Ranking All Plant Island Monsters! [Remastered] (My Singing Monsters)

[@FutureProGamer90]

Reuploaded because Ghazt had the same description as shugabush

[@MSMthealtfire1234]

Oh ok

[@RareGhazt55571]

Hi

[@meredithholt9988]

“T-Rox is good” The most inspiring quote I’ve ever heard

[@PentumbraMSM105]

I 100% agree with you on Bowgart. I'm pretty sure almost everyone could agree he changes the songs impact. Continue making great content!

[@Noggin-msm-u6p]

Death sentence for putting noggin in 24

[@YourLocalFunBot123]

6:13 it’s called my singing MONSTERS for a reason. It’s a game about monsters. That’s why people think Shugabush is ugly

[@Adrian-hs4gi]

It’s humanoid and weird that’s why

[@V01D_Soon2B]

It is a trend why people don’t like humanoid monsters, especially the shugafam

[@Nimmersatt7491]

Clamble is just underatet. He is goog when you don't have the epic wubbox and he makes the end epic.

[@PerrcusionBox]

Underatet goog

[@JustA-RandomBoy]

Honestly ur entire ranking is great. I’d bump up the colossal sound to okay in my opinion tho. It’s not terrible and I do get your point but I think it does a pretty good job of starting off the song. I can hear everyone else on my island

[@gleebert9240]

0:15 bro probably wants to make a diss track on the Colossal’s💀

[@lcbtaxconsultingsl]

I think i can actually hear pummel in plant island kinda well or maybe it's the voices in my head

[@cathytish4223]

voices def

[@ej_makesvideos]

“Talker is better than person” I like *person* better though

[@Kreeper_Kat5764]

Ranking Updated Perfect 1 Bowgart: This carries the song. I don't care if someone says it's overrated this is a masterpiece in string form. 2 Epic Wubbox: Adds precussion and vocals + i like the rattling sound. 3 Ghazt: I don't care i like this sound it's my favorite single element monster. 4 Shugabush: Both the guitar and vocals are amazing in the song. Better 5 Dipsters: They are so catchy and somewhat nostalgic and carry a bit the song. 6 Maw: Not only does it sound good but this is easily it's best island. 7 T-rox: Noggin but more audible and with a better design. 8 Wubbox: The original wubbox sounds relaxing and is pretty unique. 9 Furcorn: A memorable monster for giving us high notes. 10 Mammot: The most simple sound to remember from the game. 11 Parlsona: Same as below but i like her voice a bit. 12 Twakker: They may be repetitive but i like the concept of talking monsters + they are just good. Good 13 G'joob: It carries it's section but could have played more. (It literally plays just 2 times) 14 Rare Wubbox: Same as the one above. 15 Clamble: Some say it's boring but it actually adds something to the transitions. 16 Entbrat: In terms of sound he may not have the best voice but the ending is nothing without him. 17 Toe Jammer: Without Mammot sounds weird but it's ok. 18 Potbelly: 1st track adds a touch to the beggining the other track is an alright background singer. Ok 19 Fwog: It's catchy but it's only used in transitions. 20 Drumpler: It's effective but nothing else above that. 21 Shrubb: It has a fine rhythm + it adds a bit to me. Mid 22 Oaktopus: It''s fine but it's almost unaudible. 23 Colossal: I guess even though it sounds loud it has another track... the other colossals don't have more then one track. and i guess it adds to the... beatdrop? 24 Punkleton: It sounds pretty decent in the beggining but later it gets drowned out a bunch. (Overall it's an interesting seasonal) 25 Noggin: A simple precussion that gets drowned out A BUNCH. Mediocre 26 Pummel: It's so useless i even feel sorry because of how much useless he is.

[@CHOMIKSHARKED]

I kinda think bowgart is really overrated

[@jack-q8m9l]

You're back ranking monsters!

