Rabbi Manis Friedman: How Israel can win this war?

[@evgeny9999]

Thanks to both Rabbi Friedman and the presenter. I have been listening to the Rabbi for a long time - always a clear and precise analysis of the issue.

[@טליתמרי]

תודה רבה לרב מאניס פרידמן

[@OZcomingFRoo]

אני שמח לשמוע שגם הרב פרידמן אוחז באותם אמונות כמו מנהיג "זו ארצנו" - משה פייגלין :)

[@hen_176]

גם אני מייד חשבתי על זה

[@OZcomingFRoo]

@@hen_176 הם היו בהרצאה משותפת, אז זה דיי היה לי ברור חחח

[@user-zg3nb1mk5b26]

מצטער שאני מאכזב אותך ,הרב מניס פרידמן הוא מדבר רק דברים הגיוניים שהם אפשריים מול אתגרים . פייגלין אומר דברים שהם בגדר חלום שכולנו רוצים בו אבל הוא לא מציאותי כי לדוגמא כשפייגלין אומר להתקיף את זה ואת זה , פייגלין אומר וכולנו מסכימים ,ההבדל הוא שלפייגלין אין מידע לגבי מה כדאי ומה מסוכן ומה לא רצוי מול האוייבים כי הוא לא חבר בקבינט הבטחוני ובוודאי אינו יודע סודות מדינה ,כגון מה אפשר לעשות ומה לא . לא כל דבר דמיוני שעולה לרוחינו אפשר להגשים ,החוט הדק הוא בין קיומינו לבין חלילה להפך .

[@hen_176]

@@user-zg3nb1mk5b26 אל תשכח שהוא היה חבר וועדת חוץ ובטחון, כשהיה חבר כנסת, אז זה לא שהוא תלוש מהמציאות. זה נכון שדברים כמובן השתנו מאז, אך הוא כן נחשף לדברים הכי הכי רגישים של מדינת ישראל וכמו כן, הוא נפגש עם המון אנשים שתפקידים רגישים שנמצאים בתפקיד גם היום

[@danielbreslow4959]

Rabbi Friedman is brilliant!!

[@openNature9]

ואו תודה על הראיון איתו. נפלא

[@user-zg3nb1mk5b26]

האישיות החכמה ביותר בעולם , הוא כוכב עולה בלא מעט ערוצי תקשורת בחו"ל , נותן עיצות בכל תחום ,ולומדים ממנו המוני אנשים בעולם . בארץ הוא לא כל כך ידוע או פופולרי אבל ברגע שיראיינו אותו ,הם יבינו כמה האיש הזה יכול לתרום המון לעולם למדינת ישראל .

[@dinushblau4247]

@@user-zg3nb1mk5b26 בדיוק!!!!!! החכם מכל אדם עלי אדמות!!!!!

[@noisy77555]

@@user-zg3nb1mk5b26 גם (ובגלל) עם כל הדתות וה״מוסר״ בני אדם זה היצורים הכי מסוכנים וגרועים שיש עם הלאומים וה״עמים״ שמביאים לנו מלחמות . ברגע שהמושג של זהות לאומית ימחק יהיה פה באמת שלום עולמי עם מדינה אחת בלבד

[@dinushblau4247]

בדיוק!!! האדם החכם בעולם הוא הרב מאניס פרידמן!!!! כל כך רציתי שהוא יפגש וידריך את מקבלי ההחלטות, מה לעשות.

[@OZcomingFRoo]

הופה! תראו מי הבאתם!

[@yoni1b1]

יפה. נקודת הדעת על הירושה מדגישה יפה את הסכסוך.

[@elizabethbooth5446]

Thank you rabbi

[@Themis333-r1y]

Hashem Knows All, Sees All, It Is Time

[@yifathanan2132]

הרצאה מרתקת !! תודה רבה לכם. לא הכרתי את הרבי לפני כן, אבל עכשיו אתחיל לעקוב אחריו. מדבר פשוט והגיוני, בשכל ישר, ופתאום הכל ברור.

