Q&A: Do Ahmadiyyahs Have Heretical Beliefs? | Dr. Shabir Ally

[@ReasononFaith]

Dr. Shabir Ally, you have always impressed me with your reasoned and compassionate positions. Your dedicated to peaceful dialog is a model for others to follow. While I am a former Ahmadi Muslim, I do admire the peaceful stance that Ahmadis take. It's nice to see a Sunni Muslim speaks so clearly and unequivocally about the subject, without misrepresenting or denigrating another denomination in the process. I salute you! Peace and love.

[@eklautasaquib]

Reason on Faith masha allah dude. welcome to Islam

[@ibrahim786ish]

may I ask why you left I am looking for debate just wondering

[@nasirahmad1023]

I think this is Mr. Sarmad, who left Ahmadiyyat and became an agnostic.

[@adilshah7844]

If one chooses to be anonymous, we should respect that just as If one chooses to call himself/herself a Muslim we should respect that too.

[@PurePeacePower]

HafizSAQUIB DEENIKHIDMAT Reason on Faith became a Sunni but became so disgusted at them that he left Islam altogether and then became a Hindu,

[@pashamuzaffar]

This maulana is not Ahmadi. But, compared to mainstream scholars of Sunnis, he talked nicely and honestly, like a gentle man. I appreciate it. I still want to know those many ahadis which say that there will be no prophet of any kind after The Prophet Mohammad SAW.

[@Ahmadmudassar2504]

There are tones of Hadiths says I’m the last one, the whole thing Ahmadis made is fake and untrue, I myself is Ahmadi before but now allhumdulillah converting to Islam really soon, if you need more proof of Hadith I can help u out

[@Dark-cl6md]

@@Ahmadmudassar2504 I’m an Ahmadi. Change my mind brother

[@danieljakunin4303]

Sahih al bukhari 3455 there will be no prophet after me

[@smassociates3252]

Quran itself says the possibility of coming of Prophets, read chapter Alnisa 70 and check what are the 4 blessings almighty is rewarding to those who belive in this prophet Muhammad pbuh.

[@fasamus]

@@danieljakunin4303 And the holy prophet saw said the masih will be nabiullah. The message of Islam cannot be understood in 2 lines like you quoted. You gather all the relevant messages together then you'll come to what it all meant.

[@munassaralam5442]

Speaking as an Ahmadi myself, I like how he was not very abusive in his tongue as some others are. He described Mirza Ghulam Ahmad (as) well and he was not harsh in his explanation on the way we differ. I appreciate his humbleness and ease of words. Jazakallah.

[@musiclocate9357]

He died on a toilet

[@dlhussain81]

Music locate no he died in bed, in his own toilet

[@dlhussain81]

Munassar Alam Ghulam Ahmad is a dajjal

[@betweenshadownlight2208]

Wake up!! Leave this dajjalic religion and come to Islam!

[@sensefirst475]

As the Muslim son of a Qadiyani father, I ask you, wasn't Mirza Ghulam Qadiyani Sahib "very very abusive in his tongue" ?

[@KyleS.1987]

Thanks for answering my question. Appreciate the clear and gracious response.

[@AL-qz8nw]

Kyle S. brother, how to ask the questions. Can you give shabir Ali's mail Id or whatsapp number

[@hasherquoom2160]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/b4mycqyLma6or7M Please watch this.

[@ilmikitabiengineering2893]

Can any Scholar quote a single verse from Quran to the effect that God Almighty would not raise any prophet after Mohammad Rasoolullah Sallam?!

[@wnadeem]

A good approach for dialogue and absolutely no violence against any sect

[@saniatamanna7763]

Yes

[@Truth_Seeker1]

@شیر دل خان صاحب They believe in most things. It’s just that they think Jesus won’t come back. And that a man who found their religion was Jesus that came back.

[@udboys3935]

As an Ahmadi I really appreciate the way he explained the difference and he mentioned that muslims not to be violent for anyone.. I pray that may Allah enable him to find the truth and accept the Imam of the age❤

[@azizpaktia7672]

It’s not only „Sunni“ belief that the prophet Muhammad s is the last prophet. It’s an essential part of the aqida of every Muslim whether they’re Shi’a or Sunni. Unfortunately Qadiyanis don’t believe in this because they claim that their founder is a prophet (he himself also said that). Thus they’re nonmuslims. May allah guide them to the straight path.

[@Gandaogo]

Naam Tayyib Do you know who is a non muslim? Prophet mohammed is the last law bearing prophet.They are subordinat prophet after him

[@azizpaktia7672]

Mohammed salifu no they are no prophets after him. If you wish to go to hellfire it’s your free will to do so. But the evidences are clear.

[@Gandaogo]

Naam Tayyib I believe the prophet Muhammad is the last law bearing prophet.Am expecting Nabi Isah(as) to come after Prophet Muhammad so there can't be absolute last. By the way what punishment does the Qoran prescribe for those of us who say there can be prophets after muhammad pbuh)?

[@azizpaktia7672]

Mohammed salifu eternal hellfire

[@ibnkhair7896]

Mohammed salifu prophet esha (pbuh) second time coming is not as a prophet.

[@victorycomeswithpatience8975]

The ill Effects of Sins : Shaykh al-‘Uthaymeen | "O Muslims, O worshippers of Allaah: By Allaah, sins affect the security of a land; they affect its ease; its prosperity; its economy; and they affect the hearts of its people. Sins cause alienation between the people. Sins cause one Muslim to regard his Muslim brother as if he were upon a separate religion other than Islaam."

[@burreifort]

I am hearing just about this Ahmadiya community. I find his explanation clear and to the point. Why are you people so aggresive towards this group? Allah will sort them out if they are wrong. What's your problem? Look at your own matters so that you are correct and are doing all the necessary things that need to be done as far as yourself is concerned, not others. Let them be.

[@burreifort]

@@sababajwa93 So, are you saying that prophet Mohammad (pbuh) is not the last messanger?

[@burreifort]

@@sababajwa93 Imam Mahdi followed??? followed?? By the way, I was not talking about him. I was talking about you, what do you believe? And Imam Mahdi is the promised Messiah? Are you sure? Jesus is the last Messiah. Imam Mahdi will be just, well, an imam.

[@sababajwa93]

Burre Ifort can you even deny promised messiahs truth when he was better muslim than even you?

[@burreifort]

@@sababajwa93 how old are you by the way so I don't waste my time?

[@burreifort]

@@sababajwa93 you sound like a 10 year old child or even younger than that who keeps repeating what other person says and that is annoying.

[@amaanbajwa6794]

Honestly Shabir Ally has the most respect out of every maulvi including ones of Khatam un Nabuwat. Like I’m not saying he’s the only one, I know there are other very kind maulvis who do not support the killing of Ahmadis and believe that Muhammad (saw) was touched by Satan at birth God forbid etc, but this man is so well respected and some ask why didn’t he answer the question, but he has so much respect that he knows this question is very sensitive that he looked around the question. Very respectful man

[@stevenv6463]

Does maulvi mean Sunni/non Ahmadi Muslims? Does that include Shia when you say maulvi? Does it come from the Arabic word mawla مولى?

[@zohaibsaqi2548]

Beautifully explained with reason and logic without creating any violence

[@abdullahmr4307]

May Allah protect us from deviants of islam.

[@fidelcatsro6948]

amin

[@noorulameen804]

Shabir ally doesn't answer the question. Are the beliefs of the Ahmadiyya heretical or not? Yes or No?

[@samsaracen9648]

If the Qadiani beliefs contradict the Qur'an & Sunnah & 3aqeeda of Islam, what do you think?

[@GuyI9000]

YEs, and he answers it respectfully

[@meraypass]

@@GuyI9000 Ahmadi Muslims follow real Islam the only Naji sect. The 72 sects of the Khatm e Nabuwat terrorist ideology are hell bound according to Hadith.

[@meraypass]

@@samsaracen9648 Ahmadi Muslims follow real Islam the only Naji sect. The 72 sects of the Khatm e Nabuwat terrorist ideology are hell bound according to Hadith.

[@amaanbajwa6794]

M-K Production no it doesn’t at all. Jesus (as) was only sent by Allah to be the messenger of Allah and the messiah to Bani Israel. Jesus (as) died a natural death and will never return to the earth. And that the messiah to come in latter days cannot be the same Jesus (as) from 2000 years ago, as proven in the Quran that he died. It’s sad that now Muslims justify the Quran based on the Hadith, when it should be the other way around! When the Hadith says it’s Jesus, they will change the Quran meaning that mentions Jesus (as) and put “take away” and not death. When the Quran says Jesus (as) is dead, the Hadith cannot contradict that, so the Jesus to come cannot be the same Jesus from 2000 years ago. Also the description of the Jesus to come is a totally different person than Jesus (as), the Messiah of Bani Israel. No one can be physically raised to the heavens as that contradicts the laws of nature created by Allah.

