Reacting to

[@zassar]

Bhai Sbse Pehle Dhanyawad for taking the video as a feedback. 2-> I Understand Everything what You Said. 3-> I believe in you, sir ji 🙏take your time and give some next level game updates 4-> You Are Really a Good Person ❤

[@deadchannel5540]

❤

[@sharunps4356]

🔥🔥🔥

[@Indiaeducation6565]

Bro you are genuine you get new subscriber 🔥🔥 also i believe in nikhil brother they will definitely improve it

[@ROHITsharma_study_cgl]

🤟

[@kunaldhiman8733]

Gameplay looks like total overdose if you agree

[@Urvish1410]

Bhai hats off to nikhil Bhai for taking the criticisms in positive way

[@wildfoxgamerz3691]

Criticism nahi hai wo feedback diya hai usne, dono me fark hota hai🤦

[@Urvish1410]

​@@wildfoxgamerz3691sorry my bad

[@pablochocobar074]

ye positive criticism hai Bhai isme positively he lenge na 🙃

[@BrandSerpent]

​@@wildfoxgamerz3691Criticism ka matlab hi hota hain aisa feedback jo kamiya bataya

[@AbhinavVerma-l6v]

agar thodi bhi mehnati kari hoti graphics pe to itna criticism na hota

[@adityaroy7216]

I won't judge till the game comes out. I believe in your project and I believe in us as a gaming community. Hum India wale kisi se kam nhi. All the best!

[@N0OB_69]

India me gaming community hai?

[@definitelyafan2541]

INDIAN GAMING COMMUNITY is only a myth it doesn't exist

[@fun_g]

@@definitelyafan2541 being carried by the last few such as bbs others are just naam ke chappri papa ke pari serrving 5y/o content making lallus

[@endergamerplayz100]

@@fun_g faxss

[@Undead2882]

@@fun_gpreach 🛐

[@Oparmy069]

Zasaar is one of the most genuine, experieced but still underrated gaming youtuber its good that you are acknowledging his feedback

[@jgappy]

Experienced? He said "Sekiro lacks story" 💀💀💀💀💀💀 Bro onto nothing

[@Andrewtate200]

Ghante ka experienced😆

[@Shibu-069]

if he was experienced, i don’t think he would have criticized an in-development version of a game

[@jgappy]

@@Shibu-069 he dont even how much effort it takes to build a game and many of the people are just dumb it takes a lotta time and 1000s of lines of code Few months ago gta 6 alpha stage video got leaked People were calling it trash and don't even know how game dev works

[@Shibu-069]

@@jgappy so true dude.. i hope they research things before sh!t talking like they know everything

[@kvrthikay]

Mumbai gullies should be next shown only when it's almost finished or finished, and I do think the game wasn't supposed to be shown to people right now as the main thing people notice about the game is graphics and graphics are usually the last thing finished when making a game. Animations i hope will also improve, and driving physics too, so that we can get a trailer that's professionally shot. no shade to the game, totally looking forward to it! best of luck :D !!!

[@akshatk5943]

Yes bro absolutely right

[@kalki_sevak1947]

Coming to Mumbai Gullies and GameEon- It is always great to see developers appreciating criticism and kudos to Nikhil for that. I also appreciate him engaging with the community to understand their pulse. I realise this game not might be a AAA or AA level game and I honestly don't care about that. I've seen more dedication and heart being poured into indie games in the last decade than any AAA game. While I realise the developers and their sponsors have set a goal for themselves to create an open-world RPG, it'd be my humble suggestion to not go the Ubisoft (Assassin's Creed) way with their game. It is way better to have a small map with hand-crafted and meaningful quests, immersive environment and interesting characters than having a massive map with copy-paste quests, boring characters and generic environment. While I'll not make any comments until I see an alpha stage game-play, it'd be great to see innovative gameplay mechanics inspired by the different aspects of life in the city. I also realise that the budget is tighter compared to other open world rpg makers, hence I'll not be expecting super realistic mo-cap enabled animations, high quality voice acting and next-gen graphics. Having said that, I'd like to see interesting gameplay mechanics, meaningful character progression and real-life Mumbai-inspired map and asset designs. I'd like to wish you guys all the luck in the world and may the god of crunch bless you!!

[@ERICTENHAG56]

Try plague tale and metro exodus they are really good

[@soumabharoy9516]

Nikhil da u are one the few game developers who actually talks and interacts with the audience, gamers and try to add the suggestions given by them in the actual game. I hope u do a livestream where all of us can debate and have a meaningful conversation on how to improve this game. I am 200% confident u and your team will deliver the best game from India. I have high hopes.

[@PakoY2J]

nikhil bhaiya the fact that u takin feedback from every criticism is really good nowadays game companies just strictly ignores their player base companies like Activision and ubisoft doin this for years whoever criticizes them they sometimes even took their video down or never invite them in release event

[@jsrrishi6008]

proud of you for listening to this youtuber in a descent manner.

[@prithvee_]

Kudos to you for acknowledging valid criticism. With Indian gamers having access to tons of games these days, expectations are way too high. As a long-time supporter, I'd suggest sharing only the content you're truly proud of. Your efforts will surely shine through ❤

[@TheKenzo_47]

kabhi indie game dev ke game dekh woh better bana lete hai game looks awful

[@TheKenzo_47]

example hazardous he make game from their unreal engine 5 scraps that look hella better than Mumbai gully

[@primanftw]

@@TheKenzo_47 bhai thoda wait karle

[@itsmohdmustafa]

"Sirf Indian game hai isliye support mat karo, accha game hai isliye suppprt karo" yahi toh sunna tha bhai, dil ko sukoon mil gaya ye sunke..

