Sh. Mani Shankar Aiyar’s comments on the situation in Nepal and the state of Indo-Nepal relations

[@JitendraYadav-nb4tw]

I'm a Madhesi. And I can safely say he has spoken the truth! India please do not start a war in Nepal like in Sri Lanka. This beginning of ethnic war by India supporting ethnicity based tiny parties is making all hell break loose in Terai region of Nepal.

[@rrrrr1463]

Which party does he belong

[@srpproduction8586]

This is the real fact of Nepal. Well study Mani Shankar, when somebody speaks truth I would like to appreciate him heartily.

[@bishnupaudel8820]

Mr. Mani Shanker Aiyer is stand for peace, cooperation, friendship , humanitarian. Respect from bottom of my heart.

[@bigkeyk.c4936]

What a kind hearten person he is, this is the reason why i CAN'T hate Indian.. His thoughts and comments are so truth and touching. Whatever some bad minded politician of India do but there are a lots of people like Mani Shankar Aiyar who knows what is true and what should be done. Hope everything settle in the end. Thank you for every words Mani Shankar Aiyar sir. #Respect

[@sudeepbhushan]

Humanity still alive,,very truth speaking and its the reality,,well done Mr. Mani Shanker

[@suryasubedi4516]

Great ! We Appreciate you very much ! Thank you Mr. Mani Shankar Aiyar for such an understanding !

[@anilshrestha2853]

Thanks Mr.Aiyar sir for his generosity towards my country Nepal..I dnt wana go through all these reasoning and political agenda behind this blockade..I jst wana share my experience of my recent visit of Sindhupalchowk (one of the most affected place by Earthquake) for post earthquake recovery Project..People there are living in temporary shelter where long cold night can shivers u deep down and it's complete misery...The only transportation from where basic items like food, warm blankets etc could be reach there had stopped due to no fuel because of Blocades..3 child and 2 women who are sick had died on the long way of 4 hours on foot to hospital of capital of that district.Those life ccoild be save if they can bring to hospital soon by vehicles..People are having such a hard life which can only imagine and feel if u actually there to witness it..This really is very big humanitarian issues which need to resolve asap coz people are seriously affected..hoping for the best.

[@createchannelranjit5753]

Full of tears as I am Nepali citizen,what a great speech and the real truth of Nepal by great political personality Mani Shankar Aiyar,you are the real hero ho 3 core citizens of Nepal...

[@bikalshrestha964]

True perspective regarding indian blockade on Nepal by Mani Shankar Aiyar. Thank you.

[@HariharBhandari]

After his recent print/online article I think he is really a genuine leader or at least an analyst who cared the perspective of respect to the people's representatives, their voice and the voters finally. This is what democratic/loktantrik leaders should take care of. And this is also a situation within a sovereign nation, not a controlled state!....what a say Aiyar saab! Nepalese really salute you!

[@susmaize]

+Harihar Bhandari We in Nepal needs someone like him who speaks so clearly and present the facts !

[@dr.roshanchaudhary6932]

Thankyou sir you you proved that humanity still exist.

[@lsd8272]

Thank u sh. Mani shankar Aiyar ! you made us cry through your humanitarian speech...!!

[@rajivbista1522]

Now I feel Like some Indian are Really Listening Nepalese.

[@deepakdhakal9916]

Excellent Discussion of the current situation of Nepal in Rajya Sabha, India. Hope the current foreign policy of Modi's Government over Nepal will change as Mani Shankar's advices ASAP otherwise India will lose a small neighbor but a strong supporter from the world.

[@kushthaiba90]

yes! theres is the person in India to whom we rely upon and have faith on! the facts you've addressed is so undeniable, really appreciate your gutsy oration on the onset to the end!

[@rajughimire2030]

From this video It came to know " In india there are also few good people who knows the humanitarian" Appreciated!

[@TheSysrocked]

Such a nice argument supported by facts and details. 100% of what is said is true. People from your constituency should be proud to have a leader like you. Thanks you for such a lovely speech.