[@listenmullahsb]

I think his answer was not extreme enough for some people, the whole issue is about the word "Khatam" which some people claim to mean "Last" and others as "Seal" of the Prophets (pbuh). It is pretty clear from the Quran and hadiths that once someone repeats the Kalma Tayyiba, they are a Muslim, no human has any authority to disclaim his allegiance to Islam anymore, the arguement stops there. The mullahs on the other hand can not let the arguement stop as this would mean they are in the wrong and unfortunately there is a lot of power in religion and people do not like to let go of power/influence. If we used our brains a little, we should be able to see the purpose of Islam, "There is no God but Allah and Mohammed is his Messenger", if you believe this and only submit to Allah and behave in a righteous manner you are a Muslim. The amount of Sunni maulvi speeches I hear where they are using some of the dirtiest swearwords in existence should tell their followers, something is wrong here, this is not how our beloved Prophet(pbuh) would have conducted himself, why am I following this Jahil in spiritual matters?

[@sensefirst475]

As the Muslim son of a Qadiyani father, I would like to ask you why many of the books of Mirza Ghulam Qadiyani are not translated to other languages, from Urdu?

[@luqmanahmad9294]

@@sensefirst475 we translated qyran to over 200 langauges which qhran had never beeb transtaed befors..... which is a huge task and we chose to do quran first because that is tge most important book.... the greatest book, the allah's word..... it was more important to do first and when we translarltw it in all languages then we will traslate the massiah maud A.S books also to diffrwnt languages not that they r only in 1 language, they r in english, arabic, peraon and urdu so i dont think u have an excuse of not reading his book because u can surely read english

[@sensefirst475]

@@luqmanahmad9294 I didn't ask about Quran, I asked about the "books of Mirza Ghulam Qadiyani Sahib"!

[@sensefirst475]

@@luqmanahmad9294 This is what the Qadiyani website (alislam) says: "Mirza Ghulam Ahmad, wrote more than eighty books, mostly in Urdu, Arabic, and Persian. Only a small number of these have been translated in to English. In order to hopefully bring English readers closer to the original writings of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad, we are serialising Introducing the Books of the Promised Messiah by Mr. Naseem Saifi. In this work, Mr. Saifi has presented a brief account of every book written by the P M."

[@sensefirst475]

@@luqmanahmad9294 Wait, wait! What do they write: "In order to hopefully bring English readers closer to the original writings of Mirza Ghulam" ..... "serialising introducing the Books". How is it done? "In this work, Mr. Saifi has presented a brief account of every book written by Mirza" In short, you won't get real translations of Mirza's books! Only books "introducing"! WoW Just "brief account"!

[@sammul1382]

they arent Muslim we just have to respect them just like Christians, Jews and Hindus

[@muhammadbilalmirajdin3764]

sam mul they are not US

[@fidelcatsro6948]

mormons would be the suitable word

[@amaanbajwa6794]

Ok the “we aren’t Muslims” is a different story but thank you for at least respecting us like Christians, Jews and Hindus, unlike the mullahs of Pakistan where they want us killed and persecuted until Ahmadiyyat is destroyed which they cannot. Also how about the Hadith in Bukhari which states that whoever prays like us, faces our Qibla, and eats our slaughtered animals is a Muslim and is under Allah’s protection and His Apostle’s protection. Why are you trying to get us out of Allah’s protection and His Apostle’s protection when no one can ever get someone out of Allah’s protection and His Apostle’s protection.

[@t.jackson]

Layer. Ahmadis dont read a Translation of any leader. Ahmadis read the Translation of original Kuran

[@samsaracen9648]

Translated by whom then, Mirza Ghulam?

[@zaryabfarooq4432]

As an Ahmadi, I really respect the way Dr sahib answered the question without much bias and hatred. Hope more Muslim ulemas show the same respect to other sects and answer peacefully like him

[@mujeeb8189]

@Abdi Basr besides this 1 major conflict, most of our other beliefs are identical to the Sunni Muslims. We have the same shahada, we follow the 5 pillars, we seek out guidance from the Quran and the hadith of Prophet Muhammad pbuh. The only difference is, we aren’t waiting for a prophet who has passed away. The sunnis have failed to recognize the messiah and it’s honestly embarrassing especially after the countless signs that were given to us by Muhammad pbuh.

[@mujeeb8189]

@Abdi Basr the verse you are referring to does not mean he’s the last prophet. It translates to the seal of the prophets. The word “khatam” in Arabic when used at the time of Muhammad pbuh doesn’t always mean final. For example, hazrat Ali ra was given the title of khatam-ul-Auliya, meaning the chief of the saints. So does this mean he was the last saint ever? No, absolutely not and there’s countless other examples. The true meaning of this verse is praising the excellence of Muhammad pbuh. The promised messiah Mirza Ghulam Ahmad (as) has beautifully explained this verse and it’s true meaning that was revealed by Allah. So although Muhammad pbuh did bring law-bearing prophethood to an end, this doesn’t mean the door for prophethood under the shariah of Muhammad pbuh has ended. It’s Exactly like how you await Jesus to return as a prophet who will follow Islam. We weren’t given any new teachings, rather the true teachings of Muhammad pbuh and Islam were revived.

[@Burak-wi5qn]

This ahmediyyat belief is just heretical. There is a strict ijma all over the Islamic world. No doubt

[@Lm-mz2jp]

We just don’t want you following a dajjal, it’s not hate, speaking against falsehood is good for everyone.

[@boxingmonthly]

Dear Ahmadiyya: WHERE did you get the phrase: 'Love for All, hatred for None' ? ever heard of the word Biddah ? that is a dangerous game you're playing. As Islam is perfect and we don't need to add our own phrases as if it is part of the deen (let alone the false 'messiah') - that aside. Using this man made slogan is just another example that Ahmadiyya is Outside of Islam. And what if i showed you something that totally opposes this teaching? this is clearly just a ploy to get kaffirs on your side

[@bjrn-erikmichalsen2825]

Very good that he says Muslims should not be violent against people based on different ideas

[@razakza]

The question was, "Do Ahmadis hold heretical beliefs?". He went into a history lesson, but he just didn't answer.

[@GuyI9000]

He did, he inferred that they do, and did so in a respectful manner

[@razakza]

@@GuyI9000 I actually don't get that from the video... In any case, when a scholar is asked a direct question from a layman, then perhaps he should not "infer" his answers. I would have liked to know the answer to this question, and I just don't get it.

[@amaanbajwa6794]

He has respect and doesn’t want to offend anyone. That’s what a true scholar of Islam should do, is to have respect towards everyone and to not be like the mullahs who hate Ahmadis and want us to be killed and believes in false beliefs like death for apostates, that Muhammad (saw) was God forbid touched by Satan at birth, that Muhammad (saw) was affected by black magic God forbid etc. Scholars need to be like Shabir Ally who have consideration and respect for people, where there is a very hard question to just bluntly answer, rather explain in a manner that is kind and respectful.

[@razakza]

@@amaanbajwa6794 Look, I don't know who is interested in "killing others" as you say. Clearly the original question asks about heretical beliefs or not. I don't find his answer to be respectful, as you claim either. I find his answer unnecessarily vague and a complete non-answer to a really very simple question. He just did not answer the question at all.

[@ThePreppyTurd]

No they are not. Read Quran. If Allah put another person in place of Jesus and show to people of israel that you killed him. Than later reveals in Quran that you did not kill him it was someone else. In the day of judgement when Allah asks the people of israel why did you not believe jesus. They will say but we killed him and proved that he is a false prophet. Allah will than say but you did not kill him it was someone else and I took jesus to myself. Than the people of israel say Allah you deceived us. How are we to know that you did that. People of israel already passed away and the Quran was revealed 600 years after. How are they to know that they did not kill Jesus. Also if jesus comes back from heaven than he will witness that people are worshipping him and his mother. So when jesus will be asked on day of judgement 5:116 Allah will say: "O Jesus the son of Mary! Didst thou say unto men, worship me and my mother as gods in derogation of Allah'?" He will say: "Glory to Thee! never could I say what I had no right (to say). Had I said such a thing, thou wouldst indeed have known it. Thou knowest what is in my heart . . ." Hear he denies that he witness any such thing but if he comes back than he cannot deny. So this is contradiction of your understanding and explanation. Chapter 21 verse 34: We granted not to any man before thee permanent life (here): if then thou shouldst die, would they live permanently? And in chapter 21 verse 35: Every soul shall have a taste of death: and We test you by evil and by good by way of trial. to Us must ye return. This verses prove that Jesus have passed away because Quran was revealed in 600 years after the crucification of Jesus...if what you believe did happen why would Allah reveal this verses. Allah knows best.

[@Ninjatech1980]

I love Dr. Shabir and i was honored to personally meeting him years back in Washington state where he debated james white... miss u shaikh and may Allah bless u

[@darklight797]

Seattle?