[@saraurban3784]

❤❤❤❤❤

[@Themis333-r1y]

His Council of Holy Divine Laws Are Just, Compassion, And Forgiveness

[@Themis333-r1y]

There Must Be Holiness and Great Peace of Prayer Divine Unity Each With Hashem. To Receive His Court

[@noreensirianni3135]

Great analysis and another insight to this commentary perhaps is in "the enemy of my enemy is my Jordanian homeland to the Palestinians queen. "Job 1:21 and Zechariah 12:10.

[@Themis333-r1y]

A Holy Divine Justice of Hashem The Holy Court of Righteousness and Law, Right Next Door To The Palace Temple, The House of Hashem Shall Be Greatly Honored, Respected, and Kept Pristine. Maximum Holiness, No Need For Ever Any Need To Fight🕊️

[@Themis333-r1y]

In The Eyes of Hashem Let Us Put Honor Completely Aside. Hashem Eloheinu, Adonai Our Father, Creator, Suffers, When Both Of Brothers Fight to Death. Love and Unite, the Land Shall Be In Peace. Caution To The Fighting, He Watches. There Shall Be Holy Divine Justice And A House of Hashem. Respect Obedience Peace All Shall Have One Great Place of Honor To Hashem All Shall Unite Share Yes A DNA in All Of Us Same

[@Themis333-r1y]

May Hashem Bring Great Love of Rose 🌹 Petals And Manna To Bring Clean Waters and Sweet Honey of Peace, Brotherhood, Unity. Land Cannot Be More Valuable Than Life. No Fences, No Walls , No Evil Again

[@PSx1991]

They simply cannot. Indeed, the Creator is with the oppressed and not with the aggressors.

[@conductoralweinstock]

Since when did Muslims start believing that they are the heirs of Abraham and the land of Israel? They were the last of the nations to come to the faith in the One G-d and the legacy of Abraham, which they did not even come close to honoring until the 7th-8th centuries AD. The Arabs were idolaters, they had their own idolatrous beliefs - their own idols and did not observe any heritage of Abraham or faith in the One G-d. Only when their false prophet created the "new religion" Islam, which he clearly rewrote from the Torah of Israel, which was already known to the whole world for a long time, the ideas of which were spread by Christianity at that time, only then did the Muslim faith in the One G-d and the faith of Abraham begin. And until the 7th-8th centuries AD they were not interested in the legacy of Abraham, nor the One G-d, nor the land of Israel. Nowhere and never during the entire existence of the Kingdom of Israel was it seen or heard that the Arabs declared their right to the land of Israel, since it did not interest them, due to their lack of involvement in the heritage and faith of Abraham. So what "merits" of Ishmael are we talking about, if they forgot about Abraham and his heritage and the One G-d? And all that they have in the Koran is a miserable copy and plagiarism of the ideas of the great prophets of Israel.

[@rigel472-ql9dd]

we dont share the same God. they might be believing in A God but it is not the One God and certainly not the God of Israel, researches tells us that underneath the pretense they are still pagan and idolaters ( Kabba Moon deity worshiping ) also it is been observed that the first Arabs "Muslims" joined certain middle eastern sects of Christianity in their effort to fight the byzantine( that's how they manage to conquer vast lands so fast ) those sects did not accept Jesus as divine( Muhamad, the favored one) , later own they created Islam 10th century . let us not forget Ishmael was a child of Sin ! the Sin of Abraham and Sarah disbelief and non confidence in God promise . now we pay the price, fighting the devil

[@Neverstopwinningyouheard]

If anyone says, ‘I love God,’ and hates his brother, he is a liar; for he who does not love his brother whom he has seen cannot love God whom he has not seen. And this commandment we have from him: whoever loves God must also love his brother.” - 1 John 4:19-21 If you will use the Bible to justify, you must also use to Bible to rectify.

