Ranking All 31 SUDSY BEAR Soaps Worst-to-Best!

This is my Honest Review for all 31 Sudsy Bear soaps in their current catalog...
Link to Sudsy Bear: www.sudsybear.com

[@MariankGonzalez]

As a Floridian, I absolutely love that Sudsy Bear is crafted in Florida. ❤️

[@thatonewabbit]

Im glad I'm not crazy, a lot of sudsy bar scents completely disappeared on me in the shower as well! I was super bummed by it. Smokey mountain fog is absolutely fantastic though!

[@infines5047]

Hi Gary, so I’ve only tried a sample size of the PW&H and I loved the scent as well. However, the scent was actually pretty strong in the shower for me and I could smell it on my skin after. I got a full sized bar coming in so we’ll see about this one

[@mrguru091]

I'm sold on sudsy bear over squatch. I might get the bourbon one from squatch. Also how long do they last if u shower once a day

[@jamesl642]

squatch lasts about 2 and a half - 3 weeks if u shower once a day but u gotta make sure u let the water drain out of it when ur done using

[@mrguru091]

@@jamesl642 I got some soap bars from sudsy bear along with the soap savers. they do smell really good

[@BigBobster86]

I'd like to see a vid ranking all the Squatch/Sudsy Bear. Calling it now: Absolute dead last will be Spartan Scrub, followed by Birchwood Breeze and Jurrasic Earth.

[@allenr265]

Yo bro, those are your top3 mine are completely different. Smokey mountain fog for me and others would be some where in the middle. and everyone else on you tube are also completely different it all comes down to personal opinion. ☺👍

[@cjheery]

I would love to see a side-by-side ranking.

[@Jbarbeau13]

I just ordered backwoods brew a few days ago cuz cold brew cleanse was so underwhelming for me. Got the bar a week and a half ago and backwoods brew is 100 times better than cold brew cleanse

[@Some_Kind_of_Stranger]

Man you sure do like soap!

[@KaeganThornhillTheCyberRaven]

Man lives, breaths, and bathe in soap.

[@baine5.7]

Twisted grapefruit is one of the best ones .

[@stedfastace750]

Just ordered 10 bars that you ranked it costed me 121.25$ after tax and shipping and your 20% discount code. Holy f@#$ it’s expensive I hope it’s as good as you say it is! 29$ for standard shipping btw

[@Gary828]

you must live outside of the US

[@stedfastace750]

@@Gary828 yea canada

[@Gary828]

ok, that's why. which bars did you get??

[@stedfastace750]

@@Gary828 twisted pumpkin x2, backwoods brew, gettin lucky, Florida grove, bear rum, dark side of the moon, twisted mango, blueberries and cream, smoky mountain fog.

[@Gary828]

ok, let me know what you think when you get them.

[@dbean5174]

Blueberries and Cream is back!!

[@GenX_US_Marine]

Here are the soaps I've smelled out of the catalog. Blueberries and cream - smells fantastic Raspberries and cream - smells fantastic Wild Caribbean - smells fantastic Twisted Mango - smells fantastic Dark side of the moon - smells fantastic Swamp soap - Meh Florida soap - Meh Fresh Clean Aloe - smells fantastic Wild Cherry soap - Meh

[@Gary828]

you must have smelled the old FL Grove b/c I guarantee you'll like the new one

[@GenX_US_Marine]

@@Gary828 I don’t know. That Florida one I wasn’t fond of at all. I didn’t know they reformulated it. I got it when it first came out.

[@Gary828]

yeah, that bar was dull; you must not have finished this video b/c I go into detail about it on here; it's #5 on my list; if you hated the old bar you can contact customer service and they will refund or exchange it for you; get the new one!

[@Jbarbeau13]

When you gonna review Grandpap’s oak aged Bourbon?

