REACTING TO OUR OLD VIDEOS (SURPRISE EMOTIONAL ENDING!!)

[@minenek]

I'm all tears watching this. Dave and Ashley is such an awesome parents to the kids. Your family is an example of how love looks like. Love you all😘😘

[@berenicereyesg.7895]

@@es5696 Congrats! Realizing it is the best thing to be a better and good mother. Your daughter is lucky and full of light too just like yourself. Infinite love and blessings for you two.

[@MRRYANGRIFFIN]

Btw dave has a yt channel called dave crosby

[@aiyshaali7553]

Claire: "We've always got your back and we're ready to support you" Me: 😭😭😭😭👍👍👍👍 Claire is so grown up

[@thunderbirdice]

Aiysha Ali she is way too grown up. Speaking just like an adult.

[@aiyshaali7553]

@@thunderbirdice lol😂😂

[@daliladeliahepes1564]

yep

[@alyssagrace1431]

shes more grown up than me and im lot older than her lol

[@ericquisenberry9043]

Definitely like I forgot about this channel and then I found it and I was like now I remember this channel !

[@jessicarodriguez8784]

I’m not crying, you’re crying... seriously, your family is always a breathe of fresh air in social media today. I respect the example you leave for everyone. Thanks for sharing it ❤️

[@mossrun]

I like Dave's honesty and appreciation for Ashley. We cherish greatest what we appreciate most. I do understand why Dave wants to see financial success and fulfilling his financial obligations to the family. I think Dave is pretty well grounded and his and Ashley's kids seem to be pretty down to earth as well. Watching their videos gives me hope for the future of this country.

[@chrisfulton9377]

The “bug” video is my all time favorite! I find myself when friends are “discussing” politics, quoting Claire saying, “let’s just talk about flowers” Families are forever and you have one of the sweetest! 🥰

[@angelarthrasher]

Funny thing is that if it was not for bugs (bees) there would be noooooooooo flowers!!!!!

[@hazelold2882]

Me too Chris!!! I quote from that video quite a lot 😂 “but for now, let’s just talk about flowers’ has come in very handy indeed 😊

[@thunderbirdice]

I’m the same as Clair. I love flowers but I don’t like most insects.

[@iiisimplycucumberxxx3976]

Now..let’s talk about flowers!!🌺

[@kavithamary1995]

Claire's talk is always matured and amazing and your family is God's gift and a good role model to anyone.

[@mathurabalu6130]

claire is much more mature than me and i am 11!

[@MrNikmax]

Shut up

[@briellescreativecorner9236]

Claire you are so beautiful

[@briellescreativecorner9236]

I'm only seven

[@jesseuguccini]

How is Ashely not the most arrogant person in the world? She’s literally the most beautiful person I’ve ever seen and she has a the best husband and 3 beautiful kids... it’s amazing how humble and genuine she is.

[@kristinasworld1692]

She is reading the bible! God teach us to be humble and full of love!

[@just.for.love.7880]

I know! She is the best person I’ve ever seen

[@thunderbirdice]

We definitely need to learn from her. All the hate in the world. Crosby Family is the most beautiful people I’ve ever met.

[@AndySaenz]

She's also very talented, she sings and plays piano very well.

[@tracyc4006]

🤗🤗🤗

[@catherinekelso5592]

Ashley! You are the centrepiece of such a beautiful family. Thank you for sharing all the love and joy with us xxx

[@florencialaurito6982]

I love the Crosbys, I subscribed to this channel years ago after watching one of the very first videos of Claire, but I stayed because of Ashley. I know that I don’t know her, but, through the screen, I can feel how sweet, caring and loving mom she is for those kids, and how good and supportive she is for Dave. Raising a family that is somehow in the spotlight it is not easy but she is rocking it. I admire her, she inspires me! Thank you for your example Ashley, your smile lights up the world!

