Ranking ALL 289 ProSeka Covers/Comms [AS OF 10/9/24]

[@MarceCloud39]

Are you opinions super different to mine? Cool! Tell me by partaking in the annual viewer survey!!! It may take awhile to fill out, but it's your only way to let your voice be heard in a video on this channel! Vote here until November 13th!: forms.gle/uabi8VDTvAEBzJBg8

[@kokoro7996]

I was playing a video game when the full version of Cyberpunk Dead Boy was released, and when I heard Tsukasa’s growl in the bridge, I paused my game rewinded because I was shookith by that part! Tsukasa is my favorite character alongside An. I’m doing to be devastated if he doesn’t get a Cyberpunk Dead Boy alt as well!

[@Machination_24]

Watching the entirety of this video is the kind of thing which just makes me love Project Sekai all over again... this many songs, without even accounting the vs only ones is crazy Some of my favorite songs were quite low, some high, I was just happy to hear them once more Also, I know it's not the first year you've done this, but I really love the idea of using your favorite alts. It made me discover some of them I wasn't aware were THAT GOOD ?? My next Shiho cover card is definitely going towards Bokura Made Underground... Also hoping for a Tsukasa alt on Cyberpunk Dead Boy, I share the sentiment towards his performance here 🙏

[@LemonJuice978]

Oh my god I watched your video last year and EVERY TIME a new cover or comm comes out theres something in the back of my head going "I wonder how that one youtube person is gonna rank it in this year's video". Very excited to watch this one!!

[@MarceCloud39]

I love being "that one youtube person" so much lol thanks

[@Heyyoe_]

OKAY YALL DONT LET ME DOWN AND LET L/N DO WELL IN THE VIEWER RANKING PLEASE

[@Machination_24]

Leo/need fans unite !!

[@FreddieBarringer-h2g]

REAL omg

[@marinamoraes6174]

I'm so glad you enjoyed the Kisaragi Attention cover! Fingers crossed we get at least Outer Science and Additional Memory eventually

[@MarceCloud39]

Oh you get me. Those are like the two KagePro songs I REALLY care about.

[@marinamoraes6174]

@@MarceCloud39 I remember it from your wishlist video, hehehe. I was sooooo happy when Kisaragi Attention was hinted and then announced. I'm hoping we get Otsukimi Recital Minoharu as well

[@cerulean1003]

PLEAAASSSSEEEE Kisaragi Attention was one i really wanted (i was hoping itd be MinoShizu but im more than happy with a full group cover) and now im really hoping for those two. Outer Science i reeeallly want to be RuiKasa (its been close to 3 years give them another duet!!) and Additonal Memory could be either MizuEna or L/N i just wanna hear some belting!!! Let them belt a bit i know they can do it!!!

[@Furjan-ls6er]

I like Kisaragi Attention but the pitch change was weird at first and no IA version to choose on the VS side disappoints me since I knew this song on IA’s voice.

[@MarceCloud39]

No IA is a choice on Jin’s part. From what I understand (don’t take me as an authority on the subject, I’m just repeating what I’ve heard) 1st Place (IA’s company) really screwed Jin over licensing wise when it came to KagePro songs. It’s very likely any KagePro songs added going forward will be rearranges not featuring her. Kinda sad in the case of a potential addition of Outer Science since I really like how IA sounds on it, but that’s not a problem for Additional Memory. These rearranges are kinda like the Taylor’s Versions of KagePro if the way I understand it is correct. If anyone sees this that has a better grasp of the situation, feel free to elaborate or even correct me if necessary.

[@hongxiu1668]

Things will never be the same after the mizu5 incident

[@MarceCloud39]

I actually set an alarm and woke up in the middle of the night so I'd be awake for its drop (4:30 AM for leaks, 5 AM for official release). It was a wild experience.

