Ranking FNAF Character Designs - TIER LIST

Sorry if my voice sounds off, I'm a little bit sick!
Music Used:
• Save Menu - Tomodachi ...
• FE Three Houses OST - ...
• Fire Emblem Three Hous...
#fivenightsatfreddys #tierlist #tier #characterdesign #fnaf #fnafruin #fnafruindlc #fnaftierlist #fivenightsatfreddy #tiermaker #fnafsecuritybreach #fivenightsatfreddyssecuritybreach

[@VaguelyRowlet]

Remember, this is all my opinion and stuff like this is very subjective! If you disagree with any of my takes in this video, that's perfectly fine! Just be respectful to others.

[@Kalquam]

Also our opinion

[@rakeshganga2271]

True

[@bigmanxeo]

My boy Withered foxy did NOT deserve F

[@danial7050]

Your opinion

[@rumundy9541]

You're Opinion (chain your Opinion chain)

[@Waterrmelonncat]

your opinion

[@Totallynormal_tango]

Your opinion

[@janapavlikova4553]

Nah man he kinda deserves it okay the f tier is a bit too much but if you showed me pictures of withered and og foxy I would probably say "that's the same animatronic" they could make him look more interesting

[@onioncutterninja1535]

Be honest and admit that you just ranked the entity in S tier because of his absolutely chiseled face.

[@Doomview]

MXES do got rizz tho

[@sophitiaofhyrule]

GigaChad Entity

[@34r343]

Nah putting the over designed nightmares higher than the more realistic uncanny withereds is crazy 😭 The classics will always be s tier in my book tho they look so alluring at first but the longer you look the more weird they get you notice oddities with their designs. They are perfect

[@vs3347]

I never realized nightmare Foxy doesn't have an eyepatch wtf

[@VaguelyRowlet]

I found out a lot of things about these designs during the creation of this video that I had never noticed before

[@GeneGerald925]

Id really have to argue for Withered Freddy. He doesnt have the most drastic change and thats why he scares me the most. He still FEELS like freddy but just with vengeance. Him standing in the hallway is probably one of the coolest shots out of all the games.

[@VaguelyRowlet]

fair enough!

[@Red-lu1rx]

​@@VaguelyRowletI need to know this, in this tier list where whould you put Helpy?

[@VaguelyRowlet]

@@Red-lu1rx hard to say since he’s not supposed to be scary, so I have to kind of judge him with different criteria, but probably A tier? He has a very charming little feel to him and he has a successful color palette

[@Red-lu1rx]

@@VaguelyRowlet Yeah true, I wanted this because I like Helpy :D

[@VaguelyRowlet]

@@Red-lu1rx I like him too :)

[@lorislogsdon8761]

One of my favorite designs without a doubt is grim foxy, the idea of him being set ablaze all the time is great, and I love how his hook is replaced with a farming sickle.

[@VaguelyRowlet]

the sickle is very very cool, and since he doesn't have his eyepatch, he doesn't need a hook anyway

[@rosepunk5187]

Bro you call grim foxy to jack o foxy.

[@VaguelyRowlet]

@@rosepunk5187 I completely forgot he had a different name

[@Mr.Freeze420]

Thank god Funtime Freddy got A tier. I really really like Funtime freddys psychotic and malicious yet childish behaviour. It makes him so creepy and putting him in the books is so so cool. Plus Kellen goff is the goat.

[@yams8445]

Withered Bonnie not being S tier should be illegal. Also I would argue the mimic to be low C tier. (The Gregory fact was interesting though)

[@drlolzsilllyz]

about the Gregory fact i think thats just such a cool idea that the mimic would make them selves look more like gregory and steal wool did the mimic story great but idk about the design if he was ennard looking it would be crazy

[@Spiralredd]

The ruined animatronics are legitimately terrifying. Like they give the nightmare animatronics a run for the money in the creepy as fuck department. Especially considering the fact that while the nightmare animatronics aren't actually real in the universe these guys are and looking at what they became in contrast to their bright vivid security breach counterparts is absolutely heartbreaking and horrific

[@Spiralredd]

@@CaptainGlitchTrap how are they not scary. They made me jump

[@Spiralredd]

@@CaptainGlitchTrap like not even kidding I'm more afraid of them than the fnaf 4 animatronics

[@Spiralredd]

@@CaptainGlitchTrap just cuz it's not scary to you doesn't mean it's not scary to everyone else. I'm also 19 years old

[@VaguelyRowlet]

@@CaptainGlitchTrap Relax. If you're insulting people over a video game, you're the one that sounds like a child.

