Ranking All of the Eyeshadow Palettes I Tried in 2023!

[@tiffanykennedybeauty]

You're the only one who has taken the time to insert the arm swatches you have even for the bottom palettes. I appreciate your hard work for us!!!

[@MartinaLily]

Thank you! I'm glad it's helpful 💗💗

[@lynettefinnigan9540]

Yeah.. others I've watched haven't done any swatches. Even if it's just a couple..like "here's my fav 2 from this palette.... or these were the worst 2 and why it got a liw ranking.. you just want some evidence of the decision 👍👍

[@shannymac484]

I respect that you’re being honest and not placing Mothership XI higher just because it’s PMG. I feel like other channels trashed it when it came out and now it’s near the top in their year-end rankings…because of habit, loyalty, maybe they really changed their minds? Who knows.

[@MartinaLily]

I wish I had changed my mind honestly but I just can't get into it :( 💗💗

[@TracyD2]

Exactly I pay attention to these things as well. Especially when it comes to potentially spending my money based on other peoples opinions.

[@roxypaquette9501]

I was previously a die hard Pat fan but am so sick of the pink color stories that I didn’t initially buy Sunlit Seduction when it came out. I recently got it on sale and am so surprised at how much I like it. I would even rank it higher than a few of the other mothership palettes in terms of wearability. I still wish it was different but I can see people liking it more than they thought they would.

[@kiki29073]

@@shannymac484 my problem with Pat is that no palette is worth what she charges. She's not the only one I feel that way about. Same for OmcFord, Charlotte Tilbury the rest of the Luxury products.

[@kathleenmoortel5449]

Everything about you is stunning - earrings, eyeshadow, and your sweater. The colors are absolutely beautiful 🤩

[@MartinaLily]

Aww bless you, thank you! 💗💗

[@michellerocco5073]

Agreed 🤝 💯 Amen gorgeous ❤❤❤🙏

[@MartinaLily]

@@michellerocco5073 Aw thank you! 💗💗

[@ehgeffers]

I love the eyeshadow look here! I’m inspired to recreate!

[@karlieneporter4939]

Danessa Myricks is apparently bringing out replacement pans for her groundworks palette . Great vid as always, thank you for your honesty .

[@MartinaLily]

Yay! I am so glad she is cos I'm going to need them haha Thank you lovely 💗💗

[@kerriwright4593]

You should do a video comparing your top 5 palettes for the past couple years and rank them.

[@MartinaLily]

OMG brilliant idea, thank you so much! 💗💗

[@almostacrone8046]

Thank you for taking the time to do this 😊 I am wondering if next year the lights might be a little less? The palettes are kind of washed out. I know that the lighting is what it is because it makes the most sense for the majority of your content so I am not saying you should permanently change the lighting. Sorry if my comment is considered rude

[@MartinaLily]

Not rude at all! I love the feedback, thank you and I can do that for sure. I'm honestly never sure if they are too bright or too dark so super helpful haha 💗💗

[@cocoloco8922]

OMG this green goddess look is STUNNING girl! Wow 🤩

[@jennclayton]

Girrlll you need Indie makeup in your life!!! So much better then main stream!

[@JoeysMagGoth]

Thanks for taking the time to add swatches

[@tacoscatmya-3239]

I'm so glad you reviewed Isamaya palette since not so many KZbinrs did. Interesting enough, this palette is so comprehensive that I can't identify what's missing from this.

[@MartinaLily]

Agreed, it is such a good palette and so underrated! 💗💗

[@Bdhstl95]

I think Isamaya is replacing Pat McGrath since she has become so safe and boring

[@Observette]

I really like your taste in colors and formulas. It’s quite eclectic compared to other makeup people I watch! Loved this ranking and there are more than a few palettes you ranked highly I still have my eye on for a future “get it while on sale” purchase!

[@MartinaLily]

Thank you so much!! 💗💗

[@gwendolinehall1386]

This look absolutely slays! The eyes, earrings and top 💚💚💚 so stunning!

[@MartinaLily]

Thank you! 💗💗

[@deborahdelgado3193]

Loooved your ranking. You nailed it! Respect your honesty and sincere descriptions. I probably would rearrange a few palettes in your top 20 but still keep them within the 20 because they deserve it. You made me giggle with your number 1. I know many ppl brain exploded 😂 but, yes, you're 💯 correct. That DM's palette IS THAT amazing.

