Response to Yasir Qadhi "Unrepentantly Reveals ALL!" Podcast

Response to Yasir Qadhi "Unrepentantly Reveals ALL!" Podcast
Listen on Soundcloud: / s-m19wx
Podcast: itunes.apple.c...
Please support Ilmstitute:
Patreon: / ilmstitute
GoFundMe: www.gofundme.c...
PayPal: www.paypal.me/...
Social Media:
Facebook: / brothersaajid
Twitter: / saajidlipham
Instagram: / ilmstitute

[@SK-ix8jb]

Will Einsteinian physics be enough for Yasir Qadhi or is he gonna progress to Quantum Physics and compare it to Allahs unchangeable religion

[@hamzazulfi]

Shaffique Kausar lol. Good one. I literally thought about that.

[@hamzazulfi]

@@bigfish819 A bad one at best. Shaffique is also giving example of quantum physics btw.

[@mohammedahmad8039]

1. I don’t remember Dr Qadhi suggesting going to western countries to learn about established Islamic sciences such as Fiqh and Quran Tafsir...etc instead he explicitly said western muslims problems need to be addressed by western muslim scholars who understand context better than a middle eastern or a Pakistani scholar. He explicitly referenced Ibn Alqayim talking about the importance of understanding the cultural nuances related to the Fatwa. Under this understanding I understood his reference to Newtonian and Einstein physics which to me means for example a fatwa ruling given in an islamic majority country ruled by a king or Shaikh (one set of circumstances) cannot be implemented in a western democratic country (a different set of circumstances) where Muslims are a very small minority ruled by someone like trump and are targets of islamaphobia. Therefore, a well educated western scholar is better suited to give the Fatwa. 2. The issue of Yale vs Madina is taken out of context. The reference to learning how to learn in an ivy league university is not elitist. If anything I personally enjoyed Sajid’s interviews with Daniel Haqiqatu and I enjoyed his way of reasoning. There is nothing wrong with learning from other cultures: early muslim scholars translated and elaborated on Greek works and early islamic sciences were built on Greek, Persian and Indian sciences so my question is why not learn from Harvard or Yale and use the same logical weapons western academics are using against Islam to serve and defend Islam. No one is talking about Fiqh or tafsir or sirah here we are talking about developing our Muslim capability to logically refute people who are attacking us.

[@ImranAli-tm3rq]

It amazes me when people love to jump on someone even when they dont grasp what he said.. YQ said the manmade madhabs that came many years after the sahaba and the middle eastern schools of thought were great for a time and a place but need to evolve and change in some places for western muslims.

[@sikandar08]

It's an analogy lol he's saying he understood more after studying more, using physics as an example. We thought Newtonian physics was everything, but after studying more we realised there's more to it. Which is to mean he learnt more and realised there's more to the picture. It doesn't mean he created a new one, he's saying he learnt more Why read in the worst possible interpretation? I find that unfair.

[@deltrotter3371]

Who’s the guy on the left? Seems like a blessed brother.

[@ilmseed431]

MashaAllah, he is a blessed brother :) He has a KZbin channel also: Omar Chatila.

[@ziasmailbox]

Which of Allah's creation is not blessed...

[@rathernot6660]

@@ziasmailbox MarshAllah. BarakahAllahu feek

[@quran2819]

I m from jamiat ahle hadith indian occupied Kashmir plz pray for us

[@TomSuckAtFinance]

mohammad aasim May Allah give our brothers and sisters of Kashmir victory

[@thooriqulannam8243]

mohammad aasim insyaallah bruhh ☝

[@stonerosesuk]

May all of JK come to ahlul hadith and liberation. Ameen.

[@AnakiiD]

@@TomSuckAtFinance Aameen

[@azadajk7128]

May Allah liberate Occupied Kashmir and keep you and all the Muslims of the subcontinent firm upon the straight path. Āmeen

[@ilmhunter7362]

"The more knowledge... you have the more you need to be Humble.." (Medinah teacher) May Allah..Guide Yasir Qadhi back

[@ilmhunter7362]

@ sometimes we need to be cautious too..about theology..... some may have PHd or new graduates...but if someone teaches other way around...then we must be aware of Aqeedah... Remember All Ulama may commit mistakes too... so we must be aware of it... Fuqaha use to Quote "if you find unclear on our teachings Go back to Quran and Sunnah, take what is benefit from us..it, according to Quran and Sunnah and ijma of the scholars...and leave for what is unclear and unresolved....... Shaykh Saleh fawzan Haf. Use to say... nowadays many Qura(speakers) than Fuqaha... Nowadays Speakers are many but Fuqaha are few... So we need to balance ourselves... to avoid Taasub and Focus on our Intentions and Understandings.. Ilm in Islam is Vast... so we need to take it slowly, inorder for us to gain proper understanding of Our Aqeedah... May Allah bless us and grant us more patience and understanding.. Amin

[@ilmhunter7362]

@ my advice bro.. to you and also to myself we need to check the Aqeedah first...before we follow....or take knowledge from someone.. we need to clarify their manhaj...and their Understanding about Aqeedah... and Fiqh... And Allah knows best... thanks also for sharing your opinion... May Allah grant us more understanding

[@nasirhill]

@@ilmhunter7362 yes, to make sure first that they are wahhabi, then only will we follow. Yall need to chill.

