Classical Composer Reacts to Pushit (Tool) | The Daily Doug (Episode 275)

[@adamdetweiler5269]

The version of this song on the "Salival" EP was probably one of the best performances Tool has ever done.

[@thewal1ofsleep]

For my money, it's even better than the studio version. Otherworldly.

[@klipfellgames1158]

It's special.

[@unwantedscrub]

The Salival version has that sick bass note drop after Adams guitar solo that the studio version lacks.

[@JungleScene]

I was literally just listening to Pushit Live on the way home and thinking "this is easily one of the top five things theyve ever recorded" I cant think of another song by any band that build tension as well as that. It gradually changes from tender to tenderized over the course of the whole song and you cant quite put your finger on when it changes because they masterfully build layers and intensity. Adam and Dannys dynamics are completely off the charts in this one.

[@heathleblanc9604]

@@unwantedscrub absolutely 100% correct. It creates that "gap." They start grinding against each other again, adding to the feeling of the lyrics.

[@TheDeadlyDan]

One of the most addictive features of Tool for me is how Maynard uses the lyrics and his voice as an instrument equal to the others in the band. It's only "front and center" when it's necessary. Aenima with headphones and a bowl was my introduction to Tool and, as is so common, I fell in.

[@vanilla_milkshake]

"There's no love in fear" is my favorite Tool lyric

[@JungleScene]

yea to me theres three lyrics that really stand out in this song and thats one of them. The others being "I'm alive when you're touching me Alive when you're shoving me down", and "Remember I will always love you As I claw your fucking throat away" those three moments are so intense.

[@hoist8111]

I always thought it was "there's no love in this"

[@ericram76]

It's a close second for me right behind " I will work to elevate you, just enough to bring you down"

[@jensclarberg6419]

@@JungleScene I love "if I say I might fade like a sigh if I stay", it's very poetic in the way it's said. I can also relate strongly to "I'd trade it all, for a peace of mind".

[@johnnyb6067]

My wife (girlfriend at the time) said, “I didn’t know Tool wrote music like this!” when I had her listen to the Saliva version.

[@ADMO54]

I've been a fan since, 94ish, and this song, Pushit, is by far my favorite of theirs. I know everyone loves the Salival version, and it's great, but the album version got me through my darkest of days. This song was a glimpse into what they would go on to become. It has EVERYTHING that makes TOOL, TOOL. Complete masterpiece.

[@palmereldritch_6669]

It's an epic song. I remember going to Sam Goody, I already had unterdtow. He told me that Aenima was different, but still very good. I bought it. That album changed my concept of what can be achieved with music.

[@laceydez]

I love and prefer this version too. It is soo powerful. Been a Tool fan since about 92ish, and have an Aenima eye tattooed on my inner right bicep. Their albums have been literally a soundtrack to my whole life and will continue to be!

[@pmcapture7877]

Seriously, the Salival version of this song is so different and much more intense... would absolutely love to hear your thoughts on that.

[@MaddSpazz2000]

I second this

[@jeroen1989]

Third this

[@michaeld.6977]

I forth it

[@wodzjar]

Just do it! You won’t regret…

[@BD-fj1bc]

Completely agree.

[@darenmiller2218]

Understand something, breaking away from the significant other that causes you pain that you’re obsessed with is the absolute hardest thing you’ll ever do in your life. I don’t care what your career is I don’t care what your ambitions are none of that matters. Realizing the damage you’re doing to yourself and having the courage to break away from it is the ultimate boss.

[@MostlyCloudy]

You'll love the live version of this song. They took it somewhere REALLY vulnerable.

[@TheNewAmericanMedia]

Facts

[@Jadenity]

You often mention that it's interesting what backing music Tool decides to support their lyrics, but I believe their creation process is usually to create the drums/guitar/bass, and then bring it to Maynard to interpret and create vocals and lyrical ideas.

[@nolanjenkins4180]

This is indeed how they write

[@rmr5044]

I don't get how people can write songs like this. EVERYTHING is just perfect and so creative. I love Adam's textural guitar accents and squeals and super subtle licks during the quite middle section. And I love how Danny will include those single cymbal bell "dings" during the hihat patterns in the latter half of the song. *Definitely listen to the "Salival" version of this song. It's even better imo*

[@jaybeezy6062]

They're literally on another plane of existence.

