Classical Composer Reacts to The Count of Tuscany (Dream Theater) | The Daily Doug (Episode 118)

[@psychobeef5176]

“I’m trying to count the rhythm, but I’m not succeeding.” Sounds about right.

[@TheEmperius]

6/8 > 9/8 that's one way to counter that part. It's a simple part actually

[@thecalminsanity]

@@TheEmperius yep thats how I do it too. I was counting in 8th notes by habit and it was 6 -> 9 (nice) so basically 15/8

[@edgarmaestre6622]

Yeah, typicall dream theather XD

[@woodchuk1]

@@TheEmperius Similar to The Ocean by Led Zeppelin, except theirs is subdivided as 4/4 > 7/8. End result still sounds like 15/8, just a different pulse.

[@TheRicardosuman]

We've been there so many times...

[@alandoughty1]

They’ve done heavier songs. They’ve done more epic songs. They’ve done more complex songs and more progressive and edgy songs. But for my money this is the song where they bring everything together perfectly, it’s my favourite track of theirs.

[@iau]

Couldn't agree more! They've done more of everything, but this song is just pure good taste, backed up by all the lessons learned before.

[@gabrielpiccolo]

Absolutely!

[@Enochulator]

A Change of Seasons

[@Sleepwokkr]

Very well put

[@undeadd666]

Don't know why, but I don't like them. The only thing I really love though is that 6/8-7/8 riff from the middle section of Metropolis pt.1. Like, that riff gives me a boner. Otherwise their music seems just too light and positive for my taste (dreamy? :) ), despite the rhytmical difficulties. Only occasionaly I find myself enjoying it.

[@yavorpetkov7572]

You absolutly have to react to Change of seasons.. A MUST!!!

[@wyldeman7]

Masterpiece

[@maidtallica]

Absolutly!

[@GL32168]

The best.

[@jeffersonaraujo7591]

Yes, Absolutly! It is a must haha.

[@VHDT10]

Yes! I love Octavarium but ACOS is way better imo

[@Groovemancer]

The ending of this song where the acoustic guitar kicks, still gives me goosebumps to this day, every time I hear it, even after ~12 years.

[@martinknost3227]

Reminds me of Trial of Tears, when Part III kicks in. Still gets me, even after almost... 25 years (jesus christ, 25 years!?!?!?!?)

[@michelebolzoni9358]

I saw them live yesterday in Milan, that part got me mesmerized

[@MnyFrNthng]

Me, too. Not goosebumps but tears after 12 years maybe 200+ listens. You don't expect a so heavy song at the first section get so emotional later on but that's DT.

[@WillWindWonder]

100%

[@cuacko]

Absolutely mesmerizing, every single listen since it was released, times ten when watching live.

[@DlSASTERCHlLD]

Fun fact: The "bitter gentleman and historian" John is talking about in the lyrics is Count Niccolò Capponi, the inspiration for the character Dr. Hannibal Lecter! I don't know how or why, but John got to meet Sebastiano (Niccolò's brother and the Count that took John for a drive to the estate) and was feeling nervous and trapped in this mysterious estate. Then it finally ends with Sebastiano reassuring John it's of course just a grand story and a character, and that he's of course not in any danger and free to go whenever!

[@ludvincontreras974]

Thanks for the fact bro

[@BinxTrophies]

He went with John Myung and the bands drum tech who was an avid wine tester and apparently there is a winery at the estate. There's an interview on here somewhere where he goes in more detail.

[@blandopher]

Actually the lyrics say "bearded gentleman"!

[@tchristianphoto]

To me, this whole album seems to have a recurring theme of having things that seem terrifying on the surface turn out to be completely innocuous -- even positive -- and the album title seems to support such a reading.

[@BinxTrophies]

@@tchristianphoto Yeah they tried to write every song on the album about different experiences they have all had such as a car wreck that JP experienced as a kid for "A nightmare to remember" and Portnoys dad passing for "The best of times"

[@stekikun6854]

When my son was 4, he heard this song and instantly he wanted me to put it on the living room Sonos over and over. He called it "the 19-minute song" and could listen to it 10x a day, until he could sing the lyrics phonetically (he's not an anglophone), even playing the E-D#-B part along with his glockenspiel X) Couldn't blame him, it's such a great piece !

[@TheRicardosuman]

Oh boy! And I'm stuck with childish songs with my 4 year old son... I'm trying some prog and death metal, but he just doesn't care.

[@ryanmalin]

@@TheRicardosuman good luck buddy. Good job dad. My old man taught me to play most of the classic rock epic songs when I was a little kid. I didnt understand the significance of them until I became a grown man.

[@jedinxf7]

that's proper parenting. my little guy loves metal too

[@jpslaym0936]

My son when he was 6 in the same way. It began his appreciation of what good music can elicit and be enjoyed as

[@insafsamaromari5041]

You’re me from the future i guess cuz my kids better prepare for this 😂

[@Tintop]

one of the rules of listening to progressive rock and progressive metal: "expect the unexpected"

[@justdave9610]

Even a blues section in an Ayreon song

[@u.v.s.5583]

Expect that a young eccentric man who lures a young innocent guitarist in a car is actually not a serial killer or even a pedophile, and his sinister brother is sinister just because his profession is a historian.

[@RBos1971]

@@u.v.s.5583 spoiler alert!!