[@Spiralredd]

@@CaptainGlitchTrap and your still continuing to do it. Just cuz you aren't scared of it doesn't mean other people aren't. I'm scared of it cuz I'm naturally sensitive to jump scares. So they hit me harder. But yeah I'm a child I guess 😒

[@BepBepBepis]

18:34 how did I never notice he crafted the costume to resemble Gregory, I feel stupid

[@yams8445]

Fr😭

[@palico76]

Ignoring your withereds ranking ( just objectivally wrong XD ) , this was a pretty good tier list.

[@VaguelyRowlet]

Looking back I do think I was too hard on Withered Chica but I stand firm with where I put foxy and freddy. Glad you enjoyed!

[@bonnieplushtuber5517]

@@VaguelyRowletyeah withered Bonnie and chica are PEAK designs

[@baguettefarm7959]

What abt golden freddy

[@VaguelyRowlet]

@@baguettefarm7959 I'm okay with where I put him too

[@reliablelikekoichi]

​@@VaguelyRowlet B..but you chica 😢

[@Peepaw_Afton_Art]

Endo 01, Endo 02, Bonnet, LolBit, Yenndo, Bidybab, Electrobab, Minireena, Neon Chica, Neon Bonnie, Beacon Bonnie, Burnt Foxy, Dreadbear, Spring Bonnie, Fredbear, Phantom Shadow Freddy, Dark Foxy, Party Freddy, Hardmode Freddy, Freddles, Burnt Freddles, Cupcake, Toy Cupcake, Golden Cupcake, Shadow Cupcake, Nightmare Cupcake, Nightmare Pumpkin, Funtime Cupcake, Dee Dee, XOR, Lemonade Clown, Fruit Punch Clown, Gumball Swivel Hands, Rockstar Parrot, Shattered Chica, Shattered Monty, Shattered Roxy, Mini Music Man, and Candy Cadet left the chat. Still great video, loved it.

[@SesarioYT]

That withered chica ranking should be illegal, i think her withered design looks best amongst all the withereds. Toy Chica is a easy "A" her design to me can feel creepy and i like the how the toys look in general. I would've put Ballora at a "A" or "S" tier for her design tho. Pigpatch, Orville, Mr. Hippo, Happy frog to me go to "B" tier cuz idk why but I really like their design. Funtime Chica feels like a high "B" cuz i really like how it looks and the cupcake looks really cool. Scrap Baby is high "A" tier for me" Molten Freddy to me is a "B" tier cuz i really like the spaghetti feel to it. Springtrap is better than Glitchtrap but I really also do like glitchtrap. Glamrock Freddy is a low "B" (sorry). Glamrock Chica is high "A" for me. I'm not the biggest fan of monty as much so it'll be lower than glamrock fredd. Roxy is probably the best design in Security Breach for me. Sun is better than Moon for me. DJ Music Man is "B" for me. Vanny is a "S" fpr me, I love the design how it looks like a costume and an animatronic. Agree with Ruined Chcia. Ruined Roxy is a designed I loved, easy "A" tier. Ruined Glamrock Freddy is a easy low "b" tier. Idk why but I like the Mimic design, easy "A" tier. Just my opinion but I really like your ranking and understanding why.

[@spookilyunstable]

Ruined Monty gives off wet chihuahua.

[@VaguelyRowlet]

He DOES

[@foolishexpress2532]

I still can’t get over the fact Bonnie was suppose to be blue and then we just this classic purple 😭

[@positiveneutralstuff4515]

Molten Freddy is really just an alright character but I wish they give his top wires to someone a little cooler, it’s a neat aesthetic to look like he’s having to pull himself up in order to stay together or that maybe he’d move almost spider like

[@VaguelyRowlet]

I feel like almost anything would’ve been better than what we got (except for the Blob which is the worst incarnation of that concept imo)

[@Horhaywastaken]

Thanks for taking the time to add non-auto-generated subtitles as an option.