[@MartinaLily]

Aw thank you so much Deborah! Haha I know it's the most boring palette but it is sooo good haha 💗💗

[@victoreoleighlay]

I love your makeup look!! So pretty 😍

[@biebsoholic]

This is the first video I have ever seen from you and you seem so lovely! And WOW you swatched all the palettes and edited it in. I very appreciate it

[@cm20029442]

Totally agree with your number 1. I use this EVERY time I do my makeup. Such a clever pallet. Really the only extra thing I need is a little sparkle and I’m done. I use it for contour, bronzer, brows, clean up shade., eyeliner. I love it

[@HollieLambert]

Your eyes are so pretty! That greenish blue shimmer really brings out the color!

[@amykingston3133]

My favorite this year was the Byredo Remembrance Palette. I’m glad you mentioned it here. I’ll be first in line to buy whatever they put out next year. Such gorgeous formulas!

[@MartinaLily]

Such a good palette! I cannot wait to see their next one 💗💗

[@juliayk]

Wow you already hit pan on the danessa myricks palette! I think that's the first pan I've seen in the palette haha amazing. I am thinking of picking of the DM lightwork palette. The colours look gorgeous.

[@MartinaLily]

Haha yeah I seriously use it so much haha 💗💗

[@alexlyubenov5690]

I absolutely recommend it too. It's one of the few palettes i feel like are worth full price at any time.

[@TheRealAriLove]

Thank you for all the work you put into this video with showing us the swatches and all. The mothership pallete was such a bummer this year, you got that right. I didn’t pick it up. It’s usually one of my favorite releases from her. Hope the next one is better

[@MartinaLily]

I'm so glad you liked it, thank you! I am so hoping next years mothership is back to her normal formula 💗💗

[@catherinelynnfraser2001]

I put the Groundwork palette on the top of my purchases too. Have you tried using the Groundwork putty formula as your eyeshadow primer for the Lightworks V? That was a wonderful summary of a lot of hard work and discernment. Your swatches are next level and including them in your Yearend review was so very helpful and considerate. Happy New Year and all the best in 2024.

[@stephieshappymadness]

I absolutely love that you like colors and neutrals🎉😊 To me they're hand and hand🤎🖤🩶🤍💚💙🩵💜🧡🩷❤️🖤🤎🩶🤍

[@ella3796]

THE WAY MY JAW DROPPED AT 61 😂😂😂 but appreciate the consistent honesty ❤❤❤

[@alynnhirsch]

Also I use NYX Glitter Glue w/ Danessa Myricks Lightwork 5 and have no issues. I’m wearing it today. The primer will last you forever. Very affordable too!

[@MartinaLily]

Thank you I need to try that for sure! 💗💗

[@alexandreaturcot8921]

Thank you for your honesty. Especially with brands like Cosmic Brushes and Odens Eye. The talk on KZbin is that the "Muse" palette is to die for, and I don't understand why? Pretty color story, affordable depending on where you live, but the best quality? Not so sure. I appreciate your reviews and rankings! ❤

[@lisanutini5183]

Thanks so much for your hard work! A) I love to see someone’s personal ranking of eye shadow palettes. B) This reminds me of what I’ve got and inspires me to use them. C) I especially enjoyed Yucca and Jewels & Gem this year.

[@MartinaLily]

Thank you! And yes! Yucca and Jewels and Gem were soooo good! 💗💗

[@dawnbonome9056]

I respect your honesty on each and every pallet. No need to apologize. Good job 👍🏻 I hope you are feeling better. Merry Christmas and Happy New Year to you and your husband.

[@MartinaLily]

Thank you so much! And Merry Xmas and Happy New Year to you and your family as well 💗💗

[@Tanya-rf6kl]

Love your earrings and eyelook! Hope you are having a wonderful week!!

[@gwendolinehall1386]

I love your taste in color stories, I was so entranced by this ranking. Loved every minute!

[@MartinaLily]

Aw thank you so much! 💗💗

[@bea.sn1327]

Thank you for all of your hard work! Hope you all have a great end of the year!