[@sabrinalux3632]

When June blew that kiss I was in awe!🤗 Then Ashley started to cry more.😭😭

[@carolyncarroll3802]

This is awesome!! I am crying so hard! I love Claire saying at the end, "Mom, we have your back and support you!". Those are the words Claire has heard from both of you and she knows you mean it! Dave and Ashley, you two are such spectacular parents and all around the sweetest people. Your raising such a sweet little family that blesses us and we appreciate the sacrifice of all your hard work that each of you do... Even little Carson and June. Each of you play such a special part for us and make our weeks happy after your videos. Thank you😘

[@berenicereyesg.7895]

Love your words. I think that too. Thanks for sharing. Blessings always...

[@worms4africa]

So true

[@finburns155]

Man, I don't usually cry over KZbin videos but... I was bawling my eyes out over this one. I love you guys so much and am so thankful that I get to watch your guys' journey!

[@MzJust1girl]

I've never had fame or fortune and have never, ever wanted those things. Family is everything. Crosbys you are an amazing, blessed family. *tears streaming down my face*

[@thunderbirdice]

Kari Lynn The Crosby Family are the best people that are created in the universe.

[@nissyktomy281]

The ending indeed brought me to tears... Ashley is so humble and a wonderful lady... God bless your family.😍😍

[@jbauntie]

I cried through the majority of this video....so sweet. I could listen to your children laugh, talk and sing all day. Seeing past videos reminded me how long I’ve been watching your videos. I remembered Claire’s aversion to bugs lol, the pancake fail lol and Claire’s views on Valentine’s Day....sooooo sweet 😭 And the new video for Ashley was precious and so deserved....it’s not hard to see what an amazing mom she is. You’re both wonderful parents and you have a beautiful family that so many of us have fallen in love with. It’s such a joy to watch your children grow and to follow you on your adventures. Looking forward to your next video.❤️

[@berenicereyesg.7895]

Love your words also. I realized I missed the Valentine´s Day...I hope I can find it in order to watch it. Thanks. Blessings always...

[@lifeoftaty8794]

When she said “and you” when he left out himself when referring to their family .... My heart is full. 🥺

[@lisadalessandro7905]

Carson: "What's this thing I'm feeling?" Claire: "Scared? Oh, no it's the table." Hahaha I love them. :)

[@kimsloveforreborns6458]

Very well said,❤️❤️❤️🙏🙏🙏

[@jessicahedges6048]

I just paused the video and was looking for this comment because I knew that I couldn't be the only one who thought that was absolutely precious!

[@sabrinalux3632]

Jessica, I thought the same thing!!

[@pamelastoddard1]

😂 😂😂😂

[@wendyhenschel.]

These 2 are just the cutest. Cannot wait for June to catch up with her 2 sibling in their giggles

[@daniendres812]

I love how caring and nice claire is with her speech and we all hope you have the most awsome year

[@rebeccashirley5157]

I shouldn’t have watched this at my desk in the office 😭😭 you guys are such an amazing family. It’s been a pleasure to have the opportunity to watch Claire, Carson and June grow up. Hats off to you mama 💕

[@angelajohnson577]

Oh my goodness! Tears in my ears as I watch this (as I’m supposed to be sleeping!)! Beautiful! And my own heart is lighter for the experience! Thank you for sharing and showing your love - inspiring ❤️

[@kaitlinandrews7269]

That’s such an amazing surprise you made for Ashley, Dave! She is such an incredible person! Claire and Carson are so sweet, they’ve grown up and matured so beautifully! You have such a stunning family, I love watching your videos!

[@btsyarce]

I have followed your channel since your first video, the sweetness of you relationships with Claire always warmed my heart and made my days easier. My husband and i have been married for almost 10 years, and watching your channel and your family always gave me hope, that parenting can be so funny and amazing, even though we couldn’t have children. Last year when Claire learned to ride a bike, I showed that video to my husband and told him I wish we could have a child so I could teach the way you did, with so much love, patience and fun. And a few months later we found out we were expecting our first ever child, something doctors couldn’t help us achieve, and a dream we thought was lost and not meant to us. Now that I see your videos, I wish I could rise a happy child with the tenderness that you show. Thank you for showing that it is possible in this time to raise healthy, faithful and happy children against all wickedness that is in this world. Thank you so much. (Sorry for my English, I’m from Mexico by the way)

[@elizabethwright4784]

Ok now I'm bawling! What 7 year old thinks to tell her mom "We've got your back"? Love you all! 💗

[@marina.cudala]

Awww. This video made me cry...AGAIN. I've seen it before & I think I've commented on it too. Definitely cried the 1st time I saw it. Better than watching reality TV w/ people fighting all the time. What a truly kind family. And Dave... what a nice gesture. What an awesomely sweet & gentle man. May God protect them always. May each of them stay humble, authentic & down to earth. Crosby's... keep on doing the good stuff you do.