[@vitovittoria1540]

@@canhaktan9674 Why doesn't he debate Christian prince

[@vitovittoria1540]

@@canhaktan9674 Everyone is afraid of him because he tells the truth and he shows the facts on street corners it's just a lot of screaming but no facts

[@AllahURabBI19]

I watched it and i was just overwhelmed with sadness because this was the man i learned tawheed from him from his old videos. I had stop listening to him but i wanted to watch this podcast and see where his head is really at. Wallah brother Sajid i feel exactly what you are saying. May Allah guide him ameeem

[@ahmede.1375]

What did you watch, where’s the video of him?

[@native5647]

Can u please send me the link of yasir qadhi video that they are talking about thank u.

[@ajazio]

I watched the video by yasir qadhi and I did not come out of it with the same conclusions as you have. No where does yasir qadhi suggest that we should learn Islam from non-muslims. I think he was talking mostly about his phd experience at Yale and how the research methodology at Yale is different than, say, a Saudi university. To suggest that yasir qadhi has completely deviated from the right path is a huge stretch.

[@sikandar08]

Agreed, I see it as a complete misinterpretation and somewhat intentionally taking the worst possible interpretation of his words. Calling him arrogant as well. Definitely not convinced or impressed

[@shoaibhaq8680]

Making a comparison of the aqeeda of deen with physics(which is not based upon absolute knowledge but is rather progressive knowledge and ever-changing) is jahiliya in itself and then on top of that calling himself Einstein and other past scholars as of having newtonian understanding is clear as day that he thinks of himself as some sort of reformist and thinks high of himself based om whatever western outlook he got on the deen from yale... As those in yale who don't believe in islaam in the first place definitely have a more materialistic and secular approach towards the deen because that's what they are concerned about the dunya... Remember the deen of Allah wasn't send down to be maimed and distorted so as yo make it to fit into the ideology of some human being's rather we humans have to let go off of our desires and outlook and mould ourselves in becoming a sincere Muslim as per what Allah wants it to be nobody has the right to change it's fundamental to suit themselves

[@L6ila12]

I love you for the sake of Allaah, Saajid!

[@kochi561]

My only question is does anybody try to talk YQ about this and ask him to clarify this issue ? I want to know what is his answer ?

[@selinan3077]

Did u guys try to contact him??? Its very disturbing that u talk bad about him

[@abdullahibinmubarak7535]

may allah help you people

[@kamalamina6609]

Many have", many talked, most notably several speakers from Umm Qura his agenda was always known even when he was a teenager for some it did not shock them sorry but arrogance always consumed his heart.

[@abdulallahabdulsomad3202]

yes many many people advised him privately and no one is taking the advice

[@ebrahimadan3630]

@@selinan3077 don't be disturbed they are not talking bad rather they are doing good job may Allah bless them.

[@skahrama]

The Imaam Muhammad bin Sireen said: «إِنَّ هَذَا العِلْمَ دِيْنٌ؛ فَانْظُرُواْ عَمَّنْ تَأخُذُوْنَ دِيْنَكُمْ». “Indeed this knowledge is the religion, so be careful with regards to the one whom you take your religion from”

[@shuaybx1811]

That can be applied to Madina university as well? Why do graduates from Madina Uni (in the west) not speak out against the wrongs of the Saudi Gov eg the recent Niki minhaj controversy. Do they fear so much for no visa entry?

[@abdlquadri]

Given by what I know about this channel. This interview should have been with Yaasir Qaadhi not someone else. When the issue of Mufti Muneer occurred, you talked to him directly. You still have a chance. Let's us know if Yaasir declined the interview.

[@SeekerofTruths]

Why would Yasir Qaadhi entertain a ratty beard, brainwashed salafi who converted yesterday and makes videos from his mom's basement?

[@SeekerofTruths]

@Harrey potter Take that back you weak chinned, son of a harlot

[@hodanc6526]

Cabdiqadir if video was public tha reply video must be public

[@ibnamanot]

@@SeekerofTruths Why are you talking about another Muslim like that? calling him names? They are talking about Yasir Qadhi, but they are not disrespecting him by calling him names etc. Also, The Sahabahs were also converts and are know as the Salaf (righteous predecessors). So yeah man.

[@rahatahmed6188]

@@SeekerofTruths he's literally studied for 8 years in madinah, why do you think yasir qadhi is so much better than him.

[@ahlanwasahlan4556]

Saajid bro i love u man i miss your vids in madinah...

[@anwarar677]

Assalamu Alaikum🌹 Brother if you have any disagreement with Yasir Qadi please contact him or meet him and try to convince. It will be good for all muslim too. Sad that Now a days muslim brothers are debating and arguing each other in the name of islam. We r giving chance to others for laughs on us

[@uyghurrights8595]

If you're sincere about this issue, why don't you discuss this with sheikh yasir in private? By publicising this are you not opening the doors to more confusion? Allah knows best.

