Reacting to Treasure Box: Episode 3 | Ams & Ev React

••••
INSTAGRAM📸
Our channel (amsevreact)- ...
••••
Logo made by: Matias Jacob- www.instagram....
••••
Business Email: [e-mail]

[@AmsEvReact]

Hello everyone, this is Ammy writing 😊 I just wanted to tell you guys that I appreciate everyone's comments. Evelyn and I do read every single one, even if we don't give them a heart or a like. I will always be grateful for the love and support, every comment, concern, opinion, etc. What I said in the video is exactly how I felt when watching this episode. For the people that don't know me, I've always been the type of person to say what's in my mind. I tend to not hold back and at the end of the day, some people might like it, a lot of people won't, and honestly that's okay. We can all agree to disagree. Now in regards to Hyunsuk, I still believe he's an AMAZING person; one with pure intentions, a great leader, an amazing artist with a beautiful soul. No one's perfect, and I didn't say those comments to disrespect him; this was never my intention. What I said in this video, doesn't change my honest opinion or love towards him. He will continue to be my ultimate bias in Treasure. Thank you again to everyone for your love and support, for your concern, even for the little bit of hate, it's okay 👍; Thank you! P.S. I won't throw away the Hyunsuk pillow.. didn't punch it either for those of you who are concerned lololol!! Love you guys!! ❤ - Ammy

[@anggioktaviani4014]

I mean now that you know about his situation, you're not planning to at least to say/feel sorry for judging him like that? lol, you do not even address the real issue afterward. But whatever

[@fucku9492]

Thank you for understanding..we know you love hyunsuk very much,and i witness that in your back..i know everyone has diff.opinion i dont blame also my co teumes for commenting,coz they know the struggle of hyunsuk since mixnine,and how close teamA..God bless!!! heheheheheh

[@__kashea__]

I wasn’t concerned about what you were going to say because I’ve understand that you (Ammy) really just speak what you think and don’t hesitate. I was really concerned about the Hyunsuk pillow I was scared he was going to be put under your bed for a while! Lol 🤣

[@naddianesanna1055]

I hope after u read all comments & explanation u will have diff way to view upcoming situation. sorry if we love these kids too much & can’t bear the harsh words. but honestly they don’t deserve it. btw, will be waiting for next ep. thank u for your love & willingness to learn more about Treasure journey. happy holiday ❤️

[@nc8586]

Ammy, appreciate your honest reactions and explanation. I was fearing for the Hyunsuk pillow ngl. We know you love Hyunsuk still dw.

[@jaehyukbae7813]

baby junghwan struggle with his opening line, but now in treasure he mostly got the opening line and be a center. so proud of him😭❤️

[@CELEBEEJ]

i'm proud (╥﹏╥)

[@ashashborn7307]

We called Junghwan as our intro king...

[@chediebedos4702]

His diction is good in any language ... Same as junkyu and yedam..

[@leenanishanthi2817]

Yup ....

[@kwisha9595]

I just want to say, Hyunsuk had no ill intent with his words when Midam left. Treasure A were together the longest (2-4 years) and i think he just wished they could have performed together as a team for the last time. That's also why Treasure A were crying after they performed. You will see in the next few episodes of YGTB how selfless Hyunsuk is, I don't want to spoil anything but it doesn't get better for him in the next episodes yet he still supported everyone around him and helped them get better even when his future didn't look bright. Also, with the previous episode I don't think he meant they deserved it cause they've been there longest. I think he was simply explaining how they've been there longest yet they couldn't be on top and he was embarrassed and mad (at himself) that it turned out like that. I also want to note past yg trainees and treasure members have regarded Hyunsuk as someone who guided and supported them, i don't think that many people would say such good things about him if he was a selfish person.

[@ardeegallega3121]

agree

[@boradoriichoi9667]

yes, also there's a rumor that midam actually leave ygtb because he doesnt want to beat his friend, and also if I'm be hyunsuk, I'll do the same thing cause, midam is really great but yeah like what you said:(

[@pratyashagupta2331]

Exactly !I agree with you!!

[@코알라-n7e]

agree

[@lovelune1011]

agree!

[@widyawandira1079]

The scariest thing abt yg trainer and 'yg' himself is tht they never yell or shout at you when you're wrong... they just give harsh comments tht kill you inside with a poker face

[@lovelife5467]

💯 thats also one of the point that scared me the most of YG family

[@Booguhnbelle]

Ikr. But still love them 😂

[@stantreasure7900]

for me that's the the good thing abt how YG train their artist. better to learn from criticism rather than sugar coated words without the assurance

[@mariellerosales7054]

In short, YG doesn't babying their trainees:) He's making them ready for the real world.

[@gabbipicar1126]

Yeah, it just depends on how the trainees are gonna take it.

[@icemorcillus955]

I respect your opinion but its not that Hyunsuk is heartless or very selfish. He actually wanna perform even for the last time with all the members.

[@samantharahman6706]

Hi Ams and Ev, Hyunsuk is behaving this way because he badly wanted Treasure A to debut together. They all trained together for years and YG made them believe that they (as in treasure A) are the next in line to debut. Moreover, Hyunsuk wanted Midam to stay since they were together for many years and he knew how good Mi Dam is and how he is giving all these up more so when he needed to show his full potential that Hyunsuk was already aware of. While watching the treasure box in 2018, even I was frustrated just like Hyunsuk because I thought treasure A will surely be the next group to debut. Also, YG fans called treasure A as "Silver boys" since at that time we all knew they will debut together. Later, he introduced this cruel survival show (that too with so many new trainees) which was not really fair for treasure A. Fun fact: Treasure A members are more like brothers and best friends; Hyunsuk and Byunggon are very close to a point where they put each other's pictures as their phone's wallpaper. LOL

[@_RL.]

I felt bad for the group and Midam when I first watched this...and apparently Midam joined another company after and joined another show. I think things happen for a reason and Midam was not meant to be with YG but I lost my compassion for Midam after I found out he ended up with another company and joined another battle show.

[@brendav4695]

@@_RL. maybe he had to leave it to know that he wanted it

[@user-ui5vh5fc4q]

Suk and Gon were the original mom and dad of team A LOL.

[@jea284]

i get your point about hyunsuk but actually as a hyunsuk stan who has been watching him ever since mixnine i know that he’s gone through so much thinking that he was about to debut but it got canceled and i think he understands what midam is feeling at that time but he kinda got disappointed at him cause they were a group for a long time, they faced so much hardships together and he was trying to keep their group together cause they think that it’s their last chance to debut. midam hasn’t shown his full potential in ygtb and i know that hyunsuk knows how much talent and skill midam has that’s why he was trying to tell him to not give up and show what he can do. if you guys will watch the next few episodes you guys will se how selfless hyunsuk is:) i dont think heartless and selfish is the right word but i understand your point thooo

[@pratyashagupta2331]

I agree with you!

[@xxialbl1449]

yes, I think they've tried their best to reach out to Midam. I saw fansite's photo of Hyunsuk hanging out with members after Mixnine

[@Booguhnbelle]

👍

[@prettysavage557]

Exactly! He just wanted Midam to hang in there for another month and debut together. Since it is so hard to debut in kpop.

[@vip_bang547]

Hyunsuk actually wanted Mi dam to Hold on just like the rest of TEAM A

[@hc8637]

Knowing how you already misunderstood Hyunsuk’s actions from the 1st episode up to now i’m afraid that you will continue miss understanding his actions on the next episodes. I hope as you go on try to remind urself that the show is only 10% of what really happened, let’s not be too quick to judge everything base on it.

[@goinbulilit3846]

Exactly, i learn it watching Produce...the MNET evil editing.... Kang Daniel.... To Not JUDGE base on the little video only.

[@odethbrutas]

In episode 2, Hyunsuk does not think he/they deserve the top spot. He was expressing his dissapointment in himself and the rest of Treasure A because they've been trainees for far longer and were given every support other trainees could only dream of and yet they weren't able to meet the expectation. His comments were not toward feeling superior among other trainees but embarassment toward themselves from not reaching a standard. In this episode, Hyunsuk wasn't being crass but was actually being nostalgic. He was trying to grasp a last moment for "silverboys", because that evaluation was the last time they will get to perform as a team. They knew that after that evaluation, they're bound to be separated and they've been an unofficial group in yg for more than 2 years. I get that with just that scene, anyone can easily misunderstood. Hyunsuk is far from selfish, the kid has no evil bone in his body.

