Red Velvet - Goodbye | 레드벨벳 - 안녕 [Immortal Songs 2]

Red Velvet - Goodbye | 레드벨벳 - 안녕
------------------------------------------------
Subscribe KBS World Official KZbin: / kbsworld
------------------------------------------------
KBS World is a TV channel for international audiences provided by KBS, the flagship public service broadcaster in Korea. Enjoy Korea's latest and most popular K-Drama, K-Pop, K-Entertainment & K-Documentary with multilingual subtitles, by subscribing KBS World official KZbin.
------------------------------------------------
대한민국 대표 해외채널 KBS World를 유튜브에서 만나세요. KBS World는 전세계 시청자에게 재미있고 유익한 한류 콘텐츠를 영어 자막과 함께 제공하는 No.1 한류 채널입니다. KBS World 유튜브 채널을 구독하고 최신 드라마, K-Pop, 예능, 다큐멘터리 정보를 받아보세요.
------------------------------------------------
[Visit KBS World Official Pages]
Homepage: www.kbsworld.co.kr
Facebook: / kbsworld
Twitter: / kbsworldtv
Google+: plus.google.com...
KakaoTalk: @kbs_world (plus.kakao.com/...)
Instagram: @kbsworldtv
Tumblr: / kbsworld

[@havielchoir9124]

seems like my wendy always hit the highnote very effortless lol

[@reveluv8642]

ikr😭😭

[@myheaven3734]

😭😭😭💙💙💙💙🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 WENDY GOLDEN GIRL🥇🏆

[@HaNguyen-nd4mz]

Sm is really lucky to have Wendy. Her vocal is overwhelmed.

[@myheaven3734]

YES! Wendy is seriously golden girl💎🥇🏆🎤

[@haki3m402]

Hà Nguyễn Wendy have it all... VOCAL, RAP, SWAG, PRETTY FACE, DANCE like urrgh I'm so proud to be a reveluv

[@eyebrowstj]

I agree!! Wendy is soooo underrated in this fandom!!

[@AznIntegra521]

Sm is lucky considering when Wendy was auditioning, she got turned down y multiple labels but not SM. SM saw something in her and we see it. I bet those labels who turn her down are kicking themselves for not scooping up such a talent when they had the chance.

[@diemanhle6365]

AznIntegra521 haha YG said he regretted that he did choose Wendy into their company

[@ravensebastian3746]

Joy is great At Harmonizing She can easily adjust Her pitch to blend well with others Seulgi is Good at Showing The emotion of the song And her voice Is easy to blend with Wendy is has the best technique She know where She should used Her voice

[@salmanabila5002]

RV = Real Visual & Real Vocals

[@noonu5575]

OMG, so true. I just hate it when people say SM artists are not talented, and just popular because of those faces and “SM” (I stan SM artists, not the company tho.)

[@greentea4775]

+Ria Nick Yap yap yap! Me too. They said that SM just has VISUAL, while the best dancer is in SM (Hyoyeon, Eunhyuk, and Taemin) and the best vocal is (Taeyeon, Wendy, Luna).

[@oohseungwan5648]

+Zilfa Love Soshi truee!! haha

[@Argonsora]

+Zilfa Love Soshi no, not true Honestly, if you can find a boy/girl group full of ugly people, then I'll acknowledge it. All the companies have nice looking people. Some natural while other plastic. But in the end, they all look good. Its the basis of every boy/girl group. Talent....vs hardwork, they both get someone to their destination. Sure, there are those who are always higher in the industry. But, at the same time, all the companies have their own talents. Some in the form of vocals, in the form of dancing and also when producing music. So no. Its not sm that has talents and visual. Its not jyp that has talents and yg with visuals. Its that they all have trainees or idols, that are working hard to do what they like.

[@berrycupcake1968]

Salma Nabila AGREEE with you!!!!

[@annieslittleadventures1907]

Joy really impressed me here, her voice has always surprised me but not as much as it did here. She does have some improvements to make (she looks like she's holding back and is having a bit of trouble projecting which is mostly probably due to nervousness) but beautifully done nonetheless. Those things are easy to improve through practice and I'm excited to watch her vocals grow ☺️☺️☺️.

[@SicaRun]

+Annie's little adventures She was extremly nervous, you can see on her face, she keep looking at the ground every time and at Seulgi, she can't properly look at the camera.

[@thek-boom3234]

Joy's tone and stability, Seulgi's harmonisation and Wendy's power... the best vocal line in K-Pop.

[@joannezapf3681]

for me the best vocal is mamamoo

[@rafaelfaria5568]

@@joannezapf3681 good for you

[@CosmicWin]

They kinda put to shame the vocal lines in a lot of groups, both western and Korean alike.

[@eldestreveluv7273]

@@CosmicWin Indeed ! I live in the USA we have nothing here that compares to Red Velvet ...

[@aricalista784]

SNSD: taetiseo RV: wenseuljoy

[@baddad9141]

Ari Calista - i tried to think of another group that could have performed this on that level and TTS was the first thought i had...and im still wondering...mamamoo maybe? Dang

[@oddfish5269]

That would have been a vocal attack. We now have Irene and seulgi but it’s a different kind of attack but it’s an attack nonetheless lol

[@judezalabadan282]

@@baddad9141 Mamamoo's vocal is powerful but I do think that this song doesn't suit them since they have thicker voices

[@baddad9141]

@@judezalabadan282 hehehehe...they weren't as stylistically thick 2 years ago lol...but nowadays i agree

[@judezalabadan282]

@@baddad9141 Most of their singing styles nowadays suit the western vibe kind of music.

