Red Velvet Cosmic recording ver.

[@pochii_7802]

Yeri being included in almost every harmonies, which is why I think she has lesser lines in RV. She is the foundation of their harmonies 🫶🏻🫶🏻

[@ninemilwer]

She does most of the low notes❤

[@Yarotska101]

When they used to film them running around during promotions, there would be a few of them just randomly singing parts of songs. One person would begin and Yeri would always listen out first and come in with the harmony. I'm glad that videos like this are out now so even non-Reveluvs can see that Yeri's talents may not be outwardly visible but they have always been put to good use!

[@arturomonasterio9371]

The dark color that yeri puts in the chorus...chef kiss 💜

[@parkhae-il9211]

Yeri's vocals are so underrated, she's literally a backbone on RV's harmonization

[@sarana2598]

FACTSS

[@christine00h]

@@sarana2598ㅅ싸ㅑㅏㅏ

[@PreciousBY309]

Indeed!!!

[@arsenewenger6099]

exact·ly!

[@juliahoseok]

LOL

[@winialuvies3483]

Their harmonization is perfect

[@mrcak2]

I dont find any other kpop group can harmonize beautifully than RV

[@_minji_bunny]

@@mrcak2you can check Mamamoo. They are lovely as well

[@lipeepipol]

​@@mrcak2 EXO has a wonderful acapella part in Tempo, you should check it out 😉 also, it's SM water hahaha SM may mistreat its idols and do MANY stupid things, but at least they're TRAINED to perfection.

[@kio04]

​@@mrcak2mamamoo can do it as well, being a reveluv and moomoo makes me feel proud to follow such talented artists

[@mybelovedpillow]

​@@mrcak2 Lovelyz too. All these groups including RV are so talented ❤

[@victoriatorres406]

The fact that we have enough footage of their raw vocals in the recording to put the whole song together just proves that these girls have nothing to hide. They are the REAL DEAL!

[@ayyjac6997]

Yeri's low register is STRONGGG. Also Irene showing her range. She's holding down a lot of the adlibs in her low register AND upper register

[@ddez]

wish they could do music forever :(

[@Myl-np9pz]

Yes 😭

[@abi_living]

My wish too 😢

[@twicatcher]

joy obviously will quit red velvet

[@Myl-np9pz]

@@twicatcher You seem new to this SM kpop world, but it's okay, i think there are a lot of people with this question, but that's not how it works. All Red Velvet members have 2 types of contracts, solo and group contracts. Joy won't leave Red Velvet (group contract), but she will probably leave SM (solo contract), just like Wendy (solo contract). So for those who are true fans, don't worry, they will be together. What we will no longer see with Joy and Wendy are SM content (seasongreeting, smtown, etc), so season greetings will be just with Irene, Seulgi and Yeri, smtown as well. But if you saw Joy's reaction to what the fan said, don't worry either, it was just a misunderstanding, the fans are so sensitive these days. Joy just felt relieved knowing that there are people who care about Red Velvet like the fan did. 🥹♥️

[@twicatcher]

@@Myl-np9pz but if they really do leave sm then red velvet will not be active like nowdays right

[@Jane-gh5sv]

예리 저음 깔아주는 거 걸그룹에서 진짜 귀한 보컬이다...위에서 웬슬조가 탄탄하게 질러주고 밑에서 린옐이 안정적으로 받쳐주고 진짜 환상의 조합 아닐 리 없음...

[@영양사-y1e]

노래 못하는애들이 원래 저음이라도 깜

[@life.onmars]

Obsessed with Yeri and Wendy on the bridge 🔥🔥🔥

[@mllewhimsy1161]

yeri is killing her lines

[@CosmicWin]

2:55 my favorite Wendy high note. It's so emotional. It's not a sad song by any means but the high note breaks my heart.

[@Lyf4rMusic]

It maybe bcoz it feels strangely nostalgic

[@jomo.2288]

TOTALLY FUCKING AWESOME

[@Aespagurlz]

FINALLYYYYY SOMEONE SAID IT!!!! IT'S BEAUTIFULLY HEARTBREAKING 😢

[@cosmosisrose]

I think the song is sort of sad. the lyrics have this air of melancholy like you feel like somebody is slipping away from you and are desperate to keep ahold of them

[@joobies]

im pretty sure the song is about feeling attached to someone that you weren’t expecting to feel attached to :)

[@ruebze]

From Wendy powerful belt, Seulgi siren vocals and Joy's sweet tone to Yeri and Irene deep lower register they are the Queen of Harmony, each vocals are unique and perfectly fit each other.

[@oo2877]

우리가 아는 레드벨벳의 목소리는 5명 중 단 한 명이라도 빠지면 안 됨… 후렴에서 나오는 하나로 합쳐진 그 목소리가 정말 아름다움 🥹🥹👏🏻

[@da1b0ng]

여성 중창단이라는 댓글이 안잊혀져 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 왜케잘하는거야

[@bruh-hr1mt]

This just reminds me how much I NEED a Red Velvet acapella song..