[@MartinaLily]

Thank you so much! Happy New Year to you as well 💗💗

[@beautyfude]

Very interesting ranking 👍🏻, you look stunning 🔥🔥🔥❤! I bought Makeup by Mario Ethereal Eyes Palette and felt in love with it. But Natasha make really good eyeshadow palettes too. I purchased the eyeshadow palette from Rabanne (green), because I loved your look with it ❤

[@sonia.butler]

I always love your rankings! So fun to see. I am not even a palettte girly but i love these long rankings. YSL stora dolls is my 1. Luxury quads right?! The groundworks palette is still in my wish list. You are probably convincing me 😂i hope they come out with groundworks quad

[@Lilkam114]

Love these videos! Are you considering to review the Huda Beauty Pretty Grunge palette? It looks stunning!

[@simplyblair]

I know how difficult this video must’ve been for you! I absolutely suck at ranking makeup 😂 I knew DM Groundwork would be in your top 5, but I did think I Need A Nude would be number 1! Idk what’s wrong with my DM palette, but it has such a strong chemically smell! I wonder if I got a bad one 🤷🏻‍♀️

[@MartinaLily]

Haha it sucked so bad Blair! lol I don't know why I put myself through ranking videos lol I have heard other people say that too though, so I honestly don't know if it's like a bad batch or I just can't smell properly lol I thought INAN would be first too but I can't go past how much I've used that DM one haha 💗💗

[@theambitlady]

I am new and also fair skinned and looking forward to your reviews. Happy New Year ❤🎉

[@cynthialees2760]

Great video Martina! What a ton of work! So fun to watch and I would say you have a gift, truly. Thanks again!

[@MartinaLily]

Aw thank you so much Cynthia! 💗💗

[@minakabess3586]

I am a new subscriber to your channel and I am so impressed with your video. Thank you so much for sharing your ranking with us. I cannot wait to see more videos! My favorite pallet this year was actually the Ghost Face pallet by Glamlite. **chefs kiss** to that one.

[@chantalmeijer8491]

Your wearing the green from mothership 2 and 5 what I suggested the other day! Yay! ❤😊 Beautiful with your sweater

[@MartinaLily]

Sure am! Thank you lovely xx

[@skeletongirl76]

Love your ranking! And thanks for the video! And I have bought the Danessa Myricks Groundwork palette per your recommendation and I really love it as well! And the Glaminatrix Glimmering Creatures are on their way across the globe to the north as I write this (it may even be here but stuck in the Swedish post) also thanks to you!

[@MartinaLily]

Ohh I am so happy you love the DM neutrals!! And I hope you love Glimmering creatures too!! 💗💗

[@shawndickson2390]

I knew it!!!!! I got your top 3 and KNEW groundwork’s was going to be #1!!!!!!! Long winded me: #1 I totally get what you are saying when you say you like to just look at the palettes. When I’m struggling with my depression or panicking, I can sit down in my makeup chair and just start looking at the palettes and if it’s a really bad day then I pick out my favorite shade in each palette. By the time I’m done, I’m smiling and calm. #2 My Martina Mug was missing and it is actually the only thing I can use to have hot coffee to the very last drop. We tore the house apart, I thought someone tossed in all the Christmas wrapping. I now owe my son a BB gun because he found it!!!! LOVE, LOVE, LOVE!!!!!💗

[@marqueliarawls-gaines3728]

🧡 I never comment but u and @beautyandthefrizz are my fav! Headed over to check out queer bones now….Happy New Year love 🎉

[@Amber86queenbee]

This is my favourite video of the year - I love yearly rankings, was curious on yours the most and I really appreciate the editing with the swatches. Indi beauty brands have been exceptional this year and very interesting with both the formulas and colour stories. The Adept arrow inspired palette is in stock (I am just struggling to prioritise my wish list of Adept arrow/seahorse, Isamaya 2.0, Bella Beaute Bar basic witch, Ensley Reign, Lisa Eldridge’s Vega/Sorcery restock out now, Oden’s Eye…). My top brand of 2023 is Glaminatrix and I am looking forward to their releases next year as they have said they are bringing out either a green or pastel palette in a DM.

[@MartinaLily]

Aw thank you so much Amber! And I soo know the feeling. There's a few things I have my eye on too that I want and can't decide between haha Also you got the inside scoop with Glaminatrix! They were my top brand for the year as well! 💗💗

[@patriciamaguire9914]

LE Sorcery is magical - she is a genius!