[@sarveshjain8064]

Sir one suggestion from my side is that these health bars don't look good. Instead you can use the style like ghost recon or valorant in which the enemy body directly falls down after death

[@erenyeager3008]

Yea

[@maheshwaranarul6926]

I think adding other languages like tamil Telugu Malayalam bengali punjabi etc. In some specific minor locations or areas Can increase the audience Of other languages too

[@himanshuwiz]

seriously nikhil sir is one of a kind person because he can easily ignore this video but he come upfront and make a video about it and clear any doubt point by point

[@ompachpind7106]

Car customisation, character customisation, nature (mountain), airport, swimming, proper reflection, proper physics like gta 4. These are my suggestions😅 I like the trailer and waiting for it since last year.But take your time to take this at the peak hats off to you man for making such a good game ❤❤❤.

[@manoyal]

Few things which I hope come out good in the final version: would be the physics system.. Apart from gunplay , I think car driving also plays a big role in this type of game so- Regarding the Vehicle physics, I hope its slightly complex, and we are able to 'feel' the difference between the Vehicles based on if its a Super car, or a heavy vehicle, or an auto or something.. Other than the basic variables like Acceleration, Braking, Top Speed, Traction, Handling I hope there are more complex variables in the physics system like- Suspension, Weight, Center of mass, Aerodynamics, Engine Power, Drive Type: (Whether the car is front-wheel drive, rear-wheel drive, or all-wheel drive, which affects its handling and traction. ), Gear Ratios, Tire Type. Also regarding the Melee Combat System: - That flying kick animation felt a bit funny and unrealistic to me. ( or idk if people in Mumbai really know kungfu ), I hope the melee combat gets some more realistic punching and kicking animations. Also the ragdoll physics- The ragdoll animations/ death animations of enemies feel quite a bit stale. Hope more work is done on that

[@princeladdi9476]

First of all Being a Game developer myself I Can understand each and every point Nikhil said , But one of the most important and core thing that is missing in this field in our country is the knowledge and experience . I think comparing an Indian Game developer and a foreign game developer there is a space of difference , you accept it or not this remains a fact. This mostly boils down to the fact that we don't have any specializations (Degree or courses) provided by any institutes to this and many other fields. Still I think we can go a long way In this field . All the best to you and your team!

[@mayankindian3750]

True brother hame ispar kaam karne ki wakai me bahut jyada jaroorat hai bhai

[@arghyaprotimhalder5592]

Business and market doesn't work that people won't care whose efforts what efforts if it don't standout nationality or anything can't save it

[@Kk-rc5dl]

Ha bro Hamare yha Animation, gaming, ai nya hai toh Whatak pahuchne Mei tine lagega

[@Gaming_Clown]

Their Final Card Of Stupidity is The Amount of Indian Developers name you can See in RDR2 End Credit 😑

[@bigjaws488]

I thought zassar took serious step and tslking reality. In response nikhil took even more seriously

[@Gaming_Clown]

Graphics ke Liye Boolna Sahi point tha Lekin , Game Lore , Story , Environment , mechanics ko chor ke sirf graphics ke liye rona galat hai

[@himanshupandey8771]

@@Gaming_Clown mere lie game ke graphics jyada matter mahi karte . Gameplay acha hona chahiye. Agar graphic hin sabkuch hota to resident evil 4 og , Minecraft,gta san Andreas etc. Jaise games ko koi nahi khelta

[@Gaming_Clown]

@@himanshupandey8771 bilkul bilkul bhai , Even Terraria , Minecraft , Undertale , Omori , etc. Aaj ke time mei nahi perform karte Steam/Nintendo store mei 🙂🙂

[@crazygamer2540]

​@@himanshupandey8771my guy they were old times at that time they were considered games with masterpiece graphics

[@himanshupandey8771]

@@crazygamer2540 my guy i am talking about present time. There are so much players who still plays these games .

[@manmathgodre5360]

Nikhil Bhaiyya is a True Game developer True Interactions true Talk True nature True passion True Support True Indian 🙏🙏

[@FleetNine]

I would like to point out that most people prefer right handed view on the shooting games. But I can see Mumbai Gullies has left handed view which would make it a little weird for me to play. If it has or will have an option to switch perspectives then that would be great.

[@TheSoundofTanay]

Hopefully shoulder swap will be an option.

[@mayurpillai3181]

God level humility Nikhil bro, Hope you & your team will do your best. All the best

[@PakoY2J]

i agree with u nikhil bhaiya on gta 5 development stage coz i know big of a team was involved in gta 5 production Rockstar USA were handling the main stage of gta 5 while whole team of rockstar uk and india were outsorcing other assests of the game as u can assume how big of a group it was to develop a game like gta 5 . Even with such big team it still took 5 years I am pursuing course of 3d character artist and i have to learn human anatomy for it just to understand how to make 3d characters ragdolls more realistic which is pretty tough especially in india 3d character artist are not even professional and those who are professional charges alot indian game design institute still behind many small countries like sweden This is message for all viewers who's saying some big games who were created by small group of 10-12 people they are highly professional coz from they learnt its in depth meanwhile in india u will find lakhs of game design artist but u will only few thousands of artist who really professional and they charges alot and also will take more time coz they will be busy with triple a companies

[@nikhilvardhantawania4591]

bhai as a Game Dev I feel you as long as you are taking criticism positively then hopes are still high. Maine kabhi socha bhi nahi tha aisa game Bharat mein develop hoga...... Ye mei karne wala tha but you are ahead of me :) P.S. you were so right about the scope jab open world game hota hai to GTA, RDR2, AC ki teams or budget dekho. Apko gameplay mei jaan dalni padegi kyuki graphics aap ek hadd tak hi upgrade kar paaoge kyuki na to apke pas Rockstar Games ya Ubisoft jitna bada budget hai na team.