[@VaguelyRowlet]

of course! I do it on all my videos. I feel obligated to since I know my mic isn't too good and I speak kind of quickly.

[@Horhaywastaken]

@@VaguelyRowlet Thanks, I hope to see more FNaF tier lists in the future, and other content as well.

[@Bigggiudo]

No time wasted! Thank you for getting to the point and not making the video any longer than it had to be.

[@murtazashakeel5704]

You forgot the GOAT Dread Bear, and also Freddy Frostbear since he is kinda considered more as his own character rather than just a skin.

[@VaguelyRowlet]

I'd probably put Dreadbear in A. Pretty neat design. I didn't rank any of the AR skins, but now I'm curious as to why he is considered more as his own character? Is he significant in some way?

[@Spiralredd]

​@@VaguelyRowlet Don't blame you for not ranking the ar animatronics because if you tried the video would be three hours long.

[@NooTaYa]

FINALLY SOMEONE SAYS THAT WITHERED GOLDEN FREEDY IS WORSE THAN NORMAL GOLDEN FREDDY! THANK YOU 🙏 edit: you are speaking true fax with the nightmare animatronics 🫡

[@Heyyimeddie]

I feel like the Withered animatronics deserved a higher tier and personally i feel like Withered chica is so underrated and my favorite.

[@cheese_cat1]

I know I'm a month late but i still wanna reply and say I AGREE!! Her design is so menacing with the loose hanging jaw and the cold wide stare she has. It looks a little goofy at first but once you look at it for a bit it actually is a great design, along with her many rows of teeth which just adds to her disturbing design. Withered Bonnie will always be my favorite but chica is definitely a close second.

[@VaguelyRowlet]

@@cheese_cat1 Yeah after making this video, I took another hard look at withered Chica and rethought her placement. She deserves to be one or two tiers higher

[@Rabbit_lady]

I agree with your opinion. Also congratulations on almost 900 subscribers. (:

[@VaguelyRowlet]

Thank you!

[@yusufmaster6027]

Nobody talking about his cute pfp of the Rowlet costume from sun and moon?

[@TireWasntHere]

W vid i related to a lot of your rankings 😊

[@VaguelyRowlet]

Thanks!

[@QuinnDwyer-wm3ik]

Wait, people hate Monty, HES ONE OF MY FAVORITE CHARACTERS

[@sophitiaofhyrule]

Same I love Monty

[@Loogi_boogi]

Great vid keep up the good work

[@VaguelyRowlet]

thank you!

[@splonk7868]

That thumbnail is playing with as much fire as Fazbear's Fright

[@user-vp1fk8ry7i]

For me, in S tier it would have been roxanne, glamrock freddy, mangle, lefty, springtrap and nightmarionne

[@firebombplayz947]

Pov literally any fnaf tier list trying to rank toy Chica without making people think you simp for her:

[@Doomview]

Pretty relatable. Puppet is the best design. But you did our gamer boi Toy Freddy dirty there. No judgement tho!

[@Bred-Studios]

I’m glad this wasn’t biased cuz these are genuine opinions not which characters his favourite

[@Sticky1792]

I'm new to your channel but this video is going to make me stay great video man

[@VaguelyRowlet]

Thank you!

[@anaolari542]

Rockstars rock!!

[@absolutebarry]

You didn’t even go over scraptraps design, there is so much he has going for him and the amount of hate he gets is not deserved at all, I wish you at least observed his design, he isn’t as bad as people say, he has a lot going for him

[@VaguelyRowlet]

I DO regret not doing a deeper review on Scraptrap but he still probably would've landed in F or E tbh

[@Spiralredd]

He would have been better if he wasn't so goofy looking.

[@Zalmoxesuwu]

@@Spiralredd100% He is just so unscary. What really brings him down is how slim his body is compared to his feet and head and his silly ass eyes

[@Spiralredd]

@@Zalmoxesuwu yeah like Scott does a terrible job making springtrap look scary. Even the original one from fnaf 3 looks silly. Especially when he's peeking in the doorway of your room. He looks like he's about to steal your wallet

[@Zalmoxesuwu]

@@VaguelyRowlet I feel like taking away his suit’s eyebrows alone would atleast make him 50% scarier

[@ender01o66]

17:42 Welp, at least we have Jack 'O Moon now.