[@Wahid0172]

Because it is for the public good, he's a public figure.

[@silveoconstragio8881]

No. He said these publicly and not in his house. He will be refuted publicly.

[@sonofadam7633]

@@silveoconstragio8881 yeah Some people think everything should be a peanut butter

[@alaminbrand2274]

Tufael Salam Brother I also thought so same like you. I listened YQ lecture on LGBT and i was disappointed which was so disturbing. As he is public figure, we can deal in public

[@EthioKenya]

You guys need to do something better than this, your critics against Dr yasir khadi is absolutely empty and baseless

[@Abrar5280]

brother the critic is not empty...the brother got apoint,a point in the main creed of islam..i wish dr comes out and retrieve his speech..becuse it conflicts of the belief of the unseen..

[@raheemhanifa9636]

You are correct, they're thinking is so surface level and ignorant. They have a fake understanding of what the Islamic tradition is. Islam is much broader than their simple minded understandings of Islam.

[@yasminhusain213]

Allahu Alam, it's good they are warning the people.

[@newlgmustby9157]

Assalamualikum, I thought as Muslim you SHOULD personally talk to him. I have nothing against you, probably u are smart enough to listen carefully. You should resolve this question with out public opinion, views and likes. You have A RESPONSIBILITY of solving and come up with Dr. Qadhi to public. Just think of how our prophet (SAW) would solve? You didn’t follow the SUNNA. Someone made similar accusations ...took a clip of speech(some people did bad things) from Ilhan Omar to the 9-11 attack. I think you and your Jordanian gust should go talk to Dr. Yasir Qadhi. Allah gives accordingly what we can handle.

[@newlgmustby9157]

RUCKAS NUCKAS unless you’re among the many people who talked to him, don’t trust your left hand now days.

[@number1gstar]

Much needed.

[@kab1r]

The other brother insinuated that Yasir Qadhi has gone astray. This is a very dangerous conclusion to make without speaking to him and getting answers from him directly. Another important note akhi, a PHD is purely research based qualification. The only thing you learn is how to do research and write an essay basically. The subject i.e. Islam you would learn from your degree and masters which brother Yasir did at Madinah university. He got all his knowledge from primary Islamic sources and NOT from some professor from Yale. Salafi brothers are too judgemental without proper fact finding and research (as ironic as it sounds).

[@benmuhsin]

This has validity

[@k40L1n]

Salafis have refuted his nonsense since early 2000, when he came out of madinah. His own batch mates had warned against him. You stupid people, don't know the history yourself of your own YQ and then blame us. He used to be amongst us salafis and we know his true colors. His PhD is joke, especially it's proven now. Back when we used to say ppl made fun of us and now lo and behold it's proven. On his way to creating a new sect. Maybe call it Qadhi 'ni.

[@shuaybx1811]

Fair point but not many people fact check when they want to "refute".

[@ibrahimgarane2209]

I have watched 15 minutes of the video and these brothers have not raised any serious issues but rather criticizing Yasir Qadhi for earning his PHD at Yale. I know PHD is usually about research and it's not a level where someone goes to learn about the core content of a subject. This is just unfair criticism, maybe if there are personal issues involved you need to resolve this together as Muslim brothers.

[@T1000-e7s]

Maybe you should watch the whole 1 hour 20 minutes and then comment.

[@thegoodthebadandthepagli2736]

The best way to refute somebody is to present a positive alternative.

[@armughanbangash1069]

Please use your energy for something constructive, ummah has already fallen apart, try to bring people together.

[@ismailismail8438]

armughan bangash mashaalah well said

[@luqmanhakeem9392]

armughan bangash Absolutely you are right

[@revert2014]

🙄 Bring people together in falsehood?

[@themistersmith]

Sound advice.

[@hn4364]

unity upon Quran and sunnah. not upon falsehood

[@mechtron2544]

Thank you brother Saajid for clearing up a lot of things in this video.

[@AISHAHALI05]

السلام عليكم ورحمة اللة وبركاته جزاك لله خيرا I ask Allah to bless you both for this clarification. والله this is very sad because this is someone I use to study with at al maghribi institute. Alhamdulillah Allah saves me from that.

[@bikazful]

Umm Maryam Aishah Jalloh salam mignan(or jaja lol). I think you shud stick with learning from Almaghrib institute as I'm sure it has benefited you greatly. you shudnt be discouraged because of this intervention of brother Sajid.

[@AISHAHALI05]

@@bikazful maybe you benefited from it but not me. Speak for yourself

[@ummzaynul370]

Wa alaikum mussallaam wa rahmatAllaahi wa barakatuh.

[@haarishashmi8322]

Jazakallah khair brother. You made this video as i had many of the shuhubaat and (still have some) similar to that of Dr Qadhi.. but now i have much more clarity.

[@hammadtaalibdin7.gallery]

It’s called inferiority complex. It’s a sad reality among us from a third world state of mind. The facts that he went to Yale he thinks that he is among the elite. He went to his head. May Allah guide him and guide us, Ameen!

