Ranking all my Leather Bags

[@robertlarsen6516]

I can’t get over how much I appreciate your videos, perspective, and thoughtful honest reviews. That was as close to gushing as I get.

[@CarlMurawski]

Hahahaha well I really appreciate that!!

[@urielcohen5221]

You all prolly dont care at all but does someone know a way to get back into an instagram account?? I stupidly lost my password. I love any tips you can offer me!

[@jamisonfelix8138]

@Uriel Cohen Instablaster :)

[@jonathanmcphail5254]

I’ve seen your review of the Filson brand and could not agree more. Living in MS, I can not justify much of their wool material. Simply would not get enough use. However, i purchased that briefcase for grad school in 2010. Since that day, it has been used almost every single day. It’s been thrown on so many passenger seats, floorboards, and overhead compartments that I should be embarrassed. I condition the leather once a year. The thing simply will not quit! Only thing that makes it look used is the blue indigo from my jeans. It’s truly a “Buy once. Cry once” piece.

[@fossilimprint2954]

I thoroughly enjoyed your many bags. That Moose Brand bag at the end, wow.

[@mrk131324]

Frequent traveler business consultant here: After cycling through many bags, I have settled for Tumi. Their high end stuff with ballistic nylon and leather details. The thing with leather bag is: a) they are heavy, when you have to travers Shanghai airport is a hurry, that matters, b) their vintage design is from an age before air travel and notebooks and thus they are not actually designed for that use case. Sitting in a middle seat in a cramped airplane and having to access your gear, is when the right bags shines. Or having 5 min. before boarding and being able to finish a document without having to fiddle with latches to get your stuff. There are stylish accessories and there are working utilities, finding the sweet spot between these two, is what picking a bag is all about. For my luggage I do prefer a weekender duffle (also Tumi Townhouse) over a cabin trolly, you are just more agile and especially on trains (I‘m from Europe) you move so much faster and hassle free. If you want to go with a leather briefcase, cut the cheap options and go directly to Swaine in London and commission one to your specification.

[@categoricus]

Also a frequent flier, mostly international, also highly recommend Tumi.

[@golfinguru11]

Agree that Swaine makes the best briefcases in the world, but like you said - there are very limited use cases for them today, and they don’t really belong in an airport. Also, if you want Made in USA and don’t mind a more simple look, Frank Clegg is nearly as good as Swaine for about half the price.

[@kfung4]

OMG, I have to stop watching your video...you made me want to purchase something every months

[@CarlMurawski]

Hahaha, I’m sorry!!!

[@oneeyeman6258]

I've been using a Filson Sportsman's Bag as my every day gym bag for years. Other than the bottom being dirty, it still looks and functions as new. I'm sure one of my grandchildren will enjoy it after I'm gone. And as far as Messenger Bags go, my Satchel and Page is the bomb. Substantial Veg tanned leather, no zippers to fail, simple minimalist design, and will most likely last forever. Every time I use it, it gets a little more beat up and looks better for it. Keep up the good work Carl; love your videos.

[@saviourofrockandroll]

Absolutely love the Moose Heirloom Messenger! I've carried the original for the last four years and you're right, that one is the top of the heap. The only minor thing I'd change on the Heirloom 2 is that I would prefer the original carry handle design. In my opinion, I'd prefer the handle on the 'body side' of the bag. Having it attached to the top requires latching the flap when lifting/moving the bag, whereas on the older design I could move the bag around the room without having to fully close it if I just needed to quickly retrieve something.

[@DHill-qn8us]

Hey Carl, nice vid, and I knew the Moose Brand Messenger II was going to be your top choice. I purchased that bag this summer based, in part, on your initial review some months ago. I use this bag everyday, and it is as functional and durable as it is beautiful. It’s an attention grabber.

[@CarlMurawski]

Nice!!! It’s a beauty for sure.

