Desh Deshantar: केंद्रीय कानून और विधानसभाओं की सीमा | CAA Vs Powers of Legislative Assemblies

[@kavindrasachan1087]

Thnx for watching Desh deshantar nd ur valuable suggestions and comments

[@rituraj3088]

thnku sir you are asking valuable questions ..... thanks it really helping us to know the facts related with current thanks

[@shwetachoubey984]

Sir your Hindi is outstanding... thank you so much

[@MAHENDRAYADAV-yg8pl]

sir is programme ki time badhaiye

[@sushilkumar-hl3dp]

Nice and peaceful debate

[@dreamlbsnaa20]

U r awesoms boss

[@productReviewe]

Thank

[@bhaktiamrit5970]

Ye anchor shi hain yaar....सटीक sawal krte h..👏👏👏👏

[@VijayKumar-nt1ho]

The great chinal rstv

[@indreshkumar4429]

मल्होत्रा सर ने बिल्कुल स्पष्ट बात रखी...😊

[@ashok.choudhary75]

Thanks kavin sir ..and.. also spacial thanks ..malhotra sir

[@krashankumaryadav3805]

Thanks all team members RSTV.

[@Pawan_kumar.]

Thanku p k malhotra sir and thanku very much kavindra sir to clear the doubts of state list legislation.

[@kushwahaconcept2.025]

Super

[@deepakkumar-rf6tb]

Thanks to rstv

[@gajanankadam2804]

Sensible discussion... Very informative

[@________msinnocent]

Very informative

[@sudhirmaurya4220]

Thanku sir

[@mediationmusic3068]

Tqxxx sir so much

[@balramsinghpal2717]

Best debate i ever seen

[@Skumar-ux2kc]

I like you sir. Very nice Program. Jay hind

[@rananjaysingh2565]

thank you sir

[@Motivationalwallah2149]

Thnx sir

[@saurabh4195]

Me. Malhotra explained well

[@aheadoflifewithhimanshu2147]

Thanks kavindr ji

[@ShivamSingh-le2du]

Best Ias channel

[@sandeepkumar-yn9hm]

Thanks

[@tanudwivedi6634]

I like P. K. Malhotra sir so much.

[@invinciblewill7091]

Me too

[@deepaksharma-mu6dx]

Sir sankalp or prastav mai kya difference hai

[@lakhanyadav6986]

Thanks pk malhotra sir

[@lipsaranimohanty9873]

Thank U very much sir ji 🙏 🙏

[@jawalaprasad3361]

In the absence of satya sir, j sai Deepak,this type of debate is incomplete

[@ManishGautam-dm5gq]

I completely agree with you friend. Atleast, one of them should be in the debate panel. It's viewers demand and RSTV should look into it.

[@mohnishkumar7410]

👍

[@govindshekhawat9094]

Tq sir mlhotra sr n sachaan sir

[@anilkumarsaw3167]

Kyo rad kare karan to bataye

[@bhardwajom2867]

Thank you

[@विद्यार्थी-ड1ब]

Live kitne baje chalega

[@riteshjha5594]

It's called conclusion by malhotra sir. Thank to all

[@satishjaiswal5266]

Thank you so much Kavindra sir

[@swapnilsingh3812]

I like P K Malhotra sir👍

[@erajeetsingh5096]

P K malhotra sir ne bahut acchhe se samjhaya

[@ashutoshkumar6022]

Very important topic.

[@varsha8972]

Kai log govt newz channel ko lekar majak udate hai n they prefer aajtak,zee newz etc channel but the fact is those channel does not provide essential newz....but this channel is not only a newz channel.....this a knowledge channel also😇.......from a sincere student...

[@pushpamaurya76]

P. K sir Bhut Bhut thanks apko

[@vinaypandey4636]

Very helpful

[@Foodyykitchen]

Thanku malhotra sir lekin satya sir ko bhi hona chahiye

[@abhinavaditya8416]

Concept clarity=P.K Malhotra sir and Thankyou kavindra sir for asking again and again

[@Libra-ql8pc]

That's great Very interesting

[@chemistryaffair]

very good discussion sir thank you kavindra g

[@manoharpanwar1106]

P k malhotra jyada clearly bol rhe hain.

[@sudheerkumarchaurasiya96]

Thank you RS TV. Is debate se kafi Kuch clarify Hua. Is me pariksha ke lihaj se vi kafi points mention hai.