[@anotherhadith9951]

Yasir qadhi most probably got cloned in Yale

[@Abdullah34610]

I stopped at 15 minutes in because I think you have grossly misunderstood Dr. YQ points. 1- I do not think he ever said Yale was better than Medina (you went on a tangent about your thoughts, then put it on YQ). His reasoning to go back to the West was not because he thought it was better nor because he wanted to. He felt the NEED to so so that he could support the Ummah in the west (as an American, would you not want to help your fellow Muslims in America?). If you are amongst those that think Muslims shouldnt live in nonMuslim lands, I dont expect you to understand. 2-im pretty sure he mentioned only 1 scholar that told him to go back, but I think you split it into 2 people. Either you weren't paying attention, or it was I. And majority doesnt always mean correct. If 50 people told me to drink mercury to improve my health, but 1 said dont, which would be correct? 3- I think you 2 are a great example of knowledge vs experience. You are thinking of what hes saying/did as though it occurred in a vacuum, and dont provide it context. 4- the physics example was about how there is a time and place for everything. Or are you going to say abrogation is illegitimate? A fatwa in Medina cannot always be applied in America. The muslims of Mecca, Medina. and Abyssinia lived slightly differently. There was so much to comment on in 15 minutes that I forgot some of my points. I wonder what more I wouldve said if I kept watching.

[@GhostRider-yh7sh]

Wallahi this podcast was needed. I thank both brothers for analyzing the podcast with Yasir Qadhi. I unsubscribed from his youtube channel. The last few years he has changed alot. Something he always mentions is his degrees, this is not the way of the salaf. I saw a video with Sheikh Salih alfawzan, when somebody was praising him he immediatly said NO im just a student of knowledge like you, same thing with Sheikh Tahir wyatt. The way of the salaf is to stay humble no matter what degree you have. Yasir qadhi also interacts with women in conferences. The guy is slowly but surely taking a different route, i hope more people especially Sheikhs talk about this " new way of thinking " Brother saajid even though i disagree with the whole Mufti Muneer/Shamsi speakers corner thing. Again you are spot on with this video. May allah guide Yasir Qadhi and us

[@simpleviewer7445]

His decision lead to the fact, that hamdulillah now a real sunni muslim is teaching islam at a university to muslims or nonmuslims who want to study Islam. We Need muslim teachers at universities in nonmuslim lands

[@ahmadalvi9037]

I was listening to his lectures on the Seerah of the prophet (PBUH) . But now I’m concerned that I shouldn’t. Can you recommend whose lectures I should listen to?

[@aminayusif3175]

Mohammed Tim Humble, Abu Taymiyyah Jeylani, Hadith Disciple, Abdul Rahman Hassan, Abu Ibraheem Husnayn, Green Lane Masjid, Naseeha Sessions, Kalemah among others

[@ahmadalvi9037]

Amina Yusif JazakAllah khair Sister

[@ahmadalvi9037]

Amina Yusif I cant find Tim Humbles on KZbin. Is it a podcast?

[@aminayusif3175]

@@ahmadalvi9037 Naa basically lectures. Just search his name from the search bar on KZbin and you will find a number of lectures. Same with the others.

[@hamzazulfi]

AHMAD ALVI I think you should avoid Naseeha sessions.

[@anmfarhan6867]

Sajid, I love you for the sake of Allah.

[@shuaybx1811]

He hasn't said anything controversial i.e he believes the Ashari/maturidi and Atari Aqeeda is within Sunni Islam and that no mountain of knowledge scholar(s) in Saudi Arabia are going to help guide the masses to Islam in the west by attacking Muslims in a very sectarian way. Yes these debates will exist till the day of judgement but to focus on these debates alone and make that the priority is wrong. That's just my interpretation of what he said but Allah knows best.

[@ImranAli-tm3rq]

Brothers brothers brothers.. YQ is very knowledgeable...and has the credentials and is sincere...so I will watch his podcast and get a true picture before making up my mind..

[@muhammadibraheem3652]

Who's Yasir Qadhi compared to the Scholars of our time? Honestly he's not someone that's even worthy of speaking about matters of the religion. Only ignorant, foolish in mind individuals are fooled by people the likes of Yasir Qadhi. That's why it's very critical to learn Arabiyyah(Arabic) and take from the Scholars directly.

[@ImranAli-tm3rq]

@@muhammadibraheem3652 'He's not even worthy of speaking about matters of the religion'... Really? Have you stamped him not worthy to talk about religion? So who does have your ijaza? Dawahman?

[@PSNloversalu]

@@ImranAli-tm3rq so what happened now? Did you watch? What do you think?

[@borgahun5778]

Guys, you sound like if Dr YQ is uttering blasphemy or something... can you address what fundamental issue he has advocated for change? Has he said anything about pillars of iman, arkan of Islam? And where did he say that West understands Islam better? He only said he was amazed about how he learned the science of studying at Yale...

[@borgahun5778]

@slashZ890 Bro.. honestly, where does YQ say that fundamental aqeedah changes over time? Belief in God, Angels, Messenger, Books, Last Day, Qadr ... where does he say it changes? Stop lying to yourself.

