Ranking EVERY dark island monster | my singing monsters fan made island

Ranking every monster on fanmade dark island.
Credits to the creators of dark island:
Licoad666
Roman Art MSM
Logan peters
PrimalKev
CjVibess
Exclaim!
Treble Stroke
JakeTheDrake
Cesar The Sanchez
Orde Placus

[@AbnormalOddityGuy]

"It just sounds like a stick hitting a stick." Claves, the instrument it is: Thanks Mr. Obvious.

[@0xxgodlyshadowxx015]

Bro did my boy staclavmite dirty... He fits in so well to the full song, and I liked the frogs guys, they made a nice noise

[@ToastedMallow592]

He kinda looks sus

[@Huggyyy-]

@@ToastedMallow592 how.

[@oofable]

@@ToastedMallow592 dirty minds have spread too much holy crap

[@louisperry6138]

@@ToastedMallow592how so

[@UrLocalPumpkinSoldier]

@@ToastedMallow592 bro is the type of guy to think every thing is sus

[@chillnote123]

" i think it's a steel pan " steel tongue drum: are you kidding?!

[@chillnote123]

@Schmoochle wdym

[@HAT_CREATURE]

@@chillnote123 its more of a handpan correct me if im wrong

[@chillnote123]

@@HAT_CREATURE Handpan sounds more soft an watery than a steel tongue drum, Just listen to the differences And you can kinda her the mallets

[@MissileDoctor]

I hate that people always put Noggin so low, Noggin is the beat of the song, and the heart of it! Edit: they put drumpler ahead of noggin even though they said noggin is a better noggin than the ones they’ve seen, and said drumpler just sounds bad. WHERE IS THE CONSISTENCY? Edit 2: I listened to the full song and Noggin can be heard so well. So why is Noggin so low? Because other monsters sound straight up dumb in the song.

[@MountainDewisthebest]

I also feel like noggin’s design is underrated. I love it because of how random it is!

[@emilywilliams1167]

@@MountainDewisthebest when did the design come into play

[@Benjamin-pt1bg]

Ikr

[@MountainDewisthebest]

@@emilywilliams1167 I was just saying how I think the design is good and is underrated.

[@MissileDoctor]

@@emilywilliams1167 they ranked on design as well though

[@Phobia824]

No one is talking about how the 4 element rating (or whatever) said that they like the idea of a turtle with a long neck . Do they know long necked turtles exist?

[@Phobia824]

Not to be rude or anything

[@raian4594]

@@Phobia824 ok

[@pissheater3k]

they probably do, they just put it like that because a long necked turtle doesn’t exist on msm.

[@akallalsimon1554]

hi

[@KoolAidBeGood]

I mean it's my singing MONSTERS so

[@kris1922me]

I hate these tier list, why do they always put #1 before the end?!?!

[@cheeseguy7322]

every new my singing monsters youtuber be like: ranking my singing monsters monsters

[@MPMandMusic]

totally

[@cheeseguy7322]

@@MPMandMusic I like your pfp

[@rheeeeeee2011]

i have left the chat

[@clammytheclamble]

You used the old Fwog I think

[@Zen_BR]

theyre all old tracks

[@noobroblox1409]

For me the old fwog is way better than the new one.

[@DevMan2342]

@@noobroblox1409 old fwog sounds much worse

[@noobroblox1409]

@@DevMan2342 I think this because the new Fwog is overused, sounds nothing like to original fwogs, I keep on hearing that voice everywhere. He literally voices everything and it is super annoying.

[@theinkyoneiguess_]

I like the old Fwog track more tbh, in the full updated song he’s way more hearable but not in a good way. I have to turn down my sound every time the new Fwog’s part comes on now because it makes me cringe a little :(

[@theIrishlad]

2:20 "I absolutely love the south"

[@VijiKarthikeyan]

0:00 Noggin 0:21 Toe Jammer 0:40 Mammot 0:59 Fwog 1:18 Drumpler 1:38 Maw 1:56 T-rox 2:16 Murkobe 2:54 Staclavmite 3:32 Piktate 3:52 Balabufo 4:10 Gnostrel 4:28 Yap (Name from msm the lost landscape green buddy 💀💀) 4:48 Snakuhachi 5:25 Tenebroise 5:45 Taigitwo 6:03 End

[@zaklee1934]

He is called yap

[@i-laik-slingshot]

Tysm

[@mahmoodahmedzai3863]

GG toe jammer

[@Jonathanlol.]