[@kckillakrack9714]

A lot of what musicians do isn't written its added after a song is written and practiced. Good musicians add their own flair. Songs are usually pretty basic when first written. After playing and practicing over and over tada you got a song

[@palmereldritch_6669]

Experienced musicians understand that creativity is a snowball effect. Chipping, tinkering, adding until it feels complete. I've never had a great situation with a band where everyone is throwing their own creativity into the pile. I had one experience that came close. But then we got Yoko'd. Fkng Yoko's ruin everything.

[@nickskrtic2788]

You need to put all of your tool reactions in a playlist

[@TheNewAmericanMedia]

Agreed. We need a TOOL playlist

[@carolbowen4349]

Tool is truly a band that tells a story! I’ve been listening to them for almost 30 years and I never get tired of their music. True musicians!

[@Arrow2theACL]

Tool was all about soundscape angst through my High School years. I couldn't get enough at the time.

[@brandoncrow3741]

Thank you JJ for recommending this track! Great reaction, Doug. This is my favorite TooL album, by far. A lot of the album deals with interpersonal relationships, and Maynard was still working out his demons on this album. There are a LOT if intense emotions that he touches on, and specifically the tracks Jimmy, H., Eulogy and this one. You can't go wrong with anything off AEnima, man. It's darker and angrier than Lateralus, but unbelievably emotional at the same time. Masterpiece. Thanks again! 🤘

[@diz3338]

Unbelievable foresight..I watch a lot of reaction to music videos and I must say your focus on the overall composition and the lyrics are the best I’ve seen..Kudos Mr Doug. And keep bringing them!!

[@McFearsome2]

Best TOOL song ever.! Toolsday is a good title there.

[@neobliviscarisa650]

I strongly recommend you play the live Salival version on here, to experience how they completely changed the experience in a far more tribal Asian vibe. Influences from live Led Zeppelin ...

[@JungleScene]

yea definitely got a zeppelin vide from the live version. The way the song builds is akin to stairway to heaven. not saying it sounds like stairway, but structurally and dynamically it draws parallels.

[@jejejexD123]

Also in the record they have the no quarter cover, so the led zep influence is there ❤️

[@nubbinthemonkey]

I'll add to the chorus of, "Do the Salival version next!" it's completely rearranged and quite breathtaking

[@egratudo1974]

Maynard introduced this song like this in 96......"have you ever had someone love you so much you had to kill them to get away?.......................me either"

[@malin9314]

I'm literally never going to get tired to hear your analysis of Tool's music. Such great and poignant insights. Makes me appreciate the music so much more!

[@mollyloupintok5851]

I absolutely LOVE watching you react to the artistry that is Tool. I love how you break down not only the music from a technical perspective, but you also incorporate the overall pathos and ethos into your analysis. You are holistically experiencing each key change, timing change, lyrical implication, cadence, etc. the way that I envision we are MEANT to. It's this complexity and intensity that allows me to listen to different works from Tool (or APC) at different times in different places and receive DIFFERENT meanings from each encounter. Watching you 'get it' makes me SO HAPPY. Thank you for these, keep them coming!!!

[@richpeltier9519]

When this started, I'd already planned on suggesting you give a listen to the reworked live version from Salival. If only for the comparison of the difference in the two versions. Then during your summary, you talked about EXACTLY WHAT MAYNARD SAYS DURING HIS INTRO TO THE LIVE VERSION. Epic Doug. So, yeah you might wanna check that out. TOOL IS PINK FLOYD FOR THE NEW MILLENNIUM Rich the Ancient Metal Beast

[@k333rl]

sometimes an unpopular opinion but i almost prefer the salival version on most occasions.

[@matrixc2701]

Toolsday love it. This should be a thing

[@EtadamfnN]

Agreed!

[@MikeyB-Rod]

Others have already said, but I think you'll really enjoy the version from Salival. Pack that bong, close your eyes and go for the ride.