[@Trina_smiles]

I am soooo crying right now!! We love you Crosby’s!! Claire has so much passion in her words! JuJu is growing up so wonderfully! Cars is AMAZING little guy! I can’t thank you enough for sharing your family with us, I hope for many years to come! Bless y’all! 💕

[@ShawnMarie-i5n]

I cried so hard😭 This video really speaks to us out here. Such a beautiful expression of love for your wife and your children’s love for her❤️

[@Dachdogoriginal]

What makes a solid marriage? One thing is a solid and grounded wife who is humble, kind, supportive and respectful. Ashley always impresses me with her demeanor and her dedication. We all see it. You don't have to be famous Ashley. I admire that. How I look at your family Ashley is that you set an example to imitate. You have a wise wife Dave, listen to her. The world is not needed. It only allows place for the Devil. Keep your community small and just be yourselves. We love you guys.

[@Dachdogoriginal]

@Rico Williams I believe the bible. And I'm not here to debate with instigators. The world as in this ungodly system of things. Which is under the control of Satan. We have to live here. But we don't have to let its ungodly ways influence us or seek its approval. I don't think they are doing that. And I think they are spiritually centered people.

[@ionemurray2035]

A wife makes a happy relationship? Not both people who love each other. Crazy

[@alfachiara5281]

Crazy

[@Dachdogoriginal]

@@ionemurray2035 I didnt say that. Man, the trolls are out today.

[@forkygacha9272]

Rico Williams Rico Williams There are devils, that is what brings the baddest into people. You can’t assume that people just become mean because they want to, they become mean when a devil wants to control their life.

[@Gigi714]

June, “I wuv you” sims it up. The love you all have for one another is beautiful and is to be cherished. God Bless you, Carson family.

[@elaineinman7077]

Oh, this was so precious & thoughtful of you Dave. I'm truly thankful for each one of you. I am in my 70's with no grandchildren, so I thoroughly enjoy it that you share your sweet loving family as you do. I am a musician/singer, so have great appreciation for your beautiful musical talents. True love to you & your families... You're the best! ❤😢😍😙 God bless!!!

[@shelbieherold5902]

Had to stop the video to wipe tears so I could see the rest. You all exude love & what it means to put family first. Such an example to the rest of us. Love being on these adventures with you all!

[@laura8512]

Tears of happiness. Love that you follow your faith and stay grounded for your children sake. Blessings of great joy for the years to come.

[@dave730601]

You have an amazing family. What makes you so great is how humble you are about it. Thank you for sharing these videos.

[@Pepa14pig]

This is a perfect opportunity to teach the kids that once something is put on the internet, you can’t erase it... it’s up for everyone to watch. You have amazing kids and I hope they’ll stay sweet and grow up to be like their parents ❤️

[@nickpassion123]

Can't

[@Pepa14pig]

Angie Nimo thanks!

[@bernicehccheung]

young claire was SOOO CUTE and her reactions were gold. thank you dave and ashley for sharing them with us

[@mariekastigar2294]

What a lovely tribute to Ashley, Dave! I’m sitting here in snowy OH with tears streaming down my face. Love seeing the memories you have shared with all of us. Your family is so special. Love to The Crosby Family. XO’s 😍❤️🙏🏻

[@sydneydumelie4369]

The last two videos made me cry tears of joy. I really enjoy your family, youtube channel and kids!❤❤ Enjoy your day!

