Ranking All 35 of my Pat McGrath Labs Eyeshadow Palettes! Vol. 3

[@alexandreaturcot8921]

The first mothership palette I bought was Decadence!!! I love the metallics! If you dont have mattes, I dont know what to say??? Midnight Sun was the 2nd Pat McGrath palette I bought (off Mercari), I love the color story! I have that Mothership and the limited edition MOTHERSHIP Divine Rose II (also BNIB off Mercari) and I am set with those motherships. I would love the Subliminal, the 1st one but I can't wait. Great Rankings!! P.S. I love how makeup brought you and Beuaty and the Frizz together. Makeup is what brought me to all of you wonderful KZbin creators and beautiful, strong women to have to watch, enjoy and learn about makeup with. ❤😉

[@DrAshMakeup]

Decadence made me fall in love with Pat McGrath! I think I failed to say that about that palette. It was the palette that sealed the deal!

[@Kittichanlove]

Love a good ranking. I like that you update these rankings for us. And you look stunning. Hair, earrings, shadow, top, The whole look

[@DrAshMakeup]

Thank you, so much! It was time for an update! I didn’t expect Mothership X come thru and grab me like that but, it did!

[@tianiortiz8529]

Divine rose 2 is still my favorite mothership as well.

[@divadream]

1) I love, love your story on how you got into the PMG passion - I wish makeup could feel like that again! 2) Has anyone ever said you resemble the Bailey sisters, especially Halle?!

[@DrAshMakeup]

Really, no one has ever said that before! Hey, they’re too cute!

[@keishahudson487]

That’s exactly what I thought 😊

[@tarautubelover5903]

Thank you just started on my eyeshadow journey so I don't have any but wanted a few. I love the special shades that would be a factor in grabbing 1.

[@DrAshMakeup]

You are so welcome!

[@makeupnmedicine]

I just bought 2 of the mother ships ( 1 and 2 ) and I am so excited to get them. They will be my first PML and first real "luxury" eyeshadows... i cannot wait. It makes sense that I am drawn to 1 and 2 because the colors make me nostalgic for the timeframe they released I guess!

[@DrAshMakeup]

I hope you enjoy them! I have videos on both of those palettes. PMGL truly makes some amazing formulas.

[@DrAshMakeup]

Also Mothership I is a silent sleeper!

[@sharon9256]

I just bought my first motherships

[@Lynnonymous]

So funny! I was also adamant I would never spend $125 on a palette or $60ish on a quad! But now, I don't even care. If it's on sale, great, if not, I'll buy it anyways. I have about 30 quads, 6-pans, and Motherships. I have all the Motherships, but am missing a few quads and 6-pans. I have both Star Wars collections and pink packaging limited editions. I'm a total collector. 😂😂 I'm excited to see your ranking! I appreciate your time, this had to be a lot of work! Oh and happy Sunday!!

[@DrAshMakeup]

When I tell you I wasn’t going to ever fall into the hype I wasn’t! At that time I don’t even know you could call it hype! I loved makeup but, just couldn’t see myself buying a palette that cost that much! Now, just throw it in the bag!

[@Lynnonymous]

@Dr. Ash & her Makeup Same!!! So much the same LOL! Once you try the higher quality there's no going back haha! Especially Pat McGrath, special products for sure. I still kind of gasp at the price but not even remotely enough to stop myself. 🤣🤣

[@loytoco]

The first time I saw a pic of Midnight Sun I went "wow", loudly. It is my absolute favourite palette by PML, ad one of my two favourites overall. I just love it.

[@akspov]

I enjoyed watching this! My only surprise was Mothership X being so high up. But that VR Sextacy shade alone is top tier. In thinking about my own collection, I’m surprised that I have over 20. It wasn’t that long ago when I said I would never pay these prices for make up.

[@DrAshMakeup]

I think we all fell in that boat when it comes to Pat McGrath! I had so much fun with Mothership X it really shocked me but, I feel confident about that ranking!

[@Jin04115]

I have yet have not found any eye pallettes that come close to PM pallettes. The pigments and staying power on darker skin are remarkable. Too bad my aging and creased up eyelids make it harder to work with.

[@DrAshMakeup]

The pigment is amazing and the staying power for sure! Just use a good primer and maybe some glitter glue for the shimmers.

[@MakeupLoverInfinite]

The Speed with which I clicked on the video….. I even forgot to get snacks haha.