[@Dread_Devil_0_0]

i don't have any thoughts on game trailer because there's a lot of development left and you can't predict how final game gonna look like you can only understand how game theme gonna be with trailer but you never know, i hope devs get more budget because making a game from the scratch needs more then they have and they are giving there all i just hope for the best and wish good luck to whole team

[@nikmlnkr]

Thanks for the good wishes!

[@harshitgoswami160]

My first interaction with PC games was vice city when I was 6 or 7 idk I’m playing GTA V and RDR2 since their respective launches but It’s sad that Mumbai gullies is not even looking close to a 10 year old game. I’m 😔 sad

[@manvendersingh2799]

Taking criticism in a positive way is always a good thing

[@sudiptochatterjeeallinone8335]

I am eagerly waiting for this game. Making a good game and taking more time, is worth it. Bring something unique in the shooting and storyline part, for example, cinematic scenes while playing a game like Call of Duty and also some romantic scenes in a good way should craze the public and try to insert mini-games within the game itself, and some more parts like cash withdraw from ATM, something interesting like haunted places and secret missions, television and radio control, this little things matters a lot in an open world game and please make the car and character movement more smooth .@GameEon best wishes to Nikhil and his team. Love from Kolkata ❤

[@VEDANTKUMBHAR-vi6tx]

We all know that you will definitely improve this game. 100% full support grom us Nikhil sir❤

[@ChoitiBose]

Feedback 1: In the Mumbai Marine Drive scene, please keep some people sitting on the walls and stones. Feedback 2: In the Diwali/Mela scene, the balloon firing competition between Jimmy and Vangya should be improved, like ironsight or cross-hire should be added and their names in the balloon board should be dynamic, it should pop up at the start, and should disappear at the end. Feedback 3: Please improve animations and camera movements currently it looks really bad and unprofessional. Feedback 4: Kindly improve the AI in the NPCs. NPCs should look alive like the GTA games, hire somebody who can do that, that's a very important thing in every open-world game. Animations of NPCs, like they should do unique activities randomly, they should talk, react to any actions made by the player, NPCs should smoke cigarettes, use public washrooms, etc. Feedback 5: Don't keep the 'U' button to dance randomly, the player should get an option to dance in certain areas. Feedback 6: There should be player customization like changing clothes, gym to gain muscles, tattoos, etc. Also, the player should be able to steal clothes from NPCS after killing them and should be able to drag and hide the dead body. Thank you so much, hope you will listen to me :)

[@saeedaqibahmed]

Please look at this @nikhilmalankar @mumbaigulliesofficial I totally agree with her. ❤

[@Whitesnowwinter]

Sir Mai hindi me suggestion de sakta hu 😔 english achhi nahi hai meri sorry 1- Jab character run kar ke ya walk kar ke ruk raha hai to bahot jhatke me ruk ja raha hai robot ke jaise ye sahi kar dijiye 2- character thoda sa aage ke side jhuk ke chal raha hai aaise --> / ( sidha kar dijiye thoda sa) 3- Character ki walking and running animation/physical bhi sahi karna hai 4- Shooting animation bhi character ka ajib hai 5 - road ke divider pe jo plants 🌱 hai vo box jaise lag rahe hai like mobile game ke jaise grass hai vo usko achha kar dijiye jaise chote chote plant kar dijiye uske jagah ( I hope ye point explain kar paya mai) 6- car ke models bahot kharab hai car dikhne Me achhi nahi lag rahi issliye drive karne me achha feel nahi hoga , thodi achhi dikhne wali car add kariye SUV type ki jaise ford, fortuner scorpion jaisa model 7- female npcs and male npc ka walking style alag alag kariye 8 - npcs baat kare comments pass kare vangya ke different different actions pe like rdr 2 9- sabhi ghar identical lag rahe hai ek jaise and ghar ki windows and doors bhi identical hai bahot jada , variety laiye sabhi chijo me nahi to map boring lagega repeative lag raha 10 - marine drive pe pani ki lahare aae halki halki to jada achha lagega, pani bahot jada still hai to dikhne me achha nahi lag raha 11 - jump mechanics kaisa hai? Hai ya nahi hai? Jump ka feature bhi add kar dijiye 12- cycle bhi add kar dijiye 13 - jo aapne pani puri ka stall dikhaya tha vo mobile game ke jaisa dikh raha usse improve kar dijiye 14- trees ek jaise hai bahot jada, usse alag alag shape ka kariye rdr 2 jaisa 15 - Vangya 19 saal ka hai and jo apne game me dikhaya hai vo 26-30 + ka lag raha hai, 19 ki age ka character waisa nahi dikhta 16 - sabhi small details add kar dijiye ga jaise - tyre puncture, fire propagation, water effect (ripple effect) on firing in water, car glass break, good physcis, improved texture, falling from height animation etc