[@R.L.Maverick]

Wow! The progress on your DM Groundwork palette is amazing!!! You Have!!! Used that palette! The proof is in the pan! Lol! Happy New Year!!!🎊

[@lynettefinnigan9540]

Loving the make-up look today, the bold green eyecolour really suits you!❤

[@brookezab7290]

That light blue in the Rabanne quad 😍😍😍 so good to see all the Viseart and Glaminatrix rating highly too! ❤

[@avapodyl4954]

Love the arm swatches! Thank you for taking the time!

[@anjulirivera9332]

I love hearing your opinion and a few of these palettes have joined my collection based on your review; zero regrets. I appreciate that you insert arm swatches- visually it’s helpful for me when deciding on a color story. Packaging sometimes gets in the way for me lol. Of all the palettes I’ve been attempting to get the Byredo one is the most elusive for me; YSL Stora Dolls gave it a good run for its money though but I was able to snag it and I love that quad. My top 3 palettes this year are My Tom Ford Quads- Smokey Quartz & Nude Dip- & Patrick Ta’s all matte palette this year.

[@cassiel.6918]

Do you do your base before your eyeshadow? Because the only way to control the fallout with some palettes is doing your eyeshadow first and wiping the fallout off.

[@alexlyubenov5690]

I adore your ranking! My top palette of the year was also from Danessa Myricks, but the Lightworks Vol. 5, for me it's an absolute perfection! Also, I'm so glad someone else also acknowledges how beautiful the Paco Rabanne eyeshadow is! ♡

[@MartinaLily]

Thank you! I love that Lightwork V palette! Also yes. the Rabanne Makeup line is being slept on so hard! 💗💗

[@Jennifer_Ann]

I love your ranking videos, this is so nicely edited and enjoyable. The Yucca palette is on my wish list- I’ve learned this year I’m more of a singles girl. Those Glamminatrix singles are also on my wish list 😊

[@87Ashlee]

You won’t regret the Yucca😊✨

[@sarahspaltro]

Martina! Thank you! My husband probably feels the same way and I’m not even an influencer! lol. Quick question. I have fair skin like you and I can’t seem to use DM palette. Can you do a few looks with it?

[@truth.is.freedom8686]

I LOVE the Natasha Denona Yucca palette too!! It's the best palette of the year imo ❤️‍🔥💖❤️‍🔥💖

[@BeautyAndTheFrizz]

Martina! I looked at your look and said SUBLIME! I love your content ❤

[@nidiadoherty5405]

Great video, and gorgeous green look today. I can’t wait to rediscover some of my palettes that you mentioned.

[@MartinaLily]

Thank you! Have fun playing! 💗💗

[@brittchristensen5284]

I don’t see a lot of people mentioning the PMG Intensifeyes - does is prevent glitter fallout? My glitter glued aren’t enough for the ND INAN palette…

[@kymmie1st]

Thank you this video was just what I needed after the horrific Xmas night tornado that hit our beautiful suburb Cedar Grove... I have now turned into a part time lumbar jack😂. At least we still have a house just about every tree is either destroyed or badly damaged, but my happy place is makeup even if I haven't worn any sice Xmas day. Love your work and I think I really need the denessa light works one I have ummed and arrhed about it since you review and think I need some sparkle at the moment 😊

[@Agi454]

If it were 2 hours long I would still watch! Love these rankings! My first would also be the DM Groundwork!! Love love love I use it all the time. Also ND INAN and Yucca. Definitely agree they are my top too.

[@MartinaLily]

Aw thank you! And great minds! haha Those three palettes though, I just can't go past them! 💗💗

[@tianiortiz8529]

Thank you Martina. I always use the intensifies stick for my shimmers, but I noticed with certain shimmers it wasn’t working. For example, the adept shimmers were not lasting on my eyes and I never have that problem but I used the Devinah glitter glue and they last all day. weird but I’m glad I got it to work for me because I skipped on Samarian Sunset because the shimmers weren’t lasting on my eyes. So glad I found another option because I love the adapt shimmers. As for next year I want to add more natural hair brushes from SG or WG. I love my rephr brushes and after trying their higher quality brush they released this year I was floored on how much better it was so definitely this year is the year to invest in even better quality natural hair brushes. Some of my faves this year were definitely the ND I need a nude palette along with the latest shimmer Devinah came out with so dam good. However I reach for my Viseart neutral mates alot alongside my special shimmers. I love the matte formula I definitely want to get a few more palettes from them like the cool mattes, but I’m also interested in the cool toned one you used in your wedding and or the one they just came out with.