[@queenofthediscotheque]

I love her so much! Ashley inspires me to make a family as beautiful as yours and be a good human being. I don't think she realises how inspiring and loved she is

[@emmanicole_woz]

I loved it when Claire said “ sometimes you catch them and sometimes you squish them” SHE IS SOOOO CUTE!!! 💖😂😂 made me laugh sooooo hard!!! And then she said “I like flowers” and I LOST IT!!!!! SHE IS SOOOO SWEET AND PURE!!! Sometimes I wish we were all as straight forward as little kids!!💖

[@marylang7607]

This was one of your best videos ever. And yes, it brought me to tears. All couples should strive to have a “Dave & Ashley” kind of love And as parents you all are the best. You rare raising three beautiful and bright stars.

[@mira6875]

This video touched my heart 💓. Thank all of you for being such a good example of a great wholesome family. X

[@katelinthomson5249]

They are the cutest kids ever and I love seeing how much all three the kids have grown. I love the Crosby family so much, such an amazing family 😊🥰❤️ xxx

[@ritasais9941]

thats so nice

[@ChrisGilland]

I could not agree more with the most recent comment I see from 10 months ago. David, you truly are a role model! God bless you for the way you treat Ashley, as well as the kids. We need more husbands, and more dad's in this world like you. I have tremendous respect for you and what you did in the surprise video clip.

[@carrotswan5503]

yes...they have the best mom she's an angel to the family😇

[@caheddr]

Ashley, you’re so sweet and a blessing to your family.❤️

[@hollylevey5889]

I love the LOVE that you ALL share as a family. This world needs more of that. Thank you 💜💜💜

[@lauraclaire]

Omg best one yet. Dave I think I can speak for all of us when I say you just made us all cry. Thank you for this channel it's a joy to watch your family is beautiful. you don't have to worry about going big with the music stuff. Just watching you and Claire do your thing together with singing and the guitar is gorgeous maybe do a song together with Ashley and the piano I love the acoustic stuff. Ashley you remind me of my mum with how loving you are with your beautiful family.

[@amberstephenson8744]

DAVE - Standing ovation!!! Totally cried. We love you, Ashley! You’re the glue that holds it all together. Our family loves you guys so much and it’s so refreshing to watch you grow over the years and stay true to yourselves and your family. Keep at it! 😭

[@7mec]

Claire, Don't doubt yourself EVER. I know it all doesn't happen in front of a camera. I am happy to see kids participating and replicating/recipicating kindness bubbles. Please you don't have to share with "the public". I am eager to hear good news on #4

[@juliecrozier3614]

OMGoodness!! So beautiful. Ashley held it together better than I did! 😭 So pure. So beautiful! America is blessed to have your family represent us!

[@remembertodaysanewday1575]

You all are amazing, amazing people, an amazing family, amazing. I don’t know how anyone could watch and not be in tears.. it’s just so sweet. 💝💝💝

[@jhascefelmarishanezulueta4950]

The Crosbys are very lucky to have Ashley as their mom ♥️

[@TheNight171]

That was the sweetest video you made for Ashley...had me in tears 💗 I loved the kids reaction they are too cute and funny! Love being part of your journey and watching your family grow.

[@Karen-dx4cs]

I loved this video today. It brought happy tears to me. Watching you all and your love for one another is such an inspiration. I love to see and feel the presence of God in your lives through your videos. It was such a great contribution to our ❤Love❤ month. Happy Valentine's Crosby family!❤❤❤

[@kimmyhawk5612]

What a wonderful tribute to your beautiful wife! What an amazing family! Oh, and I haven't seen your videos in a looooong time and just found out you have another lucky beautiful baby on the way.. Congratulations to the Crosby family! 🎉 You guys rock!!!

[@sharonannamathew4534]

One day I want a family like urs sweet,kind,caring,God fearing,fun and amazing! Praise God for this close family..love all the way from India 💟

[@marierivera1456]

Seeing Dave react to Clairs first cry at 9:08 after all this years warms my heart.

[@hoosierladyus48]

I love the video Dave made for you, Ashley. I was crying right along with you. Your kids have gotten so big and sweeter than ever. God Bless your family.

[@carebearz227]

I just can't get enough of this beautiful family. Dave and Ashley, you are the most perfect parents and your babies are so lucky to have you both. It's so nice to see kids who are so sweet and respectful and so full of love in this day and age because those qualities in children are so hard to come by lately. God bless your beautiful family and thank you so much for sharing your lives with us.

