Top 11 Disney Remakes That Could Work - Nostalgia Critic

[@crpgdungeonsdragonsnight]

The joke with Belle in the count down is she sings less and less before exploding. In the end she barely sings "There" before the explosion.

[@Nicrocon]

You wouldn't have noticed because you kept skipping it, but the transitions with Belle kept getting shorter and shorter as the video went on with the explosion cutting Belle off sooner with each number. It was a really funny detail I wish you would've seen, as it highlights making fun of the bad singing in that movie by giving it less time to be heard.

[@MovieFan1912]

I missed the days when multiple people reacted to the Nostalgia Critic. I wish there were more of these, and not just Nate alone. It just isn’t as fun.

[@Naiverine]

i felt this too

[@SJ_RANKS]

The reason Doug was at his house was because the studio suffered water damage from a storm

[@TheBlackfox730]

i was so mad about what they did to lion king. Aslan from the lion, the witch, and the wardrobe, was done perfectly. They could've just done that or made them look less realistic

[@megamarsonic]

Kate’s face when Belle blew up the first time was absolutely perfect. 😂

[@HB-fq9nn]

I honestly think Doug has some good ideas in this video. Especially Atlantis. I feel like that film would work wonderfully in a live-action movie.

[@jcj268]

Cole Sprouse would be perfect as Milo

[@sebastianemond5313]

​​@@jcj268 I know some have said they'd want Tom Holland and Zendaya for Milo and Kida, but I think there are others that could fit Milo better. Like Dylan O'Brien from Maze Runner. Besides, sometimes Tom Holland isn't always the best pick for movies outside of Spider-Man, especially after Uncharted (2022). Don't get me wrong, I love Tom Holland, and his movies aside from Spider-Man have been good too, like The Impossible or The Devil All The Time, or Onward. But yeah, Mark Wahlberg, or let's face it, Nathan Fillion at their current age, had more believability as Nathan Drake than Tom. Also, if they do have the "surprise villain" in an Atlantis remake, make him someone with ties to the ancient civilization, who wants to use the Crystal or *Heart of Atlantis* to rule or destroy the surface world. You know, like Mark Hamill's Muska from Castle in the Sky, who had ties to Laputa, the floating city.

[@jcj268]

@@sebastianemond5313 true but have you seen Cole’s Milo costume? He looks exactly like him

[@georgeeastwood6930]

@@sebastianemond5313 someone else I could imagine as Milo is Nick Robinson from “Love, Simon”.

[@coopercane500]

This is my idea for fixing the villain in Atlantis. Make him a mirror to Milo. Have him be someone obsessing over the civilization and desperate for validation. Make him like the villain in Up where he goes from discoverer to selfish monster who will stop at nothing to bring back his trophy. Let him be a warning to Milo of someone he could become.

[@BlueRoseWolfie]

That's actually a really good idea

[@LittleBlueReviews400]

Yes Finally More People And Not Just Nate Reacting To Something Nostalgic Critic!!!

[@deshawnedwards6412]

I know right? That have honestly been frustrating me. These guys use to watch NC as a group not just one guy. As a group you get more than just one opinions.

[@LittleBlueReviews400]

@@deshawnedwards6412 Exactly!

[@jcj268]

They should react to the NC’s review of Devil its hilarious

[@LittleBlueReviews400]

@@jcj268 agreed

[@jcj268]

@@LittleBlueReviews400 thank you

[@jakobmata7011]

A Live-Action Treasure Planet would sound so fun to watch

[@stephano1019]

Yes! I am honestly surprised Doug didn't put that on the list

[@jakobmata7011]

@@stephano1019 I have heard from other channels say that could be either a Live-Action Movie or Series

[@TheSpectator7]

Disney already made two Treasure Island live action movies, one with the muppets too

[@spider-423]

I love Nate's cheerful sense of glee, I hope he gets more people to react to nostalgia critic.

[@charliecomer6001]

50:12 funny thing is if you pay attention, the explosion comes a little bit faster throughout the video.