[@improvequality]

Desh deshantr bht hi helpful h upsc candidates k liye.aap isi trh ke vedios aplod krte rhe.bht bht dhnyavad

[@anshishukla8577]

Nice debate👌🏻intersting👍🏻tqRSTV....pk malohtra sir👌🏻👌🏻best explained 👌🏻

[@ankittrivedi7396]

कवींद्र जी हमारे संविधान में प्रभावी कानून राज्य और केंद्र में मतभेद होने पर केंद्र सरकार के कानून लागू होगा। केंद्र सरकर के पास अनेक शक्ति है । 256 और 365 एवं 356 ये सब संविधान के अनुच्छेद के तहत् केंद्र सरकार के हाथ में शक्तियां केन्द्रित है और सरकार कानून प्रभावी कर सकती हैं ।😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😁😁😁😁

[@umeshsushil1288]

Thank u for this

[@MotilalMahtoVidrohi]

art 131 ka jikr nhi huwa

[@kanchansingh-nr6dm]

I always wait kavindra sir for this programme... P .K. malhotra sir ne bhut ache se samjaya... But today I missed saty sir also. Thank you very much kavindra sir🙏

[@mayurdhandhlya8286]

Best discussion

[@tbfyouthtalks1812]

Kavindra ji hamesha satik sawaal poochte hain but experts unsawalon ko gol gol.ghooma k apna answer dete hain...pk malhotra sr grip is strong over subject2👍

[@pushpamaurya76]

Thanks sir

[@bantirajput1769]

Thanx rstv

[@salmankasgar6070]

Thanks for sir

[@EduventureIAS]

Thank You RSTV👍

[@AbadTiwari]

Thanks for clearing this topic Mahlotra sir is great but we missed j sai deepak sir.

[@yudhishthirakumar5856]

Ap logo ne Ye nhi btaya Ki Kerala ne. Kon Se points hai Jis ke base PR resolution pass kiya ya unko objection hai

[@sanipandey379]

P K malhotra sir is too good but satyaprakash is also important

[@study66udaipurpraveen84]

Thanks sir ji

[@target3billion.]

Excellent discussion.... P.K.Malhotra sir...best point out 👌👍👍🙏

[@jayshelke5096]

P K Malhotra Sir Thanks Aa.....👍👍 ♨️😅.....Thanks RS TV.....Jay Maharashtra.....😅♨️ Also Kavindra Thanks.....👌👌

[@captainamerica5037]

Jay Maharashtra 🤣😂😂

[@jayshelke5096]

@@captainamerica5037 ......ok Bhau Jay Maharashtra 🙏🙏🙏

[@shwetachoubey984]

Jai Hind🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@jayshelke5096]

@@shwetachoubey984 .....Shweta 👍👍 Jay Maharashtra 👍👍

[@kushwahaconcept2.025]

Nice

[@jagatkaushik7021]

Ajay sir Kya explain Karne ka tarika bhi aacha tha Thanks rstv

[@manoharpanwar1106]

Achari ji achha answer nhi kar paye.

[@ajitauchare6957]

Very informative video. All panelist provided important inputs. thank you RSTV

[@avinashkumar329]

Mal sir can make a polity channel for upsc std

[@shyamgupta8632]

Very good topic debate thanks Rajya Sabha TV

[@jagdishbaldania]

Very nice conversation . It's good understanding for the power between the state government and the Central government

[@AllahabadiTrader]

use laagu karne me ve apna aghoshit asahyog karenge. is resolusion ke dwara ye wahi batana chahte hai. pannal ke visheshayo me ak vykati rajnitik paksha rakhane wale ko bhi rakha kariye , ye rajnitik vishleshak ya patrakar ho sakta hai , use bolne ki aajadi hoti hai.

[@ak-so9iz]

debate should be this type,,,,

[@zahidsaifi22]

Ye question pakka h upsc main me

[@artisingh1568]

Satya sir is very clear in his view

[@study66udaipurpraveen84]

👍👍👍👍👍

[@gauravchauhan9963]