[@SuzdalPanic]

Thanks for always being so detailed with your thoughts, these videos are super fun to watch because of that! It's great to see how far this game has gone over the years, but I really hope they fix the character balance eventually (>_

[@MarceCloud39]

Thanks! I didn't always do the commentary (only started doing it last year) so I'm glad it's appreciated. With there being over 300 to do next year I'll need this kind of encouragement to do it again lol

[@cinnakins]

i look forward to these videos coming out each year! even if we may not agree on every song ranking i love to hear what you have to say about them ^_^ already voted in the viewer ranking

[@lapis-lazurite]

The tonal switch of the comments from the cupmen song to reincarnation apple broke my lungs 😂

[@manburger_3939]

a lot a lot of my fav songs may have placed low (i will personally remove the cutlery sounds from cutlery for you to place it higher) but im glad a lot of my favs also got in the top 100!!! also very very happy to see kagepro songs up there and SLOW DOWNER TOP 50 im looking forward to the viewer ranking!!! (and the next wishlist if thats gonna happen)

[@Heyyoe_]

7 leo need songs in the top 20 is so based 😍😍

[@_Lola-]

REALL

[@Kenji39miku]

HORRAY, I GET FRONT ROW SEATS FOR ANOTHER YEAR OF MARCECLOUD39'S プロセカ RANKINGS! 🧡🃏

[@Average-mavuika-enjoyer]

Ghost rule not being in a higher rank gives me a new type of anger

[@MarceCloud39]

If it makes you feel any better it used to be super high up. I just really hate how they made Miku sound on it (not a problem with other IchiMiku duets) and as it sets in that we’re never getting an Ichika alt I’m just disappointed in it. So close to having something really good, but it’s locked in a vault and it’ll probably never see the light of day.

[@Katsudon-P]

Ghostrule is so overrated so it made me so happy lol

[@yuakim77]

proseka next songs need more recognition I was feeling giddy from watching it being brought up

[@MarceCloud39]

Yeah as someone that’s a Vocaloid fan first and a Sekai fan second I thought it’d be a fun bonus thing to tack on at the end. We’re at a point where there’s enough winners for a Top 10 to be interesting. I’ll probably keep doing this segment as long as I do these video too- it’s a shame Parry just barely didn’t make the cutoff.

[@Katsudon-P]

With how much diversity and numbers of songs there are, unironically its probably impossible for anyone to agree with a specific ranking, BUT This was pretty damn great, and I’m so happy the overrated vocaloid songs weren’t so damn high in the ranks! I personally would’ve put Deep Sea Girl and Tengaku in Top 2 since those two are my most favorite vocaloid songs in general lol

[@raichouthepenguin]

You kept the clips nice and short and this video is still almost an hour long. That's crazy :0

[@MarceCloud39]

Yeah if I made them any shorter they’d go by waaaay too fast. The sub Top 50 are at the absolute shortest they can be and it’s still like this. To think 5th anniversary will probably have like 350-something songs… It’s already taking me out just thinking of the render time (this took a little over an hour to render).

[@moonofalola327]

Cyberpunk dead boy is hands down the best song in the game for me. When wxs is at their peak, they’re honestly unstoppable. I actually prefer Goodbye Declaration to Ego Rock (though they’re both 2 and 3 lol). Personally I think the emotion they put into it is amazing. I’m curious as to why you’re not a huge fan of the full group version? A lot of ppl find emu’s high note to be grating, which I understand lol, but I love that song wayyyyy too much lol. Also, great video! I haven’t seen your other ones but I’ll definitely be back next year! ❤

[@RoseSparkles5]

OMG I MISSED YOU SM, WELCOME BACK, IDJEI2KSJDUDBDNSKSJ

[@green-violins]

1 IN 6TH EVERYONE CHEERS

[@Meow-kokei]

AHHHH QUEEN IS SO GOOD THO-

[@MarceCloud39]

The lowered pitched edit someone sent to me actually was really good. In its current state their voices are too grating for me. Had they been allowed to not strain their voices by staying within their comfortable register I actually think it would have been my favorite EmuNene cover. The most common complaints I’ve seen of QUEEN are that “Emu is bad” and I’d actually disagree because I think lower pitch Emu would have been great on it. As is it’s just kinda painful missed opportunity imo.

[@Furjan-ls6er]

@@MarceCloud39 And considering the complaints about Meiko’s inclusion, she sounds nice on the cover and Nene sounds good considering the final result. Also the song itself is catchy as hell and echoes in my head all the time, I love it.