[@milkaandcookies]

SM... You have gold in your hands

[@winwinislifenctzen6267]

unfortunately sm treated all these "gold" like shit

[@jayleonhart6160]

When we all thought RV won't have a problem becoming one of the top girl groups since they're nice kids, pretty and talented af both singing and dancing but then we still have one problem, their own bloody company.

[@jjkjjk4020]

that's right. fans are really angry of SM's manage and promotion way.

[@velvetra29]

Gold? RV are DIAMONDS.

[@khy491]

milka real mora

[@parksooyoungsdaughter225]

remember that they perform this 1yr after they debuted and joy was debuted as a lead rapper!!! SM be like: suprise bitches my lead rapper can beat your main vocals....

[@Dan-pq5zk]

Hahahaha trueeee

[@j6nrod]

exactly and she was just a rookie to and a lead rapper. she proved herself from her rookie days that she isn’t just a rapper but also a good vocalist!

[@anajwa51]

TaeTiSeo and JoWenSeul should have their own concert.

[@casspricot]

SM is really hinting it when they all both performance twinkle though

[@sameeraatiq8866]

+xTheIconicMaryG means??

[@casspricot]

+Sameera atiq they're hinting they could be a sub unit because those 3 are really seens

[@casspricot]

+Sameera atiq seen

[@sameeraatiq8866]

xTheIconicMaryG yeah.but first I want Wendy seulgi swag unit like g dragon and taeyang :p

[@hiimcatbug9901]

red velvet is NOT a flop group. they are NOT just a cover up for scandals. they are TALENTED. they are BEAUTIFUL. they are AMAZING. stop sleeping on them and wake up, people.

[@stevenkimujimin9111]

i do agree with ur perspective

[@Crystal_wolf123]

What scandals did people think they were a cover up for? Kris & Luhan?

[@areyoukirringmeirriyaa]

Kim Junmyeon yes, jessica leaving and all that shit that happened.

[@_PutriRiangAtika]

Yeahh... people must sleep on bed not rv..

[@SuperPianogirl123]

It's crazy because Red Velvet is like the top three groups in Korea currently

[@zishana_ash]

I once said this, if you are looking for a fierce badass concept then go for Blackpink, but if you are looking for cute and sweet concept, Twice is waving. But if you are looking for both, adding great ballads, diverse kind of music then there is Red Velvet.

[@mangakuota122]

Bc they're very versatile and their talents are above average. Expected from SM they're pick the bestest from the best.

[@zouz3588]

Twice is not only cute and sweet concept anymore, they’re much more diverse

[@slaycgirlsitsgoingdown9800]

@@zouz3588 They changed their concept in 2019 now they r more mature with concept

[@breadgenie1558]

AMEN!

[@mangakuota122]

@@zouz3588 But they still carry the feminine and sweet innocent sides which is their group character and identity, and it's not a bad thing. It's their color in the industry.

[@Catz1a]

I'm getting some serious TTS vibes from this with Wendy and Tae, Seulgi as Seohyun, and Joy as Tiffany. These three could totally make a vocal sub-unit

[@jessicationg7775]

Wendy has such soul and great techniques shown just like Taeyeon. Seulgi has the unique vocal colour just like Seohyun, pure clean and pretty. Joy is not that similar with Tiffany but both of them are decent in both singing and rapping which makes them super lovable (both are fruits too! Refreshing visuals)

[@Catz1a]

yeah but in parallel to TTS Fany is the only one left lol :P But yeah Joy and Tiffany sound pretty different but they are sound similar skill levels compared to their other members vocally. Tiffany has more experience and improvement though

[@MryellowKy]

+Catz1a I think joy has a similar voice to Sunny

[@Catz1a]

Skill wise or the way they sound?

[@MryellowKy]

Catz1a I think in the way they sound. Every time I imagine SNSD singing a Red Velvet song, I assume Sunny would sing a lot of her bits

[@moonstar01]

Red Velvet should have more ballad songs. I love their vocals

[@minhphuongbuiqs9097]

+moonstar01 listen to Candy in their Ice Cream Cake album. it's perfect i cry TToTT

[@RanggaAlamPurnama]

+moonstar01 let's wait for their Velvet album

[@jessicationg7775]

I re-watched this, and you guys might know about this, The Velvet album is out! Check out 'One Of These Nights' and the rest of the album.

[@bree2705]

one of these nights is a really good song.

[@YERI-TTY]

they really don’t make rookies like this anymore.

[@markleeismylee1511]

aespa is similar to them i guess.Great vocals yet again from SM.

[@psycho1093]

@@markleeismylee1511 mmmmmmmm..