[@bigmactiger3398]

Dr u make it sound like its something to be debated about, where as there is nothing to debate. Prophet Mohammed saws is the last messenger, and who doesn’t believe so, cannot be a true muslim , it’s part of our belief and Shahada. U should be more direct and not try to sound like the good boy in the class

[@farhanahmed9526]

fun fact! it is actually not a part of the shahada that "Prophet Muhammad saws is the last messenger"

[@AmirAmir-cp1qo]

I think you're being to much diplomatic on your answers. Hence confusing everybody. If only you could just answer the question straight forward,if only! Say the truth even if it is against you.

[@AmirAmir-cp1qo]

Rasheedat Shade ...by believing that Ahmad Ghulam is a messenger of Allah you're directly saying that Allah never perfected and complete his deen and favors to the humanity as he stated in the qoran. Are you saying that humanity needed another messenger after Muhammad pbwh? If yes, than you're directly saying that the qoran has contradictions because it's clearly mentioned that the deen is complete,meaning no need for new revelations which means no more messengers for the humanity because Muhammad pbwh has sealed and cover every aspect of life that humanity needs to get closer to their lord hence attending Paradise. I have a message for you. If you believe that Ahmad ghulam is a messenger from Allah than you are directly a kafir and if you die with this believe you're going straight to hell. You need to repaint to Allah and become a true Muslim. If only you knew it!!

[@Gandaogo]

I did not finish reading your reply but can simply answer you.The Prophet Muhammed himself said the Prophet Isah(as)would come after him.Do you know the QURAN better than him?Small mind.

[@GholamFareed]

Mohammed salifu Syedna Essa was technically born before Syedna Rasoul Sallalahu Alaihi Wasalam hence your point is moot!!

[@salam-peace5519]

We Ahmadis do believe that the Quran was completed and perfected by Allah and is the final message from Allah, but a majority of humanity has LEFT the way of the Quran, so Allah has sent the promised Messiah to lead back humanity to the teaching of Quran and Islam. So we believe that Mirza Ghulam Ahmad did not bring a new message but leads back to the message of Islam. Islam means peace and justice but a lot of "muslim" countries have intolerance, violence and extremism, the opposite of Islam. This is why we believe Allah has sent the Messiah to lead humanity back to the teachings of the Quran.

[@GholamFareed]

PEACE except that Gholam Ahmad Qadiani was a fraud & proven to be a fraud in his lifetime, he was a British Zionist stooge who sold his faith to divide the Ummah. He's just one of many Dajjals that Syedna Rasoul Sallallahu Alaihi Was Sallam warned us about. Do yourself a favour & research the Ridda wars fought during Syedna Abu Bakr Siddiq's time, it was fought against frauds like your master!!! Did he have any divine proof of his ridiculous claims???

[@kamiingtv]

Dr Shabir I'm new on my way of reverting to Islam .I have question do Muslim believe that the Prophets Elijah and Enoch will come back to preach at they End of Time at the apparition of the Antichrist or Dajjal ? Shukran

[@mohammednissar4040]

He never answer clearly.... I dont understand him ??

[@sensefirst475]

Dr Shabbir Ally don't know Urdu.

[@Hamza000h]

Your IQ is too low

[@truthopinion5991]

So it says in the Quran that no other Messengers will come! Yet this guy from India is claiming he received revelation from Allah! Now theres a sect based on this Ahmadiyyah person! I am not very practising but I have some basic common sense to know thats the false sect!

[@GholamFareed]

@Tanvir Ul Isalm Mirza go research the Hadith it's mentioned there plenty of times!!!

[@YameemHoque]

@Tanvir Ul Isalm Mirza Brother it's stated in almost all the hadiths that Muhammad SAW is the final prophet. Furthermore, in the Qur'an it says The title khatam an-nabiyyin or khatim an-nabiyyin, usually translated as "Seal of the Prophets", is applied to Muhammad in verse 33:40 of the Qur'an. Ahmadiyya are NOT Muslims if they don't believe in this, one of the basic shahada of Islam.

[@dlhussain81]

Tanvir Ul Isalm Mirza get lost you deviant

[@luqmanahmad9294]

seal of all prophets... not last prophet.... seal is a way of saying the greatest... if u open arabic litrature, u will see seal word is use for descriding a persons greatest and that is what quran is saying....

[@dlhussain81]

Luqman Ahmad go away you qadiyani creep

[@MehdiSheikhLovesPie]

I don't know why he wouldn't just come out and say that they are NOT muslims. Why compare them to sunnis as if they were just another sect?

[@MehdiSheikhLovesPie]

Practice is irrelevant if the belief is not in line with Islam.

[@MehdiSheikhLovesPie]

irshad.org/qadianism/differ.php

[@NeXuzMotionzz]

He tells us how the sect evolved & stemmed from a person who was a Sunni himself. Please watch the video carefully before launching criticism.

[@ParvezKhan-py5ys]

xchampx Fallacy of Qadianism below are some writings of mirza ghulam qadiani; "You are to Me like My Unity and My Uniqueness. Therefore, the time is approaching when you will be helped and will be made wellknown in the world. You are to Me like My Throne. You are to Me like My son" English Online Tadhkhirah Book page.860 PDF page.880 "Allah has preferred you to everything" English Online Tadhkhirah Book page.584 PDF page.604 footnote "Many thrones have descended from heaven, but your throne has been set up the highest of all" English Online Tadhkhirah book page.441 PDF.461 "O My Ahmad. You are My purpose and are with Me" English Online Tadhkhirah book page.101 PDF page.121 "You are to Me like my progeny" English Online Tadhkhirah Book page.510 PDF page.530 footnote "You are from Me and I am from you." English Online Tadhkhirah Book page.400 PDF page.420 "In a vision, I saw God Almighty personified as a human being. He put His arm round my neck" English Online Tadhkhirah Book page.609 PDF page.629 it’s clear that the founder of qadianism mirza ghulam qadiani contradicts even the most basic teaching of Islam (tawheed). Thus mirza ghulam qadiani was an imposter and polytheist. Now let’s see the Quran; "So woe to those who write the "scripture" with their own hands, then say, "This is from Allah ," in order to exchange it for a small price. Woe to them for what their hands have written and woe to them for what they earn." [Quran 2:79] "No vision can grasp Him, but His Grasp is over all vision. He is the Most Subtle and Courteous, Well-Acquainted with all things. " [Quran ch 6 vs 103] "And who is more unjust than one who invents a lie about Allah or says, "It has been inspired to me," while nothing has been inspired to him, and one who says, "I will reveal [something] like what Allah revealed." And if you could but see when the wrongdoers are in the overwhelming pangs of death while the angels extend their hands, [saying], "Discharge your souls! Today you will be awarded the punishment of [extreme] humiliation for what you used to say against Allah other than the truth and [that] you were, toward His verses, being arrogant." [Quran 6:93] In Ek-Ghalati-Ka-Izala; Mirza ghulam qadiani alleged to be second coming of Prophet Muhammad (SAW). Mirza also claimed to be the messiah by name as mentioned in the Quran [nadwah page 16]. But mirza's dogma is a fabrication; he is not mentioned in the Quran at all. In fact the Quran states that Islam is complete in Surah Al-Maida. Also Prophet Muhammad (SAW) is the seal of the Prophets as stated in Surah Al-Ahzaab. Therefore Prophethood was completed by Muhammad (ﷺ). Let’s not forget that mirza wrote poetry and used vile/abusive words against his opponents. Prophets do not write poetry; "And We did not give Prophet Muhammad, knowledge of poetry, nor is it befitting for him. It is not but a message and a clear Qur'an" [Quran 36:69] The dajjal mirza ghulam qadiani alleged that he is mentioned in the Quran; "If Quran did not give me the name of Ibn-e-Mariam, then I am a liar". [a gift of an-nadwah page 19] also mirza ghulam alleged that qadian is mentioned in the Quran [tadhkira page 94 and 95] so obviously the imposter mirza ghulam was a liar. He is not mentioned in the Quran and neither is qadian. Let’s recall what the Quran states "So woe to those who write the "scripture" with their own hands, then say, "This is from Allah ," in order to exchange it for a small price. Woe to them for what their hands have written and woe to them for what they earn." [Quran 2:79]

[@Ismail-ez7um]

shabir has akheeda problems himself therefore is incapable of defending Islam from a orthodox position

[@abdulkareem8034]

To any Indian, Mirza Ghulam Qadiyani was a big traitor who served his British Masters! Mirza Ghulam wrote to them: "My father was a well-known landlord in this country and he enjoyed great eminence in the Government's offices. He was a true devotee and well wisher of the British Government. In the mutiny of 1857 (the independence movement against colonialism is called 'mutiny' by Mirza), my father supplied fifty horses and riders to aid the British Government. For this favor to the Government, he was very popular among the officials." (Izala-e-Auham, P. 58, footnote) "The benevolent Government is aware of the fact that we are from among their servants, their sympathizers and well wishers. We have come to their aid with a firm mind in every hour of need. My father was held in close and high esteem by the Government; and our services to this Government held clear distinction. I do not think that the Government has forgotten these services of ours. My father, Mirza Ghulam Murtaza, son of Mirza Ata Muhammad Al-Qadian, was a great well wisher and friend of this government and enjoyed great respect from among them. Our loyalty has been proven beyond doubt. Rather our fidelity was proven among the people and became clear to the government officials. The Government may confirm this from the officers who came to this side and lived among us; so that they may tell what sort of life we lived, and how faithful we have been in serving their Government."