[@antdee7743]

OMG, your saying that ''the kid has no evil bone in his body'' suddenly makes me remember that kyucalyptus' content about sorting treasure from lawful good to chaotic evil 😂😂😂

[@linn4823]

exactly!!! Hyunsuk has always been so selfless, everyone can see that

[@jays171]

I don’t want you to misunderstand them.. In the last episode, when Junkyu wasn’t confident, remember how A team members have sent Doyoung to say ‘You worked hard today’ to Junkyu? You said they were making fun of him. But that’s wrong. You don’t know how long they were together as a team. They comfort and love each other so much. They really meant to cheer him up. It was kinda awkward but it definitely wasn’t intended to make fun of him. This episode, you’ve mistaken Hyunsuk’s words. He cared of Midam. He wanted Midam to stay in their team. Didn’t you all see how he was crying when Midam was leaving??? Please don’t misunderstand these precious boys. You know how nice they all are! He was NEVER selfish.And Hyunsuk’s attitude wasn’t like that. He wasn’t like ‘How dare they are on top of us?’ Don’t you remember the interview? Hyunsuk said he felt angry+embarrassed how they were under the list. He was angry at himself, not to the boys who were on top of them. I’m sorry if my comment made you unhappy but please I really love your reactions and simply want you to NOT misunderstand them.. please! It would mean a lot to me if you leave a comment about this comment!! Thanks girls + the day Midam left their dorm without a notice was ONE day before the assessment. Team A already had the part division and the choreography for seven members. But Midam left right before it so they had to quickly change the parts and some dances. So it definitely would’ve gave them a mental breakdown. Not only cause they are losing a teammate, but they also needed to revise a lot from their performance. +Evelyn said that she thinks it’s also the other teammates fault why Midam was like that, that they didn’t put in effort to hang out with him. But I think it isn’t the truth. What you saw, the way the edit portrayed it, it’s just a few moments of them together. How can we know when Midam joined team A, whether they tried hanging out with him or not? How would we know whether they talked about it and decided to respect the way Midam is(=not exactly a socialized guy) and gave him space he needed? We shouldn’t judge them just watching these few moments. +Midam made the choice to quit. He is still doing his music and was a part of another survival show and currently is a trainee in another label. I love team A so I look in his instagram account from time to time. I support them all. Midam was stressed out and couldn’t bear the burden that he needed to compete his friends.. I’m NOT saying it’s Midam’s fault. It’s totally understandable. But we shouldn’t think that Hyunsuk was selfish. Please don’t. I hope they read the comments and maybe could change or add these point of view.

[@littlepenguin9064]

Yeaa tbh i think they missunderstood many things😭 i was like whaatttt am i the one who got it wrong and then i realised they r the one who missunderstood 😫

[@antdee7743]

That is what is called a different point of view. For us who have known these A team boys for a long time (fans even called them Silver Boys), we understand what's going on between them. And we even know their real personalities. But clearly here, Amy and Evelyn do not know the history and they state their opinion from their POV. Remember when they said, they're not familiar with that kind of idol trainees system in South Korea. No offense to anyone, I just try to understand both sides. Being the longest trainees is agonizingly hard, because they never know whether they will debut or not, or when and how they will debut. Moreover, seeing their long close friends leaving one by one is totally hurtful. The desperation is real. It's just that they have different ways to express it. Some will cry, some others will look angry or annoyed, while some others will say confident remarks to motivate themselves. I remember when I saw a reactor saying he didn't like what Seunghun said because it sounded so arrogant. But for me, it's understandable because I knew his situation and that's how he tried to cope with his feelings.

[@user-kl5jm2yz8j]

I also thought like that,,things are not that simple,Midam has a quiet and reserved personality .It does not mean that he didnt had a good relationship with Treasure A,they had been training together for a long time,we cannot jugde based only on this moment.

[@blackpinkbtstreasure]

I totally agree with this. Hyunsuk really cared for him. He wasn't selfish at all. He wishee that all Team A will make it no matter what. Quitting is never an option. If you want to win, never quit.

[@jace425]

They haven’t watch enough survival shows especially from YG. This maybe pretty much new to them, I think that is why they misunderstood

[@sitimeriam4616]

I dont agree when you said hyunsuk kind of selfish of him when he tried to prevent midam leaving the group. He said that bcuz he and the team wanna go through this as 7 members. It seems like nothing to us but it is a special thing for them. Thats why when YG said they looked like real team, yedam cried. Then, are you more prefer that they just said nothing to midam and just let him leave. Midam not the only one who had a hard times. Most of them had their problems too but they keep going for their dream. Actually the one who pissed me off is midam. He said in this YGTB he hate going through this thing again n again right? But at the end he still join the other survival show ( produce 101). Then what happen with his remarked, at the end he just ran away from it.

[@shamiii8362]

Tho I agree with most of your comments but I hope you won’t blame midam also. He was in a mental state wherein it was not bearable already in a way that it will do more harm to him considering that he was not even certain if this is really what he wants in his life (age is a factor also). I think the produce 101 was his last push to see if this dream of his is really worth fighting for or not. And sadly, it wasn’t :(

[@sitimeriam4616]

@@shamiii8362 yup, i know. I just kind of dissapointed that i cant watch him till the end in YGTB since i really2 love silverboys.

[@jinnxx2729]

@@sitimeriam4616 Midam did the right thing. I understand him totally and I felt bad for him. Boy had a hard time in YG, it's good he left that company.

[@namiyaa1116]

Hyunsuk is just trying to keep them together for best of team just because of he is not heartless he knows Midam and he didn’t want to go that way Midam gone from competition not trying and didn’t show others to his skill cause he knows that Midam has skill and think that he blown his chance not also group also for Midam I think that way and you will know him and his desire throughout your treasure box episodes he is so emotional and crybaby

[@cjvlonzo]

Yeah, Hyunsuk's intention was pure because we all know the struggle Treasure A went through the years they were trainees but the words came out were really not well thought off in my opinion (at least based on the translations that we read on the screen and maybe because of the emotions that were roaming the room that time). But I'm still glad he tried his best to say something on that emotional moment for them though, he's a great teammate and a leader, always has been.

[@calorl.5272]

Yeah, i actually think its because he wants all of Treasure A to debut..

[@crmrm4135]

Also, it seemed to me that his comment of "I wish you would have hanged till the last assessment" I didn't take it as Hyunsuk asking him to put up until the last assessment for the sake of the group, but rather it seemed like Hyunsuk was so disappointed because it was their last chance to all perform together as Treasure A and he was sad their last performance wouldn't be the 7 of them together since it was very special and their last opportunity. I never saw it as selfish or being unkind or insensitive towards Midam's feelings.

[@calorl.5272]

@@crmrm4135 yeah i think thats right, he only said last assesment together..

[@russelsiasonofficial593]

@@crmrm4135 yeah I agree. Treasure A is always 7 for him. He love his teammates so much I think he really didn't meant it that way. Sometimes Wrong Words will come out to your mouth because your emotional that time and it'll make others misinterpret what you mean. Tho you can see what I mean when you finish reacting to ygtb 🤗

[@VidEodRiVe101]

It was selfish of Midam to leave for a whole day without notice A DAY before the assessment. It’s like abandoning ur 9-5 job’s big day without telling ur manager. Treasure A couldn’t practice the choreo properly as a result. So Midam basically put the other members’ future AT RISK and just thought of himself and how he felt. Also, it was a good decision to change Treasure B’s leader bcoz they were LITERALLY running out of time considering they were the most inexperienced group. They couldn’t afford to waste any more of their time translating almost everything to Jyuhao. And it would have been selfish of Jyuhao if he had not agreed to let Jihoon take over. Jyuhao would have also put the other members’ future at risk! See? This is Korea. Koreans take other people into account, unlike western artists who are more of an individualist type. Besides, this was a YG show and not some mnet show where they baby the trainees 🙂

[@VidEodRiVe101]

Well imagine this.. you and ur classmates were assigned a group project presentation that u have to present in front of the class. This presentation is important bcoz it would determine ur final grade and determine whether or not u’d graduate. U had been preparing for this presentation for a month. But a day before the presentation, one of ur groupmates decided to quit and just gone without telling u and the group members. How would u feel? 👁👄👁

[@VidEodRiVe101]

I have nothing against Midam and his mental instability. This was a survival show after all..just like how life is a survival of the fittest. He unfortunately was just not fit enough to stay. The main concern here is the term “selfish” used in this video. In my opinion, what Midam did was an act of selfishness bcoz he had to put his SELF first and his emotion before the group A DAY before the Energetic performance, hence the term SELFish. But what hyusuk said to him was NOT an act of selfishness. The treasure makers and i in this comment section are just trying to shed light on being more careful with choice of words next time, especially if u say it on a reaction video since Treasure members watch yt and reaction!videos a lot and hyunsuk might come across this video. But again, everyone is entitled to their opinion and this is their yt channel after all. So we basically have to just agree to disagree.

[@VidEodRiVe101]

How would Midam staying benefit hyusuk? Lol u’re not getting it. Midam leaving the show actually benefited hyunsuk more coz it meant fewer number of trainees to compete. There were 29 trainees there and YG announced initially that they would debut 5 members only. If hyunsuk was selfish, then he would have felt glad about Midam leaving. But he was not. It’s bcoz Hyunsuk was not thinking about himself only, he was thinking about the group. Therefore, he was not selfish and he isn’t! And u don’t have to agree with me. Merry christmas!!!

