Bashani says Why India does not take Pak’s offers for talks serious ? Pak FM once again wants talks

he Qamar Cheema Podcast Link
• Ambassador Hashmi Spea...
Dr. Qamar Cheema is an Islamabad-based Academic and Stretegic analyst. My area of interest is Islamist Parties of Pakistan, Indo Pacific Region and South Asian Politics. I regularly appear on national and international media Including DW, Aljazeera , India Today , CNN News 18, Times Radio UK , CBC Canada and other Tv Stations as Strategic and Political Analyst. Other than Research Work I also write articles for newspapers.
Follow Qamar Cheema :
Facebook: / qamar.cheema.1
Twitter: / qamarcheema
Instagram : / cheemaqamar

[@Value_Pilgrim]

*MESSAGE TO ALL INDIANS & SPECIALLY MODI JI : No Trade! No Talks! No Aid! No Engagement of any kinds with Pakistan!*

[@njyala]

Fully agreed!

[@Sam-kd2dc]

Not even free medical treatment. We have many deserving people. Help them instead of helping demons

[@Value_Pilgrim]

@@Sam-kd2dc 💯👏👌

[@rajp9183]

Request to Indian's ... Please boycott Pak channels , Utubers Don't waste your time अपना दिमाग खराब न करें , आगे आपकी मर्जी

[@ranapartap1501]

Keep your friends close and enenmy closer so you can keep an eye on them in this case beware of their mindset hate and thinking So you prepare for them

[@rohitbarman7642]

Also ban dhruv rathee's channel

[@rajp9183]

@@rohitbarman7642 I think he is out of India , should be punished

[@ex.fighter8939]

जब आपकी अपनी गर्लफ्रेंड या घरवाली से लड़ाई हो जाये तब मन बहलाने के लिए पाकिस्तानी चैनल देख ले 😅

[@mahenderpalsingh7509]

Dislike

[@Anonymous_Introvert_26]

Pakistan (joker) foreign policy in short: June 25, 2024: Pak's Foreign Minister says "Pak doesn't believe in perpetual hostility with India. We want good neighborly and friendly relations with India" June 26, 2024: Pak alleges that the so-called TTP (which is Pak's own creation) commander caught in Baluchistan says that India is behind the terrorism in Pak and RAW wants the merger of BLA & TTP to fight against Pakistan. This is the seriousness with which Pak conducts its foreign policy where within 24 hours it takes complete 180-degree turn. You allege terror charges against the same country with which you want to normalize relations to save your bankrupt economy while knowing that TTP has nothing to do with India and everything to do with Afghan Taliban. On top of that, Pakistan asks India to restore Article 370 & 35A in Kashmir (which is completely an internal affair of India and our Constitution) for talks to resume. What right and value does Pakistan have to demand India to include something into the India's Constitution? Moreover, did Pakistan realize that India never asked for talks with Pakistan? Your request for talks with a pre-condition (demand) to restore Article 370 & 35A sounds like a joke to us. Nevertheless, India doesn't need Pakistan for anything and we are happy with no relations with Pakistan. Pakistan as a country is a live circus and no one takes Pakistan serious in the region and around the globe.

[@urbashidigitalbangriposi8749]

Rightly explained to Cheema ji. But our FM has cleared that victim of terrorism don't sit with perpetrators of terrorism. Cheema ji cleverly avoided this angle.

[@ajayagarwal7977]

1947 से 2001 तक पाकिस्तान भारत ने हमें आज तक तकसीम नहीं किया है। अटल जी :- हम पाकिस्तान को तकसीम करते है (मीनारे पाकिस्तान) में खड़े होकर कहा 2001 से आजतक पाकिस्तान बो भारत ने हमें दिल से तकसीम नहीं किया है 😂😂😂😂😂

[@Yahabibi70]

Tkseem nhi tsleem.. Tkseem = baantna Tsleem = maan na​@@ajayagarwal7977

[@pradyutkumarghosh6337]

We should discontinue all diplomatic relations with Pakistan.

[@vp6945]

India should talk to Pakistan only when they declare that Pakistan is not an Islamic country and changes its name and actions.