[@akbarali7293]

Mirza gulam Ahmad born was in washroom and died also in washroom

[@quiasnoorzad]

Ahmadiyya was created by the British colonialism empire in india during colonialism to cause further divide in Islam. Why was this mirza so close to top British colonialism officers?? This Mirza imposter claimed to know where Jesus is berried has been proven wrong by historians.

[@ShahidhameedUSA]

Almighty God says in Quran 5:3 “This day I have perfected for you your religion and completed My favor upon you and have approved for you Islam as religion” After the religion Islam is completed, Nothing new can be added nothing can be subtracted from this religion. If anyone says, He gets the revolution from Almighty God, Anyone says He is Prophet of God, He has to go to psychiatrist.

[@ringgotumpal8320]

Is there any reference in the quran for not to be violent against a group when it is not inline with the quran ?

[@omartanweer3643]

Beautifully explained. As an Ahmedi Muslim I agree that his explanation was spot on!!! The debate whether ahmedis are right or wrong let the Allah swt be the judge of all meanwhile if anyone accepts the message of ahmadiyya then that was just meant to be! Love for all Harted for none!

[@NotesofKhan]

Yes Allah is the judge but we need to use our minds before we die or else you will face the consequences for not using our brains in a proper and sound way

[@roberthannah7983]

Even if they are heretical, Dr. Ally is right. They should not be viciously attacked as they are by some Muslims and discriminated against as in Pakistan. Let them follow their beliefs as with other religions.

[@ahiyaahmed2411]

I am an ahmadi and I Really appreciate the way he has presented our belief respectfully

[@omarsahibzada5117]

So as an Ahmadiyya Muslim. So there are some incorrect things. We do read the same Quran with the same translation. But with one difference, we interpret the part of the Quran where it says Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) is the ”seal” of all prophets. The Sunnis translate it as the last and Ahmadis believe it as the best of all prophets and all others after him can only preach what Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) has already established. Other than that... some other beliefs that can be debunked are... We are not Israeli spies, we face Mecca when we pray, we don't change any part of any Surah.

[@anasm4496]

Brother the Prophet Peace be upon him in his last sermon said no other prophet shall come after him.

[@Litewiz]

Shabir Ally is a lovely example of a muslim, had there been far more like him, islam wouldve been a much more attractive option for non believers.

[@Precious-n4i]

one should look to God and his prophets as an example first and foremost. not the believers everyone has struggles and may not be practicing properly

[@sensefirst475]

Yes, Dr Shabir Ally has nobility as expected from any one following the practice of Prophet Muhammad sallallahu alaihi wasallam! The character of Mirza Ghulam Qadiyani Sahib was totally different! He used very foul language against any one who opposed him! Please read the books of Mirza Ghulam Qadiyani Sahib to verify it!

[@meraypass]

@@sensefirst475 No He was quiet justified. Even Quran uses word like Pig. Is Quran abusive in your opinion? Then leave Islam.

[@meraypass]

​@@sensefirst475 Its you Khatm e Nabuwat terrorist ideology followers are are killing, oppressing and persecuting Ahmadi Muslims. Not the other way round.

[@sensefirst475]

@@meraypass I know these Qadiani people! My father was a Qadiani!

[@luqmanahmad9294]

I am an ahmadi and i can respect that answer, because he is speaking truth

[@void_9966]

Quran clearly says there is no prophet after prophet Muhammad

[@luqmanahmad9294]

@@void_9966 give me the verse where is says, there is no more prophets after prophet Muhammad s.a.w?

[@void_9966]

@@luqmanahmad9294 What's your tafseer or explanation for (Muhammad is not the father of any of your men, but (he is) the Messenger of Allah, and the *Seal of the Prophets*: and Allah has full knowledge of all things.)

[@void_9966]

Narrated Abu Huraira: Allah's Apostle said, "My similitude in comparison with the other prophets before me, is that of a man who has built a house nicely and beautifully, except for a place of one brick in a corner. The people go about it and wonder at its beauty, but say: 'Would that this brick be put in its place!' So I am that brick, and I am the last of the Prophets."

[@luqmanahmad9294]

@@void_9966 hazrat ayesha said "yes call him khatamun nabiyyeen but dont say there is no prophets after him"

[@Amaaaaan1]

No violence towards Ahmadis but Ahmadis are not Muslims! End of the story!

[@sensefirst475]

@@dhokabaziaf8873 Bring your proofs, if you are truthful!

[@dhokabaziaf8873]

@@sensefirst475 Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad was the Promised Misaiya As promised by the Allah.... No Doubt Hazrat Muhammad PBUH IS THE last prophet of Allah... But the Masih moud which would have be come that was the Mirza Ghulam Ahmad.... sahib...You fool people did not exept

[@GholamFareed]

The title khatam an-nabiyyin or khatim an-nabiyyin, usually translated as "Seal of the Prophets", is applied to Muhammad in verse 33:40 of the Qur'an. The popular Yusuf Ali translation reads, "Muhammad is not the father of any of your men, but (he is) the Messenger of Allah, and the Seal of the Prophets: and Allah has full knowledge of all things." - The Qur'an - Chapter 33 Verse 40 "Keystone" ("brick") metaphor In a well-known hadith reported by Abu Hurayrah, Jabir ibn Abd Allah, Ubayy ibn Ka'b, and Abu Sa'id al-Khudri, and recorded by al-Bukhari, Muslim, at-Tirmidhi, Ahmad, an-Nasa'i, and others, Muhammad compared the relationship between himself and the previous prophets to a building missing a single brick. In Sahih al-Bukhari it is reported by Abu Hurayrah that Muhammad said, "My similitude in comparison with the prophets before me is that of a man who has built a house nicely and beautifully, except for a place of one brick in a corner. The people go about it and wonder at its beauty, but say: 'Would that this brick be put in its place!' So I am that brick, and I am the seal of the prophets" (fa’anā ’l-labinah, wa anā khātamu ’n-nabīyīn). This hadith is narrated with similar wording in Sahih Muslim, Musnad Ahmad, Sunan al-Kubra of an-Nasa'i, and Sahih Ibn Hibban. In Mu'jam al-Awsat, at-Tabarani narrated a variant wording of the hadith with the last statement being, "So I am that [brick], I am the seal of the prophets, there is no prophet after me" (fa’anā dhālika, anā khātamu ’n-nabīyīn, lā nabīya ba‘dī).Ibn Hibban also has a variant ending with "I was the place of that brick, with me concluded the [line of] messengers" (fakuntu anā mawḍi‘u tilka ’l-labinah, khutima biya ’r-rusul). In Sahih Muslim and Musnad Ahmadthe hadith is also reported by Jabir ibn Abd Allah, with the last statement being "So I am the place of that brick, I have come and concluded the [line of] prophets" (fa’anā mawḍi‘u ’l-labinah, ji’tu fakhatamtu ’l-anbiyā’). Abu Dawud at-Tayalisi in his Musnadhas from Jabir, "So I am the place of that brick, with me concluded the [line of] prophets" (fa’anā mawḍi‘u ’l-labinah, khutima biya ’l-anbiyā’). Other ahadith In another hadith, Muhammad prophesied the appearance of a number of false prophets before the day of judgement, while asserting his status as the seal of the prophets. It is reported by Thawban ibn Bajdad that Muhammad said, "The Hour will not be established until tribes of my ummah(community) unite with the idolaters, and until they worship idols. And in my ummah there will be thirty liars, each of whom will claim to be a prophet, (but) I am the seal of the prophets, there is no prophet after me." (kulluhum yaz‘umu annahu nabī, wa anā khātamu ’n-nabīyīn, lā nabīya ba‘dī). Hudhayfah ibn al-Yaman reports that Muhammad said, "In my ummah there will twenty-seven liars and dajjals, among whom are four women, (but) I am the seal of the prophets, there is no prophet after me".

[@ShahidhameedUSA]

Fareed Mahomed Indeed b Subhan Allah

[@azud1]

A very watered down answer The crux of the issue is they don’t believe in islaam as revealed by the final Messenger ﷺ It’s truly a sad spectacle when we see so called “people of knowledge” giving watered down answers for the sake of appeasement As Muslims we don’t fear the blame of the blamers and speak the truth > Ahzaab v 70

[@ab.digital5737]

Ahmadi also believe in the same Verse excatly as you do.... yet they still do not kill or go towarda violence exactly like Mohammad PBUH....