[@Gary828]

don't have money to make soap reviews anymore

[@Jbarbeau13]

@@Gary828 oh dang that sucks :(

[@mikeagovino3573]

Dude:(

[@ilsantomorto]

THEY SHIP IN GERMANY BUT NOT IN ITALY? WTF??? MAMMA MIA!!

[@pedrovaccari9946]

lo so, stra triste

[@ilsantomorto]

@@pedrovaccari9946 Perchè?

[@CAM-tn9lv]

What is the shelf life for these bars?

[@l750z_6]

2-3 weeks with daily showers

[@lazyrhino8578]

Nice thumbnail you little gremlin

[@Bboykidcombo]

It took sudsy 5 days and 1 week end to ship my order. And squatch shipped withn 3 days. Hopefully the soap is as good as evry1 says🤫👌💨🐼🐻🐼

[@DBDPlayer76]

Yeah it’s been 5 days and they haven’t shipped my order but squatch shipped right away.

[@tyronewilliamson661]

Great choice for number one Smoky mountain fog hard hitting MF.

[@kaeganthornhill3936]

Longest it ever took them to roll out my shipment was 4 days and that was on account I ordered several of their Limited Edition. But if you Order one of their Year Round scents, I had a order shipped out in 30mins before.

[@GusTeasPlants]

I’m heavy in buying soaps lol I’m loving your real raw reviews and I just placed my first sudsybear order I got 2 eucalyptus mint and the newest coconut pirate one … 😅 I’ll probably review it since you inspired me hahaha Also used your code

[@damnwrightsports5045]

Yes do the whole ranking of both brands

[@brockbehnke1650]

I would highly recommend twisted pumpkin to anyone who wants to try sudsy bear they just hit the site and will be back for the fall season

[@sheesh5422]

Where's is the wood maple bourbon scent?

[@korygraff1568]

I love old glory but when I lather up with heavy grits without a cloth or loofa I have bad acne breakouts even if I use a zero grit the next day

[@LostConcept_]

Yes I would love too see you compare sudsy and squatch soaps side by side

[@hyperbolic-time-chamber-strand]

How long would you say a bar lasts for tops if stored correctly Gary ?

[@kaeganthornhill3936]

You can usually get 2 to 3 weeks of Showers out of each bar. As for how long you can store them. Around 2.5 years.

[@boolaidman471]

Used correctly with putting bar on soap saver and used it rubbed on a body scrubber or rag instead saves it even more, showering every other day will last about 3-4 months

[@abelrichards9640]

Gary 828 I appreciate this video

[@jordanmcmanaman8008]

Just ordered Hunt Camp, Arctic Aloe, blueberries & cream, buck hunter. Ol Saint Nick I grabbed a shampoo bar, bricc and Deo. Also grabbed a hunt camp deo too. Living in Canada our stock is pretty limited (I go through our only authorized dealer up here) excited to try sudsy and can't wait until Joey gets in Barbershop.

[@justinhill4374]

Yes! Rank both

[@monstermash5780]

I like Squatch a lot been using them for some time. I want to try these dudes. Im digging the non harmful ingredients.

[@DBDPlayer76]

Idk if it’s because of the Black Friday sales but the shipping has been real slow for sudsy bear and Squatch has been way faster when I ordered both on Black Friday.

[@Gary828]

Yes, Sudsy outgrew the size of their crew and slowed down, but have recently expanded their staff to meet demand, so they will be back on track within the next month or two.

[@DBDPlayer76]

@@Gary828 yeah I figured that makes sense. I’m excited for the soaps though lol

[@DBDPlayer76]

@@Gary828 I got my soaps and they are great, for me right now way better than Squash.

[@Cdtstevo0824]

Do you find that they are out of stock a bunch? I asked them about the BB and they said it should be ready in two weeks. Seems like half of their bars are always out of stock. Must be a really small company.

[@Gary828]

they're small, but growing fast, and keep selling out b/c they're gaining in popularity.