[@VaguelyRowlet]

Yeah! I really like Jack O' Moon. Probably A or S tier for me

[@ender01o66]

@@VaguelyRowlet He's really charming in all the right ways.

[@burntrap_el_critico830]

only dissapointed about withered foxy but everything else is a W

[@cryptidvirus4649]

I love it because i agree 100%, i would rank them exactly the same XD

[@user-ju6kc5er8b]

No 😊

[@berybluu6081]

you know i love to see the toy bonnie recognitionnn 🤩🤩

[@bonecrushboy2242]

I liked the music, what’s it from? Also you have good taste 👍

[@VaguelyRowlet]

Thanks! The music is from Fire Emblem: Three Houses! Here's a link to it: kzbin.info/www/bejne/pnPUYXuwgrJ1hdE All music from my videos in the description!

[@Hanibear333]

i was so happy when you put nightmare freddy on S tier he is my favourite🤎

[@MikeAftonsWife]

W for putting Monty in S tier i love him sm

[@danial7050]

Some people only want there opinion to be right Why are u getting mad that he don't have the same opinion

[@dwfan91-]

Great video! Drop the link to the tier list!

[@VaguelyRowlet]

tiermaker.com/create/all-fnaf-animatronics-fnaf-1---sb-ruin-tier-list-maker-15097544 Here you go!

[@ReeceCie]

Ur amazing for putting roxy foxy and mangle at s tier

[@vihangachamod651]

Guys uta his opinion dont waya u like him iri u like her ITS HIS OPINION

[@danielbrugovsky6018]

Enters. *sees withered Chica is ranked D* Leaves.

[@toxicglitch9685]

My rank on the Mimic is Low B Tier if he is out of the costume, I find him to just look another Endoskeleton but a cool one. A with costume, I adore the idea of the Mimic putting on costumes, it fits the endoskeleton idea great and honestly if he comes back and he wear multiply costumes if could bump him up to S for me

[@BroColli56]

Withered animatronics did NOT have to be so low. They are some of the best designs

[@personman348]

Good video tho I feel that too much thought was put into the opinions lol also asides from the fun times and scraps and a couple other animatronics down the line the animatronics endos are the same size so how is nightmare Bonnie shorter then nightmare Freddy?

[@VaguelyRowlet]

I just compared their models, Nightmare Bonnie looks kind of shrimpy compared to Nightmare Freddy

[@1HourLoopedgameOST]

enjoyed this video more the I thought I would

[@CaptainGlitchTrap]

Never let bro cook 💀

[@NoobyNubguy]

Bro did NOT just say the withereds are trying to hard and then say the nightmares are good designs, when THEY are the ones trying to hard (still good designs tho)

[@TristanLNeal]

I can't explain why, but I always thought the mediocre melodies looked super small. Like I know I'm supposed to believe that they're roughly as big as any other animatronic, but something about their proportions and smoothness just makes me imagine them as being the size of desk lamps

[@SirPheonixNo8]

Tiny Portable Mr. Hippo is one of the best thoughts I've ever had.

[@BananaArt5803]

Nightmare Foxy should gottten the blank eye along with an eyepatch!

[@VaguelyRowlet]

yeah chica's one red eye/one blank eye would've looked great on Foxy

[@CreatureReveal-ij5nq]

(not including AR skins or Help Wanted exclusives) Missed animatronics: Endo 1 Endo 2 Paper Plate pals? Yendo Bidybab Electrobab Minirina El chip Helpy Candy Cadet Fruit Punch Clown Lemonade Clown Prize King Gumball Swivelhands HandUnit Bon Bon Bonnet Spring Bonnie Lolbit Security Puppet Dee Dee X.O.R Nightmare Endo 8 bit baby Mr. Cupcake Trash and the gang Old man consequences Music man Egg baby Security bot Map bot Cursed bot Wet floor bot Security breach Endo Mimic skin; Gregory

[@VaguelyRowlet]

I wanted to keep the list exclusive to the more important animatronics, but I definitely should've ranked Candy Cadet and the Bidybabs and other memorable "side" characters

[@johnnycripplestar5167]

All withereds below nightmare freddy.... I am shooketh. This is a SIN! HERESY!

