In conversation with Dr Aaron Motsoaledi | The Clement Manyathela Show

[@generaldmthunzi3139]

The only minister that does his work.

[@jacksonmpala7870]

which work has he done, problem in South Africa anything that sounds xenophobic is considered to be doing its work. talk is cheap.

[@generaldmthunzi3139]

@jacksonmpala7870 to revoke laws , it's not being xenophobic. I'm not applauding him for this home affairs portfolio only. You need to go back to all the portfolios he has held and see his work.

[@takuramutasa1529]

Which work does this guy do ,creating dozens of backlogs at Home affairs and BMA which is a money spinning project for him .. research properly you will know he is not about securing borders lots of ghost workers with this BMA system.

[@pebbleRock-l6i]

@@generaldmthunzi3139 He was leading health department before, it collapsed under his watch. Do not believe any lie from SABC please.

[@nthabisengmasia8988]

Chest pains 😂😂😂😂😂

[@SifundoThwani]

I wish more years to this guy,Minister continue to fight for us,you are our voice...

[@bobbyshabangu]

Dr Aron Motsoaleli is always knowledgeable and knows his story down to the minutiae details.

[@Intothelight1981]

......and yet he still can't do the job. Controversy and incompetence follow him.

[@pebbleRock-l6i]

@@Intothelight1981 True, he messed Dept of Health.

[@bennybala8556]

South Africa like many countries is a Sovereign country. What's so difficult implementing that? Citizens are not protected. He's busy sounding like he has got no powers. What kind of a refugee goes on holiday in December? If he cannot serve he must give to other parties. WW2 history doesn't solve our problems. This is absolute nonsense. Problems are existing now.

[@diatilenthoba8262]

This interview was very interesting,thank you for inviting Minister Motsoaledi👌👌👏👏👍👍

[@lutha1720]

Motsoaledi always on point, its funny how people cry about borders and illegal immigrants and the moment someone tries to fix it they get crucified.

[@pebbleRock-l6i]

He created the problem, so that he can appear to be solving it. Do not be fooled, Motsoaledi is just scratching on top. Home affairs department is rotten to the core, just like traffic department. There is no amount of effort that he can do to solve the problem that ANC created. If you want to get rich quick, apply for a job in those departments.

[@thoeize]

No minister is so informative like this man, he really proves that education is key

[@luckymolaudzi1985]

Our favourite Minister 🎉 great job Minister as a country we are indebted.

[@stamonmakhuvele]

Humble and knowledgeable minister in all portfolio he served under.❤❤

[@Jojo-l7h]

Dr motsoaled must remain home affairs minister even if there can be a new government or different government because he is the one and only minister doing his job and understand his work. He is a patriot he loves his country and does not take corruption

[@pebbleRock-l6i]

He must just retire with his corrupt ANC. No one is irreplaceable.

[@nthabisengmasia8988]

​@@pebbleRock-l6ilol you are soo angry you even comment negative to any comment that gives positive comment to Dr Motsoaledi😂😂😂😂😂

[@charmainemoodley2414]

May God cover you with his protection

[@papimphahlele8166]

The president we never had 😢

[@mapfo]

Say that again

[@papimphahlele8166]

@@mapfo the leadership selection criteria in politics unfortunately is not based on merit and integrity 😢

[@zanellatutu6735]

A genius is able to articulate a complex subject in a simple and clear way for everybody to understand . Mr Motswaledi you are a genius sir.

[@wonderful-m4v]

I pray for God's protection over your life minister.May He's angels surround u like the mountains of Zion surround Jerusalem.May those who desire your demise meet the same encounter met by the president of Iran on the 19/5/24.

[@cppmj]

the only minister I have respect for in the ANC, I wish he was in my party DA

[@thembamokoena2685]

If it dr Aaron I go watch

[@bobbyshabangu]

Same here boet.

[@thoeize]

You get this guy and Naledi phando, you ave the best of the best in government

[@giadvisory]

Some radio hosts in SA have for many years dismissed concerns about illegal immigration. They often labelled these concerns as xenophobic. It is encouraging to see the media beginning to pay attention to the challenges associated with the exploitation of SA's immigration laws by foreigners and corrupt government officials.

[@siyabonganxumalo4574]

Bongani Bingwa being number 1.

[@vuvufuzzy2594]

For the minister to even get threats on his life shows just how much people disregard the laws and ezokuphepha eMzansi aziqinile, and how vulnerable this country is.

