Q: Go! I give you 3 Divorces. Does his wife become forbidden for him, forever?

[@YunusKhan-pk4xk]

Talak ke upar abhi tak ki sabse behtarin video yah hai Allah aap ki Umra Mein Barkat De

[@mj7996]

Subhan Allah.Bahot bachhiyo ki dua liye aap

[@mirzatahirbaig3444]

ماشاءاللہ بہت خوب صورت طریق سے سمجھا

[@muhammadasifkhan2296]

Jazakallah bohat ala bayan hy aap ka

[@badrujzamanfaruki1921]

Jazakallah! Amazing explanation! No doubt full clarity!

[@firozfaisal4557]

M apka bohot shukrguzar hu apne bohot sahi tariqe se samjhaya or mujhe lagta h sahi samjhaya h

[@jannatulferdousjannat2474]

Many Many Many thanks for this video & all of this information. Now I can take my decision with full of confidence. Assalamu Alaikum.

[@TheAlp.]

Can u update me? Also going through something sumiler

[@babololo3836]

Thank you sir, for this all information. I love so much Allah, and I’m so happy after this information.

[@muhammadishaque7500]

ماشااللہ بہت خوب ۔جزاک اللہ خیر ۔شیخ

[@almasjosephs6065]

What if the man gives the third Talaaq but was coerced by others to do so? Does the talaaq stay valid even if he based his decision on false information by people who wanted to gain from his divorce.?? Can it still be accepted or is it NoT accepted as the last talaaq

[@bourney4914]

Both those views can be adapted as both are strong Evidences example.. A man gives Talaq 3 times in one go and he is not aware that this after the iddah leads to them not marrying again at all. Then it is one, however if he was aware of it then it's full 3. It all boils down to questioning the man and him swearing by ALLAH wether he knew the end outcome or not, or did he know 3 times in one sitting is just 1 or did he believe it being complete 3. if he didn't know both outcomes then it's just 1(as favoured opinion of the shaykh in video) If the man lies then it is ALLAH who will judge him in the end we have no ability to know the hearts of mankind. This will wrap up both views comfortably for implementation.

[@rehanakhan8021]

Aslamualikum wa rahmatullahi wa barkakatuhu Kya Hayz (menses)mein talaq ho jati Hein Kya plz reply

[@Dai_rui]

Divorce is not allowed in islam for women if they have not suffered physical or emothional abuse. Most imams will not agree to divorce without these types of conditions for women, whereas men dont need any excuses. So situations like mentioned here about not being in Love with her husband, under islam law, you dont have the right to divorce. I have heard so many imams talk about this, and everytime it comes to this. But i believe men and women, doesnt matter what religion or culture, arent fully educated on marriage. Although it seems islamic stay away from sin for sisters, please think about yourself and the double standards you might face if you end up in a divorce. If anyone has more info about this please share. So we can talk about these very serious issue that surround women in islam. There is more discussion on youtube about what to do on wedding night then these issues, and we need to change that together.

[@naimkhan1217]

Masha-Allah sir, we need to teach Muslim people how to understand Quran.

[@ayeshasaphdar3383]

Asa, Sir kindly tell if a husband divorce thrice in 1 majlis and get seprated and doesnt Ruju in 3 months. And never repeat divorce 2nd and 3rd time does the lady get divorced? implemented after 3 months?

[@razamughal4582]

Yes. As soon as iddat is over the woman is free, in this casee she can do a new nikah with her ex husband

[@AkasMd-zm1ig]

Mashallah ❤❤❤

[@afshansajjad6439]

Very right way to give talaq

[@SnowyPlayzAdoptMe]

You are disgusting

[@SaaSar-l1l]

Agar third time at different instance said only once talaq nog three times …is it done ?

[@razamughal4582]

yes

[@missnbcrafts]

What about talaq given in menstruation sir ji?

[@razamughal4582]

it counts as a talaq

[@adenabdi5696]

God knows Everything.

[@worldfacts7337]

This one is for face to face what if husband give divorce to wife on message sending the message of divorce 3 times ? Will it also consider 1 or 3 talaq?