[@kaeganthornhill3936]

Yeah they sell out fast, but also restock fairly fast as well. ( For a company their size) Also, sometimes the scent you're looking for turned out to be a seasonal scent. However, they will sometime make a small batch for you if you ask. ( Say 8 bars) if they still have the ingredients on hand.

[@Cdtstevo0824]

@@kaeganthornhill3936 when you do a subscription for the first time do they ship that one right away or wait the 30 days? They are not responding to my chat questions.

[@kaeganthornhill3936]

@@Cdtstevo0824 They should send the bulk order within 1 to 2 weeks and then every 4 to 5 weeks after that. ( Based on their supply in stock and how much you order for your subscription) Edit: If you have to wait more than 2 weeks for your first order than it's usually means the Scent you order was being restocked and will be super fresh.

[@Cdtstevo0824]

@@kaeganthornhill3936 well I saw the BB cream just came back on line so I jumped on that and a bunch of others so hopefully I get them within the two weeks. Looking forward to trying these out. Thanks!

[@mrguru091]

I wanna get one of their underarm deodorants. Any ones u like in particular?

[@mrguru091]

Update got the ol saint nick soap and the deo, all I can say is I bought 3 more bars of it excellent scent and the deo lasts. Just ordered another 12 bars of different soaps. These guys have great quality stuff and soap last a good time. They also give a good amount of samples just leave a note of what u want and they come thru.

[@pikawalsh9672]

Thank you for these videos man, really help out a lot via the information and opinions you give. Keep it going man 👍🤝

[@rapj.r.6133]

star wars gon be bussing Dr sqautch

[@joeyrubin21]

Cant say the same about sudsy bear, i ordered the 28th, it’s currently the 1st, still have yet to ship to me

[@Gary828]

Sudsy Bear have outgrown the size of their operation since I made this video, and are now nearly always far behind processing their orders. They will right the ship, though; it's a GOOD problem to have; just frustrating for the time being. Give them some time and they will grow into their bigger business model and get items shipped much quicker.

[@kaeganthornhill3936]

Do you plan on making a fallow up video covering the 6 Soaps that got a Reformula/2.0 version?

[@statics1]

If you happen to have any influence, could you please ask them to find a way to get free shipping to the uk like squatch does? I would really like to try sudsy bear but just can’t justify £26 for 1 bar and it gets worse the more you buy

[@l750z_6]

What the fuck?? Is shipping 20 quid to the uk??

[@statics1]

@@l750z_6 yes mate, if you spend £50 it will cost you a total of £90

[@infines5047]

Hope you get a chance to try them one day man. I started with Squatch but Sudsy Bear has great quality

[@kaeganthornhill3936]

Sudsy's is working on expanding their company and Shipment reach. They are still a Small company while Dr.Squatch is 6x their size.

[@scentadventure]

Hey man this was good. I like that you didn't talk up any of the ones you didn't like. Honest review! Enjoyable. Sudsy over squatch for sure. Id probably say the swamp dweller was my favorite.

[@Dolfan0118]

Please rank both!!!

[@AaronLee-ph5nf]

Are there any sudsy bear soaps that you would compare to the scents of Sinister Scrub, Deep Sea Goat's Milk, Only Hope Soap, Dark Side Scrub, Birchwood Breeze, Legendary Lather, or Suds of Darkness by Squatch? These are my favs by squatch so far, but I honestly want bigger bars that have more pronounced scents in the shower....... and to not have to wait the friggin 2 and a half weeks that squatch takes for shipping.

[@liammartin355]

If you like bay rum, get the smoky mountain fog, I only have twisted grapefruit and smoky and those two smell amazing

[@michaelbarrett1759]

Yes do both please

[@Trigg73]

Lousy customer service. My past 2 orders were a disaster. Contacted them, no response to an email AND a phone call. Order finally showed a week late with no response from anyone. They won't have to worry about processing anymore orders from me again. Dapper Yankee, Grizzly naturals and The Black Stuff have better soap anyway and WAY better customer service.