[@theseeker7243]

I first of all have benefited plenty from YQ, Alhamdulillah. But very little from you so far, still Alhamdulillah. If you graduated from college of dawah then so far in my humble opinion you do not have the talent 'to inform and to remind' - just yet. But I hope soon you 2 have the ability like YQ to have eloquent lectures on here jammed packed with knowledge and content, inshaAllah. The right methodology, in my opinion, is to ask the disagreement you have to YQ personally and give him the change to answer and clarify. Was he saying it by mistake, intent to insult, or simply joking where he should not, or maybe you took it the wrong way. So you do not propagate things which you 'only assumed to begin with,' and this only make you look bad. Once you establish that then you could speak your opinion. Second, once that confirmed, instead of saying what he said, put on what he said here so I can hear what you referencing to. Because I heard things where I felt 'you said more' on top of what he said. Thirdly it's YQ opinion, and it's your opinion. God knows best.

[@T1000-e7s]

It seems very ironic that you are doing the exact same thing you are accusing the brother of doing, what qualifications do you have to advice the brother? You are openly advising him with your comment. Yasir Ghadi has been controversial for many years openly and the brother like he explained made excuses for him for all those years yet now the danger of his dawah is affecting many muslims including yourself, salam.

[@tazkhan9606]

In other words stfu. Not say a word. Who owns this Deen? Is it yours or his real estate? Crawl back into your hole with that Mocker of Islam

[@yayatoure3978]

beware of eloquent muslims for we have been warned against them. do not take the speech at face value give scrutiny to the content as you cross check against the Quran and the Sunnah.

[@yayatoure3978]

beware of fame . it is the killer of iman.

[@AbdulMajeedHamid]

"The disease that knowledge brings is arrogance, and the disease that worship brings is showing off" ~ Ibn Taymiyyah

[@BinuJasim]

True knowledge brings humility. True worship brings humility as well.

[@mohammedih25]

Br. Saajid I'm a regular Muslim I like to learn more about Islam but I am kind of confused. Which Mahadab should I follow which Akeeda should I follow which Faiqe should I follow? I don't know much about any of these.

[@tranquilambiance1751]

Brother, we don't follow people, we follow haqq. People can change any time before their death. Sometimes I feel that the people around us are like a ship that only carries us a certain distance. Then we need to get off and find a new ship.

[@ibnamanot]

I need a course or lesson in saheeh 'Aqeedah.

[@ziasmailbox]

Search aqeedah lesson by Muhammad Tim Humble

[@Aisha1522]

Barakallahu feekum, May Allah bless you both, May Allah make us of those who hold tightly to the Quran and sunnah.

[@Aperekahaziq]

I dont understand.. So what is the podcast about?

[@ummzaynul370]

A wise person does not need degrees in knowledge than a person who holds degree in the case of Luqman alayhissallaam.

[@mizmagica764]

Can this be another form of back biting by using KZbin... or informing about someone's wrong ?

[@adnaahmed5167]

Subhana Allah, speechless, and disappointed, wow very scary ,

[@dubaddubad7520]

Subsahnallah Why are we spending so much energy in small issue.

[@yayatoure3978]

this issues deemed small by you can take someone to the fire... literally.

[@yayatoure3978]

i am not trying to disrespect you. as you certainly know there is nothing small with Allah. even the size of an ATOM. I GUESS THE QUESTION WE SHOULD ALL ASK IS : WHAT IS THE METHODOLOGY TO REFUTE A MUSLIM? BEHIND A HIJAB FIRST? AND THEN IF THE PERSON PERSISTS BRING IT OUT IN THE OPEN? MIND YOU I AM JUST ASKING . DID ANYONE CONTACT HIM FOR CLARIFICATION?

[@sonofadam7633]

Nothing is small in our religion

[@vlogsofsamiyusuf6651]

My prayers are always with you. May Allah protect you and increase your knowledge and wisdom. May Allah grant you the success of this life and the life after and bless you with highest ranks in jannah.

[@surayatimol2385]

Look man I'm a nobody,Muslim in South Africa who is trying everyday to stay focussed on my deen. Alhamdullilah we have fantastic Ulama,not infalible,but fantastic. Just one point,Islam has many evidential based aspects which points you to the truth. In saying that it's about Faith,I find many of the scholars try and explain aspects or events when you can just say I have "Faith" And when you try and explain you get into a knot

[@mzahidfullah2]

It's good to see Muslim in America refute each other. React and critic to other Muslim brothers. Congratulations. I don't know why people just don't go to Dr. Qadhi and make dialogue with him other than try to spread hate to other Muslim brother.

[@anthonygloria5192]

Abu Hurayra learned Islam from Shaytan according to a hadith in Bukhari so what's wrong with learning Islam from an academic non Muslim?

[@michaelvilla3486]

This is very political for someone who claims to avoid politics. Or is it limited to saudi royalty?

[@ededdy1607]

saudi royalty is like their god fathers.