[@VidEodRiVe101]

Lol

[@zaire3131]

@@응응-p8m it's not like he's an outcast. It's been portrayed like he was outcasted. You dont know what's happening behind this editing.

[@peaceminusbd]

I don't think hyunsuk meant it that way. Team/Treasure A were trainees there for so long and they put them in that team making them believe they would be the next people to debut. Watching hyunsuk from his first survival show (MIXNINE) and on his 2nd survival show (YGTB) probably just made him feel more pressured. He wasn't yg's favorite, he would always get ignored and criticized. I wish you wouldn't think that way about him during that time because it's been really hard for him and for their team too. Most of the original team A members and the people who trained the same time as them...he saw them leaving and giving up way before this happened. It was the hardest to accept and endure. YGTB was the cruelest survival show i've ever watched as a hyunsuk stan. You'll understand that more on upcoming episodes. It was so harsh and heartbreaking. He may have said the things you didn't expect on this episode, but to be honest nothing was easy on their team during that time because all of them think it's their last chance. They put them in one team and then made them believe that they have the highest chance to debut but in the end, it goes back to zero when ygtb happened. No one really expect the survival show. And Hyunsuk really values their team so much that's why it was so hard for him/them to bid farewell knowing that it's their last chance to perform as a group (complete members) because they have to separate after this performance. I hope you understand that somehow...he wasn't trying to be selfish nor think that he will comeback after saying that. But he wish to see them perform as one before they separate with each other. You can see after the performance they all cried and at the same time happy they got the compliment as a team. That's how important this performance for Team A. Hyunsuk is always so selfless and even though yg pushed him away many times, he dont give up and even help all of the people around him. :) And Team A has a really really good relationship with each other. They are more than what this survival show are portraying them. Imagine, your debut was cancelled during your first survival show and then on the next survival show, it's obvious that yg himself pushed him away many times and ignored all his effort to be in the debut team. It was the hardest time for Hyunsuk but he would always help lift his members up when they're struggling. And on the last ep, he was mad and embarassed at himself for ranking too low despite being a team known as ACES and the closest to debut team. And they didn't make fun of Junkyu last episode too, they were just simply cheering him up because he was so down. The editing made it look awkward, but they were each other's strength all these years that's why they managed to stay as a team for so long. I hope you'll understand.

[@ardeegallega3121]

true

[@ardeegallega3121]

up

[@emjaysais]

💯💯💯💯

[@aly3439]

i hope they read this, i was also gonna comment about what hyunsuk said so thank u for explaining it. I hope they research about their past too so they understand what really is happening

[@farisfiqran3739]

yeahh trueee

[@akiharu8324]

This reaction video is a proof that we do really have different understanding about a particular issue or something. Hyunsuk doesn't want to be selfish, just for his own good, he just wants all TREASURE A to debut, that is why, he is encouraging Midam to hold and fight especially in their last assessment as a team. He is not selfish I'm telling you, I'm hurt OMG 💔 and for the ranking issue, of course if you have the longest trainee years, you're supposed to be good! That is why he is annoyed. Not to other members or other trainee, but for himself! He is annoyed for himself, for not being able to top. Its just that, Hyunsuk is the purest, if you just know ❤️💎

[@DPD04]

I think it might also come from the fact that we know me about the trainees such as how close they are and how well they trained

[@brigittamicella9095]

ITS TRUE.. I am sad now 😭😭😭

[@thegodsofgalaxy2109]

Well Mashiho is trained longer than any members of Team A, but The one that should be blame is the producer, they tend to make the show based on Team A perspective. If they dont do that, there will be no trainees to be blamed for

[@asdfghjklb7484]

@@thegodsofgalaxy2109 Yedam is in team A and he trained longer than Mashi, that's all just to correct on that note.

[@pncvsx9888]

I definitely agree!

[@hinataaahyuga451]

What Hyunsuk meant was totally different from what you understood.Treasure A had practiced together for years and it was their last performance.Every trainee is frustrated and mentally drained and think of Hyunsuk whose debut was cancelled,nobody gave up.I understand Midam and respect his choice but I still think he should have stayed for that one final performance.I would have reacted the same way if my close friend had done that.Also that last comment about Hyunsuk being selfish was seriously disappointing since he's one of the least selfish members along with Yedam :( the translations are sometimes different from the emotions with which they convey.

[@atikaindrianiputri7427]

ikrrr. hyunsuk and yedam are 2 of the least selfish members

[@kath8983]

Yeahh I actually hated the editors back then because Hyunsuk was misunderstood a lot. A LOT. What he have been through in MIXNINE was already too much. And i think hyunsuk deserves better on YGTB

[@_RL.]

@Life Goes On... this is my biggest problem with non Asian and non Korean reactors because language and translations are completely wrong a lot of times and also understanding Asian culture and society. I understood Midam's POV (at the time) and also the other team members too. It was a bad situation for everyone on that Team including the managers who are responsible for this trainee. Now, I see that Midam ended up another label and joined another battle reality show the year after and that pisses me off. (but that's my opinion)

[@yamix9291]

Yes exactly!

[@mysterioussky8500]

Hey! You said that hyunsuk's debut was cancelled . can u tell me what happened I am a new teume so I don't know much😊

[@aly3439]

the part with jyun hao, I know it looks bad and they should've not changed the leaders but at that time survival mode is on, all their future is on the line and they have so little time to practice. also the fact that most of them are new trainees so they need more practice than the other team so I think that decision was good for all of them honestly.

[@ashashborn7307]

Correct! They need to so it especially Jyun Hao had a little knowledge of Korean words so it'll be difficult for each member to understand his instructions.

[@user-kl5jm2yz8j]

Jihoon handled the situaton really well,he did not acted out of selfishness,he tried to help the team.Because,at the end,what matters is being chosen by YG,in which he barely was.I never misunderstood Hyunsuk and Jihoon actions,since because I first discover them through this show,I know their struggle and hardwork,turning them into great and supporting leaders for TREASURE

[@yellowlee6200]

Agree!!!! They just find it horrible because they only think about the feelings of jyun hao after all it is only for the betterment of the group

[@yndb11]

Agreee

[@xoxojessiexoxotix]

Agree in the syrvival show it was tume fir them to get technical abd stop being personal. Abd to think of the team first. . the time they waste on communicating should be wasted on practicing more and more as it was done and they found jihoon a great leader and the performence was carried by him he choreographed that dznce brrak and led the team.in a short period that was the best decision

[@jea284]

i just know that hyunsuk and treasure A has gone through so much even before this show that’s why hyunsuk puts lots of pressure in himself cause he has always been criticized and ignored by yg eversince mixnine and i know that he wants to debut so bad. i don’t think selfish or heartless is the right word to use but i get your pointtt but yeahhh ygtb has been really cruel for hyunsuk and you’ll see why in the future episodesss! i hope you guys don’t misunderstand their feelings and words

[@ardeegallega3121]

they said like that cpz they never saw mixnine. they should not jump to coclusions. they don't understand hyunsuk. her comment about hyunsuk triggered me actually ...

[@jea284]

@@ardeegallega3121 yeahh sameee i love their reactions but i got triggered in this one too but let’s just not make it a big deal and let’s hope that they will learn lots of things from hyunsuk and treasure a through our comments and not jump into conclusions next time:)

[@aiseil4531]

I’m that kind of person who started YGTB last month and still keeps rewatching every ep every single day. Treasure Effect

[@homah7784]

omg same

[@Demiee1093]

On the previous episode. Hyunsuk is pissed and embarrassed because he expected too much from team A since they're the longest running trainees and they did not get a compliment from YG. YG intentionally calling him on the spot to let him watch the youngest trainee basically dissed him. It's more of they're frustrated on themselves to be beaten by the younger trainees than literally being mad at the little ones for beating them. you know pride thingy. And in this episode losing a team member, and trying to let him stay not just because its the last moment they will be treasure A, but I see it as he believes in Midam that he still can make it. It's more of encouragement, as he said "I wish you would've hang in there" maybe he thought that if they'll get a better compliment it will boost Midam's will to stay and be better. It's just a roller coaster of emotion that led him to act like that. And not everything that they're saying is filmed, it's still more to them than what we see :)) anyway thanks for this guys :)

[@prettysavage557]

I dont want to judge anyone by watching some 2/3 minutes moments in a survival show. They were together as a team for 3/4 years. So they know each other and the situation better. Hyunsuk was 5th in Mix Nine but the debut was cancelled. Midam was there for 3 years, so he wished Midam could hang in there for another month like he did and debut with them together. Hyunsuk is not my bias or anything but I dont think he was selfish.