[@shuriken4100]

God give the Jews that promise Land, you are the blessed people of God, every one is Jealous because God made you teh chosen ones, what people dont understand is teh responsibilities that come with it, and all the talents that God gave you.... God bless every Jew in Israel... USA is with you! Rabbi, why the vicious attack that shock the world in the festival?

[@yosefaharon4239]

כתוביותתת

[@dinushblau4247]

צודק. תהנה מכל מילה של הרב מאניס. גאון העולם!!!!

[@lesaheliorahavramsonkarapo4211]

The land is not an inheritance! The land was a gift to the children of Israel by G-d Who owns the land and gifted it to His children, the children of Israel.

[@bobperrone2105]

to be honest the 1973 war with syria lasted over a yr due to heavy Israeli losses against Egypt and syria...

[@mhasson33]

When do we see the discussion with feiglin

[@hen_176]

הוא אומר דברי טעם, ומאוד הסכמתי איתו אבל בעולם האתאיסתי של ימנו, אי אפשר להכנס לאו"ם עם זה, כי אנשים כיום הם כופרים גמורים בקיום האל

[@m.shlezinger4809]

@@hen_176 נכון וכואב

[@uriel7203]

מה אכפת לאו ם? הסכסוך בין העם היהודי והמוסלמים. אנו צרכים לשחנע אותם, לא צרפתים או הסבעדים.

[@yifathanan2132]

למה לא לנסות? אולי נופתע? שום דבר אחר בוודאי לא עוזר. אולי כשנהיה בטוחים בצדקת דרכנו וגם נעמוד גאים ונגיד אותה לעולם - אולי אז יקרה משהו טוב. בעזרת השם, כמובן!

[@dinushblau4247]

האום נראה לך לא יודע את האמת??? הוא יודע!!!! הוא *מחכה* לשמוע את זה מיהודים בביטחון גמור!!!

[@Ariverwhosestreamsmakeglad]

Q: Why is it taking so long? A: Hamstrung by an unworthy and untrustworthy ally, who stipulates the terms of engagement and is in reality an ally of your enemies.

[@SuperKripke]

Yeah I make excuses when I suck too.

[@Hock.Z.E.]

I see only one issue with the Rabbi's truth. The Muslims claim that WE changed the Text. If we use THEIR Quaran, we will win this argument. And we can. It indeed says that the land is ours as long as we obey our law that was given over to us by God. So to win we must simply BE JEWISH

[@deborahs1430]

ישמעאל היה הבן הראשון שנולד - אך לא לאשתו של אברהם. אמו הייתה משרתת. לפיכך, הוא לא עומד לרשת.

[@rigel472-ql9dd]

הסיפור מתאר את חוסר אמונתו של אברהם ושרה בהבטחת אלוהים לבן המובטח, הווה אומר שהוא נולד מתוך חטא וכל קיומו הוא חטא , ואנו חווים את חטא אברהם עד ימינו אנו , ישמעאל מקולל , והיה מרושע מהרגע הראשון " פרא אדם ידו בכל ויד כל בו" וגנטית הוא שמי-חם אפריקאי (הגר) אננו שמי .

[@waawareeykirakaraa619]

Ishmael was the first born and Hagar was queen and first born of the Egyptian king/pharaoh and the first believer of Abraham religion/god. He is the first highborn.

[@יונהטמיר]

אין תרגום ???

[@assiarolie543]

Maybe the Palestinians are the biological descendants of Isaac. They are Jews that have recognized Jesus as the Messiah.

[@lesaheliorahavramsonkarapo4211]

The question to the Rabbi, How can Israel win this war? And the correct answer is, ... only the G-d of Israel wins wars. This is not a mystery. It's in the Hebrew Bible.

