RDR2 ALLIGATOR TOOTH TALISMAN

[@Chum_Ok]

Idk why i don't have the alligator tooth and the handcuffs if i killed the alligator and completed the cards mision💀💀💀

[@StonedDragon-kj1di]

I've used my Springfield Rifle and he almost had me but I managed.

[@tobythomas66]

Mine isn’t popping up I have everthing

[@pinkypusher5135]

Same issue, I sold him all 3, but it shows 0 on all 3 things

[@brucemiller6881]

Use a shotgun for the alligator it takes three shots