[@alyssa9795]

After reading the comments, I hope ams and ev don't misunderstand the treasure makers and think that we're ganging up on them or something cuz we're not. I hope ams & ev know that we appreciate them, we're grateful and adore them so much and we just don't want them to misunderstand the boys especially that they are new teumes and they are getting to know them little by little so they don't know their past fully yet.

[@abby_marquez]

Yes !

[@Hyunsukfan99]

YGTB IS so brutal for hyunsuk but look at him now his one of the best member a leader and a all round idol i love hyunsuk being patient thanks hyunsuk for staying

[@hinataaahyuga451]

Let me also clarify Hyunsuk's comment in the previous episode.He meant that though they were Treasure A they couldn't make it into the top.He himself said that he was disappointed in himself,it was never meant in an arrogant way.I'm not being a blind fan or anything,but as a Hyunsuk stan I thought you'd know about his personality.He is one of the purest idols I've seen(coming from a multistan) and he's so supportive of others.

[@kath8983]

And I also think the translation mattered. Because the way he said it in korean, as what i understood in his worda, he didn't mean it that way. And the evil editings

[@aly3439]

yesss!!! and also the fact that a lot of trainees admire hyunsuk so much and said that hyunsuk helped them the most SPEAKS VOLUME, they wouldn't say that if he really was selfish or heartless. This type of leadership isn't really new if you stan yga, just like hanbin and gd they are v serious and honest when it comes to work because they believe in their members and they want them to do good not because they hate them hahsaha

[@kath8983]

@@aly3439 Yes. You will know his side and personality in YGTB side contents like survey cam, reaction cam, diary cam. And you will notice how much the trainees respect and like him

[@choiruto1594]

So many people already clarified about hyunsuk thank god. I'm a hyunsuk stan and yeah kinda disappointing when you say him selfish when he's the most selfless one ☹️issokay I forgive u guys but it takes time also 🙏😂 but I'm now talking and clarifying about treasure B that change the leader. For me, it's a good decision and seokhwa doesn't actually mean to be rude to gunho. How could they make a good performance when it's so hardddd to even communicate with the leader? A leader is so important to make a good performance and being a leader you must consider the others too not only yourself. Gunho choosing hard songs for them when treasure B is obviously the most less trained one out of all the team. And you can see how clueless they are while training and the trainer also said they don't even deserve an F for the performance. So changing the leader is the last thing they could do to improve and jihoon actually **this one is a spoiler** the most experienced despite being in treasure B. Later you will know why. And you can see how the performance is actually not that bad. So, they're doing it for their own goods. Last but not least sukhoon best leaders 🙌

[@antdee7743]

Well said, very well said 👍

[@ardeegallega3121]

I was really actually disappointed when she said that to hyunsuk. she already saw tmap so she should know how sefless hyunsuk since mixnine. HYUNSUK BEST BOY!! they misunderstood my baby :(((((

[@yndb11]

Agree

[@jinnxx2729]

I not disappointed at all. I agree with them. Please realise that everyone has different perspectives, but that also doesn't mean the reactor is hating on hyunsuk.

[@andreaabrigo149]

@@jinnxx2729 but still.. if ur a real teume you should know that hyunsuk is not a selfish person, he’s just trying his best to help them. It’s not fair at all

[@jihyunkang1647]

Haha, that's not what Choi Hyun-suk meant by Korean sentiment. It doesn't matter whether you become a debut member or not. It was the last mission with 7 members under the name of Treasure A team, so I think it's more regrettable that we couldn't show the performances of 7 members in the team. In the last episode, Do-young's greeting for Jun-gyu is also seen as an effort by the team members to make Jun-kyu laugh with Korean sentiment. I couldn't speak English, so I looked at the comments with a translator and saw that it was interpreted differently from what Koreans think, so I got help from the translator with the hope that there would be no misunderstanding. I hope you understand what I'm trying to convey. Your casual comments always make me feel good.

[@LS-qc8hw]

THE MORE PEOPLE MISUNDERSTAND HYUNSUK, THE MORE MY LOVE FOR HIM GROWS. MY BOY DOES NOT DESERVE ALL THOSE WORDS YOU CARELESSLY THREW AT HIM BUT IF THAT’S HOW YOU FEEL THEN GO AHEAD COZ MY BOY WILL PROVE YOU ALL WRONG. I LOVE YOU HYUNSUK! CAN YOU SEE HOW MANY PEOPLE LOVE YOU? YOU DESERVE NOTHING BUT ALL THESE LOVE.

[@treasure9125]

I'm not hating on what you said about Hyunsuk. But I suggest you do some research about him. Treasure A or Silver boys are the longest trainees (6 years-2years) they grow up together as a team, and the way you all said that Treasure A doesn't value Midam that much is so very wrong, you may think that Hyunsuk is so selfish to say that kind word, but the truth is he just only wants them to debut together. Treasure A expect their going to debut soon, but YGTB happened. They wish to debut together as a TREASURE A, but Midam wasn't able to take it anymore (which I understand why he did that), so just imagine how frustrated Hyunsuk and the others members, because their wish to debut together as team will never happen. We don't any rights to say a word "selfish" when we're not on their position, because in the end of the day only god knows how they suffered just to be the TREASURE they are right now.

[@allrounderchoihyunsuk581]

I kinda sad when they said Hyunuk is selfish... 😢 Our Hyunsukie have gone through a lot since mixnine... 💔

[@zaine3515]

Yeah! Lets just understand her because she misunderstand hyunsuk without understanding the situation 🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂 lets understand her way of thinking

[@haleyhutchinson8302]

About Hyunsuk he didn’t mean it that way. He knows it wasn’t Midam fault. They had been a team for 2-4 years and it’s hard watching your friend leave. That was the last time all of Treasure A performed together. With the previous episode. It’s so much pressure of Treasure A from YG. YG expects Treasure A to be the best...to be...#1, since they were the longest running trainees. It was a lot of pressure on him. YG comments about how he should be embarrassed didn’t help. If anything it’s more YG fault that Hyunsuk feels that way. He spent 3-4 years as a trainee to get embarrassed by someone who is 7 years younger than him. Like, I said before YG comments about how if he was Hyunsuk he would be embarrassed didn’t help.

[@crmrm4135]

I also feel like the editing in the show didn't help much, they purposely edited in order to make it seem like trainees were constantly battling and competing against each other, when we know that was not the case. Especially Hyunsuk who does nothing but support, encourage, and even protect the other trainees especially the younger ones.

[@crmrm4135]

@Black Treasure I agree, I think that despite some efforts to make it seem more of a competition and dramatic between the trainees, you can see that it was far from the truth and they all truly just supported and cared for one another.

[@mein2398]

I don't think Hyunsuk is being selfish, he just hopes that Treasure A who has been together for years can debut together. and remembering that hyunsuk has been on 2 survival shows, where he previously participated in the 'mixnine' and had managed to be in the debut line-up and finally the debut failed🤧

[@jessfray8747]

The thing with Hyunsuk is that he tries his hardest to be strong when there are difficult circumstances like this one. It may appear like he is cold hearted or that he has a "bad attitude" it really is because of the many things he had gone with Midam. Midam is literally a brother to Hyunsuk they trained together through a hard time. Many people might not know about silver boys which originally consisted of trainees Midam, Woong, Noah, Raesung,Byounggon, Seunghun, Hyunsuk,Jihoon, Junkyu, Yedam and Doyoung, these boys literally went through a lot together. Hyunsuk reacted that what because he did not want to portray his weakness and sadness of not seeing Midam accomplishing his dream with him. I know it may appear like he is showing attitude but it is how YG trains his idols ever since they are trainees to have this tough look no matter the situation, because in the outside world you will deal with a lot worse. YG focuses on making their idols built up character like this, honestly it is portrayed harsh because in a situation like that we expect to see someone weak. Eve YG himself he always appears to look bad and tough with the trainees saying such comments to them because he knows those comments will impact and help the, for the better. Furthermore in the show you will see how slowly Hyunsuk can't handle being strong and shows himself as how he is. Hopefully this is helpful for you to understand because we understand what you mean but that is not how it is. Anyhow, love watching your reactions every week and thank you for reacting!

[@samantharahman6706]

Oh my god, yess! I wanted to say the same thing. In 2018, even I badly wanted silver boys to debut. And I thought that YGTB was very cruel and unfair to these boys who were already on the verge of debuting (since, YG himself made fans and these silver boys feel this way). And that’s why Mi dam said that this is too much for him to endure after all these years of training now a survival show.