[@thecapone45]

An hour long video on leather bags? Yes!? I wouldn’t mind that at all! 😅

[@paulafigueroa1573]

I love this review. You just consider everything and nothing is missing. Thanks 🙏🏻

[@Dortch3]

You have great taste Carl...can't fault your choices here, for you do get what you pay for. I am impressed with the Moose Messenger....thanks for introducing that one to me. Carl Friedrik makes a nice weekend bag, and roughly half the price of FC...so perhaps not an apple to apple comparison, yet certainly worth your time to review to see how it stacks up.

[@limjazzdedragonheryadi1290]

I have several bags like your Basader Minimal Messenger...and I added top handle to them. The handle is added by rivet at the top back...like CRAVAR. I have CRAVAR FC too...sure it is a wonderfull bag. Having 3 bags from CRAVAR, one of the them is Daypack type (backpack). Filson 256...just about 2 weeks with me...I think, no matter what canvas, the strongest canvas it still a canvas, not leather. People just seeing the brand... I always pleasure watching your video...thanks Carl

[@cravarbags]

Carl, thanks for including your F.C. in the roundup, I'd like to drop in quick to thank Oom Lim here for his awesome support.

[@SaadonAksah]

They are all lovely and it does help to form your decision on the type of bag to buy! 👍

[@henryho2293]

Great shirt Carl!

[@gregduric5638]

Currently using the Musette Gaston bag from Bleu de Chauffe. Love the canvas material. It too only has one big pocket but that works for me since I like to organize my things in smaller bags and pouches. It’s bags within a bag lol. Love the look of it too. It’s ruggedly refined. Can take it hiking but also to the shop or the cafe and it doesn’t look out of place!

[@IdeaStudioBKK]

Nice collection, Carl.

[@CarlMurawski]

Thank you!

[@Murhamdilah]

I have the small tanned Leathershop heirloom messenger 2. I really love the look and material of the bag. It is very structural to protect the inside and surprisingly lighter than it looks. My only wish was that it could be much smaller than the medium which is only one inch bigger at 16 inch wide. I use it daily as my office bag. My students love it.

[@shacorraboyd9026]

Thank you for posting a video on leather bags. ☺ Needed help on what I should choose for college.

[@CarlMurawski]

Glad it was helpful!

[@karimkhan7140]

I would like to see your review of the Filson Dawson Leather Briefcase.

[@cgranero1]

I love my Cravar bag, which I got on your recommendation. It's been great.

[@cravarbags]

Hey Chris, so happy you're pleased with your Cravar bag.

[@garrettbredell1314]

Are your Satchel & Page bags holding up well?

[@CarlMurawski]

Sadly I don’t have them anymore. Thinning out the collection meant some had to go. They were fantastic though.

[@StarWarriorMusic]

just gonna stick with my Canyon Outback bag i got at the thrft shop a couple years ago. wish it wasn't black but it is super solid and looks professional. not bad for 6 bucks! great video!

[@tedbaeseman1619]

You should make a video about what your edc (every day carry) is and what you use and why you have the thing you have in your pockets/bag love the videos keep up the good work

[@CarlMurawski]

Thanks for the idea! I've done this before but I really need to make an update.

[@VuNguyen-ri7vg]

May I ask whether the Heirloom Messenger 2 is in Large or Medium size? Will the Large be too big?

[@jovianleong4651]

I’ve been looking for a messenger bag for years now…none of it settles for me, until bolts briefcase by water field…Man love that bag have been using it ever since

[@fjlbanks]

Beautiful bags and another great video, Carl. A heads up: your timestamps say “Cuscom hide”.

[@CarlMurawski]

Thank you!!! I’ll fix that

[@Aggnog]

I bought a ruitertassen tan briefcase last month and although it is made in all the right ways, the leather is not at all what I expected. The only leather items I had before were shoes and quite a few pairs, I was used to leather that has some heft but is also pliable with some bounce. The veg tan leather of the briefcase was much lighter in weight and pretty stiff, despite being thicker. I haven't seen them in any recent reviews but there was a review a few years ago on this channel, the products are pretty much the same. Just something to consider if anyone is looking for more options.

