Who is Alberto's Biological father?? I WAS WRONG || LUCA THEORY REVISITED

[@RandomCritique]

Just curious to know: how many of y'all related to this movie in an LGBTQIA+ type of way and how many of y'all related to this in a friendship type way? Do you see this movie one way more than the other? BE RESPECTFUL TO EVERYONES OPINIONS! (Last time I asked something similar, there was a lot of arguing. I just think it's important to have a conversation like this) I'm excited to read your responses!

[@mayteallon8028]

Well I don't see really see much romance in the movie but if there's a Luka 2 movie that comes out and there is some one that is part of the LGBTQ+ comes out I 100% support that 😊🏳️‍🌈🏳️‍⚧️❤🧡💛💚💙💜

[@cassiepaine8229]

Get better soon!😀

[@could-be-anyone]

I kinda shipped Luca and Alberto but that was before Julieta

[@RandomCritique]

@@cassiepaine8229 I will! Thank you!

[@Mila_aria]

Can I have a shout out please

[@The_Orignal_Crackhead]

Thank you for the shout out, and I hope you feel better

[@potatohamster1085]

OMG! Thanks sooo much for the shoutout, ive never had one before! You literally made my day! :D II was so excited!!! Get better soon, never stop theorizing!

[@nene77519]

Can we appreciate how much work she had done and time she spent to make a video for us Even if she's sick ... Get well soon 🥺💕

[@AlexTrusk91]

This is the 4th video I watch from you. The other 3 were all on the Luca theories. Gotta say... the recording and editing skills got better and better. Keep up the great progress. About the minor apperence differences of Massimo and the man on the boat in La Luna... If that is Alberto and he can look completely different, Massimo could as well look different. And if it's a dream or a bedtime story misremembered as real, it can be a little fuzzy as well.

[@COMALiteJ]

Thanks for refuting the _Encanto_ Bruno theories. Enrico Casarosa wouldn’t use a Disney character in his continuity. You speculate that Papa Scorfano (I think his given name might well be Bruno because of Alberto’s use of it, despite Casarosa’s denial) is human and that therefore Alberto is a hybrid. I think not. I _do_ think that Papa Scorfano was human, but _not_ that he’s Alberto’s _biological_ father. I think hybrids (if even biologically possible) can’t fully transform into sea monsters at least in the external sense, but may have some internal traits (more on this in a bit). No, in my own headcanon I think that Papa Scorfano was a fisherman and wannabe sea-monster _hunter_ from Portorosso. He comes across a sea monster and doesn’t yet understand them as people, and hurls a harpoon at it, but the sea monster turns out to be female and places herself between his harpoon and a tiny sea monster behind her and begs him, in Italian, not to kill her baby. “Kill me if you must, but spare my _bambino_ Alberto!” are her last words, and shock Scorfano. He’d already thrown the harpoon and couldn’t stop it, and it was only after she said that that he even noticed the child, perhaps of toddler age. The child is crying for his Mama, and begging her to wake up, not understanding the reality of death. Scorfano breaks down over what he’d done, and realizes that he has to do the only thing he can to make it right, and becomes Alberto’s _foster_ father (not a legal adoption, but this is why Alberto shares his surname). Scorfano tries his best to raise Alberto, but keeps him hidden from the people of Portorosso, so they live on the island in the tower. Yet as much as he tried to be a good foster father, every time he saw Alberto, even though Alberto seemed to’ve long ago forgotten the horror of his mother’s death at Scorfano’s hands (and presumably her mate, Alberto’s _biological_ father, had either died [maybe at the harpoon of another Portorosso resident] or abandoned the family before this), he just couldn’t bear looking at Alberto because of the guilt that rose up every time he did. So, once Alberto was old enough to at least sustain his own life, Scorfano left him. Who knows what happened to him after that? Fortunately, thanks to Luca, Alberto meets Massimo Marcovaldo, and I like to think that after the events of the _“Ciao_ Alberto” sequel short, Massimo officially adopts Alberto as his son. He’s Alberto Marcovaldo from then on, and Giulia now has a big stepbrother. As for hybrids, I think that they can’t shapechange to sea monsters, but if they inhale water, instead of drowning their lungs grow gills, and also when wet their human limbs develop sea monster musculature internally for better swimming. I suspect that Ciccio, Ercole’s heavy-set henchman, is a hybrid, though doesn’t know it. Remember, Casarosa’s original plan was for Ciccio to be a full sea monster child, a third friend in the Luca and Alberto friendship. This hypothesis would keep some of that intact. Ciccio may be the son of Pinuccia Aragosta, the short stout Aragosta sister who transformed into a blue-scaled sea monster after Luca and Alberto were revealed to the townsfolk, and after the Paguros were revealed. Concetta (the tall, slender, purple-scaled sister) may be a spinster, but I suspect that Pinuccia is a widow or abandoned wife of a human husband with at least two children fathered by him: an older girl [ask me about her if you’re interested] and a younger boy, Ciccio. Part of the reason they kept themselves hidden so long is that these children never transformed when bathed or otherwise wet, so they kept the secret for the sake of their children. When her husband died or left (maybe on finding out that he’d married a sea monster), she moved in with her spinster sister. Also remember that Ercole chose Ciccio to do the swimming in his triathlon team. Ciccio’s bulk would normally make him ineffective at swimming. Either Ercole himself or Guido would seem to be a better swimmer. Yet notice that Ciccio was by far the fastest swimmer competing, and would’ve won that phase of the competition if Ercole’s dousing him in oil hadn’t attracted fish to bite him. While he may not’ve known about his hybrid nature until his mother transformed, he’d always been a very good swimmer, able to hold his breath seemingly indefinitely (actually he could breathe water as a hybrid, though he wouldn’t know that).