[@kkr6254]

@@markleeismylee1511 no I don't think so

[@markleeismylee1511]

@@kkr6254 i mean,they are not gonna make another redvelvet in SM.Whats the point in doing that?Comparing other 4th gen and 3rd gen girlgroups,aespa definitely stands out for vocals.Specially,winter and Ningning

[@angela-dm7vo]

@@markleeismylee1511 aespa was honestly a dissapointment Ngl it's like for the first time SM gave up on the music and just went on with whatever is popular and released a generic concept and generic song for them no hate to the members but I was so dissapointed with what they did SM usually never follows the trends and that's what I love about them but aespa was a dissapointment (Obviously not a flop tho)

[@loveis_2002]

CAN WE TALK ABOUT WENDYS VOCALS😍😫😫😫😍😫

[@reveluv8642]

YESSSS

[@myheaven3734]

nothing to say, I just 😭😭😭 so hard bc she really made my day. EVERY DAY!!!👼🏻💙🔥💕

[@octrishakristianty]

love her voice 😱😱

[@eyebrowstj]

Luv_kjs You have time? Because I literally can and do talk about her vocals all day 😂😂😂

[@eyebrowstj]

Notice no one wants to talk about Wendy's vocals in this fandom. I'll never understand it. She's just on another level and hardly is appreciated. Insanity.

[@AD-fq7zp]

I see Wendy as a humble woman with an exceptional voice. She could've debuted as a solo artist but chose to stay with our angels. She's smart but doesn't flaunt it and allows us to see her crazy and gullible side. She's cute and clumsy but her vocals is no joke. I love love Wendy!

[@nurpazlina5918]

dnns co trueeee.

[@derpface5156]

dnns co same bruh... Same...

[@maliarodriguez5496]

yoongi_realSANTAhal-abeoji she can debut solo but still PART of the group like taeyeon

[@darkfeather111]

im pretty sure wendy was suppose to debut as a soloist. i think the original red velvet member included gong seung yeon and when she left they added wendy and introduced her as an sm rookie and as the 3rd member of red velvet but their was many talks that sm thought her voice was good enough to debut as a soloist.

[@Ripy]

darkfeather111 Lol, that’s just speculations... 😂

[@theycallmealexis]

After 2 years, i still come back to this performance wow jowenseul wow

[@Dan-pq5zk]

Me too. They are so good

[@chickfighter5587]

me too!

[@rosesrerosei]

Its been 4 years and im here...

[@egichany5483]

@@rosesrerosei me too

[@xcxjjku]

i thought who's jowenseul for a second. Lol

[@KunoBaka0908]

this is their level after 1 year debut omg so good, i don't know where they'll go after 9-10 years, it's scary lol

[@jiminsfilter1909]

OH MY GOD YEs i didnt even remember the fact they debuted for a year only while watching this

[@KunoBaka0908]

+bang(tan) jimin I honestly think they're the most talented girl group rookie till now.

[@MinealotPlaysMC]

+Kuno Baka and Mamamoo! But mamamoo doesn't feel like a rookie group because they are a bit older than most rookie groups. Red Velvet is just as amazing !!!! I love both groups!

[@KunoBaka0908]

Yerwendy oh yeah i forget about them xD. To me Mamamoo doesn't look like an idol group at all lol their songs are very mature and their voices are amazing.

[@Square3hree]

What are you saying??!?!?! Irene and Solar are both oldest in each group (25) and are the same age! Hwasa the youngest is only 20 and Joy is 19 if you don't count yeri who joined later. They just give a more mature look because they are so much more professional than many existing groups out there.

[@remynren]

Joy's voice reminds me of honey, Seulgi's voice reminds me of a super star and Wendy's voice reminds me of a diva

[@elsaa_arg]

OMG! YES

[@daniellepetit1207]

Joy-sugar: very sweet voice Seulgi-honey: very smooth voice Wendy-chocolate: very rich voice Idk what I'm even saying. I'm just a foodie. 🤧😅

[@sammysiddhi3874]

@@daniellepetit1207 yaaaa

[@adellianaura7910]

@@daniellepetit1207 Hahahhaha You must be hungry 🤣

[@deejourneyz_]

Joy = honey Seulgi = creamy/cheesecake Wendy = rich/ dark chocolate

[@Ryysight]

Red Velvet sub unit proposition: Joy: leads the verses and harmonies Seulgi: does the main choruses Wendy: comes in right at the end and absolutely SMASHES the power part Share it out like this: Joy singing majority, her voice has so much beautiful simplicity, but her soft, light tone is ideal for the majority of the song Seulgi singing the choruses, her voice is a good base for them Wendy singing the least for a reason... because her part will be so massive and reserved for the end to blow the song up

[@vicky-wc5ev]

Taeyeon - Wend (powerful voice) Jessica - Seulgi (angelic voice) Seohyun - Joy (sweet voice) Love them so much. Proud to be red velvet fan🤍 P.s. i’m back again and still proud to be reveluv✨

[@gowatchredvelvet3818]

ʙᴇᴀʀ ʙᴇᴀʀ I love your display picture, Miss.

[@perlenoirechannel5364]

ʙᴇᴀʀ ʙᴇᴀʀ 👌🏾

[@edgarsaavedrallado4988]

Look seulgi singing withney houston, she is also powerfull

[@queen_o_o_roses]

👌🌹

[@itsevaem9605]

WENDY OH GOD HER VOICE IS DEFINITELY POWERFUL AND THE BEST I DON'T KNOW THAT SHE CAN SING THIS GREAT OMG

[@avee7858]

you should watch her pre debut video, she sang beyonce halo, she slayed that song

[@eyebrowstj]

its Evaem Yassssss! Wendy is the best singer here. I give Seulgi and Joy credit, too, but it's plain to see why Wendy is the main vocal.