[@matrixc2701]

Your the only person I know that goes thru the lyrics and music at the same time. Keep pushit No pun intended

[@han-dell]

I'm so happy KZbin suggested your channel last week. I've been watching these reaction videos for Tool and Metallica all week! It's so good hearing a classical composer's opinion and observations on any kind of music.

[@themcgeachys]

Brilliant,I am 65 years auld ,been into tool for a year , this song brings back memories of my upbringingJim from bonny Scotland

[@kevsim70]

This is probably my favorite Tool song, ever, and I've been listening to them literally since the first EP. It's very very definitely about a toxic relationship. The person in the song *knows* that the relationship is terrible for them, but the other person has kept pulling them back in. I have always viewed the song as being a descent into a kind of madness as they can see themselves getting pushed back into the relationship once more. Notice the off-center buzzing at the beginning, as the starting maddening whine, as it were. Then the song gets more and more chaotic all the way though that instrumental passage about 2/3 of the way through. Then, they apparently reach a moment of clarity, where they have resolved, no matter what it costs, that they will *not* go back into that relationship, on pain of death, possibly literal.

[@DouglasDorner-I812]

Hey Doug, Doug here. Gotta say you were properly impressed by Tool, I thank you for breaking down the time signatures and key changes etc. I've been a TOOL fan since Sober first got played on Mtv's Headbangers Ball. Not being a musician however has limited my experience ever so slightly. Thanks for filling in the gaps

[@dadouttolunch6486]

As a TOOL fan, it’s humbling and exciting to learn new aspects of their music through people like yourself who know about the A, and D minor stuff. You know what I mean, lol. Cheers friend! ✌️🇨🇦🤘

[@jamiewatton7732]

As per probably everyone else's comments to come... The live version of this song on 'Salival' is worth a spin. It is, for me, the best example of tool's process of healing through it's music.

[@matthewwilcox7484]

Great reaction. Love seeing the music hit you. Listen again through the lyrics only. It’s such a DEEP song. Almost bring one to tears. I understand you were focused mostly on the music, rightfully so. This band has so many levels. Spirals.

[@ДанилаФахрутдинов-в3е]

Thank you very much! I really loves your professional look on Tool. "Flood" please, sir.

[@thewal1ofsleep]

My favorite Tool album. I think Lateralus is probably their best record, but Aenima was my introduction to them back when it released and holds that special place in my heart.

[@jaimeecherivel2927]

Doug, I wish I had your ear. You literally hear the note and immediately know it. Channels like yours are the reason that I want to go back to school and get a degree in theory and composition

[@guyfnsmiley]

I always appreciate your analysis of TOOL! Thank you for sharing.

[@eggstu]

Now do the Salival version. It's live and they recomposed this song. It's phenomenal that they can take a great song, change it, and it's still badass

[@MaraxisArcanist]

Casting yet another vote for the Salival version while this one is still fresh in memory. It's truly incredible how they were able to turn this song on it's head but still emphasize the meaning and keeping it recognizable.

[@stevenhoward3358]

I'm in my mid-fifties and just started listening to TOOL. I'm not really into metal but this stuff is really interesting, complex and well played. Some of the underlying sound effects intrigue me. Great stuff.

[@waltergoring8428]

Now listen to it on LSD.

[@jensclarberg6419]

@@waltergoring8428 Zzzz

[@waltergoring8428]

@@jensclarberg6419 Obviously you have never done that. I highly recommend it. You will not be disappointed.

[@jensclarberg6419]

@@waltergoring8428 probably not but I can also appreciate music drug free

[@waltergoring8428]

@@jensclarberg6419 L7

[@chrismontaigne6288]

Grab my phone to write how the song just gave me goosebumps as I tried to say it I tear up I’ve heard this song since the 90s I’m 41 years old it means that much to anyone who’s had any kind of relationship where you felt you were powerless and you wish you could save it but you know that your action will create disaster it’s insane

[@claymiller2409]

I know you're getting tons of comments recommending the Live Salival version, but I'm here to do so as well in hopes that it will help convince you to do it!! Please, you'll love it, and we all want it!