[@TheEmperius]

Actually the right way to do this is: Expect nothing and be prepared for anything.

[@felipeandres8203]

Like jazz or classical music...

[@nickwoollon9855]

21:42 "It's like a mini movie" - oh boy would you love to hear the entirety of the album Metropolis pt 2. That album has one hell of a story

[@Bardizzle4895]

I have told everyone I’ve ever told about this song that it plays out like a story and to hear someone else say nearly the exact same thing was a hell of a feeling.

[@elijahsacco]

Especially that one particular section in Home 😂😂

[@nicetry69420]

@@elijahsacco people that don't know 🤨🤨🤨 People that know 🥴😉💦

[@ConnorHammond]

Standing in front of Petrucci while he slays this live was something else. The way the reverb and and decaying notes filled the hall while his tight lead crunched in front of me was so magical. Make a grown man cry. And the fact the "acoustic" parts are played on his piezo pickup on his Majesty really confuses the ear.

[@ActuallyEric]

The ending to this song is one of the most beautiful sounds Dream Theater has ever produced IMO. It's just SO. DAMN. GOOD.

[@gammanickify]

I have to agree. I would listen to the count of Tuscany and Hell's kitchen instrumental all day.. every day

[@juanramonvazquezmendoza5018]

This ending and Octavarium's ending are the best outros, definitely

[@rahatmahmud5435]

​@@juanramonvazquezmendoza5018Illumination theory, In the name of god, Ministry of lost souls all want to know if you hear them or not

[@bjjace1]

And the beginning

[@TheIllyrianRTW]

Octovarium is definitely a way to go. They also have an entire B side of an album as a 42-minute epic called Six Degrees of Inner Turbulence. Probably not so great for content, but a really cool piece nonetheless

[@TwoandaHater]

ACoS is their best 20+ min song.

[@Dilly137]

I second this, especially live score version. It's a musical marvel

[@firasnacef001]

Octavarium is THE way to go*

[@Metalton95]

@@TwoandaHater A Change of Seasons is their best song* Top 3 songs I've EVER heard (and they're all between 23-31 minutes long).

[@carlosneto8461]

And also Illumination Theory, the string section in the middle is one of the mos beautiful pieces of music ever written

[@VegetableSui]

Consider "A Change of Seasons." Written based on the drummer's experience dealing with grief from the loss of his mother and how it changed him. Really excellent track.

[@RafaelFaenir]

I second that! Another mosnter 22+ Minutes song, but one of my favorites!

[@marcoferrao]

Better than Octavariun I´d say.

[@FanaticDrummer]

My mom grew up with Rush. But she actually preferred DT over them when she heard this song. Thats how profound and underrated it is.

[@Beardfish.]

This. And then do Haken - Crystallised after 😁

[@tusotusin]

I agree! This song has the magic of Kevin Moore´s era. No rush in the song, only story-telling music

[@ivangomez8584]

"This is like a mini movie...", my friend, welcome to Dream Theater's music world...

[@RickGreen_McNutt]

He should check out "Scenes from a memory" - not as musically inspiring as this, but it really is a movie told through the ears.

[@RandyLott]

In my opinion, this is the best performance and composition Jordan Rudess has ever done with DT. Check out the isolated keyboard tracks, specifically after the last guitar solo. He's playing arpeggios, chords, and a counter melody at the same time. Absolutely astonishing orchestration.

[@PabloSaavedra84]

I fricking love those arpeggios!! that part it's my always favorite too from JR

[@gilbrun7830]

Up

[@cassianopereira4775]

I totally agree!! he’s so into the song and never gets carried away with shredding

[@vinniciusrosa8284]

YES

[@faroffgrace5490]

I love those isolated keyboard tracks! I wish they were mixed louder, particularly the piano in the chorus because that stuff sets the mood so well.

[@sabin97]

one of the things i love about your reactions is that you help us improve our understanding of musical theory, which in turn helps us have a deeper appreciation of the music we love and also helps us become better musicians.

[@robbiburrell1168]

True for me also!

[@GermiesCoasterYard]

@@robbiburrell1168 I third this

[@ritblock]

And Mike Portnoy on drums... He does so much wonderful things on this track. This song is truly a masterpiece!

[@JT40_]

Please consider 6 degrees of inner turbulence too! Nice weekend everyone!

[@falloutfan2502]

Lol, did you mean the whole double-disk release, or just the 42-minute long opus itself? The Glass Prison is there, and a great introduction to the whole 12-step AA process (which I'd love to see reviewed as well). But from a weird music perspective, "Misunderstood" and "Disappear" are very nice.

[@bobmac8309]

@@falloutfan2502 glass prison shifts astral planes near the end.... 😆

[@JT40_]

@@falloutfan2502 the 42 minute whole song! Hopefully the live with the orchestra one. You are completely right such a great album

[@99Anarkya]

Definitely a more classical approach regarding Dream Theater's direction in Six Degrees of Inner Turbulence. Would be a great piece of music for Doug to react to.

[@moisesfernandez5681]

6doit it's long, but maybe as a stream? I'd definitely watch that!

[@MM-nd1zz]

The beauty of the whole part starting at 14:22 strikes me every time. Every time. Heard this song countless times through the years. Wow.

[@andrewlamont3053]

Dream Theater had a habit of starting an album mirroring how the last album ended. Glad you enjoyed that experience!