[@bobperrone2105]

tech Israel loss against Egypt in 1973

[@שמואלקאשי]

למה אין תרגום

[@א.ד-ד1ק]

יש תרגום לעברית

[@שלומי-ג4ב]

תלחץ על C בזמן הסרטון. או על סמל הכתוביות ליד הגלגל שיניים("הגדרות")

[@user-rbimanisfredman.InHebrew]

איפה הכתוביות

[@שמעוןדהאן]

לוחצים על המסך למעלה מופיע איקון הגדרות ושם לוחצים על כתוביות ואז בחירת שפה עברית

[@bobperrone2105]

This is Urban combat Israel has never fought this kind of war its extremely difficult to win..

[@Themis333-r1y]

The Bible is Only One Of The Holy Books New Modern Day, Yeshua Loves Torah and All Holy Of Holy

[@JC_LOVE-777]

The Truth the land was INHERITED PHYSICALLY by humans own hands and was being witnessed---WITHOUT 🚫 the presence of Hashem's own Sovereign Mighty Hand through an Angel the protector of the Isrealites having Hashem's Name in Him---that Mighty Angel a TRUE Messiah and Saviour, the first born who was JESUS born of VIRGIN Miriam.

[@אמת-ה5ט]

מי זה

[@Silversoon78910]

זה רב חבדניק מאוד מאוד פופולרי באמריקה גם בקרב הגויים. הרב הכי פופולרי ביוטיוב. מדבר על פילוסופיה ואמונה ביו-טיוב וכתב ספרים.

[@388Caroline]

@@Silversoon78910 I’m a Catholic who has such respect for this wise Rabbi 🙏

[@chriss2452]

Let me see if I follow your logic. If you're a descendant of Isaac then you belong to the land, even if you're a muslim. And if you're a European who is not a descendant of Isaac, you do not inherit, even if you're a jew. Great. Let's get this settled immediately! Only problem is that DNA search is severely restricted in Israel. I wonder why. 🤔 We have the cave of the patriarchs, let the search begin. It's also interesting how you can be so confident to say that the arabs are not the biological descendants of Ishmail. How do you know that?

[@glennlgg6871]

You missed the point. The current "Palestinians" are mixed. Mostly Arab from Arabia but mixed with Byzantine, Greek, Turk, Kurd, Armenian, Slavic, Bedouin, Hashemite,... and many more. They are mostly Muslim now. But that''s only a religion open to anyone. The Jewish faith is tribal. It's an ethnic group. Conversion and intermarriage was always rare. History and the core of the religion say more than the pseudo-science of haplogroups.

[@chriss2452]

@@glennlgg6871 When I ask jews which tribe they are from, they can never answer and get very hostile. Do you really think they were able to stick to their tribes after they were scattered into exile? They were mixed up, blended, forced to convert etc. They've taken so many routs before their re-entry to the Holy land. It's interesting how the European and American jews treated the indigenous and Middle Eastern jews as trash. Many didn't want to move to Israel but were threatened by the zionists. Like the 135000 Iraqi jews. You talk about the core of the religion, well the rabbinic judaism of today is certainly not the judaism that was exercised in the days of the temples. But the priests had no office after the destruction of the temple, and the prophets ceased, so the P'rushim, (the pharisees, the rabbis) took over. Only God Himself knows who are the true jews. Many are in for a surprise.

[@glennlgg6871]

@chriss2452 Who are you to ask them about their tribe? What's your tribe? Everyone is mixed. Every people were immigrants, colonists, conquerors, at a time in their history. So why were Jews fleeing the holocaust treated by the Arabs in the British Mandates in a violent xenophobic way? Should Europeans do the same with "M" immigrants and settlers as they bring a foreign political-religion? Israel came into being because of the following reasons: extreme antisemitism (including in Europe, Russia, America, and the Middle East), Arab xenophobic violence against refugees, and the Jewish struggle to survive as a nation as well as individual people. Yet some people want to turn the clock back 80 years. But only in the case of Israel of course. Not the many other migrations or creation and destruction of countries. Why? What is your solution?