[@ayushdavra7628]

I have some suggestions regarding the first trailer, 1)try hiding the health bar of a player and see difference, i think without bar will look great and more realistic, 2) cross walk of player needs some work, it is not good gaming experience

[@nikmlnkr]

Thank you for the feedback

[@ayushdavra7628]

@@nikmlnkr can't believe i got reply, i know Mumbai gullies will rock when release

[@anshumandwivedi6361]

Enemies me Health bar ki need nhi h, gamplay graphics story teeno important h, And Reverse Strategy boht sahi hai execution ke liye jo apne mention kiya, also ek aur chiz bht important h wo h Physics in Gameplay jo ki near to accurate hona bht zaruri h, usse object ki real density ka feel aata hai

[@mudit_mathur]

unreall engine 4/5 gives you amazing graphics out of the box without any configuration, so I think the problem lies in models and custom shaders , that's why previous build looked better in terms of graphics because it was put together with pre-made assets from asset store. They need to focus on their designers to provide better graphics

[@i_am_Varad]

Bhai Please Ek Naya Mic Lelo Apki Voice Bahut Low Aati Hain...

[@himanshu830]

One thing I would like to point out is, you should put "Work in progress" watermark in the gameplay video so that people can know it's still not ready yet. Because when anyone sees that trailer they will think the final product will be like this only. Btw I believe in you and your team.

[@Elisa9395-y4z]

Why are they showing it beforehand

[@xtreamtech6747]

Ek important feedback hai bro gta 5,max payne 3,rdr 2,detroit become human in game ki footage dekhna ussme usne clothes ko dekhna backside par usme aapko wrinkles padte dikhenge and wo bahut hi simple hai bnana bus aapko wrinkle ke normal map ko animate kerna hota hai cloth pe and believe me ye chhoti si detail bahut realism add kerti hai

[@MRGAMERIDER]

Keep it Up Nikhil Sir You are The Best Excited For Mumbai Gullies I Created Many videos On Mumbai Gullies 🔥🎮💪

[@nickysahu]

We would love to watch next trailer cinematic with storyline.

[@cyan_nyan]

I don't care about realistic visuals, maybe try having something that has a specific aesthetic/artstyle, zassar's points were really agreeable. The yakuza series/many J-RPGs doesn't look that well visually but have a unique artstyle and very decent melee combat mechanics, various other stuffs like choice based story progression that make them very appealing to play. 13:18 the expected release date was 2023, no way someone can make a decent game in just 3 years especially when it's your first game of its kind. Please take your time.

[@Tejasavbhasin]

we can also take example of cave story a 2d indie game which took more than 5 year and now is the best indie game of all time . the developer took time and made a masterpiece so we should also wait for this masterpiece

[@AllieThePrettyGator]

13:39 its still a work in progress, my only consern is that the traffic does not look like what you see in Mumbai or else ware in India

[@joelyochak103]

If we can wait for more than 10 years for GTA 6 and still it's not out then .. why not for Mumbai gullies... Atleast nikhil Bhai is trying best... We should support him... No matter what... Nikhil Bhai don't want us to play Indian cyberpunk full of glitches and all... We should wait for final game and It would stand out I believe... Guys support Mumbai gullies... 🤝... Its still a proud moment that one of our Indian game development teams is trying to Stand against the outer world... We as an Indian gaming community should support them and Nikhil bhai aap kro kaam ham hai saath 😊

[@Shivamgx]

Sir could you give an option to turn on/off enemy health bar because many people don't like it and some of them like it.😊

[@frigontech]

Bhai max to max last 3 months mein post production ka kaam hota hai(which is main thing for looks textures, post-processing, shader, final character models, Game Art, environment, UI). Takes time

[@dishansinghmehta8891]

True that though Raji was also a top down approach game , whereas HeLL Blade as well was more of a narrative driven game with less focus on gameplay, if you were to look into its review , folks have called it a walking simulator but it had very good plus points in order for folks to compare with it , so yeah the game making process here would be a lot different , with more money and time needed. And its not even in alpha test phase so clearly a lot , a lot of work needs to be done

[@coolmansish8146]

Nikhil bhai, agar aap gameplay trailer mein yeh specify kara dete neeche ke section mein ya ending card mein ki "This game is in development phase, final result may vary." toh jyada problem na hoti. Isse hume bas yeh idea hota ki progress kahan tak pohunchi hai. Agge agar koi dusra gameplay showcase karein toh iss baat ko dhyaan mein rakhiyega.