[@MonstrumAsylum]

48:13 I feel like for a brave remake they should put in some Scottish mythology like make angus secretly a kelpie or even the black horse, make the side enemies bogels, red caps, Stoor worms, or even Nuckelavees that are under ruled by Moordu

[@benschultz1784]

Disney recently re-upped their licensing with Lloyd Alexander's estate for The Chronicles of Prydain as a miniseries for Disney+ There's a guy named Bryan Seeker who does fancast videos for certain movies and series. He even predicted the actress for Katara in the Netflix Avatar reboot. Who he cast for an Atlantis remake are good, especially Clancy Brown as Rourke, Christopher Lloyd as Whitmore, and John Tuttoro as Vinny.

[@georgeeastwood6930]

That guy should be a casting agent!

[@danielscott5673]

32:16 lyrics from The Three Caballeros: We're three caballeros Three gay caballeros They say we are birds of a feather lyrics from DuckTales 2017 reboot: We're three caballeros Yes, three caballeros They say we are birds of a feather lyrics from Legend of the Three Caballeros: We're three caballeros Three brave caballeros They say we are birds of a feather Gay = The term originally meant 'carefree', 'cheerful' or 'bright and showy'. The word 'gay' dates back to the 12th century and comes from the Old French 'gai', meaning 'full of joy or mirth.' It may also relate to the Old High German 'gahi', meaning impulsive. i googled it.

[@ARCtheCartoonMaster]

Funny you mention that, as the Esperanto language has two words derived from the English _gay,_ but the different meanings thereof - _gaja_ meaning “merry/cheerful”, and _geja_ meaning homosexual. The former is based on the English spelling but pronounced “guy-a”, while the latter is based on the English pronunciation.

[@hiddendesire3076]

It’s not a Disney film, but picture it, Road to El Dorado. Especially with their musical numbers.

[@hiddendesire3076]

38:53 Said it on his video, but, what if he was hired by the guys that ran out on Milo at the start, still have Cookie and the others “betray” Milo and the others as they were spies for him, broadcasting their location so the other team could stalk them, but still have them redeem themselves in the end.

[@wokenlunatic2849]

My Brave Fan Cast: Merida: Karen Gillan (she’s Scottish and she got Red Hair) The Dad: Ewan MacGregor The Mum: Tilda Swinton Mor’du: Drew McIntyre The Witch: Julie Walter

[@ARCtheCartoonMaster]

Funny you mention that, as Tilda Swinton was the original casting choice for Professor Trelawney in the _Harry Potter_ films, but turned down the role as she had bad memories of boarding school, so the role instead went to Emma Thompson, a.k.a. Queen Elinor.

[@jordanhunter3375]

For addendum, Doug is a big fan of Batman: The Animated Series

[@CassieJo]

Disney's The Black Cauldron was based off of a mashup of the first two books of the Chronicles of Prydain by Lloyd Alexander. The first volume was called The Book of Three, and the second volume was The Black Cauldron. Quite a bit of the story was on point, but there is a LOT of stuff missing, including my favorite character, Gwydion. He's the prince of the story that actually knows what he's doing and Taran's really a brat for the most part, like in the movie. Some appearances of the characters that DO appear in the movie don't make sense. Gurgi, in the books, feels more like an orangutan or gorilla type character (to me) and Eilonwy's still a princess, but she's only half-human. Her father is what was known as the Sea-King. Her mother was from a long line of sorceresses, called the Royal House of Llyr. Now, Fflewddur Fflam, the rather bumbling old bard, in the book was a much younger and spry man with a hair full of yellow hair that looked like the rays of the sun. Turns out he was a king of a northern kingdom who wanted to give up that life to be a bard. Seems he wasn't good at being either. Dallben in the books looked more like Gandalf or Dumbledore, and there was another man living with him and Taran at Caer Dallben who was a blacksmith named Coll, a bald man who actually was a hero and his claim to fame was that he saved the oracular pig Hen-Wen from Annuvin, the book's Mordor if you will, where she was being held captive by the Horned King and the Dark Lord Arawn, king of Annuvin. In the movie, the Horned King and Arawn were mashed together into one character. The Black Cauldron didn't show up until the second book. Neither did those three hags, Ordu, Orwen, and Orgoch.