[@DrAshMakeup]

🤣🤣🤣

[@sparklingsia7279]

Thank you for this❤ I’m a huge PMG-fan and it’s always interesting to hear other peoples point of view. I also love the Midnight sun palette and don’t really understand why other people didn’t love it😂 (it’s actually one of my all time favorite Motherships). I do absolutely love the Fleur Fantasia quad, but I’m very (VERY) fair, so for me it’s amazing to finally get a shadow from PMG that I can use as a transition shade😂

[@DrAshMakeup]

You’re so welcome! I have previous videos ranking her whole collection as well when it was smaller and less released. People really hated Mothership VI until about 2020.

[@kellygarland63]

I’m so envious of your eyelid real estate! I’ve got about 1/3 of what you’re blessed with! Lucky lady! No wonder you love your eyeshadows!

[@DrAshMakeup]

Awww! Thank you, so much! The funny thing is I don’t think I have great real estate!

[@melina_m_makeup]

I'm sooo here for this!! Love me a PM ranking video!! I haven't counted all my PM palettes but somewhere near 35 or so. I am the same , I just have to have them! I agree on the mega mothership Celestial Nirvana with those colorful mattes! I even picked up a 2nd palette at TJMaxx last week for $34.99. I dnt know why there is so much hate on that palette, it is sooo good! The shimmers , I do wish were more colorful. Like a shimmery sparkly lavendar, turquoise green, or even a nice duochrome in it. I usually pair it with other palettes. But the mattes are chef's kiss 💋! My top 5 would be 1. Mothership 1 Subliminal 2.) Mothership 3 Subversive 3.) Mothership 6 Midnight Sun 4.) Mega mothership Celestial Divinity 5.) Nocturnal Nirvana My least favorite is Bronze Borealis. When she re-released it, 2 of the shades are literally identical compared to the first release. Maybe I got a dud but it's so disappointing.

[@DrAshMakeup]

So I think the problem with Nirvana is the shimmers aren’t the greatest. I think she should’ve pushed the limits with them for sure. However, the looks are endless when you mash it up with other Motherships.

[@dubsbeautydiary]

I loved this video! Rankings are one of my favorites to watch. Thanks for sharing!!!

[@DrAshMakeup]

Thank you!!!

[@beautyisforfun5479]

I got both of those little quints from holiday but skipped the Star Wars ones. It sounds like they have that similar super molten metallic formula that goes on forever. I really do like both of them that I got. I don’t think I can pick a favorite but maybe midnight sun and voyeuristic vixen.

[@DrAshMakeup]

Those are some really great choices as favorites! You just can’t go wrong.

[@Jin04115]

Mother's hip V must be in the top 5.

[@iamjamila]

First kudos to you for ranking all your palettes…I don’t think I could do it 😅

[@DrAshMakeup]

I had to lay them all out on the kitchen table

[@KaliKali-hv9bt]

❤❤❤ thank you for this

[@raaziabanks2552]

Such a relatable story of how you got into PML. I was the same and for years I had stopped buying make up…..until I bought Divine rose 2 on sale and oh men…it was love at first sight. The compliments I received on using the palette! 😊😊 it was a slippery slope from there….

[@DrAshMakeup]

Thanks!!! Exactly, I just became hooked!

[@lisanutini5183]

My favorite is Mothership I Subliminal. Yes for my very dark brown eyes 😀

[@DrAshMakeup]

It’s so stunning!

[@dkycutie78]

Such a great video!

[@DrAshMakeup]

Thank you, so much!

[@luvsmakeup]

OMG you are making me want to buy palettes I thought I didn't want! Love the video and that you ranked the entire collection in the order of your true loves. I liked not knowing what type of palette was coming up next!

[@DrAshMakeup]

Thank you, so much! That’s what’s so great about it! A quad can outdo a Mothership!

[@welikegoodies]

Great video 🎉👏that sith seduction 5 pan is my current go to and I have all of the motherships. She did something extra with that little 5 pan. I want a back up 😂

[@sandyandchance]

💚 I'm really enjoying all the stories you included.

[@DrAshMakeup]

Thank you, I think it adds value to the ranking.

