Reacting to "St. Anger Reimagined" hate comments

Good, let the hate flow through you!
Confession: Being the gluttons for punishment that we are, we mostly did this video for ourselves. However, while we were on the topic of our St. Anger cover, this seemed like a good opportunity to dive a little deeper into why we covered the song in the first place. If you're interested in hearing more about the process or you're just here to laugh along with us, then join us as we go through the worst comments we got.
DISCLAIMER: Please do not seek out any of the commenters and harass them. We only made this video to poke fun, not to send an angry mob out to those whose names are blacked out for a reason.
James Hetfield quote clip: ‪@metalupyourpodcast9664‬
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
0:00 Intro
1:18 Reading some good comments first
2:12 The end
2:21 SIKE!
2:37 Part 2 (shoutout to ‪@AlexHefner‬)
2:58 More positivity?
4:17 That's it?
5:23 There's the hate comments!
6:28 NO ANGER
7:41 The Metallica simps
10:15 "We've got clipping"
11:27 The Metallica haters
13:24 Lukewarm comments
14:38 It's raining salt
16:29 "The lyrics are different"
17:21 The weakening
18:22 Why we did St. Anger Reimagined
21:25 Outro
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Music used (in order):
Gürschach - St. Anger [Metallica Reimagined]
Gürschach - Köpfschtpökau
Gürschach - Undead Empire
Gürschach - No Anger
Gürschach - St. Furious
Heat Of Damage - Voyage To The Highlands
X - Project Vyntrygyl: Chapter 1 Base
Gürschach - Purest Momentum
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WEBSITE: www.gurschach.com
INSTAGRAM: / gurschach
TWITTER: / gurschach
FACEBOOK: / gurschach
BANDCAMP: gurschach.bandcamp.com
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Please don't subscribe ;_;
#gurschach #hatecomments

[@tannerfiddler7676]

I actually really liked this cover. I honestly wish you guys would cover the whole album. I loved it. Maybe consider covering all within my hands

[@bobmiller6870]

I was laughing so hard by the 10-minute mark that I nearly pissed myself and fell out of me chair. Fortunately, I was able to keep it together and then you guys put up that "Holy wall of text" from that one comment at 11:03 ... And remember to click that sub button peeps. We want to see a Shot in the Gut Part III...

Don't listen to this man, don't subscribe, we will die ;_;

[@jesswise8680]

I’m a big Metallica fan, and I love your cover of this song! You guys are very talented, don’t listen to any of the hate

[@damianblu]

I like the mix between people saying "metallica does everything absolutely perfectly" and "metallica is gruff and unpolished" Are they ultra clean and perfect or are they a diamond in the rough?

[@sharf661]

guys pls cover the whole album!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 🤘🤘🤘

[@arcadeslum5882]

You guys need to do this more often, make a podcast shitting on music videos and the comments section. Like Beavis and Butthead did and Mystery Science theater before them. This was FUCKING. HILARIOUS!

[@TommyTrink]

Loved the cover, loved your appearance on Metallicast, and I love these videos. You guys have more or less the same type of “goofy dork” energy that my best friend and I have, and I always have a good time watching! ...SUBBED.

[@khellendross3573]

6:43 still better than the original

[@jeffhermes1139]

I mean, I loved the cover. I don't care what anybody else says 😂

[@SlyHikari03]

Metallica/Metal fans hate change. Also, the “Metallica otaku” sentence made my die laughing. Ps. That vine reference at 12:42 was gold.

[@paulgronner]

I just did a real long solo road trip and decided to listen to St. Anger in its entirety because I never really gave it a chance back when it was released. There are actually some really great riffs that impressed me. That being said, yes, the production sucks. If I had the money I would definitely pay you guys to do the whole thing. The vocals sounded great, kinda old school Metallica and the solo was a great addition. James lyrics have a lot to be desired since Justice and I fully support a reimagining. Looking forward to hearing more from you in the future!

[@futurewavecs]

Haters are gonna hate. EDIT: LOL - You got me. Not haters.

[@kennethmanning9984]

It’s the way it should of been allong

[@Lost_n_Found_1]

Saaaaaaiiiiint Aaaaaaanger restless leg, heeeeeee never rests his leg. Ya walk it off, ya walk it off!

[@ProjectMayhemYT]

I've never been a Metallica fan, when I watched Alex's video I had to go watch Metallica's version as well because your cover was so amazing. Your cover is 100% amazing, been listening to a lot other songs from you all as well. Keep up the amazing job

[@The_Pony]

The intro, X....... If I was single, damnit boi 😂😂 Edit: I'm not really a Metallica fan, but I loved your cover Re-edit: Scotty, your humor is amazing

[@sarakaster]

omg Pony behave! lol

[@Daquarius_.]