[@shuklarajeshsrtrajesh3535]

Not only india but many countries keeping distance with pakistan

[@arunagarwal17]

Not only india all countries keep hand distance from Pakistan

[@user-jg3ed5ql6r]

Pakistan making their own happiness with such day dreaming stories

[@SadguruPrernaTrust]

Happiness index they are much better placed than most asian countries☺with 46% poverty and begging katora☺

[@sid8285]

​​@@SadguruPrernaTrustSeems like polio infection also contributes to happiness for beggars since pakistan is the only country in the neighborhood which has failed to eradicate polio😊

[@user-jg3ed5ql6r]

@@SadguruPrernaTrust kzbin.info/www/bejne/qpfFcpuDeMiXhMksi=CRdx43VSVM_Kvxwm

[@ganeshrothe6708]

India is busy and have no time. Go ahead and Talk with Iran, Talk with Afghanistan 😂😂

[@amvedin]

India has said a million times that terror and talks can not mix. There is an ongoing terrorist incident in Indian Kashmir even now.

[@shyama4960]

Do you know the size of brain in that fat head is of kidney bean? Mr. Bhashani would have said it dozens of times in the past few years. QC doesn't get it. So, sit back, relax, watch, enjoy and repeat it every month. उस से ज्यादा लोड नहीं लेनेक।

[@chinmoyadhikary6917]

They (Pakistanies) have no shame.

[@deepaksogarwal6286]

Cheema ka jo mindset h wahi overall pakistan ka mindset h Sala apne dukh se dukhi nhi dusre ke sukh se jalan hoti h😂😂

[@aditichoudhury3425]

Ussey 100 Guna zeherila hai, pataa nahi hamare max logon ko kab samjh aayega, Aaj tak bahut gadhon ko yahaan ye samajh nahi aaaya , usika fayda ye Cheema jaise log uthaate hein.

[@Aryann-sharma]

We dont want,,we don't need any relationship with Pakistan 😍😍

[@darshanchhajed9150]

Mote, Pehle Internet ka bill bhar 😅😅😅 Yaha hum Indian's ka precious WiFi ka bill mat bhada 😊

[@hotmail28]

❤

[@pradiptagaurangadas5647]

We majority of Indians never ever want to have any relationship with Pakistan.

[@pnmishra7577]

डॉ बसानी को भारतीय उपमहाद्वीप के बारे में गहरी समझ है पाकिस्तान को उनकी सलाह पर गौर करना चाहिए।

[@debajyotinath5021]

usse Pak army ka ya politicians ka kya fayeda hoga?

[@Rowoon24]

Not interested- Do not bother at all 😂

[@ArunSingh-km7ik]

Government of two countries talk formally, pakistan is the only country want to talk informally through television.

[@HIMANSHU79879]

India has much more important issue to handle yeh timepass kaam ke liye waqt nahi hai ....

[@rabarimehul8608]

Bashani sir it's feel very good to see you back otherwise this Qamar cheema's foul cry was become very boring

[@vivekkrishnamurthy8746]

Sometimes it feels like Dr Cheema is a devil's advocate

[@chakrabortyabhik2002]

'Victims of terrorism do not sit together with perpetrators of terrorism':--- Dr. S Jaishankar...(Minister of External Affairs, India)

[@masterstroke7163]

The Bull Dog has started showing it's true color from the shores of Turkiye.

[@sahilsinghnegi7041]

#FREEBALOCHISTAN

[@shakeeljanjua195]

And pojk also.

[@hariompatel1199]

जी हेलो दोस्तों मे हु हलवाई कामरान चिमा चिमा हलवाई इन पाकिस्तान लाहौर, कीमा कढ़ाई, कीमा कोफ्ता, कीमा नान, कीमा मटन उपलब्ध है 😄😄😄

[@aditichoudhury3425]

Everytime he says - hello doston mein hun qamar cheema, my mind says kyun ho Qamar Cheema 😂😂😂🤣🤣.

[@NasirUddin-ww7zi]

190 kg kamar mutton keema internet chaltaa nahi 😅😅😅😅

[@virendrakumarsethi9339]

In fact there is nobody in Pakistan to whom Indian Govt should talk to.

[@bhaphursingh8283]

Bashani sir g is great personality 🙏🙏🙏🌹

[@jai4096]

Finally Cheema sahab got his answer that India doesn't need Pakistan's support to be leader of Global South nor for neighborhood first policy. It is not a village leadership contest.