[@luksvasco1]

That went from Metropolis to Octavarium, not? Octavarium had the "it ends where it starts" theme, so it started the same as Train of Thought, but ended as it started, closing the cycle.

[@andrewlamont3053]

@@luksvasco1 you're absolutely right. The band brought it back for Black Clouds & Silver Linings / A Dramatic Turn of Events, but it wasn't every album for sure. The atmosphere of that ending made me remember about it.

[@fendi-bull8167]

They brought back 6-7-8 tracklisting and it descending instead of ascending

[@MetalMann-de3xi]

I assume you're a Pink Floyd fan. Dream Theater is as well. Along with Rush, Kansas, Emerson Lake and Palmer, with that being said Dream Theater tends to be an album band. I hope one day you would consider listening to at least Metropolis pt 2 Scenes From a Memory in it's entirety. It's arguably their pinnacle album that came from a little joke on their Images and Words album which was Metropolis pt 1 (Miracle and The Sleeper) which they had no intention to make a part 2. A few albums later the little joke became something so brilliant. It's a concept album based upon a man having lucid dreams about a woman in the past and it starts with the man at the therapist being hypnotized, and you go on quite an adventure up until the very end where you will get a very twisted ending. If you like Pink Floyd's Wish You Were Here or Dark Side of the Moon album, this is their own tribute to those albums. When they went on tour with this album with the extended band extras they hired for the album as well and covered the entire Dark Side of the Moon album from beginning to end. Dream Theater will take you on adventures for sure and they have a different sound with each album and will leave you guessing what they will do next. I'm glad you came back to Dream Theater and hope you will do more.

[@Wazoodust]

I noticed that about the time this was released, thought maybe it was just me overimagining it....maybe not!!

[@ephesians.6]

10:23 -- lol -- oh, Doug. It's prog METAL 😆 🤣 there's gonna be some crunchy bits. Your face leading that comment cracked me up though cause I have watched so many of your videos and always know when a part comes on that you might not be a fan of so much. 😉 Great review as always!!! This is literally one of the best songs they ever wrote!!

[@nightwishlover8913]

Dream Theater will always test your time signature counting...

[@firestorm755]

Fantastic. First time for me too!. I can hear 80s guitar work, I can hear Rush, I can hear Metallica and I can hear Pink Floyd and the crazy guitar and percussion work of DT going on. Awesome, I'm going to buy this album!!

[@nicholasvinen]

I hope you enjoyed it, it's a great album. Several others of theirs are great. Definitely inspired by the acts you mentioned. I feel they are the spiritual successor to Rush even though they are heavier.

[@EessaTube]

You feel drained after 20 minutes. Most DT concerts are about 3 hours. At one, here in the UK, They played for 3 hours, with a 10 minute break in the middle. Then, came on for an encore and did two songs. One was 17 minutes long and the other was 23 minutes long. So, altogether, they played for three and a half hours.

[@bloodletterable]

I went to one of those 2 part gigs. All seated. Hell of a show, started a 8 finished just after half 11. Cant remember if it was Wolverhampton or Manchester. But it is definitely up there with my favourite gigs, alongside sabaton and amon amarth.

[@EessaTube]

@@bloodletterable The one I was at was at the Wolverhampton Civic.

[@Md-ht3cg]

You get ALL your money's worth and then some at every DT concert. Every one of the 5 shows I've seen has been completely different but not one under 3 hours lol. They're marathoners and I love it.

[@SuperCoon88]

It’s crazy. I went during the Images and Words album anniversary tour on a school night. They played the album, had the intermission, then came back with a bunch of their famous songs, then an encore with ACoS. Needless to say, I was exhausted at school the next day, but it was also the only concert I’ve been to where my ears weren’t ringing for the next 12+hours. Don’t know if the lower volume was a choice by the band or venue, but it was appreciated for their type of music. Ear protection would’ve taken away from some of the more nuanced sections. Easily the best concert I’ve been too!

[@nicholasvinen]

It's almost like they are inspired by Rush 😉

[@AMGU2B]

I’ve known DT for over 15 years and I’ve listened to this song countless times. Just wanted to let you know that, as someone who is not trained in music (let alone classical music), I’ve enjoyed this video so much because it has allowed me to understand this song at a whole new level thanks to your expert comments. God bless you.

[@fernandocast435]

I love this song cause it's "I shat my pants over nothing lol"

[@HollowGolem]

Having been to some of those chapels in Italy where they literally have the dead remains of a saint inside a clear glass altar, it can freak you out. Add to that somebody like John who has a panic disorder, which he's talked about in the past and even written a song about, and I could definitely see how he could freak out.

[@RezaKulasidini]

Or "He's so weird, I'm gonna die."

[@zacharykim295]

@@HollowGolem JP has a panic disorder? I never knew that, he always seems so chill.

[@SuperCoon88]

@@zacharykim295 Panic Attack makes a lot more sense now

[@senditkevin]

@@SuperCoon88 oooOOOooo ok.

[@RareHarmony]

4:46 "It's almost like Jordan's playing keyboard with him... no he's not..." *Me* "Oh, yes he is!"

[@johnnelson3869]

DT are on another level. It's cool to see others in the know light up at the brilliance of Dream Theater. It's pure, it's polished, it's thoughtful, it breathes, it shreds, and your reaction to it is awesome. Thanks!

