Ranking ALL Doctor Who Companions!

Watch myself and Harry (‪@HudsonMedia‬) debate who are the BEST and WORST #DoctorWho Companions, from Susan Foreman to Dan Lewis!
0:00-0:34 - INTRO
0:34-4:24 - 1ST DOCTOR
4:24-6:30 - 2ND DOCTOR
6:30-8:54 - 3RD DOCTOR
8:54-10:16 - 4TH DOCTOR
10:16-11:56 - 5TH DOCTOR
11:56-13:08 - 6TH/7TH DOCTORS
13:08-14:30 - 8TH DOCTOR
14:30-16:13 - 9TH DOCTOR
16:13-16:56 - GEMMA'S THOUGHTS
16:56-18:18 - 10TH DOCTOR
18:18-19:41 - 11TH DOCTOR
19:41-20:23 - 12TH DOCTOR
20:23-21:23 - 13TH DOCTOR
21:23-24:05 - FINAL THOUGHTS
Chicken Casanova - 2023

[@Electrobolt913]

It would be interesting to see you do maybe a Doctors/Masters tier list next 👀

[@DoctorWhoReeves]

We’ve done a Doctor ranking over on Hudson Media’s channel! But Masters would be a fun one…

[@hollymatton474]

To be fair I surprisingly agree with all of them! My favourite classic companions are sarah jane and ace. The new who era companions are the ones I started with and they're all quite different. Rose was my first companion so I do admit to having a soft spot for her, despite her faults. Martha and bill were underrated and donna noble is the best! I didn't like amy much or rory to be honest, clara wasn't great but I did find her more relatable than amy. Yas, ryan and graham were pretty terrible companions, and Dan's story was just cut short! 😂 Can't wait to see donna's daughter rose in the 60th anniversary specials, and ruby sunday looks like she's going to be a great companion! Great video! 😊😊

[@DoctorWhoReeves]

We'll have to re-visit this in a couple years!

[@MatthewCYN15]

Classic Who fav companions: Sarah Jane, Ace, Leela, Jo Grant, Molly O'Sullivan New Who fav companions: Martha, Clara, Bill, Dan, Graham, Christina

[@SamyulDavis]

Huge ben/polly fan. The books help a bit, but their dynamic is great fun from War Machines/Smugglers alone.

[@DoctorWhoReeves]

Ah yeah I'm not big in the expanded media. I'll keep those TV stories in mind for a watch though!

[@British.diabetic]

tbh im so sad how low dodo is lol, i absolutely love her. shes my fav 60s companion

[@DoctorWhoReeves]

I’ll have to check out more Dodo stories

[@abby4590lohan]

You forgot turlogh the 5th doctors companion

[@DoctorWhoReeves]

I honestly don’t know how we did that 😆 He wouldn’t have ranked very high tbf

[@ttproductions23]

I feel called out. But yes Jack i agree with you about Charley 🙈

[@DoctorWhoReeves]

I HAD to argue for Charley!

[@ttproductions23]

Also Nyssa is gods tier hahaha😅

[@DoctorWhoReeves]

I expect you and Josh Snares with guns outside my flat any day now XD

[@anthonytremaine2821]

I loved Graham I would have put him way higher 😊 also an entire spin off with Rory? Be still my beating heart 😍😍 great video guys 😁 x

[@DoctorWhoReeves]

Graham is a good companion hampered by a mostly weak couple series IMO. And YES RORY SPIN OFF BABYYYYY!

[@anthonytremaine2821]

@@DoctorWhoReeves I'd love that Rory always has a special place in my heart 😍. I also really liked Clara I just admit 😁

[@DoctorWhoReeves]

Gotta love Arthur Darvills performance, especially as it went on. And ehhhhh Victorian Clara always has my heart, never will forgive Moff!

[@TheLegacyofHitchcock]

12:28 Out of curiosity, how would you rate Mel now? I still wouldn’t say that she’s the greatest character ever, but I do think that the Series 14 finale did a lot to improve Mel, as messy as a lot of that episode was IMO. Gone was the glass shattering screaming, and in its place was someone confident, capable and able to get the Doctor to rise out of his self-punishment. Of all the things I expected from RTD2, redemption for Bonnie Langford was not one of them.

[@DoctorWhoReeves]

@@TheLegacyofHitchcock I did really enjoy her in the finale and The Giggle, so I don’t know exactly where she’d go BUT she’d deffo be higher

[@regspanglesdustbin8002]

Did you forget Turlough?

[@DoctorWhoReeves]

mmmmmmaybe

[@regspanglesdustbin8002]

@@DoctorWhoReeves where would you have ranked him?

[@DoctorWhoReeves]

@@regspanglesdustbin8002 Ya know, I'm not sure! Probably in the middle or bottom as I'm not to versed in him as a companion

[@regspanglesdustbin8002]

@@DoctorWhoReeves that's probably right, I think.

[@MrPcgamer4ever]

You don't like Clara. Unsubbed. Im just joking I appreciate your opinion 🙂. She is my favourite companion. Victorian Clara should have been his companion.

[@DoctorWhoReeves]

Victorian Clara best Clara!