[@JunaidMuhammadSyed]

Listen him extremely carefully, to become peaceful to appease the west he Several times become Piss-full. But this is not the agenda Allah has sent down.

[@ahmedakhan1]

@@JunaidMuhammadSyed What was the agenda Allah sent down? Force people to one's own beliefs, and if they do not accept then kill them? Allah says, "And I will not worship that which ye have been wont to worship, nor will ye worship that which I worship, to you be your way, and to me mine" (The Quran, 109:4-6).

[@rafiquecarrim4331]

And nobody is promoting violence but Haq is Haq and Batil is Batil

[@TheUmaragu]

I am a Hindu; “No violence”; such clarity; I respect you Sir;

[@brunosinger18]

I am neither Sunni or Shia I am just a Muslim the reason for this because neither this groups such as Sunni, Shia, Ahmadi etc is never mention in the Quran.

[@libertyyyy84]

Bruno Singer. Of course not, but there is also no mention on how to perform salat in the Quran and many other practical things muslims have to follow. Therefore we have the Sunnah of the holy Prophet (saw) and the authentic hadith‘s. The Prophet (saw) informed us that the Muslims would split into even more sects than previous nations. Abu Huraira reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said: تَفَرَّقَتْ الْيَهُودُ عَلَى إِحْدَى وَسَبْعِينَ أَوْ اثْنَتَيْنِ وَسَبْعِينَ فِرْقَةً وَالنَّصَارَى مِثْلَ ذَلِكَ وَتَفْتَرِقُ أُمَّتِي عَلَى ثَلَاثٍ وَسَبْعِينَ فِرْقَةً The Jews were split into seventy one or seventy two sects, and the Christians were split as well. My nation will split into seventy three sects. Source: Sunan al-Tirmidhī 2640 Grade: Sahih I get your point though. Every person who calls himself a muslim should be considered as one. We shouldn‘t be judging people how good or bad they perform as muslims. Only Allah will make the judgment.

[@SaadatMansoorOfficial]

Molana so tell me u said sunni has no any beleive about prophet after Hazrat Muhammad S.A.W so tell us why u r waiting for Hazrat Isa A.S. and if he has to come why he didn't come yet he can't come because Hazrat Esa A.S was the prophet and he died as same other prophet and we have Everything from Holy Quran And Hadith which proof Hazrat Esa A.S has been died...JazakAllah

[@sensefirst475]

Waiting? Waiting? Where did you see Muslims waiting for Isa a s ?

[@calmmorningdew]

Salam, could you please speak about the Baha’i too?

[@drunkensaurus8379]

They declared themselves as a separate religion and their way of life is very different regardless of their origin

[@SeeMahbub]

Furthermore Quran didn’t mentioned Muhammad as last prophet in 33:40 or in any verses. It just said he is sealed of prophets seal. Meaning he will be right always, no need to be get confused.

[@ZakriaRathore]

SeeMahbub Bro you need to see a psychiatrist

[@suhailalam7040]

SeeMahbub actually it does, if it is read in the warsh reading. It can be read as “seal” of the “last” of prophets, same meaning 😁

[@meraypass]

@@suhailalam7040 Nonsense! Seal has nothing to do with last. You Khatm e Nabuwat terrorist religion followers have made up your own separate religion away from Islam.

[@meraypass]

@@ZakriaRathore Nonsense! Seal has nothing to do with last. You Khatm e Nabuwat terrorist religion followers have made up your own separate religion away from Islam.

[@SeeMahbub]

@شیر دل خان صاحبI am not a Qadiani. You better stop guessing about others and read the Quran. Ghulam Qadiani was just another mullah from Sunni community.

[@maanroovmaanrethca5113]

He didn't gave a answer. Qu'ran and Sunnah upon Selef-uh-salih.

[@eesah37]

The only thing you need to know is that Ahmadiyya are apostates

[@ameerzaeen4333]

Iam ahmadhi from india.. alhamdhulillah

[@sikandarabbas9034]

Congrats you have earned a jahanum for yourself!!! Am from Lahore where this Dajjal Qadiyani erupted and we curse him Daily. We all know he died in Toilet!!!

[@amaanbajwa6794]

Sikandar Abbas but no proof he did so is it right? And you can keep disrespecting him if you want but won't change anything on how Ahmadiyyat is growing every year and is the fastest sect of Islam, have MTA network 24/7 including Islamic teachings and our Imam's khutbahs that talk about Holy Prophet (saw) and his beautiful life and the Holy Quran.

[@meraypass]

@@sikandarabbas9034 Nonsense! Seal has nothing to do with last. You Khatm e Nabuwat terrorist religion followers have made up your own separate religion away from Islam.

[@zishaanmirza88]

If you believe you can command judgement as to who is Muslim, and who isn't - then your faith should be the least of your worries. Rejecting a minority is unislamic. End of. Its shocking how many modern sunnis so openly reject Ahmadis = extremism.

[@salehyassin9245]

Dr. Shabir Sahib welcome to Ahmadiyya the true Islam. Your modesty and respect to the Islamic etiquette of peace and respect for the people makes you a noble man.

[@salam-peace5519]

We Ahmadis do believe in the Shahada, the five pillars of Islam and in every word of the Quran and in Muhammad (saw) as the highest of all prophets. This is the definition of a muslim. We also do believe in Muhammad (saw) being the seal of the prophets, we just interprete this word in a bit different way. But there are different interpretations about many words in the Quran, this does not make someone Non-muslim. Also we do believe that Muhammad (saw) was the last law-bearing prophet and that after him only non-law-bearing prophets will be sent that do not bring a new teaching, but instead restore the original teaching of Quran. Why is it so difficult to just accept us as muslims? We do consider Sunnis as muslims, and Ahmadiyya is completely peaceful and never used violence. And in everyday life the difference between Ahmadis and Sunnis are very small. We have the Quran and the prophet Muhammad (saw) as the same base, why not just accept us ?

[@TahaKhan-is9zm]

Because the prophet (saw) said in sahih bukhari ',kaala rasoolALLAh i (saw)'Anna khatam an nabiyyin ,La nabiyya ba'adi'.-'I am the seal of the prophets and there is no prophet after me'. Why can't you get this simple thing in your mind ,that there is no prophet after the Prophet(saw),don't you believe in the Ahadith of RasoolAllah (saw),Take heed for truth is very clear and you know it deep inside your heart.May Allah guide you and all of us to the truth and towards righteousness ,my brother.thanks.

[@happyone2319]

assalamu alaykum my friend in islam , i love your peacful view , i class myself as muslim only as a revert , but if i finally pluck up the courage to visit a masjid for salah instead of praying at home i will definataly visit an ahmadyyi masjid inshallah , love for all hatred for none , from scotland .

[@19721sally]

Assalam alaikoum, honest and clear truthful answer of Ahmadiyya faith. I comment his honesty. Ws

[@victorycomeswithpatience8975]

As-Salamu 'Alaykum (السلام عليكم) We are the helpers of Allah; we believe in Allah , and bear witness that we are Muslims ( we submit to Allah )

[@mohammedaghi12]

The ahmeddias are not moslims but i hope they come to the right way.

[@bismahzjallani5916]

Whats your beliefs shabir Ally ??

[@PearlsOfwiszdom]

That there is no god besides Allah, and prophet Muhammad pbuh is the final messenger of course.

[@laibaahmed5325]

Abdullah Mahmood yesssss

[@laibaahmed5325]

Abdullah Mahmood subhanullah

[@ahmedakhan1]

@@PearlsOfwiszdom I am not a Ahmadi and I do belief that Mohammed is the final prophet but please do not change the kalima. It is that there is only one God and Mohammed is his messenger! There is no mention here that Mohammed is the final prophet!

[@user-gz5mx2nd5p]

Does anyone have a right to question anyone who said they are Muslims regardless of their beliefs?

[@ax3226]

Yes absolutely.

[@ahmedhajwani8980]

Yes. If someone claims to be muslim then there are few things which are absolutely essential for them to believe. Like many "muslims" claim to be muslims but say that I also belive in other religions like various Indian celebrities. This is just one example.

[@magnuscritikaleak5045]

Doesnt make sense.

[@DreamBelief]

Wow a lot of you commenting here act like you are Allah and have all the knowledge and wisdom to pass judgement so serious as this. A little humility would be nice.

[@faizelrahimankhan3483]

DreamBelief some people cannot handle the truth.Truth shall overcome falsehood.Your leader is a fake.

[@GholamFareed]

DreamBelief that's ironical because Qadianis are ignorant to the truth, go research the Ridda wars & why it was fought!!!

[@aliass3931]

Mashallah

[@tahirtijani2846]

Love For All Hatred For None

[@SA-kz6zc]

❤

[@newprofilenamesosomethings8103]

Except for their own nafs / souls whom they are going to send to Jahanum, out of their arrogance and stubbornness.