[@mehulsheth7688]

The quiet sublime smile at 16:10 when Petrucci swells to that high F# says it all 😌

[@gabrielnascimento161]

I just loved the explanation of the E D# B motive. I don't have any extensive knowledge on music theory, but I was glad that I managed to really understand it (had to build the chords, though, since it still isn't something that comes naturally to me yet). And the best part is around 20:00, how Doug is so happy about getting the smartness of the music. It's so inspiring to see someone so excited about something they like, he must be a really awesome teacher.

[@gabrielpontual9735]

oh boy, can't wait for Octavarium

[@torture10]

I'd love to see the live version :)

[@gabrielpontual9735]

@@torture10 the Score version, right? It's amazing!

[@torture10]

@@gabrielpontual9735 Yes :) My favoritve - the drum cam ;)

[@omarlinan3234]

Same thought when I see this

[@chadhoward07]

@17:00 that's one of john electric guitars that has a piezo pickup that gives an acoustic sound. I can tell it's an electric guitars by how crisp the strings sound.

[@woodchuk1]

This kind of reaction is EXACTLY why I subscribed, Doug. You have a great ear for pitch. One thing I thought I’d point out is the contrary motion at the end of the ambient section in the middle, before the final acoustic bit. The guitar figure descends from B to A# to G#, while the chord progression ascends from E to F# to G#min. So the solo phrases target the fifth, major third, and tonic of the underlying chords. There’s also some parts in the beginning where the tonality almost seems to briefly shift to E Lydian, mostly where the keyboards play over that alternating E-F# bit. You sound like you probably have a good idea of the chords...you caught the minor iv chord in the middle part, and I can give you the full chords if you’re interested. Please don’t stop the Dream Theater train...Octavarium next! Great reaction!

[@Cestariarts]

Hey Doug. I attended a DT concert this past Wednesday and they played The Count of Tuscany, so emotional!!! Thanks for your review. I have visited Lithuania as well, beautiful country.

[@petermalik2536]

"Learning To Live" should be very interesting concerning time signatures etc.

[@Diola_Drone]

Masterpiece,my Dream Theater favourite 🎩

[@christianrojas3357]

Totally agree.

[@steev11]

That last guitar solo is one of John’s best. I love that last run where he uses a pedal tone in that descending line and then he bursts into that ascending run. Wow.

[@elBanananas]

I cannot wait for you to hear Octavarium. For me this is the greatest masterpiece from Dream Theater, especially when you know all the hidden meanings. Out of this world.

[@KhordLizardMage]

Indeed, it is a highlight of their epic career.

[@Aquila81]

Yes!! "octavarium" or "a change of seasons", absolutely!!! Please Doug 🙏

[@derrickmelton5844]

The thing about Octavarium is that it isn't as great as a solo song...you NEED to really listen to the whole album to fully appreciate the song, because the other tracks really contextualize what the song is about.

[@elBanananas]

@@derrickmelton5844 Yes. But once you know the hidden meanings and all it's very listenable on it's own.

[@Ja-mbi]

What hidden meanings? In the song or the album? I’m curious about them.

[@christianbenson67]

Dream Theater's "Illumination Theory" is not only an outstanding song, but has probably one of the most beautiful pieces of classical music inside of it..

[@Cheese-0x]

Absolutely. It's one of my favorites to hear live from the more recent songs.

[@Gamfam23]

Yes

[@theeuropeanlegacy5075]

Lmao. This is an overrated song compared what DT produced before 2009

[@BradenMcClure-q6k]

​@@theeuropeanlegacy5075whatever you must be one of the whiny baby's who don't know how to get over portnoy leaving the band so heres my advice to you. SHUT YOUR MOUTH 😑

[@RobCaldera]

In addition to Octavarium, which is a must, try Illumination Theory, which is a 22-minute Dream Theater epic. And don't forget Change of Seasons too! And "In the Presence of Enemies, Parts I & II," and "Six Degrees of Inner Turbulence"...you've got lots of Dream Theater epics to cover. :)

[@XxDar10xX]

Yes! A Change a Seasons is an experience, my favorite from them.

[@JosesAmazingWorlds]

The long pieces are just boring. DT don’t need that kind of thing when you have written over 10 minute pieces in the same album.

[@RobCaldera]

@@JosesAmazingWorlds Boring?! They’re masterpieces. That’s certainly an unpopular opinion.

[@JosesAmazingWorlds]

@@RobCaldera I don’t mind having unpopular opinions. Saw them live and people were yawning when after one hour of lengthy pieces they played an instrumental. The closing track on the Dream Theater album is boring. DT playing with orchestras is just them playing at being directors. Having said that, they have full albums that are masterpieces in their entirety, like Images, Metropolis or Systematic, even Awake, but not those 20 minute pieces, not for me.

[@RobCaldera]

@@JosesAmazingWorlds I’ve seen them live a few times too and I’ve never seen people yawn. I mean, this is what they’re known for, as is the whole genre of progressive rock/metal.