[@razamughal9095]

3

[@shshnawazmallick]

​@@razamughal9095what you have learnt from this video.. Still you are in misconception, the right way is that if a person gives talaq 3 times or 3K times in the form of verbal, sms, ya other means it will be considered one.

[@razamughal9095]

@@shshnawazmallick rubbish. you are a rakhel. din rat talay sunti reh gaye ho. no self respect. This man has died making women a rakhel. and a rakhel gives birth to haram children and haram children do not get their fathers name or inheritance.

[@razamughal9095]

@@shshnawazmallick baqwas. teri maa behn sari zindagi talaqy sunti reh gaye hain

[@ShovasDiary_]

Are you sure about your answer? ​@@razamughal9095

[@fawadahmadi9579]

If the couple is going to get back after first talaq. Do they need a fresh nekah?

[@razamughal4582]

Only if the womans iddah is over. Once that happens she is free from her nikah permanently even after just ONE talaq. She is free to marry anyone. This initself proves that three talaqs are THREE.

[@ShovasDiary_]

Triple talaq in one setting is consider 3 talaq or 1 talaq..

[@razamughal4582]

3

[@ShovasDiary_]

@razamughal4582 Reference?

[@razamughal4582]

@@ShovasDiary_ its not references that todays people need, its education. your concepts are not clear so understand the concept: a man should break the nikah with ONE talaq. That is the sunnah way to do it. After that the woman observes iddah (IDDAAH IS NOT TALAQ - thats why it has a different name. that is IDDAH). During the iddah in this instance the woman remains a WIFE. This is why the man can reconcile with her in the first place without requiring a nikah. She cannot marry anyone else. when someone is your wife you can divorce her as many times as you like and each time he says it divorce comes into effect *on the spot* Divorce ALWAYS happens on the spot. So, here is the thing to understand: when a man reconciles with a woman he reconciles with a *DIVORCEE* She is a divorced woman. By him taking her back the divorce does NOT cancel out, it is counted forever. So she is a divorcee but she can live as a wife because her husband reconciled. An example of this is when a company dismisses an employee. If he decides to take his company to a union and they mediate and resolve the dispute, and his job is re instated, we do not say that he was not sacked in the first place. rather, he was sacked (the same as a woman WAS divorced), but reconciliation meant that the sacked person got his job back. so reconciliation happens AFTER the event. something *must* have happened for reconciliation to be required. That 'something' was talaq. Same process for a second divorce. In the *third* divorce, Allahs law changes. This PROVES that in islam there are only *two* talaqs. There is no such thing as three talaqs in islam. when something does not exist then saying stupid things like 'three are one' or 'three are two' or three are three' is futile. yes, when one nikah is broken with ONE talaq that is the sum of 1+1+1=3. That is *not* a three talaq concept. that is simple maths where 1+1+1=3. in other words three NIKAHS exist, NOT three talaqs. When a woman is in iddah and her husband does not reconcile with her, just after receiving ONE talaq she is free from her nikah forever. Then she is free to do a nikah with any man she wants including her ex husband. Now, coming to the third talaq: in this particular iddah the woman is NOT a wife any more. despite this she *still* observes iddah when she cannot be reconciled with nor can she marry another man, she STILL observes iddah. at this point you will understand what the Quran is saying and why. This proves that this third talaq was merely a formality with the understanding that when a man gives a talaq for the third time he has burned all his bridges. so saying the talaq for the third time can be likened to when two people make a verbal agreement yet they still decide to type out a contract and one signs it, or when a court stamps a document: its JUST a formality. What this then PROVES is that talaq is NOT a process. because there are at least 5 circumstances that I can think of when Allah has forbidden men and women reconciling in the iddah. So iddah is not the determining factor of talaq. what it PROVES is that the ONLY criteria Allah has set for talaq is the man SAYING it. if he says it once, its one. if he says it twice, its two. if he says it three times its THREE. NO ONE HAD A GUN TO HIS HEAD. As for evidence from the Quran and the Sunnah, they are NUMEROUS and thats another topic. here I have cleared the concept. what talaq ACTUALLY is. There is a lot more to be said. One thing is clear: any woman who lives with a man is a mistress and any resulting pregnancy will birth a haram illegitimate child. And illegitimate children do NOT get their fathers name or their inheritance. This is a much more serious issue than halala. and a halala that happens by coincidence is VALID. one that happens with preplanning is haram.