Why does the Staclavmite kinda have the same sound as Bridget?

[@notsansutplays8178]

Similar instruments. Bridget is a kalimba, and this guy… I don’t know but it sounds almost like a kalimba

[@coffeeZZZ]

​@@notsansutplays8178i think they might be referring to the melody

[@johnjabbour227]

It sounds like pango trying to play bridget

[@MythicalHandler]

​@@johnjabbour227 exactly

[@woa.h]

It sounds nothing like bridget

[@Cannibal_essaywriter]

I don’t like people who leave emojis after a name to fit their name or personality I find it weird for some reason especially maw tho.

[@ICREAMTOHANDTIE]

aint no way drumpler is above staclavmite and balabufo they deserve more

[@BingusBangus]

Yeah

[@mpsrpo]

yeah

[@hux0rd]

Yeah

[@XxWOAHxdcc]

True

[@I-have-kids-in-my-basement-3am]

Balabufo is the best monster on the island including everything on the island and they put the crusty musty busty dusty floogull rip-off in the #1 spot💀

[@saralaainarathan1427]

T-rox is not a dinosaur. It's a dog Based in dawn of fire, the bio says its a puppy as a baby t-rox

[@enri1270]

no its not it’s named that because t-Rex but since its a rock covered body t-rox and ur probably reading the wrong bio or t-rox is half pup too

[@plukohenk_games4419]

The reedling is a dog, the t-rox is a t-rex

[@fried-chicken-]

​@@plukohenk_games4419 rock + t rex = trox

[@Pixolotl0.0]

Facts

[@Pixolotl0.0]

Just because the name is T-rox doesn’t mean it’s a dinosaur.

[@thedabbinggamer3726]

Why don’t people give percussion more respect D:

[@Behumble8289]

thats what IM SAYIN

[@whatsaeuphonium9077]

Percussion sucks

[@bethy115]

FR

[@frontfacinggobbleygourd9264]

it’s already overrated

[@hasmaelaca3724]

"In the full song fwog sounds wonderful but alone not as good but still pretty good" *proceeds to put in 11*

[@I-have-kids-in-my-basement-3am]

It’s old fwog’s sound

[@nano34677]

Balabufo is so good! Its design and sound is so good Also him: *BALABUFO GOES TO 15*

[@luciacanova8426]

Bruh he did not say that

[@I-have-kids-in-my-basement-3am]

Balabufo should be #1 ik

[@Shulkern]

this is kind of a weird tier list im gonna be honest, sorry man but you placed noggin LAST, which doesnt make any sense because you put drumpler (which you said doesn't sound good (???)) above noggin, bro what is your ranking.

[@RandomChannel-nh9no]

In my idea Taigitwo should be the number 1.

[@Goober1342]

TAGITWO SHOULD'VE BEEN IN FIRST PLACE OML

[@arizonamaps]

Snakuhachi Is The Only Snake In The Game

[@thatonesillycatlover]

Actually i never heard of dark island but everyone sounds good-

[@Sunshine-Cat-Cat]

taigitwo was the first one I've ever seen before🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@jesulitomahinay4194]

Tbh dark island is like light island but more sinister

[@arizonamaps]

5:44 Taigitwo, ^our Sond Likes A Kid Music

[@Benjamin-pt1bg]

The best part of this vid was “the only cool” word

[@erintonnous1382]

Is it just me or does yap look like maw?