[@MartinaLily]

Oohh I have Devinah on my list so when I try them I will get their glitter glue too thank you!! I'm glad you love Viseart too! They are so slept on as a brand 💗💗

[@megdvs21]

Uch a good list 🤩😍😀 hope you are had a good Christmas love 💕

[@MartinaLily]

You too lovely! 💗💗

[@geewizlana]

Ground Work is the same for me! Also love using it for the perfect lip liner shade

[@mariam.a.]

Ah damn, I would have put money down on INAN being your #1 haha. Did not see DM coming for the win. This video seems like a pile of work, you are a trooper. I can barely go through 20 palettes in a video 🤣. I am in my 40s now and except INAN all the other 17 palettes I bought this year are quints or quads.

[@concettaciaccio4543]

Love this ranking and love that every palette you showed is well used❤

[@melina_m_makeup]

Hey beautiful! Hope you are having a wonderful holiday!! Gorgeous, stunning eyelook today!! Im so here for this palette ranking!!! ❤❤❤❤

[@MartinaLily]

Hi lovely! You too! I hope its been nice and relaxing for you. Thanks Melina! xxxx

[@notaninfluencer4882]

Thank you for the very thorough ranking! I’m so curious about ensley reign! I’d really like to see you review their palettes if you’re interested in them!

[@MartinaLily]

Thank you! Yes, I really am trying to get my hands on their new palette cos it looks amazing 💗💗

[@notaninfluencer4882]

@@MartinaLily No pressure! 💖

[@__shasha]

My absolute favorite types of videos ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@patriciafuentes6646]

I totally agree with the MAC palette assessment. I wish I had checked your review first before I bought it! I was sold on what I remembered MAC eyeshadow was like in my youth. Just so disappointing. Your reviews are so thorough!

[@stefaniemezigian414]

Your eyeshadow looks so beautiful!

[@MartinaLily]

Thank you lovely 💗💗

[@charlenejensen3559]

I loved listening to you rank all of the eyeshadow palettes. Hope you had a great Christmas! 🎄❤

[@MartinaLily]

Thank you! I hope you did as well 💗💗

[@marionallen2222]

Natasha and Pat’s definitely my favs 🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍 Divine Rose and GLAM

[@MartinaLily]

💗💗💗💗

[@EmilysMakeupBag1]

I don't need it at all, but I can't get the Yucca palette out of my mind... may need to pick it up soon hahaha

[@Soulecitou]

I love and respect your ranking videos so much, you just seem super genuine. ❤

[@MartinaLily]

Aw thank you so much! 💗💗

[@isabelab6851]

I like your selections because I too love more cool toned color stories. They go better with my gray hair and light skin with cool undertone. There are some I would like to try…and definitely have the Danes sauce myrick on my wish list

[@kerriwright4593]

I'm very fair but typically a colorful clow. I absolutely love the i need a nude so much 😍

[@lisasmith7]

I have actually used PM XI much more than I thought I would. I also love my DM Light Work V. Great reviews. ❌️⭕️

[@MartinaLily]

💗💗💗

[@michellerocco5073]

Absolutely Gorgeous look!!! ❤❤❤🎉❤❤❤🎉WOW!!! THANK U LOVE these videos Yeahhhh 🎉🎉🎉😂🎉🎉🎉❤🙏 😊

[@BethaneyLilly]

My top are gonna be the same Groundwork, iNAN, Yucca as well as Huda Pretty Grunge which is my ideal grungy Smokey palette, relive my early 00 youth …lol The cream shade in groundwork is damn near perfection for brow cleanup and just cleanup blending …the way it looks on the skin is unlike any eyeshadow I’ve ever used. I’d rebuy the palette for that damn shade alone …. For me owning and buying a LOT of makeup price doesn’t equate the same way, it become more about Usage.

[@seekthetruth1485]

It is clear you have an adversity to nude palettes...but the Doll 10 pallet is my everyday go to. This is an exceptional palette, maybe use a primer first. I have oily eyelids so I do not, but you may want to revisit it. It also does not contain crap like Bismuth Oxychloride that makes you itch, or other nasty ingredients that will make you eyes water. Check out her shadow sticks, they are delightful too.