[@JS-st8pp]

When Wendy is a top main vocal Seulgi as a lead is better than some main vocals And joy as a sub vocals is better than some lead vocalist

[@yulithecutestbaby1796]

joy is a lead vocalist now lol

[@JS-st8pp]

@@yulithecutestbaby1796 sadly no she is oficially a sub vocalist ;-;

[@hiHELLO-yx6jk]

woah wait she’s subvocalist???

[@JS-st8pp]

@@hiHELLO-yx6jk yes sadly yes

[@xanyeeast]

Joy best sub vocals of 3rd gen Seulgi best lead vocals of 3rd gen Wendy best main vocals of 3rd gen

[@Endlesslove1974]

I feel like Cube Ent is seething that they didn't pick up Wendy when they had the chance, but I'm glad she's with SM.

[@Crystal_wolf123]

@tha tha SM actually looks at talent lol, the one thing they do right

[@harmonyfuntime1082]

Ro Choa also YG 😂😂😂

[@agustindavid5126]

@tha tha but yes, SM made Wendy better and she can be the most pretty now if she join to cube. But lucky her, shes now in SM. Shes not gonna be as flop as Cube now.

[@FarahEmoticonna]

when Wendy and seulgi sang together, it reminds me of Taeyeon and Sica ! the chemistry

[@lennsson834]

+Farah Boucherit I agree

[@willyj7849]

Don't talk sica anymore!! I'll cry a river😭😭😩

[@Qossslikeee]

+Wheein Wylie I agree with you😥

[@ringdingdong4679]

shit dont make me feel the feelings again lol

[@hi_bellaaa1087]

Farah Boucherit we're have same feeL.. i miss TaengSic voice...

[@lester9105]

the fact that seulgi debuted as a main dancer and joy debuted as lead rapper gives me chills

[@kaydotle]

Seulgi being main dancer, pretty much 2nd main vocals w/ Wendy, and elite backup vocals is crazy

[@hunniehuang]

@@kaydotle She's a lead anyway

[@aprilluis1981]

They are so goooood! ❤️

[@sowhat8397]

Seulgi is lead vocal

[@ghnkh573]

Another fun fact, seulgi audition with her amazing vocal and became a main dancer of red velvet 💛

[@velvetra29]

I'm not into this genre so much, but i will throw my dollars if this trio made an entire album.

[@camellia6910]

me too

[@mo6816]

David Dadoali what would you call this genre?

[@thek564]

JoWenSeul

[@siegeslander9759]

David Dadoali They will be the 3rd Gen's new TTS :)

[@enfpflower5751]

David Dadoali neither am I into red velvet, but when I was hospitalized 2 years ago, I was listening to this song all day. I really love this song.

[@Hyxnjxn]

This was absolutely amazing. I don't see why people are surprised by Joy's vocals. Must have missed the many song where her Seulgi and Wendy are hitting high notes for days ie Red Dress, oh boy and a song or two off their previous mini album. But literally such a great performance. Literally when Wendy belted out at the very end I felt that and literally started to tear up. And also the harmonies between the three, BEAUTIFUL. I love this vocal line combination because they all can sing and they all sing within their strengths they don't try to hit notes that they know they aren't able to hit comfortably. I hope they get to perform more ballad stages like this in the future because it was amazing.

[@Justdance272727]

+Rainier Surratt Don't forget about Cool World

[@daifallahhassan345]

People are surprised because the debut she only rapped, and had only a few lines. Her singing has grown since then.

[@Hyxnjxn]

+Daify everyone rapped in their debut song happiness. Hahah but once they covered be natural that's when I knew joy could sing.

[@jonc8561]

+Rainier Surratt No one is impressed until it is does live. Anyone can hit high notes in the studio with the aid of auto-tune, etc.

[@phoebeheart9631]

+Raini Kim joy can also hit high notes like seulgi and wendy if she believes and tries. haha. i know her voice will also have some to progress

[@synkkwangya8911]

Rookie nowdays can't relate to Red Velvet and Mamamo when they were in their rookie days~~

[@Shadowboost]

Monday in Weeekly. But yeah, for the most part

[@henryreselosa7870]

aespa duh!

[@kuliskalimha6578]

Facts only

[@maou-sama6628]

aespa

[@jungwoof]

@@maou-sama6628 🤔no

[@ireneisbae3904]

I really love this group, why? 1. They can do any concept 2. It's rare for other girl groups to sing like this one 3. They have real vocals and visuals (some girl group members lack vocal techniques but them, well pure talent) This is my opinion only!!!!

[@pastellcutie]

Irene is Bae I completely agree with you, if you want more girl groups who sing like this check out Mamamoos Immortal Song performances, they’ve been on the show 13 times xD

[@rasmiapriliani8640]

I agree with you.