[@hanssalosensaari2118]

Hello Doug and greetings from Finland! I´ve been watching your videos for a while now and wanted to tell you why your content is so great. I´ve been listening and following Dream Theater and Nightwish (also Iron Maiden) for over 10 years and as a guitar player I know most of these songs you have reacted to. It´s always nice to see how you really understand music and are able to tell what chords and notes you hear and how these combinations of chords, notes, lyrics are used to tell a story. This is really a professional analysis of these songs and some of your comments make me see and hear new things in these songs and understand them better. For example, in this song you noticed those keyboard notes and their relationship with the chords. I`ve always thought it just sounds cool, but now I understand why. I`ve listened and played this song over hundreds of times and still I´m like "oh yeah, that´s true by the way!". Also nice to see how you really appreciate these songs and musicians and how much you enjoy them! There are so many requests what songs you should listen to next. There are some truly amazing Dream Theater songs I think you would enjoy and I believe your followers would like to hear your analysis about. Metropolis Pt.1 is a great song yes, but if you listen and react to that, you REALLY should also listen to Metropolis Pt.2: Scenes from a Memory, the whole album! It´s a long album and would probably take you a whole day to really react and dig into. :D But that album is such a great piece of music. If you think Count of Tuscany is like a mini-movie, that album is like a whole movie series 6/5 stars. If you want to hear something different from these guys, you should listen to Space-Dye West. Change of Seasons is an epic song. Yes, it´s 23 minutes long, but such an awesome song both musically and storywise, really worth your time. Octavarium is requested a lot and that one is also one of their greatest songs and yet again, quite an interesting story. The last request from me is The Best of Times. Also one of Portnoys last songs with DT, in fact the song just before Count of Tuscany in this album and lyrics written by Portnoy for his father who had cancer and passed away. Such a beautiful song and interesting musical ideas (not those 20 notes per second unisons this time). Yeah Doug. I really thank you for making these videos and sharing your thoughts about these songs! There are so many videos people reacting to music and being like "oh oh oh my God so cool damn whoa" every time they hear even a C major chord on a piano. Sometimes feels like overreacting. And of course music is meant to make you feel something, you don´t need musical knowledge for that. If the reactor doesn´t understand music, of course the reaction is their only "tool". But when a person who knows a lot about music thinks they hear something cool and is able to tell why it´s cool, you can learn something you can try yourself. Of course that might not be so interesting or entertaining for those who don´t play any instruments, but everyone has their audience. Keep going and keep enjoying music Doug! All the best!

[@Md-ht3cg]

Outstanding comment mate, and I couldn't agree more. I very much appreciate they way he can break down the composition elements and bring them together

[@albinlundberg5583]

My dad introduced me to dream theater when i was 8 (2009) the count of tuscany was a song that struck me immediately for some reason and since then its been our biggest object of bonding. This album and in particular this song is our mutual favourite. Loved this video!

[@increase9896]

My dad bonded with me by getting drunk and and coming into my bedroom while I was asleep to love me.

[@albinlundberg5583]

@@increase9896 I dont know if there is a joke with an implication of the word ”love” in your sentence but if there was real parental love im happy for you to have had it (even if he was drunk)

[@jacobhumphrey3535]

This was the album that got me into Dream Theater. I bought it randomly after taking my ACT, and was just blown away by this song. Dark Clouds and Silver Linings is very underrated by most fans I feel.

[@albinlundberg5583]

@@jacobhumphrey3535 I agree! I always feel like it gets, almost ignored, when speaking of great albums or songs. My number 1 favourite dt album for sure!

[@lachlanrusin987]

That's a beautiful story man

[@DamienDrake]

This is one of my favorite pieces of music ever. Add to that the narrative it tells and you've got a true masterpiece. The whole thing is great, but the story's denouement, when we finally get to hear from the Count's perspective, is the icing on the cake for me. "Go and tell the world my story Tell about my brother Tell them about me The Count of Tuscany" That sentiment really packs a ton of emotional weight for me. The notion of being so deeply misunderstood while only wanting to be remembered as who you are is a kind of simple, deep beauty rarely heard executed so well lyrically as well as musically. LaBrie's vocals are tremendous throughout the piece and they truly shine in the last section. The whole piece is brilliant at covering the mystery, perceived danger, misplaced terror and, finally, understanding. The album is one of my favorites by Dream Theater for sure, and this is one of the best album-closers ever.

[@billymaus6287]

Loved this! I suggest giving “In the presence of enemies pt 1 and 2” from their Systematic Chaos album a listen, it’s a 25 ish minute epic. They didn’t want to open the album with a 25 min track so they spilt the track and put part 1 at the beginning and part 2 at the end. Great movements in the song.

[@julioluiz]

To me, ITPOE is the best album opening of all time. Part 1 intro until the lyrics makes me so emotional I can't fathom to explain. When I had the chance to catch DT live in 2019 and they played pt 1, it was one of the best moments of my life.

[@moreisallyouneed4175]

@@julioluiz ITPOE is a metaphor for just about everything in life - I used to joke that ITPOE is really about (love, drugs, sex, getting coffee at a slow drive-thru) and then explained why - That's how universal and relatively simply the story of the song is - Coming up, struck down, darkest moment (Deal with the devil), mourning of their choices, Change of heart and Redemption) - I maintain that it is where the story line for World of Warcrafts Wrath of the Lich King Death Knight starter zone gets it's influences haha. Fun game to play - the making everything related to ITPOE, i mean.

[@MechMonstrosity]

I would literally buy DVDs of you analyzing songs. It's not just a reaction what you're doing, you open up my eyes to little music trivia that I would've never understood on my own. As a PhD student who's constantly working, your channel is pretty much my only source of entertainment 😂 So thanks for that!