[@carlamiller2330]

Oooooh. Ooooooh. I’ve been waiting for this video😃

[@hildaalvarez4702]

Awesome video 🤩🤩 this is the meaning of hardwork and commitment! I betted with my husband that the I need a nude palette would be in the top three! And I won 🤣🤣

[@jenniferd5477]

Gurllll I love this video and trust your reviews !!! Where can we get those ysl palettes in AUS 😢😢

[@MartinaLily]

Thank you so much lovely! Ugh I am so annoyed they haven't come out here yet. I promise as soon as they do I will shout it from the roof tops haha 💗💗

[@TheSlimjadey1]

I was going to ask this too. I've looked everywhere and I mean EVERYWHERE. I still haven't come up with a way to get them without a shipping service

[@jenniferd5477]

@@MartinaLily thank you so much ❤️

[@jenniferd5477]

@@TheSlimjadey1 right !!

[@Annaseptember1978]

The Mac Nude Unfiltered Palette is my favorite palette of the year, followed by Remembrance by Byredo, Yucca and INAD. I love the Mac palette because of the colours, blends well en stay on my eyelids. It’s my most used palette.

[@MartinaLily]

Oh wow, see this is why I think I might have got a dud on the MAC one cos mine was truly unusable. I loved the color story of it too so I can see why you love it 💗💗

[@Annaseptember1978]

@@MartinaLily well, I do think they are not consistent. The very dark brown is not the best but the other ones work very well, especially on more mature eyelids. Satin mattes are my favorite formula. I like it much more than the Master Mattes by Mario. Other favorites are Supernudes from CT and warm neutrals from Viseart. And for the next year I wish Byredo will come with a cool toned palette.

[@rebeccawainwright4515]

I love this video and thank you for all the hard work on it. I think your rankings in respect to PM was spot on. Just wasn’t so impressive this year

[@MartinaLily]

Thank you so much Rebecca. And lets hope Pat returns to her normal self next year! 💗💗

[@leannakimball6259]

I Need a Nude was my personal number 1 palette for the year!

[@kerriwright4593]

The circo loco is one of my absolute favorite Natasha Denona palettes. It and the retro are my 2 i would for sure repurchase if something happened to them.

[@lavayuki]

Wow I never thought I would see a Pat palette at the bottom of the barrel in your ranking, although I agree with you. My favourite palette this year was the ABH cosmos which I got 25% off

[@MartinaLily]

Me too! It doesn't feel right but it just didn't wow me haha 💗💗

[@LisaF_]

I put Isamaya Industrial 2.0 on my Christmas list because of your review…AND I LOVE IT. ND INAN, Industrial 2.0, Byredo Remembrance, Suqqu 125, and YSl 100 are my top 5…with DM Lightworks 5 a very close 6. (And I wonder if you got a weird one because I don’t have the same application issues even if I use no Pat stick or glitter glue. Weird) OTOH… I need your secret to the Groundworks. I want to love it. The colors and formulas are stunning. The cream blends in as contour or bronzer beautifully but it fades on me. I’ve tried everything. I’ve set it with the corresponding powder which stamp a bit on my cheeks but not my eyes, I’ve set it with other bronzers, I’ve used different primers. Whatever I do the cream formula looks stunning when I apply it to my face or eyes and is basically gone with 2 hours. 😢 I want this to be my everything, but I just can’t make it last on me! Help!

[@MartinaLily]

Yay, I'm so happy you love the Isamaya palette! Hmmm super weird, I definitely don't have that issue with the DM palette. I wonder if its just how your skin reacts to it maybe if you tried all different primes etc 💗💗

[@kerriwright4593]

I always do my eyes first unless I'm just tossing on the cover girl champagne single and a bb cream. I am so messy with every single shadow. Idk how people avoid tons off fallout. I'll tap my brushes with mattes. I'll spray shimmers or use the pat stick. I'll use my fingers. Nothing helps idk why. I guess I'm just heavy handed and wild when feeling creative 😂

[@janinepaim1488]

I just bought the rabanete Palette just because of you!! 😅❤

[@MartinaLily]

Aww yay! I hope you love it 💗💗

[@megdvs21]

I had 9 to rank that i tried this year 😆 😄 ☺😉: ok here we go 9: ND mini gold 8: ND mini nude 7: ND 5 pan camel 6: ND yucca 5: ND mini star 4: ND mini starlette 3: ND mini my Dream 2: ND midi xenon 1: ND I need a nude

[@MartinaLily]

Ohhh a year of ND, I love it! 💗💗

[@megdvs21]

Yea eyeshadow palettes are the category i have learned that in the past I’ve had the least self control with so last year i decided for now to only buy from my 1 most favorite brand that i will get the most use out of so the number of palettes i buy and have is actually useable 😆@@MartinaLily

[@lizbakeslemons940]

Woohoo!!! I love your channel 😄😄

[@MartinaLily]

Aw thank you so much! 💗💗

[@omegasobsessions]

I love my Snow Dreams palette, performs fabulous and I can get a huge range of looks. No idea why it gets so much hate but my guess is that it isn’t a color bomb like most of their stuff is.