[@potathoe2608]

@@pastellcutie 14 now

[@potathoe2608]

Mamamoo goes on immortal songs 2 before every single comeback

[@crackmamamoo3801]

Then you should try listen mamamoo.. Belismamamoo uwu

[@judithjamarolin3196]

I WANT RED VELVET AGAIN IN IMMORTAL SONG!!!!! PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE!!!!!!!!!

[@dragonwings3417]

Twice: Happy Concept Blackpink: Girl Crush concept Red Velvet: Murders, Sad, Happy, Food, Weird, Cute, Girl Crush *Red velvet always tries a new concept and experiments.... They deserve more..* No Hate on the other groups.

[@f.w.s.8095]

Couldn't agree moreee

[@fmsriver]

I'm a blink and a reveluv aswell and I agree with you. They have 80 songs but you won't hear 2 songs that are the same. 💚💜💗💛💙

[@LittleBearbrazil]

So true !

[@zuojiawang5980]

agree

[@nurulfazlina3976]

Thanks for mention twice

[@LilyMarie1D]

I CRIED WITH THIS!, SO BEAUTIFUL! I'M SO PROUD OF THEM!

[@reshaamanda2037]

me too when they hit the high note OMG!!! my eyes suddenly wet

[@5angles955]

+로라 Me too

[@ThaoNguyen-sw8li]

This is one of the reason why I love and hate SM for! They recruit talented people like these three but only showcase the voice of one! I never knew Joy was this good because she doesn't get to show it with their songs but I at the same time cannot blame them since they are idol girl group and people prefer lively songs from them but this made me love red velvet a lot more!

[@kpopluverkpopaddict]

i feel like SM finds the right time/concept for that certain member ex. taemin. back then taemin rarely had lines but during Hello they finally showcased his vocals and now he has a solo. Kai too did not have many lines before he was only allowed to sing little parts but now in monster his vocals are showcased more. amber used to only rap and now she has a solo. SM tends to (idk for sure this is just what i've noticed haha) develop their artists vocals more before letting them out as if they were some kind of hidden card bc at first you're like aw he/she probably cant sing that well and then the next comeback you see immense improvement. this is just what i've noticed btw :)

[@ThaoNguyen-sw8li]

+Angel Song yeah I do admit that SM is very good in their selection skill!

[@kpopluverkpopaddict]

proudStarlight TN not to mention they have amazing trainors

[@nez5677]

i think you also have to think the idol as well. here joy seems really nervous so we have to keep in mind that they might not feel ready

[@ThaoNguyen-sw8li]

+Yoyo Hoho yeah you're right! I hope they get more comfortable and opportunities in the future!

[@stvvbb]

This just proves that Joy is a Lead Vocalist.

[@chokynt4986]

honestly i don't understand why ppl say that wendy has no emotion while singing this? her first line really got me feeling super sad with no reason at all...

[@eyebrowstj]

CHO KYNT Wendy is all about emotion for me. I'm always swept up in her voice and how she sings the words of all of their songs from Red to Velvet concepts. Some people just don't want to give credit to Wendy and she deserves all the credit in the world! Her vocals are no joke!

[@eyebrowstj]

@Taichi Suzuki She should've been appreciated in the past as well, though. She's sorely underappreciated.

[@angela-dm7vo]

Who says Wendy doesn't have emotions while singing? Don't lie to me 😂

[@seaverantonio1138]

Who the fuck said that? Her eyes alone made me depressed

[@reveluviebb9698]

For me, Red Velvet is the best when it comes to harmonizing and being versatile.

[@jywvxz7302]

not the best.

[@tenzingpaldon8053]

okay, but the fact that this was a performance by a rookie girl group is unbelievable. They're are very talented and were born to be stars.

[@Catz1a]

Honestly if you look at just the vocal line, Red Velvet ranks very well next to other girl groups. They always surprise me, especially since I didn't see them as very strong when I first heard of them. But honestly Wendy is better than most main vocalists around right now and Seulgi better than a fair amount of leads

[@vincentciussatya9853]

Around main vocal right now ? Bitch please. SNSD is not yet disband. Taeyeon still held best main vocal as wendy senior, she's still the greatest right now

[@rvtrash3687]

@@vincentciussatya9853 the person didn't say anything about Wendy being better than Taeyeon. The person said better than MOST not ALL. So stop being so butthurt

[@uzoei]

Lina is the best tho, in sm

[@hungphamviet3543]

@@vincentciussatya9853 No she is not she does not support as much as Wendy

[@lazyg7218]

And it was in 2015

[@bunnyearsandteeth]

Seulgi and Joy have good voices but man Wendy is something else. I'd love to hear her sing alone

[@alyssasoon2029]

she did an OST for MIMI before she debuted! she also covered a song for EXO 90:2014

[@meganchuon4002]

+Alyssa Soon where can i watch mimi

[@ctkim696]

+BlaBlaBlueBerries smtown youtube channel

[@alyssasoon2029]

+BlaBlaBlueBerries if u mean the ost wendy sang, its on sm's yt channel. as for the drama, I think any drama website would have it. I didnt watch mimi

[@e-1014]

Which one is Wendy?