[@todayisfey1256]

I think yerim got a lot line distribution with her harmonization. Their have perfect vocal. Our cake girls

[@dinoteatime]

crazy harmonization from irene & yeri

[@roaa4327]

their voices mix so well with eachother, genuinely elevating the song just with their tone and talent

[@thevvvvv]

1:22 this part always gives me goosebumps

[@-someone-cherry-]

I WAS SAYING THAT

[@ceceshire]

at that point i was like "this girlgroup should never ever disband. they should make music until they're old"

[@-someone-cherry-]

@@ceceshire GIRL FR

[@thanstay99]

literally the song of the year

[@shymaknae97]

Yess ikrr

[@anastasyaasionn]

Yeri and Irene really complete the RV sounds...

[@shelfj3901]

That Yeri x Wendy bridge is FIRE tho 🔥 our queen of harmony and queen of vocals 🎉

[@wanyusofzakaria1253]

In love with yeri's bridge at 2:39

[@rosieareinsane]

right, this bridge is really important for wendy's after part

[@Bxbyalys]

@@rosieareinsane also yeri killed it ;)

[@allyouhadtodowas_stay]

예리 저음 진짜 숨은 보석이다…

[@torooo4]

Irene and Yeri are the key to harmonization

[@alyslim5234]

YERI’S ERA FOR VOCALS FINALLYYYYY🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@eyebrowstj]

Wendy's voice is such an important part of their discography. I often wonder when they mix the harmonies on the final product they tend to drown out Wendy's vocals, but you can clearly hear her on the harmonies in the studio.

[@wonbinsarangheyo]

진정한 페스츄리 그룹…. 보컬합 최상

[@나돼-v3c]

개개인으로도 너무 좋은데 합쳐졌을때 합이 진짜 너무 좋음. 레드벨벳 최고.

[@iWantSome_CHURROS]

Yeri low voice is so good

[@joyaaa12248]

I'm obsessed with Joy's voice. Her voice is so sweet

[@krwonwoofiee]

If ill be not be biased THIS SONG IS THE SOTY

[@shymaknae97]

YES IKRRR

[@하루전-o2x]

레드벨벳이 ㄹㅇ 과몰입하기 좋은 노래 많음 하나하나 들어보면 진짜 이게 음악인지 클래식인지..와

[@user-ck1fy6fh1d]

0:51 여기 아이린 톤 진짜 좋다.. 와 서늘한 느낌 제대로 살려줌

[@albalinus]

Irene's deep voice is beautiful and impressive, it is underrated

[@alicehealy99]

Yeri did so well on the bridge she sounds amazing 💜

[@joyrining]

the harmonies ❤ especially yerene on the prechorus parts

[@adihrdd]

people arent lying when they say, being kpop group which mean you can sing, dance, be harmonized, also visual tho, thats why they train so hard for their debut for over a years, redvelvet one of a succesful kpop group who have standard from that, wohooo!!!!

[@Bxbyalys]

in love with yeris voice, especially her lows in the chorus and her bridge

[@minxxgreen]

가수 맞는데 진짜 가수 같아서 너무 좋음..ㅠㅠㅠ 그래 이거지예 이게 k-pop이지

[@Lyf4rMusic]

The synergy of their voices coming together in the chorus with either singing in unison or blasting out in harmonies has been a signature of Red Velvet, right since their debut

[@바니쨩-c8n]

페스츄리 장인들 미쳤다 레드벨벳 한명 한명 개인 다 목소리 너무너무 소중함 계속 다섯명 목소리 들을수 있으면 좋겠음. 사랑해❤

[@cyrask]

The vocal layers 🔥

[@u____22_o]

진짜 앵콜 너무 듣고 싶었는데 1위 못한 게 너무 아쉽다..ㅠ

[@stanloona8881]

I love SM ent idols😢, they are the true vocalist of kpop and can deliver their voices beautifully 🌹

[@computer874]

I love how everyone is moving while they sing and Irene is just 🧍‍♀️

[@chr1s5ophi3]

Such a cool part at 1:22

[@youare-myday]

켄지의 페스츄리 실력 진짜 대단하다... 레드벨벳 중창단 너무너무 듣기 조아 너무 황홀해...

[@Dj.alokssi]

Red velvet should boost their confidence level to sing live on most occasions. Cause they really do have great vocal ability! Really love it when their mic was on! Pls SM let them be pls!

[@marifonseca31]

In need of Yeri solo album, come on SM

[@ventaliq]

and irene

[@ssong3628]

예리야 진짜 보석이다ㅏ 저음이 미쳐따ㅏ

[@mikehat5548]

wendy and her cold 🔥❤️

[@eyebrowstj]

😂😂😂

[@6-__-98]

너무좋다 이게 아이돌이지

[@hellohello-dm1dh]

0:34 this part going into the harmony just wowww ✨️ definitely gives that cosmic feeling

[@Asl06icec0ld]

This IS MY FAV PART?!!!!

[@RiswjyV]

Nothing like Red Velvet's 5 layer harmonies. That's truly their identity and uniqueness. Love my vocalists so much. 💫

[@Standby_sseulgi]

정말 천상의 목소리들이다 🥹

[@silverpanorama]

레드벨벳 목소리 합 진짜 어디서도못찾아... 소중해...

