Rating YOUR Photoshop Edits! |

[@BennyProductions]

I KNOW I KNOW I messed up some of the ratings on screen… I KNOW😤😂

[@jeremycreations8608]

Benny…HOW COULD YOU!!!

[@onzanimation]

I was about to say that

[@smorfmello6305]

Lol I can’t believe you Benny. Do better 😤🙄

[@DianeFoxxx]

okay at least you know than you know and i know that we both know ..

[@near9564]

.

[@NoobySteaK]

I love how he gives clear advices and even modifies the pictures a bit to illustrate what he means. He's actually teaching everyone watching this video how to improve.

[@HateHater2205]

It’s good he edits them cause some artists will attack your work but can’t do better themselves. He justifies his criticisms with examples

[@yunxi2715]

😂

[@carbonKaneki]

People don't learn if you hold their hand all the way. Love that you are honest and give good critiques!

[@BennyProductions]

Y E S

[@hassanmasood186]

@@BennyProductions How did you master all your photoshop techniques? Also, how do you use the pen for your graphic design tablet? I seem to have had issues with mine recently.

[@johnmarkantolihao216]

@@hassanmasood186 his using mouse

[@onzanimation]

@@BennyProductions AND IT IS

[@freeadsmaking6585]

@@BennyProductions human sometimes makes mistakes

[@TeamBeastmode]

3:46 “Deserves a whopping 4.5 pixels” *gives 3.5 on the meter* 😂

[@BennyProductions]

yee I did an oopsie

[@paulwitter5184]

Haha that’s what I thought 😂

[@paulwitter5184]

@@BennyProductions „hopes no one noticed“

[@TeamBeastmode]

@@BennyProductions oopsies happen 💀💀💀

[@KINGPANTHERZ]

I was going to comment this 😑

[@ryangoated74]

I like how honest he is, Benny really has an eye for rating photoshopped images especially compared to me. In my opinion they all look perfect😂🐐

[@amoschirwa3263]

Me too

[@robertefremov9380]

It's fascinating how it was all just a simple fix, like making the lights brighter, which takes like 1 minute, but made the composition look 100X better! The example at 3:56 went from 5/10 to 9/10 just by making the windows brighter 🤯

[@G04T3D]

I am not one of the people that has sent anything in for you to rate in this series, yet I just want to let you know how amazing I think this series is! Like, you taking your time to review and critique your subscriber's work teaches me (and the rest of the viewers) so much about designing and it gives me so much motivation to continue designing! :) And the fact that you even take you time to "correct" some of them is even better. It *shows* your though process instead of you just trying to explain what you would have done differently, only using words. Keep up the great work!

[@Mr23Design]

Thanks for the shout-out Benny! That was unexpected and 4/5 means a lot coming from you! 🙏

[@mittenzr7779]

i enjoy how you show the edited versions, it helps me out a lot to visualize what you are trying to say! great video as always

[@ARTTSvg]

Love your work and it's great that you give feedback to others! So helpful :D

[@celticbabs3105]

These are great advising videos from you, Benny! This is a wonderfully honest and uplifting way to show how artists' creations can be improved by pointing out common sense things light adding a horizon, deepening shadows under water, and adding brighter highlights. I love how you SHOW the difference between the original and your improvements to give a visual reference. Please keep these types of videos coming! Maybe I will add some of my own art to be reviewed someday. :)

[@mohammedezzinehaddady7252]

Man your editing style is flawless, i really enjoy your videos a lot, keep up the great work 👏👏👏👏

[@florivia2419]

If this was another rating I would feel bad for people getting three or less pixels, but Benny's just so good rating that it feels right lol

[@framesbyflo]

U need to do more of these Benny! Very enjoyable

[@abbaskazar3211]

3:50 "this deserves 4.5 pixels" the pixel counter:"i think we could go a little lower"

[@yamishjain2497]

3:53 it shows 3½ pixels :(

[@paradox473]

3:46 You said 4,5 pixels but then you only put 3,5 pixels on the little ratings

[@nebula1266]

I noticed that too haha

[@relampagoxd1500]

I thought I was the only one hahahaha

[@relampagoxd1500]

@Gay Killer thx for the info

[@chxlaw8588]

This is just amazing, the fact you give examples to your explanations is just fantastic. Keep it up

[@michaelheighway8584]

On the second image, you shouldn't be able to see the stars behind the dark portion of the moon. Even though we sometimes only see the crescent, there is still a full circle blocking the stars behind the moon. Just a note for the creator! Cool image though.