[@ulvisenani1833]

Wendy has a strong voice. Seulgi has a satisfying and unique voice. Joy has a sweet voice. (Note: all of them has a strong voice) Joy+Seulgi+Wendy= WAİT İ CAN’T HANDLE THİSS

[@__jjapagetti]

Seulgi is so flexible ahh she's a damn good dancer and can even reach high notes😭💛 she's my forever bias wrecker my bias is joy btw💚 and for wendy ohh no boy your voice is gold💙

[@Zdavid99Z]

TO THOSE ONES WHO SAID THAT RED VELVET DON'T HAVE VOCALS. AND MY JOY ♥

[@umarismail2281]

Wendy’s vocal power Seulgi’s harmonies and sound joy’s clarity and uniqueness

[@JoyismyQ]

Umar Ismail perfect! 💚❤️💚

[@benjieboy2539]

I like RV more than other girl groups cause they are like a gold cause look they have visual check voice check charm check unique check dance check cuteness check height check body shape or sexynes check rap check

[@vincentciussatya9853]

You didnt know their sunbaenim ? I bet you didnt know about GG

[@bbumply]

Vincentcius Satya honestly shut up I’ve seen you say the same thing to other commenters This person isn’t saying rv is the best of them all just some

[@gamer_girl99_]

Omg joy😍im in love My bias list changed in red velvet! 1-Wendy 2-Joy 3-Seulgi 4-Irene&Yeri

[@karlaviriful]

+D.O IS MY BAE OKAY Same

[@nandokgg]

+D.O IS MY BAE OKAY her voice is so clear and pure and she sings with such an easy, i love it

[@vanhoangkhanh2578]

+D.O IS MY BAE OKAY me too

[@Catz1a]

Honestly same. It started like 1. Joy, Irene, Wendy, Yeri, Seulgi but now it's the same as you I think :P

[@loonavelvet7611]

My RV bias list :3 1.- Wendy 2.- Yeri 3.- Irene 4.- Seulgi 5.- :v I don't like Joy I'm sorry but not sorry :3

[@valeryaleman8084]

Joy's vocal are not joke, y'all see the cover of "coming age ceremony" or her clips from "the liar and his lover"

[@Chekas1292]

Wow.. The gems of SM. I'm so suprised and impressed by Joy. I always knew Wendy and Seulgi were powerhouses, but wow.. Joy!

[@nghiathang4143]

OMGGGG my wendyyyyyyyyyy Seulgi and Joy are very good, too

[@jash973]

they performed this a yr after they debuted, they were insane for this

[@dawntroian5168]

damn Seulgi triple kill! visuals, dancing and singing skills 💯🔥🔥🔥 slayyyyy

[@eyebrowstj]

Damnnnn! Wendy, Seulgi, and Joy sang the shit out of this song!! Wow!! Wendy's vocals are unreal! She really is one of the best vocalists in Kpop, but Seulgi and Joy are also reallly good!! SM trained these ladies really well!! Wendy reminds me of Kelly Clarkson, also a powerhouse in music!! Mind blown!

[@zikrireveluv8038]

i know right

[@revemochi4998]

no. wendy isn’t ONE OF the best vocalists in kpop, she is THE best and that is on her blonde hair periodt.

[@aestwitzypinkislife4042]

Wendy is the best of 3rd gen, its unbelievable how Joy is just a sub and Seulgi is just a lead

[@choerryknif3191]

@@aestwitzypinkislife4042 ailee is the best

[@choerryknif3191]

@@revemochi4998 ailee is the best one

[@anavillavillaver9816]

red velvet is the reason why my standards on girl groups is high

[@kpopsaywhat9056]

I love Joy's 'yeah yeah yeah yeah' part

[@docrvtrash6133]

RV was even humble enough to say that Immortal Song 2 is too big of a show for them. They really never disappoint. I really like their attitude. They still do their best even after getting famous.

[@goghforth]

Reminder that when JoWenSeul sang this, they were just rookies. And they did it live. I know *mindblown*

[@3doongie517]

wendy will be the next best vocal idol after taeyon

[@Rose0004]

Seulgi is my favorite singer in RV, and Wendy is obviously a powerful singer, but I'm glad Joy was up there with them because she sings EXTREMELY well, too, and she doesn't get as much attention as Wendy and Seulgi. My favorite part was when they all harmonized together! I mean, WOW!

[@wendyson5284]

what do you mean she dont get much attention? in this or in rv?

[@Rose0004]

+wendy son I mean that Joy doesn't get as much attention vocally as Wendy and Seulgi.

[@wendyson5284]

+LunaChick415 ouh i understand now XD

[@eyebrowstj]

Wendy's more than a powerful singer. She can sing anything. She's the best singer in the group and gets less attention than Seulgi and Joy. This fandom is cray cray.

[@stqrsvn]

@Mya joy is actually popular for her vocal tho bc she did ost

[@acciosharpie4441]

Watching Joy here makes me wanna cry cause this was probably the period of time when she hated her voice and when she let haters make her insecure😩😩 You're amazing sweetie you sound amazing here and you always sound amazing💚

[@fuckery276]

seulgi's voice gets me every time

[@miyakakayami3781]

me too

[@Arc1Yuni]

Seulgi gets me even pre-debut lol(SMRookie Era)

[@nelidyalala3482]

OMG RV is REAL VISUAL and REAL VOCAL😍😍😍...when is it guysss???

[@k.l.p.4]

Joy really has a special voice.Ahe is so emotional and unique.Maybe she isn't a perfect vocalist like Seulgi and Wendy but her voice is stil more than just beautiful.It is a hearttouching voice.