[@ThePreppyTurd]

May Allah guide us alll and give us courage to understand the claim of Hadhrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad AS. He is a prophet on the sense he is the true follower of Prophet Muhammed SAW ummah. Allah guides who he pleases. Every prophet were mocked even our beloved Prophet Mohammed SAW and it is revealed in Quran. It happened before its happening now. Try to understnd the fundamentals of Ahmadiyya. Our claim by Hadrat mirza ghulam ahmad AS already broke all the cross from the world because he explained from the verses of Quran Isa AS died a natural death and he is not coming back so after accepting this the Christianity is poven wrong . Read Quran. According to Islamic views If Allah put another person in place of Jesus and show to people of israel that you killed him. Than later reveals in Quran that you did not kill him it was someone else. In the day of judgement when Allah asks the people of israel why did you not believe jesus. They will say but we killed him and proved that he is a false prophet. Allah will than say but you did not kill him it was someone else and I took jesus to myself. Than the people of israel say Allah you deceived us. How are we to know that you did that. People of israel already passed away and the Quran was revealed 600 years after. How are they to know that they did not kill Jesus. Also if jesus comes back from heaven than he will witness that people are worshipping him and his mother. So when jesus will be asked on day of judgement 5:116 Allah will say: "O Jesus the son of Mary! Didst thou say unto men, worship me and my mother as gods in derogation of Allah'?" He will say: "Glory to Thee! never could I say what I had no right (to say). Had I said such a thing, thou wouldst indeed have known it. Thou knowest what is in my heart . . ." Hear he denies that he witness any such thing but if he comes back than he cannot deny because he will witness that Christians are worshipping him and his mother . So this is contradiction of your understanding and explanation. Chapter 21 verse 34: We granted not to any man before thee permanent life (here): if then thou shouldst die, would they live permanently? And in chapter 21 verse 35: Every soul shall have a taste of death: and We test you by evil and by good by way of trial. to Us must ye return. This verses prove that Jesus have passed away because Quran was revealed in 600 years after the crucification of Jesus...if what you believe did happen why would Allah reveal this verses. Mohammed SAW would have surely ask Allah but Jesus is alive so isnt he living permanently. At the time of Mohammed SAW no one believed Isa AS is alive and would come later days. So please do not contradict the Quran and believe in his prophets and messengers. Allah knows best.

[@rashidbhatti7648]

Isa has died and is burried in mohalla khanyar Sirinagar Kashmir. His mother died in Murree Hills burried there. Ask any old man about the grave of My Murree. It is at the opposite side of Pindi Point. You can Google Indian or BBC documentary on "Tomb of Jesus". Also read Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadiani book, "Jesus in India".

[@juslearnin730]

U reject the Quran verse Your reject the Hadiths where Muhammad (as) says their is no prophet after me Ur lost

[@ThePreppyTurd]

@@juslearnin730 you saying that Mohammed SAW said there is no prophet after me but than you wait for Imam Mahdi and Second advent of Isa AS. We did not reject the faith, we accepted the Imam Mahdi who is to revive the faith. Every Ahmadi Muslim know the Quran more than the Maulvis you follow, because our Imam Mahdi and Messiah has revealed the truth of the Quran, the way it was followed by the companions of Muhammad SAW. We follow it the way Allah intended Muhammad SAW to understand the Quran. Muhammad SAW is the khataman nabiyeena and Mirza Ghulam Ahmad AS is the subordinate prophet of Muhammad SAW. Mirza Ghulam Ahmad AS is the true Muhammadi, which makes the Ahmadiyya Islam the true sect, therefore Ahmadis are true followers of Muhammad SAW ummah. Allah guides who he pleases.

[@quiasnoorzad]

The British colonialism empire created this Ahmadiyya in india to cause further divide in Islam. Why was this Mirza Ghulam so close to top British colonialism officers?? This Mirza imposter claimed to know where Jesus pbu is berried has been proven wrong by historians.

[@goku-ssaiyan4xx275]

Your not a Muslim u disobey the Quranic teachings, u haven’t Accepted the Imam Of the Age Hadhrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad,Muhammad SAW said one Nabhi would come in light of Jesus his name would be Ahmad, Ahmad Mirza Sb Not Jesus that would Decsend from Heaven, the one u Believe Astagfurlah, is About time u People Sunni and Shi’a Accept the Imam Of the Age, u can’t say we are wrong or swear at us calling us Kaafir, 600,000 People alone this year has accepted Islam Ahmadiyyat so you’re saying Allah ke Jamaat is wrong?

[@GholamFareed]

600 000 more Jahanamis shame you've lead them astray to your fraud of a leader who didn't even know whether he was the Mahdi or a prophet or the messiah!!! Has he made his mind up yet???

[@hailzzz313]

Ahmadis also believe Prophet Muhammad s is the last law bearing prophet and seal of the prophet. And believe Mirza Gulam Ahmad Qadiani A as the Messiah came for the revival of Islam

[@aymeneaymene111]

they believe that mirza is a prophet

[@ArslanAXE]

@@aymeneaymene111 i guess an ahmadi would be able to tell u what are their beliefs... Idk how ppl got this idea that ahmadis do not believe that prophet is the last messenger. They do believe in that and does not consider mirza ghulam as a prophet but yes as the scholar said.. In the spirit of isa the massaiya and the imam mehdi which was prophesied by prophet muhammad (may peace be upon him)

[@Thomas-ORaghaill]

I'm not even Muslim, I'm a Jew. Simply just interested in Islam.

[@nichandesign]

How could you believe Mirza is a prophet, and the prophet Muhammad SWS said there's no prophet after me

[@Spillers72]

Sounds sort of like the equivalent of the Moonies for Christians.

[@beastvader]

Do you mean Mormons?

[@ericferguson9989]

Yeah, real kooks.

[@samsaracen9648]

Moonies and Mormons and JW's etc,..

[@meraypass]

No. Like Jesus of Jews more like.

[@meraypass]

@@beastvader No. Like Jesus of Jews more like.

[@Ismail-ez7um]

if only shabir could give a straight answer for once when the question was asked "do the ahmadis hold heretical views" the answer should have been categorically YES !!! why give a khutba just to make that point ? 😕

[@smhashimnasser5619]

Heretical views based on the perspective of man, a creature created weak, not on the perspective of Allah the almighty.

[@EsotericMedic]

Ahmadis are clear cut zindiqs

[@Sikander---Great]

In the beginning any person who comes up with a new ideology or belief which is different from theirs has been opposed neglected and outcasted Mirza gulahm Ahmed claimed to be the coming of Jesus and the awaited mehdi for most Muslims this was a ridiculous claim

[@jazzsaz]

Thanks!

[@barackmugatsia4714]

THOSE WORSHIPED BESIDES ALLAH ARE DEAD ALL INVOKED ON OTHER THAN ALLAH ARE DEAD (16:21-22) وَالَّذِينَ يَدْعُونَ مِنْ دُونِ اللَّهِ لَا يَخْلُقُونَ شَيْئًا وَهُمْ يُخْلَقُونَ{21} أَمْوَاتٌ غَيْرُ أَحْيَاءٍ ۖ وَمَا يَشْعُرُونَ أَيَّانَ يُبْعَثُونَ {22} “And those on whom they call beside Allah create not anything, but they are themselves created. They are dead, not living; and they know not when they will be raised” (Chapter 16 verse 21-22) These verses of the Holy Qur’an illustrate something really important. It is being mentioned that all the false Gods who people worshiped are dead and not alive. Since Jesusas is also one who is worshiped as a God he also is included in this verse, and has also died as the verse says. The only person in the entire world, who he is invoked as God more then even Allah is Jesusasalone. There are over 2.2 billion Christians who believe in the divinity of Jesus. We also know that during the life of Holy Prophet Muhammadsaw, people believed Jesus was a God and worshiped him which clearly shows that he is included here. According to this ayah it is clear that when this was revealed to our Master Muhammadsaw, Isaas had indeed died already.

[@coolguy1283]

I'm wondering why he is he refering Muslims as Sunnis!! Laa haula wala quwatan illaa billah!! I never expected that from him.

[@victorycomeswithpatience8975]

May Allah Taala bless us to be like Al Ansar & Al Muhajirun Ameen Alhamdulillah Rabbil Aalaameen.

[@umarsyed7538]

Dear Dr. Shabbir you disappoint on this one. It's nice to be diplomatic but when it comes to Ahmediya you have to be more critical. I am sure you understand the weight of the problem so you cannot be so lukewarm.

[@mdsaifuddinahmed2199]

Brother he has to speak politely and in a manner that he doesn't offend anybody

[@noluckgamer9254]

@@mdsaifuddinahmed2199 O you who believe! Keep your duty to Allah and fear Him, and speak (always) the truth>> Ahzaab v 70 The truth is the truth and we should not try to hide it

[@A.--.]

The questions were very limited. Who are they and should people be violent against them. How about who are they and what proof do they give.