[@PrincepalJiafei-sw7tq]

I would believe you if this was just a quieter inst but the fact this is their raw vocals makes me starstruck

[@kosssg]

수영이 음색 진짜 말도 안돼 그게 라이브로 된다는게 신기해..

[@brixleesinadjan5932]

Yeri's vocals has improved. ❤

[@earthcitty]

Oh that was great!!! Ive thought this since Bing Bing, but Wendy and Yeri have great resonace with one another.

[@user-tihzy7oiz5]

믿고 듣는 레드벨벳 레코딩 비하인드

[@lucasaugusto36]

Finally a song in their range.

[@Jesus-bq4gz]

their voices are so pretty ♥

[@alyslim5234]

i sincerely hope they NEVER disband, i just LOVE them as a group so much ❤

[@totheworld_NCTot25]

SM groups never disband 😩 You're new to SM?

[@alyslim5234]

@@totheworld_NCTot25 no i’m not actually! but yeah now that you’ve mentioned it, they never disband 🥹🥹

[@eyebrowstj]

Wendy had a cold here, folks 😂😂😂

[@zuriel117]

The fact that Wendy was sick when they recorded this song yet still her vocals sound like this!? 🩵

[@BroedellJaime]

Wendy's run at 1:39 is so smooth and buttery

[@cool7584]

말이 필요 없다 진짜.. 그야말로 perfect.

[@liyouzhendema]

여성중창단 레드벨벳.......... 최고야

[@MjYosh]

This is why i love that RED VELVET releases their recording diary because it so interesting to hear everything come together ❤❤ this vid is amazing

[@hdkim66]

예리 저음 진짜 죽여준다. 너무 너무 좋아.

[@Bazsigood]

Their harmony os perect, still Seulgy's voice is so dominant. it's like she is singing the whole song alone :)

[@hugecake4178]

This is what I like about SM's GG, the harmonization, voice combination and layering in their songs is on a whole different level ❤

[@juliawidmaier5334]

Joy's voice is so sweet, it makes me smile every time

[@JoyismyQ]

💚

[@aquirapagunsan]

Those harmonies and adlibs are heaven 💖 Moment of appreciation to Yeri's vocals!! Wendy is effortlessly doing those high notes and powerful vocals ofc she's the best vocalist in kpop.

[@alvi_omi]

Wendy🔥

[@boni9033]

WE NEED WENDYS VOCAL WARM UP OF THE WHOLE SONG

[@gappmoe]

1:28 i love joys bubbly voice so much hearing her just makes me instantly joyful 1:37 wendys runs are always flawless but full of depth and life 2:59 is absolutely stunning

[@arsenewenger6099]

스튜디오 버전도 나왔으면 좋겠네요. 아으 지렸다

[@JoyismyQ]

Tone Fairy Joy is just perfection

[@fatyfarrell]

Wendy in her element! She's so fucking cool!

[@vaniwaa]

Wendy's voice got me crying, so beautiful 😭

[@jayjay1798]

“Yeri is useless”…bro she actually carries the chorus in all their songs apparently

[@moisesportillo618]

Omg Wendy, she's so perfect

[@kidcaptainwembri]

I'm obsessed with every recording version of Red Velvet's songs TT Thank you so much for doing this!!

[@hydewii1717]

WENDY 💙💙💙

[@치키닝-i6o]

여기 편집이 제일 깔끔하고 좋아요!

[@navi_chou]

I hope this is going to be a new trend where they would release the full length of the recording version of a song, so that we can listen to their raw vocals

[@hummoon6920]

They forgot to include irene part on the reff so when we mix this together it feels like there's something missing or incomplete because irene wasnt included. But when we listen to the actual song it feels so complete

[@TomasNTM]

She’s in the final recording ofcourse😊with chill kill there was no footage of yeri singing the chorus but she for sure recorded it

[@DHesper9194]

They only provided their first-day recording. Pretty sure they recorded more than once. But yeah that's what we've got😢

[@riffgroove]

Thanks! I was wondering why Irene was missing during the choruses.

[@azwannasrull]

@@riffgrooveshe definitely contribute especially for the lower vocal

[@qdotsg]

shoutout to all their writers and producers for bringing this out of them as well~ 💜

[@Alyaa9697]

Suka banget RV kalo rilis recording selalu lengkap partnya

[@TheRV02]

RV = Real Vocal hope Red Velvet will sing live forever

[@shaider1taps]

Thank you for your service, I was looking for real vocals gg recording ver.

[@RobertEsguerra]

Um ... so ... does Wendy get overtime for all the additional voices she adds to this song? A bonus? A brand new car?😉

[@alltheprettygirls9]

Her rewards? A 15 seconds screen time on their MV.

[@a23g23u23std]

of course, red velvet harmony never fails ❤️

[@fikrihaidar4732]

these raw vocals layered oh my god!!

[@TrangNg95]

Every comeback, I wait for this version to be put together and get amazed all over again at the layering and harmonization. Rv truly is amazing ❤

[@aritaX15]

La Cosmic era empezó en junio y seguirá viva conmigo ❤

[@izurzuhri]

i got goosebumps! I didn't know they have beautiful voice