[@Commanderlaser]

Noggin sounds like faire island noggin

[@koyee23]

msm fanmade becoming a creepypasta💀

[@officialphangler]

i actually kinda agree with this ranking 😊 but i think maw was the best because maws part was pretty good already but when maw comes in it makes me go insane with how good it is but yea i agree with most these ratings also amazing video ❤❤

[@1.s_cake_fun_offical]

Shut up

[@imonahmod8686]

Balabufo is based on beezlbufo, a frog from the prehistoric era and it eats GIANT insects

[@East335]

Ominous Black Void With White Eye Looks So Cute

[@Fanta_and_friends]

GNOSTREL MAKE ME SCARED BRO😱😱😱😱

[@AREALMAN1]

Would Pikate’s hand be a finger or a hand…..

[@agamiskahabdillah2505]

You mean Piktate?

[@Fwog-wj3ey]

@@agamiskahabdillah2505 piktate’s you mean and it’s talking about it’s hand not just the name

[@1.s_cake_fun_offical]

I Hate You I Love Noggin😡

[@Oroark5678]

Taigitwo is mythical of a dojo

[@LogHex]

When monsters have a stroke:

[@Zen_BR]

gnostrel is a giraffe and its a trombone not trumpet

[@IguroObanai_21]

Never rate again 💀

[@RealWheezerTF2]

Please, never rate again 😊

[@MorAyıAmaMistik]

1)Gnostrel🐎🦒 2)Pikkate🎻 3)Mukrobe🌙 4)Taigitwo☯️🌙 5)Snakuachi🐍🪈 6)Teberoise 🐢🌙 7)Yap🦇👄 8)T-rox🪨🦖🦕 9)Mammott❄️👹(MY FAVORİTE) 10)Maw🌸👄 11)Fwog🐸 12)Drumpler🥁 13)Toe Jammer💧☝️ 14)Staclavmite🗿🪨👄 15)BalaBufo🐸🐡(MY FAVORİTE 2) 16)Noggin🪨🥁

[@AsherBeHappy]

eh as a murkobe fanboy, shoulve replaced no2 with gnorsterl and move pikatate down one. leaving 1st for murkobe.

[@ChilledGreeseSandwich]

this guy doesnt know how to rank properly you have to do it from 16-1 not 16, 36, 122387416548, 2, 3.1415926, 1, 69, 1875

[@CR3AMPLAYZ0]

Bro did tenebroise DIRTY- he's literally most of the melody! It's the best part!

[@BingusBangus]

Corrupted pompom? Did they place you right next to humbug again?

[@Principal_of_the_thing204]

4:55 he’s cursed

[@LoarvicLoarvic]

Old Dark Island is better than new, IMO

[@I-L1ke-stuff]

I've never agreed more

[@cjxander9205]

Depends on the monster because old balabufo is better but new gnostrel is better

[@olbaiDiablo13]

*Taigaitwo dies* *me* OH MY GOD THEY KILLED TAIGAITWO *max* YOU BASTERDS

[@bunnicutie576]

You hatched a Murkobe Class:Fanmade Element: Dark

[@dhavieddyby883]

In the full song, Gnostrel last sound before the Tenebroise verse sounds like Strombonin OoO

[@CatBat5905]

me when reading murkobe explanation: Why do you love the south? What does it have to do with this monster?

[@praloedra6738]

Bruh is acting like noggin sucks, don't do one of my favorite natural dirty like that

[@Cornyboi]

I don’t really like fwog because it’s much deeper than usual

[@prestonemeneya2806]

Murkobe sad story is that someone bullying him and the he added mamoth toe jammer and noggin to the party and the gave the instrument

[@ЮлияМалышева-э9ю]

it's not the music there, I had to watch another video. in general, let's get a little worn out in a different way

[@MichaelLeeAdams]

Bruh what are the vocals on this vid, it sounds like you recorded your voice on the vocal monsters.

[@yourbrouji]

Fun fact:piktates breeding is drumpler and murkobe

[@tcam4177]

Why does it feel like taigitwo represent jester in garten of ban ban cus look at his arms and legs

[@redyoguy7]

Me thinking about the island song :cool vs the monsters alone :🖕🏻

[@jeffcantcry3275]

Tenebroise anywhere but 1 is a crime and I will not except this list solely because of it

[@Joran_HeHe]

man this ranking is all over the place

[@pufflecuriosidades]

fun fact: the sound of mammoth resembles megalovania from undertale

[@Draedoon]

Does... Does this guy not know about snake necked turtles?