[@Sparkling34]

10:52 im glad we agree that funtime chica is terrible

[@Sopsy_Hallow]

where did u get that ennard is 16feet tall? just the eyeball size comparison?? i dont think thats a proper argument for size at all, they're 100% NOT 16feet tall, they're like person sized. also idk if you can say that ballora is taller than baby in appearances, we never see them side by side afaik (the trailer is on a multi-floor stage so that doesnt count)

[@VaguelyRowlet]

I'm not saying he's actually 16feet tall canonically (obviously something like that can't fit inside Michael's body), I'm just saying Baby's eyeball was modeled too small in Ennard's body, so going off that, he SHOULD be 16 feet tall technically. Even though the floor in the trailer is multiple levels, you can tell by looking at their proportions that Baby is modeled to be way smaller than Ballora. I mentioned during Ennard's segment that Scott must have just not paid much attention to character height in Sister Location specifically

[@Sopsy_Hallow]

@@VaguelyRowlet wdym "you can tell by proportions", ballora is shaped like a human adult (roughly), baby is shaped like, well, a baby. ofcourse her proportions are weird but that doesnt matter to her size, thats not how that works

[@anthony19248]

I like monty. Overall i like bonnie more ,but it was a very fresh air to not have bonnie in sb so please stop hating on monty. I dont like glamrock bonnie

[@Spiralredd]

Yeah the only reason they put him in ruin was because people were asking for him and now that he's there people don't like him

[@SadBasiqs]

Withered chica is my favorite animatronic in the whole franchise she’s truly terrifying to look at and she’s so silly and extremely underrated

[@aegonrhaegar]

Roxy kinda makeup but Glamrock chica stole her lipstick

[@Eddo15878]

9:16 the rockstars are meant to be the unwatered withered animatronics

[@FluffyTheKitty471]

I was watching this in my room and I have a withered foxy jumpscare poster in it He is mad My nightmare bonnie poster got roasted Yes I have both

[@ShadowFreddy127]

Actually the place c you chose for Nightmare foxy was Grimm foxy 🤓

[@spottymaxy1628]

A bit overcritical towards withered chica

[@Spiralredd]

She looks more goofy than scary.

[@eggo2]

i kinda feel the same way about withered foxy because he looks kinda ugly

[@sophitiaofhyrule]

Personally I think Springtrap is scarier than Burntrap because Burntrap just looks too frail. He's so skinny he looks like you could snap him like a twig. It's hard to be afraid of a character who looks like you could easily beat him up

[@VaguelyRowlet]

That's fair

[@realtopg5854]

ranking withered foxy in F is CRIMINAL

[@Skye0709]

Wher lolbit

[@Spiralredd]

Ikr he completely skipped yendo and bidibab plus the minireenas

[@eggo2]

never seen an “e” tier before

[@VaguelyRowlet]

It always bothered me that everyone skipped over E

[@MimickingEntertainment]

*Beauty is in the eye of the beholder*

[@Springtrap_editz63]

I don’t like roxy because they got rid of her hair freddy doesn’t even have a head

[@Spiralredd]

I know that's what makes it creepy. And in all honesty Roxy being bald with just an empty crater where a face should be is absolutely horrifying

[@ElizabethMaeSun]

You must be mistaken cause Grimm foxy is not called "jack o foxy"

[@xavierjones1354]

Bro, what’s your problem with withered foxy

[@CRAMDLE.]

Anyone else click on this video because of Springtrap in F tier?

[@boymas2013]

Can you do more FNAF rankings

[@VaguelyRowlet]

This video was pretty fun to make, so I’m definitely not against the idea. I’m open to suggestions on what to rank

[@LuigiStory4740]

​@@VaguelyRowlet How about every FnaF Jumpscare?^^

[@VaguelyRowlet]

@@LuigiStory4740 that sounds like fun :)

[@Gonner-cd6xn]

Where’s trash and the gang?