[@mayteallon8028]

This theory makes a lot of sense can't wait for next week's new theory hope you get better soon😊

[@RandomCritique]

Thank you so much! I should be completely better by next week's video

[@mayteallon8028]

@@RandomCritique really I am so glad 😃😊

[@infiniteeditor2827]

@@RandomCritique can I get a shout out

[@aidenworld2755]

@@RandomCritique I have a question how did Alberto become a sea monster if his dad isn’t a sea monster?

[@lindsaymariangonzales4003]

I SWEAR I LOVE YOU SO MUCH, YOU'RE SO SMART AND YOU ALWAYS WORK HARD ON YOUR VIDEOS. THEY ALWAYS ENTERTAIN ME, KEEP DOING THIS, WE LOVE YOU!

[@otarimuradishvili5540]

One problem : Moon boy was shown in credits so he isnt Alberto... his dad may be related to Massimo though. Personally I think Bruno is Alberto's dad who immigrated to Italy after 'LA VIOLENCIA'

[@lpsgalaxygirlizzy8687]

Can i just say your voice is feels good to listen to

[@CozmicKaos]

Amazing video, as always 😁

[@itsfinneclipse6675]

May I have a shoutout Also love your luca and coraline theories and everything else!! Hope you feel better :)

[@javeriaayaz3416]

Your videos make my day😍 Love your theories😊 Thank you so much for shout out😘 Need more tangled theories😃

[@amarachukwuechoke9192]

Thanks for the shout...and yup got the pronunciation right 👍 I hope you get well soon🤞🤞

[@RandomCritique]

Thank you so much!

[@TheGoldNinja101]

This little boy's shirt looks like Luca's shirt Alberto's gifted.

[@allaroundalina1855]

I love all your theories and they make soo much sense

[@RandomCritique]

Thank you so much!!

[@plusultra9576]

OK BUT THINK ABOUT THIS! Children's eyes actually change color when they're growing! Explains the different eye color from childhood to preteen! PLUS in the film la luna (brilliant connection btw) when the kid reaches the "moon" he thinks he's floating up, BUT, what if Massimo was utilizing his half sea monster son to go UNDER the water and catch fish?! Which is why he thinks the stars are fish? Cus the moonlight must have been reflecting off their scales?? AND THE KID PUT THE ANCHOR IN PLACE IN LA LUNA! Which furthers my theory that they were actually UNDER the water. In Luca they used very early diving equipment, massimo could have used it in luca to gather the fish(stars)under water! And like when luca used it in the race, those suits are heavy which explains why it seemed like they had gravity under water(on the moon) in LA luna. They needed the ladder to get back to the boat! And it all seems whimsical cus it was from a child's pov

[@plusultra9576]

Hypothetically.....