[@aaryachavda7985]

Much respect Nikhil Bhai, I am sure you'll make Mumbai Gullies great...😊

[@gmrayb_editz321]

tips for improving game 1)Put good and realistic weapon handling and recoil along with camera reshake 2)put good and realistic ragdoll which will give weight of body 3)give realistic weight to car and also put good camera 4)for health bar use a weapon aim reticle and when aiming on npc put healthbar around reticle

[@bev3140]

Hello Nikhil. Hats off for taking criticism in a positive way, despite the amount of negativity that your game is receiving just because it is a trailer and not the final game. I have a suggestion, just as how Tekken 8 and MK1 have started Open Beta Testing. You could also start an Open Beta testing for Mumbai Gullies, since you did mention that you are using the reverse strategy or something, that way beta testers can actually play and give feedback towards your game, at the same time, this game will become even more popular with youtubers recording it. This is my suggestion towards your game. Thank you

[@nextgengaming8584]

bro , don't worry I am getting a game for your competition will be ready in 3 years

[@ChillieGaming]

Ap log Photogrammetry aka 3d scan karo like ek camera lelo Like Sony A7RIV 64 megapixel camera With cross polorasation filter and tripod/monopod And 3d scan rocks , dirt , etc And scan trees trunk and bring into zbrush and make low poly to high poly bake Then bring the realistic tree into speedtree And convert photogrammetry trunk into 3d tree. Sure the tris count would be slightly higher like 80k tris to 150k tris for the trees. For the small props and objects, stones you can bring the tris down to 1k or 10k tris using quad remesher addon in blender I even turned a realistic brick of 60million tris down to a low poly 1650 trie that looks good like megascan assets But remember nowadays games can handle quite high amount of poly counts so yea its not that necessary to optimise polygons down to the lowest of lowest The visual quality shouldn't suffer just to get 1-2 fps more. For scanning leaves use photometric stereo technique instead of normal photoshop old school technique which normal map isnt that accurate

[@bigjaws488]

I know too about these too but these tools require special artist which are barely difficult to hire. No one uses these tools except a few.

[@ChillieGaming]

@@bigjaws488 what u mean no one uses these Lmfao. Every AAA game studio and even indie studios uses them Even some youtubers uses these technique to create a short 1 min cinematic animation and this is a full game So why not use that. Of course it's not possible to use it on every model But like in most material I mean Even EA games and ubisoft showed that a realistic grass material can be scanned and made production ready in just 3-4 hours Whereas a artist who would have to make this by hand can take 4-7 days and even then it can't beat real life as real life just have that story in the texture and that wear and tear Sure you can get close to real life but never beat it So it's just better to scan it Photoscanning isn't a hard task Heck even I learnt everything from beginner to pro in the span of just 6months. Photoscanning is easier than procedurally creating a material in substance designer as you need to first study how the material looks , how it reacts to light and study it's roughness,formation and so many things. Photoscanning is great for biomes and making it tileable and so many stuff. It's not that these kind of artists are hard to find. It's that no one in india thinks this is worth it lmfao. If you will never try it how will u even learn it and know it's pro and cons Game industry is changing very 2-3 years And if you don't adapt to it You will get out of the game and lose to other game companies

[@bigjaws488]

@@ChillieGaming I am talking about India bro. Just like we saw in vfx films even with high budget they are unable to achieve a fine quality. Blender has incredible addons which are exception in quality and no need to pay thousands dollars. Addons are only one time purchasable. Films like adipurush can be better if they use it but seems which technology they are using 🤣. Specific artists in speedtree and zbrush like tools needs artist. But can be difficult to hire. All about awareness we never use these tools so it need time to perfect in these tools. Photogrammetry is easy but can be risky for game size coz of high poly count AYK.

[@ChillieGaming]

@@bigjaws488 well photogrammetry scan with 60million tris or 150million tris can be brought down to 1500-20,000tris using just 1 single click. Quad remesher addon in blender or zremesher in zbrush. And later bake normal map So you never need to worry about photoscan be high poly So in the end you will have a model that not only looks high poly but will consume the same amount of ram and GPU power as a low poly.

[@bigjaws488]

@@ChillieGaming it seems we know about it more than the developers. If they are aware they will definately take step

[@touseefahmad7119]

me to graphics dekh ke yhi smjta raha mobile game he. 😁 but muje bhi pc games khalte 15 saal h gai han. and ye graphics kisi trah se bhi PC Game ke ni lgte. graphics pe bht kaam baqi he. but i belive on you. final product next level h ga.😊😊

[@diazostreta4473]

I believe India will be the hotbed for gaming. It is important that we manage expectations from Indian game company who are foraying into this genre of game (open world sandbox). In honesty, you can make a game look 10x better than anything in the trailer with assets purchased from asset store, but it may backfire when the art design clashes with the rest of the environment later down the road, it is a bad idea. If the gameplay is solid to the point that you cannot put down the controls of the game for the first half an hour, it has very well captured the expectation. I also think that this game should adopt some early access strategy to raise money (similar to Baldur's gate 3, bit of a stretch but expendable resources are resources to expand when it comes to early access). People like me who can spend a bit of money can help the devs make this a better game by buying it early and giving critical feedback and the community can enjoy a bug free experience on the day of launch. I also think that if this game were to adopt a more stylized approach (as someone who has dabbled into game development, the idea sounds crazy to me but it has done wonders for some games), there would be lower expectations on realism and more on the gameplay-loop.

[@Highphen]

isko ayese hee daal Dena chahiye tha Bina kisi trailer ke tag ke bagair, taaki feedback mil jaye aur trailer name daalke under development game ko dikha ke expectations atleast kill na karein, hype and marketing zaruri h...