[@ex.fighter8939]

भारत सरकार कि पाकिस्तान से बातचीत ना होने पर चीमा का तड़पना बहुत सुकून देता है 😊

[@jeevanbasumatary454]

Qamar Cheema, let me inform you that on our (Indian) world map, Pakistan does not exist. For Indians, there is no country named Pakistan. We do not recognize Pakistan as a country.

[@samir32118]

Indians don’t want to talk with Pakistan

[@user-cg9vl1ev6t]

Notice that neither of them talk about Pakistan taking action on Pak sponsored terrorism in India.

[@isacr4063]

Talks with pakistan means benefits without cost for pakistan and risks without reward for india. India will have to compromise on issues like terrorism but pakistan won't compromise on kashmir. Why should we? Please go away.

[@anitasingh37]

This is joke, why India should talk to the county like Pakistan.

[@jawaharlalbansal1062]

Pakistan has lost opportunities to mend relations with India when PM Modi has not to ask anyone for his decision.Now in a coalition government Modi ji will have to ask his coalition partners before taking any decision to start a dialogue with pakistanis

[@user-sx4mq6zn9o]

In Pakistan elected PM is nothing. Army chief is everything. So, no use in talking with PM of Pakistan.

[@amitbaishya8869]

Paxtan ki aukaat nehi ki india ke sath barabar me bainthen

[@SR-pk2ph]

Cheema should talk to ISI and Pak military and convey their consent for peace talk to India, on internet !!!!

[@parveshjain6067]

In the presence of army chief in Parliament, they hv to pass a resolution unanimously to talk with india

[@nishithdave8184]

*CHIMA'S LAUGHTER IS Artificial* 😂😅

[@hirendesai8343]

Laughter to disguise the feel within cry 😢 of jealousy induced anger and frustration !

[@umsss6258]

Cheemu Pakistan is not exist for Indian diplomacy.

[@Bahadersinghbawa]

Swaal achha tha lekin awaz kat gai 😂😊

[@ex.fighter8939]

भारत में बातचीत का अधिकार सरकार को होता है भारतीय फौज किसी बाहरी मुल्क से बातचीत नहीं करती भारत कि फौज अपनी सरकार के आदेश पर काम करती है

[@s9ka972]

As if Indians are eager to talk or deal with Pakistan 😂

[@user-gs5im7uv7j]

No Terr-0-Ist offers are accepted here.😊😅

[@RahulSharma-hi8id]

Pehle ye decide karlo ki " BAAT KARNI HAI YA RAAAA KI SAAZISH KARNI HAI". Ek minister baat karne ko keh rha dusra Raa ki saazish ki baat kar rha hai. Saare mulq main lallu hi rehte hai kya. Look at DENIAL ON CHEEMA FACE. He is completely oblivious to FACTS. BAS CHOOORAN BEECHTA REH.😂😂😂

[@sulochanasalian3873]

America China Saudi etc ke samne toh pak leth jata hai toh apne Asli baap ke samne lethne mein kya pareshani haii 😂😂😂😂

[@hirendesai8343]

😂good one yaar 😂

[@BhuviJassal]

Pakistan ki taraf se boht achi offer hai aisa kr mote is offer ki batti ban k piche daal le apne 😂

[@sccyt]

India might take it seriously if the gesture comes directly from Asim Munir. The other day, three guests on PTV were fantasizing about conditions to put on India for a dialogue! Here was my response. A). 370 will not come back A1). No modifications for face saving B). It's bilateral only. Not multi. UN, US, Russia, or China are all irrelevant B1). READ UN RESOLUTIONS again; stop lying. The first step is for Pak to pull back its Army first C). Stop killing pilgrims (as in Raisi) C1). India only kills terrorists in Pak. It doesn't touch innocents D). Stop tickling yourself (like the three guests on PTV) Now do your plan.

[@KanishQQuotes]

Share the link. Sounds like fun

[@bhaskarshetty4981]

Are you asking or saying if Japan or South Korea or Taiwan can function without engaging with North Korea their international standing will suffer? So it’s possible for India to disengage permanently with Pakistan in view of their 75 years experience which international community has convincingly accepted.

[@hirendesai8343]

Great analogy 😂 Pakistan like North Korea - unfortunately becoming a pariah state…

[@sd-wm1sq]

Cheema thinks Pak is out of India's Global South group. But he doesn't realize India is keeping Pakistan out of it.

[@cimage1000]

So far that's what PAK is doing, asking, a better word is begging for a dialogue. Why can't both your PM and Munir make a joint statement.