[@CarlMurawski]

Yes! That’s vegetable tanned leather for you. It’s like leather cardboard at first but it just get better and better over time.

[@crochet_the_pain_away]

SERGUIO ROGETTI makes absolutely gorgeous leather work bags! I have a vegetable-tanned, full-grain leather messenger satchel with a zipper closure and a buckle closure, which is very convenient for those who commute on foot more than on wheels. It's roughly 15 inches wide and 13 inches tall. I love it because it has three cavern pockets on the inside, a zipper pocket both inside the bag and outside on the back, and a small buckle pocket on the front. I believe it was roughly $100, and I could get my name branded on the bottom corner of it.

[@olumsezbey]

I wish you would have brought up the Ruitertassen bag. The Professor Backpack II has been my dream bag for some time now. I know it’s under $400, but it’s an expense that hard to justify with a low budget.

[@imtiakumpongen3497]

What do you think about wrist bags or fanny bags

[@georgebulbakwa9017]

Hey Carl, ever come across Mahi Leather? I'm kinda curious if their stuff is any good considering how cheap their price point is.

[@CarlMurawski]

I’ve heard of them, but never had a chance to try them.

[@susmaryjose]

Unfortunately I purchased a bag from Mahi Leather. I certainly got what I paid for. It’s very cheaply constructed.

[@JM-ke1xm]

Wondering if you’ve had Saddleback Leather and Colonel Littleton products? They definitely should be on your list as super premium options. Saddleback’s catchphrase: Stuff your kids will fight over!

[@chukzombi]

my mom likes that moosebrand purse you got there. :)

[@justanut]

Will u be getting the Moose Business Briefcase 2 to review? I’m torn between that and the Heirloom Messenger 2..

[@brad1574]

My Carl Friedrik weekender stays in a box shape which is my favorite feature.

[@CarlMurawski]

That is the best feature.

[@adamunruh3209]

Carl reminds me of my PE teacher from school named Robin Roberts. Mr. Roberts was awesome I miss that guy.

[@yamanashi1534]

Hey Carl, did you pick the small or the medium size for moosebrand messenger. I got a Lenovo X1 carbon the I wanna fit. Thank you 🥂

[@bigvisk1125]

ive been enjoying the satchel and page brief case (well i was before covid, i havent had to go to the office since end of march 2020) and duffle. i need another duffle and have been thinking of going up to the frank clegg but the satchel and page is so nice and wears in so nice i might just get the zippered version (as i have a non zippered version now).

[@sherwin4ever]

Leather bags are pricey so before I buy anything I usually check which part would be the weakest part, if it deserves a cotton/canvas/leather for that part, how it will look when it's worn out, will its handle ruin/deform its look or wrinkle it, does that bag design look better with napa/veg tanned leather/oiled leather.

[@mathurinkerbouchard8931]

I like the Cravar FC and the Heirloom Messenger Bag 11

[@ashy812a]

Just wondering if its better if these bags are better with an interior lining of some type bc I heard something about leather interior but alot of these bag look like a single layer of leather throughout without anything to protect the it from coffee spills etc

[@BadMunkey]

The frank clegg siganture bag looks alot like the Von Baer Weekender bag (or vice versa). Thoughts?

[@sherwin4ever]

I'm just curious @Carl Murawski in case you wanted a custom leather bag. Which one would you prefer in the long run the soft buttery Napa leather or the stiff often boxy vegetable tanned leather?

[@KB1.1]

I noticed that you did not like the leather in the front flap supporting the load of the bleu de chauffe - isn’t it the same case in the moose brand? Thanks

[@CarlMurawski]

It is, but the Moosebrand leather is crazy thick. It’s easily three times the thickness, almost like harness leather

[@petercuevas2184]

Land Leather Collection what do you think?

[@ibrahimadiallo7444]

I appreciate this review. Thank you 😁

[@CarlMurawski]

Glad it was helpful!