[@supergold-d1q]

Mr. Shabir Ahmad you did not search the fact. In 1974 all scholers of Islam gathered in Mekka and studied the beliefs of Ahmadis. Finally, they said that Ahmadis are unbelievers, they are not Muslims.

[@ahmadi_de8762]

Fair point though 33.41 means best of prophets for ahmadis 😊

[@arshadiqbal2980]

ک ا ف ر

[@ahmadi_de8762]

@@arshadiqbal2980 یور پِلر اوف اسلام اِز ٹو تکفیر آئی نو ۔

[@Blunt-k2m]

All Muslims should be United in common faith. All should be under the Muslim umbrella and stand together

[@Phicxtion]

God Alone

[@dlhussain81]

The words Ahmadi and Muslim do not go together....

[@barackmugatsia4714]

Ahmadis are true Muslims THOSE WORSHIPED BESIDES ALLAH ARE DEAD ALL INVOKED ON OTHER THAN ALLAH ARE DEAD (16:21-22) وَالَّذِينَ يَدْعُونَ مِنْ دُونِ اللَّهِ لَا يَخْلُقُونَ شَيْئًا وَهُمْ يُخْلَقُونَ{21} أَمْوَاتٌ غَيْرُ أَحْيَاءٍ ۖ وَمَا يَشْعُرُونَ أَيَّانَ يُبْعَثُونَ {22} “And those on whom they call beside Allah create not anything, but they are themselves created. They are dead, not living; and they know not when they will be raised” (Chapter 16 verse 21-22) These verses of the Holy Qur’an illustrate something really important. It is being mentioned that all the false Gods who people worshiped are dead and not alive. Since Jesusas is also one who is worshiped as a God he also is included in this verse, and has also died as the verse says. The only person in the entire world, who he is invoked as God more then even Allah is Jesusasalone. There are over 2.2 billion Christians who believe in the divinity of Jesus. We also know that during the life of Holy Prophet Muhammadsaw, people believed Jesus was a God and worshiped him which clearly shows that he is included here. According to this ayah it is clear that when this was revealed to our Master Muhammadsaw, Isaas had indeed died already.

[@hamzakhairi4765]

Isn't Isa AS supposed to kill the dajjal... so what does this this other dude claim to have done in the fight w dajjal

[@ahmad7171]

MashaAllah Dr. Shabir Ally very well explained.

[@syedshah7510]

Believing in any “prophet” after the final prophethood of prophet Muhammad (swt) takes you out of the folds of Islam, plain and simple. There is no compulsion in religion. Ahmedia is a different religion. Plain and simple. A weak reply from Shabbir.

[@ibrahim786ish]

I truly Admire Dr Sahbir Ally

[@Youtuberhannah]

I'm sorry but ahamdi cult has lost me when they said their leader is isa , a prophet and also mahdi all three at the same time that is madness. May Allah guide us all . Also if he was mahdi how come isa isn't here ? Isa will come when mahdi finally accepts the decrees and dajjal & mahdi will fight expect neither can the both kill one another so isa will come afterwards. After Mahdi's decree is finished Allah will take mahdi meaning mahdi will die and judgement day start the mountains will be folded , the rest of the creation will be in a drunk mode may Allah protect us the horror of the day of judgement it is very scary .

[@Billionaires29]

Muhammad SAW is the last law bearing messenger , the problem arises when you have different people interpreting Islam. Ahmadiyya claim to follow the correct interpretation of Islam. And do your research ahmadiyya follow the correct Islam.

[@sensefirst475]

Who is Abdul Ghaffar Jamba Sahib?

[@quiasnoorzad]

No Ahmadiyya was created by the British colonialism empire in india to cause a divide in Islam but thank God that they’re not even 1 percent of Muslim population.

[@rz8772]

seal of prophet means that he is the last prophet who can bring laws into the world. mirza ghulam ahmad (as) claimed to be a prophet who can bring only allahs message into the world and remove misconceptions. visit ahmadianswers youtube channel or website for more information. jazakallah khair

[@sensefirst475]

What sort of messages did Mirza Ghulam bring? Did you read them?

[@sensefirst475]

Often I watch the videos of your Ahmadi Answers! If you post a comment there inviting the attention of the viewers to a quotation of Mirza Ghulam Qadiyani, you will see that comment itself sometimes disappearing altogether! This fact further proves the Muslim accusation that Qadiyani people don't like to discuss the character, personality and sayings of Mirza!

[@كؤنؤمعالصادقين-ب4ن]

ختم نبوت اور حضرت علی There is another incident of Hazrat Ali which is as follows: وأخرج ابن الأنباري في المصاحف عن أبي عبد الرحمن السلمي قال: كنت اقرىء الحسن والحسين، فمر بي علي بن أبي طالب رضي الله عنه وأنا اقرئهما فقال لي: اقرئهما وخاتم النبيين بفتح التاء Abu Abdur Rahman narrates that he used to teach Hazrat Hasan and Hussain. Once Hazrat Ali bin Abu Talib passed nearby him while he was teaching them, so he said to him “Teach them Khataman Nabiyeen with a fatha on the ta” (Durr-e-Manthoor, Under 33,40) Now firstly, we already have proof from the Holy Prophet saw and his wife, the mother of the believers, that Prophethood is indeed open but only to a prophet from within the ummah. Hazrat Abu Abdullah Muhammad Bin Ali Hussain Al Hakim Al Tirmidhi states: يقول الصوفي المعروف محمد بن علي الحسن الحكيم الترمذي (المتوفى عام 308 هـ): “فإن الذي عَمِيَ عن خبرِ هذا يظنّ أن خاتم النبيين تأويله أنه آخرهم مبعثا. فأي منقبة في هذا؟ وأي علم في هذا؟ هذا تأويل البُلْهِ الجَهَلة.” (كتاب ختم الأولياء، ص341 المطبعة “According to us, it means that prophethood manifested itself in its full and complete manner in the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him . His heart became a vessel for the complete perfection of prophethood an d then hisheart was sealed. How can the glory and superiority of Muhammad, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, be manifested if we claim that he was the last to appear in the world. This is, no doubt, an interpretation of the foolish and the ignorant.” (Kitab Khatamul Auliya, Page 341) Al Imam Ibn Qutaybah ad-Dinwari who passed away in 267 After Hijri stated: ويورد الإمام ابن قتيبة - رحمه الله - قول عائشة رضي الله عنها، ويعلق عليه ويقول: “وليس هذا من قولها ناقضا لقول النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم: لا نبي بعدي، لأنه أراد لا نبي بعدي ينسخ ما جئت به.” (كتاب تأويل مختلف الأحاديث ص127 دار الكتاب العربي بيروت) “So far as it concerns the statement of ‘Ā’ishah ra: ‘Call the Apostle of Allāh (saw): The Seal of the Prophets and do not say: There will be no prophet after him’; it is directed to the descent of ‘Īsā asand this statement of her does not contradict the statement of the Prophet saw ‘There will be no prophet after me’, because he meant: ‘There will be not prophet after me who will abrogate that with which I came.” (Dar al-Kitaab Al Arabi, Beirut) Furthermore, a famous scholar named Shaykh Muhammad Tahir stated: ويقول الإمام محمد طاهر (المتوفى عام 986 هـ) أحد الصلحاء المعروفين، في شرح قول السيدة عائشة رضي الله عنها: “هذا ناظر إلى نـزول عيسى، وهذا أيضا لا ينافي حديث “لا نبي بعدي”، لأنه أراد لا نبي ينسخ شرعه.” (تكملة مجمع بحار الأنوار، لمحمد طاهر الغجراتي، ص 502) “And it is narrated from ‘Ā’ishah: ‘Say that he is the Seal of the Prophets and do not say: There will be no prophet after him’. This aims at the decent ‘Īsā, and this also does not contradict the ḥadīth‘There will be no prophet after me’, because he meant that no prophet will abrogate his sharī‘ah.” (Takmilah Majmaʻ biḥār al-anwār fī gharāʼib at-tanzīl wa-laṭāʼif al-akhbār) Even in the Sharh of Mishkat al Masabih it is written: وقال شارح “مشكاة المصابيح” محمد بن رسول الحسيني البرزنجي: “ورد “لا نبي بعدي” ومعناه عند العلماء أنه لا يحدث بعده نبي بشرع ينسخ شرعه.” (الإشاعة لأشراط الساعة ص149 دار الكتب العلمية بيروت) This is also telling us that La nabiyya badi refers to a prophet abrogating the shariah of the Holy Prophet saw. Hazrat Imam Mulla Ali Qari states: ومع هذا لو عاش إبراهيم وصار نبيا، وكذا لو صار عمر نبيا لكانا من أتباعه عليه الصلاة والسلام كعيسى والخضر وإلياس عليهم السلام. فلا يناقض قولَه تعالى: (وخاتم النبيين) إذ المعنى أنه لا يأتي نبي بعده ينسخ ملته ولم يكن من أمته.” (الأسرار المرفوعة في الأخبار الموضوعة لملا علي القاري ص192 دار الكتب العلمية بيروت) “Had Ibrahim lived and become a prophet, and likewise had Umar become a prophet they would be follower prophets of the Holy Prophet , peace and blesings of Allah be upon him, like Isa, Khizar and Ilyas upon whom all be peace. It does not contradict the divine word ‘KhatamunNabiyyeen’ which means that there shall not be a prophet abrogating his law nor one who was not of his followers. (Al Asrar al Marfuah fil Akhbr al Mauzuah Page 192) Hazrat Imam Jalal-ud-Din Suyuti states referring to the Advent of the latter day Messiah and his Prophethood: حقا كفر ته نبو بسلب قال من “Whoever says He Will not be a prophet, he has committed disbelief” (Hijajul Karamah Page 431) He also states that despite the latter day messiah would be a khalifa of the Ummah of Muhammadsaw, he shall remain a Messenger and a respected Prophet (Hijajul Karamah Page 426)

[@hailzzz313]

Really appreciated to hear the answer from Dr shabir Ally sb. He is really a broadminded person by saying Muslim donot have right to act violence.