[@BadalChamlingRai]

Brilient & Possetive Mani Sankar is One of Twinkal Star Not Only India. He is Posetive Guidlinar Humanbeing This World. HisThouht Never Die Never Out From Human Sprit

[@thamanrawat5319]

Wot a crystal clear evaluation with accurate datas by Mr Mani Shaker Ayer ...absolute has hit the nail ..we shower love for our neighbor India ....But we cant tolerate such nuisance as blockade in a sovereign nation who is slowly coming out of imapcts of massive destruction like earthquake and 10 years of maoist insurgency which killed thousands ....how can a neighbor had such a evil eye in a progressive nation.....Hattss of Mr Ayer for your well conceived vision

[@bikashsir2004]

I am a nepali citizen and I appreciate Mr. Mani Shankar's speech. His speech washed off some of my frustration towards Indian politicians. We have utmost love for our Indian brothers and sisters and want a good relationship with India. It is the Modi Government which messed up everything with our relationship.

[@singhar87]

+Pramod Lamichhane Nepali people of your mindset are better off serving our gates as Bahadurs than calling us your brothers. Every country has their interests and Indian govt has all the rights to pursue it. We Indians have elected this govt and we stand by its decisions. The way you have treated Madhesis is something that you need to think about and correct it for better relations.

[@singhar87]

+Pramod Lamichhane As a matter of fact, Mani Shankar Iyer is a proven traitor for us, Indians. We just dont have any time for him

[@bikashsir2004]

+singhar87 Do not forget, Nepali are protecting India Giving up blood for your country in your border, who are commonly called "Bir Gorkha"! We do good things for other people, we care for other people. People use abusive language when they run out of logic! I don't mind your language, we have big hearts!

[@RajIndia31415]

+Pramod Lamichhane Brother, most of us love Nepal and Nepalis. I have had Nepalese classmates. We want the best relations with Nepal and most of us are distressed by the current happenings. In fact we were very hopeful of much better relations with Nepal as Modiji gave it so much importance. Hope the issues are sorted out soon.

[@IamAFreePerson]

+Blues Machine It's not hard to find scumbags in our society, somebody "pretending to be Nepali"... remember you were the ones who were English slave for many generations... not us.

[@naveenshrestha894]

i salute you sir mani shankar aiyar... good thinking n moral support... happy for the moment..thank u very much

[@MekhPaija]

Wow, This is the best speech I have ever listened in my life. He talked the fact.

[@20nu65]

🙏🏼 Salute sir, what a speech!!👍🏼👍🏼

[@nilusoni5205]

Thank you very much Sir for understanding the current situation of Nepal and being with truth and with us...

[@SubasHumagain8]

An Indian speaks on Indian Parliament, what Nepalese failed to.

[@SagarRana]

+Subas Humagain (SubasTheOne) true story!!

[@pgsherpa524]

Mr. Mani Shankar Airyar sincerely articulated the crisis in Nepal at the present moment. I do hope that the primer of India listen to his suggestion. Due to the border blockade, Nepal faces a dire crisis which is the last thing we need after the recent massive earthquake in Nepal. As he pointed out that we have so many women and children are suffering and some are at the verge of dying from this political interference. I request as Nepalese, please be more human to Nepal and Nepalese People and open the border for basic goods and fuels to pass through. Economically it is impacting both side of the countries.

[@romikagurung9842]

What a true man he is . I have no words in my dictionary to describe him all i can say is wow!!!! He speaks the truth n for the humanity huge salute to him. He spoke our minds n the generation pf ours will forever salute you . Thank you indeed from the bottom of my heart. Such politician should be born more it would be pleasure to see him as the prime minister #true man # true words.