[@razamughal4582]

its not references that todays people need, its education. your concepts are not clear so understand the concept: a man should break the nikah with ONE talaq. That is the sunnah way to do it. After that the woman observes iddah (IDDAAH IS NOT TALAQ - thats why it has a different name. that is IDDAH). During the iddah in this instance the woman remains a WIFE. This is why the man can reconcile with her in the first place without requiring a nikah. She cannot marry anyone else. when someone is your wife you can divorce her as many times as you like and each time he says it divorce comes into effect *on the spot* Divorce ALWAYS happens on the spot. So, here is the thing to understand: when a man reconciles with a woman he reconciles with a *DIVORCEE* She is a divorced woman. By him taking her back the divorce does NOT cancel out, it is counted forever. So she is a divorcee but she can live as a wife because her husband reconciled. An example of this is when a company dismisses an employee. If he decides to take his company to a union and they mediate and resolve the dispute, and his job is re instated, we do not say that he was not sacked in the first place. rather, he was sacked (the same as a woman WAS divorced), but reconciliation meant that the sacked person got his job back. so reconciliation happens AFTER the event. something *must* have happened for reconciliation to be required. That 'something' was talaq. Same process for a second divorce. In the *third* divorce, Allahs law changes. This PROVES that in islam there are only *two* talaqs. There is no such thing as three talaqs in islam. when something does not exist then saying stupid things like 'three are one' or 'three are two' or three are three' is futile. yes, when one nikah is broken with ONE talaq that is the sum of 1+1+1=3. That is *not* a three talaq concept. that is simple maths where 1+1+1=3. in other words three NIKAHS exist, NOT three talaqs. When a woman is in iddah and her husband does not reconcile with her, just after receiving ONE talaq she is free from her nikah forever. Then she is free to do a nikah with any man she wants including her ex husband. Now, coming to the third talaq: in this particular iddah the woman is NOT a wife any more. despite this she *still* observes iddah when she cannot be reconciled with nor can she marry another man, she STILL observes iddah. at this point you will understand what the Quran is saying and why. This proves that this third talaq was merely a formality with the understanding that when a man gives a talaq for the third time he has burned all his bridges. so saying the talaq for the third time can be likened to when two people make a verbal agreement yet they still decide to type out a contract and one signs it, or when a court stamps a document: its JUST a formality. What this then PROVES is that talaq is NOT a process. because there are at least 5 circumstances that I can think of when Allah has forbidden men and women reconciling in the iddah. So iddah is not the determining factor of talaq. what it PROVES is that the ONLY criteria Allah has set for talaq is the man SAYING it. if he says it once, its one. if he says it twice, its two. if he says it three times its THREE. NO ONE HAD A GUN TO HIS HEAD. As for evidence from the Quran and the Sunnah, they are NUMEROUS and thats another topic. here I have cleared the concept. what talaq ACTUALLY is. There is a lot more to be said. One thing is clear: any woman who lives with a man is a mistress and any resulting pregnancy will birth a haram illegitimate child. And illegitimate children do NOT get their fathers name or their inheritance. This is a much more serious issue than halala. and a halala that happens by coincidence is VALID. one that happens with preplanning is haram.