[@mmatsatsimatlou6298]

True

[@gordenmg4966]

If ministers can be threatened what about ordinary certizens? We are in a banana republic indeed because of the ANC and EFF we can't even venture intk businesses in fear of our lives 😭😭😭😭

[@zubeidakhan2372]

Thank you this topic is very informative. More must be deported. What about the illegal Europeans, whose permits have expired but they are sitting tight in our country and even acquired properties and businesses.

[@nthabisengmasia8988]

He answered that question.

[@AmoMoëti]

Thank you Mr president Herman Mashaba to call in to interfere on this matter. It's affecting South Africans on the ground.

[@siphiwengwenya1606]

Clement🎉🎉my favorite presenter l am happy to see you Live

[@mariahkamogelomoloisane6276]

There's no way you can listen to Dr Motsoaledi and not learn anything.

[@aphistamataboge4847]

There is no law that foreigners legal or illegal can be in the Spaza shops. They are to come into this country with R5m as investment.

[@collinphahlane7527]

ANC, who we suppose to be the ones upholding and enforcing our laws ended up being the ones breaking our own laws.

[@RaulJiminez-rd5eq]

True 🤞. But now the anc wants to legitimize these makwerekwere and their criminal network of spazas.

[@bonolomakgatadeluent3150]

Him and Pandor are the only hard working ANC cadres

[@ThembaMthimbana-m1u]

No denial,but less not forget that they are getting old the must teach the younger ones and provide all documents when they are no longer working, they must be compulsory for them to advise thanks

[@muano5183]

I always look forward to listening to Dr Aaron. Dr. Action! & Relevant.

[@dumingwenya5836]

I don't think ordinary people can do that but people whom work with Minister who are being disturbed by him to get tender from the department.

[@ThembaMthimbana-m1u]

Take the Land now and never ever tell us no resources,if we own the Land we have everything that our Rich country has to offer poor African

[@GiftMolemela]

This cowards are afraid of whites why the hard working motsoaledi not pushing for freedom charter to be utilized we want free education clean water

[@dennisdanzo1615]

Clement is the only journalist that pose questions without wanting to sound smart ❤❤❤he is relevant in terms of questioning

[@vuvufuzzy2594]

All SA laws are weak. The ANC government wanted to rule the country when they didn't have the relevant expertise and skills to administer the country, that is the reason why we are where we are today.

[@khayanomoyi3551]

Mandela put us in danger with his naive stance on borders and immigration.

[@chumza7498]

To much bro

[@RaulJiminez-rd5eq]

That one sold us out yoo🤦🚮. Whether it was deliberate or not we don't know.

[@dudumzuke6488]

Yooooo.Its a mess

[@nazikay1340]

The sooner we stop blaming the dead may they continue to RIP and fight our own fights the better, so many years in Prison and come bk still makin sound decisions was a lot.What can we do for us and those coming after us is the question.

[@kwazingcobo8551]

The truth shall be told. Maybe his long impronemment affected his perception. Lesson is a person that has been in prison for more than 1 year should not just walk out and be a elected as president

[@elizabethandrsu369]

There was a time in a certain country , when a person claims to be a SOUTH African and want to apply for Asylum,, that country was clever enough to have a SouthAfrican man, I wont tell the name . who would be called to prove if that person is a SouthAfrican, by talking all the SouthAfrican languages even Afrikaans , to prove the chance takers , how far true was their story.. ( Lot of people were not from SouthAfrica, they were chance takers and the Asylum will be regreted. and that person will be deported These chance takers were selfish because that time the SouthAfricans were really in need and the chance takers wanted only to enjoy the life in Europe that is why they applied for Asylum as SouthAfrican .Refugees . SouthAfricans never liked to stay by others , we like our country. Immediately SouthAfrica received ( socalled freedom ) they all went back home in our beloved mother country. No chance in this world for chance takers .

[@japrosper7240]

Whats this na? Sounds like folklore

[@elizabethandrsu369]

@@japrosper7240 It is is what happened .The people who were in Exile know what I am talking about, especially those who were in this country. So( you), would never know because you were not there.And you will keep on asking.

[@elizabethandrsu369]

@@japrosper7240 Sometimes I have a feeling that South Africans go to University to learn to speak high English than to learn skills. No skills nothing no knowledge of anything with their highest education and cannot be compared with those from abroad .it is a pity.Maybe that is why the investors prefare maybe to bring their own workers.This is sad .This applies even in courts as I am always listening.Can it be possible that is why there are no jobs in the country?.Even when one is analysing it is difficult to understand no difference between people like me .

[@mpmatabane5166]

How do I get a job at border management I am willing to go through everything to stop nonsense.

[@mpmatabane5166]

They signed without thinking… what a mess😂.. mxm ANC ya bora Shem.