[@afiqahsabali487]

here’s my opinion 1. Hyunsuk wasnt being selfish. the words he said in the past eps “we dont deserves below there” wasnt for the other teams. it more to their hardwork. they trained the longest yet they still ranked below of the new trainees. and it makes Hyunsuk mad. byunggon also said “i dont like this” when they saw their ranking. it was for themselves. that’s when it hits them that they still lacking despites being trained over 4 years+ therefore,hyunsuk said “im embarrassed” when he lost to junhyuk. also,he didnt mad at Junhyuk. but more to YG bcs YG setting them both to battle like that. if it was me,i would get mad too😂 in upcoming eps,Hyunsuk & Junhyuk become brothers. the sweetest thing you’ll ever watch during ygtb. 2. Team B changing the leader. team B had struggle with language barrier. i also felt bad for guno,but we had to think about the time they had wasted just to communicate with each other. their practice with the dance teacher showed that their teamwork wasnt good. the dance looks messy. unlike Team J,they had to changed their song. but they made it bcs they’re all Japanese it bcs they can communicate well. after they changed to Jihoon,they give guno the dance part too. Guno shine the most in Go Go performance. so it’s a win-win. 3. In YG,there’s a rule. it was shown in eps1. once they break the rule,they have to leave. Hyunsuk wasnt being selfish for trying to hold midam into the group. he just doesnt want his teamA members go through hard times. Midam is not very social person,he have the same personality with Junkyu. but Midam are mentally exhausted that he decide to “run away” that night. that put teamA into trouble as well,it would affect the whole group. since,it was near their monthly evaluation. Hyunsuk was being honest and he wish Midam could stay a little more bcs that was their last TeamA performance. there’s one video on vlive channel that TeamA cheered for Midam and asking fans to support midam. TeamA are still close until now. they’re family but in different agency. 4. i hope you watch others YGTB segments like -YGTB diary cam(every trainees updating how their practice goes) -YGTB reaction cam(all ygtb trainees sit down and watch ygtb together) -YGTB survey cam(ygtb trainees votes each other) -YGTB game cam(ygtb trainees play some games) -YGTB christmas party(ygtb gather and prepared for christmas party) -YGTB social gathering(ygtb trainees played game called manito and prepared gifts for each other) -YGTB chuseok special(ygtb trainees gather to celebrate chuseok with some games) all these segments from YGTB is gold. it shows how closed they are despite they had to against each other. i would burst into tears whenever i watch all YGTB contents bcs it’s too precious. their friendship are th sweetest!! i hope you both are okay. dont get hurt by all these comments. we’re just trying to correct the whole things for you guys. and i know you loveee hyunsuk now😜😜 cant wait for the next reactions!!! 💗💗

[@maladieme1690]

Yess, another YGTB segments are really fun to watch. They should try to check them out too

[@kimcondedolllisa2154]

Yes YGTB as in the competition itself is intense and they are all in a competitive mode, while the other YGTB segments are fun and it shows how really close they are. Also I love Ammy and Evs that they speak their mind I love that from them.

[@ashashborn7307]

All of the members in Team J had been debuted and Keita will be the last one to debut in a boygroup CIIPHER. I'm like a proud mom...

[@tanyakrotowa]

Same

[@aly3439]

okay idk if it's just me but I don't think you guys understood what hyunsuk meant because when he said "This is A team's last assessment with the seven of us together. In a way this is really our last", this is because after their last assessment they're not gonna be able to perform as a team anymore because survival will start and they will all be separated and they are sad because their dream of debuting together as a team is now impossible and now that midam decided to go it's confirmed that it is really their last :( oh I wish we get more silver boys interaction in the future bc they r all so precious.

[@aly3439]

bruh when they said "we can meet at the end, good job" I fucking cried again :( silver boys the group that we almost had :(

[@Booguhnbelle]

Don't worry. Our TREASURE's mom Hyunsuk isn't selfish, you guys just misunderstood his words.

[@brigittamicella9095]

SO TRUE. Maybe also because of the translation, the sound effect and how they film the show. I am so sad they thinks this way 😭😭😭

[@annerey332]

I kinda agree with these people defending Hyungsuk here. I don’t have a bias in treasure because I love them all and I’ve known some of them from their pre-debut days especially silver boys. Silver boys are the popular trainees before in yg which the fans thought they’re gonna debut all but unfortunately some of them left and only 6 members stay, 5 became members of treasure and 1 became a producer in yg now(Raesung).on my opinion on how I discern to what happened in ep1 and 2, I think Hyungsuk is just desperate. I actually understand his action that time. And in fact I think he’s not selfish because being selfish is totally disregarding other people’s existence for his own good but Hyungsuk is still thoughtful to other members. He has this competitive side which is natural because they are in a competition and they are always in a competition ever since they’ve entered yg. And we can’t disregard to what happened in mixnine. He’s been trough a lot that’s why he is so competitive. He is so anxious to what’s happening that time which he only wanted was to debut together with his longtime friends.

[@lingling7667]

I'm quite surprised the word 'selfish' was used on Hyunsuk >< from Mixnine till now, he always put others before himself and we can clearly see it especially in Mixnine. His debut journey was not as easy as we only see in Treasure box if anyone want to know more about him, I'll suggest you to watch Mixnine before Treasure Box instead.His reaction towards Midam was only because he really hope all members from Team A will debut together but Midam was giving up this hope when their dreams are so near and Hyunsuk was disappointed that now they can't fufill this dream together. I hope this reaction will not cause any misunderstanding to those who are new to Treasure especially towards Hyunsuk.

[@artsy_ivy]

I understand how you feel about Hyunsuk's when Midam is leaving. But I think what Hyunsuk is trying to convey to Midam when he said "you could have hang in there" . is the same as saying that "dont give up" like Midam is now doubting if he will be able to debut or not but if he could hang in there and give his best for the last performance, who knows, he might be able to make it. Because actually Hyunsuk feels the same way too. He is also doubting if he will be able to debut or not. And it feels like pointless for him to do this after what happened to MixNine (survival show) where he is about to debut but it was canceled and then he is now in another survival show, YGTB, so it feels to him like he will start all over again. If there is any person who can understand Midam at that time, its definitely Hyunsuk. and he just want Midam to give his best even for the last time, because who knows after that performance Midam will make it. The point there is "its not over until its over". But i guess, because Hyunsuk is so straightforward, so it sounds like he dont have compassion towards Midam. But i know , he means it that Midam should not give up and stay positive and put his trust on them as teammates and not keep it all to himself. They have been together for so long that each one of them should be open to each other. Anyway, looking forward for the next episode. :))

[@kimcondedolllisa2154]

If Hyunsuk was selfish he would have let Midam go without feeling upset or disappointed, thinking there was less trainee to compete with the debuting lineup. After all, it was a survival show and an individual competition they have to battle against each other. He said that and feels that way not because He wants to win for himself, No but because He wants it for Midam. He just wants Midam to grab that last chance to hopefully debut, for Midam himself, and also He wants it for their team not for him. He's not just thinking about himself It's for his team and Midam's sake, It's painful for him to let Him leave because it's their dream to debut they already did practice the performance together but sadly Midam decided to quit. Also after Midam left YGTB he joined Produce 101.

[@jinnxx2729]

Uhmm it was not easy for Midam, please. If he didn't want to continue in YG as a trianee than it is his wish. He was obviously having a hard time in that company so he wanted to quit.

[@andreaabrigo149]

@@jinnxx2729 But hyunsuk is trying so hard to help his members succeed. I know it’s not midam’s fault but I’m sure he could do better than that

[@nurauliyar2490]

ygtb mashiho's hair was THE BEST I LOVE HIS CURLY HAIR WE NEED CURLY MASHI BACKKKK

[@amaanpatel7434]

I think HYUNSUK was not being selfish..... Its just that he wanted whole TREASURE A to debut..

[@kai-vj1vq]

yes 🙁

[@amaanpatel7434]

@@kai-vj1vq yeah he wanted midam to debut too that's why he was quite annoyed by the fact that he leaved.... Plzzz don't hate on him...

[@kimcondedolllisa2154]

Ok, I totally understand both of your opinion and point. Just remember that All trainees are struggling in their own way they all gone through so much especially treasure A cause they all have been in YG the longest plus they already faced 2 survival shows, Him and Midam are part of the original silver boys. He has that bond with them I think Hyunsuk is just sad, and disappointed about him leaving and not taking that last chance to debut cause HE knows Midam got those skills, and he wants all treasure A to debut. I think he just wants them (Treasure A) to all debut and sadly it will be their last team performance for them as team A, He cares about his teammates thus you can see Hyun-suk crying when Midam was leaving. I also understand and respect Midam's decision, the boys faced 2 survival shows already they have been through so much since mixnine and after that, they all felt and believed they have the upper hand and have the chance to debut as a team but YG announced YGTB so it kinda put pressure on Midam and drained him. I understand both Midam and Hyunsuk's sides. Everything's okay though I understand all your point., and I love how genuine your reactions to these trainees. I love that you guys speak your mind appreciate that. Thank you!

[@shamiii8362]

Also, just a TMI, you may know already that Hyunsuk was in a survival show called Mixnine prior this, and really struggled a lot mentally/emotionally there to finally make the cut but his supposedly debut that time was cancelled so you can also not blame him for having this mindset of despair and determination. This fact made me respect him more.