Man i love the original st anger and honestly i coincidentally came across your version a few days ago. I've been head banging since my first listen, simply can't get enough of it. Awesome work you guys! Shit is INTENSE AS FUCK!! FOCK ON🤘🏼🤘🏼🤘🏼

[@CalebMJSharp]

i came from alex. i like both the original and your cover, great job!

[@TrainSkater3709]

9:20 yo frantic cover when tho? 👀

[@PastorShayne]

Your redo is the best Metallica has sounded since Justice! You had me at the bass.

[@Dcool77]

Too bad we weren't friends at that time X cause I do in fact enjoy St. Anger. And from time to time i listen to it. In fact the other night i liatened to the whole album at work.. doesn't hurt that i was pissed off so that is a very good album to listen to when you're pissed.

[@poopypants660]

I love it

[@rayjackson5499]

Try Covering Shoot Me Again or Invisible Kid

[@swisscheeseaviation590]

I quite like the original St Anger, but your cover improved an already good song. Keep up the good work.

[@TheMetalMixtape]

Love this video lol You guys kickass

[@chv.9665]

no anger on spotify when?

[@CannonTongue]

YESSS JACK DANIELS!!!!

[@davidhughmiller]

Haters can hate but I fracking love both versions of St Anger! And yeah, I like the album too.

[@francisbacon3949]

I don’t understand why people are acting like you can’t like both versions

[@Gremlin.liftz0_]

You guys had a two part solo on a Metallica song what did I think was gonna happen? Dude U guys crushed gives me ideas for my band

[@regorf]

That Megadeth shirt to piss off the Metallica simps. Brilliant.

[@Sumpfkrebs]

Maybe you could make a re-imagination of "All Within My Hands"??? Kill, Kill, Kill, KILL, KILL, KILL!!!!!

[@ShiggyMiyamo]

Just happened upon the cover when I felt like hearing the original again. I'm one of the minority that likes the record. I think the cover is pretty damn good, too. Gonna check out your other shit now. Goal achieved?

[@Prophias]

hahaha, meme it up boys!

[@TheMetalMixtape]

I SPIT MY WATER ALL OVER MY COMPUTER WATCHING THIS LOL

[@chv.9665]

already cracked up at metallica otakus

[@marcograppasonno7965]

You're version kicked ass!!

[@a.t.3192]

I have my own criticisms of your cover (even though I think it's mostly great!) but I really can't understand why people would complain about the lyrics. Your changing of the lyrics was one of the biggest improvements to the song, because though I do like some of the imagery and symbolism in James' original lyrics, it's so fucking repetitive. There's like one or two verses and a single chorus that they just copypaste throughout the whole song. Your rewrite really breathed some life into the lyrics. It's weird that people are criticizing you for that.

[@Gabrostil]

Tbh, i love st anger, the whole album (almost, not a big fan of invisible kid and unnamed feeling) But your version is just better, in every sense, guitar tone, drums in general, i just think that it's better than the original, and i love the original and the song being different i think that it's better than a straight cover, trying to imitate James' voice for example imo

[@hectoramador6397]

Invisible kid 2015 is very nice

[@ntsHR]

I loled at the jack daniels part

[@RubyRoks]

Frankly, i mean, like Shit-giving aside, great video and the cover rocked

[@decent6175]

You guys are fucking geniuses 😳

[@fabian7463]

This song was a sick cover...

[@andresardon2286]

Well you defenitly should make another risky move

[@annath_ii]

Poor guys, they just want to be hated ;DD

[@rottengut]

I think it was a great cover because it is its own thing, not a carbon copy.

[@hostofsoulslol]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/ooaQhnxplJt7ma8 :Y'all don't have to re record the whole thing. Already been done!

[@charliemartin8955]

For the record, "No Anger" would actually sound identical to Metallica's St. Anger. So much so, that there may be a copyright infringement lawsuit if it were to be made. Too bad, sounded promising, promising...ly bad.

[@snake7156]

I mean, your version sucks so much, I totally did not listen to it 500 times and played guitar over it. And I totally don't wanna have a beer with y'all because you really don't look chill I love y'all just flex on them haters

Ah, no way dude, that sounds awesome! Tell you what, if we gave you a version of the song without the guitar solos, would you mind making a video of you playing along to it? Oh wait, I mean screw you

[@snake7156]

@ yeah, the sad part is that I don’t have anything to record on, but I can try Huh I mean yeah piss off

[@Crispy808]

The song belongs to you now

[@charliemartin8955]

Wtf is everyone talking about? This album was ABSOLUTE SHIT! Gürschach SAVED this song from ridicule! If these keyboard warriors injected all this raw emotion into the original St. Anger...IT WOULD EMERGE AS THIS VERSION!

[@marthastubbs8321]

Your new version is so much better. The new lyrics are so much better too. Rather than the lazy copy pasted pro tools Metallica version you improved it

[@tomanderson798]

Here’s a HATE comment… I HATE the original !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!