[@chriss2452]

@@glennlgg6871 The outset of the discussion, based on the rabbi's opinion, not mine, was on who is the rightful inheritor of the land. Therefor, in this case it's instrumental to know your lineage and your tribe. Not because I say so, but because this rabbi does. And YOU were the one who brought up tribalism. I couldn't care less. But I think that if you claim the inheritance of a land after nearly 2000 years, there needs to be some standard, don't you think? In this case, the Bible is the standard, the testament, the "will" and as the rabbi interprets it, his people, the jews are the rightful inheritors. He even gives the criteria: if you are a descendant of Isaac, then you are an heir. All I did was to further that thought into practical consequence. DNA testing. What seems to be the problem? The "problem" is that many who claim to be jews would not meet the criteria, while many who don't claim to be jews would. That's all I'm saying. Edit: to further complicate the matter; some would say that only the tribe of Juda, one of the twelve sons of Jacob, who was the son of Isaac, are the "real" jews. The rabbi only excluded Ishmael and focused on the promise to Isaac. But is that the correct definition of a "jewish" person? Jacob had a brother, Esau, and he is not well seen among jews. Many jews claim that he is the ancestor of all the godless violent idolators: THE CHRISTIANS. This is a complicated matter, as you can see.

[@glennlgg6871]

@chriss2452 If you listened well, you would understand that this argument was made because of the Muslim/Arab belief it's "their land" and that the honour of keeping the land is more important than (their own) life. If you start this issue from a belief system like that, the Judaist belief system is as good as that - if at least not more original by the time of its creation. If the discussion is a secular, pragmatic, humanitarian one, everything is different. But remember that also the trueccause of Israel - antisemitism - also has a religious background.

[@berrios27lorenso]

war is art respectfully we allow them to fight back! Cordially . excessive force brings forces brings resentment that why its meticulous!

[@waawareeykirakaraa619]

Ishmael was firstborn and Hagar was queen and firstborn of the Egyptian king/pharaoh and the first believer of Abraham religion/god. He is the first highborn. So Ishmael is the right inheritor.

[@glennlgg6871]

Should god not decide that?

[@ashraf9667]

@@waawareeykirakaraa619 Hager was a servant and slave. Just that.

[@berrios27lorenso]

3 birds one stone

[@JT13974]

Friedman...clueless.

[@SuperKripke]

"The Palestinians are not biological descendants of the territory." says some guy who obviously looks Eastern European about a people who have been in the Middle East for centuries.

[@rigel472-ql9dd]

but most of them also look eastern European, or at least Turkish, and by the surnames you know they mostly not from here, they migrated from other areas , the Ottoman empire starched to the borders of Austria-Hungary, and those who look Arabs are from Arabia .

[@rigel472-ql9dd]

not centuries, its the narrative you believe in, not the facts ,but it does not matter, the fact it is not promised to Ishmael, even if only religiously and culturally ,but to Israel ,even if only religiously and culturally ,for centuries .

[@SuperKripke]

@@rigel472-ql9dd The world accepts less the claim the the region was promised to a religion. If it will take a military defeat to persuade you of that then I won't stand in your way of desiring it.

[@rigel472-ql9dd]

@@SuperKripke the muslims believe it, it what drive their intire struggle , and they comprise 20% of it . another 20% or more do believe it is been promised as well the all steuggle is based on this fact .and that's what he talks about so what are you talking about? you do not realize what's going on do you? . military defeat ? of who? one of the sides must expiriance a defeat ,total which there is no coming back from it , and it will happen for the other side i guarantee it .

[@rigel472-ql9dd]

@@SuperKripke your world view is of the gullible mostly western post modern thought humanitarians and liberals, the muslims use this against you , they do not believe in those nonsense .

[@rigel472-ql9dd]

Ishmael is a child of sin, and a mistake of Abraham and Sarah ,their lack of faith in God promise lead to this act of joining Abraham with the slave Hagar from Egypt ( Ham ) . we here to suffer the consequence.

[@user-vj7np9ru8c]

“After coming into contact with a religious man I always feel I must wash my hands.” Friedrich Nietzsche.