[@akshatkhedekar8561]

Video sound thoda low lag raha hai , check karo nikhil bhaiya Aur ha ek sugesstion tha : game banane me thoda time jyada lage to chalega , 1 aad saal ka dealy to aajkal waise bhi normal hai

[@atharvajoshi1252]

Nikal bhaiya is really a nice person. ❤☺️

[@CUL14865]

Player movement look's like they doesn't use motion capture game ko abhi kafi development ki jarurat hopefully they understand what people want 😊

[@snapesrds5766]

The most played games are not always big-production games but indie games. There are many games launched, but not everyone can play them because their current PC or system is not capable of that level of performance. So even if the game is not as good-looking as MW2, etc., if the story, gameplay, and support from devs for future content are good, we are really happy because we want to play games after an entire stressful day and we want to play games that we can afford. If they produce something like GTA 6, but my system is not capable, then it doesn't matter if the game is Indian or not. Hey where we can test the game (demo) ?

[@deadinskyrimtomb]

tbh zassar mentioned three levels which is true but very basic things to talk about and there is huge gray area but making a game is entirely another beast to conquer what he mentions barely scratches the surface and most of the games he mentions sure has elements you can compare but not necessarily all of it Mumbai gullies is an ambitious project it is an open world third person shooter the only valid comparisons he mentions of are RDR2 and GTA both owned by big dog of gaming industry Rockstar and Mumbai gullies is just a new start and the budget constraint def will be a big issue to tackle even Nikhil mentions that kudos to him taking the feedback in a positive light and I agree with his approach and honestly speaking about the game. There is a lot to talk on this topic I still have hope for Mumbai Gullies and wish to see this game rise in ranks among the likes of GTA all the very best to Nikhil and his team.

[@adityatiwari3646]

Tip for the game - health bar ki jagah , opacity kr dijiye.....like full health pe opponent fully visible rhega and health low hote uski opacity Kam krte jaiye r marne pe yaa toh body aise niche jameen pe Directly collapse kr dijiye wrna koi cool sa animation marte time.... Additional Tip - cam add visible bones to the enemy which gets visible after after health deduction.....more the health more the muscles appear out of the body(veins) and lesser the health more the skeleton of the body appears.....I think you are getting that right what I trying express..... These things will work out for real dope shitt!!should work....🙂I mean better than those health bars!!.... Btw following since 4 years🙃💌✨

[@aryan_rai]

I have been following your channel since before the announcement of Mumbai Gullies. You have come a long way, and I hope you keep going further. I had some feedback that might help. First of all the health bar doesn't need to change, just remove it altogether. There is no need for an enemy health bar in an Action-Adventure game, it's not an RPG. You'd be wasting human effort trying to perfect it. And secondly, graphics do need some work. I'll suggest increasing the polygon count of props and characters as it stands out the most and investing more into better lighting and texture work, lighting being the most important of all. Textures don't need to be clean and perfect. Often the more dirt and scratches you find on a texture, the more realistic it looks. But that of course is subject to your art style. I understand that it'll come with a major performance impact but that's where good optimization comes in. This is what makes the difference between experienced and non-experienced developers. I know you want the game to be accessible so that most people can play it, even with a low/mid-end PC, which is reasonable, as the majority of people in India don't own a gaming rig. But you can use the power of customization to grant people a high range of graphics options that'll allow them to choose between higher fidelity and higher performance. Lastly, I wish you guys all the best. We want to see you succeed and most of all we want to play this game and want it to fulfill the expectations that were set when the announcement trailer was released.

[@parasgupta7392]

Mera ek suggestion hai ki aap badhe badhe youtubers ko apna gameplay khelne ka mauka dijiye aur unka feedback lekr aap apne gameplay ko improve kr sakte ho, jaise indus battle royal ko rawknee games ne khela Tha toh woh kaafi zaida famous hua hai aur issi Tarah aap bhi youtube streamers ko gameplay khelne ka mauka do jisse logon ko pta bhi lagega ki game ki development kahan tak hui hai aur kya kya achha ho sakta hai game mein, you can approach mythpat, rawknee, lazy assassin, total gaming,beast boy shubh, etc. Joh kaafi genuine hain aur woh apko ek genuine review denge. Unhone raaji ko bhi promote Kiya Tha aur woh indian games ko promote krte hain woh sabse achhi baat hai. So as a subscriber of your channel mai genuinely chahta hun ki aap approach Karo and best of luck and love and support from jammu.

[@kartiksharma5318]

I think Mumbai gullies break many records in India . All the best sir 👍🏻Jai hind🇮🇳

[@broniksindia]

Isro moon mission main ek bat kahi thi kisi ne kam ki bat suni hoto unhone kha tha ki moon mission duniya k liye race hoga humare liye ye race nahi h hum is tarah se nahi sochte hume ye karna tha bas india k liye hum fail hote jitni bhi bar farak nahi padta kamiyabi main kitna bhi time lag hume bas karna tha ,jo kiya bhi unhone this is the real power of india .... Bhai kuch kam jo humare desh main nahi hote ho thodebhot hone start ho rahe hai iski khushi banao naki bakwas karo rellay bhot bura lagra hai koi kisi artist k kam ko bura bolta hai reality jane ina ya us kam main kiya issues ate hai kaise hota hai uski abcd na pata hoto as a sr artist main nikhil bhai ki dil se respect karta hu ❤ or dil se chata hu ki ek stable company start kar sake unko cheer karo yr ... or kuch feedback hai to tarike se do ha

[@CrewDrastically]

15:52 Steam Reviews need to be open since you said it.

