Red Velvet - Studio vs Live vocals

Hey
This is a short video, theres a big chance it will be taken down but if it does then atleast u know i tried to post. I wasn’t too happy with my opinion video, it became messy and im perfecting it sorry if it’s taking too long.
-----------------------------
All videos are used for entertainment purposes.
All videos and pictures belong to there rightful owners
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, commenting, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favour of fair use.

[@izonexbae]

Hey, read my description it explains alot!

[@JuliaTDI23]

Imma read

[@redredred407]

thanks btw... i read. it

[@foreverinsfired]

Red velvet never disappoints and I actually prefer Wendy’s voice live most of the time as she tends to sounds fuller

[@chrissyalapo-calg9748]

That's cause they're always lowering her voice in the studio😒 they're some songs where you can't even notice her adlibs in the MV but then they perform it live and ppl are like "Wendy had a adlib there?" Or "I think she added that" but nope, it was always there, they just made it really quiet for who knows what...

[@eyebrowstj]

@@chrissyalapo-calg9748 I also notice this. For some reason they try to hide her vocals in the studio. I'll never understand it

[@BubblyBlunt]

The live for dumb dumb was the best one period

[@izonexbae]

They did not come to plaay.

[@eunicenurwinata1904]

The fact that red velvet is the best when it comes to jumpy choreo like dumdumb, rookie, and all of their song (most of their choreo are jumpy) 🤭😅

[@user-qh6ge6py4o]

IKR! I guess it is the dancing that is very difficult and singing at the same time, they have to breathe twice as much,to dance and sing at the same time.

[@littlepeony21]

I really love Dumb Dumb's performances, I feel like that's one of the hardest song to perform but they slayed!!

[@sanspurple5621]

Zimzalabim has the best bridge in kpop

[@time7732]

Ikr i really like it more when is live

[@BEcauseILoveYooh]

Nobody questions Red Velvets vocals. They are the recording studio

[@yoonist]

I love how Wendy’s voice turns deeper live

[@naimaahmed9730]

1:54 Irene and Yeri🤍sound so good they all do they better not disband I need to see them live at least once

[@darthestaaar]

in conclusion red velvet velvet true vocal group wendy best 3rd generation vocalist

[@kspectrum]

i love how they turned the mic to her because girlie can sing

[@jjrmmrrja4535]

The transition in oh boy between the live and the album version is golden.

[@BubblyBlunt]

The Zimzalabim one got me on my knees 😩😩😩😩

[@c3real835]

Joy also have a really pretty voice, she actually sound same as the recorded version

[@JL-jg8tr]

Love all their voices, especially Joy’s tone. However, all together is entirely something special.

[@kissukissu3624]

4:32 the transition is so smoooth, they really eat CDs

[@JuliaTDI23]

They sound amazing both in the studio and live anyways---- Stan RV for a better life

[@wendy9481]

Wendy main vocal ofc.😗

[@shou199]

4:27 Oh Boy is Just gold

[@aiyulee6366]

You know RV also stands for Real Vocal right? I pity people who doubt their magical voice

[@tasvihashaian3191]

Never question SM artists' vocal capabilities

[@regularpotato]

I love hearing red velvet sing. The vocals in all their songs are just amazing

[@eyebrowstj]

I prefer listening to their live vocals! The studio for some reasons doesn't always do them justice. They slay in and out of the studio! My girls 💖💛💎💚💜

[@sswblue]

WENDY 🔥🔥🔥

[@bdzmru8489]

The professors of the encore no doubt are red velvet

[@cc0241]

oh boy is their best live performance, it sounds SO MUCH better than the studio recording, but at the same time the girlies live vocals always sound either the same as the studio recording or better. thats on talent period. we stan queens.

[@xxopxxfan54]

I wish they sung live more often they sound amazing when u can hear the real voices no auto tune or vocal photo shop 🥰🥺 they sound great in the studio as well just need more of red velvets real voices! Edit: Just saw Red Velvet Live at Mik Festival London 2022 and girlies still have live vocal skills

[@izonexbae]

Honestly it has been a new thing this year honestly, before Red Velvet were very consistent and known for still singing live quite alot. But since the debut of aespa all sm groups have been relying on pre recorded vocals

[@xxopxxfan54]

@@izonexbae It's such a shame, whilst I get it that idols sometimes need to rely on backing tracks and so forth it's so frustrating cause there are comebacks where I have NEVER heard the song live even once depsite them performing that song on multiple channels - I wish SM would let us actually hear idk their singing ;-;

[@sanuhh.]