[@tinapinneo7423]

Keep on building a family full of LOVE! What a beautiful surprise in support of a beautiful mother!

[@ericagonzalez6287]

Wanted to watch something to make me laugh and smile. Decided to watch you guys and now I'm in tears. How adorably sweet

[@juliettemccartney]

Wowww I can’t stop crying 😭❤️ They are seriously so cute at that age, cherish every moment! You’re so blessed to have these amazing videos to look back on.

[@Caliashford123]

I don't usually cry while watching videos, but this one touched me deeply and tugged at my heart strings. We watch your videos every week...we live in San Jose Ca. so we feel we were somehow a part of the beginning of your journey since you lived here for a short time. Our granddaughter (she's 5-almost 6, & we have been raising her for 3 years) wants to be a singer because of watching Claire. She has had a rough life, but watching Claire has brought joy to her broken heart and is a HUGE reason she is doing as well as she is today. We have watched Claire's "Into the Unknown" video THOUSANDS of times. :) Thank you for bringing us such joy these past years. Love to you all!!

[@TXNLaurenMcN]

Every part of this video was exceptional and I loved it. Dave, your surprise video for Ashley and her reaction was absolutely beautiful. Now, I have to watch it all again so I can see it without tears blurring my vision. Love you guys!

[@antoinettefoster5598]

Thank you for sharing those beautiful videos. It's only when you look back you realise how fast time flies & how quick your gorgeous children are growing up. You are amazing parents & they are so lucky to have you both. Dave, you reduced me to tears with your special video for Ashley. It was great the way you made it not just about yourself but incorporated the kids too. Hope you enjoyed your surprise Ashley. Love watching you guys. Stay safe & again, thanks for sharing your special moments with us...xx ❤️

[@pattiharrison1211]

Awhhh. So touching... I had tears through that last half , happy tears - you are all such nice people, sending love ❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@Joy-qw3wm]

Omg! It took but a few seconds for me to tear up.You're such a beautiful family ,God bless you now and always xxx

[@rienekewesterink9852]

Thank you for sharing this precious moment with us... IT was thouthing my hart. I'm blessing you all with the love of Jesus, from the Netherlands.

[@harrietmullen936]

You’re a Beautiful Family that bring so much Happiness to so many other’s. Thank you.❤️

[@rebeccashoemaker4443]

I cried so much watching this beautiful video. I became a fan after seeing Claire sing on “Little Big Shots”. It’s amazing how much the kids have grown. Love you guys!

[@susansunga7527]

You’re an amazing Mom, Ashley! God bless you.

[@alinachacon4897]

OMG! 4yr old Claire explaining love and Valentine's Day ❤ and Dave made me cry #daveandashleygoals

[@marina.cudala]

Yeah...Dave made me cry too. What real love & appreciation he has for his wife.

[@arandomgirl306]

I love how the kids laugh at things that aren't even funny. Love your family!

[@hannahpowell2459]

I love when clair said Carsten broke a whole cup of glass

[@ajhwood1961]

I wish I would have found someone like Dave. That never happened for me but I love you and your family!

[@seajay20]

Ditto!

[@lovingtherain]

Me too!

[@maggiemae8110]

Same

[@godsbabeborn-again5945]

Same 😭

[@matttaylor9141]

Thank you so much for sharing your family with all of us. You are an inspiration to us every day. I have been happily married to my lovely wife for going on twenty four years, our kids are grown and providing us with grandchildren now. But it is truly in the collection of “little moments” that life is remembered. We pray for your family every day, your ability to stay humble in all of your talents and successes is amazing. May God bless you greatly!

[@mishionajourney]

You are the most perfect family in the world 🌏😍 Claire - you are amazing 🎤🤩 Jun - you're so cute😘 Carson - You're the sweetest kid I've ever seen🍭 Dave and Ashley - You have amazing kids👨‍👩‍👧‍👦 Love you so much❤

[@carolyngalbraith6202]

OMG. I AM CRYING CROC TEARS. YOU GUYS ARE SO SWEET. WE LOVE THE EXAMPLE YOU SHOW OF KINDNESS AND REAL LOVE IN THE FAMILY. GOD BLESS THE FIVE!!!