[@itzorin600]

Emma Watson singing sounds like somebody wrote that and speech text and it's really sad that the original voice of Belle did a really good job Emma Watson sounds like a robot when she sing😅

[@shiro-kun5604]

Okay, so this is really hilarious to me, given your work to skip it every time, but while I was watching the review, I just let the song play out until I eventually noticed a funny little trend. He was actually having the explosion occur earlier and earlier within the song as he went from 11 to 1. At first I thought I was just getting so sick of the song that I was imagining it, but then, after a bit, I realized "nope, it actually IS happening sooner". If you rewatch it, keep an eye out for that. XD

[@Valentin_126]

Although it isn't a Disney movie Disney now owns the property since they acquired Fox, and I think that Anastasia could use a remake. The original is good but it has some questionable decisions, like the bat character and the jarring editing. It would very much be an adult focused film, but it would be great for actual live-action since most of the characters are human and the movie takes place in a human environment, the city, the train, the wilderness, the boat, all very much doable without CGI though it would probably be needed to give that 1920s/1930s look to buildings and whatnot. And I can only imagine who would play Rasputin, who easily has one of the best villain songs in all of animation history.

[@nikkivillemaire4855]

OMG! Nate and I had same reaction to Atlantis The Lost Empire! One of (and still is) my favorite movies growing up along with it's sequel "Milo's Return". Of the characters, I would like to see who managed to get to play Audrey; I loved her character in both movies.

[@av_8596]

*Alright!* It's always good to see y'all react to Nostalgia Critic videos. Hopefully, y'all will react to the *Lackadaisy pilot* next!

[@slashermaster28]

26:30- I find it funny he said this considering in his Disneycember review, he complained about the giant being able to shapeshift being unnecessary for a being who's already amazing by simply existing.

[@CassieJo]

Also, I also thought that the submarine in Atlantis: The Lost Empire felt like it was on par power-wise overall feel with the Nautilus from League of Extraordinary Gentlemen. Captain Nemo's side of things always felt like Atlantis fare to me. If only they did that movie so much more like Atlantis than the LXG we got. It had SO much potential, and most of the characters on the team were great...well...except for Tom Sawyer, who literally had nothing to do and no talents, Alan Quartermain, who was talented but had a problem with women, and Dorian Grey, who was just a d!ck. Mina, Dr. Jekyll/Mr. Hyde, Captain Nemo, and Skinner the Invisible Man were pretty great.

[@0ne0nlyLarry]

41:42 As we all know he sadly passed away And Bushmaster actually somewhat did play Dr. Facilier (Baron Samedi) in American Gods

[@sorenthefilmbrony]

32:42 Then again, the Pinocchio remake kept the "actor's life is gay" line, so they might not have to change it with Three gay Caballeros.

[@sammyt7981]

Have you thought of actually meeting Doug Walker in person and actually think about doing a collaboration with him not in your videos, but in his videos like you can ask him if you can appear in his videos

[@jamesmoyner7499]

Now to be fair to Prince and the Pauper Disney did do a live action television film back in the 60’s.

[@MusicGirl881]

Video starts at 7:30

[@matthewelliott7294]

Thanks Caleb the Calebman! CALEB FOREVER!

[@themoviehound8033]

Nate: Disney will never do a R-rated movie Deadpool: Let’s fix that, shall we? MARVEL STUDIOS’ DEADPOOL III: COMING 2024 Kevin Feige: “It’s amazing. And we’ve got Hugh Jackman coming back for our first Deadpool film within the MCU. That’s our first R-rated film.

[@camos117]

A black Calderón remake would be really good with a 3d cgi mix for the main cast of characters, but have the villains, and monsters be done in a horror claymation tim burton style.

[@cleverpsyche115]

Beauty and the Beast did initially have a practical suit for the Beast, but I guess it didn't work for them so they went all CGI. Personally, my favorite live action "remake" is Cruella, it's easily the most original and stylish of them.

[@MusicGirl881]

Atlantis the Lost Empire Live Action I could see it visually being amazing. Also me and my friends had discussions about a live action Princess and the Frog and we talked about having the cast from the animated to be the live action cast

[@benjm03]

I had a bunch of the Mickey Mouse movies on vcr as a kid, and looking at some of these brings back nostalgia.