[@morangkobhai]

Wowwwwwwww. U ARE CLEARLY SPEAKING TRUTH SIR. THIS IS WHAT WE WANT AND WHAT HAPPENING IN NEPAL. . im very happy to watch this video. this is what Nepalese people wanted from India as neighbours. if India do this things each Nepalese will ready to die for india. that is fatct guys. . as a neighbour this is not a big deal TO respect eachother bt some criminal minded people trying to used us both for their own interest. thanks for support sh. Mani shankar!!! . WE NEPALESE ARE NEVER WANTED MORE FROM INDIA BT JUST DO NOT TRY TO DOMINATE US. WE ARE LANDLOCKED BUT WE CAN BUY OUR BASICALLY NEEDS. WE RESPECT ALL..... WE WANT SAME AS REPLY.... THAT IS OUR HAPPINESS. .

[@pranayshrestha6114]

Well analyzed, honest and truthful views.. This is exactly what happened.

[@RamPrasadGhimire]

Humanity is still alive in our friendly people though seriously wounded by the conservative Modi government. Truth is like the human soul; it never dies and no one can hide it for long as long as humanity exists. Thank you very much Mani Shankar jee for your impartial, wise and courageous statements at the critical juncture of our age-old bilateral relations.

[@sujanpokhrel926]

Thank You Sir,thank you for speaking the truth We respect your perception about current situation of Indo-Nepal Relationship. You are a true friend or ours.

[@santoshgautam2349]

Ture leaders are always honest, faithful and trustworthy. SO r u . Thank you.

[@jiwann4213]

Thank you for bringing the truth Mr. Mani Honorable Shankar Ji.

[@ashkafle]

Really appreciate that sir. U r the sign of real neighbour and a real friend

[@babinshrestha]

Only people like Mr. Aiyar can make this world a better place!!!

[@subbatyson6517]

Thanks For What you Said.. HatsOff :)

[@ArjunSapkota]

The only speech having truth about the reality of current Indo-nepal relationship. The every Indian people should know the very reality stated by Mani sir.

[@inthisworld7494]

You are right Mr. Aiyar, you are the kind of person who can keep this age old relation survive

[@hangurung2127]

Thank you Mr Aiyar for channelling the core accuracy - Mohan Nepali

[@sasankkhanal9695]

Respect ... you speck out the things that our politicians cannot speak .. ... really sorry for them :( Huge respect form all Nepalese ...

[@kishorbikramshah3524]

Indian Media should know research based journalism for facts/reality rather than selling emotions in their media. Two historical/cultural neighbours' relation should be maintained and respected despite differences in size n economy. A true neighbour has come with unbiased research. ‪#Respect_Panchsheel

[@bibekkoirala81]

A very balanced and pragmatic speech by Mr Aiyar. The only winner in this fiasco is China. Both Nepal and India are going to be losers in the long run. While the aspirations of Madhesis (around 20% of the population) should be addressed, that of the rest 80% of the population should not be bulldozed in the process. Egos of babus in South Block should not be more important than the lives of 3 million kids. Again, if India can't get along with Nepal despite such shared heritage, it can't get along with any other country. Peace!

[@kiranshrestha7710]

thankyou so much on behalf of all the Nepalese! truth is bitter but this is what happening right now .. lets not spoil ind-nepal relation.. we both need each other...

[@sujankoju5408]

Thanks for the support.

[@yubrajshahi]

"We have a Madeshi Delegation consist of 4 members 3 of them were defeted!" They are the Real Agitator.

[@chandrakantsilwal8604]

thank u Manishankar

[@jkknn1]

Loved his speech,he has broad vision and knowledge. I can say that he is perfect leader.

[@prashanshrestha235]

Praiseworthy... He speaks the truth. Good people still exist in India.

[@kaustuvadhikari7054]

Thank you mr aiyar.. truth has been spoken!!

[@sagararyal4481]

Want to salute Mani Shankar Aiyar sir.... 100% truth.

[@sagardahal4783]

Mani Sankar Ayar is a true Indian. Thank you.