[@ahmedakhan1]

He is not being broadminded, he is answering in the way of true Islam, of the Islam of the Quran, Allah's Book!

[@Aminxyo]

We are permitted and, in some cases, recommend violence, whether aggression or defence, as long as it is justifiable and done accordingly to the quran. You can find any solution to any problem there. There is nowhere that states that 'remaining a Victim' is the 'Muslim way'! That is not the correct way to approach every problem. We as a ummah we should Stop making excuses for avoiding any type of Jihad passive or non passive or everyday conflict to live comfortably in our self conscious lifes while the rest of our ummah suffers for our greedy neighbours' luxurious needs and/or judgemental criticism. Allah knows best.

[@mdrasid007]

Dr Shaabir Ally ,why did you say repeatedly that according to sunnis ...Are you saying that Shia accept Mirza qadiyani as a messiah or prophet but not sunnis??.Do you accept Mirza Qadiyani as a prophet or Messiah?

[@bf6724]

So that he can say that they are not Sunnis without having to say that they are not Muslims. This is his indirect way to admit that they are Muslims! even if he does not agree with them. Unfortunately, Dr. Shabir Ally has a lot of false beliefs, and these are not the only ones. I hope that he will repent to Allah before it is too late.

[@muhammadimuslim2179]

You didn't mention that they consider their new prophet equal to prophet Muhammad S. who has a share in Kalima. This belief makes Muslim have violent reactions against them.

[@areejrizvi29]

We never believe that? Where are you getting it from? hazrat Mohammed saw is the most superior the most high rank the best noone will ever be equal with him,ever.

[@behuman8855]

Please note that any hadith could contradicts the Holly Qur'an: What is the "Hojjat" Allah upon people? Of course the Prophets! Then where is the prophet for nowadays greatest "Shirk" and "Koffr"? We know all that the Humanity now exposed to a great "3dab", then where is the suitable prophet according to verse in Holly Qur'an: - ( ...وما كنا معذبين حتى نبعث رسولا...)- For me if "Murza" isn't the Messiah then in all case the right Messiah is surely among us and should be a Prophet! Allah is All-knowing, Salamoâlaykom

[@sensefirst475]

Dr Shabir Ally is an academician. He will say things only with academic discipline! As most of the books of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadiyani Sahib are still in Urdu (not available even in English) they are unreachable to Dr Ally! (I suppose, he cannot read Urdu)! Much of the controversial writings and fake claims of Qadiyanism are therefore unknown to him! This I think, is the reason why Dr Shabir Ally is cautious while speaking!

[@sensefirst475]

I am the Muslim son of Qadiyani father and Urdu is difficult for me. It is my personal experience that it is impossible to get the English translations of some books of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadiyani!

[@soroshbk1379]

@@sensefirst475 it indeed is possible to get all books of the promised messiah and mahdi a.s. in english by now. The translation work takes a while. Patience counts off.

[@mrHasan-go8kr]

@2.44 this is exactly we should do pay respect to others thoughts even they are against us and never be violent and invite for a healthy dialogue

[@flowerh691]

Shia’s also dont believe there is any prophet after Prophet Mohammed (PBUH&HF), not just sunni’s.

[@gems1717]

Ask him if he believes in Hazrat Muhammad saw as the last prophet of Allah ??

[@sutil5078]

The best answer is "they are not considered correct interpretation of islam" and the last question was a shame, I urge you to change it. do not ask it, islam never encourage violence.. it is obvious. Islam is against violence, the question though give the impression is otherwise.

[@ahmedakhan1]

It may be obvious that Islam is against violence but that is not what has been happening in the Islamic world with all the violence. It is good for Dr. Shabbir Ally to reiterate that violence is never acceptable!

[@Reverted2006]

Dr Shabbir didn't mention that Ahmadis believe Mirza Ghulam the second coming of Prophet Muhammad S too.. Nauzubillah 😮

[@bhb9926]

What about polytheist brelvi, Shia sects who are henotheists worshipping one chief God and several subordinate gods like prophets, imams, peers and so on. Besides, what about salafi Muslims who fabricate false hadith about prophet, although the glorious Koran categorically refutes all hadith other than what is mention in the glorious Koran (7:185,186) and Allah calls such people as liars and cast His curse upon them (45:6,7,8). So, who is a true believer ? Only Allah Almighty knows it.

[@akongvlogg9737]

If Prophet Muhammad Saw(pbuh) is the Last Prephet.Why Muslims waiting for coming of Imam Mahdi? The Qur’an testified he is the last (saw)

[@boxingmonthly]

Dear Ahmadiyya: WHERE did you get the phrase: 'Love for All, hatred for None' ? ever heard of the word Biddah ? that is a dangerous game you're playing. As Islam is perfect and we don't need to add our own phrases as if it is part of the deen (let alone the false 'messiah') - that aside. Using this man made slogan is just another example that Ahmadiyya is Outside of Islam. And what if i showed you something that totally opposes this teaching? this is clearly just a ploy to get kaffirs on your side

[@leebrown4570]

so who will be the last prophet when jesus dose come back ?

[@Suhail0906]

Lee Brown Jesus Has Died A Natural Death Just Like Every Other Prophet...The Imaam Mahdi Mirza Ghulam Came In The Spirit Of Jesus(as). Chapter 3 Verse 145 It Is

[@sensefirst475]

Whether Jesus, pbuh, comes back or not Muhammad, s a w, is the last and final Prophet!

[@Suhail0906]

@@sensefirst475 Yes...he is the last prophet who BROUGHT A LAW to MANKIND...

[@sensefirst475]

@@Suhail0906 Last Prophet is Last Prophet! صَلَّى اللّٰهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ

[@eesah37]

@@Suhail0906 Quran 33:40 Read that and tell me what that says and what it means

[@quantumresonance8201]

He is afraid of imprecating the wrath of God upon himself. Ahmadiyyat interpretation of the Holy Quran is far more clearer and logical than those using a 500 years old interpretation of a book that stands the test of all times. Sunni Muslim have a very limited understanding of the Holy Quran. The Quran is more of a book that they recite melodiously but don't understand the intrinsic message of it in our contemporary world. Just looking at the turmoil in the Muslim world, whom the majority is purported to be Sunnis. www.alislam.org or www.mta.tv to inform yourself about Ahmadiyya from the source.

[@DubSalvation]

From a leader that died in his on excrement? No thanks mate I'd rather not.

[@ethanthompson9569]

@@DubSalvation if you died in your excrement would you want someone to say things like this about you?

[@SaadatMansoorOfficial]

ASLAMULIKUM So this molana said is right but one thing which he didn't said the thing is Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadiani A.S is the Messiah and Mehdi which was already announced by hazrat Muhammad S.A.W 1400 years ago and one more sunni vs ahmadi difference is the topic of this video so tell me if sunni are more beliefs why they are famous in the world as bad people And Ahmadi Muslim as peaceful people think about this...JazakAllah

[@sensefirst475]

You can shower beutiful epithets around the name of Mirza Ghulam! You do have the right and freedom! For Muslims, he was a Promiscuous Nonsense as observable from that man's actions and writings!

[@sirAkiliz]

Do Ahamdiyyas beleive in hadith?? I've a Ahmadiyya muslim friend he told me that he doesn't believe in the return of Jesus

[@theultimateshaz1774]

Knight of Ren we do believe in Hadith.

[@GholamFareed]

@@theultimateshaz1774 you Qadianis obviously don't cos if you did you would never accept your prophet Qadiani who was so confused he even didn't know whether he was the Mahdi or a prophet or the messiah. In the Hadith Syedna Rasoul Salallahu Alaihi Was Salam explicitly warned us of false prophets & dajjjals like your Qadiani!!!

[@yusufal-muqtadir2494]

Im sunni and i love ahmadyaa muslims. They really value science and peace. Some of the sunnis are so backward. But Mohamed sws is the last prophet