Reeve Carney on His 'Super Poopy' Humor, Liking Older Women & Modeling Speedos on Side by Side

"Spider-Man" star Reeve Carney and Susan Blackwell head to the guitar shop in the latest installment of "Side by Side". Carney dishes about his love of "Cats," what he thought of Miley's twerking at the VMAs and going shirtless on "Penny Dreadful."

[@jnicolebean2468]

He's more attractive when he's playing sociopathic immortal but just as a regular guy he seems so sweetly naive and adorable.

[@catherinemary2098]

Jordan Bean I think he kinda seems sweetly naive in the show too especially in the beginning

[@QUARTERMASTEREMI6]

This is so late, but yeah, he can easily play both sides so well and smoothly! 😍

[@chelspat5920]

If I knew then in 2015 how desperately I would LOVE, "the Dorian Grey guy" NOW in 2022...

[@alieninthecaribbean]

That woman wanted to unlock her jaw and swallow him whole.

[@ssharkbait]

alieninthecaribbean she looks at everyone she interviews like that tbh.

[@gloomyJulia]

Talented, super gorgeous and a little shy = ADORABLE!!!

[@SaturnCrashing]

Reeve is a very handsome human being!

[@StaceyMONeale]

I love how bright red he turns when she starts talking about that dance bell thing. LOL!

[@K3r0411]

He obviously wasn`t just a shy kid, but is still shy. SB must have realized that too, because she was kinda gentle here. She usually stops at nothing.

[@AaronLover85]

He is so cute. She is flirting so much

[@camilelcoyne]

I like to make eye contact with people when I talk to them but damn! She is staring at him to the point of it being very creepy. He's a human being, not a pork chop. I feel very sorry for him!

[@sawsannaser3680]

She makes me feel uncomfortable. I wonder how did Reeve feel while she was starin' at his face, it must be very uncomfortable for him too.

[@chelspat5920]

I seriously need her to STEP BACK 😂😂

[@ASMRyouVEGANyet]

They're actually friends. She's well know in the Broadway scene.

[@TVC15ohoh]

For a guy who's as breathtakingly good looking as he is, he's remarkably unaffected and takes his very good looks in stride. Those eyebrows and eyes - wow. He's going to age well. I'm sure he's used to girls and ladies and guys and men goggling him constantly; he didn't seem uncomfortable with Susan, and all things considered, she handled herself relatively well, despite obviously finding him ridiculously attractive, as I would think most people would. Who wouldn't want to jump his bones? Not that I mean to be lewd or crude. But he's got more going on than just his looks. There's some actual talent - multiple talents, actually - going on. I suspect we're going to be hearing more from this fella in the years to come.

[@soulmistin]

Well, you were right!

[@GabbyAbby]

Hello it’s 7 years in the future and he’s like 38 and I thought this was a new video 😂🎉

[@ASMRyouVEGANyet]

Susan is a well known Broadway interviewer. She's had many interviews with Reeve. So they're actually friends.

[@MyFairDiva]

Daaayyum...he's hot.

[@an9628]

thanks

[@MyFairDiva]

Gamer Pops Lol, you're welcome!

[@an9628]

Dont thank me it just my job to save people when they are in need

[@shadyea]

LOL he's so weirded out by her. She makes me feel uncomfortable too. LOL

[@sawsannaser3680]

Me toooooooooo!! I was like wtf is she doin'

[@Sianpb97]

She’s like stood so close to him and won’t stop looking at his eyes 😂 I mean I know he’s good looking but personal space at one point she jumps in his face and he jumps back away from her 😂

[@ASMRyouVEGANyet]

He's actually not. They're pretty well aquatinted. She's well known in the Broadway scene and has interviewed him before.

[@jjburkk]

Super cool guy. I really like him in penny dreadful. I didn't know he had a band. Great singer and musician. I wish him the best in the future. Nice to see a humble normal guy. And not some freak wierdooooo like so many of the younger people these days.

[@ScionStorm1]

I swear he hasn't aged in 8 years. Is this what happens when your career trajectory goes from playing a superhero to soulless immortal to demi-god?

[@adaj472]

… basically

[@carmenh1839]

I know the interview is just doing her job to keep the interview rolling... but damn, I sure said, "Shut up and just. Let. Him. FINISH." a lot in my mind.

[@bwaybabyrose]

I'm guessing a lot of people im these comments aren't particularly familiar with either Susan's interviewing style or Reeve's general demeanour lol

[@themeltedchocolate]

Right? He didn't seem uncomfortable to me even for a second.