[@abrarfaiyazkhan420]

Which school of aqeedah should I follow? Ash'ari? Maturidi? Deobandi? Athari? Can anyone answer which one is okay and which one is not, and if not then why.... I am a general muslim, not an 'alim, and should I affirm myself with these? Or I should learn basic aqeedah at first? Are the terms related with scholars with high knowledge specifically in aqeedah, or they ar related to all general muslims? Jazakallah

[@maryamabdulmumin2642]

First, I will advice you to be sincere in seeking guidance from Allah. Make du'aa to Allah guide you to the correct methodology. My advice to you is to follow the Sunnah of the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وسلم) and his aqeedah and the ahlul hadeeth. I can not guide you, only Allah can. So, be sincere in your search for the truth. Allah will not leave his slave who is seeking for guidance astray.

[@iimiboy]

Athari also called ahlul hadith, salafi

[@laraaib1233]

Going and talking yasir qadi is not a good idea. Dr qadi would start debating and would try to put bro. Sajid down. What bro. Sajid is doing is GREAT!! Alerting Muslim Ummah.....especially When the majority ummah has very little or limited Knowledge of Traditional Deen e Islam.. The one & Only that Nabi Akram Sallalho Alehe wasallam Brought...🙂 Bro. Sajid keep up the Good work..

[@laraaib1233]

yes

[@mizmagica764]

Assalamalikum brothers and sisters. Can anyone tell me who the brother with the dark hair on the left is....?

[@rahatahmed6188]

Omar chatila

[@vazeemasiddiqui1611]

Jazaak Allah kum khair for spreading awareness.

[@hamzahrizvi1928]

Yasir Qadhi is not perfect but the kind of extrapolations being made here is just frankly careless. Yes he is Athari. All he means in a nutshell is don't be making tabdee3 on each other when ur kids are questioning whether Allah is real instead of arguing over creeds.

[@e.k874]

So by this Logic Raza Aslan cant be a professor, historian of religion cuz he’s only a muslim and not budist Christian jew?!

[@youngerbrother4048]

I am glad the brother Lipham made this video. I will not longer put YQ on a pedestal and next time I will take YQ’s lecture with a grain of salt. Eye opening indeed. May Allah bless you for making this video.

[@12Hydrocarbon]

Wallahi I remember asking myself who are the professors that teach PHD level Islamic studies at Yale University. It didn’t make sense to me and now it seems that notion is revealing itself to the public. May Allah guide us. If people love PHDs, please study engineering or other technical/empirical fields from these elite schools; the Muslim community is desperate for experts on science today. But, please don’t learn Islam from western universities.

[@starcrafttube]

are we in 1994 again?

[@TFQ0]

no human being is perfect. we do all mistakes. we cannot ignore his deen and dawah just becoz of 1 mistake.

[@propheticadmirer1701]

Yasir Qadhi has guided many to Islam..Although In Aqeedah and most aspects of deen he is right but such views of him as pointed out are really worth repenting...May Allah bless him for his Work for deen and forgive and guide him for his faults...The best thing we can do today is to follow the Quran and hadeeth and refering to them before following anything.

[@musajallow5710]

Allah will always bring people of tawheed and knowledge to preserved his deen .may Allah guiide him back to Islam.ameen

[@TomSuckAtFinance]

Jazakallah to brother saajid for explaining this matter.

[@raushanali5733]

Brothers, let's be honest here, there are many many mashaikh nowadays go and do masters and PhD also in our Islamic intellectual heritage we can see the classical scholars went and took knowledge from the non Muslims. When Yasir Qadhi went to do a PhD he didn't intend to learn his deen from yale University. How absurd is it to think that, seriously? If he wanted to learn his deen all over again then he would not be doing PhD as you very well know PhD is a research discipline....

[@alimal-haqq7758]

a scholar knows a jahil because he was one but a jahil doest not no a sholar because he was not one so sajhid know your level and stop slandering yasir qadhi your just jelouse may allah guide you ameen

[@alimal-haqq7758]

what makes a person any more knowledgeble if he studies overseas this is a exotocised idea muslims fall into by the way signs of a false scholar as stated by imam gazali is to speak ill of other scholars he looks more emotional upset than talking intelectualy what a time of fitna looking at the faults of muslims than to call people to the deen

[@theprince8079]

19:05 thats not true. I got a question do u have a wahabi mindset?

[@marzet70]

nice right and exact!!!

[@damirage2010]

Iam not trying to be rude.Its a serious question who should we listen to help us I get so frustrated they say we should ask people of knowledge.Now I just follow my instinct when sheikhs differ.

[@dilxaz820]

Really confused 😓😪😪😪

[@abuanihas3pazg149]

The Truth (Allah , Al Haqq) is what we worship even if it goes against our parents, I am in the same boat as you Sajid I departed with Brother Yasir long time ago I found Anwar Al Awlaki's seerah to be truthful and Yasir Qhadhi was White washing, prevaricating, but anyway it is well known to study the Deen you need to study from trustworthy sources you can compare and try to understanding on specific issues but for majority matter of the Deen you definitely need traditional schools the four madhabs etc

[@misssimmi2]

Is it any wonder the world is going in the direction it's going when we as an ummah have to publicly attack one another for fame on KZbin and other public platforms! Astaghfirullah, may Allah guide us all.