[@curtischen8440]

In a nutshell, what is your opposition to Saddleback Leather based upon? I had bought a number of them and have lost interest... And you're introducing Moose Leather messenger 2 has me intrigued

[@CarlMurawski]

It’s mostly due to their weird price hike that came out of the blue and Dave’s ignorance on leather types. He’s selling Hondas at BMW prices.

[@jayandrew87]

Got any of those you want to sell? I won’t buy one new at those prices but I love the Gladstone closure design of the flight bag.

[@jbr2]

Great video, Carl! I really enjoyed this thorough review. Just wondering if you’ve ever had a Ghurka bag? I’d be curious to know how they compare.

[@CarlMurawski]

I haven't, but I'm really curious about the brand as well!

[@tkdman1999]

Hey Carl. Love the content! Is there any Canadian leather bags you can recommend?

[@markclaypole1573]

I don’t have any personal experience other than seeing in store, but Roots has a really nice leather collection. Made in Canada too I believe!

[@kennethboehnen271]

I was thinking about the Filson all leather brief vs the Nutsac Jones 15 inch. Any thought between those bags?

[@bradyhill6877]

I’m having a hard time deciding between the Filson and the Cravar. I think I prefer the cravar overall, but I haven’t seen any really long term reviews of them, so I’m afraid of dropping $400 on something that might not last. Any advice would be appreciated. Thanks

[@CarlMurawski]

Well I can tell you this: I used my FC for about a year and then gave it to my sister. She’s been carrying it daily and hasn’t had a problem at all. I don’t know if you’re looking for something longer term but that’s all I can offer.

[@bradyhill6877]

@@CarlMurawski Okay, good to know. I wasn't expecting a reply from the man himself, so thanks!

[@PaulAndBiscuit]

Buy the Filson, even Carl gave the Cravar away.

[@jerrysolonsmith8471]

No saddleback!?

[@Teromi]

I hope you’ve given that Custom Hide a nice brushing.

[@rawpilot84]

I'm interested in the olive color Frank Clegg duffle bag, but I can't find any videos or pictures of it other than the few on the website.

[@BlueJazzBoyNZ]

Why do Messenger Bags not have a replicable wear strip on their bottom .?

[@unboundcycling4288]

AMAZING BAGS

[@Will67267]

Great content! The Frank Clegg is beautiful, can you please tell me what shade of brown is the bag? Thanks.

[@ryanmcculloch]

I’d like to know as well. Looks like chestnut which is what I’m looking to buy.

[@paulcaskey]

Take a look at Frost River. Their stuff is all Made In America and is bulletproof. My brother bought one of their packs for his second trip to Afghanistan, then used it to travel all over Europe.

[@davidlandrum]

Basader posted on IG about four days ago. I believe they moved to Rhode Island. I love my Filson 256. I use it for work and it’s bomb proof.

[@luiscarrizales2533]

For the Frank Clegg duffel you showed was it the harness belting or soft tumbled leather?

[@CarlMurawski]

That’s the tumbled leather

[@gabek1381]

@@CarlMurawski Do you have enough time with both leathers to be able to compare and contrast them? I'm just curious.

[@FloridaFortify]

Awesome review 🙌🏽

[@EastofVictoriaPark]

Unfortunately the new Filson zippers aren't smooth like in the video.

[@CarlMurawski]

That’s what I’ve heard. The old Talon zippers are wonderful

[@PaulAndBiscuit]

@@CarlMurawskiI have a NOS Pullman with Filson zippers, it is extremely smooth compared to my new 256 also with Filson zippers.

[@TheChetOne]

Hey, Carl. I'm working on a leather bag project with Lithuanian artisans. How would you describe your perfect bag?

[@CarlMurawski]

For me it’s probably two compartments, big enough to fit a 15” laptop with a little wiggle room in case the actual computer is bigger. A few pockets inside but not too many, and a full width rear pocket. Leather strap and handle. Brass hardware, and vegetable tanned leather.