[@plusultra9576]

PLUS IDK HOW I MISSED THIS, LITERALY THE FIRST SECONDS OF THE MOVIE, THE OPENING SONG IS THIS; Don't trust it Non ti fidar Of a kiss at midnight Di un bacio a mezzanotte If there is a moon do not trust Se c'è la luna non ti fidar Why why Perché perché The moon at midnight "La luna" a mezzanotte He always manages to make you fall in love Riesce sempre a farti innamorar Don't trust galley stars Non ti fidar di stelle galeotte Which invite you to love each other Che invitano a volersi amar Midnight to love Mezzanotte per amar Midnight to dream Mezzanotte per sognar Fantasticar Fantasticar But how will I do without loving anymore Ma come farò senza più amar But how will I do without kissing Ma come farò senza baciar But how can I not be tempted Ma come farò a non farmi tentar Moon moon you Luna luna tu Don't look at me Non mi guardar Moon moon you Luna luna tu Don't poke around Non curiosar Moon moon you Luna luna tu Don't be a sentry Non far la sentinella Every star in the sky Ogni stella in ciel Speak to my heart Parla al mio cuor Every star in the sky Ogni stella in ciel Talk about love Parla d'amor Every star in the sky will be Ogni stella in ciel sarà My star La mia stella Midnight to love Mezzanotte per amar Midnight to dream Mezzanotte per sognar Fantasticar Fantasticar Don't trust it Non ti fidar Of a kiss at midnight Di un bacio a mezzanotte If there is a moon do not trust Se c'è la luna non ti fidar Why why Perché perché The moon at midnight La luna a mezzanotte He always manages to make you fall in love Riesce sempre a farti innamorar Don't trust galley stars Non ti fidar di stelle galeotte Which invite you to love each other Che invitano a volersi amar Midnight to love Mezzanotte per amar Midnight to dream Mezzanotte per sognar Fantasticar Fantasticar Which IMO is referencing not only la luna BUT massimos affair with albertos mom

[@ThePinkDragon]

I think Bruno from Enconto is too kind to abandon his son

[@Eclipswulf06]

Love it btw im currently camping. La luna is pretty underrated

[@Nott.jam24]

I love all your videos. They are so amazing and I hope you feel well❤❤❤❤

[@chelsearyzdagohoy446]

Your videos are amazing there really cool

[@bettymcduffie6335]

The girl in vid: why does Julia's dad has one arm but in la Luna he has both Me: what if in la Luna Julia's dad had a fake arm

[@dutchchann9317]

My theory is that syndrome zurg buzz’s father turned him into a sea monster he orders his zyclops to capture him and take him to his ship zurg then injects him With sea monster dna which he had stolen his dna from a random sea monster not dead zurg then injects it into him and he turns into one Bruno tells Alberto to get away and Alberto leaves

[@irvingavilanes2197]

You theory is the best😃🌺💓

[@STAR_THE_BUNNY4ever]

Amazing theories ❤

[@DoggoIsCracked]

Hope you get better soon ❤

[@bobbyparks3620]

I love your videos and I love you Love Corie

[@mimi_crystal5068]

HII ITS ME AGAIN! KEEP UP THE GREAT WORK! LOVE YOUR VIDS :)

[@jessiewessiewoo]

Tbh I think Bruno is the grandfather in lala Luna

[@harleigh6580]

I don't get why people say Bruno from Encanto in Alberto's father. It just never really made sense to me enconto takes place in Colombia and Luca takes place in Italy. If Bruno was Alberto's father then wouldn't he have to be a sea monster? Luca takes place in the 60's Encanto takes place who knows when! But most likely it near the beginning of the 21st century. But hay that's just a theory! A FILM THEORY! AAAAAAAAANNNNND CUT!