[@biancaenera2500]

Style, she just talks too much.

[@ASMRyouVEGANyet]

Yep. The comments are hating on her but she's well know in the Broadway scene.

[@mel_rose96]

Holy hell is he gorgeous

[@allandraadams8329]

He looks like a mix of Jared Leto and Jeff Buckley

[@iLitAfuseiCantStop]

This is such a great interview. Love Susan Blackwell & so wish I had her job!

[@ASMRyouVEGANyet]

Agree

[@aznezane8992]

WOOOOOW, such an amazing singer and guitar player!!!! nice nice song in the end, the one he's playing and singing. gonna try to find out what song is !

[@evchannel7205]

taylor swift brought me here as well.. he is so handsome..his face is like an angel

[@catherinemary2098]

I love how he talks about how from a young age he liked older women even though his 2 most recent dating rumors are with Victoria Justice and Eva Noblezada who are 26 and 23.

[@bonniemessick8570]

He is living with Eva I think,they are a perfect match.

[@sarahdaniel9912]

Yea he has at least 10 years difference and he's the older one

[@wisco9er536]

I think he just meant he was physically attracted to older girls. He probably fell in love with Eva's personality

[@kimberlyjeanne9456]

He admits his maturity level is 14 yo so he is actually dating older women lol

[@okashi10]

I don't know why the woman doing the interview makes me feel so uncomfortable.

[@breeship]

She IS really really close to him.

[@vw3610]

she's totally flirting with him and it's kinda gross.

[@crystalamma1975]

Yeah...she's a bit too touchy-feely for my comfort.

[@ssharkbait]

she does that with literally every guest. side by side is supposed to be very personal.

[@ssharkbait]

shes actually pretty conservative here. i think its cause they dont know each other outside of it or hung out before filming.

[@jayduke8554]

Good lord I could watch him do anything for hours ❤

[@pedjadjokovic1770]

2.24 HE GOT SCARED!

[@TheGeorgiaRiley]

oh some of you are new to Susan Blackwell aren't you...

[@pinkitydrinkityyas]

whats with her tho

[@helRAEzzzer]

So Susan Blackwell is known for her sexual harassment then?

[@KamuiJJang]

Reeve is blushing when talking about his soon-to-be sex scene so cute

[@joesoria2624]

No wonder he is Dorian in Penny Dreadful. Still looks young.

[@sophistik000]

He was 29 there of course he looks young...

[@iLitAfuseiCantStop]

Reeve Carney is one beautiful, beautiful man...

[@ojj75]

Why do people keep saying Susan Blackwell's being inappropriate? Looks like she's just having fun teasing him. And Reeve's adorable when he blushes aww. :)

[@ASMRyouVEGANyet]

Because they're jealous she got to get up close and personal with him

[@jodybb2151]

Lol he is so uncomfortable. .. she is drooling all over him ...I cant.

[@Daystar311]

Okay, now he's won this old lady's heart. Likes older women, Check. Plays the guitar. Check. Has a sense of humor and can act! Check, check! If I was only 15 minutes younger! (Love Penny Dreadful, btw!)

[@elladrawswell]

WHAT IS THIS TITLE I AUDIBLY WENT "OOP-"

[@gonzalezm511]

Funny how people are talking smack about him and how hes "not even a Broadway performer" to justify why we shouldn't like him. 1. He wouldn't be in Broadway if he wasn't good. 2. I found out about him YEARS ago through his music before all that. Crazy story is that Demi Lovato had a music playlist on myspace when she first came out, and thats how I found Nothing Without You by Carney. I love her for that. I wouldn't have known about Carney had it not been for her, haha.

[@OldRaver]

She wants to see Speedo catalogue of him as a 10 year old???

[@cadencestephens2016]

*says he likes older women* *is 13 years older than his current girlfriend* (Disclaimer: no hate whatsoever, this is strictly supposed to be funny.)

[@orangeswild3699]

Defintely can't be that close now with corona 🤣

[@unecuisse627]

I’ve never cringed so much in my entire life I feel so sorry for Reeves

[@blancheduboisapologist]

Thank GOD. Why must we always wait so long between these episodes?

[@DauwXelfje]

Fuck, his voice is so good. And that woman, is freaking me out a little... I have your nose? Hahahahhahaa

[@liviloo8783]

Ok, he’s beautiful. Just beautiful.