[@HacknSlashPro]

Sleeping dogs and Saints row type gameplay would be really appreciable

[@raunakroy3940]

Gameplay me acche acche functions hone chahiye, aur isme roleplay wala bhi system daal Dena ,play as cop or doctor or taxi driver,or anything 😊

[@Billioncompany786]

I would personally suggest ki Graphics department mai thoda work karna hoga before you guys launch another trailer. The presentation of trailer wasn't that catchy enough it looked like ki koi ek banda video editor se bus clips ko merge karke audio add kardiya ho. Game overall still feels like an Indie game project rather than a AAA game as it should be. I also noticed ki characters Shadow project nhi kar rahe the aur gameplay part is a bit laggy. I hope you guys are also working on optimization along side it.

[@nikmlnkr]

Thank you for the feedback. We shall improve the next trailer.

[@oogaboogacute]

quality girti ja rha hai sir par jo night view tha jab aapne gameplay revel kiya tha usme police ka costume tha vo best seen tha

[@KSR_77]

Some Suggestions 1. Improve Character and NPC's movement 2.Improve the animation of character entering in car 3.Add some NPC's interaction and use Indian outfits on npcs 4. Improve game lighting 5.Add some villages ❤❤❤

[@papul_6]

you should release the trailers with the caption* very early stages or very early build* that's the reason for some criticism

[@manmathgodre5360]

Interaction with our supporter discussion about any project is the best strategy Yeh Aisa hai ki agar hum akele hi kisi bade project pe kaam kar rahe toh apni itni khapat nahi hai akele hi itna handle kr paye toh phele apne supportive badao aur unko hi apna teammate bana lo

[@ryzen4070-j7m]

As A Gamer ... Some Advices and suggestions To Nikhil Sir (I hope he reads this) 1. please optimize the game as much as possible as you know the condition of majority people in india ....... Dont go for 4k textures for the base game... instead add it as a free dlc for those who can run it 2. Sometimes i wish for the graphics and extra content modders to be hired by a studio .. they can already make a good looking game great 3. Would love to see easter eggs and secret locations like the gta series so that this game can stay relevant for a long time. Best example is the Mount Chilliad Mural From GTA 5 4. Dont go woke 5. Need to have good character progression and memorable side characters (A notable example could be munna bhaiyya from mirzapur)

[@DoctorJain-vy2gx]

4th Point🗿

[@adityarawat9500]

full support bro work hard and it will be paid off 👍👍

[@bamremix8235]

Graphics quality matters a lot...I feel like if you start using Quixel megascans and 4K textures in Unreal Engine, it would make a huge difference to the quality. And also, the player health markers could be made better. Taking inspiration from Hitman and GTA would be helpful!

[@shivanshraghav538]

Boss you have sold me on this game , I will be buying first day no matter what. We need projects like these to exist in our ecosystem. Kudos to you and the team

[@bonjovi1354]

the thing is mumbai gullies is more ambitious project ..if u all see still rockstar took 25 27 years to develop gta 1000 and 1000s of artists nd workers nd still alot of bugs so i hav my hopesup ..because games like this takes time and continuous growth ...

[@ImaD34dM4n]

The lightning was good but post processing like ambient occlusion was missing out . If added it would have left different impression to us. I'm not saying that was very bad but there are some rooms for improvement. I think The devs should work more on lighting and how an object reacts after exposed to certain exposer of light . And for a PC game world textures and Global illumination looks very dull. Don't forget some details like lens flare, No hate by the way. And seeing his feedback he is the most humble game dev I've ever seen. Waiting for the next update.

[@ShubhamKumar-bu5fz]

Keep the gameplay on top priority It shouldn't feel repetitive add more functionalities

[@THA_PHOENIX]

Sir 2 saal or le lo par game next level hone chahiye ❤❤ Hamko aap par pura bharosa hai 😊😊

[@ashwinprakash436]

I would say, the beachside buildings look like matchbox, and some of the gullies and the vehicle looks a bit like clay model. The gunfight is very very mediocre, but I do believe there will be a good output by the end. My suggestion is that add a second layer of realism, such as in game lores, secrets through things such as posters, mobile ads. And a big thing I want to say is that, some of the buildings, especially those in gunfight areas, the things look too much squary, if that makes sense? Too much symmetry makes the world look mediocre (it felt like a pubg mobile terrain). And I think mo-cap is pretty easily available in today's development era, even KZbinrs with their bedroom as studio is able to put out decent output, the character movements felt lifeless, from the running to gunfire(there is a lot of physics playing out in a gunfight, and this felt none of them applied here). Please improve over the buildings and vehicles, do what gta has been doing since ages, do fake car brands which reflects real life. Again this all are the points I got from the trailer. I do keep hope on the final output. Also I suggest to keep updated on the development through posters or pictures instead of releasing half baked gameplay footage as 'trailers' as it gives a feeling of this is what is being finalized. Please make the game lively and interactive and provides a lot of freedom, or what happened with Watch dogs 2 and legion would be translated to here too. I don't expect GTA 6 but surely do expect something similar in what is done with GTA4. All the best.

[@UltraMonS12]

Texture Quality could be improved and Environment is little empty So, add some cracks ,Trash, potholes,half constructed Roads, Broken Roads ,Broken Buildings, Some Plants and Rocks ,Broken Vehicles,Road Barriers

[@mayank4156]

Gamedev is HARD. Even small games are complicated. Respect this profession.

[@ManishBhartiya]

In my opinion Mumbai Gullies should be a sandbox game, like Hitman, driven by a solid story. It would kick ass.