[@razamughal4582]

its not references that todays people need, its education. your concepts are not clear so understand the concept: a man should break the nikah with ONE talaq. That is the sunnah way to do it. After that the woman observes iddah (IDDAAH IS NOT TALAQ - thats why it has a different name. that is IDDAH). During the iddah in this instance the woman remains a WIFE. This is why the man can reconcile with her in the first place without requiring a nikah. She cannot marry anyone else. when someone is your wife you can divorce her as many times as you like and each time he says it divorce comes into effect *on the spot* Divorce ALWAYS happens on the spot. So, here is the thing to understand: when a man reconciles with a woman he reconciles with a *DIVORCEE* She is a divorced woman. By him taking her back the divorce does NOT cancel out, it is counted forever. So she is a divorcee but she can live as a wife because her husband reconciled. An example of this is when a company dismisses an employee. If he decides to take his company to a union and they mediate and resolve the dispute, and his job is re instated, we do not say that he was not sacked in the first place. rather, he was sacked (the same as a woman WAS divorced), but reconciliation meant that the sacked person got his job back. so reconciliation happens AFTER the event. something *must* have happened for reconciliation to be required. That 'something' was talaq. Same process for a second divorce. In the *third* divorce, Allahs law changes. This PROVES that in islam there are only *two* talaqs. There is no such thing as three talaqs in islam. when something does not exist then saying stupid things like 'three are one' or 'three are two' or three are three' is futile. yes, when one nikah is broken with ONE talaq that is the sum of 1+1+1=3. That is *not* a three talaq concept. that is simple maths where 1+1+1=3. in other words three NIKAHS exist, NOT three talaqs. When a woman is in iddah and her husband does not reconcile with her, just after receiving ONE talaq she is free from her nikah forever. Then she is free to do a nikah with any man she wants including her ex husband. Now, coming to the third talaq: in this particular iddah the woman is NOT a wife any more. despite this she *still* observes iddah when she cannot be reconciled with nor can she marry another man, she STILL observes iddah. at this point you will understand what the Quran is saying and why. This proves that this third talaq was merely a formality with the understanding that when a man gives a talaq for the third time he has burned all his bridges. so saying the talaq for the third time can be likened to when two people make a verbal agreement yet they still decide to type out a contract and one signs it, or when a court stamps a document: its JUST a formality. What this then PROVES is that talaq is NOT a process. because there are at least 5 circumstances that I can think of when Allah has forbidden men and women reconciling in the iddah. So iddah is not the determining factor of talaq. what it PROVES is that the ONLY criteria Allah has set for talaq is the man SAYING it. if he says it once, its one. if he says it twice, its two. if he says it three times its THREE. NO ONE HAD A GUN TO HIS HEAD. As for evidence from the Quran and the Sunnah, they are NUMEROUS and thats another topic. here I have cleared the concept. what talaq ACTUALLY is. There is a lot more to be said. One thing is clear: any woman who lives with a man is a mistress and any resulting pregnancy will birth a haram illegitimate child. And illegitimate children do NOT get their fathers name or their inheritance. This is a much more serious issue than halala. and a halala that happens by coincidence is VALID. one that happens with preplanning is haram.

[@Imadeyourun]

Assalam alaikum, I hope someone can answer my question here. I have told my wife that I divorced her, and although I said the words three times in one setting, I was angry and was merely repeating myself, but was unaware that uttering the word three times in one sitting could actually lead to me not being able to tske her back. So even though my wife was misbehaving and I only wanted to scare her, I think I may have made a huge mistake. Is she now haram for me? Please help. Because I feel terrible, and really didn't mean to hurt her in any way, as I truly do still love her. Thanks in advance, and jazakallah khair.

[@Sharjeel456]

Surah bakra verse 228 to 242 plz read and u will got ur follow only quran

[@razamughal9095]

nothing can be done. three talaqs are THREE

[@Imadeyourun]

@@razamughal9095 Late reply, but I have spoken to an actual shiekh, and a detailed explanation, it was not three. This matter has already been put be, but thanks for your input all the same.

[@razamughal9095]

@@Imadeyourun you went to the wrong sheikh. simple as that. only a qualified mufti can give a fatwa and to date, the hanafi is the last fiqh standing that adheres to the original fatwa of the four imams. *none of the four great imams EVER considered three talaqs to be one* any mufti today that goes against the learned men from the first four generations of the Prophet are CORRUPT.

[@Imadeyourun]

@@razamughal9095 So are you the right sheikh? You don't even know my full story and you think you are well informed enough to say that went to the wrong sheikh?!?! It was just one sheikh, by the way. It was different sheikhs, people of know, and an Islamic judge. Make that last comment you have on the matter, as have absolutely no idea what you're about, and are merely a layman.