[@BennyProductions]

I see a lot of people do this wrong indeed. However I often just pick one or two things from a photo. I don’t wanna come off as too critical… Basically I pick the most obvious flaws and only talk about those! I don’t wanna completely destroy someone’s work🤣

[@jamesrodger1439]

This is probably the best creative critique I’ve seen on KZbin. I just found your channel and to be honest I didn’t want to like it, but you’ve won me over with your knowledge at such a young age! Also, I like how you offer up your knowledge without any fluff, just straight forward explanations and not overly flashy production. I wish more KZbin art channels were like this. Great job!! 👍🏻👍🏻

[@BennyProductions]

May I ask why you didn’t want to like it?

[@jamesrodger1439]

@@BennyProductions most of these Photoshop channels are just fluff, not really, giving any substance. So, at first coming across your channel was like yeah here we go again, then you did something that most don’t! You gave an honest critique, constructive, intelligent, yes, hard to hear but truthful! That won me over. I’ve been to art school I work in the industry, and that was refreshing.

[@jamesrodger1439]

So yes, you gained a fan!

[@MONARCH-MARCH]

He is great at rating edited photos and helping others learn to use photoshop by rating them and describing issues and perfections.

[@Zachary-]

On the last photo, I actually liked the original more. A distinct horizon is obviously realistic, and always looks good, but the original is a pure fantasy, and the endless depth in the background adds to the feel of that.

[@atharvabedarkar]

3:48 you gave him 3 and a half and now he's crying 😅jk

[@pranitGulati]

The legendary #BennyReview’s new edition is back with an Episode 2!

[@emiliorios8799]

Best kind of videos. As an artists or designer you need to learn how to receive criticism. So this is wonderful and it’s even better because Benny gives detailed feedback on how to improve. Keep up the honest reviews Benny. And don’t be afraid to add some half a pixel pieces on there too you know. Hearing feedback on the really bad ones are just as helpful as hearing feedback about the really good ones

[@Real_MisterSir]

1:40 something a lot of artists accidentally do, is put stars in front of the dark side of planets / moons, in this case it effectively makes it look like the moon is literally see-through in its shaded area, rather than being a solid sphere. So remember to erase the stars where the line of sight is blocked :)

[@welovesummernz]

Really really appreciate your honestly. At the end of the day we all want to improve and we dont need or want faux appreciation. Awesome content, you're killing it!!

[@nirajfilms1040]

When you explain something about any art...you don't just speak and review it but you also edited it and finished it...so the point would be more clear...so amazing 😍

[@thurst6127]

PLEASE do more of these types of videos Benny, super helpful! 🙏

[@sanjaydqtalkz]

Amazing Edit 😌❤️

[@realouttasight]

bro a 🐐 been watching you lately i fw the content

[@RedCaio]

you should do an IRL (live action) version of the LEGO Star Wars Skywalker Saga poster

[@xistudios3378]

its a great job you're doing buddy, good critiques are always a pathway to greatness, especially from the master itself ❤️

[@RedWall_]

Woah, great video man! Been watching you since 2019! Keep it up

[@gravity7208]

7:00 this was nice focus is not always necessary.

[@lukes_perceptions9315]

The last one is awesome but the thing I noticed the most is how most boat images, the boat doesn't sit low enough in the water, just makes it look floaty!

[@WhatnotArt]

I’m really early!!! Also, amazing job as always Benny!

[@syedm.sultan3658]

Benny: 4 and a half Also Benny: gives 3 and a half

[@neemsfps]

3:46 four and a half?

[@Hahny]

sheeeeeeesh

[@SaurabhDsigns]

Thanks for reviewing my edit.. Benny ❤️

[@UsmanAli-sv8ny]

Oh wow i abosluely love this new way of rating and the mini tips are so beneficial. Thank you

[@wishah1]

Absolutely frekkn amazing tips

[@amoschirwa3263]

I love how he rates them and how he likes all the comments

[@maalaulimikaele2561]

Best different rating advices but I rather agree on the jellyfish, no need too get to close to her face for highlights, i loved how the way it was before… good job benny

[@MStanonik]

I like this kind of videos, I hear a lot of useful tips :D

[@QuackQuackQuack]

Hey Benny, I think the word you're looking for for the underwater depth of field is "Opague". As in, making the water not look clear and transparent. Making it opague and adding different depths to each subject underwater.