[@mrsgbrandi]

0:53 that is because rare wubbox always plays at 1 short verse of the song

[@buzzinga_and_YOOREEK]

The goat verse pf plant island

[@Mirrored_Rage]

IMO: 26. Pummel 🔇🟥- cannot hear it at all, it's a monster and not a singing monster. 25. Noggin 🔇🟥- can't hear it on the full song but when you're a beginner it's actually pretty good 24. Colossal 🟧- it makes the beginning transition good, but it fails rare wubbox verse 23. Oaktopus 🟧- no opinion 22. Drumpler 🟧- it's actually pretty good, but earth island is way better 21. Shrubb 🟩- should've been higher but colossal made it inaudible in the first verse 20. Clamble 🟩- outstanding transitions. 19. Fwog 🟩- same as Clamble 18. Rare Wubbox 🟩- love the verse, but it only plays that time and it's very short, still a great sound 17. Punkleton 🟦- i actually think the beginning is nothing without him. controversial opinion. 16-15. Werdos 🟦- i like the part when they say "everything here is alive", the part during rare wubbox verse and also the echo of Tawkerr when he says "it's just a bunch of plants". 14. Toe Jammer 🟨- Mammott is the better duo though 13. Furcorn 🟨- the main icon of the game, it sounds GREAT on plant island 12. Mammott 🟨- THIS is the main singer of the song, and the best natural i know. 11. Wubbox 🟨- changes the entire song making it intense in a good way, literally.. 10. T-Rox 🟨- both this and air island are grrrrreat percussions. 9. Potbelly 🟨- better Punkleton, the beginning when with epic wubbox sounds weird 8. Maw 🟨- it makes the song intense. i find Maw as my favourite double element in the island 7. Entbrat 🟨- I understand why many hate Entbrat, he's very loud and overpowers many.. but i really like it! carries the final verse a lot probably my most controversial opinion in all of MSM. 6-4. G'joob, Ghazt, Shugabush 🟨- G'joob and Ghazt really pair up with Bowgart well. G'joob is the backbone of the rare wubbox to final verse, Ghazt just has that magical sound. Shugabush solo at the end is legendary. Dipsters 🥉- didn't everyone hate dipsters back then? anyway, it's ghe best vocalist at the intro, gets repetitive in a good way, lots of stuff. Epic Wubbox 🥈- what's the intro without it? makes the song get a really big turn especially during "everything here is alive" and the final verse. Bowgart 🏅👑🟪- it's plant island bowgart, you know it. it's pretty complicated to explain how good this monster is in plant island, but here: it plays nearly the entire song, and all the time Bowgart sings are the climax/best part of the song. always top tier in almost all, if not all of the tier list ranking videos of him. design for rare, epic, and common look good. sounds really great without overpowering monsters/being too loud, or drowning out ANY monster.

[@Blue_soft_animation]

I love your vids

[@Cr4ftyP4wz]

Ranking so u can remember Red-Bad Orange-okay Green-Good Blue-Better Gold/Yellow-Goat 👑-Favorite Purple-Perfect

[@EtherealSupreme2.0]

I’m so honoured to be your favourite ethereal

[@UltraTheUltarge]

W ranking (dunno what happened to the first one)

[@FutureProGamer90]

I deleted it and changed Ghazt description because it was the same as shugabush’s

[@UltraTheUltarge]

@@FutureProGamer90 k

[@Kreeper_Kat5764]

1 Bowgart: This carries the song. I don't care if someone says it's overrated this is a masterpiece in string form. 2 Epic Wubbox: Adds precussion and vocals + i like the rattling sound. 3 Ghazt: I don't care i like this sound it's my favorite single element monster. 4 Shugabush: Both the guitar and vocals are amazing in the song. Better 5 Dipsters: They are catchy and carry a bit the song. 6 Maw: Easily it's best island. 7 T-rox: Noggin but more audible and with a better design. 8 Wubbox: The original wubbox sounds relaxing and is pretty unique. 9 Furcorn: A memorable monster for giving us high notes. 10 Mammot: The most simple sound to remember from the game. 11 Parlsona: Same as below but i like her voice a bit. 12 Twakker: They may be repetitive but i like the concept of talking monsters + they are just good. Decent 13 G'joob: It carries it's section but could have played more. (It literally plays just 2 times) 14 Rare Wubbox: Same as the one above. 15 Clamble: Some say it's boring but it actually adds something to the transitions. 16 Entbrat: In terms of sound he may not have the best voice but the ending is nothing without him. 17 Toe Jammer: Without Mammot sounds weird but it's ok. 18 Potbelly: 1st track adds a touch to the beggining the other track is an alright background singer. 19 Fwog: It's catchy but it's only used in transitions. 20 Drumpler: It's effective but nothing else above that. It exists (The mid teir) 21 Oaktopus: It''s fine but it's almost unaudible. 22 Colossal: I guess even though it sounds loud it has another track... the other colossals don't have more then one track. 23 Punkleton: It sounds pretty decent in the beggining but later it gets drowned out a bunch. (Overall it's an interesting seasonal) 24 Shrubb: It just exists... thats about it. 25 Noggin: A simple precussion that gets drowned out A BUNCH. Bad 26 Pummel: The most useless monster in the whole island.