[@zubeidakhan2372]

Also spaza and foreign shop owners don't pay tax and become so rich at our expense. Besides being registered they must pay tax.

[@annetlugoloobinabasirye5557]

Clement thanks

[@LindaSibeko-j2v]

We are in trouble

[@beautyzimbabwe1001]

S.A should just come open with zimbabwe..Ramaphosa shouldn't be friends with the Zim president..Sadc should end political crisis in zim to stop Zimbabweans from crossing the borders

[@Erasmusthuso]

Start your own party, win elections and sort out Zimbabwe, and stop being friends with ZANUPF. Don't just talk from hatred n emotions

[@scelokhumalo294]

Infect we do have good learder in our country the problem are scattered in to these useless political parties we need to pick only those good ones from each and every party to form new garvenment that will make a good balance every party will participate on distinction taking and we'll represented

[@ZuluQuinty]

Please help me us my daughter 5year old have been raped 😓 in school special school she have autism speechless please be a voice for her My son sow everything trauma we are getting treated and my fone I can't do anything with it to get help they're trying to silent us because my daughter is not the only one being abuse my child is very hurt and doctor cormfamed and case open but I can't just see it

[@biggiemurisa3903]

For heavens sake how can someone apply for asylum in Zimbabwe or Malawi?

[@PsMotebangElias]

What is the role of VFS in Home Affairs. It's a privite company that making money but it doesn't helps us at all. How can be that someone outside the Country be responsible to run your affairs. It's a company tendered to get money for free. Let Home Affairs run it's business.

[@gordenmg4966]

What about retail business? these people have taken retail business from cape to musina.

[@CarinNel-x3q]

JA re spasa shops a lot here including chinees who stay in there shops but nothing happens 20 years eich poor RSA

[@eyakwantutechnicalprojects3680]

It's amazing how this government can change a lot of policies in other aspects yet can't develop/create maybe even change existing policies which are redtapes in seeing black south African in developing We are in a movie

[@khethamngadi5928]

Viva Minister industrious one....

[@andile5945]

The ANC doesnt deserve Dr Aaron. Its blaffing in itself that he managed to reach the top given the organisational dysfunction at the African National Congress.

[@Megathrough]

I feel sorry for this minister

[@obySedgefieldgemofourgardenrou]

Nhi. Insurance, rather self and party enrichment at the cost of our poor,weak and unemployed,jobs is priority, nhi will cost rsa many jobs,many people are packing their businesses up,next theyll pack their bags,take this nonsense from a government that cant manage a spaza,iesh we will suffer too much

[@ChinaDondi]

Who is controlling south Africa economy?

[@siyabonganxumalo4574]

You should be worried about who is controlling your country's economy and leave us alone.

[@makhulooduori9994]

Do I hear the French home affairs minister speak? The dream for an African anchor nation is really far fetched.

[@JimmyHove-yj4on]

Yes we have work permits to be here in South Africa working hard was contributing UIF just give us our money then will leave SA

[@ichoosegodfromnowon847]

No 1 invited u, go ask yr president to pay u

[@zanellatutu6735]

Sorry you have already benefitted from the state much more than your measly pathetic UIF value. Just go Abaaaaahambe!!!!!

[@sammlamlijacobs1691]

I trust ActionSA when it comes to the boarder question shame.

[@thabangtladi8057]

White people payed Mashaba huge money thats why he changed his stance on migration, borders & foreigners, Gayton is the only solution to this migration crisis

[@GiftMolemela]

Where's motsoaledi s office

[@pebbleRock-l6i]

Why Motsoaledi is always praised, while he can not close parallel home offices in the squatter camps in Soshanguve and Zithobeni. He runs the most corrupt department. If you want to get rich quickly, get a job with home affairs department, bribes galore like with metro police.

[@annamojapelo2292]

He is doing a great job. So many DOH affairs employees have been arrested and are in jail under His management

[@pebbleRock-l6i]

@@annamojapelo2292 until parallel corrupt people issuing id and asylum papers are not arrested, I am not convinced

[@thandol448]

His own department is under siege since he came in. Visas and permits are no longer being issued as easily as before because of internal investigations going on. Many of the corrupt staff are being caught and fired. He is overhauling the department

[@pebbleRock-l6i]

@@thandol448 Who dismantled the scorpions? ANC, So that they can loot untouched. Most of you ANC voters did not ask yourself a question why they dismantled the efficient investigating unit, you just followed them religiously. Now everyone is stealing, from minister to ordinary traffic officer, not to mention ghost workers in government positions.