[@UpgradedTitanClockMan1281]

Gnostrel be lookin like the "let me do it for you🥺" dog

[@gagehornsby9946]

Actually the snake plays a Shakuhachi

[@simondasloth2196]

4:08 bro took the floogull ripoff to first place 👽👽👽👽👽👽

[@trashpandaRaku]

PeopIe ranking monsters be like: Ah yes, i will put all of the 1 and 2 elements on last because they sound bad, i will also put the most overrated monsters on 1st, i only put the mytthicals and seasonals on the first places lf they are on natural fire lslands and magical islands, but in their islands they are on last place because they're "coin farms"

[@insertusername310]

Couldn’t have been summarized better 💀

[@BingusBangus]

Yeah💀

[@felli5987]

Not really.

[@insertusername310]

@@felli5987 Explain why.

[@felli5987]

@@insertusername310 just like, not everybody rank like that. Get it?

[@GangleCrybaby]

Your so wrong bro I love balabufo and staclavmite

[@tictac7892]

Nooooo tenebroise 😢 is my fav monster of dark island 💔 🐢😫

[@Dubious-Duck]

bro snakuhachi aint a flute, they play the shakuhachi which ties with their name

[@DefinitelyNotHarrison]

Your first emoji is your new element This is mine:🅱️

[@ConcernedGD]

Are these the old monsters? Cuz they’re way different from the new ones

[@hedgemchog80]

stalackmite below noggin slackmite adds nothing

[@BirdNovice]

Staclavmite sucks hard. I have never liked claves.

[@SuperBoxSiegeFan]

How did they make dark island like did they use an app like how?

[@catcomposerofficial]

Gnostrel is creepy

[@catcomposerofficial]

And snakuhachi is a copy of roottheto

[@Finsteristic76]

Not to be a hater but this was by far the worst ranking I have ever seen sorry

[@myrabros7003]

Toe jammer and Mammott are Wrong REALLY wrong

[@edithtagnipez8896]

Good thing he did not put gnostrel in any other place

[@titan_seba365]

all monsters in spañol is Pierche mamutto trox raña batarata boz

[@patiencegonqueh5637]

Ugh I'm good just the I really moved

[@Justalittlebun]

Murkobe will be the first but you put on the third

[@ibccenter]

i like your videos and how to breed taigitwo

[@OnlinePlatypus4848]

Maw in this song alone sounds like Josh Gad

[@periclesalvesdenovaes5714]

This to good like plants vs zombies

[@kianandkyriesworld9651]

I LIKE THE SOUND OF THE T ROX ITS SO FUCKING COOL

[@Stinkin_Lincoln]

When I get a KZbin channel, I’m gonna rank every short KZbinr and I’m gonna put you in last place because you put noggin in last place

[@EarthWubMSM2024]

Who cares,

[@swatisule502]

Someone give Fwog some water. Jesus.

[@ihsaanabdur-rahman7900]

I like how stacivemite sounds like

[@jacobsmith8134]

Is the Taigitwo some kind of Ethereal, Mythical or Seasonal monster?

[@dudeman-wb1ql]

yes Taigitwo is indeed a Seasonal

[@Qiqi_Iscoming_inurnext_pull]

Murkobe makes me want to. go to sleep

[@landonb6767]

Frenchie is the best dark island character

[@madisonbentancur143]

It's a japanese flute call shakuhachi

[@paulopipoka]

nah that doesnt sound like mammot thats man not

[@xenithx2958]

900th subscriber exactly 0:51

[@sabarathore5174]

How is Balabufo a puffer fish?

[@James-jn3nr]

I swear I had more monsters lists off

[@ammarsurya7178]

Mammott sound like megalovania

[@Erwt3]

How is balabufo on number 15

[@ihsaanabdur-rahman7900]

Babuflo is like stacivemate

[@James-jn3nr]

List of monsters from dark island