[@hobispinner]

hello there! did you mean “opaque” because there’s no such word as opague. also, i think it’s more appropriate to use the word “translucent” which means blurry but you can still see through (e.g. foggy glass) because opaque means no light passes through at all (e.g. the wall) so it would be just one solid layer of color.

[@QuackQuackQuack]

@@hobispinner yea opaque, and yea my misunderstanding, i was thinking of the opaque slider in image editing softwares that changes the transparency of a layer

[@hobispinner]

@@QuackQuackQuack oh, like the opacity? okay i get it now my bad

[@QuackQuackQuack]

@@hobispinner woops, yea opacity, damn my brain not working at all haha

[@yes3dtube]

Best review I have ever seen.

[@AP_Visuals]

Thank you Benny for reviewing my Witcher Artwork and for the helpful comments! Much inspired by you and your work.

[@MinhLaDatNe07]

7:20 MR23 🥰🥰

[@Abba2sk]

God bless our work's for this blessed month of Ramadan Mubarak.... happy iftar to you guys

[@ashurakingrhyzenkukobun1802]

Ill declare you as my teacher and mentor benny :D, your so incredible

[@Marteenofficial]

Some of them are really cool and well made! But also some people seemed to use pictures from pinterest or other places.. should do reverse image search before rating them. But majority is very original and impeccable work. Have a blessed day!

[@zwatchxd]

do they use raw images (from pinterest) or just took someones edit?

[@Marteenofficial]

@@zwatchxd I have seen both unfortunately :/ , but what’s the point? This whole things’ point is practicing , not a competition 😅🤷🏻‍♂️

[@zwatchxd]

@@Marteenofficial if they have permission to use the raw images, then that shouldnt be a problem because its still their edit’s, but if theyre stealing someones else then its different

[@Marteenofficial]

@@zwatchxd yeah I got your point, but I mostly see some else’s edit :/ raw images are ok to use IG but not whole edits… :/ but yeah

[@eduardo29494]

my fav series!

[@cinematic5901]

Just wow! 😍😍

[@HelloCraig]

4:06 I see you Castle Combe 🔥

[@IbieDibie]

3:47 Benny: A whopping 4 and a half pixels! Pixel Rating Bar: 3 and a half, take it or leave it

[@nyanstreem2034]

I love how he puts so much effort into his videos just for us, also a suggestion is remake the sonic poster.

[@diomian_irony]

love this format

[@lukes_perceptions9315]

I love watching these, Some great images!

[@hassanabed-al-hadi6331]

Thanks you benny you are fantastic

[@caydenschmidt9126]

This episode was sick Benny, keep it up!

[@valentinmladenov9667]

How is that even possible

[@jetboxtm4038]

you haven't even watched the video xd

[@itslooth2133]

You didn't even watch it 🤣

[@Erix963]

You haven't even watched the video bruh

[@caydenschmidt9126]

@@jetboxtm4038 yes I have

[@martinlambert6027]

thanks benny i learn soo much

[@ABZDesigns]

Benny! You Are Amazing!!! Please make video about your Virtual Studio! Please...

[@mister.green8598]

Thank you this review as always helpful.

[@773Spair]

Checking image lighting in photos with greyscale is similar to checking the audio phase in stereo music with mono audio.

[@lyssasletters3232]

A great way to teach, Benny!

[@paplu2593]

Bunny productions is legend of ps Btw love from india 😎🤝

[@GoldenEditsStuff]

Ayyyy this was uploaded on my birthday 🥳

[@eastonwest3402]

I love it man!!

[@TerukiVAL]

3:53 benny: 4 1/2 pixel rating illustration: 3 1/2 7:54 benny: 3 pixel illustration: 3 1/2

[@werewolfgamer4980]

You should make a video on how to make a edit will look realistic . Talking about the shadows, lighting, highlights etc.

[@mohammedkj1239]

These vids are cool to watch

[@ak_yt_up]

I LOVE YOUR EDITING

[@KENN0]

I love so much this concept !