[@jonikfirst9760]

Asalomu aleykum I like this brother.May Allah reward him

[@danoneall4013]

Did Sheikh Yasir Qadhi attend Yale for Deen or for Islamic History? Also I seen an interview with Sheikh Qadhi that he took some classes because Tony Blair was taking the same classes so he wanted to see exactly what they were teaching and to go after Tony Blair. Before you guys jump all over me, I like Sheikh Qadhi, there are things I disagree with him on. I don't blind follow any sheikh. I have about 19 throughout the world I listen to but I always question them so I can learn better.

[@boxer1639]

“Save that energy” am I right your a boxing/MMA fan bro? I loved it when you said that haha

[@rehanriaz620]

Why would anyone want to study Islam at yale???? Doesn't seem logically to me... Choice between medina or yale.... Medina wins hands down every time.

[@mohamednuur5044]

May Allah keep us firm on the path of Salafiya. Subhanallah

[@abdullahaligarcia9501]

I always say... That you have to be humble in our Deen... Don't think to high of yourself... May Allah Subhanahu wa Ta'ala protect us all... Ameen...!!!

[@mohammedahmad8039]

I watched the video and my understanding of what he said was completely different to lots of people who are commenting here. I understood that Dr Yasir Qadhi said that with the current attack’s on Islam, muslims need to stop attacking each other’s schools of thought and should stop regurgitating old theological arguments and should focus instead on confronting the bigger, newer threats that are causing people to abandon their islamic faith. I believe this is a valid point. For example western textual criticism of the Quran is a serious threat that very few people are addressing in a convincing academic refutational manner. He also said people should stop treating scholars like they treat revelations from Allah. Personally my prophet is Mohamed (SAAWS). Neither Ibn Taymya nor Alghazali are my prophets and whether people like it or not scholars are not infallible. What is wrong with that? I believe the job of scholarship is not to blindly read back old arguments (since anyone can read the books and find those arguments) but scholars should address current issues and shubuhat and personally I am trying to find scholars who are doing exactly that. Instead I am finding people who are attacking scholars and each other and not paying attention to muslims loosing their faith because of what western academics are pointing out as discrepancies in Islam using a very sophisticated line of reasoning. What Dr Yasir Qadhi said is that we need new Ibn taymiya’s in the muslim world and we should focus on teaching scholars how to think and learn. What is wrong with what he said. Can someone explain to me if I am missing something?? I am really confused

[@ededdy1607]

this is what happens when you study in the khawarej kingdom of saudis. you go around attacking Muslim preachers .

[@sonofadam7633]

Hey stop it

[@rohanysaed7551]

It’s sad to see our Muslim brothers judge their own Muslim brothers. Wasted my time. Unsubscribe!!!

[@ibnmasood]

I think i have the same table...raymour and flannigans

[@hadjirokhayasarr3603]

Salam An other interview helpfull for understanding the power of Allah Diazakallahou khairan brothers

[@saleubarrow1319]

When you say he was not like this before, what do you want them to do wait until when he become like this

[@alinasreddin7197]

Brothers Brothers, "if u cover a muslims mistake and Allah will cover ur mistakes in the lday of judgement" so what u r trying to do is fitna and opposing the teaching of islam. Is this video aimed at driving people away from YQ. I mean what is the the benefit on what u r doing? We all make mistakes and if u feel that YQ has made a mistake u need to confront him and let him explain himself instead of judging him and humiliating him in public.

[@GREENREDISLAMICTV1971]

I think you brothers missed one important point from the podcast : How Dr. Yasir “studied” Imam Fakhruddin Raazi RA at Yale University. A course of 3 persons including the instructor, where he admitted that the instructor says he doesnt know anything about Imam Raazi RA and they “studied” - this says a lot about his PhD program, its depth and quality of ‘Islamic’ education at Yale! Wallahu a3lam

[@raheedrm]

He didnt actually deny yahjuj wa majuj He was asking if the meaning was open to some interpritatation. To say the hadith comes across as strange in its apparent meaning is not problematic, but if it leads to denial then its a problem. Within dawa its easy to say to a muslim you must just accept, But when confronted by non muslims You have to go to some extent in explaining the logic of things. He claims to believe in the creation of adam (as) from dust, the creation of the universe from nothing accept the will of Allah, the night journey, rising of the day of judgement etc So hes not a materialist or atheist. So he believes in miracles and the power of allah to do as he wills. The real problem with him and many other da'es is in my opinion is the issue of evolution or rather theistic evolution being preached by so many. Not surprising to see another salafi brother come back from madina and start criticising, rather than adressing the political situation facing the ummah around the world. But thats whats taught in the curriculum, Athari interpritatation of aqeeda as if it was held by the majority of ahulul sunna through out time and distorted politics.