बात आसान सी है संविधान में वर्णित सातवीं अनुसूची distribution of powers उल्लेख करती है - संघ सूची पर केंद्र ,राज्य सूची पर राज्य और समवर्ती सूची पर दोनों कानून बना सकते हैं तथा अवशिष्ट शक्ति केंद्र में निहित है । नागरिकता पर कानून बनाने का अधिकार केंद्र को है अतः संविधान के अनुछेद 256 के अंतर्गत राज्य पर उस कानून को मानने की बाध्यता है । यदि राज्य विधिसम्मत केंद्रीय विधि को मानने से इंकार कर दे तो केंद्र के पास अनुच्छेद 365 के तहत अधिकार है कि वह एक निर्देश जारी कर और ततपश्चात स्थिति बरकरार रहने पर वह अनुच्छेद356 के तहत राज्य में संवैधानिक आपातकाल की घोषणा कर सकता है । ताज़ा मामला केरल विधानसभा का है जिसमे उन्होंने एक रेसोलुशन पास किया यह कोई विधि नहीं है राज्य को केंद्र से किसी मत पर असहमति होने पर अनुरोध दर्ज कराने का अधिकार है । यहां प्रश्न ये भी है कि इस तरह की असहमति पर क्या राज्य सरकार केंद्र विधि की नकारात्मक बातों सम्बन्धी प्रचार हेतू राज्य के धन का प्रयोग कर विज्ञापन प्रसारण करवा सके । दूसरी बात ये है कि अगर केंद्र सरकार ही असंवैधानिक कानून बना दे तो क्या उस स्थिति में राज्य उस कानून को मानने को बाध्य होगा ।

[@shwetachoubey984]

👍👍

[@shwetachoubey984]

Good for knowledge ....

[@gauravchauhan9963]

@@shwetachoubey984धन्यवाद

[@shwetachoubey984]

@@gauravchauhan9963 "welcome"

[@jaygupta8951]

धन्यवाद

[@sonusinghaniyasp1635]

Thanks guru ji 🌷🙏🌷🤔

[@PawanKumar-kd5mw]

Aap ki debate real m so good advisers ke hoti h

[@pankajdubey7632]

Thought building programme ☺

[@padhiyarmahendra8762]

कोई भी डिबेट में सत्या सर और मल्होत्रा सर बगैर डिबेट अधूरी है।

[@kumaranil3558]

Thanks rs.

[@MAHENDRAYADAV-yg8pl]

sir time ko aur badhaya jay taki aur acche se samjhane ka mauka mile

[@mdabusayeed2429]

Zordar triqe se rajye ko dhamki derhe hain lekin rajye ki bat sun hi nhi rhe

[@prygann]

तुमसे कोई राय माँगा चुप चाप वीडियो देख राज्य और केंद्र को अपना काम करने दे

[@nimeshmourya3052]

Advertisement wale matter par to ek dam maza aa gya

[@NewdelhiUPSC]

Future IAS IPS ...... Everyday following this channel

[@gopinathsuryavanshi5986]

Please J saie deepak sir must invited.

[@GeographyByRahul]

इस चर्चा में लास्ट का quesition पर हँसी आ गयी ऐसे थोड़े मजेदार क्वेश्चन पूछा करो जिससे चर्चा में हसनुमा माहौल बना रहे

[@yamanksingla]

Why doesn't someone just mention constitutional emergency?

[@teenasisodiyarajput9741]

Enko to sare article yaad h yr

[@SHAKTISINGH-td9rz]

Thanks rstv

[@adeitykaushik4832]

Central laws & state assemblies powers * Powers under union list * State assemblies power to issue resolutions * Laws related to Citizenship-sch 1 list 1 entry 7- parliament * Sch 1 list 2- state govt * List 3(concurrent)- centre & state eg- motor vehicles act Federal issues * Federal duty of states to comply to it * Statutory resolution is mandatory for implementation * Concurrent state list- 1994- SR Bommai judgement- art 256(mandatory for each state to follow parliamentary law) , art 356(president’s rule) , art 365-if direction is defied * Art 253- centre can make laws -issues involving international treaties Resolution vs legislation * Resolution is a request * Legislation is direction Modifications procedures * State may pass law modifying earlier law * Which is then sent for prez assent * Law thus is passed modified * In case of conflict central law travails even in respect of list 3 Way forward * Healthy opposition a way of check & balance Final word Thus Defiance by state government in case of implementation of central law is out of question. There are adequate provisions in the constitution to make sure a law is duly implemented

[@KaranKumar-wp9yc]

Thanks

[@navnathshindeofficial410]

Nice..law ke student ho kya aap

[@PratikPande2608]

center state relations very important for upsc

[@upendrabhushan6826]

What a conceptual discussion!!! RSTV is lucky to hv an anchor like Kavindra sir....

[@naumershaikh5313]

क्या लोगों को नागरिकता देने का कोई और तरीका नहीं है क्या?

[@kishorekaintura815]

Waww

[@mangal9410]

Advertisement.

[@pujamishra9902]

Sir pls j sai deepak sir aur satya sir ko jrur bulaya kre

[@mdabusayeed2429]

Ek diabete is par honi chahiye ki rajye kiyon nahi lagu karna chahti

[@अजातशत्रु-प4ज]

Rstv 🙏🙏🙏🙏 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