[@meghanarbour7267]

this makes so much sense and can i also get a shout out is my first time asking

[@shellyroses5707]

Oh my gosh I love your videos so much I could watch them like all day I could literally literally literally I love them so much

[@RandomCritique]

You're so sweet! 🥰

[@Akanikki]

So,One thing.. So if Alberto WAS his son. Like- When he had his arm he was young. But when he didn't Alberto was older. So maybe he just didn't get attacked when Alberto was young. Also i love your videos and I hope you get better soon!❤‍🩹✨

[@Akanikki]

Oh. Nevermind she said he said he was born without an arm😅

[@sara_callie_besties2013]

Yes, Bruno left for 10 years because Mirabel was 5 when she didn’t get her door , and in the movie she was 15

[@MeepMeep6895]

That would've made Alberto 10 but he's 14 so Bruno couldn't possibly be his farther.

[@otarimuradishvili5540]

Repeating. Bruno left AFTER mountains split.

[@katiestevenson7742]

I always think some how Luca is the Little Boy but he had a memory wipe at some point and he's Alberta cousin and Alberta can't remember Luca either. Also I think Alberta has ADHD. And maybe Luca has Autism.

[@reganweirbach6966]

Or maybe Alberto got a sea monster like from a grandparent cause in the dream that's what it actually is there seems to be like an old man on the boat Maybe that could be a birthdays grandfather

[@anikagauvin1931]

The tall mountains in encato did not allow bruno to get out so

[@imogenlindsey3204]

I love dis channel

[@victoriaburns1267]

Oh and did you notice that the tower that Alberto lives in is Rapunzel's tower

[@charlizemoore1149]

As much as this theory makes sense, I still think that the ‘Bruno’ theory could still be true. I just like that thought. To me, it makes a little more Sense for me, please don’t come after me…

[@xSushix134]

I love your videos and you shot out

[@arniellezamore9298]

What if Alberto‘s mother was Luca‘s mother But she turned into a sea monster and his father hid the truth

[@Eyefestation1362]

I like this theory man

[@mimi_crystal5068]

And get well soon! :)

[@RandomCritique]

Thank you!! I'm almost all better lol

[@bambichoi5850]

Ok but how do u explain the eyes, they are similar to Bruno’s eyes

[@torikellyreeves]

Love your videos. You should check out supercarlinbrothers theory videos. They go in depth about how Bruno is Alberto’s father.

[@brinkleydeboer7348]

Get well soon!Can you give me a shout out?I really love your theories!

[@tianareevez9032]

YA A NEW ONE SHOUT OUT PKSSSSSSS

[@amandascott567]

I think a Abteto is actually in a coma

[@louisefernandez18]

Bro the little boy has blue eyes while alberto has green eyes

[@katarinaivanov7362]

You are getting more confident by the day!

[@stella_blxsoom5995]

Can u do a Scooby doo live action movie theory pls btw I love your theories they are the best

[@chainsaw_mouth]

probably his moms last nameeee

[@IBONE_BIRD]

Hi i just want a shout out and can you make a theory of beauty and the beast who is the beasts mother and father

[@bdariamihaela]

Alberto might have had his mother's last name

[@ivettesoto9453]

You do awesome videos🥰 can I plz have a shout out

[@amaravlogs3563]

I literally love your videos and your personality can you do a theory of Encanto if you do thank you I just love your videos can I have a shoutout please❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️ btw hope you get better

[@happyedits8833]

Hello can I please get a shout out? Love ur videos! I’m always watching coralline theory’s xD

[@andrejohnson5379]

I love your view I want About coraline Echo stop it

[@aminajunaid5919]

this vid is o cool and nice and intesting shoutoutplases

[@lunaraldc]

Hi I love your videos and theories hope you get better soon! (Could I please get a shout out)

[@victoriaburns1267]

Oh and I hope you get better

[@AlexTrusk91]

Let's just not ask how the teach English under the sea (but not italian, wich would be much closer). That convience is jsut presumed everywhere. And good thing that even the italian characters mainly speak English, that's very polite of them including everone :)

[@vivianaverveen4598]

Rose 🌹

[@Kinito_PET62919]

Wow 🤩

[@bdariamihaela]

Hi can I get a shout out. It was actually the original video on this theory that made me subscribe