[@luatala8008]

The last one looks cheap and nasty. I wouldn’t get it even if it was free. What do you think of Rodd and Gunn satchels?

[@MuhammadAnwar-yn7fo]

You are doing Excellent.

[@splashpit]

I bought an Rod & Gunn messenger 20 years ago and have never felt the need to replace it , don’t find that not having a handle on top was ever a problem . I have lusted other messengers over the years like Col Littleton but I’m not the kind of person 5hat doubles up for the sake of it .

[@CarlMurawski]

Fair enough! Did you see that Col Littleton valet tray? It’s beautiful

[@endriksy1270]

Very nice collection! i really appreciate your videos and their contents! What about leather backpacks or canvas backpacks? Do you have any in your collection? Thanks a bunch! =)

[@aznlemonboy]

No more satchel and page diplomat?

[@rheeneek]

I know this is an older video but does anyone have any good recommendations for a good medium size leather backpack? I'm gonna watch the whole video. Tired welder asking because I destroy a regular bookbag every few months hanging my bookbag in the shop. Leather is the thing we wear for PPE so I thought hey maybe a backpack made of leather would work lol

[@storeroomjeff1]

Do you have any experience with Saddleback leather goods?

[@charlesbronson240]

Really overpriced but decently made.

[@kgsvv1975]

Hi, Are you interested in selling the bag that carried your 17 inch HP laptop? I think you said it was called custom hide 1945?

[@CarlMurawski]

I might be! Email me: [e-mail]

[@kaiserflame1673]

Have you ever heard of Vermilyea Pelle?

[@Elizabeth-pc2yx]

What about J.w Hulme??!! Or Duluth pack co! Woe to my soul, their classic American brands!

[@CarlMurawski]

They are, but I just don’t own any!

[@Elizabeth-pc2yx]

@@CarlMurawski you need to reevaluate your purchasing priorities! Classic before clegg! ;) Hulme American heritage leather is drool worthy.

[@mikecotw]

Hey Carl, great video. But no more Marlondo?

[@CarlMurawski]

Nope. I sold it! Otherwise I’d need a room dedicated to these things

[@mikecotw]

@@CarlMurawski both the briefcase and the backpack?

[@davidr.massey419]

If your in sales, and are presenting a new unique idea then one upping everyone is why you want a Floto 4050 messenger bag. I can just fit my complete 17" screen mobile workstation(engineers big laptop for 3D-Design) with all the necessary hook-up gear into a fleece lined sipper compartment. Other lined areas allow documents, and goodies. This is about five inches wide by 13" tall by 18" long. First impressions are everything when results matter. This is the "PRIMO" leather bag with silver plated key locking, hand, and shoulder straps.

[@drakesummers934]

I love my Colsenkeane 217 utility bag

[@savvylifestrategies9445]

Great video, Carl. I am a fan of the Allen Edmonds duffle and briefcase, both of which I own. They are exceptionally well made and attractive. The only downside is $$$. I am an author and speaker and consider their purchase an investment.

[@CarlMurawski]

Did you end up getting their collaboration with JW Hulme? They tend to license some really great products.

[@bngr_bngr]

My favorite bags are Italian leather bags. Followed by British bags then American bags.

[@tombosechannel3931]

Very cool guy

[@ericpatrick5542]

I Love To Have My Own Messages Bags. At Least Three.

[@mattmcgivern9308]

Another good video. Have you come across Jekyll & Hide leather products from South Africa? They have some really nice stuff - particularly like their Oxford range. I have now invested in several of their bags and wallets. Really nice gear.

[@frankrizzo7185]

I like my sachel and page Except it zips from the bottom- not useful when I am sitting in a train I cannot access it without putting it on my lap and opening it lkke a clamshell.

[@ChawnCrawley]

As much as I bash Filson for being near-total sellouts, my go-to bags for everything are their 24hr and 48hr waxed canvas bags. Not perfect but hard to beat.