[@rbsunar5095]

mani.shankar sir is the best polition.thanx sir all nepali respect you

[@Gemma0787]

Great respect and appreciation to Mr. Aiyar.

[@rajivmaharjan7207]

Good one!!!!!! Some sort of relief that there are still some Indian who thinks good of Nepal and its people........

[@PrabinSiwakoti]

We Nepali Really Happy Today becuaus we know that more indians are supporting Nepal except Modi. We know now Mani Shankhar like people are also in India who know the real facts about Nepal. Thank u Mani Sankhar.

[@aloeveRa12104]

He's such a wise man. Respect to you sir.

[@badrigautam3527]

recently become the great fan of Mr. Mani Shanker .

[@santospant902]

thank u Sir ! Really a appreciable speech !

[@BirajShrestha123]

Thank you soo much Mani Sankhar Iyer ji for understanding nepal's problem

[@roshanacharya2099]

Thank you sir ! you have presented the exact scenario of Nepal conflict. may modi government listen and act as you suggested!

[@MrAnanta911]

Well Said Mr MS Aiyar. Thank you for this....

[@createchannelranjit5753]

Eyes full of tears what a speech....

[@mohammadrezarezaei3159]

mani shankar is highly respectable politican,who thinks before he speaks and great knowlegment of politic issues in the world,good for india with such a man,i wonder why india not using him in post he deservs..

[@ShishirRajbhandari]

Very truly said..... This is the reality the intl media and indian media is failing to depict

[@bhojpurekto6063]

thanks for your honest comment

[@ParshuramDahamala]

great man mr manishankar salute you

[@pastorsurya]

My humble salute to Mr. Mani Shanker!

[@ayushbajra]

thank you Mr Aiyar

[@deepmaharjan3820]

अयर साहेव का मै बहुत बहुत आभारी हु। यिनो ने नेपाल और नेपाली लोगोका भावना सम्झी है। अयर साहेव ने जो कुछ भि सदन मै बताइ है। वे सत प्रतिशत सहि है। रहि बात मधेशी लोगो का। मै आप सब को बता दु , मधेश मै जो कुछ भि हो रहा है, जिन मधेशी नेता लोगो कि आप बात कर रहे है । यिन मे से लगभग सभी नेता इस संविधान सभा चुनाव मे मधेश मे हारे हुवे लोग है। यह लोग मधेश वे मधेशी लोगो का प्रतिनिधित्व नहि करता है। और बात-नेपाल के संविधान मे मधेशी का हक अधिकार हनन कि बात उठ रहा है। यह सरासर गलत बात है। नेपाल के संविधान मे मधेशी को भि बराबर का अधिकार दिया हुआ है।जेसे कि अंगिकृत नागरिकता के बिषय मे। समानता के हक मे । यह बात सबको समझ मे आ जाना चाहिए कि यहाँ सिधे साधे मधेशी लोगो को भडका रहा है। कुछ अराजक तत्व ने जो देशको बिखन्ड्न करना चाहता है। जो नेपाल भारत सम्बन्धको बिगाड ना चाहते है। आप यह बात खुद समझ सकते है । जिन मधेशी नेताऔ के बेहकाव मे आ के मधेश उबल रहा है, वे मधेश का प्रतिनिधित्व नहि करता। वे इस संविधान सभा चुनाव पर हारा हुआ नेता लोग है। मधेशी लोगो ने हराया है। यहि नेता लोग अनेक बखेडा खडा कर मधेशको आतंकित कर रहा है। अगर भारत नेपाल संबन्ध प्रगाढ बनाना है तो हमे अभि से दुरदर्शी निर्णय लेना चाहिए।

[@omkarki1516]

Whoever he is he actually know about current situation...

[@samashtipaudel230]

thank you sir..finally some one spoke truth...

[@bardanism]

The honest statement indeed...

[@kapillamsal8556]

Dear Mani sir... We don't blame all Indian friends... As you say, Modi Government is cruelly behaving with us....

