the TimeGhost Army to help us get this history to as wide an audience as possible. Thanks for watching www.patreon.com/join/timeghosthistory

[@deniahmadhendra8842]

I am among the first audiences here, whats actually happened in history, happening now in Ukraina 2022, its a sadness fact.The history repeated itself, and anybody can avoid this? Surely not. Thank you redaction we observe everydays whats happening now in Ukraine, or Europe.

[@firingallcylinders2949]

Great work as always. I always hate how much damage to historical sites wars do.

[@MrNuserame]

Susan is demanding my passport to see this.

[@---rd3eq]

You folks are doing a great thing, keep up the good work.

[@TimeGhost]

Thank you for your support

[@CaliRed1865]

Fucking Hell.

[@bend1483]

Yes… exactly what I said.

[@williamgipson5246]

Indy, Spartatuc, Thank you for your commentaries...

[@19angela71]

Pray for Ukraine. Civilian casualties and indiscriminate bombing are beyond a comprehension.

[@firingallcylinders2949]

I pray nukes aren't used.

[@MarcosElMalo2]

@@firingallcylinders2949 The only thing keeping Putin safe from arrest and still in charge of S.P.E.C.T.R.E is the damn nukes.

[@anestisfraganestis1540]

Great... as always.

[@MrRedsh1rt]

I can't watch the Babyn Yar WAH episode again. I watched it when it was first released and maybe it's because I had recently became a father but I cried. Never forget.

[@roberthiggins6401]

Never forget.

[@stoffls]

Thank you for posting this. The story of Babyn Yar still turns my stomach. And as was stated below: I was not aware how much the Ukrainians actually contributed to the Red Army and the defeat of the Nazis. Never forget!

[@ClannCholmain]

It’s reverse ‘Barbarossa’ and ‘living space’, that’s how the Ukrainians are seeing it.

[@firingallcylinders2949]

Putin wants the old Soviet Union back. Russias GDP is embarrassing for its size. He knows Ukraine and the Baltic states are heavy with resources. Just like Hitler with Czechloslovakia I think the west are naive if they think Putin stops with Ukraine.

[@hendrikvanleeuwen9110]

End yt censorship of history!

[@nicobernard]

I don't know how you deal with the nightmares. Thank you.

[@reddeercanoe]

Lest We Forget!

[@TimeGhost]

@Clifford Jessup Thank you for watching

[@nemosgaze]

Someone please send Indy a proper microphone

[@Southsideindy]

Since this had to be done in just one day, and I’m in stockholm and our studio is in Munich, you get what you get.

[@PotatoeJoe69]

As a group of folks who knows much of WWII, I you must see how this Ukraine war ends... and the fact that it doesn't end, for a long time. It is unfolding exactly like the beginning of WWII, including other nations doing nothing about it ....

[@robviousobviously5757]

NEVER FORGET...

[@davidjrlocilento3353]

I feel sorry for a lot of people in Ukraine Let there be peace

[@marmotman151]

I remember this WAH episode. It is no more palatable now than it was then. Something which must not be forgotten.

[@ryancresswell4398]

Well done on this important docuseries. I'll admit it's not easy to watch these episode but it is a matter of historical importance and contributes towards the justice of the victims of the WAH - to be aware of what happened, and never forget.

[@TimeGhost]

@Ryan Cresswell Thank you very much for watching. We depend on your support so tell your friends! And if you haven't yet, please consider joining the TimeGhost Army on Patreon so you can help us continue to create this important series www.patreon.com/join/timeghosthistory

[@gnarzikans]

where did you get the figure that as of 1944, 40% of the soviet military was ukrainian?

[@TimeGhost]

its from "Ukrainians in the Second World War”

[@gnarzikans]

@@TimeGhost thank you! is that a book, or?

[@mariannelynnlatjow5641]

As an American Pole I beg of you please discuss the past relationship between Russia Poland and Ukraine and how it has changed. I am proud of the Polish people and how they are showing their kindness and humanity to Ukraine although at one time they were enemies. Please let it be a lesson to the rest of the world that one time you may have been enemies but that is not this time now. You have found common ground. It's called humanity

[@Serendipity818]

The irony is Putin's mother was Jewish and he is a Chabad Jewish Grandmaster look it up it is all recorded on Google