I’ve been meaning to add irish literature to my self - education process, along with philosophy, and this provides a lot of helpful information. thanks robin :]
@Skavop5 ай бұрын
That was a very good intro to Joyce's "Ulysses", and I loved the screenshots and footage you used to explain points. Joyce's corrections for the final section of the book really shows how thought out, revised and thorough his writing was. There's the extra difficulty for readers who aren't Irish that you point out; the context and politics referred to. Not just that, though, but the fact that it's written very much in a colloquial style Hiberno-Irish. We Irish love playing about with language, and have various tenses that exist in Irish but not English, and have transposed the English language to expand these tenses. This becomes relevant in Ulysses, because it's a saga, set over the course of a day, but is an ongoing and epic wandering of the jewish man, Bloom, who eventually comes full circle in his circumnavigations and preambulations, and finds his (spiritual) son at the end of the journey, which is a quest for meaning (something every reader of the book will relate to, as it's also a struggle to convey meaning to the reader, in a literary stream of consciousness style). When I read it first, I had a companion reader to help me not get too lost on the journey, and I do think that paying a little, but not obsessive, attention to notes and scheme (particularly the listing of bodily organs within this body of work ) will provide the keys to really unlock this book. Of course, you rightly point out that one shouldn't obsess over each and every meaning, but let the flow of the words and ideas do their thing.
@suneasmussen26505 ай бұрын
I feel that exact way about Pessoa's 'Book of disquiet' (i.e. that I'll keep re-reading until I die) which I find more interesting, less slapstick and more sincere than the part of Ulysses I've read.
@ZacharyGrubbs2 ай бұрын
Interesting that you mention that book, while I was writing my first movie script I was reading both to inspire me.
@suneasmussen2650Ай бұрын
@@ZacharyGrubbs For what I have read it is the masterpiece to end all masterpieces.
@SRBallard5 ай бұрын
Can you do similar videos covering the harvard classics?
@basserman5 ай бұрын
This reputational reading - constant labeling of Ulysses as "terrifying", it does little good for the aspiring reader, especially towards those who may have the initial faculty or affinity for works like Ulysses. Leave this mindset in the past, for it only invokes the current feckless reading habits currently propagating the institutions of today. Welcome whatever works you want to read, enough of this fear mongering for humanity's greatest contributions; we still read them today for this and all other marvelous reasons, least of which should ever be fear or anxiety.
@Sorcerollo4 ай бұрын
Agreed. The book might be "scary" if you're a student writing a paper on it. To anyone else, it's just another famous book, nothing more, really.
@pi3.1415-y5 ай бұрын
OH MY THIS HAS COME AT A PERFECT TIME🤩 I'm going to Maynooth as an exchange student with Erasmus next year and I wanted to buy a proper copy, so I can go to Dublin when I'm there and read it for the first time😍Ohhh I'm so excited 🥳 This feels like fate!!!🥰
@janeneeeee28 күн бұрын
mo grá sa na fíliocht agus na leabhair de hÉire, an teach de mo saol agus mo harta.
@ansonso15085 ай бұрын
Very insightful review (or preview) of Ulysses Robin! I absolutely love the part where you interviewed Prof McDonald, which is very rare and unique for a booktube video essay. Do you plan on discussing other modern classics in this format in the future as well?
@anthonydraper12312315 ай бұрын
Love this video and the style, especially including your professor’s thoughts. I’ve enjoyed watching your evolving video style/content over the years.
@ryansisters15 ай бұрын
Your videos are such high quality. Keep up the great work!
@CMri4 ай бұрын
I love how you speak about literature. It's always very informative, interesting and full of passion. I always look for content creators like that and sadly there's not many.
@jackjax79215 ай бұрын
Lmao youre like the male version of Ruri Ohama KZbinr.
@MothsAreTheBest5 ай бұрын
no way is his name Ronan Mcdonald T_T
@ambreenali.5 ай бұрын
Wow, thanks for all the info on which edition we should read, this is really helpful. Ulysses has been on my TBR for almost two years now and your video just gave me motivation to finally start reading it.
@IvanK1rzhaev5 ай бұрын
Finally, I’ve been waiting for this video for a long time
@Cristian-so5 ай бұрын
Great video. It will help me a lot in my journey of reading Ulysses. Thank you :)
@Varykino19175 ай бұрын
I always enjoy your videos. I enjoy your take on things and the fact that you make me think about stuff. I tried reading this book once: it was like eating a rhino. Okay, from your inspiration, I'll try eating it again. Funny how this book is now over 100 years old and we still esteem it. Yet, when people speak of past society, they always describe the past as being horrible and not of value. But here we are loving the Paris set.
@Literacure5 ай бұрын
Elite content
@7nochannel5 ай бұрын
Thank you for sharing this take on enjoying books that have been so studied they are now mostly depicted as canonical rather than actually fun (even when properly hilarious, such as "Le Rouge Et Le Noir", Stendhal).
@helenskaa5 ай бұрын
I'd love to see more of these videos! Introductions of big/difficult books and which edition to read.
@bujobyfilo5 ай бұрын
That was really interesting, I appreciate all the research you did and your teacher is very nice and interesting too!
@JimBEATTIE-os1jk3 ай бұрын
I have read Ulysses myself at least one time all the way through and I have read numerous individual passages and I agree with the professor in Melbourne that a reader should not worry about all of the details that are obscure but to simply enjoy the play of words the thought processes of Bloom almost as if you're listening to jazz music which is the art of improvisation and you don't understand it in the sense you can put anything to words but you just enjoy the flow with Ulysses it's the wonderful language and the play of words you don't need to worry about Irish politics at the time add politics are always the same anywhere I used to read portions of Ulysses allowed with a friend in New Jersey who has read Ulysses cover to cover half a dozen times and we would just enjoy ourselves and we would lay off and shake her heads and Marvel at the Incredible use of language and we would do this for hours while smoking cheap cigars and drinking Sam Adams beer
@praalgraf5 ай бұрын
introducing something like ulysses in so little time is no small feat, but you did a great job with it !
@ocdtdc5 ай бұрын
Great video
@PrinceAndreiBolkonsky5 ай бұрын
I have the penguin edition (paperback). Still thinking if that's the best I can afford and read.
@LifesHourglass5 ай бұрын
amazing! it was really helpful and fun
@allyedmondson33425 ай бұрын
This was a great one, thank you!
@greglbennett2 ай бұрын
Professor McDonald's advice for reading "Ulysses" ("unclench. Relax.) is how we ought to approach any of these difficult books. You are not going to "get it" all right away or get it all ever. Just read and experience it.