[@scotthamp384]

When Disney did the reboot of DuckTales, they brought José and Panchito back and they did switch the lyrics from "Three gay caballeros" to "Yes, three caballeros"

[@Shuichisaihara5499]

Ever since I checked out Ronpa and friends, I fell in love with the calbaeros. Especially my man José. That suave parrot

[@RandomMarcus92]

Actually, they already are making a Live-Action Hunchback of Notre Dame! Josh Gad Gal Gadot Chris Evans Peter Capaldi Imelda Stauntan Jack Black Kelsey Grammar & Chelsea Baron Cohen

[@danielscott5673]

well, Gal Gadot, i really like her, she sings fine in 'A Place Called Slaughter Race' in 2018's Ralph Breaks the Internet, but in 2020, she gained backlash for her 'Imagine' cover youtube video. on top of being casted as Cleopatra, which divided people, it's best not to cast her in the hunchback remake.

[@danielscott5673]

54:30 film divisions that Disney released rated R movies: Touchstone Pictures. Hollywood Pictures. Miramax Films/Dimension Films. 20th Century Fox/20th Century Studios. Fox Searchlight Pictures.

[@Lucasrobe]

There's a live action movie that just came out called Quasi. Its not made by disney though. Its a satire movie though by broken lizard so in the same vein as their other movies like Super Troopers

[@Cynim]

HEY!! Belle being blown up was awesome. Especially that the singing grows shorter and shorter :P

[@Gambini_93]

27:37 Beavis and Butthead 🤣🤣lmao haha

[@chenstormstout9456]

There is a live action Atlantis. It’s called Stargate.

[@Wolf_Dominic]

Yeah, the joke with the transition was that each time it played, it was a little bit shorter.

[@GraveDigger35]

52:27 It's Tom Hooper that's directing the live action Hunchback movie

[@sebastianemond5313]

Oh dear... Here's hoping they get Frollo right. I'd so like to Peter Capaldi in the role, but my guess with the history of past castings, it would be someone like Ian McKellen, which I feel wouldn't fit him. Speaking of Tom Hooper, if he ever directed a remake of *Oliver!,* what're your thoughts on Geoffrey Rush playing Fagin?

[@GraveDigger35]

@@sebastianemond5313 idk, never saw that movie, so I don't know who you're talking about lol 😅

[@sebastianemond5313]

​@@GraveDigger35 *Oliver!* was a musical take on Oliver Twist. They made a movie about the musical back in 1968, featuring Ron Moody, Oliver Reed, and Shani Wallis. The only most recent notable adaptation I can recall is the one with Rowan Atkinson, or Zazu, as Fagin.

[@GraveDigger35]

@@sebastianemond5313 and that's why, i'm not the biggest fan of musicals, so i'm the wrong person to ask about that

[@Not_Soundwave]

As much as I would love to see Atlantis make a comeback, I unfortunately don't trust Disney as it is today to stay faithful 😅 (same with Treasure Planet)

[@stormshadowproductions1660]

Please do NC Tarzan, game theory Yoshi's identity crisis and food Theory is a hotdog a sandwich

[@CaptainCat101]

That'd be cool

[@stormshadowproductions1660]

@@CaptainCat101 which one

[@CaptainCat101]

@@stormshadowproductions1660 any of them

[@stormshadowproductions1660]

@@CaptainCat101 which one would you like to see first

[@wokenlunatic2849]

What they Should do (and this not technically have to be a “Disney” Thing) is make a Horror Movie Spinoff version of Lion King (Especially, Scar as The Monster, like maybe Scar would be a Lion that is Bloodthirsty and it’s Skinny and Boney with Razor Sharp Dagger-Like Claws and Teeth that Slaughter both Humans and Animals, even Lions)

[@alexwashere1601]

Nic just gained a lot of respect from me I LOVE SLEEPY HOLLOW.

[@ace6151]

28:37 Nice Frame to pause on there Nate! XD

[@danielscott5673]

2:00-2:46 Also Sprach Zarathustra from 2001: A Space Odyssey and Bohemian Rhapsody by Queen, the tracks Doug played on the player.