[@nafables3626]

I loves the goodbye goodbye goodbye part omg they should make a subunit, JoySeulWen xDD

[@JYODKSSJHPSYNYZJK]

Baby Joy killed me! I really love her voice. Goosebumps Wendy!

[@wansuhailahsukri8935]

I love see our joy face when she is singing because her face is showing how determined she is to sing and work hard to showing a great voice from her and to make sure she don't disappointed her member and fan..i always smile when i look her when she singing that make me soo proud to her and want to meet her to tell her she is doing good job, her singing always improve, also be happy,confident and trust to your self and enjoy when you singing..you are good and great ☺

[@laeafa6784]

SM knows that Joy will get big attention with her sweet voice, bright personality, and cute face too, so, although she is not a part of SM rookies and have the shortes trainee periode, SM keep debuting her

[@invictus8377]

same thoughts here...they should have plan on how to treasure and maintain such pretty, talented and charming lady in Joy. all members of red velvet are talented but Joy has the shortest time training before debuting, they must have seen something in her too, she has a lot of potentials!

[@nganvu2529]

maybe because her house is rick

[@AttyRedV]

+ngan vu what do you mean?

[@laeafa6784]

ngan vu yep, what do you mean btw?

[@constantiamk2708]

i think so..

[@1ok21am3]

I like joy's sweet voice

[@sunshiens]

the rookie rv did that

[@kpopgalaxy4276]

OMG! I can't believe joy can sing! I mean, that powerful voice? Anyways, Seulgi fan here...

[@Endlesslove1974]

Check Joy's cover of Greatest Love of All by Whitney Houston on their Instagram page.

well SM vocalists arent joke like Twice

[@hearteyeskai7735]

+Jarosław Puchacki Don't drag twice into this. They have nothing to do with RV tf.

[@장미-z8t4w]

I shouldn't be laughing omg

[@kenanperez3151]

+Jarosław Puchacki So True 😂😂

[@SomeStranger9]

Wendy looks so pretty here and she doesn't look like she even needed effort to sing like that!

[@eyebrowstj]

Wendy made this look easy! She's amazing!

[@squidxward8450]

@@eyebrowstj ikr

[@maejee8189]

These vocals is no joke. To think they are just starting in the industry but singing like they've been in it for years. SM really producers of best vocals.

[@faewarriors761]

Wendyy is GOALSS like seriously.. she's not breathing #Nowords, and seulgi's voice is sooo UNIQUE 😍 😍 it's my favorite so far, Joy's voice is MAGIC...like her voice is soft BUT CAN BE SOO DEEP

[@missladyhaha]

Joy is just girl with an amazing voice that people don't give enough credit to.

[@huffnpuff3179]

+Lady Haha ikr

[@jazmineoso1129]

They don't let her showcase it enough, now that they have yeri which can rap hopefully joy can sing more

[@pearljay7088]

Wendy really had been in a choir group for this. this was definitely her food and she ate this. This really showed her background as a choir singer. her voice projection just explained it all especially during the high note starting at 3:38 😂 and it's amazing how clear and loud her voice is even when the mic is quite far away from her lips. she really knows how to balance her voice to not overshadow the other members. Imagine if she placed the mic closer, lmao we would be dead already with her voice 😭

[@dingdingding7480]

i hope they bcome a sub unit. they r d next TTS for sure👍

[@miyoungiekr]

I know right~ 🌚

[@dingdingding7480]

Eggy Senpai hey hey hey u found me🌚

[@miyoungiekr]

+wifi ht I've been ur subbie for a long time 🌚

[@neonekeo]

i hate SM for sleeping on these girls

[@YERI-TTY]

team rocket were monster rookies

[@dwikirakandaputra9546]

OMG IT GIVES ME GOOSEBUMPS... RED VELVET SLAY! Idk but I think Wendy is Taeyeon ver. 2.0.

[@lalalalisa1408]

Totally agree!! Wendy definitely has better vocal skills

[@valenyosas]

+SistarBora Wendy doesn't have a better vocal 'skills' at all . What do you mean is maybe vocal tune . Or , their voice . Most likely voice and power . But vocal 'skills' is very wide . Taeyeon is much better in 'skills' but Maybe , what you meant to say is vocal tune.

[@keirorin]

+Valentino Yosarian (ValX) Wouldn't say Taeyeon is that much better than Wendy. They might be on similar levels tbh

[@trinandagilang5187]

+Val Y (Nino) Actually Wendy is a little bit better than Wendy (just a little bit) Technically but we can say that they are equal

[@trinandagilang5187]

+Val Y (Nino) Actually Wendy is a little bit better than Taeyeon (just a little bit) Technically but we can say that they are equal

[@shalimarlynepablo4603]

Almost everyone here talking about Wendy and Joy, yes they're great and we're shookt then I will comment about SEULGI! JJANG!! She harmonized so well with the two!! Complete package! Can dance and sing well!

[@eyebrowstj]

Shalimar Lyne Pablo They all can sing and dance 😄😄😄

[@cinthyacruzado9095]

@@eyebrowstj they can but not as perfect as seulgi, shes the main dancer indeed

[@yesoryes2436]

Yes seulgi can sing well but not as perfect as wendy, she's the main vocal indeed 😝

[@jessacater6421]

And dont forget she's so adorable too. All of them were born VISUALS.