[@MartinaLily]

I'm so glad it's not just me who love the Snow Dream palette! It is sooo good! 💗💗

[@omegasobsessions]

I also have both of the Hellaween palettes and aside from the one silver shade that is holochrome I see no difference in the performance. I adore color and have few neutral palettes but noticed I was lacking lighter shimmers and multichromes so got the Snow Dreams, zero regrets. I did a full Xmas look, a few soft matte in crease with a shimmer on lid looks and 2 others with the holo, loved them all. The ONLY thing that is different is this palette is a softer color story than the rest of their stuff and I think vast majority of their Stan’s are all about the bold colors. It is the only reason I can come up with as it is a fantastic palette. Reminds me, I need to go review it now that I have used every shade lol

[@debbieotoole1072]

ND definitely did something special with Yucca and i need a nude, i absolutely love them. Unearthly cosmetics Sorcerous smoke and Devour palette are fantastic 👌 one of my favourite indie brands. Cosmic brushes Muse palette an fantastic palette, the brand blow me away this year, i can't believe the quality of the shadows for the price, amazing. Blend bunny sugar and grudge palette gorgeous palette. Oden's eye Jewels and gem palette is so so good i love it, Christmas eve palette i love, flora palette and trick or treat love them all. Just so many good palettes this year 😊

[@MartinaLily]

Agreed! Soooo many good palettes this year 💗💗

[@chaoswitch1974]

I've realized how much that climate effects the makeup I like. I live in a pretty dry climate in Los Angeles, but I know when I go to very humid climates, my makeup doesn't perform the same.

[@kerriwright4593]

Where is the isamya ( can't spell) sold in the US? Anyone know?

[@MartinaLily]

On her website - isamaya.com/ 💗💗

[@Lynnonymous]

I bought Rememberence because of Alicia Archer too! 😂

[@jsmith3021]

I just got the DM one from trend mood and can't wait to use it for a great base of nudes. I'm just hooked on the Mario "limit edition " for now. 😊

[@MartinaLily]

Oh nice! I hope you love it 💗💗

[@anp22fab]

I understand the ranking of Mothership XI but that is sacrilege! 🤣 I purchased 7 palettes this year and Mothership XI actually ranked 5 on my list so I get it!

[@MartinaLily]

I know right! haha It just doesn't feel right lol 💗💗

[@anp22fab]

@@MartinaLily But I agree with you because my purchases included both Danessa Myricks Lightworks and Groundworks palettes and those are my two 2 purchases from last year. My Natasha Denona My Dream and Yucca palettes also came before Pat McGrath! 🥰

[@alynnhirsch]

So disappointed in PMG this year. First Mothership I didn’t buy. Thank you for being honest so I didn’t have to waste my own money. I also swatched it at Sephora. Big NOPE from me.

[@kerriwright4593]

I never bought the yucca palette because everyone's looks all looked the same. Like all the shimmers are the same on the eyes on camera. Everyone ranked it so high though. I have fomo.

[@87Ashlee]

I truly disagree that the shimmers and the mattes look the same on the eye. I know a lot of KZbinrs reviewed it as such. Imo the Yucca is really versatile. I don’t want to make your fomo worse but… it’s one of my favorite palettes! My boyfriend always calls me a tropical bird when wearing it haha.

[@kerriwright4593]

@87Ashlee it's probably amazing in person. It's always hard to tell exactly what it's like in videos you know? No disrespect or anything bad meant by my comment 💜

[@MartinaLily]

I can see why it might seem that way for sure but honestly in person the shades are quite different to each other. The shimmers are slightly similar but on the eyes they look different. I am biased though cos its in my top 3 hahah 💗💗

[@marionallen2222]

🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍

[@MartinaLily]

💗💗💗💗