[@imamkhan6470]

Mashallah bahut hoob

[@QEAREMR7]

But in pakistan this law is not followed, evry one consider here that 3 at once is 3.

[@razamughal9095]

three are three

[@muftigpatel7648]

Masha Allah samjane ka tarika Bahut Hi achha hai magar sajde wali misal samaj me nahi aayi Kyu k aap kehte hai k ek shakhs sajde me teen martaba kahe subhanalaah, subhanalaah, subhanalaah. To teen martaba kehna shumar hoga to isi tarah Koi shakhs apni biwi ko teen martaba rahe tuje talak, tuje talak, tuje talak to teen hi martaba shumar honi chahiye baqol aapke jaise sajde me teen martaba shumar hota hai Aapki dalil aap par hi hujjat hai. Jara gor kar lijiye.

[@arshmanali5795]

Molana Sb ager kisi admi ne 8sal phele ak majles me 3Talaq likh kar di ho or 8sal Bad wo dobara rojo karna chata Ho or orat ke pas us ka 8sal ka bacha bhi ho tu Kia wo dobara nikha kar sakte hain Kia molana Sb ap ka koi contact no mil sakta hai

[@iman9480]

Kia fatwa mila Ruju kiya apne,?

[@razamughal9095]

Nai, teen teen hoti hain

[@krishna9078]

3 mnths mey kr skty bus

[@dr.syedasimshah5256]

Name and contact of molana Sahab plz. Can anyone please share

[@izy9911]

Shokran

[@aasimir4044]

Can a wife give talaq

[@razamughal9095]

no

[@sanashahrukh6837]

hr br talaq ka zikr krte hoay aurat ki islah ka bola ja rha hota hai jab k talaq mard de rha hota hai or baz mard to din raat talaq dete hain ghakti kr mard raha hai br br or islah ki baat aurat ko ki ja rhi hai.... aise mardon ki talaq ko accet kiya jaeyga b ya nahi.....????

[@razamughal4582]

yes accept kiya jayga. yeh bhi toh sochy k aurat ne char shadiya rok kar apny ap ko doh taqy ka bana diya, aur doh taqy ki aurat k sat mard acha ravaiya nai rakhna chaty. izad aur kushi se woh aurat jee rahi hain jo shadi shuda mardo se shadi kar rahi hain. pir aisi aurat jo hindu maa ki tarbiyat ki waja se talaq ko nai manti woh banti hain kisi ki maa. pir un aurto k hi yeh begairat bety hoty hain jo kaminy di raat talaq bholty hain.

[@miscellaneous2381]

mashallah

[@studycorner974]

Right hi yes

[@haseebwadood2322]

Marra means times, just like in Quran Allah commanded muslims to knock and seek permission three times when to enter into sb's house, including servants. Marra has been used there as well. In hadiths for sajdas and rukuh in prayers, marra has been used. If the commands of talaq in Quran were related to occassions, then Allah would have commanded that talaq in allowed in only two occassions and not two times

[@Nvm_Sanri0]

Marra is associated with Hajj too . It's a time bound word. Go and learn Arabic grammar from some native alam. U cant do two Hajj in the same year. Anyhow it's useless to do discussion.

[@Nvm_Sanri0]

@@haseebwadood2322 sorry I m tired to do a lengthy discussion and research.

[@Nvm_Sanri0]