[@chiyorins]

the mind brand “RISE RISE RISE” had me ctfu omg

[@felyyzzz]

Oh wow, im really one of the few Mind Brand's enjoyers huh. Still, i do understand why so many people dislike it jkdnsvkd Good ranking!

[@lapis-lazurite]

Mind brand enjoyer here too! 🤚 I've always read it as a song centered on fear/trauma with the angry parts being the setting, so I thought the way niigo covered it was pretty alright, though yes I understand the frustration over it.

[@cerulean1003]

for me it started out as ok but the more i listened the more i disliked it. I didnt need them scream singing but they all needed more emotion in their voices, i also didnt like the instrumental. It took out a lot of the more rock/metal elements from the OG. IMO it should have gone to vbs and Niigo should have gotten another Maretu song. (Even Though I Loved You i can see being a good cover for them, the vocals are softer on that one. Maybe as a KanaMafu or KanaEna duet?)

[@IzumiS3na]

26:16 shoutout to shanti, sayonara princess, hug and probably others doing the exact same thing. i'll never understand why the devs cut so little time out

[@pokemongirl5674]

going to only comment the ones in the top 50 in order of their appearance in the video: 47, 39, 38, 23, 13, 8, 6 (my fav followed by 47 and 39), 5 and 3. I like a few others outside of the top 50 but I forgot to write those down on the sheet of paper (when I watch ranking videos, I kinda have a bad memory where my favs get placed, especially if there is more than 10 of them)

[@xanvidd]

Not finished with the video yet but my jaw dropped multiple times seeing so many niigo songs at the bottom...

[@MarceCloud39]

Niigo has the highest average rank of 125 while WxS have the lowest average at 159. This was shocking to me given those very bottom Niigo songs and given how high certain WxS songs are. I guess neither heavily weigh on their averages. Niigo is a group I consider to have some of the highest highs, but when they miss they REALLY miss. (The averages for L/n and MMJ are both 146, VBS is 144 btw)

[@toodled1340]

Kyu kurarin missing the album cutoff was so sad like wdym i have to wait 2 more years now 😭

[@eeveeuwu9348]

This was not the sort of ending i was wishing for

[@rintari133]

6:54 I THOUGHT I WAS THE ONLY ONE 😭😭 seriously though, i feel weird about this song like it not bad but it something i can’t describe it ( i actually like the mizuki alt better tho). AND CYBERPUNK GOT NO.1 AS IT DESERVES 🥳🥳🥳 I love this song so much as instrument and everything (my rui bias as well) also i honestly surprised with how similar your taste w me (except the part when it comes to alt vocal of some song and the slow song)

[@chiyorins]

REKKA YUPPPPP I LOVE REKKA THANK U

[@NyanSpeak]

Oh, just a suggestion, you get the Mafuyu Bitter Choco Decoration alt, it's so good! Nonetheless, great video!

[@Sil_chan22]

I totally agree that iyowas songs are good. I’ve never heard of their songs until project SEKAI and tbh I’m glad I found their music. I do like heat abnormal because of the N25 cover. But ever since then I’ve been listening to their songs on Spotify!! ❤️

[@MarceCloud39]

Yeah I was aware of Iyowa before their stuff was being added to Sekai, but I wasn’t an active fan until after. Not because I didn’t like what I knew, I just never got around to checking out more than what I knew. Sekai forced me to broaden my horizons and I’m thankful for that.

[@aryasinha4321]

If you don't mind which speed do you play in?😅

[@akutgawa]

33:33 HORRIBLY BASED TOYAS MOONLIGHT COVER MAKES ME CRY UNCONTROLLABLY. also based how kyukurarin is up SO SO HIGH!!!!

[@olived9560]

EMPURPLE LOVEEEEEE (and 1 and nonbreath oblige)

[@erihtea0719]

for some reasons the songs i'm most interested in come out RIGHT after you post these videos, so I'm curious now as to where you'd rank the new mizuki5 commission on this list 👀

[@MarceCloud39]

I was about the post a general comment saying it's Top 50 for sure, probably VERY high within that. I am losing my mind. We'll see how much of that is recency bias in a year I guess.