[@gyuvingaming8459]

Make sure to turn on the transcript! Best experience of my life.

[@Nutshacklover69]

Rare Wubbox was done so dirty after the werdo extension

[@random_losers93]

honestly shugabush would be my favorite if he didn’t go “yeah yeah yeah” :/

[@Kye-kai]

W Ranking!

[@NaLian605]

I kinda like the colossal because it does give a good transition

[@JKai2OFF]

Bowgat made me ascend first time i got him lol- also, W ranking, i agree in some parts (idk if i said something wrong)

[@cathytish4223]

1. Ghazty boy (YOU TOOK SO LONG TO GET but it was worth it) 2. Mammott (og og og- Lynja) 3. Fwog (WOWOWOWOWOW) 4.Bowgart (overrated but good) 5. G'joob (first mythical monster i got) 6. Wubbox (best beatdrop monster) 7. Dipsters (DIP.) 8. Shrubb (BOOTS AND PLANTS) 9. Entbrat (hes so overhated) 10. Furcorn (LAAAA LAAA LA LA LA LAAAAAAA) 11. Toe jammer (DOO!) 12. Rare wubbox (WUBBABUNGA) 13. Epic wubbox (inaudible but good instruments) 14. Tawkerr (GOAT) 15. Parlsona (women...) 16. Punkleton (pumkin) 17. Shugabush (still. dont. have.) 18. T-rox (meh) 19. Drumpler (meh also) 20. Pummel (inaudible) 21. Oaktopus ( SHOO!!!!) 22. Clamble (hes good but inaudible) 23. Maw (meh... this was my best sorry Maw) 24. Potbelly (Mammot filler) 25. Noggin (simple beat and inaudible) 26. Colossal (who breathed?)

[@PorygonBugado]

Bowgart is good on itself, i sgree with that, but on thr song itself i can barely hear him, he still impacts the song by still Also in my opinion T-rox its the triple to carry plant island, i guess hes my fav and thats me having some favoritism for him, but hey he wouldnt be my fav without a reason

[@Woopwoopwyatt]

If the Werdos/Dipsters were taken off their islands and the colossals were quieter, the natural islands would be so much better.

[@MSMthealtfire1234]

True

[@c4r3na-s]

The dipsters and werdos are good wdym

[@MSMthealtfire1234]

What if: you ranked every castle bass in all islands.

[@JustSomeGuy-z9s]

Ngl I don't see what everyone else sees in Bowgart. I can barely hear him and other monsters just sound better In My Opinion.

[@Art_CupcakeMia]

FINALLY SOMEONE WHO DOESN'T HATE ENTBRAT

[@mrsgbrandi]

Parlsona = person Tawkerr = talker Imagine what stoowarb and maggpi are

[@AyatZhum]

@@mrsgbrandi i would think Stew and Magpie

[@PeckidnaPlayz]

Wish you could rank the isle (idk if I spelt right or wrong)

[@PeckidnaPlayz]

But it has so much monsters

[@FutureProGamer90]

@@PeckidnaPlayz it’s not done

[@PeckidnaPlayz]

Too much

[@TheKoobik1]