[@parasmore5620]

Sir it was great gesture from you but one GOOD recommendation for you that please improve voice quality so please consider this.

[@srishti2k22-iw5dh]

Sir iam a supporter and a student company secretary and a investor in your game i will stay invested as o know you started itself making good games You ill make it good with updates .. one suggestion As a student company secretary and Gen z i request you to release it max 750 rupees and other advertising inside the games Improve marketing 1 Need pentrationnin south india Kerala ( Dont make it a Nokia story) Marketing req Performance marketing will help Free realise shoud be there so that a community will adapt it After a wide adaption brand name will be know then make it paid Let your early supporters enjoy 2 legally looking good 3 realeasing for free quality shouldnt be compramised

[@Reality-Editz]

As a Pakistani i think that its not that good but i hope you will improve it & its also starting of game developement in India so i think thats a good start and i hope to get more great games in future!

[@Aryan_B2]

The only main thing that will improve the gameplay are the gameplay physics Physics== gameplay I think u need to use the euphoria engine for ragdoll physics.

[@SpotOnEntertainment]

This is how you handle criticism 👏

[@gamegamers2004]

Hey brother,I had some true dev suggestions for you,so basically after seeing the trailer,the character movement looks not that good,if you guys used ALS System for the base of the project,this would not have happened,secondly,the weapon animations,it looks like you aren't using procedural animations that's why it looks too foolish,this will result in a great mess afterwards if you don't fix these now,eithe game's graphics are stunning and after seeing the lighting,i hope you guys are using LODs for the meshes,i think it wiuld a well optimized game Thankyou, Sankalp,this side.

[@blacked_out]

PLEASE LIKE AND PUSH THIS COMMENT TO THE TOP __________________________________________________________ I would request the game developers to add these features : 1. Please do a lot of optimization so it can run on low end systems and thus a lot more people can play it. 2. keep the size of of the game as low as possible 3. allow modding

[@ShivaTheInfinite]

Mistake done by reviewer: Reviewing the game before it is launched. Mistake by game marketing and management: Announcing deadlines that they can't met. Please stay silent till you have a production level Alpha gameplay ready . If you want to attract investors then just post it on KZbin with watermark work in progress or send potential investors seperately but don't create false hope among public. People will lose interest and when your game is launched people will expect what demo they last seen and that was under development. So they won't purchase. This happened to many games and movies in past. WORK IN SILENCE AND LET YOUR RESULT SPEAK FOR ITSELF. And you can get feedback and improve after launching MVP. The feedback you are asking for is not even MVP (Minimal Viable Product) Best of luck to all the team.

[@koushik5437]

I can only imagine the hardship and responsibilities that lie on your shoulder , even if the graphics is descent ...it doesn't really matter ...you are doing something very big , hyper challenging ....we Indians must be really proud ...to put it in perspective ...many countries launched moon mission , yet ISRO's effort is a role model to the world....both in budget and quality ...so Graphics != quality ...Storyline and uniqueness is everything ...!!

[@_VenKyPlay]

Hii nikal bhaiya.!! Muje apka kaam acha laga bohat and I am very excited for Mumbai gullies Improvements needed:- 1) Walking animation like Gta 5. 2) NPC ka reaction toda real hona chahiye. 3) Vehicle Physics and Animation need to improve. 4) Graphics is great but need to improve more according to PC. 5) Shooting mechanism bhi accha kardo and remove health bar on enemies. At the end game is good i am waiting for final build ❤ Plz reply nikal bhaiya if you like my opinion 😊❤

[@furious_dracko583]

Nikhil's explanation is good and appropriate. I already liked the assets they have included to create the Mumbai vibe ! Good job 👍🏼👍🏼

[@thecodeprism]

Really great job on taking the criticism in a nice way, but I really hope to see some special mechanic in this game in terms of gameplay, for eg: bullet time physics , multiple clones or smth like that, it makes things interesting. Plus since currently it is possible to do so create a login system like blizzard to prevent piracy, blizzard checks the online user through a lot of methods and their whole gameplay is based on a response from their server, even when talking about their questing system, final responses are given from their server hence cracking the game becomes very difficult. I am saying this because piracy is very rampant in india and I wish you best of luck

[@ayuxhshah]

you got this brother. make us proud! but really wanna appreciate @zassar for his review, it really was very good.

[@dhruvzala5548]

Nikhill bhai ek baat hai joo Odd lagti hai bura maat lagana Ye left side camera view bohot odd lagta hai And second thing game ke physics sry muje coding to nahi ati but yeah character speed, gun system, camera angles, etc vo sab muje odd laga dusro ko sayad na lage 😅 And yeah still developing so if there are going to be changes then ignore this 😅 and yeah All the best 🌺

[@abhishekpradhan7777]

Sir, it's looking good but aapko gameplay mein zyada focus krna chahiye because it's a open world game aur iss genre mein gameplay zyada important he, graphics toh achche he lekin main isliye bol rha hun because you'll launch this game at international level. Yeh nhi bol rha hun ki GTA ke level ka banaiye 😂😂

[@manmathgodre5360]

Ek cheez sir kafi sunai de rahi hai ki Aapko Unreal Engine 4 pe hi reh ke Game develop krna chahiye tha kyuki usme aapka experience jyada aur gameplay bhi kafi accha dikha tha "Jail gameplay" Ispe bhi Sir aap ek video banaiye