[@boop4545]

Just wanted to share my fav version of each song if it differs from yours :D Time Machine (Saki) Journey (Tsukasa) Teo (Ichika) Starry Sky Melody (Sekai) From Tokyo (Honami) Kitty (Mizuki) Purpose (Shiho) Vampire (Minori) Mirai (Toya) Color of Drops (Haruka) Goodbye Sengen (Sekai) The World Hasn't Even Started Yet (Emukasa) Once Upon a Dream (Emu) Positive Dance Time (Emu) Ifuudoudou (Akito) Near (Sekai) Ai no Material (Minori) Flyer (Sekai) Kanadetomosusora (Kanade) Heartbeat (Ichika) Coral (Nene) Needle (Saki) Dreamin Chuchu (Shizuku) 1925 (Nene) Viva Happy (Minoairi) Paiii Sensation (An) Uninterrupted Indigo (Toya) At God's Mercy (Nene) King (Tsukasa) Teammate (Minori) Hide and Seek (Honami) Cutlery (Kanade) Tondemo Wonderz (Rui) Echo (Toyakoha) Irony (Mafuyu) Glow (Honami) Hibana (Ichika) Calc (Ichika) It Was a Very Beautiful June (Ena) Hollow (Toya) Love Trial (Minori) Aishite (Ena) Starry Sky Orchestra (Emu) Composing the Future (Mafuyu) Meteor Pulse (Shiho) Torinoko City (Haruka) Machi (Sekai) Gunjo Sanka (Kanade) Hug (Shizuku) Clear Weather (Honami) Summertime Record (Ichika) Close to Gray (Ena) Dramaturgy (Ichika) Hitorinbo Envy (Mizuki) Nomad (Ena) Chururira Dadda (Sekai) Blender (Toya) Parasol Cider (Airi) Idsmile (Ena) Buriki no Dance (Rui) Neppu (Kanade) Six Trillion Years (Ichika) Mr Showtime (Emukasa) Nostalogic (Haruka) Ikanaide (Saki) Alter Ego (Toya) Fixer (Tsukasa) Engeki (Mafuyu) Stage of Sekai (Honami) Villain (Mafuyu) Happy Halloween (Shizuku) Lost and Found (Saki) All Night Thinking of You (Sekai) Amanojaku (Sekai) Neo (Kohane) The Peachy Key (Airi) Attract Light (Shiho) Odo (An) Float Planner (Shizuku) MKDR (Kanade) Boo! (Haruka) Lower (Mizuki) Hated by Life (Kanade) Moonlight (Sekai) Literary Nonsense (Tsukasa) Rad Dogs (Akitoya) Jackpot Sad Girl (Mafuyu) One Sheep (Kohane) Beat Eater (Kohane) Telecaster B Boy (Emu) Showtime Ruler (Rui) Were Still Underground (Sekai) Karakuri Pierrot (Shizuairi) Gehenna (Mizuki) Kyu Kurarin (Haruka) Venom (Mizuki)

[@MarceCloud39]

Shizuku Happy Halloween and Emu Telecaster B-Boy in particular are so valid (I mean they all are, but those are the ones I actively agree with lol). Those are two where I actually really like those alts, but I don't want to get rid of the rest of the cast so I keep it as the Sekai version. In B-Boy's case it's genuinely Emu's best alt imo. Shizuku has too many alts that are incredible to call Happy Halloween her best.

[@boop4545]

@@MarceCloud39 I actually keep a ton of these songs on VS, especially if they're classic vocaloid songs. Alts are literally a Godsend!!

[@starrshort6403]

Nice !!!!!

[@boop45435]

YIPPIE YIPPIE I WILL BE BACK TO COMMENT WHEN THE VIDEO COMES OUT

[@spartayy282]

what do you think of this year's april fools covers

[@MarceCloud39]

Better than the first batch honestly. As someone with heavy Haruka bias I believe putting her on Devil's Manner was truly an inspired choice. My only real complaint with any of them is that Kanade wasn't great on Setsuna Trip because it was just a weird song for her character voice (her VA out of character would probably do a great job). If they do unit swap again I do hope Akito and Emu get to leave their original groups though. I at least understand why it's harder to get Ichika to when keeping one of each original vocalist on every track.