[@hellosunshaine]

I kinda have to say this hehehe. Watching and rooting for them for how many years made me understand their personalities more. And I think you kinda misunderstood what Hyunsuk was trying to imply. They have been training for so long and are good friends. He knows how much Midam wanted to debut. It's their dream. Team A's (silverboys) dream was to debut together. I personally think what Suk was trying to imply is that. The chance of them debuting together was in front of them, they just have to work so hard to get into the debut line. He knows how much Midam struggled in training for years just to debut but because of that one incident it was all gone. Welp that's how Big Entertainments in Korea works. Team A dreamed of debuting together, they know each members' struggles, but Ygtb was really cruel for them. The show made their friendship stronger but also made gaps. Midam's Father said he (Midam) decided to leave because he can't compete with his friends, since they needed to go against each other whom they thought they're going to debut with. This is how mediaplay and editing works so I think that really triggered you ㅠㅠ. And the "Longest Trainee" part, what they said was, they were mad, upset and embarrassed. Looking at the situation they said that because of the fact that they where nowhere to be seen on the top. They have been training the longest in the company, Yg spends a Lot I mean "a Lot" of money for them for how many years. And at that time Team A should be more polished than the other teams, but the first rankings says the opposite. They were mad and upset at their "selves" because as the longest trainee they should and could've done better. And I think you also misunderstood that part hehe😅 P.s Midam went to AAP.Y Ent then joined Produce X 101 but sadly he didn't made it in the debut lineup. He has a song titled Hello Christmas with Jung Myong Hoon (you guys should listen to this). But then this November, Midam's Father said or announced that Midam already gave up on his dream being an idol :'(. Right now I just want happiness for ygtb babies and for them to achieve their dreams. Btw I have been watching you guys since your first reaction to Treasure and I'm happy because your channel is growing and I feel like I'm somewhat part of your journey haha. I love youuu, please be good to Treasure ♥️ P.s part 2 Ev you're so pretty ㅠㅠ Aand Ammyyy I really admire you for how brave and straightforward you are knowing that many fans are toxic, Love you both♥️

[@hellosunshaine]

Yooo, I didn't know i could type this long. I should bring this energy making my Essays hahaha😅

[@choibabe1021]

@@hellosunshaine you will probably get an A gurll💯 well saiddd

[@yshhk9952]

I agree. I was first a Mate before I become a Teume. I was hoping and was expecting Silverboys to debut together. And I know how sad for the boys where when Midam left because they lost another member😔 and I know there were no bad intentions with what Hyunsuk said. I'm happy for them now, Noa, Woong, Raesung and Midam and I hope they'll get the happiness they deserve.

[@Cleo-ej7zh]

I want that hyunsuk's pillow 😭😂

[@irenebae8833]

So manny looooong comment in this video 😂🤣

[@lullabye5240]

you guys are still at the third episode, and things were all just starting here. Soon you'll witness how hyunsuk been having a hard time, Treasure A's pressure, desperation and doubts to themselves being a Treasure A, as the leading team to debut and the oldest trainees, and Jihoon's story as YG trainee and why he unintentionally made an initiative to lead the group. Btw, Jyunhao, the original leader replaced by Jihoon, he is from Taiwan. That's why he's also having a hard time speaking korean. PLEASE TAKE THIS INTO CONSIDERATION: If you gonna say something u can pause for a while, coz in this episode I feel kinda frustrated whenever you guys are chatting while the video is playing. Some scenes were not given focus or were just ignored then u come back watching but u guys missed a lot infos. I noticed that in this episode, that maybe also one of the reasons why some scenes were misunderstood. It is okay for us if you'll pause for a while, no worries for getting a long video coz we love your reactions and we still gonna watch it. Also, we are not hating you girls. We just want u to see the other side that u missed to consider. But u know you are entitled to ur opinion so yeah hmm... its up to you. We are just watching here anyways. Still gonna watch the next episodes :))

[@brie6718]

I honestly think you misunderstood the whole hyunsuk situation :( Hyunsuk is easily the least selfish person in treasure and that showed especially in yg treasure box with how he treated the trainees especially the younger ones. He just always had this leader personality and he knew the potential of each member in treasure A. They were a family and they were really close to one another. Him being frustrated with the past episodes also comes from the pain of almost debuting in mixnine despite being one of the show’s maknaes yet having to get that debut cancel and join another survival show with no assurance of even debuting (which also got pushed back 2 years). Hyunsuk did a lot to be noticed and get in yg so this really meant a lot to him. Anyway, i know you just misunderstood it especially with how it was edited and showed in the show but trust me you’ll love hyunsuk even more because of ygtb, here you’ll see what a true all-rounder our leader hyunsuk is 🤍

[@brie6718]

Can’t wait for the next reaction 🤗

[@mikaelaflores7821]

Wait what time did she say selfish

[@ardeegallega3121]

HYUNSUK IS REALLY SELFLESS. I was disaapointed by her comment off

[@brie6718]

@@mikaelaflores7821 at around 51:30 something i think? When midam was telling the group he had to leave and at the end they were talking about his attitude too which was when i really got hurt for hyunsuk especially with everything he’s been through 😔Maybe they just misunderstood the whole situation tho :( i think they thought that they weren’t close with one another and they didn’t put in effort to talk to him (which we all know that’s not true) but she did say she loves hyunsuk and it was just at that particular moment ☺️

[@atikaindrianiputri7427]

watch the new few episodes you guys will see how selfless hyunsuk is. he's sooo caring to all trainees, especially treasure A cz they're being together for years and become like bestfriend, brothers, family. that's why in weekly idol hyunsuk love doyoung so much as his fav maknae, cz treasure A has a loonggg time together

[@blackpinkbtstreasure]

The way I perceive it, Hyunsuk wasn't selfish. The other guy is going through something and they all have. He was just being positive and reminiscing the time and the years they've been through to be in that position and quitting is never an option coz at the very first place he wanted that. He wanted his dreams to come true. At least there was someone who encourages him not to give up.

[@spring9772]

I am just surprised by Amy's reaction to Hyunsuk. I would recommend Amy to watch the reaction cam and diary cam of Hyunsuk (on YG treasure box channel) or watch the fanmade "Everything wrong with YG Treasure box, Choi Hyunsuk's Journey" (highly recommend) in your free time. You will see a part of him you won't really see in these episodes. C'mon Amy. If you really love him, please see. He's been through so many things and we know even he's in difficult time, he is the one who still help other people and cry for them thinking it's all his fault.

[@allrounderchoihyunsuk581]

Choi Hyun Suk that I know is the most SELFLESS person in the group ❤️ He always take care about other trainee. That boy has no evil bone in his body 😢💙

[@alwaysspectator4518]

You have been warned, this gives you emotions you dont think you can feel. And those feelings will only make sense through out the show. This shows how it is very difficult to be an idol trainee, let alone a foreigner and intoverted trainee only to be bashed and hated after they debut. Btw thank you for the video as always😍

[@jennyvieaora7338]

Hyunsuk wants to portray a strong image but in reality he is such a vulnerable guy and I understands him- you will see in the upcoming episodes what I meant. Hyunsuk is one of the selfless guy that I knew tho he wants his members to shine most more than him. I don't wanna spoil anything but Hyunsuk had it hard during YGTB- the reason I've become a hardcore Hyunsuk bias. I love them all but Hyunsuk just have a special place in my heart. 💜🤍💎 Edit: I've been following Hyunsuk since mixnine so I'm kinda protective of him. What are you gonna do when you're supposed to debut but at the last minute got cancelled and then here it comes, another survival show just to debut. That's why Hyunsuk has this mentality to never give up, just hang in there and everything will come to it's fruition. I saw him breakdown many times and it hurts me when you tagged him as "selfish&heartless" I know he isn't. Peace, love. Newaysss, looking forward to your reaction in the upcoming episodes.

[@JenNy-fw9sb]

To Ams and Ev we appreciate and love your support and reaction to treasure I hope you will not change towards treasure if you read all the comments. Love lots.

[@klare4948]

I hope you won't misunderstand Hyunsuk, in my perspective that's not what he meant. That performance was their last as Team A, and they've been together for years. Hyunsuk just wanted him to stay for a little longer, to hang in there for the last time, since it was really their last chance as a group. He's not selfish, he really love the trainees I swear, you will see that in the next episodes. As for changing the leader, they only have one month to prepare for their live performance. They have to choreograph the song, change some parts, and write their own lyrics (raps). Yes it may seem a bitch move, but they had to do it for their own sake. Time is of the essence, and changing the leader is the best decision especially if they can't communicate properly, which is very cruical when it comes to group performance. Anyway I still love your reaction. Please don't feel bad with our comments. We just don't want you to misunderstand the boys, especially Hyunsuk since he's your bias :) He's kind, I promise. In the next episodes your heart will definitely cry for him.