[@BriZ3l21]

@@DoctorWhoReeves I bet you know nothing about the other splinters

[@DoctorWhoReeves]

@@BriZ3l21 I know about all splinters! Those wooden buggers have pierced me multiple times over the years!

[@BriZ3l21]

@@DoctorWhoReeves well , if it was a pierce in the heart u would have been dead , thx god you are not 😂

[@halfmoons9439]

Captain Jack deserves S how could you do this to me?

[@DoctorWhoReeves]

And I’d do it again!!

[@AuroraButterflyx]

Good ranking although Ryan deserves F, he is so unemotional 😅😅. Funny video however.

[@DoctorWhoReeves]

Yeah neither of us ever liked Ryan, but Harry INSISTS! XD He can't help find him unintentionally hilarious

[@AuroraButterflyx]

@@DoctorWhoReeves in that regrads, then yes he goes in S tier for making me cringe every time XD, and even then i still like Jodie era :).

[@ttproductions23]

Is a big polly stan.........🙈

[@DoctorWhoReeves]

"POLLY"

[@greghawkins59]

If I ever watch the classic era imma go into it with so many predispositions

[@DoctorWhoReeves]

I can only apologize XD But also, if you ever watch a Ben/Polly ep I do hope you just think "POLLYYYY!"

[@greghawkins59]

@@DoctorWhoReeves and your little bottom bit

[@DoctorWhoReeves]

@@greghawkins59 Mmm. Good..

[@greghawkins59]

@@DoctorWhoReeves one of the more unsual things I've said to a stranger on the Internet

[@greendiamond2604]

Rip William Russell. o7

[@DoctorWhoReeves]

Absolute legend 🤘

[@WhovianMG]

Dabbing is a little out of date, but it's fine. I'll say more soon. EDIT 1: I take offense to K9 being lower than A-B. EDIT 2: For some reason, I like Lalla's version better than Mary Tamm's. However, it's probably because I know more of Lalla's version than when Mary Tamm portrayed Romana, because I haven't seen enough of when she portrayed Romana. EDIT 3: Adric was bland. The only important thing he said was "we said goodbye to Romana at the gate". Seriously! EDIT 4: Peri is quite a bland character and Mel may have been screamy, but did not have enough screentime. EDIT 5: Amy is a B, I agree with River and Rory is alright. Clara is a between a B and F. EDIT 6: What's her last name? Pots? You mean 𝙋𝙤𝙩𝙩𝙨? EDIT 7: Nardole is between A and B to me.

[@DoctorWhoReeves]

Thanks for all the edits 😄 Always like seeing what folks had to say with this. However dabbing is STILL COOL DAMMIT!

[@greghawkins59]

Gotta stand by the dab, nothing like a cheeky outdated reference

[@DoctorWhoReeves]

@@greghawkins59 Sums me up

[@MarkWardReacts]

I am a big Ben and Polly fan!! love their interplay, particularly in The War Machines and I prefer them both to Jamie... sorry not sorry. :D

[@DoctorWhoReeves]

I’ll have to check out The War Machines! Although that does sound like SACRILEGE! 😆

[@MarkWardReacts]

@@DoctorWhoReeves I think Polly and Ben are both done massively dirty by missing episodes (I know Jamie is too, but I find his accent so annoying, and I literally cannot stand Victoria on screen). I’m good with Zoe though.

[@Lucia-ni4oz]

Where’s handles?

[@DoctorWhoReeves]

In HELL

[@ParakoEPC]

This better be in DWR 🔫

[@DoctorWhoReeves]

Not everything is Doctor Who Road, you're OBSESSED!

[@ParakoEPC]

@@DoctorWhoReeves I’m talking about the new guy, This!

[@DoctorWhoReeves]

@@ParakoEPC oh 😆 I wish me and Harry could film together more often but sadly he lives a few hours away 🥲 But we’ve got a couple more vids that we filmed coming out over the next couple weeks!

[@LucyMac94]

Donna 💜

[@DoctorWhoReeves]

Donne will ALWAYS be Top Tier. Now put Baby Harry to bed!

[@MarkWardReacts]

Clara below Katarina and Sara Kingdom... :D

[@DoctorWhoReeves]

Coming at ya with the HOT TAKES

[@MarkWardReacts]

@@DoctorWhoReeves lolz!

[@stuffnotlike]

Liz is GOAT

[@DoctorWhoReeves]

100%

[@abigailguessis1218]

Susan did nothing but hurt her ankle and complain, she adds nothing

[@DoctorWhoReeves]

I think you’re forgetting the outstanding moment she yelled “GRANDFATHER” Iconic

[@abigailguessis1218]

@@DoctorWhoReeves 😂, although I genuinely think that doctor who have never had a better tardis team, with 3 companions people in it, they all grow and have good characters whilst not being useless

[@LucyliciousDoccyWho]

lol jamie is a B tho

[@DoctorWhoReeves]

S tier purely for “LOOK AT THE SIZE OF THAT THING DOCTOR!”

[@LucyliciousDoccyWho]

@@DoctorWhoReeves I'll change my opinion if I ever see them kiss

[@LucyliciousDoccyWho]

@@DoctorWhoReeves or fuck, I'm not picky

[@DoctorWhoReeves]

@@LucyliciousDoccyWho Can’t argue with that!