[@paperfox19]

black cauldron and hunch back live actions could benefit from a hard R

[@sidneyrester6100]

josh gad is producing the live action hunch back of notre dame movie remake

[@CircuitReborn]

Surprised he didn't say treasure planet.

[@wokenlunatic2849]

I got one: a Live Action Gravity Falls (get The Guy who made Stranger Things and that would an Awesome Dark Supernatural Movie waiting to happen)

[@CineFunStudios]

57:06 an R Rated Disney Movie would be cool but there’s one problem, THE STANDARDS AND PRACTICES DEPARTMENT!!!

[@CaptainCat101]

Doug had some great ideas, but I draw the line at remaking A Goofy Movie

[@1805movie]

You should watch YMS's _Lion King_ (2019) review. He goes into great detail as to why the remake is horrible, and why the original still holds up.

[@simple-commentator-not-rea7345]

Hear me out. An idea about "Meet the Robinsons" What if they were like Rick's family in Rick and Morty, only without the disfunctionality, toxicity, and cynicism? Imagine like, a supportive and loving family like The Adams Family, BUT with the crazy inventions of Rick? Maybe none of the dimensional travel stuff, but just inventions that are almost too good and can backfire?

[@potrelviewer9536]

I'd totally be down for a revisitation of The Black Cauldron. The original 1985 movie was just a hodge-podge of the five Prydain books, not focusing on barely anything coherent, yet had decent animation and a terrifying villain, although very flat. For this live-action pick, I'd have three conditions to be somewhat good: _ bring back Tim Burton as the artistic director _ if a movie isn't enough to cover the lore of Prydain, then fine, make it a series _ that one's a little extra, but have all the non-human characters done in stop-motion with Laika Studio at the animation part.

[@danielscott5673]

i don't know on what i think on disney's upcoming live-action remake of hunchback. if they do the live-action remake of Disney's Hunchback of Notre Dame and may possibly screw it up/ruin it, i'll probably say it here (on record here as of 4-25-2023), "be careful what you wish for."

[@danielscott5673]

25:58 nate, you just made a reference to NC's 'Top 11 Most Awkward Christopher Walken Moments' vid. also, have kate watch it, please.

[@jordanhunter3375]

28:07 You're actually thinking of the sequel, An Extremely Goofy Movie, with all the skateboarding

[@GuardianGrarl]

I was waiting for your reaction to Doug's idea of *fitting transition* here... I think your transitions (even if you had none) would have been better.

[@sebastiantrias1529]

I’ve seen his video, and I believe he took some ideas from you guys from your reaction to his reviews.

[@wokenlunatic2849]

I can see a Life Action Robin Hood Movie 🦊 (maybe even have a Hybrid between Disney’s Robin Hood with Robin Hood from The Books, makes it both Funny and Dark because Disney’s Robin Hood Film was kinda short and I want to make it longer)

[@WraythSkitzofrenik]

For me, Mowgli was interesting because they actually put in elements from the source material. Kaa was a mentor, not a villain!

[@jackmack4181]

Ok here me out, Live action treasure planet with jason beghe as John silver

[@bridgettherose609]

Maybe a Hunchback remake could work if they just film the stage musical and put it on Disney Plus like they did with Hamilton

[@jtherealmccoy5309]

Andrew Garfield as the lead in Atlantis live action

[@antoined799]

Hope you do Nostalgia critic lion king remake review next!

[@MajinnTheBlack28]

You should have Kate react The Hunchback of Notre Dame with the Nostalgia Critic

[@zachariousmccool5768]

I agree with some of these.....but for me.....if I ever wanted a live remake (though CGI would have to be used) is......"The Sword in the Stone" I LOVE that movie and if they remade it I would be ecstatic....as long as they didn't try to force in more conflict where it doesn't belong.....but the final battle with Merlin and the witch (been so long I can't remember her name) would be sooo cool.