@@haseebwadood2322 فعل مضارع میں تعداد کی حد مقرر ہے ،،،، مگر اس کا تعلق زمانے کے ساتھ ہے،،، اور طلاق کا تعلق بھی زمانے کے ساتھ ہے،،، یہ کوئی کھجور اور حلوے کی پلیٹ کی طرح گنتی کرنے والی چیز نہیں مثال کے طور پر،،، مثال نمبر ۱،،،محمد ندیم مغل نے حلوے کی دو پلیٹیں کھائیں،،، اس جملے میں مرتان کا لفظ استعمال نہیں ہوگا،،،بلکہ عدد کی وجہ سے گنتی کا لفظ استعمال ہوگا،،،، مثال نمبر ۲،،،، محإد ندیم مغل نے دو مرتبہ حج کیا،، اس جملے میں زمانے کا ذکر ہے اور ظاہر ہے کہ حج سال میں صرف ایک بار ہی کیا جاسکتا ہے،،، اسلئے زمانے کی وجہ سے اس میں مرتان کا لفظ استعمال ہوگا،،، اسی طرح طلاق میں مرتان الگ الگ زمانے کیلئے ہے،،، جیسے الطلاق مرتان کا مطلب بنتا ہے کہ طلاق دو مرتبہ ہے،، اس کا مطلب دو مہینے کے ہیں نہ کہ صرف طلاق طلاق کے،،، اور جو لوگ الطلاق مرتان سے طلاق طلاق یعنی گنتی کی دو طلاق مراد لیتے ہیں وہ غلطی پر ہیں جبکہ قرآن میں مرتان کا لفظ واضح کررہا ہے کہ اس سے طلاق طلاق یعنی گنتی کی دو طلاق مراد نہیں بلکہ الگ الگ وقت میں دی گئی دو طلاقیں مراد ہیں اور الگ الگ وقت میں دی گئی دو طلاقوں کی وضاحت سورہ بقرہ کی آیت 228 میں ثلاثۃ قرو یعنی طہر و حیض کے تین ادوار یعنی تقریباً تین مہینے بتادئے گئے ہیں،،، وَالْمُطَلَّقَاتُ يَتَـرَبَّصْنَ بِاَنْفُسِهِنَّ ثَلَاثَةَ قُرُوٓءٍ ۚ اللہ نے قرآن میں اتنی وضاحت کے ساتھ طلاق کے مسائل بیان کئے ہیں مگر پھر بھی ہٹ دھرمی کا مظاہرہ کرنا بہت بڑی جہالت ہے،،، سعودی عرب میں رہنا یا عربی زبان جاننے کا مطلب یہ نہیں کہ انسان ابو جہل یا ابولہب نہیں ہوسکتا،،، وہ بھی اہل زبان تھے مگر جان بوجھ کر ہٹ دھرمی کا مظاہرہ کررہے تھے،،، ہمارے آخری نبی کی بعثت سعودی عرب سے ہوئی اور سعودی عرب والوں کی زبان میں ہی قرآن نازل ہوا تھا،،، مگر غزوہ بدر کے وقت صرف تین سو تیرہ صحابی تھی،،، اور موجودہ دور میں سعودی عرب کے حکمرانوں کا رویہ مسلمانوں کے حق میں بہت ہی برا اور امریکیوں کے حق میں بہت ہی اچھا ہے حالانکہ وہ قرآن کو سمجھتے بھی ہیں اور ان کی زبان بھی الحمد للہ عربی ہے،،،

[@Nvm_Sanri0]

طلاق بھی فعل مضارع ہے،،، اس کا مطلب ہے کہ طلاق عدد نہیں ہے،، اور طلاق طلاق طلاق کہنے سے پھر تین طلاق نہیں ہونی چاہئے،،، کیونکہ قرآن میں طلاق کیلئے عدد کا لفظ نہیں بلکہ فعل کا لفظ استعمال ہوا ہے،،،، اور طلاق کو اللہ رب العزت نے سورہ بقرہ کی آیت 228 میں ثلثۃ قرو کے ساتھ جوڑ دیا ہے،،، یعنی تین زمانے،، یعنی تین طہر و حیض،،،، اس کے بغیر طلاق ممکن نہیں ہے،،، جہاں تک آپ کے مشورے کا تعلق ہے تو مولانا ابو الاعلیٰ مودودی کا تعلق خود ہے فرقے سے تھا،،، انہوں نے علما دیوبند کے ترجمہ کو سلیس انداز میں آسان الفاظ کے ساتھ شائع کیا تھا،،، ان کے ترجمے اور علما دیوبند کے ترجمے میں کوئی فرق نہیں،، اور دیوبندی بریلوی سب شاہ ولی اللہ کے بیٹے شاہ عبد القادر کے ترجمے سے استفادہ کرتے ہیں،، اس وقت کسی کی اندھی تقلید کرنے کے بجائے مشاورت کی ضرورت ہے، قرآن کے الفاظ کی ذمہ داری اللہ رب العزت نے لی ہے اور اس میں قیامت تک کوئی تحریف نہیں کرسکتا،،، البتہ ترجمہ کے میں تحریف کی گئی ہے،،، جس کی وجہ سے اسلام اجنبی بن گیا ہے اور امت گمراہی کے دلدل میں پھنس گئی ہے.