Ah,new intro? Nice 1 - Epic Wubbox. The best Epic Wubbox in the game,no contest. 2 - Ghazt. Yeah,he is the best Single Ethereal. 3 - Dipsters. They are peak and the reason I like Dipsters. 4 - Shugabush. He sounds cool in the last verse. 5 - G'Joob. The best Mythical right there. 6 - Wubbox. He's cool,I like him. 7 - Maw. He's kinda cool. 8 - Bowgart. Mmmmm... Overrated. Still good,but overrated. 9 - Potbelly. He adds a nice beat. 10 - Rare Wubbox. I like Rare Wubbox :] 11 - T-Rox. Uhhh,even better Noggin. 12 - Furcorn. He's neat. Yeah,that's about it. 13 - Mammott. Unlike Toe Jammer,he isn't boring alone. 14 - Toe Jammer. Mmm,alone he's boring. 15 - Shrubb. He is a good Double Element,I'm tired of seeing Shrubb being overhated. 16 - Werdos. I have them but I don't really care about them. 17 - Fwog. Wow. 18 - Clamble. He does the job fine. 19 - Punkleton. He is a nice Seasonal. But I have all three variants and even then I sometimes barely hear him. He does sound nice in the first verse. 20 - Entbrat. He does a work of intensifying the last verse fine. Still the worst Natural Quad. 21 - Drumpler. That's just a better Noggin. 22 - Noggin. That was kinda obvious. 23 - Colossal. Drown out? Where? I can sometimes barely hear the Colossal. Also he's a pretty nice riser for the first verse. 24 - Oaktopus. Yeah,I really cannot hear him at all. 25 - Pummel. Can anyone actually hear this guy?

[@mrsgbrandi]

0:13 maybe use garbage tier here so you can use red tier on monsters in orange tier

[@FutureProGamer90]

@@mrsgbrandi I’m not going to use garbage tier in my rankings. I made it as a joke

[@lcc1221]

Shugabush's second track is awesome

[@mopsytop]

Pummel explaining: "boring inaudible quietest in th game". Tier: okay 💀

[@mrsgbrandi]

6:12 i never seen someone put shugabush low

[@Boiky_Cheezooks]

Bowgurt is good pummel loos funny and deserves more respect

[@mrsgbrandi]

6:11 same with gold island FPG: yes Me: it is mu favorite on gold island People that hate shugabush's design: he sucks Me: ☠️

[@TeeThreeAre]

For F.F. you should do Ethereal Aether

[@luna1912-fam]

I like Bowgart, but I think that he is a bit Overrated. I can’t hear him in most of the songs. But I respect your Opinion.

[@squirtlemsm]

So many plant island rankings 😭 but W vid

[@mrsgbrandi]

Castle bass: where do i go

[@Dezi-wh6xy]

@@mrsgbrandi since when was a castle a monster

[@MsmKevinBR]

my plant island tier: 1: Maw 2: Pummel 3: Parsona 4: Tawkerr 5: Dipsters 6: Potbelly 7: Bowgart 8: Shugabush 9: Rare wubbox 10: G'joob 11: Epic wubbox 12: Punkleton 13: T-rox 14: Ghazt 15: Toe Jammer 16: Mammott 17: Camble 18: Shrubb 19: Furcorn 20: Fwog 21: Drumpler 22: Oaktopus 23: Wubbox 24: Noggin 25: Entbrat 26: Castle 27: Colossal

[@FirebeeMSM]

1. Ghazt👑 2. Bowgart💛 3. Epic wubbox💛 4. Tawkerr💜 5. Parlsona💜 6. Dipsters💜 7. Shugabush💜 8.wubbox💙 9. Mammott💙 10. T-rox💙 11. Rare wubbox 💙 12. Furcorn💙 13. Entbrat💚 14. Maw💚 15. Clamble💚 16. punkleton💚 17. G,joob💚 18. Fwog💚 19. Drumpler🧡 20. Shrubb🧡 21. Oaktopus🧡 22. Pummel 🧡 23. Toe jammer🧡 24. Potbelly 🧡 25. Noggin🧡 26. Colossal ❤️

[@EtherealSupreme2.0]

I’m honoured

[@andrewdenison829]

My top 10 for this island: 1.Bogwart🏆 2.Epic wubbox🟦 3.Rare wubbox🟩 4.Goojoob🟩 5.Noggin🟩 6.Toejammer🟩 7.Mammot🟩 8.Potbelly🟩 9.Ghazt🟩 10.drumpler🟨

[@EtherealSupreme2.0]

@@andrewdenison829 at least I’m in top 10

[@mrsgbrandi]

Ranking plant island: pummel is orange tier but he is inaudible and boring Other rankings: monsters that are unhearable and boring are red tier

[@domino.s]

Ah yes my favorite werdo person

[@Andy_ShunRed]

This is your 3rd time ranking plant island.