[@gobernice1015]

I don’t cry easy but this made me cry. Thank you for showing how a loving family works. Love you Crosby’s!

[@dorisbaier8385]

Great job Ashley!! You are so brilliant at your role as a mother & wife! You do a great job, we can so easily see your gentle & kind spirit you have within you, this family is extremely blessed to have such a human being as you among them!

[@sabrinalux3632]

I LOVE the Crosby’s and all their videos! If there’s a such thing as a perfect family, this one’s it! Family over Fame😭🤧

[@kookienutquacker8692]

My gosh, I love your family! I’m crying like a baby. What a touching gift to the world, Dave. You are the best.

[@homemanager12]

I love this sooooo much!!! This had me in tears. Ashley is the kind of mom I wish I would have been way back in the beginning of my parenting journey.

[@michelem7986]

💕😪 Just. So. Very. Sweet. Whew! What a dear family expressing love.

[@SeriousMUAddiction]

Such an incredibly sweet thing you did for Ashley, Dave! Your family is adorable!

[@margaretsleator5530]

Why all the advertisements...lthat is the only part I dislike with family video

[@pattijack]

Keep on keeping on!! Nice to see a loving family doing it right!

[@stariabeebe2037]

Omg their laughter is so beautiful and contagious. Thank you for sharing and making me smile ❤️

[@moonlightedmochii]

I cried, I love how far the Crosbys have come, I can't wait for more to come.

[@candylover1433]

That family video at the end made me cry. Happy Valentine's Day!

[@Dori1974]

This was a perfect reminder that many internet sensation/stars didn't plan on being as famous as they are or the family become famous along with an individual in the family. This was a beautiful video that brought the tears of appreciation.

[@MaureenHelsel]

This is beautiful! I can't believe how articulate Claire has always been!

[@elainelindsay5296]

Cutest family ever. Love watching these videos, brings back so many good memories. Great record to keep and watch in the future when the kids are all grown up. 💜 the Crosbys.

[@gayleneelaban1161]

Oh my gosh how totally precious! All those children, what a blessing to have all those videos of them since they were born so cute so smart so funny so adorable! And the two of you are wonderful parents! I really special family! Can’t say it enough, watching your videos makes my heart so happy! Look forward to many more.

[@raynaheadrick1822]

Oh my gosh sitting in Dr waiting room with tears bc y’all are so stinkin precious. ❤️🥰 Thanks for sharing your lives.

[@teenamaree5660]

And I would like to tell you, Ashley, you make motherhood look easy....You are hands down the best mom I've ever seen...You're in the same class as Diana Ross, when it comes to being a mom..and I love you and Dave, Claire, Carson, Junie and Millie Blake so very much. You are my very favorite KZbin celebrity family. God bless you guys, forever and ever..Amen.

[@Mim-hs2pn]

Who’s cutting the onions here! 😭😭😭

[@LynnDay]

Same person that's cutting them here! 😭😭😭

[@hope_evergreen]

Same here 😭😭😭

[@seajay20]

Ditto!

[@abigalebuss359]

I'm a mess from crying 😭

[@aiyshaali7553]

@@abigalebuss359 saaaaammeee

[@katt3328]

My heart is so full. Your family is so beautiful! I hope I one day have a family as close and wonderful as yours.

[@hannainfo]

You make my crie, They are tears like troops from heaven to say thanks to you and Jesus. So many time I get comforted to listen and watch. I pray that your exemple will be a special heavenly blessing for millions people.

[@jonoeschger1552]

Well done, Dad! Great tribute to an incredible wife. Crosby Family...stay safe and continue to make music.

[@msmeilindarosioma]

Ashley is really a great person. I can tell💛

[@waterfalls4518]

I just love💖 the way you do family. Brings tears to my eyes watching all the love pour out in such a natural, simply beautiful way. God bless you and protect your tribe.💖💖💖💖💖

[@clairesim2489]

Hey, Fellow Claire here! I'm a Claire too! I just wanted to say I love u guys, and I think that all of your children have such great potential, will be extremely successful, and were and are raised so well!