[@memoregalado3651]

The final guitar solo is one the most memorable from Petrucci!!

[@reman81]

that and the of Best of times one( that i consider the most emotional JP has ever written)

[@hewp-xe2pe]

The best of times is the most memorable I think. But this one is close second

[@Bardizzle4895]

I am writing my comment through tears my friend. This has been my go to dream theater song through everything. Anytime I’m feeling down, I listen to it and it all just makes sense. When you started saying that it was like a mini movie, I immediately burst into tears because that’s what I’ve told everyone I’ve ever talked to about this song. I still remember feeling this heightened elation when the chord progressions return at the end because it’s like everything (musical and lyrics) comes full circle and it’s so satisfying. Easily one of the best songs I’ve heard in my whole 28 years of life. Cheers, you’ve earned a subscriber and supporter!

[@Tintop]

"Rhapsody In Blue" by Liquid Tension Experiment (with Jordan Rudess, John Petrucci, Tony Levin, Mike Portnoy)

[@amo757]

Yes! What an amazing song.

[@increase9896]

Liquid tension experiment sounds like a parody of a prog band name. So ridiculous.

[@maxhowlett9661]

@@increase9896 pretty sure that was the point. An intentionally OTT prog supergroup, who do a very niche genre very well

[@hawksfan5151]

Absolutely. Either Gershwin loves it or is rolling in his grave. I personally love it!

[@christofferlundgren5681]

How can you hear every chord so fast and identify them its truly amazing 👍🏼 Great videos 👍🏼

[@Doug.Helvering]

years and years of practice...

[@cappuccino4366]

Recomendations: Pale Blue Dot, Metropolis pt1, 6 Degrees of Inner Turbulence, Erotomania.

[@counterfit5]

I’ve watched the video of Mangini explaining the polyrhythms in Pale Blue Dot. I think I ended up more confused afterwards.

[@vitoravila9908]

I'd love to see Metropolis, such a classic

[@lorenzoturchetta8822]

Yeah but there are so many DT songs to recomandate like all the album of metropolis pt.2, pull me under, the enemy inside, fall into the light, STREAM OF CONSCIOUSNESS, Octavarium, Panick attack, in the name of god, the root of all evil etc....

[@dennissnyder6447]

This is my favorite one you've done. This song is just a masterpiece. You are so spot on. That piano bit over the G# progression, I can't not hear that anymore. What a brilliant observation!!

[@AToutProductions]

This is one of the many reasons I love Dream Theater. No matter how many times I've heard a song this is always something I never noticed before. You even pointed out a few things I hadn't noticed yet. Be prepared for when you do Octavarium, might need a pen and paper and a couple drinks haha

[@DanielCorrea86]

So wholesome at the end with your commentary, so nice!!!

[@mattiagaleone7726]

"End of the begnning", by Jason Becker. Before doing it, go check out Jason's history. A phenomenal guitar player who got diagnosed with ASL in his early 20's and he's still alive composing music.

[@leighjones4396]

This is an awesome reaction! Analysing on the fly, without stopping, providing enough detail without over or under doing it. I can see you have lots of experience and you know your stuff - thats what made it possible. Loved it :)

[@arpeggioblues5924]

AWESOME, Doug.. AWESOME.. I love your descriptions of the songs.. the form/musical styles/following modulations and with Dream Theater, the mix of all kinds of time signatures, that oscillate thru out their works becuase they are more than songs, they are works of art in music .. :)

[@shoryuken3305]

I just want to say I appreciate how you explain the notes I dont know a single thing about music but it made sense to me how they arranged that ascending melody near the end thank you!

[@jIescareno]

Dream Theater Is one of the last Greatest AND genious rock band of the history. From Berklee college of music in Boston.

[@lorenzomidabatacchi5342]

such a privilege to have this masterpiece explained by a professional, thank you!

[@johnjacobs7283]

Fantastic analysis on a great composition!

[@do8671]

Man that was a great reaction video, with one of my favorite DT song! At 11:50 I totally agree with you, and thx for that, you respect the song and the auditors!

[@theangryhog]

I always enjoy watching reaction videos to Dream Theater, whom I consider to be a phenomenal group of artists on every level, by people who "get it". And you, my friend, definitely get it. Thank you!

[@oklahomabonfire4022]

Hey nice listening to this with you! One of my favorite DT songs. I enjoyed your perspective!

[@bbad21]

Gran reacción!!!!! Me encantó, ojalá y algún día pueda ponerle subtítulos a sus reacciones Maestro, un saludo y hasta pronto!!!

[@dapksp25]

So glad there are others out there that appreciate and really soak in the epic DT sound and complexity of the music..THE BEST PROG METAL BAND ..PERIOD

[@TravisLohmannMusic]

how am I just NOW finding these videos; so cool to see you reacting to some of DT's works! I'm definitely going to check out the rest of them!

[@nedrini1387]

My friend you need Illumination Theory in your life. You will love it. Also it must be the live version at the Boston Opera House.

[@mattolsziewski7164]

I was fortunate enough to see them twice on that tour in New York and I bought the blu ray of the show at the Boston Opera House. The 5.1 mix sounds terrific, it’s a shame that it’ll be neutered by KZbin compression and in stereo, yet it’s amazing that you can go on and experience it for free at the same time.

[@costacafj]

Years since first time I listened to this song and still give me chills, especially the lyric. Glad you came with this one, there's a lot of DT songs to listen now!