[@FutureProGamer90]

Yeah because I got a new ranking system and my opinions change sometimes

[@rinisetyoyunisari8095]

W ranking

[@yopoyqepasa]

why people rank monsters by their visuals when the game is literally about listening to you SINGING monsters

[@FutureProGamer90]

@@yopoyqepasa tf are you on about

[@thwok59]

Will you rank the continent when Gnarls and Hoola release?

[@FutureProGamer90]

@@thwok59 yes

[@thwok59]

@@FutureProGamer90 I'm guessing 67 is blabbit

[@adrimen7329]

​@@thwok59 Well, We kinda saw that coming.

[@3D_PUPPO]

2:08 Person 💀 3:37 Talker 💀. 8:17 I disagree with bowgart btw, he really just stabilizes the melody, he really dont contribute much tho. (My opinion)

[@mrsgbrandi]

IMO (too lazy to put reasons) 1 bowgart👑 2 ghazt🟣 3 shugabush🟣 4 epic wubbox🟡 5 dipsters🟡 6 parlsona🟡 7 tawkerr🟡 8 maw🟡 9 furcorn🟡 10 mammott🟡 11 toe jammer🔵 12 fwog🔵 13 wubbox🔵 14 rare wubbox🔵 15 g'joob🔵 16 potbelly🔵 17 entbrat🟢 18 t-rox🟢 19 clamble🟢 20 colossal🟢 21 oaktopus🟢 22 punkleton🟠 23 shrubb🟠 24 drumpler🟠 25 noggin🟠 26 pummel🔴

[@Enderchomp0968]

Pummel could of carried if he was loud (I think bowgart is overrated cuz I cant really hear it) good vid tho

[@minecraftkiddo4688]

My opinion 25. Pummel. Okay, but like…Where’s the sound? 24. Noggin. Boring and quiet, but better than pummel 23. Drumpler. It’s just a slightly better noggin 22. Oaktopus. I can barely here him dude 21. Punkleton. Sounds good in the first verse but everywhere else it’s just inaudible 20. Colossal. Drown out my ass, he adds great build up to the verses and he’s not overpowering 19. Shrubb. Overhated and deserved more attention 18. Clamble. He does his job fine, next 17. Werdos. Annoying and repetitive 16. Rare wubbox. It doesn’t matter if he doesn’t play that much, if he sounds good where he does play that’s enough 15. Entbrat. Massively overhated and adds so much power to his verse. 14. Fwog. He’s so nostalgic and mammot and toe jammer sound empty without him 13. Toe jammer. Duets with mammot well, next 12. Mammot. The mascot of msm cooked here alongside toe jammer 11. Furcorn. He sounds so good that other monsters have stolen his track lmao 10. G’joob. Super catchy and adds loads to the later parts of the song. 9. Wubbox. Ik it’s the first one but it’s unique among the wubboxes, and it sounds great 8. Bowgart. Ridiculously overrated, does not carry nearly as much as people say he does, inaudible without volume mods, but still good 7. T rox. My guy carries the percussion in the song alongside epic wubbox 6. Potbelly. Lifeblood of the song, and is under-appreciated for what he does for the island 5. Maw. Easily the best maw, a main singer and key one of that 4. Dipsters. Dipsters are either really good or really bad, these ones are amazing 3. Ghazt. I’m kinda biased because he’s my fave monster, but he’s got a great design, a great sound, and super cute animations! 2. Shugabush. How could you hate this guy? The ending is empty without him and he adds much needed Melodies and vocals 1. Epic wubbox. It’s powerful, it sounds great, it’s essential, what more could you want?

[@enzolegomes]

Fgp when Is fanmade friday gona be in a friday 'sorry for but do pixel island by notTROECoffial'

[@renugaranisubramaniam5461]

W rating im 4th. Cool

[@Abelha-Carteiro]

Oaktopus ranking: Voice: 9/10 very nostalgic, I love it Appearance: -9928/10 I hate broccoli 🤢🤢🥦 Elements: 5/10 not the best elements but not pure slurry juice either Description: 8/10 these little roots are extremely strong, I liked it Egg: 1/10 🤢

[@TANGEROSC_official]

No ice × Noice✓

[@Aguywhodoestuff]

rerank earth island and put humbug in the bottom of good tier, also stop hating on good sounding monsters you cant hear, its stupid

[@FutureProGamer90]

No, why would I listen to you

[@TANGEROSC_official]

Fr like let bro have his own opinions you can't control him

[@Aguywhodoestuff]

@@TANGEROSC_official ok bro

[@mrsgbrandi]

Fun fact: i am getting werdos on plant and mirror plant Also: rank werdos

[@jack-q8m9l]

Can you do Plant Island without the worst monster?