[@Han2ndacc]

Finally somebody dosent talk about tsukasa’s damn growl like it’s rui’s song not his and everyone did so good but nooo it’s only tsukasa this tsukasa that like SHUT UP

[@harmonicmelody1710]

Heat Abnormal in top 35 (oops mistake at first) and the absolute god tier Empurple in top 5. As they should be. I didn't think Engeki would be topped for me personally but holy shit it was. By those two but also by Regulus Yes the Mafuyu bias is real And yeah An's Gekokujou is so fucking good and that's not just personal bias because of how important the song and event are to me Can't believe both the top and bottom songs got dethroned this year. That's damn impressive

[@MarceCloud39]

Yeah Sekai has had such a turbulent yeah that both bottom and top songs getting dethroned honestly just makes sense in a way. It was a really "it's so over" "we're so back" graph of a year in many regards. Also Mafuyu bias is so real. Lately I've been realizing some of my favorite line reads are from her and I'm reevaluating how high she should be in my rankings of character vocals

[@harmonicmelody1710]

Mafuyu has a lot of misses, and the misses are BIG misses, but damn when Mafuyu hits, we get things like Aishite, Aishite, Aishite and USSEEWA and Slow Downer and Kokoronashi which is literally only held up by Mafuyu and Kanade because I don't know what the hell they did with Len and I'm still begging for a Mafuyu alt that we probably won't get sadly Rui Tanabe can put so much emotion into Mafuyu's voice it amazes me

[@MarceCloud39]

Yes USSEEWA and Slow Downer in particular! There's also short lines I really love in Samsa and the "Administraitor" line in Bug is great as well. Those are all what have been converting me into a big fan of Mafuyu's voice. Kokoronashi likely going altless is such a crime. It's like Dappo Rock 2 for me, but even worse: Len is there and ruining it when the human singers are delivering good performances that we don't get alts of.

[@Savie7214]

did i go blind or did i not see mr.showtime

[@johneenerz]

can someone tell me what rank cute na kanojo got as well as ultra c 😇

[@LeekSan]

I swear I went through the video like 3 times and couldn’t find either

[@Infinitely_ena]

wait am i blind did i miss killer (kiraa by mmj) or is it js not there . also I LOVE EGO ROCK AND KYUKURARIN SMSMSMS your top 3 is so based

[@MarceCloud39]

16:11, #179. I absolutely like it, but I don’t love it like songs higher up. It’s def good though! I don’t rank based off of it, but I especially love its 3DMV ending with the sprite art. It’s so cute.

[@MIZUKIISMYWIFETRUST]

Bake no Hana would SWEEP the poles if it was on the list

[@MarceCloud39]

It would sweep this list too if it came out in time lol

[@potetopancakes]

#1 is so true

[@hrsjsbjsbsushxbdhbdusjs]

"the two new bottom songs" part makes me nervous bcs i don't think any song this year was really that bad 😭

[@MarceCloud39]

Both are covers that had vocal performances that missed the mark for me. One is just one singer sounding extremely out of breath and therefore bad but because it’s a song I love I’m very mad they didn’t do another take. The other is an instance where if they had lowered the pitch of the song to avoid straining the VA’s voices I genuinely believe it would have been amazing- so that also makes me really mad they didn’t do that (high scoring song last year Non-breath oblige is pitched down, it’s not like they’ve never done it before). The fact that both actively anger me is why they’re at the bottom even if they might not be the objective worst in the game. There’s also another new song in the bottom 10 because I just think they missed the tone entirely- and that’s not a song you want to mess up the tone of imo. The good news is there’s also a lot of new songs in the Top 150 and higher so it wasn’t all bad this year, I promise! I say Top 150 and higher only because I think that’s the least spoilery way to go about saying things are good. Don’t wanna give away too much yet.

[@CremeFrappe13-sh4ui]

The Leo/need bias is real.

[@BlossomsofCherries]

we need a shiho and/or saki alt for aioi they both sounded perfect, or better than perfect.