[@bhaskarshetty4981]

Civilian leaders reflect in public that they like to have talks but do they have the agreement or approval of COAS?

[@somaghosh2960]

Qamar Sir, Barrister Sir always simply an outstanding. Whole conversation is very good. One point mentioned, conversation's ending part, where Qamar Sir's smile and Barrister Sir's speech have given answered everything.

[@mbganesamoorthy7773]

Qamar Cheema has been advocating in his blogs that Pakistan should talk 🗣️ to Bharat 🇮🇳 when it is economically stronger, 🔔🇮🇳

[@Bharat-citizen]

Bashani. Sir it’s always a pleasure to listen to you one of the honest person who speaks truth without mixing it with sugar❤

[@hirendesai8343]

Bashani Saab talks from deep analysis based on history, reality & facts - he is the best among many on this subject. I always felt he talks to Pakistan Establishment and Qamar Cheema is his mike. While it’s real fun to see such dialogues hardly any concrete outcome is possible from his serious golden words of wisdom.

[@santri2023]

India should not talk to Pakistan…

[@bthaosen7553]

I have several times suggested that first your political leaders talk with army not India.

[@Captain.Jackk01]

Cheema As a Foreign Policy Expert :

[@Spread_only_love]

Cheema Sahab, not sure if you go through the comments section. I know several of the comments spew venom at you or your stance. However every one is not like that. Appreciate if you can make an episode on the stance of OIC on the ongoing Isreal-Palestine issue. OIC is very vocal when it comes to the Kashmir issue, and not about the POK ( what you call as Azad Kashmir) . If possible please make a episode or more on the Muslim world and OIC’s stance on major issues involving Muslims across the world. Some suggested topics. A) Isreal -Palestine current butchering . B) Uprising by local Kashmiris in PoK (what you call as Azad Kashmir); C)Treatment of the Rohingas in Mynammar, Bangladesh. D) China’s treatment of the Uighir Muslims. E)Procecution of sections of Muslims in Pakistan, like the Ahmedias , Borivalis, Baluchs ; F) The prosecution of Muslims in Philipines. Thanking you and your team in advance for the background research to be done in preparation for such episodes.

[@videovoyage3406]

Why only India ? Why not "biradar mulk" Iran, Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Arabs?

[@bapighosh2]

First answer who provide weapons to terrorist in Kashmir?

[@KanishQQuotes]

Cheema wants the military chief to discuss foreign policy

[@bhaskarshetty4981]

If Mr Vajpayee had an agreement with the COAS instead of the PM, we would have had a totally different history in past 25 years.

[@Samlad72]

Cheema Sahab, You had real quality questions today with counter observations. Unfortunately, you (Pakistan) are in a fall situation, so rather than asking for a fighter jet, you must request a parachute to survive. First thing first, sir, right?

[@SUNILKUMAR-ye2hl]

The Same Person lecture to there People. Pakistan not need to talk to India Now he 24*7 cry for Talks with India and play the Different Cards for Talk with India.

[@MrPankaj2006]

But why does your military poke its nose in politics and create confusion?

[@madhurp986]

We don't talk with Pakistan not because it is a poor country but because it doesn't have good intentions for us. In Sanaatan, it is said.. "Actions and Intentions create Karma, if someone had bad energies for you, avoid them" We follow our faith, we are believers.

[@sunilsethi5195]

I have to say that your show is very entertaining for me, you halucinate stories & debate yourself, your Ron dhona is very satisfying for me, it digests my food, 😊😊😊😊

[@user-up2gw3cb9t]

Circle of time: there was a time when Pak didn't care about Ind need & concerns. Now the table is turned. ~Atmanirbhar Bharat.

[@justcomments9326]

If the request for dialogue comes from HS, MA, SS, DI then IN might accept it.

[@shubhchandra9505]

Where is Pak's formal offer and topics for talks

[@umar_mughal.3861]

Hamid Bashani got the best mind & substance, from South-Asian region. No slogans,loud 📢 noise, he talks facts with real possible solutions. He's even better than so called "Hindu" KZbinrs. Kashmiri mind is sharp,observant & intelligent 🧠👍 R&D institutes of Kashmir will be world-famous if Govt introduces a new educational policy.