[@alice01lee46]

As a Korean treasure maker, I didn't think that Hyunsuk's attitude was selfish from the scene. Koreans tend to be more proud of being recognized by their team members. I thought that Hyunsuk wanted to say it to Midam. That's why the editor of YGTB showed Hyunsuk's comment without editting. It is just misunderstanding from the culture difference. Don't hate Hyunsuk plz.

[@xcyllynvergara5588]

Thank you for reacting today! What you felt watching this episode was the roller coaster of emotions we went through. This YGTB is the show that definitely defined the 12 members. Not to spoil anything but this is why Teumes are really loyal to these boys and protective because YGTB made them who they are right now. TMAP was more of the final touch, sticking them with glue and bond them as 1 group. I know how frustrating it may have been to see Hyunsuk around this time and even for the rest of the 12 members of which you'll eventually see too in the coming 7 episodes, BUT this is the real deal. This is how survival shows should be. No sugar coating or dramas just to gain popularity. This is how real it gets with YG.

[@bluefish3135]

Midam is actually still friend with the og team A and they've been friends for so long, including Hyunsuk, like I think even after the program ended people saw them together so it's pretty weird why he said he didn't socialize with them, so maybe that's why they couldn't understand him, tbh what was too much for Midam was the fact that there were cameras, everything was being recorded, having to win a survival, all that pressure, the yg treasure box was too much for him

[@jo22k]

Also it sucks but i think the change in leadership was necessary. Team B was a team of all really new boys to this, with very little training and needed that much more guidance. They are all there presented with an opportunity and in a very serious competition with trainees with more experience and with their actual futures in the balance. They can’t afford to keep the other boy as the leader just to be nice, when they have so much to work out under a time crunch. They all there understood that even if it feels a bit bad anyway.

[@SH_0507]

Ikr.. Cause Leader must capable to guide their team. But if communication makes its harder for them to train as a group then its necessary to switch the leader. For sake of the group🙂

[@nvlia1115]

i think you misunderstood hyunsuk. Technically it is going to be their last performance as Team A coz after that episode they are no longer a team. they will compete individually that why its very important to Team A. To think that this is the only episode I saw Junkyu cried says a lot. The seven of them trained together for years.

[@nadya0802]

It’s just kinda disappointing how you judged Hyunsuk by watching a few-minute clips here. I hope let’s be careful with the choice of words we say. Judging him as “selfish” is a very strong statement without knowing their background especially their team being together for years. You have to understand where he’s coming from. It’s not how you interpreted it to be.

[@danicakim9899]

I just want to say that Hyunsuk and Yedam is one of the selfless members.

[@bbsofie7224]

Why do I feel like they misunderstood it? Or the other way around? Bcs I dont know any background abt them when I first watched it and I dont see Hyunsuk that way. My first language is not english but Hyunsuk's words didn't come out to be selfish to me.

[@brigittamicella9095]

Same with me. This is the 4th times I seen this episode and I still think that Hyunsuk is one of the selfless guys among all of the trainees. Hope they could understand him more in the next episode.

[@bbsofie7224]

@@brigittamicella9095 youre right. I still love these girls. Maybe they just misunderstand it .

[@naddianesanna1055]

About the changing leader, its understandable. its just like u have to choose 2 destination. if they keep on with communication problem, they can’t deliver their performance. they trust Jihoon because Jihoon is the longest trainee between them. remember that Jihoon leave YG? he used to train with Team A. when he cb again he join Team B. at least Jihoon can guide them since he have experience monthly evaluation more than other members. Jihoon & Hyunsuk best leaders. this show really polished their leadership.

[@kinahylt9241]

Ngl, I'm lowkey afraid that you might misunderstood hyunsuk in the next episodes.

[@hc8637]

I have to agree, they already misunderstood his words and they got annoyed w/o understanding his point of view. If they won’t listen and try to understand all the explainations on the comments and insisted on their judgement towards him for sure they will still misjudge hyunsuk’s decisions on the next episodes. My heart aches for him.

[@nafisiim2328]

This is the reason why i'm so proud to be hyunsuk stan since MIXNINE. Hyunsuk you doing your best, my strongest boy hyunsuk pls just keep positive vibes in this bad world. Btw i enjoy watching this too 😊

[@jea284]

i hope you guys look through their povs too! they’ve been together for so much years and then suddenly one of them will leave. hyunsuk probably meant that midam should atleast perform with them for the last time cause they have been a team for so long and it might be their last performance together. i’m sure hyunsuk knows what midam feels and he didn’t say that for him to feel worse. i also don’t think that it’s treasure a’s fault that midam felt that way and that they were also disappointed that midam kept it to himself instead of sharing his problems to them. i’m kinda sad you misunderstood them but pls look at their point of views too! also saying that hyunsuk is annoying,selfish and heartless was kinda harsh cause you guys didn’t really know what he went through but i respect your guys’s opinionnn:)) love your reactions but i’m kinda sad with thiss but yeahhh love yah guys! i hope you understand why hyunsuk said that when you read the comments:)) you guys will see more of hyunsuk selflessness when you watch the whole show!

[@krstnsndart]

Midam's "I NEED TO LEAVE THIS PLACE" still haunts me to this day. It's really hard to be an introvert. But maybe knowing about the Silver Boys when I watched YGTB made me understand where Hyunsuk is coming from. It was heartbreaking, esp the part where they part ways as Treasure A. I understand where you're coming from and I thank you for your honesty. Even if he's your bias, you're just keeping it real. But my heart bled when you said he was "selfish" (I still respect your opinion). Maybe it was just hard for me to hear that when I saw how he struggled in MIXNINE. I hope in the upcoming episodes, you'll see a different side of Hyunsuk. More triggering scenes coming up. But I love watching your unbiased reaction. Thank you again for being honest. :))

[@Anna-go5pl]

seeing how much junghwans been through literally breaks my heart and it only gets worse, now i understand why hes everyone's baby in treasure, hes been through a lot for a 13/14yo kid :(

[@kimpacaldo1979]

I have been a fan of hyunsuk ever since MIXNINE. hyunsuk, junkyu and byounggon are my favorite yg trainees since they appeared in mixnine. Hyunsuk in Mixnine and in YGTB is I must say he has pretty harsh personality beacause in the first place he needs to compete for him to debut, considering there is a lot of trainees that has also a potential. His one and only dream is to debut under YG so he need to protect his position at all cost to debut, also you can tell from his intension that he really wants treasure A to debut as a team because they spent years together as a trainee. Your reaction is normal because that was hyunsuk's feelings being hurt he expresses his emotional feels because he cares for his team you may say he is selfish but nah he is the sweetest and I know you guys know it. Fact too is that YG really puts so much pressure in someone who he really thinks that has a potential being a leader and that he wants hyunsuk to be the best leader of the group (you realized it in the upcomming episodes) YG really adored hyunsuk eversince mixnine so he expect so much from him.Hyunsuk's sweat and tears pays off as he is now the leader of Treasure. Just sharing my roller coaster emotion of stanning my bibi boy 😁 Have fun watching YGTB 💙

[@wnksmile]

I actually love rewatching treasure box (although it's sad) cause some rookie groups I stan, some of the members were in ygtb, like seokhwa (WEi), Byunggon and Seunghun (CIX) so it's cool to see where they started from (although byunggon did start from mixnine but I haven't watched that yet)

[@nafisiim2328]

Fyi, just byunggon, seunghun not in mixnine

[@wnksmile]

@@nafisiim2328 ah i see thank you🙇‍♀️🙇‍♀️, will edit the comment

[@kath8983]

Seunghun did not join mixnine. It was Byounggon, Hyunsuk and Junkyu.

[@wnksmile]

@@kath8983 ah thank you, I saw the previous comment and edited the comment, but thank you again for telling me 🙇‍♀️🙇‍♀️🙇‍♀️

[@kath8983]

@@wnksmile Hihi welcome

[@kath8983]

Junghwan experienced great heartache that time about starting the song great. But as he passed through that struggle, he nailed every other song as the start singer including Going Crazy and ILY.

[@user-jz9bk5wj9c]

PLEASE DO THE TREASURE BOX REACTION 2 TIMES A WEEK! PLEASE🙏🏼

[@annmurmu]

It really hurts when you commented about Hyunsuk I respect your viewpoint but please don't misunderstand him ...he is the purest and most selfless human I have ever seen...pls keep loving him

[@teume6687]

TEAM A is the longest that’s why yg is more strict to them than the other team and he expect more every evaluation that’s why i am kinda hurt that you misunderstood hyunsuk and the rest of team A :( maybe because i follow them for the longest time now that’s why i know some of the things behind the scene

[@thegodsofgalaxy2109]

Stop making abt the longest training thing. Well, Mashiho and Keita is way trained longer than any members of Team A except Yedam

[@teume6687]

@@thegodsofgalaxy2109 i am not comparing both teams, what is wrong with you?

[@cjvlonzo]

BEEN WAITING FOR THIS LIKE FOREVER, THANK U AMS AND EV!

