Ranking ALL the Palettes I Tried in 2024 | almost 30 palettes!

[@shimmersandsilver]

7:18 EDIT: I did not declutter Simply Posh “Citrus Punch”; I had to throw it away due to mold in the mattes. But everything I said stands 🙃

[@socialliz6805]

All three palettes you ranked highest look beautiful! Great choices! I hope the situation with your family member works out with the least stress and heartache possible. Hugs!

[@shimmersandsilver]

Thank you, Liz! Yes, those top three are killers!

[@MakeupwithMariela1]

Love your eye look!

[@shimmersandsilver]

Thank you!

[@bricbeauty]

Great Ranking! I adore the Lore palette! 🤩

[@shimmersandsilver]

Thank you, Bri! Me too!

[@Katsbeautyspace]

Love your ranking❤❤❤❤. I agree those top palettes would be interchangeable depending on the day and what i was feeling.

[@shimmersandsilver]

Yeah, they are all sooooo pretty and good. Thanks for watching, Kat!

[@TheMayorsDaughter]

I love watching these ranking videos! My head would explode if I tried to do it tho ....good video

[@shimmersandsilver]

Hahaha! It’s usually fun, but definitely a project! Thank you for watching!

[@nail.art.hubris3776]

I LOVE Ranking videos!❤ And, I just thought about actually ranking what I've used this year, and i couldn't even finish my thought! Wow, it IS difficult to rank! Kudos to you for doing it! Now I REALLY appreciate Ranking videos! I pray for your situation, and I hope you still have a nice New Year! 🙏💕

[@shimmersandsilver]

Thank you so much! Yes, these videos are a lot of work, but also quite fun. I appreciate your prayers over our family situation. Happy new year!

[@michellerocco5073]

❤🎉❤🎉🙏 love the Ranking Videos yeahhhh

[@shimmersandsilver]

Heh heh - me too!

[@Teeeyt]

Love your eyelook! And rankings 😊

[@shimmersandsilver]

Thank you! I’m so glad 🍃

[@ac2055]

Ooh~ Very interesting to hear how the ER, SG, UE, and WUB mattes compare! 🤓📝!! It was fun to hear ur rankings! Some of my choices would be diff bc of my prefs due to undertone, but I enjoyed seeing ur ranking order bc it would be diff. My top 3 palettes of 2024-bought palettes would be: 1) Dieverune Dewdrops Toppers are so versatile! Let's me have fun w neutrals at work, but they also transform colors. 2) Adept x Amy Loves Such interesting shimmers that range from neutral to very unique in a cool toned color story that works for me. 3) Lethal Avatar - Earth I love greens, but this is unique bc of the depth range and undertones of the mattes, that the shimmers are very diff from each other and can take the look in diff directions, and that it has this much variation in a9 pan. Some of my other palettes look promising, but I haven't worn them enough to make an opinion yet (Adept Ardra, Lethal Avatar Water and Air, CB Winter Wonderland, Gloss Gods Color of Rain, CP Peach Out, OE Spring Dragon). I think many of the lighter color stories will get their use starting around Valentine's tho. The Gloss Gods current shimmer and matte formula are chef's kiss tho! I also love my singles, but not ready to rank these: Lethal Avatar - Soka no-glitter glitter gel, Devinah (Midnight Sun, Runts, Kazookles, Midnight Nova, etc.), and CP Ice Dream.

[@shimmersandsilver]

I’m so glad you are getting use out of your collection! Lethal seems to have changed the formula with the Avatar collection… The shimmers look much more creamy and less powdery, and they absolutely nailed the entire collab. Very versatile palettes! I almost picked up the Amy Loves palette because I didn’t think I’d be able to get Cold Moon, but now that I have one, I don’t think I need the other. Thank you for watching and commenting!

[@sharonflowers66]

I bought more palettes this year than i normally do. The 2 i have the hardest time pulling myself away from are Bella beaute bar poison garden and lands of enchantment, but almost all of the palettes i bought have been great except the vida palette

[@shimmersandsilver]

Once you find a formula you love, it’s hard to turn away! The Vida palette… Nueva Vida from Gourmande Girls or Melt Vida from a few years ago?

[@asowell]

Love your ranking! I’m so curious why you aren’t supporting Lunar Beauty anymore. Is it something you can share?

[@Lashes_To_Ashes]

I’m also curious!

[@shimmersandsilver]

Hello! In the one video I made with the Lunar palette, a subscriber suggested I do some research on Manny. It seems that he still supports James Charles, who is (allegedly, because I don’t want to be sued) embroiled in allegations and admissions of guilt when it comes to inappropriate behavior towards or regarding minors. I haven’t done a ton of research into the people potentially involved, but it’s all very sordid and I don’t want to be involved in any way. I recommend doing your own digging to form your own opinion, but hope that answers your question. Thank you for watching my video!