[@Newspeak.]

They have slipped over the years for sure but all their made in the USA stuff like the mackinaw wool and tin cloth stuff is worth it in my opinion but it might not always be practical or worth it for some folks.

[@PaulAndBiscuit]

If something is truly great it will always attract hoards of bashers. Only Filson will get you a decent ROI, all these other bags are copies.

[@PaulAndBiscuit]

@@Newspeak.Filson bags have not “slipped” at all, values have more than doubled over the last 5 years.

[@PaulAndBiscuit]

These bags are good but only Filson bags tends to hold their value or even appreciate. If you want low depreciation or potential ROI stick with Filson and accept nothing else!

[@edwardvillate2112]

You SHOWED include COST of this BAGS !!!

[@nomsi4263]

I dont care about brands. I just want a duarble, good quality leather bag. So, thank you for the video.

[@CarlMurawski]

Thanks for watching!

[@MGK-qj9yb]

Ghurka is the best leather goods brand in the world. Period. I have no clue how frank klegg keeps getting talked about. Ghurka ghurka ghurka.

[@jeffhilbert31]

Maybe back in the 70's when Marley owned Ghurka... since then the company has been bought and sold 4 times. 2018 the company went bankrupt after a holdings company botched the brand. Now an investment banking firm owns the company. The brand went from being produced 100% USA, then they shut down the original factory, and switched production to China, Portugal, Spain. Never really told the clients this and clients like myself spent $2,000 on a bag made in China, not the USA. Clegg is one of the last remaining original bag designers out there and has been in USA since 1970. That is why he is talked about so much. PERIOD

[@PORTMIAMIMIKE]

@@jeffhilbert31 Whoaaaa.

[@estano9111]

saddleback?

[@BowtieJDP]

He hates the quality of modern saddleback since they lowered quality and raised prices a few years ago.

[@Mesergschmidt]

Jesus, the amount of ads throughout this video... is it like that on all the videos on this channel ? Maybe that's forced by google, I don't know, but I didn't have so many on other channels yet.

[@emersonlakra9771]

👏👏👏👏

[@Saw_Squatch]

Anymore I would still take Frost River over filson 7 days a week for both their quality and for what they as a company stand for compared to the sellout filson has become

[@johnharrington2400]

Frost river kills all those.

[@Glasshock]

Vermilyea Pelle!

[@davidphillips2675]

Check out Buffalo Jackson Trading Company

[@henryho2293]

I have a lot of stuffs from them, especially bags. 1 pilot bag, 1 duffel bag and a toiletry bag. Beside those, I also own a leather jacket. In my opinion, they're a great if not the best choice in that price range.

[@lamarfowler5319]

I have been looking at them for a briefcase for a few days. They seem like a good balance between quality and price.

[@henryho2293]

@@lamarfowler5319 get their bags during the sales is a good deal.

[@erin7995]

next time show the bags more with some b roll or some body shots. on the table cant really see the whole bag

[@Coltan999]

Your bags looks like you never really use them. :)

[@JohnDoe-ut3sz]

Frank Clegg is over price

[@chadbaker310]

You excluded Saddleback Leather. Thumbs down.👎

[@CarlMurawski]

I don’t own Saddleback… what do you want me to do?

[@chadbaker310]

@@CarlMurawski how can you do a ‘leather round up’ and not cover saddleback leather? That would be like doing a mobile phone round up and exclude Apple.🤷‍♂️

[@ucheanwuanwu786]

Please gift me one of your lovely bags...

[@georgebeck3992]

When you pass, and your stuff rots in a storage unit, and your family gives it t goodwill. Maybe you should check your materialistic lifestyle

[@CarlMurawski]

You do realize that I purchase these items for this channel right? Do you think Top Gear just has a problem collecting random cars?

[@uncles2000]

Show me on the leather bag where the capitalistic pig touched you. Seriously, this is a channel that reviews daily use personal items. Why did you expect?