When other groups from other companies lipsynch all the time there’s no problem but when SM artists finally take a break (who knows why) everyone calling them lazy and complaining. This comment isn’t directed to you btw just a general comment

[@xxopxxfan54]

@@sanuhh. I think it's because SM is well know for having artist who can sing live really well and have amazing vocals in general, so inadvertently given this is a major pull factor for fans and the fact a lot of these SM groups are classed by fans as being more "vocal based" than performance based (*questionable classification imo) SM groups are held to that higher standard, which is kind of bs because all idols especially big three/four idol groups have the same if not more so taxing schedules which is why the aforementioned reasons why they lipsynch happens

[@sanuhh.]

@@xxopxxfan54 yup I agree! I think fans who demand live don’t realise that some of these idols have ALOT of schedules. Especially NCT members like mark and Haechan

[@user-tz3hj1vj6n]

Red Velvet definitely is the queens of vocals , all of them can sing very well, they are so popular with their harmonize ,no one can beat their harmonize..

[@ameyyaaa]

Best singer ever seungwanie! 😍💙

[@hwanwoonglee3349]

The rookie encore stage challenge is one that proves rvs vocal technique and stability is amazing

[@allaboutaespa2245]

One of the most powerful and stable vocal group I have ever seen Love my queens

[@vanfangirl2076]

wendy in every clip,,, 💙

[@cherrrryville]

0:34 The moment sub-vocalist just hitting high note, this is SM😎♥

[@redredred407]

wendy at zimzalabim.. just flexing... like thats it?? hahah... dumb dumb album is the best album. when it comes to flexing their superiority when it comes to vocals... i know someone will say hi mamamoo... but there's a big difference on their style.. and the video is about RV. so yes..

[@zapunaru]

haters : if their vocals are stable, they're lypsinc. if their vocals are lousy, they live. but don't forget they are from SM ENTERTAINMENT :)

[@youtubeisntallowingmetocom9062]

Like sis it doesn't matter if they lipsync or not, SM artists do be carrying the entire industry vocally on their backs 😥

[@Emily_fanai]

Even ex-SM trainees who debut in other groups/companies are always different if they have trained long enough

[@ruebze]

Okeyyyy, I think their live is better than the recording one... it has that rawness and dynamics that is missing in the recording version. Yeah, they are Red Velvet.

[@tenleeso10]

They ate, as expected

[@seungwanismyjoy5096]

They're always wonderful in both studio and live version. I actually hope Umpah Umpah to be included. Beside that, very nice work bestie. Hope you make the part two and soon 👍

[@seulkang846]

RV and reveluvs: Pano ba yan edi nag mukha na naman tayong mayabang nyan, kulit nyo kasi eh. 🤣

[@kittyangelzzz6512]

In conclusion, stan RV

[@maritalu]

I'M SO PROUD OF RED VELVET LIVE VOICES

[@notasimplesponge]

i peter their live vocals more than studio version 🤷🏽‍♂️

[@Isa-zk9rs]

vocal queens

[@anetaomar1644]

Queens vocal live

[@c3real835]

They give me serotonin

[@slowtokkii]

I'm living for their live vocals 😭

[@jessajira5272]

psycho live should also be here and hapiness mr removed

[@ejaytangonan13]

In conclusion, stan RED VELVET ❤️

[@BubblyBlunt]

This video is perfectly fine bestie

[@heejinsnose2027]

They ate CD before performing 👁👄👁

[@aps7347]

Because RV = real vocals = real visuals

[@aaliyah410]

I'm working on a report rn while listening to this and I'm literally having goosebumps especially in dumb dumb!! Queens never miss!!!

[@BubblyBlunt]

Not you adding oh boy 😏

[@claudialucia]

I see my girl Joy struggling with that umpah umpah high note. Take care of your voice bb

[@sanuhh.]

To be fair she did it really well during one of their encores. I think she just has a hard time preparing for it since she doesn’t get much high notes, if that makes sense

[@eightwishes4191]

she usually doesn't sing high note before, so i think she tried her best and she nailed lol she looks so proud😂 her vocals improved day by day, her solo album is good too ;D

[@MilSosVoicesSpoken22]

I don't think it was the note itself, but that she's low on breath

[@chrissyalapo-calg9748]

@@MilSosVoicesSpoken22 pretty sure it’s a combination of both. Joy definitely doesn’t have the best breath support and she knows it too, she said she has low stamina and runs out of breath quickly. Also belting D5 was hard for her because she had to sustain the note rather than phrasing it which she has done before. It’s much easier for her to hit it when it’s just “A” but if she has to hold it, “AAAAA” that’s when it becomes a challenge cause it’s way out of her comfort range and she can easily strain on it. I heard her dodge the note many times in their stage performances, she would sing the words leading up to it then suddenly back out and let the mr take over, which is ok cause she doesn’t want to damage her voice.