[@Charlton222]

I've never been a Dream Theater fan (I've tried!) but I have to say that this is the first song from them that has really clicked for me. It's absolutely epic. The music, lyrics, production, arrangement, execution - it's all so good. Dream Theater was always cold to me - very clinical, almost too technical for their own good. Not this song - it's so tasteful. Even the lyrics show vulnerability. The Count of Tuscany is hopefully the breakthrough song to get me deeper into the band's catalog. Thank you, Doug. Without you, I may have never have heard this!

[@634983]

The singing puts me of a bit but petrucci is really good

[@Charlton222]

@@634983 His voice is what I have most trouble with, too. And I like Geddy Lee's voice so I don't understand why I'm having trouble with this guy (James Labrie?).

[@sophiaperennis2360]

I find them a bit sterile to be honest. Technically accomplished sure, but not really quite as creative as one would have hoped. Also, as virtuosic as their music is, i find it interesting how they demonstrated they couldn't really improv that well with their short stint with Tony Levin.

[@porfiriodev]

Listen to metropolis pt2, octavarium and black clouds n silver linings

[@planetcaravan2925]

​@@sophiaperennis2360 this is pretty creative, but i think they are cheesing too much

[@gregorykenfield3134]

My absolute hands-down favorite song of all time by my favorite band! I'm so pleased that you were as impressed by it as I am...thank you for reviewing it. You are correct about the vocal point of view shifting near the end. I love how James LaBrie sings both parts differently to play both characters. One aspect of the overall piece that people seem to miss in the first listen is that the final chord sequence that you enjoyed so much was actually introduced in that ethereal middle section just prior to the acoustic guitar, then it was elaborated upon as you noted. Perhaps "reintroduced" would be more accurate, since this song was a case study in creating diverse sonic paintings using a common theme throughout (somewhat the opposite of what Dream Theater is known for). I would definitely love to hear your thoughts on "Octavarium" next...it is a much more keyboard-heavy epic that Jordan really shines on. Other songs you might consider are "Illumination Theory" (especially live from "Breaking the Fourth Wall"), "In the Presence of My Enemies parts 1 and 2," and "A Change of Seasons." God bless!!

[@amaryllis604]

I agree! I just love the way the instrumental parts and the vocals tell the story. And I'm especially happy that you mentioned the shift between the characters' voices. That is something that many people seem to overlook because the amazing instrumental parts sometimes overshadow the vocals. But the way JLB can adapt his voice to pretty much every complex melody and portray so many different characters is very impressive imo.

[@voithmascarenhas]

Wow! I got a new perspective about this song glancing from the eyes of an educated musician! Awesome! Thanks, Doug!

[@Lerxst3333]

Really enjoyed that. Thank you. Saw it live in Toronto. Thanks for bringing it back to my attention.

[@MisterSmith00]

When I was younger, I had a period where I broke HARD into music…particularly rock music, and metal. I would pour through the music cd section; and any of the album covers that caught my eye I would snag and peer through their track lists…anything that sounded interesting, would claim the treasured “3 CD buying limit”. “Black Clouds & Silver Linings” earned one of those spots (next to Judas Priest “Greatest Hits” & “City of Evil” by Avenged Sevenfold)…the track titles just piqued my interest. What a glorious weekend that became…fond memories. Music was a mystery; the journey of discovery was a joy, and very dear to me.

[@wiltoncalixto]

this is my favorite song, of all my life! ❤️❤️ Thank you so much for reacting to this! But hey, A Change of Seasons is a MUST! No kidding!

[@SeanMitchell4574]

Portnoy is famous for his cyclical writing and reoccurring themes, also does this with Transatlantic and Neal Morse Band... one the things I love about his influence

[@michaelflorczyk1394]

The Glory Of The Lord is a great song by Neal Morse Band

[@coolvidz1763]

Sir, I was absolutely amazed with your knowledge and analysis. It was such a great pleasure to see someone react with in depth (trying) to understand what Dream Theater is doing. Thank you.

[@sowyouthinkyoucanplant5630]

Watching someone appreciate one of my favourite albums is so satisfying, and I get to appreciate it too

[@mcclane110]

Wow. Your way to explain music is brilliant and inspiring. I suck at music theory, but you are inspiring me to study it so as to appreciate DT more than what I do!

[@Dr-Shred]

Yes! what an epic song this is. We definitely need octavarium and a change of seasons

[@vohomusic]

I know this song for a long time but I got a totally new and fresh perspective on it... thanks Doug! It is giving me more chills now :D.

[@maxmintz511]

By DT’s own admission, “In the presence of enemies” was their ultimate PR composition. Part 1&2. Worth your time.

[@txusinbilbo]

The face of a music composer reacting to a piece of art. Lovely. Music lights up something in those who love music. No matter culture. Thanks for sharing this reaction, Doug. It´s a real pleasure to watch your videos

[@humanikiakaw]

oh my this is a masterful piece of music

[@kajpaananen5082]

I just love when you are able to explain the songs as they go in theory, meaning keys, chords, notes and related things. It gives so much insight to the songs and especially to the songwriting of these songs. - keep up the great videos

[@scottrobinson4611]

Of the hundreds of 'X person reacts to song Y' videos I've watched in the last few years, this has been the most informative - and it's for one of my favourite songs. I really love how you highlight the chord progressions and the over-arching themes they follow. I'm a mediocre drummer, so my music theory knowledge only really covers rhythm, not notes and chords and keys. So if I've followed correctly, the chords progress throughout the song. Then towards the end they have that 3-note motif thing made up of notes that work with all the chords they've used previously. In this section, they progress through those chords again, almost 'revisiting' the whole song thematically. Then they come full circle and finish with the same chord they started on. I've probably misunderstood a few things and confused chords for keys, but this is still the most one of these videos has taught me about any song.

