Рет қаралды 15,502
• My rankings are usually based on online information, each member's technique and some of my own opinions, just not 100% my personal opinion. I DON'T HATE ANY MEMBER of NMIXX, I LOVE ALL 6 MEMBERS. First, I will explain the VOCALS category.
VOCALS
1. Lily (High Above Average Vocalist)
2. Haewon (Mid Above Average Vocalist)
3. Sullyoon (High Weak To Average Vocalist)
4. Kyujin (Mid-High Weak To Average Vocalist)
5. Jiwoo (Mid Weak To Average Vocalist)
6. Bae (Low Weak To Average Vocalist)
They are the gen4 group with the best vocalist in kpop so far, all 6 members have good technique (just because they ranked last doesn't mean they are a bad singer)
DANCE
1. Jiwoo (Low-Mid Tier 5)
2. Kyujin (High Tier 6)
3. Haewon (High Tier 7)
4. Bae (High Tier 7)
5. Lily (High Tier 7)
6. Sullyoon (High Tier 7)
The dance category is based on open-style and there is a lot of detail in hopeflakes' analysis video: • RANKING NMIXX AS DANCE...
RAP
1. Jiwoo (High Tier 5)
2. Kyujin (High Tier 7)
3. Sullyoon (Mid-High Tier 7)
4. Haewon (Mid Tier 7)
5. Lily (Mid Tier 7)
6. Bae (Low Tier 7)
Besides Jiwoo, she did quite well with her rap parts, the other members are not good rappers, Kyujin seems to be the best with some of her rap lines. Sullyoon performed quite well when rapping in Playing With Fire, Tomboy,... Haewon had a "pretty good flow among them" in the raps of Cool and Playing With Fire, Lily also covered a lot of raps with "flow and delivery". pretty good among them" She and Haewon could be interchangeable but Haewon shows a good flow and a voice tone more suitable for rapping than Lily. Honestly Bae has so little rap data, her raps are quite few and insignificant, that doesn't show much from her so she's ranked 6th
SP - is really subjective since everyone feels attracted by a different aspect of an idol performance but I will try to rank it as unbiased as possible, and stage presence is based on the following criteria for ranking:
Facial Expressions
Body Language
Camera Work
Energy
Charisma
Consistency
Versatility
Stage Control
(credit: @xiaoverses)
1. Kyujin
- I still can't believe Kyujin is only 17 while being this good in stage presence! She's at a level that most idols only get after years of experience and improvements what alone is already very impressive. She's really well rounded and an outstanding performer competent in every aspect, her expressions are very natural, she seems comfortable on stage! Kyujin is truly an outstanding performer.
2. Jiwoo
- Now Jiwoo is what I call an impactul performer, you will look at her when she's center very charismatic and energetic! She tends to have the same issue as Lily for energy. There's room for improvement in consistency and versatility, so let's hope she can keep getting even better for better or for worst. She's the best in stage control, management but I think she's more controlled than Lily. There's room for improvement in consistency and versatility, so let's hope she can keep getting even better.
3. Haewon
- Now Haewon is the completely opposite, while Lily tends to be a "in your face" performer, Haewon is a more subtle one. She doesn't stand out as much with her expressions but she's a very well rounded and competent performer. Good energy and body language, nice camera work and she improved a lot in consistency. I think she has potential to be even better if she focus more on having impactful expressions.
4. Lily
- 4th and 3rd place were very hard to decide since both of them are very different performers with completely opposite archetypes and weaknesses. Lily is that type of idol that clearly have fun while performing and it's very exciting to watch it, but unfortunately she has some issues with poor energy management (she sometimes put too much energy where it isn't necessary), consistency between performances and lack of versatility due to inappropriate facial expressions.
5. Sullyoon
- Sullyoon is a subtle and elegant performer, she doesn't do much with her face and her movements tends to be more light and not very impactful. This archetype can work but it's easier to look expressionless and she can sometimes fall into this, but slowly she's managing it better and being able to show entertaining facial expressions especially in lighter concepts, what makes me believe that she will improve with time as well.
6. Bae
- In last place we have Bae, although I can see her having some nice center moments her overall facial expressions and camera work is weak when compared to the rest of the group, what makes her don't be as impactful as the other members. But even with that I can see her potential in lighter concepts, her body language and energy aren't terrible so I'm hopeful that she will improve with time especially with a boost of confidence that can really help especially with the camera.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ---
THANKS FOR WATCHING! Please LIKE and SHARE this video! Don't forget to SUBSCRIBE my channel.