[@Christopher51now]

I like the fact he is a technical musician explaining it. Helps me a ton because I’ve learned on my own and reading tab.

[@simplelifedays3692]

I adored the way you made me chuckle. You're adorable. Tool Army 💚

[@joshkimes8332]

One of my favorite Tool songs. So cool to hear analysis on why I feel what I do when I hear it.

[@dmatveev89]

There was a fan made video of pushit with some european (polish?) animated movie "Dym" placed on the music. Unfortunately got removed after tool went streaming themselves. That video quite a special experience of pushit

[@HeavyStein117]

Powerful music with powerful lyrics

[@HotQahwe]

my fav album, a cool album to grow up with, before phones and flash drives and such. The accompanying visuals are a must, but thanks for doing these. Learning music is alot like learning any language and your videos are invaluable! THanks a ton

[@giovannimartinetto6001]

Hey, I really love your channel. Your videos are amazing! I'm quiete young (17), but love listening to music and playing guitar and orchestral percussion. Since your video are many (i haven't had time to see them all, sorry) I don't know if you've listened to Area yet. They are a phenomenal band from Italy (my country), but really really underrated. If I were you, i would listen to "Crac!" or "Caution Radiation Area", but all of their works are amazing! Demetrio Stratos is one of the most underappreciated voice of all time. Their strange scales used with odd rhythms, and political concerned political themes make them one of the best band ever! If you read this message, that between all the other is very difficult to catch, and liked them, please try "cantare la voce" of Demetrio Stratos, in which he demonstrates all the difficult techniques he was able to. I also apologize for my very bad English, my language skills are not very good! Thank you

[@cortesma2662]

Says the guy with better English than my Italian will ever be. Thanks for the tip, I’ll definitely check them out!

[@RailfanJason]

Should do the Salival version soon. Live version that rivals studio quality, and go into it maybe thinking from the other person's perspective. It's quite a different experience.

[@jeffstanley2972]

Love your analysis of the TOOL songs. You gained a subscription from me. I played drums/percussion for 11 years and the stuff Danny Carey does on percussion is just mesmerizing to me. Enjoy your breakdown of the different time signatures as they change within the songs.

[@IAmKrow]

I love how you analyze not just the music but also the lyrics. Subbed!

[@justinman114]

I fucking love how you describe things. This is easily my favorite Tool song. As other have said, definitely listen to the Salival version as well.

[@090nj2]

*ToolsDay, nice*

[@bettykidox1893]

Tool's Day yeah... If you can react to Third Eye,Salival's version, its a great trip.

[@lt_johnmcclane]

I’m glad they still play this version live in 2022

[@shanebilowitz7261]

it's interesting how you can combine the distinct skills of relative pitch and absolute pitch in your analysis. I'm going to dub your skill set as "imperfect pitch" lol. you're able to recognize absolute pitch, but as you said, you can be fooled or be off at times. Anyway, people with true perfect pitch often can't hear things in relative terms. They hear pitches first and then mathematically deduce the relationship to the tonic or whatever. in contrast, people with really developed relative pitch can hear the relationship, but only know the absolute pitch after deriving it from the relationship to the already identified tonic. you seem to be able to do both, and rely more on one or the other depending on the situation. for example, you said in this video "that's a flat 6, which means that if they're in D then it must be a Bb." whereas in the atom heart mother video you said "that definitely sounds like an e flat minor chord, but how the hell did they end up there?" I have a suspicion that your absolute pitch recognition centers around the tonal qualities that certain pitches have, like an F# would sound like "weer" and an e flat would sound like "wah". like recognizing syllables of spoken word. i'm starting to develop that myself but i don't know to what extent i can take it. I can reliably recognize and reproduce an F natural for example, because in my mind it makes the "Ha" sound, which I then compare it to the recollection of that same sound as played on my particular instrument, in this case the guitar. TLDR im a nerd and your channel is great.

[@joshschwarzbauer8155]

For second I thought we were talking "Perfect Pitch" in the Cosmere, but I realized we aren't actually on Roshar. And I got sad because my boy Vasher didn't have to rope somebody. (one person will get this, hopefully)

[@lele634]

@@joshschwarzbauer8155 I get it! Sanderson nerd here too!