[@devharris8400]

Hey Doug, just discovered your videos a couple of months ago. Thank you for this and all of your breakdowns of Dreams Theater. I've loved them for a long time and this song is one of their masterpieces in my opinion. I am/was a guitarist in my younger years and my knowledge of music theory is pretty peripheral, but I know enough to appreciate your perspective. Again, thank you! Best wishes from west central Florida. 😄

[@daveg7896]

Doug, if you’re into the longer “epic” DT pieces that tell a story, I’d recommend “In the Presence of Enemies” part 1 and part 2. They are separated on the album, but with the convenience of technology can be played back to back. Enjoy!

[@robbiburrell1168]

I absolutely agree... In the Presence of Enemies (pt. I & II) is Awesome!

[@shade3385]

I finally got to see Dream Theater live this past Saturday during their dreamsonic tour. When they played The Count of Tuscany I absolutely lost my mind. I thought I would never be able to listen to this live... it was amazing in every way live and you can bet your ass I sang every word of this song. The best part was that they did an encore afterwards and ended up singing The Spirit Carrie's On with the other two line up bands playing it with them. What a great and wonderful experience!

[@joemills4603]

Thanks for doing this song!!! One of my favourites of theirs, on an otherwise mixed album for me: Sometimes felt like they were trying too hard, but other times nailing it perfectly. 10:25 Most times Portnoy tries to harmonise, I find myself irritated and detached from the song. Sometimes, DT lack a really innovative approach to vocals... which is a shame. This song generally uses Labrie's voice very well. 13:23 For me, this section exposes the heart of DT. Especially Petrucci's amazing emotional writing. I know he's fast and all that, but I love his emotion... Somewhere between Gilmour and Rothery. 19:38 Thanks for highlighting this! I've always loved the composition in this section, and now I understand it more. 21:33 Probably my favourite Petrucci lead. Certainly from the post-CoS albums.

[@nicholasvinen]

Gilmour and don't forget Lifeson!

[@joemills4603]

@@nicholasvinen I'm not sure I hear a strong Lifeson influence here... can you give me some suggestions?

[@zubiecup]

I loved this video, man. This is the first video of yours I had ever watched, but I subscribed right away.

[@JerGol]

02:40 - "...kind of a simple chord progression." DT: *Oh, you gon' regret that!*

[@RonVasil-j4k]

Thank You Sir !! for your genuine honest reaction ! Dream Theater is one of my all time fave bands.... If you have (you tube allotment), may I suggest by them"Six Degrees of Inner Turbulence" Magnificent story.. Music.. Composition .... yeah ya might have to break it up into a couple react vids.. but none the less.... A Brilliant piece of work... Cheers !!!

[@wdl1980]

I was living in Europe when Black Clouds & Silver Linings was released. I intentionally drove around Tuscany jamming out to this. :) How could you not? The song will give you chills up in the Tuscan Apennines. Hahaha Doug, love your reviews man!

[@jb_50w78]

Count of Tuscany is definitely one of my favorite DT songs. Very glad you chose to react to this! It’s great to see how much you appreciate how great and also how well written this song is!

[@malawigw]

Drumming on this track is spectacular. Its like Neil Peart on steroids

[@theupsidedownguitarist1476]

This is one of my favourite dream theater songs! Such a joy to see you react to it. Please react to dream theater's ministry of lost souls. I think you will love the end section and the changes

[@goncalobaia1574]

-simple chord progression *Dream Theater starts being Dream Theater* -shouldn't have said that

[@pageylruatahmar9233]

Two years late but damn, you're absolutely right 😂

[@chegevara8896]

great things begins an simple ideas

[@mstrasser]

This is one of my favourite DT songs. Thank you for reacting to it and breaking it down is ways I didn't pick up. Especially the 3 note melody towards the end of the video (in the 15-minute mark of the track).

[@fartvader84yearsago8]

A nightmare to remember is also a banger from this album

[@LiquidShadows]

Totally. It's probably the heaviest song they've written, in my opinion. I especially love the slow, almost dreamy middle section. Then they finish the song up with blast beats? Just epic. By the way, how the HELL is your comment 84 years old?! 😂

[@wendelllanders8439]

Great review Doug!Dream Theater has been one of my Fav’s since 1993!They are technically proficient with great Melodic sense!All virtuoso’s!Petrucci the guitarist is exceptional with his speed and melodies!Great Band indeed!

[@subutaynoyan5372]

I think this is the last DT epic that actually represented the band's brilliance. Maybe Breaking All Illusions can be added in that list but I think it's just marvellous

[@MM-nd1zz]

Wow! gonna watch this, so happy I saw you covered this song. This is one of my top two Dream Theater songs out of all.

[@LuisMunoz-oq6xx]

Una de las cosas increíbles de DT es cuando hacen que la guitarra y el teclado suenen exactamente igual en partes difíciles. Me encanta