[@TMGC64]

WHAT ABOUT MY BOY LOLBIT!

[@VaguelyRowlet]

I like the black eyes with the white pupils, but while orange and purple is usually a good color duo, the bright colors fight for attention with Lolbit's mostly white body (that's why those two colors are usually laid on top of black when used in tandem). Also the specific hues used clash hard together. Tangerine Orange and Eggplant Purple don't combo well because Tangerine is a pale shade of orange while Eggplant is very saturated. E Tier :(

[@dumpstersproduction35]

Not trying to be rude but the actually core fore is the withereds not the fnaf 1 charac , overall i agree with u of putting T.freddy in E tier , bro ennard isnt 16 feet tall , hes 6 foot

[@GrubbyViper]

My hot take Bonnie's have the best designs. Another hot take withered bonnie is THE best design in the entire franchise

[@HBEAR1]

Yessss s teir for Funtime Foxy my fav animatronic

[@drlolzsilllyz]

why did you skip lolbit

[@user-yf5kx8re1r]

I Don't Agree With Toy Chica Cause I Hate How Scott Made Her Look Inappropriet

[@Ostlerrr]

What about my favorite animatronic Lolbit :(

[@VaguelyRowlet]

I actually forgot about Lolbit because they weren't in the tier list I used, but I'd say probably B? I don't hate them but I think their color palette is less successful than Funtime Foxy's. But the white eyes are pretty cool

[@gamercentral2417]

Idk bro I just think the toys deserve more leniency. They’re supposed to be children mascots, having a cute design is what they’re meant to have. Toy Freddy isn’t bad he’s just not scary because he’s actually realistic. All the designs in the games are realistic, they all look like children’s mascots that children would actually enjoy.

[@VaguelyRowlet]

I agree, but also I think as horror game characters, they should also creep you out. That's why I put Toy Bonnie so much higher over Toy Freddy. Toy Bonnie looks like a cute, children's mascot but ALSO manages to creep you out, know what I mean?

[@gamercentral2417]

@@VaguelyRowlet fair enough, I just like toy Freddy’s design as a mascot more than a horror character. But yeah he’s not scary

[@Blizzardholocron]

The true question is Bonnie purple or blue… did you just call grim foxy Jacko foxy?

[@shauna5512]

Sorry I didn't spell it right

[@user-bu6ut6fq9z]

ennard hes not 16 foot tall hes like 6 foot but why isnt he 16 foot it makes more sense then 6 foot

[@cadentubeohara3970]

You could’ve at least put my boy toy Freddy fatbear in c for being a nice goofy kid friendly pizza place mascot

[@rifty9322]

I would've put glitchtrap in e or d because of how unnecessary he is and his origins not making any sense But being serious this list was really good u should proud of yourself

[@VaguelyRowlet]

Thank you!

[@rifty9322]

@@VaguelyRowlet 👍

[@Spiralredd]

It isn't about his character as a person it's about how he looks

[@rifty9322]

​@@Spiralreddim just making my own point as to why I would put him in e or d tier but since it bothered u, I don't like glitchtraps design so still e or d

[@Spiralredd]

@@rifty9322 never said it bothered me just pointing it out

[@Based_Gigachad_001]

Toy Chica is an S tier.

[@Detectivesnow]

Bro forgot trash and the gang 💀💀💀

[@kf9235]

Glitchtrap is creepy and deserves the S tier i still remember being creeped out by the final shot of Help Wanted. That said glitchtrap isn't a spring suit that's why i think the original springtrap could be ranked higher because he is in a spring suit.

[@allywannamaker8794]

It's grim foxy not jacko foxy

[@clifford9469]

the bait on the thumbnail

[@BlueorRed714]

Nah bruh he actually put Roxy on s tier

[@Flamingspider613]

Lol bit left the chat:

[@emmaalvarez9965]

When you put withered Bonnie in no s tier 😡😡😡😡😡😡😡👊👊👊👊👊👊👊👊👊👊

[@EMell234]

Toy chica - s+++++++++++++++++++ tier

[@nodoesntcare7090]

Thumbnail is wrong