[@kennethalbert4653]

12:30 "you'll restrict my movement anyway..." You described the difference between the 'A' and the 'B-flat' with almost the exact words !

[@JellyRoger_XIII]

#ToolsDay FTW !!! Hope you bring it to the very limit, considering to study and react any of their songs. They are truly the University of Sounds & Music, imho.

[@ultimateiphonedng8756]

G’day Doug, love your work, the highlight of my day. I’m cool for Tool and your analysis deepens my appreciation. Being an old fart I find your examinations of prog masterpieces a trip of the best kind, it is great to revisit those seminal works in your company. I humbly provide a couple of suggestions in line with your coverage of Tool. First you have not, as far as I know, covered any Australian artists. Let me tell you, we have some extraordinary talent on our continent. One group that has a similar sensibility to Tool is Karnivool. They do long and short form but as a taster “Change” from their “Sound Awake” album is an amazing track, I feel confident you would find some musical joy there. On a different level, knowing you are keen on well written and expressive vocals, I would love to hear your take on “The The” a Brit artist/band, and as a starter I offer up “Sweet Bird of Truth” which hails from the almost perfect 1986 album “Infected”. The whole album feels like it could have been written yesterday and the lyrics are cutting, clever and have a rare insight that is probably closer to our current point in time than when written. Oh and the music is incredible including some percussion that would do Danny from Tool proud. Thanks for your channel and all the very best for the coming festive season.

[@johncarpenter3751]

He gets it!! The band writes the songs and Maynard pulls the meaning from the song based how the music feels

[@Catrakai]

I so much more enjoy you doing the classic prog songs. So much to discover there composition wise ...

[@pentagrammaton6793]

Aye, those are a lot better than this miserable crap.

[@Mark16PewPew]

Chills still. Ya'll, if you haven't, the live version on Salival is a must. Turns this song up to 11.

[@metalmark1214]

Tool has the affinity of having deep and intense song subject matter. This song talks about his experiences with being abused as a child and how his parents claimed to love him yet abused him. Hence the last phrase in the song, "Remember I will always love you, as I claw your f--king throat away. It will end no other way, it will end no other way." In the first verse he says, "Choke this infant here before me" - here he is referring to himself as the infant and suffering from neglect and abuse. Throughout the song, he describes how he would like to take revenge on his parents and strike back, but was afraid for fear of continued abuse. This song is one of Tool's most violent stories of Maynard's childhood. Source - Songfacts

[@robertakerman3570]

Very sad.

[@Qliphirot]

That's the epitome of the jungian conflict expressed as art

[@drivenauthority916]

Amazing channel I can’t stop watching. PLEASE do more heavy metal

[@robertakerman3570]

Mr. H. Thanx 4 the timing count! It helps Me.

[@jasonlauritsen5587]

You should check out "Morbid Angel" the album "Heretic". There is a 2nd disc thats entirely instrumental.

[@eamonahern7495]

I love your interpretation of the lyrics because I have lived that in some way, though not to that level of destructive intensity. It was my first time listening to the song too but I don't have the lyrics in front of me so your insight was very welcome. In terms of the music, I don't understand the pitch or key changes the way you do but I found it to be haunting, in a good way. They wouldn't be the type of music I'd normally listen to but they keep me hooked to a song when I do. I'm more into proper (if conventional isn't the word) guitar solos but what the guitarist does here in the instrumental part of the song is just enough to keep me satisfied in that regard. Your enthusiasm is as much why I was entertained by this as the song itself. Great song choice, great video.

[@DavidOakesMusic]

Doug i see this video lasts 17:01 Live Long and Prosper ! 🖖🏼

[@Spooked.J]

The album cover is called "Smokebox" by artist Cam De Leon.

[@thepiratecats801]

Hey Doug, have you considered doing some British punk? I was thinking you could get 3 or 4 songs into a single video as they tend towards the shorter side. I'd recommend The Clash, 'White Riot' 'Should I stay or should I go' 'Bankrobber' 'Tommy Gun' and ' Rudie Can't Fail'. Cheers Owen

[@JBfromKC816]

Tool's first album is actually, Opiate. Very unique and my favorite even though its pretty short.