[@jamesmoyner7499]

Madame Mim

[@zachariousmccool5768]

@@jamesmoyner7499 aaaahhhh right right thats her name....sorry, haven't seen it in like 17 years now and unfortunately I don't own it yet on dvd/blu ray since I haven't seen it in stores

[@Sleepingcatstudios]

the bell explosion gets faster as the review gose on

[@-zerxvil-5208]

34:38 No.5 They have great dark skin Disney Princess like Atlantis, Princess and the frog and El Dorado, but why they wanna replaced our redheads? Ariel, The Flash's wife, "MJ" in Spiderman etc... And that's not enough for them, they even backwashing Tinkabel too? What's wrong with this "awaken" people?

[@ARCtheCartoonMaster]

Old-school Donald sounds like the “Maow!” cat that circulated KZbin recently.

[@-zerxvil-5208]

8 - 6 i think it should stick to just being a cartoon.

[@wokenlunatic2849]

If there was a Live Action Disney Hercules Film, I think I know would be perfect as Hades (Micheal Keaton)

[@Excalibur-Sonic]

Atlantis and Treasure Planet for me.

[@vamphunterdlover]

I think this is the longest video they have done for a reaction that WASN’T a livestream play through! 😮

[@axelnilsson5124]

Their reaction to fox kids is longer

[@nathanspradlin8570]

If you guys reviewing Nostalgia Critic again, may I suggest reacting to their Fanscription episodes

[@wokenlunatic2849]

If they ever do a life action Three Caballeros Movie, I can see have a Donald Duck, José Carioca and Panchito Pistoles as a Life Action Humanoid Birds and put in some Mexican Mythical Fantasy in it to make it breathtaking amazing and epic)

[@matthewscorner2990]

There are some remakes that have already been made that I think should be remade again and given a different treatment. We should get either an animated or live action interpretation of the book As Old As Time, which is a retelling of Beauty and the Beast following the twist of Belle's mother being the enchantress. They do a lot of interesting stuff with it. It has a few problems, but it's my favorite version of the story. The Lion King is one that I think a few main changes should be made, then maybe you could shift the mood and other plot points around these changes. A few minor points being that I think Mufasa should stay angry at Simba for at least the rest of the night after saving him from the hyenas, I think they should change the Hakuna Matatta song to sing about Timon's past instead of Pumba's, Nala attacking Simba should end with her about to kill him and only stopping when she hears Timon and Pumba call out his name. Then she would run off in shock and shame while they healed him and slowly come back to try to talk to him, where they would reconnect and they would learn about how their lives have changed. Following from that point, skip Can You Feel the Love Tonight. When Timon says "Whatever she has to say, she can say in front of us, right Simba?" Have him agree and tell her they're trustworthy. Make her spill Scar's wrongdoings in front of everyone. I also think their argument could touch on a few points. Also, something you pointed out when watching Nostalgia Critic review the original Lion King, have the hyenas physically block the lions from helping Simba when he's being backed off the edge of Pride Rock instead of them standing around watching. I also think it might be an interesting change to have it so Scar views the hyenas as his real family instead of the lions. Maybe he finds more comfort in him, maybe they genuinely grow to like him and he genuinely grows to like them in turn, but he's also so full of himself that when he becomes king, it starts to slip and he's more inclined to throw them under the bus in the climax. Also, maybe have them show the effects of Simba's lifestyle on his body. He's happy and carefree, but his body is no longer as capable of hunting or fighting as it should be. He's been living the equivalent life of a zoo lion as opposed to a free lion. Hence why he loses to Nala and why he's on even footing with Scar, who admits he's significantly weaker than Mufasa. These are just some minor ideas that, put together and fleshed out more, I think could be a good start to making an interesting remake.

[@danielscott5673]

i mostly just agree on the book As Old As Time stuff you said. that book's better than the live-action remake.

[@jedijack0577]

Every remake had something I liked, Jude Law in Peter Pan and Wendy and the twist involving hook, the story behind Belle’s mother, Tom Hanks in Pinocchio, there’s more I like but there are more cons than pros, I’ve said this many times, I’m giving these a chance, but if they fail Hunchback of Notre Dame, I’m done watching them

[@RandomManIncorperated]

After Dumbo Burton Flat Out Said He Won't Work With Disney Ever Again. Sooooo No Chance of That Happening Anytime Soon

[@calebmaybin6896]

There's plenty of old Nostalgia Critic videos he hasn't done yet ... unless he's seen them already. At the least he could have the others with him watching him.