[@karanbharwad99]

Me teg tv 🖥 par beristar sahab ko pichle 10 sal se dekh raha hu me bahot bada fan hu beristar sahab ka

[@user-xj2kz4iz4s]

Hamid Bashani is a brilliant scholar and analyst. And very truthful. My respects.

[@user-zm7tb9ky7t]

Bhai which country initiates talk with Media ? If your govt. wants to talk, then your govt. will have to make official request not your media and not any minister talking in media, reason for that is because very next day some other minister would talk about NUKING India

[@rvssrinivas8556]

Nice to see you Bashani Sir, best wishes to you. Mr Cheema, you might have understood by seeing the comments

[@arungautam3546]

Mr Badhani is always very balanced & pragmatic in his approach & commentary on Pakistan / India relations .

[@venkataraghotham7586]

What status do politicians have Let the military tske a stand

[@ZeroVideos000]

Q: Kya hum formally poochen? A: Nahin, whatsapp karo 🙄

[@subodhmaheshwari3204]

Bhasani ji seems to be the most learned, genuine, and impartial Anylist of INDO-PAK relations. Cheema, you should also learn these things from him instead of trying to present Pak views withoit any merit. 😮😮

[@AnilKumar-bf3rq]

See even Internet is not working properly in na Pakistan. This is state of affairs in Pakistan and they want investment

[@anilsood1688]

Bashani saab my salute to you sir ❤️🙏❤️

[@mumbaitree2801]

No relationship with Pakistan ever

[@sparklestudios2083]

India sees no value preposition in talking with Pakistan. What does Pakistan has to offer to India ? We are happy here, You stay there. End of story.

[@ShaRaj1567]

Cheema on a high horse as always 😃Pulled down nicely by Barriester Bashani✅

[@snehapatil2140]

We only Respect Bashani sir, Talk to the point and realistic.

[@Prakash-bj3qj]

Terrorism& Talks ...Can Never Go Hand in Gloves.

[@UmeshGupta-sh7nj]

Cheema should understand that time is not ripe for any dialogue. Pakistan should relax and mind its business. Probably after 4/5 years things might cool down. For the time being india is fed up with Pakistan irrespective of ruling party in India.

[@Frag_talk]

Barrister sahab is on point as usual. Brilliant and brutally honest 💪

[@DoviiForum]

Sir Indian army has no role in decision making. Which is why they refused to talk. But if Indian politicians ever think of talking or holding talks with pakistan it would not be with your civil government as they are not the main decision makers so if talks are to be held it would be with your armed forces. But again that's wishful thinking it's not happening.

[@nareshvalecha4656]

Who started initial war after partition In specially kashmir

[@vinvin4001]

No talks with Hindustan unless they give kashmir to pakistan

[@Prakash-bj3qj]

Cobras doesn't Bite Till Attacked + Some Varities Are Non-Poisonus.. BUT. ..How To Differentiate ❓⚔🤐😮😮😮😮😷.

[@sonibhash]

India is not interested in few Billions aloo tomato trade. Come out something' substantial, like rail link to IRAN , corridor to central Asia. No khitta khitta , people to people etc worth wasting time.

[@RanjitKumar-kb5gf]

Bhasani sahab aapp great ho. Thanks very happy to listen you sir

[@j.r.bhandari2286]

Ye Hamesha Aapni Hi Baat Rakhege. Aap Bhi Samajgiye ki, India Govt. Kya Pak & China ki meeting Ka Video Dekh Kar decision legi ?

[@KaramjitSingh-yv6tj]

Cheema Saab Kia bacho waali BAAT karte ho AAp lot of laugh baake hi. Aap log inteligencey ki bahut ghaat hai sir 😂😂😂😂

[@pankajdhooria8703]

Bashani sir, please try to appear regularly

[@gopinathankanniyath]

Trust deficit. If any agreement is reached who would guarantee its implementation. Army would make sure it is sabotaged. Past experiences.

[@The-earh]

Bashani sir ....every second ...destroying....cheema ....! 😂😂😂😂😂

[@jawaharlalbansal1062]

You initiated the action of expelling our high commissioner from pakistan.First step towards stating a dialogue is to send your high commissioner to India

[@Aryann-sharma]

चीमा तू आज भी 2g network use क्यों करता है,, बार बार तेरी आवाज कट जाती है 😂😂

[@yogeshthakur3318]

We simply. Dont need any type. Of relation whith pak. 😂. We are happy. Without that.