[@feliksnodelman3198]

He seems so sweet!!

[@OldRaver]

He is SO good! Oozing talent!

[@blainevanity6]

I hope she interviews the Hadestown cast in the new season.

[@jeannettecontreras3345]

I came here because of the rocky horror picture show on fox

[@luciamrmota5610]

This is weird... he's everthing I don't like in a man but surprisingly I like him. I like him a lot!! Gorgeous man.

[@vothuclinh]

wait what don't you like? :))

[@lostar92]

She was creepy af no poor Reeve he looked so uncomfortable at points

[@hisashivalentine]

+lostar92 I think he was in on the jokes.

[@Teri0is0Resa]

Have you watched any other episodes of Side by Side by Susan Blackwell? That's her style.

[@sawsannaser3680]

I felt uncomfortable just watchin' her

[@CosmicPsychonauts]

He looks a little like Jared Leto.

[@helenaronan3936]

shit right i thought i was the only one who thought that ;O;

[@handsinknead77]

I agree. First thing I thought of when I heard him sing.

[@kowgyrl]

Same here!!!

[@kowgyrl]

Have any of you watched videos of "Colton Dixon"? I swear that guy looks, acts and kinda sings just like a Jerod!! Pretty weird!

[@theod99]

Jared Thompson and Jeff Buckley

[@taylorwiseman8078]

4:36 That's...not creepy at all. No siree. Okay, seriously, that's a bit messed up. All the people in the comments saying "you're new to her interviewing style", I at the very least hope you would say the same thing about a man interviewing a woman. He seems like he's trying to be very polite but is very uncomfortable at the same time.

[@dominiquepocopio777]

his hair 😭 he always wear those suspenders sjsjsj 2:44 WHAT

[@sadia_xx]

Reeve is soo cute and fit and hot OMG

[@Stepanka1111]

That was such a good interview wow

[@ceruleanmistress00]

Štěpánka Černá did we watch the same interview? He was a good sport but she was just awful. Made the interview so painfully AWKWARD to me

[@Stepanka1111]

Kayla Crockett i think she made it original and enjoyable and i honestly think he had a good time, at least that's the vibe i got from him idk. watch her other interviews, she's so funny, but yeah i guess it's not the type of humour that everybody enjoys

[@YrahSGLH]

Agree! He was nice, she was nice, and they looked like having a lovely time together. I don't understand why people find her awful and creepy.

[@blitzkrieg459]

Your boy Dorian Gray.

[@bluejadeblue]

blitzkrieg459 tru tru

[@OldRaver]

She is constantly just a little too in his space, you can smell how uncomfortable she makes him.. No idea who she is (and don't really care, so please refrain from educating me;) He is adorable - but catch him in Penny Dreadful as Dorian Gray and your pants will hit the floor ladies! (and gents!) SO sexy in that. Absolutely magnetic performance. Is 47 too old?? I think maybe it is :( (just would be wrong)

[@sawsannaser3680]

I could tell that he's feelin' sooooo uncomfortable around her, obviously cuz she keeps on stickin' her face to his, it's kinda creepy tbh

[@misslinda6902]

Why Penn Badgely was chosen to play Jeff Buckley rather than Reeve Carney I'll never know

[@sunflowerkieran8359]

I don't know why everyone keeps saying that the interviewer is all weird and harrassy, I think she's fun. Reeve though is like the most adorable guy ever, plus he's gorgeous and sexy ;)

[@madisonloscalzo5689]

Seeing him tomorrow In hadestown. I could cry

[@robwheelut]

He made the perfect Dorian Gray

[@dontcryangels]

When she did that noise thingy I was like the hell you did

[@1wolfravan]

his cheeks got so red omg

[@onice331]

And that song ended up on the album!!!

[@Pandapoop]

What a coincidence that he liked Victoria from Cats, and now he’s dating a Victoria! 😄

[@ASMRyouVEGANyet]

lmfao! throwing food into another vehicle! I used to do that shit! It's best to do it while turning that way they cant chase you down.

[@nymri8537]

Surprised taylor Swift didn't try to hook up with Reeve...or maybe she did, and he was just smart enough to avoid that train wreck all together. lolol

[@kptoca]

Nymri - are you talking about TAYLOR SWIFT, THE ARTIST OF THE DECADE, put some respect to her name

[@blueyellow8766]

If hollywood ever choose to make a, Death Note, adaptation. They must cast Reeve as Light!