[@CLDJ227]

I thought he was gonna make treasure planet number one. You could easily see a pirates of the caribean type film made with that 🤔.

[@wokenlunatic2849]

If they do a Brave Live Action Film (firstly who say that it have to be a Disney Film?, *MAKE IT INTO A DARK FANTASY FILM!* ) I like to see Scottish Mythology Creatures in The Film (like Nessy/ The Loch Ness Monster 🦕 or Kelpie The Water Demon 🐴)

[@wokenlunatic2849]

And how Dark I want The Life Action Brave? (The Game of Thrones + The Witcher in a Scottish World, I haven’t watched Game of Thrones but I kinda know how Dark it get)

[@danielscott5673]

i rather they do prosthetic makeup and costuming like on quasimodo than use painfully obvious cgi faces. then again, look up 'Best Quasimodo' from VC Andrews Critiquer's vid of Old vs. New: The Hunchback of Notre Dame.

[@radzilla1357]

Nice to see some more nostalgia critic reactions, hope you guys see his puss in boots 2 reveiw. Aside from NC, you guys think you can check out Doobus Goobus.

[@BlueRoseWolfie]

Warning long comment ahead, got too invested in this reaction lol I agree a lot with your points on the "live action" stuff. When it comes to Emma Watson in Beauty and the Beast, I have my own view on it. The CGI Beast wasn't bad, I enjoyed his own song, his style and look. For me Emma Watson was not the best singer. The first song that is usually where Belle is introduced, that is my favorite and I am super particular on how someone sings it. Emma, though she can hold a note and does better in later songs, could not handle the song. The rest of the cast did wonderfully, she sort of felt flat and weak in her singing. Someone with stage experience would be good to do that song. She should of trained with that a bit to express herself more. As for her reacting to the CGI Beast, it could of been better but if it wasn't for the singing I would be fine with it. I agree with Nic on A Goofy Movie, I feel its perfect on its own. Now a new movie with similar style based on modern times would be awesome. Nolan's idea with something real being there for CGI to be put on top should exist for everything. Best idea. Atlantis I full on agree, though I enjoyed the "surprise" bad guy. It would make sense someone would want to steal from the people their power source to make money. That is real world with how many bad people are out there. Plus his glow before he died was super cool. I also agree for Princess and the Frog, though I am completely fine with Tiana turning into a frog herself. For me that meant she was forced to slow down and relax/take a break. Realize the other stuff is just as important. It was a good lesson. Besides that I completely agree. Also agree on Brave, and sorry Nic, I have hair very similar to Merida. Mine is more a mix of Merida and Moana. Which is why I keep it no longer then shoulder length lol. I need to watch Black Cauldron/read the books lol And YES, I was hoping they chose Hunchback of Notre Dame! One of my favorite Disney movies that I always hoped for a live action remake. I would watch the in disney play so much and love the interaction with the audience. I still prefer the animated ending over book, but hey if they make it good then yay!

[@sebastianemond5313]

12:25 - 12:42 Nostalgia Critic: "Did you just make up the word *s--tily?* "

[@wokenlunatic2849]

The other person that kinda do like Angry Nerd and Nostalgia Critic and his name is Linkara who do Comics (you guys you react that it was funny)

[@takeshikujo2909]

10:58 Uh~, what’s live action about it? Disney: The ground.

[@SJ_RANKS]

I do like the 1996 live action 101 Dalmatians sure it’s basically just home alone with dogs but at least there’s effort with it and it made me laugh my ass off even the sequel in 2000 was pretty good. But the newer ones are just lazy and Pinocchio is just a Robert zemeckis cgi tech demo I’d like to know what happened to Robert zemeckis he made back to the future and who framed Roger rabbit and then he decided to become obsessed with the uncanny valley

[@nickthedreamer4434]

Technically, they already have changed the "Three Gay Caballeros" line in the 2017 DuckTales reboot so, sorry, but you're a little late on that idea.

[@shannonbohan4979]

lackadaisy pilot reaction Please!

[@matthewjarek3026]

Hey Nate, when are you gonna react to Nostalgia Critic's Animated Titanic Trilogy? Those have been requested for quite a while now.