[@annetlugoloobinabasirye5557]

Backlog for 5yrs plus seriously Clement

[@elizabethandrsu369]

How would you know if the certain person comes from a certain country where there is war? He says that one can just come in the country for instance countries like Palastine., Ukraine are allowed according to the 1951 Convention ..My question is ; If I am not from those countries and claim I am from those countries with war how would you know, because, l wouldn't even have a passport that shows where I come from, if there is war or not?. People have the Right of 1951Convention if their countries have war and can stay in the country where they ran too.There comes always a problem if chance takers also come using the 1951 Convention , how would you know. ?.Today there are people who don't even come from those countries but are staying in the country, there are not even documented . This problem is very difficult to be solved. No one can easly. solve this problem otherwise there wouldn't be so many undocumented people in country.Minister Motsoaledi this is not an easy game , not only in SouthAfrica.

[@siyoumy]

The foragners who are legally here and have a proper document you still will not see them legal because any foreigner in hospital is called as illigal so the issue is with all foragners not legality or illigaity because even if the person live ligaly and got sa Id as it happens in Europe, USA and other countries legally he will never been seen as such he will forever be foreigner and illigal except in the constitution that's the 1st thing.

[@ChinaDondi]

Please talk about equality of white people and black people . In our country white people salary and black people salary difference in our country. We now very well we don't have country .our country under the white people.

[@sellomonama7797]

What you are saying falls under the Employment Equity Act. Refer your question to the minister of labor.

[@ikgothule6463]

This minister is a President who may never occupy the office 🏢

[@NanaNana-ex7vz]

I think this minister is the most reason why ANC couldn’t get majority votes in this election!! Whenever election is approaching there is a strategy home affairs ministers use to win elections for the ruling party but this minister lacks that wisdom, all what he thinks about is the fight with foreigners must continue unabated!! Election is won by a strategy and this strategy used by all the past Home Affairs ministers including Chief Botelezi, Dlamini Zuma and the rest!!!

[@ThozamileLunguza]

He is a workaholic

[@EricDiller-on1hk]

Mnstr Motsoaledi the only ever hardworking Minister in this lethargic and corruption infested Cabinet!

[@GiftMolemela]

We are not against motsoaledi, our problem is why is it only our black fellows who are being kicked away how many somalis we have in south Africa..let alone Chinese,law must not look for colour..issue of opening borders was brought forward and it will be utilized after being sanctioned by the west..

[@YahwehVarsity]

I beseech you brothers and sisters, you blacks that have gotten help from other Southern African countries before 1994, take heed to love one another unlike you sound like u know legislation too much not to help,u are using UN and Berlin 1884-5 to repel fellow black brothers, just deal with crime and not criminalise sons of of the soil.For God is angry wth u, u stand ok and now dont care but life is a wheel.God speed

[@thoeize]

Mashaba please mr kiwi, just shut up sir

[@karma-ul7zx]

What about minerals coming to our country illegal as we saw on aljahzira

[@ruthdube153]

Shona people did steal those minerals because of corruption

[@karma-ul7zx]

@@ruthdube153 its not a tribe thing corruption is an African disease.

[@sellomorabe9274]

The only minister that is left in this crime busters, the only remnant of God… shame he must join MK in support of his father

[@Futhi.Johnson]

Aaron politicking

[@Pilane892]

So?

[@mikenick685]

Next time, please ask him why he hate foreigners. He said that he doesn't want illegal foreigners but systematically refused to process their applications. Over 92,000 pending is not a joke.

[@ichoosegodfromnowon847]

He doesn't owe foreigners anything, foreigners are owed by they country of origin, it's not hate or xenophobia, SA has right to take in who they want

[@mikenick685]

@@ichoosegodfromnowon847 I know you saw millions of SAans voting abroad. Should they have their visas pending for 2 years, how do you think that they will feel.?

[@phiwamakhanya8998]

Oh please don't play that hate card, he did mention the reason why there is so much backlog cause they need to investigate and confirm and you should question your own government.

[@ichoosegodfromnowon847]

@@mikenick685 They didn't go there illegally hence they able to vote in a foreign country, those countries knows about them and they don't commit crime in foreign countries

[@mikenick685]

@@ichoosegodfromnowon847 You came here to argue yet you have no knowledge of what you are saying. Does it seem to you that those 92,000 foreigners are illegal? Millions of SAns abroad have all their visas approved but 92,000 foreigners in SA have their visas withheld wickedly for over 2 years. This is unfair. This is wickedness. This is hate. This is not acceptable anywhere. But I guess it makes SAns happy

[@Erasmusthuso]

This minister should just join his fellow xenophob Mashaba. Mashaba should be deported to Mozambique bcz he is a Mozambican

[@zanellatutu6735]

You are a liar sir Mr Mashaba is from Soweto