[@Lashes_To_Ashes]

@@shimmersandsilver thank you for explaining!

[@asowell]

@@shimmersandsilver Thank you for your explanation!! I absolutely refuse to have anything to do with James Charles so I absolutely get where you’re coming from! I appreciate you taking the time to answer my question and I LOVE your videos!! You have the most beautiful looks!! ❤️

[@shimmersandsilver]

@@asowell Thank you! I’m glad you understand.

[@Katsbeautyspace]

I have a lot and with the sales at the end if this year i brought in quite a few to try. I think the only palette you have that i dont is the syney grace glitzy fritzy palette. I may need to see about picking it up second hand as i don't think it's available any longer, or if it is wait for a sale. Thank you for sharing ❤❤❤❤

[@shimmersandsilver]

Hello! The Blessed (SG x Glitzy Fritzy) palette is still available, and quite nice. Unsurprisingly. 🙂 what has been your favorite palette this head?

[@Katsbeautyspace]

@shimmersandsilver i have severally but my absolute favorite right now is tied between cosmic beauty undergrowth and cooltrals

[@Katsbeautyspace]

Oh yeah and unearthly spring magic

[@shimmersandsilver]

Nice! I want Spring Magic and Undergrowth so much! They both look incredible. I thought that Cooltrals resembled my Odens Eye Jewels and Gem, but I just sold that one to somebody who was in search of so now there might be space in my collection for Cooltrals or Unearthly Gargoyle. We shall see!

[@Katsbeautyspace]

@shimmersandsilver i live the gargoyle palette but like the coolrals just a smidge more not a lot more just a smidge. Though I do mix my gargoyle and spring magic palettes. And they pair well in my opinion.

[@bansheemuse4794]

I enjoy eyeshadow rankings! I absolutely loved the Subculture palette this year, but I pair it with indie eyeshadows. That Blend Bunny palette is so good, and between that and the ER Lands of Enchantment, I am set with pastel eyeshadows. I bought way too many eyeshadow palettes this year, but I did not go crazy this Black Friday 🙃 , so happy with that. I am on a low buy and I am going to allow myself only 2 makeup items a month. I really need to use what I have and I have so many eyeshadow palettes, and singles to use. I am unsubscribing from a lot of channels because the have to have every single release is too much. It is hard to rank eyeshadow palettes but my most loved this year are- Ensley Reign Cold Moon Ensley Reign Lands of Enchantment Ensley Reign Groovy Garden Nomad New Zealand Stargazing Beauty Bay Botanical Unearthly Gargoyle Unearthly Just a Taste J* Gothic Beach Adept Amyloves Adept Legend of ardra Adept Vivette Ladybug Glow Criatura I have to admit I used the heck out of my eyeshadow singles and I am actually having more fun creating my own colorstories.

[@shimmersandsilver]

Wow! You really do have a lot of great ones there! I heard that Stargazing was excellent, and I love the color stories of Gargoyle and Just a Taste. Seems like we have very similar preferences! Also, sidenote, you may really enjoy my upcoming video on January 1! You’ll have to let me know… 😉

[@derrickjenniferwatkins1394]

I'm new to Indy pallets. I'm a neutral lover who dabbles in color. My big purchase was Nomad's Ghost Town palette on Cyber Monday. Now I'm really eyeing the Dragon Eye.....but mostly for the gorgeous packaging💕

[@shimmersandsilver]

Oh yeah, Dragon Eye packaging makes me gleeful. LOL I have heard that Ghost Town is one of Nomad’s absolute best; do you like it?

[@Lynnonymous]

Oh goodness, I brought in an ton of indie 2023 and 2024. I think my top few would be Unearthly Gargoyle, Ensley Reign Light In Your Eyes, Fantasy Cosmetica Harvest Of Souls, and Nomad Speakeasy, Fuji 5 Lakes. I love more, but i think these are my most excited to use currently lol.

[@shimmersandsilver]

Those are all great palettes. I would love to try Light in Your Eyes, and Unearthly did such an amazing job with their Just a Taste color story. Don’t love the theme, but their formula is amazing. And then Nomad with the packaging! 10 out of 10!

[@Ailexyo]

Ello! New to the channel. Nice ranking ❤

[@shimmersandsilver]

Hello and welcome!

[@daniellezadora7637]

Not sure if ur aware but WhatsUp beauty's duos aren't the good Italian formula it's completely different formulas and made in china i used mine once as well and tossed them in as mercari freebies 😂

[@shimmersandsilver]

Ooooh, that’s interesting. I didn’t notice the difference because there were only two shadows. I assumed that they were all made in the same factory. My bad - thanks for letting me know!

[@sandisteko9067]

I wouldn't have time for that much makeup when getting bad news but nice.

[@shimmersandsilver]

I have found eyeshadow to be more of a release for me than I ever anticipated. There’s something therapeutic about being creative, and for me, this counts. Thanks for watching!