[@dankman712]

Done made me drop the squatch and $200 on the bear lol, hope the honey is good, I’ll give an update if I remember I just been getting tired of squatch’s lack in quality and longevity lately

[@Gary828]

yeah, let us know what you think!

[@RedditGrapevine]

Verdict?

[@dankman712]

@@RedditGrapevine it’s a completely different bar in terms of quality of ingredients, I feel like squatch takes a bunch of liquids, (essential oils and and concentrates) but sudsy actually uses the ingredients In their bars, some of the older ones and limited editions are chalky but overall it’s like McDonald’s vs buffalo wild wings Not to mention, after using dark side of the moon I pulled a hottie that’s 7 years older than me hahahaha (Im 20), she was stuck to me like glue My personal favorites are the new florida grove, and cherry & goats milk, 10/10 product, with frequent deals and discounts, and 10/10 costumer service ( especially for a small business, everything I ordered took a little under a month while they had a influx of holiday orders) and the bars in my opinion are worth more than what you pay, As far as the shampoo bars, I’d compare them to old spice conditioner in quality of cleaning, and I’d say depending on the bar it’ll last you longer than squatch’s I have yet to go through one, I’ll give another update on that later

[@dankman712]

@@Gary828 if I where you I’d do a vid comparing squatch’s eucalyptus with sudsy’s, I think the bears in the lab are dominating the celebs at squatch

[@wispy.krispy]

@@dankman712 w on pulling that hottie

[@TheKoojee]

Gary mentions rotating grit types when showering as follows: Monday - Heavy grit bar Tuesday - Zero grit bar Wednesday - Medium grit bar Thursday - Light grit bar Friday - Return to heavy grit bar All grit levels are written on the packages, But l could not find the grit level of the Blueberries & cream bar, does anyone know?

[@Gary828]

I believe BB&C is medium grit; I don't think it actually says on the site. If not medium grit, then light grit, but I think probably medium.

[@TheKoojee]

Well l'll be. Sudsy Bear stuff does not ship to Australia?

[@Gary828]

@@TheKoojee probably not. I'm sorry.

[@GenX_US_Marine]

Well here's something interesting. I received my monthly subscription and my Blueberries and Cream had zero grit, it was very smooth looking, and it had prominent white swirls. All of my other Blueberries and Cream bars had the black poopy seeds and it was a solid blue bar. I wonder if they changed the formula or just forgot to add the poopy seeds. I really liked the one I received, it smelled a little different, but still very good.

[@michaelwallis2184]

Enjoyed watching

[@lilzachsmalls]

I've been waiting for the combo ranking of Squatch and Sudsy!!! I have all the Squatch bars but not all the sudsy bars, so that would give me a great comparison to see which bars from sudsy I should buy.

[@GenX_US_Marine]

I agree with the shipping, but it depends on where your located. I from Seattle and Sudsy is in Florida. I get my order within a week.

[@lilzachsmalls]

I also used a sample of the Florida Grove bar and the pumice actually scraped my skin and life long cuts on my arm... now THAT is GRIT

[@legionslair148]

Same happened to me with swamp dweller

[@Youngboss1024]

I used your code to buy 2 bars of the Blueberries and Cream. I hope I like it. I would probably be the first one who won't lol.

[@Gary828]

awesome, no way you won't like them!

[@Youngboss1024]

@@Gary828 I think I will, the reviews are glowing and from yours, too. Gary, have you tried the Grondyke Tactical Soaps? I think that should be the next one you try out and review. They are pheromone-infused, natural soaps. Their soaps are named after famous movie characters. They have a very fascinating background story, with a clinical psychologist and pheromone expert involved in the process. I think you might like some of their scents. I've been using them exclusively for several months now. Let me know what you think!

[@C____K]

What’d ya think?