[@FutureProGamer90]

@@jack-q8m9l wdym

[@JackKendrick-lb2pg]

@@FutureProGamer90 You haven't turned off the colossal yet when recording Plant Island.

[@mrsgbrandi]

Outro joined the chat

[@mrsgbrandi]

You could tolerate continent shrubb

[@c4r3na-s]

3:29 Sorry I commented twice but U said Person instead of parlsona

[@FutureProGamer90]

Ik

[@mrsgbrandi]

4:40 *baby entbrat* ☠️

[@thatduckthatanimates]

HELP THAT TRANSLATES TO 'BABY DELIVERED' 💀

[@Tiger-Mations.]

pummel :(

[@mrsgbrandi]

8:01 bowGOAT

[@mrsgbrandi]

8:01 and stogg

[@Dog_fan7]

I know people will kill me but I find bowgart kinda overrated, idk why I just can't hear him that well in the songs he's in and if you can't hear a monster in the songs their in, then can you really say he carries every island he's in.

[@Dog_fan7]

Also I think shugabush Carries plant island.

[@TroyDaBoy2763]

Bro is so right

[@kvasonn467]

2:05 "Person" "Talker"

[@YousufMangal-sh5bw]

It's auto correct

[@GlopticsMSM]

W rating btw im third

[@Gonner-cd6xn]

I really like this tier list, but i would put lebron James in 1 instead of bowgart.

[@Zurking_yeah34]

“ person + talker” you wrote them wrong

[@mrsgbrandi]

8:32 i don't see any videos i can press on

[@FutureProGamer90]

Why do you comment on so many of my videos

[@TheDarkLordidk]

​@@FutureProGamer90free popularity for you

[@MUHAMMADDANYAYDENBINMOHAMMADHE]

Day 2: do Psychic Citadel

[@c4r3na-s]

Ik its ur opinion but parlsona is slightly better then tawker, she should be 14 instead of 15. Also G'joob should be over shrubb. Still, everything else is great though

[@mrsgbrandi]

Ranking the continent: coming soon (SPOILER ALERT: hoola will be last)

[@HappyAsHarryOfficial]

Why did twalker eat maw also what with the creepy ghost reapeting him

[@mrsgbrandi]

2:03 - 4:23 *person and talker* ☠️

[@RaineyBowBow]

Must disagree with bowgart potbelly has my heart as my favriote

[@JustABulbasaur]

W ranking #endclambleslander

[@Ioan-bb3dj]

I agree, clamble crazy slept on ESPECIALLY earth and tribal

[@MsmKevinBR]

I more or less agree with your ranking but it's your opinion, right?

[@mrsgbrandi]

1:23 you said people put him at dead last Also: people put pummel lower

[@mrsgbrandi]

1:42 *just isn't you cup of tea* ☠️

[@FutureProGamer90]

It’s a figure of speech

[@mrsgbrandi]

5:03 *ruins so songs* ☠️

[@FutureProGamer90]

I meant “some” 💀

[@WhyDoIPlayRobloxAgainIForgor]

W rating

[@DholakiMaki]

Dude where’s mammot 😂😂😂

[@mrsgbrandi]

0th place. Rare bowgart

[@justintran16228]

plant isle

[@levyguerra2208]

2:03 I have the opposite opinion, I don't like tawkerr

[@Aaroningo2]

Day 3 asking for the isle by MSM Quibble fan

[@FutureProGamer90]

@@Aaroningo2 I’m not doing it

[@Decidueye1530]

G job needs stay More high, Is a excelent monster and carry the island, and entbrant un the last, Is a ugly monster and the worst quad

[@Oogiddyhittingtheoogriddy]

Dont do my boyz pummel and punkleton like that

[@Lukaissej]

dip *start chain8

[@ElizabethMaeSun]

5:18 uh... could you be more specifec?

[@FutureProGamer90]

@@ElizabethMaeSun no

[@GhaztIsBeautiful]

ghost supposed to be first

[@Xxxxxxxxxuioo000]

oh no not again bowtrash is number 1