[@roshanshrestha6180]

Thank u

[@keshab644]

Solute to this gentleman

[@tikamaya4435]

Awesome ! Thank-you sir ...

[@deePawsdeeepaws]

we are with u Nepal. ..

[@1221HARI]

salute to mani Shankar aiyer sir to speak reality . thank you sir

[@crystalshrestha3645]

The people of Nepal are tired of India treating Nepal as its backyard. Nepal is a sovereign nation, we do not identify ourselves as Indians and nor do we look to India as our guardian. Any and all matters pertaining to our constitution is the business of Nepal and Nepal alone. We do not entrust the politicians of India to decide what is in the best interests of Nepal. We have our own politicians, whom we have voted for. I commend this man for his honesty and courage, but make no mistakes good Sir. This illegal sanction against Nepal has not rendered us weak. Rather, it has unified us and made us more resolute in assertions of our sovreignty and independence as a nation. If the Modi government or India is expecting to find a nation and its people on their knees, rest assured, that day will never come.

[@santoshgaire6495]

Truth has been SPOKEN...

[@sajakthapa8339]

Thank you mani Shankar

[@yaaatri]

much appreciated..

[@ujiwalthapa5462]

great respect for da people like Aiyar this is wat real neighbour b like

[@Random_Knowledges]

Thank you sir.....

[@mkdnpl]

This is the reality of Nepal.

[@pranjal_education.official]

Sir, thank you!

[@aswingrg1228]

Awesome. Truth...

[@indulawati4403]

thank you Mr.mani shankhar..........

[@ganeshbasti]

Mani Shankar ... love from nepal

[@suryaprasad7993]

the real politicians real lines clears all daubt and sought... he knows the reality between india & nepal.. sushmaa ji ko muskurakar smile dena aur agitators ko laalu sarwar pahuchna bast ek hi hai....

[@Downhillsnpl]

Thank you Mani Shankar for your true comments. The Nepali constitution had been signed by among more than 500 parliament members and it's true. There are only 25 Parliament members who did not support the new constitution. Our constitution dose not discriminate to any people of Nepal. 11 Madeshi Members are lying and forcing Madeshi people to protest against government , and this is fact . 3 members out of 11 are even lost in election . The Foreign Minister of India saying that relationship with India and Nepal ( Called Roti Beti), this has been already stipulated in new constitution paragraph 10 , sub-paragraph 6 . In pursuant paragraph 10 sub-paragraph 6 we still have the same right as it was in past interim constitution. We have right to get Nepal citizen when we married with Indian Family. Let me tell you , this is not the reason they are agitating. Our understanding is , Mr. Modi have been supporting to the Madeshi for his shadow self-Interest. Please, find out this from Bihar Pradesh parliament members. The possible way to bring our relationship is to uplift the blocked. Please , advise to Madeshi leaders in good faith to participate on the debate and resolve the issues . Our government is always ready to amend the appropriate demands, but we do not accept that is harmful to the nation.

[@bibekdhoj]

Sushma swaraj said that all the border point except birgunj are ope but that's not true,protest are more in points other than birgunj but trucks are passing through them.Police reports clearly suggest that the protesters attack them from the Indian territory under the protection of SSB and Indian police.

[@laldhantamang6488]

Thank you India for your support

[@MrDhiraj707]

awesome speech

[@magarismsyantox8763]

Salute to mani shanked aiyer

[@idineshroy]

Now comes all the truth.

[@sakinfood]

wow he has spirit salam merey chacha

[@ankitkarki9287]

this is wat the reality........honorable deputy chairmain aiyar said

[@pramodsubedi5926]

thumbs upp mani sankar u are the real leader and good nabour

[@shreegurung]

Wish the MPs of India had read the Constitution of Nepal before commenting on the Constitution of Nepal 2072. Yes there are dissatisfaction.... that is the beauty of democracy you make the agenda of the flaws to garner more votes to amend the constitution.