[@MarceCloud39]

Actually you know what, despite ranking it low, I kinda agree. I think it's really weird we got Tokyo Teddy Bear alts for Saki and Shiho before alts for Aioi (and more likely Tengaku for Shiho). It makes me think Aioi just isn't going to get alts which is kind of a shame.

[@BlossomsofCherries]

@@MarceCloud39 i REALLY hope aioi gets alts it deserves them

[@aly-p2f]

i used to dislike rui's alts so much, istg he sounded so dead and bland to me, i felt like the rest of the groups voices really helped his voice sound better, i listened to his KING alt and it sounded so elegant, changed my view on his alts

[@ice15464]

podium songs solid!!!!

[@chiyorins]

gehenna top 10 exactlyyyyy (i personally prefer original vocaloid ver though)

[@vocaloidfan19327]

I love O-Barcode

[@Koyanagi.K]

FLYWAY TOP 5 YAYAYAY

[@SasukaRH]

you forgot amara the great intelligence

[@MarceCloud39]

That’s a VS only song that was commissioned for the game. The main rankings are only the comms featuring the human cast and the bonus rankings are only the ProSeka NEXT winners. Tokugawa is in a weird position being so Vocaloid heavy, but Nenerobo just being Nene’s voice put through a filter of some kind makes it count enough. A quick ranking of comm’d VS Only boss songs: 1. Jouou - HachiojiP 2. AMARA - sasakure.UK 3. Machine Gun Poem Doll - cosMo 4. Seimeisei Syndrome - Camellia

[@akihikariii]

melty land nightmare being kinda low hurts me ngl 😭

[@MarceCloud39]

I’d say it’s around “A tier” still if that makes you feel any better. I’m just that easy to please that the 110s is somehow “good”.

[@JaxonBowman-h8o]

I cant wait to see how many opinions I disagree with

[@MarceCloud39]

How bad was it? lol

[@JaxonBowman-h8o]

@@MarceCloud39the one that hurt the most was sayonara princesses ranking, it’s like top 10 cover for me, but I do understand how you’d think it’s a little crammed

[@MarceCloud39]

Yeah if it were MinoShizu only it'd probably be much higher. I don't think it's bad otherwise. I like Shizuku on in particular so that one major flaw for me is kind of a bummer. If that's not a flaw for you that's great, honestly.

[@JaxonBowman-h8o]

@@MarceCloud39 I do think an alt is deserved for this song, and I think it would be shizuku, hopefully that would make it better for you at least

[@Meow-kokei]

WHY I LIKE LAGTRAIN

[@Furjan-ls6er]

The barrage of full group covers were too much to the point that I lost interest on any new covers for quite a while. Especially with MMJ! along with the bait and switch of the Minori5 event was just rubbing salt in the wound. At least the comms are getting better. And the charting of the songs in general are so much fun to play.

[@MarceCloud39]

Yeah like in theory full group covers are fine, but too much of anything makes it become dull, uninteresting, and sometimes even annoying. I liked how Mozaik Role turned out, but I bet it would have been better if it were IchiShiho + a VS. The song actually lends itself better to being divided into 3 singers than 5 so the choice to make it 5 is kind of obnoxious and forced. It’s so funny to me how MMJ’s ONLY duo song on Album 3 is one I wanted to be full group though. Like it’s literally on my wishlist video as full group + MEIKO and we got the exact opposite of that. However, I am somehow thankful because any duo MMJ song is a blessing at this point.

[@Furjan-ls6er]

@@MarceCloud39 I liked the Mozaik Role cover (that Shiho aise at the end revitalized me. XD) Too bad on the VS side it was the Reloaded version and not the original, I would play with Gumi’s vocals very often.

[@MarceCloud39]

Yeah I still very much like it, I just think it’s be even better with only 3 singers on it. The Shiho ending great! It’s such a shame that it took them so long to get around to it that they opted for Reloaded though. Had they prioritized the Hall of Myths songs like I honestly think they should have, we would have gotten the original. I like Reloaded, but I feel so bad for GUMI and her fans not getting her big hit in the game.

[@Suzu232]

I disagree with almost everything here (I still respect ur opinion tho)