[@ruthgarza1967]

Ranking palettes ? Yes, yes, yeah, yeah 🤩🤩😃😃😃😍😍😍

[@DrAshMakeup]

🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾💃🏽💃🏽💃🏽💃🏽

[@hermanlane9846]

This was such a good one! Had my nice small pot of tea with snacks while enjoying the countdown. Ok,. Since I didn't see the previous ranking,the number one was a surprise. Also I was surprised at how high Motherships X placed. I don't have any of the Motherships because I didn't know which was best for me. I need to take a deep dive and watch more videos on them. I do have a quad and a few quintsa dthe Las two holiday palettes as well as a few small palettes like midnight voyage. I think the Motherships that may be right for me are: Subversive, Huetopian Dreams, and Decadence. Divine Rose II has now caught my eye because of you. These more saturated colorful ones would compliment my deep rich skin tone. I also appreciate how the quads were integrated as I saw a few I need to keep my eye out for. I missed Nocturnal Nirvana when it popped up during the last sale. I didn't get it because I couldnt figure out what other products I wanted to get the 30% off so I had to let her go.😅. I feel more confident about selecting the quads and quints than the Motherships. I like the three sextups (🤣if you have taken Latin) recently received but they don't get included in the sale so I'll have to wait and see if they are ever around in a sale. I like PMLs formulas but I don't feel FOMO because of all the crazy glittery Indie brands I experi need before dipping my toes into the PML beauty fountain.

[@DrAshMakeup]

I’m so glad you enjoyed the video. At this point she runs so many sales you can def grab on sale. I love Mothership X so much and I’ve been having a lot of fun using it on myself and friends/family. I don’t think you can go wrong with Divine Rose II.

[@misswhite2rose]

Amazing ranking 😊😊

[@DrAshMakeup]

Thank you!!

[@melindahall8936]

Dr pepper..I'm ready.❤❤

[@DrAshMakeup]

Yassssss!!!! Hey!!!! 💜💜💜

[@katrenashaw869]

I want the decadence palette so bad! I wasn’t even aware of Pat until like 2-3 years ago! I would say that as of right now my favorite is huetopian dream

[@DrAshMakeup]

Decadence is so gorgeous!

[@rabbiroz3806]

I think I have 35 as well! But I ordered Divine Bronze and I will be picking up the new mini six pan! I can’t wait to see your ranking! Wow. Interstellar Icon is in my top three!

[@DrAshMakeup]

Stay tuned! I will be posting something about the mini six pan! If you have 35 pallets you have those shades. Unless you just really want it for travel purposes.

[@flytjsosweet]

A consensus I have noticed from watching your PM videos is which for the cost is ridiculous is how many times in a pallet a lot of the shades look a like. In maybe one or two pallets that can happen but in like 30 pallets for 65 to 125 dollars she should not be repeating and making colors that close to each other in the same pallet.

[@DrAshMakeup]

So true! That’s where our love hate relationship comes in! Ready for a switch up!

[@tonjamarshall9679]

Have ever noticed that a lot of other high-end brands repeat themselves?

[@LocMaiden]

29:13🖤 sums up my relationship with makeup in general 🥹😭😂😂😂

[@DrAshMakeup]

💸💸💸💸💸 I had to look back!

[@QueerBones]

Midnight sun is tied with subliminal for my #1

[@DrAshMakeup]

Great choices!

[@kellygarland63]

Seems to me Pat McGrath really shines on brown and black skin. So so beautiful on women of color !!

[@DrAshMakeup]

Thank you, so much!

[@wendymccullough3974]

@@DrAshMakeup I think her shadows etc look good on all skin colors. She, Pat is amazing!

[@donnareed73]

I bought my first PML Holiday 2021 and I have 28 the only ones I don’t have are the ones that are not available anymore that little mini and the all matte one. I might pick up the mini that’s coming out if Sephora hasn’t sold out during their sale but I doubt I get the all matte

[@DrAshMakeup]

You got busy as soon as you tried her! 28 that’s impressive.

[@GeeSmith333]

I don't own any of the mother-ships but huetopian dreams haunts my dreams. I think I'm going to grab the lunar quad as well. I've done so well not buying things this year.

[@DrAshMakeup]

That’s awesome! I haven’t done too bad but then I have lol! Definitely wait for a sale to get the palette.

[@LocMaiden]

Drink in hand🖤I'm ready

[@DrAshMakeup]

🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾

[@KaliKali-hv9bt]

More videos please?❤❤❤

[@DrAshMakeup]

Yes!!! I have so many videos check my whole channel out! Thank you! I do have a whole PMGL playlist as well

[@candycane6203]

Excellent 🌸🌹🎪💯✅🎪🍿🖍️⭐️

[@DrAshMakeup]

Thank you!!!!! I had a lot of fun doing this!

[@AWW2430]

Moonlit seduction is that girl!

[@DrAshMakeup]

Yes!!!

[@Muslimah33]

Do you wear eyeshadow to work?

[@DrAshMakeup]

Yes!!!!

[@DrAshMakeup]

If you catch my Palette Rotation series that’s what I’m wearing going out and about and to work.

[@candypie939]

You can't do a ranking without all of them 😢

[@DrAshMakeup]

Sorry, but not grabbing the rest