Red Dead Redemption 2: OVERRATED or MASTERPIECE?

[@GamingTank]

First video of 2025 let's gooooo!!!!

[@SLYTHER_EDIT_S]

Happy new year Boah🥂hope you make even better videos this year cowpoke!

[@GamingTank]

Happy New Year to you too Black lung 🤝

[@ThousandairesClub]

*my issue with all Rockstar games is the lack of choice and decision for the player. so many times in my RDR2 playthrough, I screamed at the tv because we're just forced through this linear path of awful decisions that I would never make* 👎

[@Jordan27893]

You can literally make your own choices in multiple missions

[@GamingTank]

No you can't lol. The "choices" you're talking about are "help this person or don't" in which, if you pick the latter, you're basically missing out on content 🤷🏻‍♂️.

[@Jordan27893]

@GamingTank true though I've seen the video Nakey Jakey made that Rockstar took a linear and heavily scripted path for their newer games ig you're right but personally I really loved the game I think the story telling is really good and the drama the story has too

[@ashudoes3D]

if anything this game made me hate tuberculosis. I hope rockstar improves gameplay for GTA 6

[@GamingTank]

True

[@movinperera5587]

Wow!!!! Really love how you worded this out. "Overratted Masterpiece" is such an accurate description of what this game is. There are so many aspects of this game from the characters to the world that have been crafted so impeccably that you simply cannot deny it's some of the best work in the industry, but it is also extremely frustrating to note that the same game hosts some of the worst controls and most lackluster mission design in the industry as well. It's like the best and worst of the gaming industry packed into one package. I love this game to death, but man do I often wonder about what could have been had there not been so many glaring flaws. Loved the video man, you just gained a sub, and you deserve much more❤

[@GamingTank]

Thanks You Very Much! 🤝

[@denzilritesh1890]

Awesome Video Man! Just wish they remastered it for the ps5

[@GamingTank]

Thank You! No need for a Remaster, just needs a resolution and frame rate bump.

[@Bugmastery]

The gameplay is the most important thing in a freaking game 🤦

[@ambrozoblak7371]

rdr2 is the best interactrive movie i ever watched

[@GamingTank]

💀

[@HelloThere-nd7px]

Great video man, I am glad to find that you are one of the few people who critically analyzes this game from a pure *gameplay* perspective for once and not just the story, the characters etc. and points out the unnecessary "realism" and linearity this game has, good job. 👍🏻 P.S. 4:14 You *can* fast travel from the camp, I think you need your horse nearby or something.

[@GamingTank]

Thank you very much! Also, I know you can fast travel to locations but I'm talking about the fact that you can't fast travel to WAYPOINT like the first game.

[@bestgamerever1]

one of the best! rdr2 is my favorites

[@GamingTank]

One of my favorites too!

[@chappanagent]

Been replaying Watchdogs 1 with a. Lot of mods and bhai its seriously a 9/10

[@Theneonguy789]

You're very underrated my man

[@GamingTank]

Appreciate that 🤝

[@99ak]

i dont like that the game Detroid become Human has like 200+ endings and rdr2 has 4 shi3 as$ ending where everytime arthur has to die

[@Lillobotomite123]

It’s a very very good game but god it’s overrated and not to mention the fans that can’t handle opinions

[@surrarham7223]

FIANLLY! Rdr2 is one of the best game i ever played, even tho it was like only a little... and the game looked like shit with my graphics uhd 620.. and the fps was at 16 with the most i could turn the graphics down.. but its still the best OW game i ever played.

[@surrarham7223]

at first i thought you were spiting shit.. But by the end of the video i really do agree with most of ur points

[@GamingTank]

Damn dude, that right there is dedication LOL.

[@bojanbozovic9200]

This game is different that any other because its so realistic. I understand you but you should go play Far Cry 6 or something similar. RDR2 is one of the best games ever and it is because how realistic it is

[@GamingTank]

This is why you shouldn't comment without watching the full video 🤦🏻‍♂️

[@bojanbozovic9200]

@GamingTank sorry, when you said I like to do it slow like with your mother, I stoped watching your video

[@GamingTank]

I proved the contradiction to realism way before that joke in the video.

[@draculatheundead1479]

Hope you won't have to make another ps5 controller tutorial 😂

[@GamingTank]

Same here 😂

[@shadowknight_2505]

Speedrunning videos: It's neither and both.

[@theplaystationgamer8133]

All you're doing is complaining 🤦🏾‍♂️

[@GamingTank]

Nope, maybe you should actually watch the video before commenting BS like this 🤦🏻‍♂️

[@Aaravspecial1]

W

[@GamingTank]

🤝

[@BruceWayne-et8kh]

My man must be tired of listening "you're so underrated" by now

[@GamingTank]

Haha no

[@nimbites]

slightly overrated

[@GamingTank]

Fair opinion.

[@mrmoonplays5081]

W

[@GamingTank]

🤝