[@wefreakout1089]

It’s so funny thinking back on when I started following this channel because I really love watching people create these hyper realistic photobashed images even though I don’t make that kind of art. Fast forward to right now, where I’m literally photobashing an image for a commission for the first time instead of drawing digitally! The learning curve is definitely a steep one but I think I’m definitely improving though. Hopefully I can share a small portion of that process to my KZbin channel eventually 👀

[@deanetty1959]

A Pirate theme next month??

[@youssefbasiony3919]

I love your videos so much and your accent too😄❤❤ From Egypt

[@lucaslafaiete4003]

3:45 Benny: 4,5 Pixel Rating meter: 3,5

[@tanvirhoque1307]

3:50 Here the elephants trunk is very close to lava but there is no highlight of lava on trunk i believe

[@npkgamerofficial4808]

2M comig soon bunny

[@ALYV0]

I had to take a break due to depression. When I back to editing images, definitely, I will use ur hashtag

[@prophydro5558]

6:50 Now I don't know anything, like not one single thing about how photo shop works, but I would for sure add a person looking at the "Kraken" as the main focus! Just like a person swimming in the water.

[@zwatchxd]

yeah, but that will just makes the composite even weirder because now you’re focusing on 3 instead of 2 (boat, kraken, person) that composite is quite cramped because the water took half of the image while having nothing in it, which is just a waste of space in my opinion

[@shukranmaupa3350]

wow...this is very epic bruv....

[@itskunaltanwar]

3:47 4.5 pixel rating John Cena face - are you sure about that?

[@kimsangthanh5376]

Amazing I ever see all perfect

[@anonra9891]

03:40 four and a half pixels. Only show 3 and a half :D fantastic works. GG guys

[@3kill313]

3:47 counting pixels is art as well as it seems…

[@nayanD69]

"Blue isn't just blue" changed my ok ife

[@arshitaphotomax]

I feel your on the work

[@TRMBABAJI]

No one literally no one benny to every image - you need a little bit highlights 🤣🤣 that's funny but also imp 🔥

[@safwansya72]

literally when to the comments to say you gave the dreamy elephants post 4.5 but displayed 3.5 XD its ok we made mistakes. Edit: also the underwater girl that got 3 but displayed 4 pixel rating.

[@Creayum1]

Better than Netflix

[@savqueen-robloxx2428]

3:46 “Deserves a whopping 4.5 pixels” gives 3.5 on the meter😂

[@TeamBeastmode]

wtf dude you literally just copy pasted my comment

[@savqueen-robloxx2428]

@@TeamBeastmode ik i saw 3 ppl post it so i did i thought someone wanted it to be a chained comment but ig its "yours" and everyone knows now anyways so were good👍🏾

[@TeamBeastmode]

@@savqueen-robloxx2428 that answer seems quite fishy since there aren’t any other comments like mine. And to assume it’s a chain? Also of course it’s mine since I’m the person who wrote it! But we good 👍🏾

[@savqueen-robloxx2428]

ok idc so what i did i agreed with u why do it matter, u that press for a shout out bet ANYONE WHO SEES THIS MY COMMENT WAS ORIGINALLY MADE BY Team Beastmode 👍🏾 u really dont got nothing better to do then go look for "stolen comments" 😂

[@TeamBeastmode]

@@savqueen-robloxx2428 so u admit ur wrong and then try to prove ur self right. I never ever “pressed u for a shoutout”. Talk about having no life when u WENT TO STEAL SOMEONES COMMENT 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😂 Direct copy. Lol. Copy paste. Didn’t even have to look that hard for this stolen copy pasted comment

[@gabrielvasilev9918]

3:47 Nobody Benny: Says four and a half puts three and a half.

[@Jul._.777]

There were like 3 times he made more/less pixels than said xD

[@gabrielvasilev9918]

@@Jul._.777 Yeah 😂😂

[@booom8986]

110 like 2 min oldin RESPECT😀😀👍

[@CarlosCruz-ug3sd]

The word ya want for underwater subjects is "murky."

[@t-chot-cho5347]

4:52 on the tigershark‘s chin/lower jaw/belly there shouldn’t be light/„highlights“ because light can’t reach this area. ;)

[@dripzgaming7636]

4:01 looks like the one map from call of duty black ops 1 if ya know you know i guess lol

[@StewChicken42]

Lol, 3:47. Benny says 4.5 pixels, graphic says NAH, 3.5. 😂