[@zakiyatussalma3985]

me too, i've already watched ygtb 2 or 3 times, but still want to watch it again and again, and yes i need friends who will watch it together, thankyou ams and ev,

[@yo.shiiii9005]

Its like watching with my friends! such a good watch it uplifts me tbh

[@CHRISSY_024]

Hyunsuk Pillow is in the house people😄😊

[@yauuuu011]

Well YG can't hide his favorite feeling from haruto😂.. Its so obvious 😂

[@crownprince8786]

I can't stop looking on Smiley HYUNSUK at the back LOL

[@sommungchisblinkifyoureate6307]

Ever since the beginning jihoon really is a leader material

[@xoxojessiexoxotix]

Hyunsuk is the most selfless person outthere HE WAS TRYING TO CONVINCE MIDAM TO STAY NOT WASTE HIS CHANCE AND EFFORTS OF DEBUT HE WASNT BLAMING HIM midam left only a day b4 the performence A DAY even the manager told him '' u are wasting your chance'' i dont think hyunsuk meant blaming him for ruining the team's last performence when he said that the way i always saw it is that he meant : this is our last assessement we are not far away from making if you 've hold on just a little but we could Make it together and your hard work and frustration will be paid like '' you shouldnt have given up and wasted your dream'' .. this is how i saw it when hyunsuk said that

[@kinahylt9241]

you guys are my favorite reactors, i know that we all have different perspective on one particular thing and i do really respect that but... at the same time i really don't want you guys to misunderstood them :(( i'm hurt ngl, and I'm afraid that you guys might continously misunderstood them especially hyunsukiee :(

[@cole2176]

Huynsuk is the softest one. He didnt have any ill intention. He wanted Midam to stay and fight till the end. Why we called YG family is because even Trainees or artists left the company, they are in good terms and still supportive to each other. Even most YG Stan still support to trainees and artists whoever left the company.

[@evelynclemeno4274]

Hyunsuk is actually closed to Midam, he knows the guy wanted to debut and he didn't want him to give up after they have been through a lot. But it is what it is.

[@gabbipicar1126]

At least, Hyunsuk learned his lesson now. I actually didn't like the time Hyunsuk was kind of prideful in the first episode but I can understand. I've watched the Mixnine and and I understand where he's coming from. As we all know, he was supposed to debut before and seeing the results made him mad. I'm not saying that what he did was right but the point is he learned his lesson now. He became a Better person. I think that was also YG's way to humble him.

[@jazminale8131]

I'll just say that Hyunsuk knows exactly the feeling that things don't turn out the way one wishes they were on another MIXNINE survival show and it wasn't a pleasant experience at all. They humiliated him a bit with words like "you really are from YG or you are from YG and that's what the only thing you can show" were things he heard so nothing was easy for him even though he remained in the final lineup they canceled the debut and in YGTREASURE BOX It didn't turn out very well, he was about to not debut, Hyunsuk knew Midam's abilities and he just wanted him to stay on the team to show his talent because he deserved to debut too

[@d-dina4661]

All the trainees were stressed out because this is a survival show. Midam being a trainee at yg for 2 years. He loves his friends so much. Team A are more like friends and brothers. We knew the real reason of him leaving yg last year from Midam’s dad letter. The letter said ‪“Young midam who really liked music and singing decided to pursue the bleak path of being an idol and went to seoul for auditions here and there and eventually dream agency yg contacted him but when he entered yg he realised it is not how he dreamt of it to be. midam who is naturally gentle/innocent and kind found it tough as he had to compete with his team mates and that created gaps(like distance) in their friendship” ‬ I hope you don’t get Hyunsuk wrong, he doesn’t want midam to stay for team but he wants midam to stay as his friends. He’s not a selfish man but he’s a selfless man. His debut has been canceled once before yg treasure box but he never give up. He was just want his friend to be more patience. Midam is now an actor and I believe it’s his dream.

[@msxx4749]

You're completely misunderstanding Hyunsuk here. In the previous episode he is getting annoyed of them not topping in the rank more of because he is frustated of himself and their team for not doing well despite being there for the longest and not because he see himself above the other trainees. Maybe you should give that scene a rewatch to understand him. Same as on this episode he is frustrated to Midam for not hanging in there. He wants them to debut together but he just gave up. They've been together since silver boys and he really cares a lot for the members. You're completely seeing him in the wrong light here. Thanks.

[@msxx4749]

If you watch other side contents like survey cam, reaction or diary cam you will see how the other trainees respect, adore and like Hyunsuk so much and that says a lot of his personality.

[@hanisfarzana8215]

from the previous ep, he disappointed with himself and not bcuz of he's selfish tho

[@veritas5287]

51:02 EV, How is it that it's their fault that Midam is like that? When Midam's problem is his inner self? I don't think it's right to blame the other guys based on a portion of what is shown on your screen. They could have not noticed what Midam's feeling but, even they have their own battles going on. And Midam didn't tell them what he's really feeling. I don't think you should put blame on anyone.

[@cainbluewin9858]

I personally think team A performance was good tho..

[@Happygoluckywithu]

I also thought that Treasure A's team performance was overall the best from vocals, raps, and dance. Maybe their opinion of Hyunsuk affected the way they perceived their performance.

[@user-kl5jm2yz8j]

They were in a different environment,without the guarantee of debuting, despite their struggle for years.Treasure A was really close in the other hand,the trainees barely knew each other.After they achieved their dreams,they seemed happier and lively,but knowing what they went through before makes it all more meaninful.

[@littlepink555]

About hyunsuk... I think you can understand why he's like that.... If you know YG trainee's since They called "Silverboys" you can understand why hyunsuk like that😂... He's just wanna keep A team still 7... Bcs you know what? They have lost members.. Jeonwoong, noa, raesung.. and they lost Midam too... can you felt that? Its really hurts.... I love Treasure... But im still love Silverboys too😔

[@rvestrada331]

oh i had the same exact irritation when i watched this for the first time - and that maybe the reason why i was never attracted to hyunsuk during YGTB. But watching Hyunsuk in Treasure Map and now, i can see he has different or kinda similar but somewaht different mindset now - CHS still prioritize the Team (Treasure now) before himself. During YGTB, i think he has just that possessiveness/protective instinct towards his own group. He was not yet ready to let go of TEAM A members ...... ahh, YG is a real genius. i dont know how his mind works but how he did YGTB has a great impact on the personalities of TREASURE on Treasure Map up to now. . he trained not only their skills but their mental health... and it is also a good thing that it was televised so that the trainees can monitor themselves and see the things they need to improve. - which they did..... Also, ah Junkyu also has strong mentality.... he overcame his slump period after mixnine through YGTB. ..... i do enjoy your raw and real reactions. its okay to be irritated by your bias - as long as you still love and support him..... just want to say that this was year 2018 - CHS has improved greatly personality and skill-wise. . i also has only started to appreciate him on Treasure Map.

[@grrrahhswagunlimited7122]

Wait hold up what did Hyunsuk say, i thought by, "in a way this really is our last performance" he meant like cause they were already being separated like it just hits him that they'll never perform together again. they were all probs frustrated cause they're all desperate to debut. i was sad that Midam left bc he was my fav before, but im thankful he took care of his mental health first... n e wayssss great vid i hope y'all continue doing this.

[@vip_bang547]

DONT MISUNDERSTAND HYUNSUK, The last time you felt he was being entitled. That was never the case coz he was simply ashamed to be called out despite the years of practice and being in Team A. It was a Battle with his self More. HYUNSUK IS FOR THE TEAM. HE ACTUALLY WANTED MIDAM TO HOLD ON LIKE THEY ALL DO. AND DON'T SAY THAT THEY DID NOT TRY TO REACH OUT. Why is it there Fault Now when Mi dam Left? He is the eldest and has the Most pressure and Can't understand why Him and probably Team A still has to Compete when they have Trained so Long. The public actually expected them to Debut as a GROUP (aka Silverboys). He also left to get a shot at PRODUCE. I have to admit, My heart cried for Treasure A Boys coz they really wanted to All Debut AS A TEAM but it never Came Easy. The Selection also navigated Towards a Younger and Fresher Trainee which you cant discount also coz there were plenty of talented Trainees with great presence in the Other Group too. I'm Just Happy that there were So Many YGTB alum who debuted❤

[@levi2044]

I totally respect your opinion about Hyunsuk Ams & Ev, this was on 2018, it was in the past already, so nothing to be bitter too much. It's kinda fresh to hear different opinions too. So if you're reading all the comments, don't be disheartened. Thank you for the episode 3 reaction, looking forward for episode 4 next week! yay!

[@wahminph2662]

Ok. I forgot to say this on my last comment but Byounggon and Hyunsuk has every right to feel frustrated during YGTB. Those two were supposed to debut on Mixnine. For all Hyunsuk Bias please make sure to watch Mixnine. You will see Hyunsuk differently. ❤️❤️❤️