[@ASMRyouVEGANyet]

They already did and it was that kid from Hereditary.

[@annegretoderso]

She's constantly interrupting him. So annoying.

[@cynthiabustamante7646]

Reeve is so cute and hot

[@themeltedchocolate]

Dang people in the comments have never seen a Susan Blackwell interview before huh. Broadway people are just chill, he knows it, she knows it. There isn't this specific fakeness that's in every Hollywood talk show, Jimmy Fallon, Ellen, whoever. She was not making him uncomfortable, calm down people.

[@adozenfinders7013]

He looks so much like Jeff Buckley wow

[@ASMRyouVEGANyet]

+Adozen Finders isnt he doing a biopic on Jeff Buckley?

[@adozenfinders7013]

I read that too I really hope it's true because he would be an a great choice

[@ASMRyouVEGANyet]

Yes he's very talented. Been a fan since snow falling on cedars. I hope he does more music too!

[@adozenfinders7013]

yeah me too I really like his band Carney but it's been forever since they released new stuff

[@ASMRyouVEGANyet]

+Adozen Finders yeah they're really good! hopefully they make more music when their schedules sync up.

[@eleanorm5080]

What is that song?! I can't find it at all, and it's awesome.

[@oemisc2880]

Song is called Father's House & included in his latest album Youth Is Wasted.

[@Ninjaorchdorkwithcat]

godbless this vid >w

[@MissAnitaManbadly]

That song at the end was sickening! Love love love it.

[@ASMRyouVEGANyet]

Sickening?

[@catherinemary2098]

Okay so right now I’m this clip he looks like he’s maybe 28/29 but in the show he looks younger than Eva and I just don’t get it cause I’m actuality he’s 36 and she’s 23.

[@katiek4538]

This woman is the stuff of nightmares...

[@julianregis8608]

Why is everyone creeped out by her?!

[@cherrywhiskey]

Julian Regis because she’s all up in his face, doesn’t respect his personal space, and stares into his soul way too much

[@ASMRyouVEGANyet]

@@cherrywhiskey they're actually friends. This is her interview style. She's well know in the Broadway scene. Just look her up. He's just fine.

[@peachykeen545]

hey gerard he dressed like orpheus when he was doing spider man lol

[@maerkstrongrock6984]

Jared Leto and James Franco had a baby?

[@1346790kate]

At 6:16 she touches his knee!!!! Hahahha he is hot!!!

[@ramonawinchester9979]

most people here thinking: too bad that he's interested in older women lol XD

[@shannonclarkey]

My god I have missed this

[@wreningber]

I just wanted to put his hair behind his ear throughout this video.

[@andyroo9381]

Does Reeve Carney realize how sexy he is? GEEEEEZ!

[@bluejadeblue]

THE TAYLOR VIDEO I HAD NO IDEA OMF

[@YesPleaseMuse]

That song was so good! Does anyone know it? Was it an original song?

[@VankVank]

can someone tell me the name of the song he sung? 😍😍😍

[@melaniegonzalez5104]

Reeve 💏

[@TheHelloJuli]

What's the name of the song at the end? Anyone know?

[@typingnoises]

she needs to get out of his personal spaceeee

[@sophistik000]

She's like a powerful, funny dragon and he's like a poult. It seems like she could eat him in one bite and she would like to do this. I liked this interview

[@FaiGal]

Dammit! Boy Y U So Cute?! 😍😍😍

[@TheSarna8]

very hotttttttttttttttttttttt!

[@Lindsey32593]

I love the song he sings at the end! What is it called?

[@jenniferbarlow8519]

Father's House

[@ZoraTheberge]

lift? I meant lick!

[@georginatilly-scholes2069]

Omg he was gonna say something about the video omg

[@dimiocto]

I missed Susan Blackwell

[@dv9096]

Taylor swift brought me here!

[@sallyannecollins4518]

WOW 😍

[@limamov]

REEVE CARNEY is sUch Talent g0rgeoUs guy!!

[@fernandobs177]

11:12 Lmao

[@mireillekang3780]

That woman is harassing him.

[@urlittlewindmill]

He’s so hot omd

[@thevrilpill]

kind of reminds me of jeff buckley

[@marinaxlove]

Wow did you know he had been cast to play Jeff Buckley in a biopic when you wrote this? You’re spot on if not.

[@markar6]

i think she s hitting on him.... but who wouldnt anyway!?