[@pinkgangsta6157]

Waiting for Red Velvet on Dingo Killing voice

[@oddyseus052692]

it's SM water everyone.

[@whatagreatme]

Best girlgroup ever!

[@cupid-mp6kz]

It's not their fault sound same with studio ver 😝 People always accuse them lipsync lol

[@orvaveenbrink4448]

About the description.. I don't think there's something wrong It's perfectly good as always

[@izonexbae]

10 months too late lol but I appreciate it so much🤍

[@goldenflower7348]

my babies i miss them so much :( ot5❤️

[@seulgisconverseshoestrings]

Thank you for this amazing video. RedVelvet queens of vocals wbk

[@vity9534]

Red Velvet queens will comeback next month❤

[@maedehhamidi7811]

Best girls live

[@yoonist]

Served both wayssss

[@velvetfriend792]

Im waiting for RBB but it not coming lol

[@wakingupinthemorning8240]

I think the closest one would be from Redmare.

[@user-gp4ss3bc5b]

Love is even better 💎 They are impressive as always 🫶🏻✨👑

[@mounirdc5201]

live vocals Queens 💕 hey Ryan I wanna ask about Wendy, did you see her covers in that show ( I forget its name 😅) are there any changes in her techniques or abilities, she sounds the same to me.

[@izonexbae]

She sounds the same, still very impressive her projection was a bit smaller but i bet it’s due to the room she was in haha

[@mounirdc5201]

@@izonexbae aww I'm happy to hear that, hope all the best for her she really deserves the best and just the best ❤, I'm very excited for her solo debut.

[@kspectrum]

zimzalabim supremacy !!

[@xloveee1550]

5 queens in Main Vocal

[@culturedswine4003]

4:55 why did she snap tho?

[@rosesrkjm]

they eat cds for breakfast, lunch, dinner

[@MutiaChoirunnisa]

This is why I adore them so muchhhhhh

[@culturedswine4003]

I’ve heard 4:55 being sung so many times but I NEED to know what the song is called

[@izonexbae]

It’s ‘Oh Boy’ by Red Velvet ofcourse haha

[@andinho6372]

I'm the opposite, i know the song for a long time, but i never seen them performing it live.

[@culturedswine4003]

@@izonexbae thx so much 🙏

[@eternal6257]

@@andinho6372 same 😂

[@sunshineoirepus220]

I never grow tired hearing rv songs... Best kpop group alive. a legend. I hope they get the acknowledgement they deserve. Keep it up girls!

[@ianm271]

#REDVELVETEATSCDS #MYQUEENS #ULTFOREVER ❤💛💚💙💜

[@riffgroove]

Best part of being an RV stan. You don't get humiliated watching your faves do an encore stage and suddenly realize they can't sing an iota.

[@shellen7930]

when sm used to let their idols sing live

[@luckynbunny]

aespa sang live yesterday

[@user-gp4ss3bc5b]

Queens

[@reandykalitouw3484]

Stream queendom

[@Teddy-un5bx]

RV = Real Vocal

[@ksgunzipped355]

Seulgi is so stable 😭

[@LOL-VBE]

anyway stan rv period

[@cherriekookiie]

vocal queensss

[@haylynshon7514]

So much respect for Red Velvet after i tried singing Rookie while dancing 🤣

[@SM-ip8dj]

Redvelvet mamam cd

[@user-gp4ss3bc5b]

💖💖💖💖💖

[@fajarridhaalamsyah8384]

❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@penguinaka8383]

First

[@eiryves8554]

p-p-ppalgamat

[@taeilsays]

can you make one for twice too?

[@izonexbae]

Suree!!

[@izonexbae]

If im done with studying on time i might even be able to post it today aswell!

[@taeilsays]

@@izonexbae omg yaaass! can't wait, but take your time

[@izonexbae]

@@taeilsays heheh i did ittt

[@taeilsays]

@@izonexbae man aren't you something else! 😍

[@JuliaTDI23]

Hi

[@batrinasofiamaries.2939]

What's the title of this song? 4:46???

[@izonexbae]

Oh Boy

[@anhpcy]

last song name?

[@izonexbae]

Oh Boy

[@dianasarinikomang8164]

Sama kan kayak di mv yadahlah gk usah jelekin idol SM mana bisa lulus jd idol dg suara jelek yakali gk dilatih nyanyi sambil dance kalo masih ngos2an blm bs jd idol SM hahaha peace

[@emilysanders5020]

vocal queens