[@Youngboss1024]

@@C____K Really good. I've used up nearly 1 of my 2 bars. Blueberries & Cream has incredible ingredients. Sudsy Bear certainly makes a very special product. As of now, I use Grondyke Tactical Soaps. They are natural soaps that are infused with pheromones. I suggested Gary to review them a while back. I hope his mother will be ok.

[@C____K]

@@Youngboss1024 thanks for the feedback! Ive gotta give Sudsy a try, there’s a few bars that have my attention. I pray for the best for him as well.

[@thepaintceo]

“Be a man… unless you’re a woman” 😂😂😂 love it lol glad you’re not an insane liberal

[@f8sac772]

Has anybody tried Charred Cinnamon

[@GenX_US_Marine]

I've tried a handful of these soaps and they are superior to Squatch. Sudsy, if you read these comments keep doing what your doing. Don't be like Squatch and have your quality go down the toilet. I loved Squatch at first, but not so much now. I have ditched squatch and I roll with Sudsy because of the quality of their soaps. My favorite Sudsy soap is Blueberries and Cream. It's a very good bar of soap.

[@randygonzalez1375]

Barbershop?

[@kammversus883]

Great video. For me, Petrified wood and honey's scent lasted very long. I would highly recommend that bar and Smoky mountain fog.

[@mikephilly6748]

Holy crap. Just placed the order 40 minutes ago (also pumpkin is back in stock) and they’ve already shipped. Yeah I think it took Squatch a week and a half to process my recent order

[@mikephilly6748]

Was given two free samples. Hunt camp and Blueberries & Cream. Really could not be happier with my experience with this company

[@statics1]

@@mikephilly6748 I wish I could buy some lol the shipping to the uk costs an unreal amount

[@Youngboss1024]

I will never buy Dr. Squatch ever again. I will also never buy Bearsville again. Both of their soaps are overrated and overpriced, the shipping is a joke and they don't make their own soaps. Dr. Squatch buys their soap wholesale from the Soap Guy, and Bearsville buys their soap wholesale from Adams in North Carolina, then sell them for major marked up prices. Sudsy Bear does everything right.

[@daltonrothchild6569]

Your too 4 are literally the exact four I plan on getting when I’m done with my current batch of Dr. Squatch. Also definitely down for a side by side ranking of every Sudsy and Squatch!

[@dbean5174]

You gotta get blueberries and cream while it’s in stock. Just got restocked!

[@azchulooutdoors]

I might get one since dr squatch scent doesn’t seem to stay on me

[@spongebobsquarepants11]

Hey Gary can you do a review on smoky mountain fog the reformulated.

[@sheesh5422]

When is the reformulatwd woody maple bourbon scent come out?

[@ceruleanclouds5871]

Thank you

[@Selfcustomfirearms]

Just got some sudsy bear soaps from your suggestions in a previous video. I've been using the fresh clean aloe and I love it.

[@jonah12705]

Thanks for the review. After watching I placed an order for 13 bars…still waiting for it to ship 5 days later. I’ll update once they get in and I can compare them against Dr. Squatch.

[@Hondo34]

To me, darkside of the moon smells like a clean musky aftershave. I love it

[@gabethegamer9582]

I would like a bar that smells like a bonfire or something burning. Does anyone have any suggestions

[@Gary828]

Jurassic Earth smells like ashes...great quality bar, but I hate the scent, which is why it's ranked last place.

[@graphixity]

"Fireside" from Dapper Yankee smells exactly like you just came in from a camp fire and its the smell left on your clothes after the fire

[@Odinarcade00]

Duke cannon “campfire” or “big bandit”

[@carpediem7654]

Guys u can make these soaps as good if not better at home. Stop overspending on these soaps.

[@foowa6900]

Make a video showing us how to do it then

[@carpediem7654]

@@foowa6900 plenty of videos out there

[@foowa6900]

​@@carpediem7654make a video if you doing it then

[@lemillion5980]

i dont think an amateur would do it better

[@matthewross2557]

Rank both !!! Lol

[@kingjames3488]

Good work Gary!