[@reverendprophet]

It would be really interesting to hear you react to the live version they did on "Salival" of this song. It's an entirely different experience.

[@memelordmark7532]

Awesome reaction! 😎👍

[@memelordmark7532]

Recommend a reaction to Swamp Song! 😎👍

[@trecool3458]

Great song and great reaction.

[@FatBoySlim696]

Would be nice to see the Salival version of Pushit

[@mendronesg]

Doug, you have to listen to the Salival version of this song. It's a completely different emotion, it could be considered as a part 2.

[@sezmo420]

Our FAVORITE Tool song!!!

[@klipfellgames1158]

enjoying the Tool reactions. keep going.

[@ted1976hailspiralout]

Not only do I love your Tool reactions but I also love your T-Shirt 😂

[@jasonread5017]

YOUR BRAIN AND SOUL INTUITIONHUMBLENESS ROCKS

[@snarkyguy2657]

Great interpretation & breakdown. First time finding your channel, & just liked/subscribed.

[@cochisetoolshed3608]

awesome reaction

[@nerfme532]

Hey Doug, you should really check out the band Imminence. They use a lot of Violin played by the lead vocalist and implement it really well into the genre of Metalcore!

[@Ekwensuocha666]

Tool is very intense for having a slower tempo. Sets them apart.

[@tempsitch5632]

Everyone else called it, “Tool Tuesday”. I love your twist on the obvious.

[@WanderingRobotStudio]

You should also look up their live version of this where they rework the entire structure.

[@frios011]

Every Tool song is a journey for the listener.

[@ACM86]

Can’t wait until next Tuesday. I vote Vicarious.

[@garypointer3496]

You should check out the live version on the Salival album. It’s on another level. And while you are at it, check out the Led Zeppelin cover No quarter on that same album

[@PowderedToastMan420]

Do the SALIVAL VERSION. Dont over analyze. JUST DO IT NOW!

[@adammichener987]

Those last few lines are so powerful

[@tomsawtelle1280]

Great videos, Doug. I think you would enjoy listening to the live version from Salival. It’s a very special performance.

[@markholden8538]

I know this is off topic, but after watching “Get Back”, I began to wonder if you’ve ever analyzed the tying together of the “Medley “ on side two of Abbey Road? That would be really cool!

[@dampersand]

Thematically this reminds me of Anti-Eulogy by Hail the Sun.

[@dougthompson9909]

I love Tool. Doug has anyone requested Billy Strings?

[@eliasreynolds6866]

Doug you gotta check out the performance by Alter Bridge with the Parallax Orchestra from 2018 on a Metal Monday. An all time great band with an all time great performance. The song Words Darker Than Their Wings is such a beautiful song and the orchestra elevates it to something incredible. The whole show is great and I highly suggest checking it out but if you were to pick one for a video, Words Darker Than Their Wings is my suggestion. The song has a beautiful dialogue about what it means to believe in a higher power and what it's like to feel lost. It's a real duet too because the Myles Kennedy and Mark Tremonti basically wrote this song based on a conversation they had when Myles was going through a particularly dark time in his life.

[@MrPigFister201]

IMO, this has deliberate dual meaning as most of their songs do which is what makes them the greatest band ever. It can be whatever the listener needs it’s to mean to them regardless of Maynard’s own personal reason for the song…& still be both at the same time, lol, if that makes sense.

[@plantdesigns7889]

Great reaction! Great song! I'd like to see you check out Rivers Of Nihil. Personally I'd love either Where Owls Know My Name or The Void From Which No Sound Escapes. Keep up the good Work 😉

[@plantdesigns7889]

@Big Homie Steve The Metal Head I love The Void... from The Work. I do wish the rest of the album was that epic.

[@breakdancinfool]

Voice effects at beginning: gate and compressor

[@Gnosoupforu]

If you enjoy Tool, check out A Perfect Circle. In particular, Passive from eMotive album! Maynard is such a talented artist!