[@hiVyle]

Lol..I know this been years ago but I felt funny to read others comparing the member with one another. They in one team lol..stop comparing for goodness sake. Each of them can sing, dance and born visual..jeeezzz they had their own specialty and colour in singing ok. Wendy sound like WENDY, Seulgi sound like SEULGI and Joy sound like JOY. No member can be like other member. They are uniques in their own talent. Can you just appreciate the song my goodness. Where did the real meaning of music gone lol..people were toxic everywhere now. People need to enjoy music more and this kind of music and their vocal need to be praise. Bravo for them indeed a singer.

[@세라-w1i]

Seulgi the sun☀️ Wendy the moon🌝 Joy the stars🌠

[@beatriz894]

Boy groups stans don't know what they are missing

[@Sizhui-mg6hc]

dazz right, especially the ones who try to look edgy by saying they do not like ggs

[@dr____ove6071]

agreeeee

[@nehalbaldewa4225]

Not really Exo and Btob have amazing vocalists. So I don't what exactly are they missing.

[@beatriz894]

Nehal watch the video again and you will see what I'm talking about, plus female vocals are totally different from male vocals so they still missing something

[@zikrireveluv8038]

agree

[@nandokgg]

I love how joy especialy really cares about getting it right, you can see it on her face, the respect she has for the quality of the job she is delivering to the audience, that makes me respect red velvet so much, even, more. Im tired of so so lives on kpop, pretty faces getting by with half assed voices. Congratulations red velvet

[@jennyuy6057]

fernando martins salute sir! Indeed!

[@mcpremier3544]

THIS IS THE POWER OF RED VELVET'S VOCAL LINE!!!

[@srijayasalim3608]

This video shows me how underrated and underutilized Joy were as vocalist

[@allanacalahatian3621]

still true. until today. she has a beautiful voice but sm just usually gives her lines that don't show off her range. it's disappointing.

[@Lunafreya_Nox]

@@allanacalahatian3621 lol...arent u satisfied that shes now popular in music than wendy. So much hate.

[@allanacalahatian3621]

@@Lunafreya_Nox woa woa, i wasn't comparing them at all. It's just true that her lines don't really show off her range. Wendy is, hands down, the best vocalist in RV. I just feel like SM doesn't utilize Joy's potential that much.

[@dubujoyjennie2691]

Lunafreya Nox Fleuret oof toxic person alert

[@Lunafreya_Nox]

@@dubujoyjennie2691 im not toxic but u all joy selfish bias.are toxic. U only care about joy u dnt care about other members to support ..

[@mahaling23]

the fact that Wendy has vocal nodules(?) but still manages to slay every high note given to her makes me go crazy.. like girl, you're suffering but how can you still kill everyone with your voice?

[@janaaa4652]

wendy hitting the notes like they’re nothing damn

[@AyseIremErdolayseeireem]

maybe joy hasn't strong vocal but she is good at feel the emotion. my tears fall down when joy starts sing.. Our baby Joy, fighting! Red Velvet, fighting!

[@madieferr966]

I didn't know joy could sing this well!!!! joy jang!!!

[@sososahel5860]

Omg joy’s voice is just so amazing and unique. This performance almost made me cry they’re so amazing

[@nataliaconeo]

they sing very good. Joy, You suprised me.

[@heartikn]

It doesn't matter who your bias is, Joy made you cry.

[@rettychaterins2343]

But i dont cry lmao

[@faeyhahah]

joy is my bias but I dont cry 😂😂

[@xav7838]

Ikr , She's so into it!

[@decireedgreat8018]

Isabella Newman same here her voice is full of sadness

[@medstew793]

What a honey voice

[@Password9141]

SM's class... they always send their rookies to immortal song.

[@takenoprisoner42]

I knew Wendy and Seulgi can sing, but I didn't know that Joy was lead vocalist material! damn girl get it

[@kimoh935]

omg i know wendy can hit high notes, but i never know she can compete with davichi. damn gurl, way to go!!

[@Esandeech2]

Oh Kah Giok look up red velvet wendy season of love.

[@milkygguk728]

2015 : Goodbye 5years later... Joy : Hello!

[@dallak93]

Ugh I love Wendy's expression at 4:41 when she looks at Seulgi closing the song. She's like "slay it, babe".

[@sunmiswashingmachine]

dallak93 let’s hope Irene didn’t see how Wendy looked at seulgi 😂😂

[@longminh2759]

@@sunmiswashingmachine woah love triangle

[@sunmiswashingmachine]

@@longminh2759 ikr

[@strtn7976]

or lets be intellectuals nd wenseulrene KSKSKSKSK

[@rizkifitriana7810]

three of them have a beautiful and powerful voice. i was lilbit shocked when joy gave us some high note parts. wendy's voice is the best, but seulgi and joy are the best too 😍

[@juviarain1128]

I’m just getting interested in red velvet these days, falling for these girls more and more after seeing each show

[@Hoid.]

Joy's voice really is one of a kind, so beautiful * . * She still have a lot of improvments to make but she could grow to be an amazing singer!