[@Nvm_Sanri0]

Bhai mai apni naqis aqal sai jitna samjh saki , beta diya. Abb please mazeed behas nahi kero gee. Aap ki apni qabar , meri apni. Allah sab par reham karay. Or hum sab ko deen ki rah par chalnay ki taufeeq dai . Ameen. Yeh ummat ka Buhat bara ikhtilafi masla hai . Baaqi Allah sab par reham karay.

[@RizwanAli-vc4vb]

Inka nmber mill sakta h

[@suomipoikasuomipoika4653]

ماشالله الله پاك آپ كو اچر دى

[@AamirKhan-gu5pt]

agar koi talaq ki jagah tallaq kahe to talaq ho jayegi

[@newgrowth7771]

Or Talakh. . 😅

[@haseebwadood2322]

The mullah is lying, Abdullah ibni Abbas in all his fitwas established triple divorce, I have another question as well. If three divorce in one sitting is counted as one, then why Muhammad S.A.W got angry when that person gave three divorces in one sitting?????

[@salahudeenshaikh7566]

Talaq must be in 3 different time not in one time 3 talaq because it's agaist allah's command. Like 5 time prayer are throughout in day so you must pray in accordingly if not then not acceptable so if you pray 5 namaz in one hour and say I have finished my 5 prayer so it's cannot be considered 5 time prayer in a day..

[@haseebwadood2322]

@@salahudeenshaikh7566 Please do not apply the rule of obligations on malimaat, prayers are obligations while divorce is dealings among the people. When people offer qaza prayers, then do you say about that. Qaza prayers can be offered at one time, even years of qaza prayers can be offered. Second Quran does not speak of first divorce, second divorce and the third divorce, quran says three divorces allowed, it means the numbers allowed are three related to the numerical value and not the occasion, otherwise Quran should have mentioned that Divorce are first second and third, in the latter case the occasion becomes the subject of interest, which is not. Last but not the least, prayers are different with respect to number of rakats and other essentials. Where as all the three divorces are the same, all of them occurs during the time of period of purity, but if sb utter divorce in pregnancy or menstruation, divorce occurs, but not according to Quran and Sunnah. When a doctor ask a patient that one is allowed to take three tablets of a prescription in lifetime, also he advises to take each tablet after a gap of one week after previous intake, if the patient takes all the three tablets all at once. It would never mean not sb can say that the patient has taken only one tablet, as it would be adsurd. similarly, Allah has advised muslims to divorce in a manner, but if they divorce against that prescibed manner, divorce occurs. Hazrat Khula case in Para 28, in that case Quran has declared that type of divorce as forbidden, but still divorce occurs and Quran has specified remedy for such divorce. Mr Sahauddin Sheikh please proof your stance according to Quran and hadith.

[@haseebwadood2322]

@@salahudeenshaikh7566 In case you rule is applied, then according to Quran, on divorce would occur during pregnancy or menstruation, but that is not true at all, as divorce was counted during menstruation, Quran even has in ayat number Al-baqarah 228 that pregnancy cannot sop from people to seek divorce.

[@MWA1407]

The hadith of prophet saw getting angry was "are you playing with the words of Allah whilst im alive". You can Cleary see playing means making a mockery joke out of it. Nabi saw was mad at the person for playing with the words and doing it happily with no remorse.

[@1untouchablepk]

And who are you to judge? Islam is a faith of logic and reason, people also make mistakes especially in delicate and emotional situations. In any case don’t call somebody a liar if you do not have any clear cut proof.