[@RandomCritique]

Really?? Lol it's been a while since then

[@bdariamihaela]

@@RandomCritique Really, well I saw it months after you posted it 'cause it took like ages to make the subtitles for Luca here

[@emmaisabelle1463]

what if massio is a sea monster but he left arbitos mom and his son and then he went to the land and he fell in love with goleas mom? btw sorry if i dint spell their name right lol

[@eleanorusrex1836]

please shout out your so cool and i look up to you ypu inspire me your awesome

[@marcyroblox_edits6657]

Im realy curious on who allberto's parents realy are, but has anyone ever though maybe alberto was adopted at a young age, or taken away ( or I'm just dumb lol 🤪 ) hope you get better soon 😊😇

[@ilemgomez1410]

Can I pes have a showuot for your video 

[@Jurassicparkfan1025]

😊😊😊

[@jamesallan2190]

True

[@infiniteeditor2827]

Can I get a shout out I love ur vids

[@katt.notfound]

Hello! Can I get shout out?? If not that ok.

[@katarinaivanov7362]

PLESE READ THIS COMMENT!!! what if Massimo is Albertos feather and lost his arm during his life but he recognized Alberto and lied to him because idk he was maybe in some danger or something so he felt it was the safest option for Alberto not to know the truth because if Alberto found out the truth he would probably be around Massimo all the time and that would put Alberto in danger and Massimo wanted to keep his son safe.🤔

[@RandomCritique]

You propose a very interesting theory!!

[@katarinaivanov7362]

@@RandomCritique thank you that means a lot coming from you!

[@arabiashop7007]

hi have you watch ciao alberto

[@amandaandherstuffedanimals1308]

Sorry to tell you this, but your theory is false number one. The boy in le luna appears at the end of Luca, making him a different person, number two he looks very different compared to Alberto if we were to assume that he was younger or at least this was a dream when you look exactly the same as he did why does he look different? And number three he had a grandfather in that story where does he fit into the story?

[@infiniteeditor2827]

Can I get a shout out

[@toresha-wi5wt]

I think burno is the father because he says son dont put that in your mouth and son dont do that we don't talk about buno he told me my fieh whoud die the next day dead nonono sorry I love Disney plus and forzen ohh ohh ohhh make more videos if you want to ❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️

[@allaroundalina1855]

Can I also get a shout out?

[@GamerGirlKinsley]

ok so your original theory could be right, the last names don't matter because the father only gets his last name if hes married to the mother, and you can still have kids even though you aren't married Edit: I commented this before I watched the whole video, I didnt realize you went with the same theory lol

[@Hello_xdx]

Make a Simpson video pls

[@sairachavez3757]

Hi I love your vids and can I please get a shout out have a awesome day and I love your Disney vids

[@RandomCritique]

Of course! And thank you so much 🤍

[@eleanorusrex1836]

and if you cant do my shout please do a marvel theroy

[@morgannelson7547]

Hi

[@timmythefish5382]

can i please have a shout out tysm 💖

[@mileyslottke8005]

You are so pretty

[@sophia8347]

Pls can I get a shout out love ur videos

[@RandomCritique]

Yes of course!

[@sophia8347]

Ty

[@prettygurl_qweenkyky3008]

Hi I love your video plz shot out

[@fangirlhairdos2788]

I love your videos SO MUCH I LOVE YOUR THOERIES keep up the good work I support you shout out please! you don't have to if you don't wanna

[@IndianaSmells]

My hole has theoryes 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@jsquad-nj1xs]

Damn!! !! Why are you DTILL talking about things llthi

[@abdulalimmustefa968]

Please give me a shout out Just saying I love ur videos

[@toisankinney4275]

Can I have a shoutout 😁

[@tritiumdotca]

Uhwhat?

[@brambleal1]

Can I have a shoutout

[@Madison-le2dv]

How dare you

[@Sonic-kp2op]

Bruuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu uuuuuuuu u Uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu uuuuuuuuuu

[@infiniteeditor2827]

Can I get a shoutout

[@GabbyOrGabrielle]

me:(finding a new video then sees this)omg who is albertos biogica no bio no biogical bi bi biological father there