[@kelvinpragassa4871]

There are holes in original manuscripts

[@vlogsofsamiyusuf6651]

brother sajjid i agree what you said yesterday not because i watch your videos because as you saidd quran and sunnah we follow it

[@akbarali-fh4rb]

What he is doing is the result of what Aalims and Ulemas in Pakistan warn. Ulemas in Pakistan always insists that no matter what sect u belong in islam you should study through some proper channel and then you are allow to do research. In every field of life when ever we need some specialist we ask first from where you studied, If you r doctor then what medical college you went, who were your teachers, in which hospital you did practice. But now everyone who do self study and read some books and deliver some lectures consider himself as an Aalim. Islam is not for intellect but intellect should submit to islam.

[@imadhurata1]

To be fair a PHD is more about research and publication then learning from lecturers.

[@maxpaine98]

The brothers in this video completely miss this point. I am not sure how Ph.D. programs are run in KSA but in Western academia, it is as you have stated. Most students come to their postgraduate studies with a specific orientation and worldview, they are not rewired and "taught Islam by non-Muslims". They are however pushed towards critical thinking and research as you have stated.

[@khaledhasanshibly7451]

@@maxpaine98Research means => The "Systematic" investigation into and study of materials and "SOURCES" in order to "ESTABLISH" "FACTS" and reach new conclusions. - by www.oxforddictionaries.com/ 1. Who set the standard for System of research(to evaluate the Deen or any religion like IEEE has its own standards). 2. What are the study materials? 3. What are the methods to evaluate the Sources(Right/wrong/credible/non-credible) ? 4. There is no such thing called "Absolute Fact" in science, but in Deen or religion it exists(Like the Existence of Allah ). So how a person can establish facts based upon the methodology which itself does not guarantee anything that can lead to absolute truth or facts?

[@ameenomar1911]

finally, a voice of reason. It is refreshing to see not everyone in the comment section are narrow minded

[@ameenomar1911]

@@maxpaine98 As someone who has tasted both traditional studies and academia, I must say that although the premise of traditional studies is superior (the notion that Allah exists, and the Prophet (SAW) is His messenger), the Islamic curricula has remained stagnant for the past couple of centuries and has not incorporated new methods and canonical texts which a huge setback for the Muslim world. This setback is indicative and perhaps is the causation of our poor state as an Ummah. I am glad scholars like Yasir Qadhi are trying to push the envelop for academic progress.

[@ameenomar1911]

@@khaledhasanshibly7451 By your logic, hadith science should not be an empirical study because Allah exists and thus you can infer that every report is correct because He would not allow for His religion to become corrupt. Under your presupposition, Islamic sciences would have never formed.

[@lexcidust1263]

I know this is an off topic point, but i noticed the way brother saajid listens whilst the other brother is speaking,the way he is focused and patient in listening is definitely something i can take from this video 👍✋✋

[@quran2819]

I love you saajid for sake of Allah keep doing what you are doing, May Allah reward you and keep you on right path.

[@ebinadam2579]

Allah swt says ”And when they deviated, Allah caused their hearts to deviate. And Allah does not guide the defiantly disobedient people.” May allah protect us from arrogance, and deviation. This video has cleared for me many things may allah reward you brothers.

[@AmsyarHanif]

Good stuff as alway. May Allah bless you both.

[@AbdulHaseebNumanRahmani]

What good did you found in this stupid non profitable non beneficial bla bla

[@themistersmith]

MY IQ decreased by 20 points after watching this.

[@Alex-bd4ov]

Why is this so?

[@-khelfallah5032]

so true

[@tranquilambiance1751]

Gosh it's impossibly low now. How do u live?

[@everythingbelongstoallah71]

You're lying you had no IQ even before fool .

[@MrStyle-sr1yv]

What is IQ ??

[@ibnamanot]

May Allah protect us, really. May He not test us with our faith and 'aqeedah. It is a big test, Wallahi.

[@hammadtaalibdin7.gallery]

My Man Saajid, keep doing what you’re doing yaa Akhi! Jazaka Allahu khayraan yaa Akhi!

[@yusuf605]

Yasir Qadhi said "follow the scholar of your choice whom you trust the most" subhanallah this statement itself is misguidance . May Allah protect us all from such self claimed scholars. What prevents us from sticking to two things which Prophet pbuh himself stressed about? The best speech is the speech of Allah, the best guidance is the guidance of Muhammad pbuh. Period !

[@SoldierOfTheDeen]

BarakAllahu feekum brothers, I watched that podcast and noticed that it was littered with ambiguous sophistry. Also, I don't understand why he thinks he's so special, Sheikh Muhammad Mustafa Al A'zami rahimahullah also got a Phd from the west and wrote books refuting orientalist snakes.

[@Procrastinators]

Yasser Qadhi rejects the cult like intolerance of Saudi Salafis, Saudi Salafis respond with character assassination and PDF refutation. The irony is over whelming. Shameless people.

[@azraa7110]

Please stop picking on the person you should spend time on constructive things not wasting time listening to his videos picking up points and making your own videos please leave the matter to Allah SWT and move on

[@mizmagica764]

Exactly bro! This is nothing beneficially and constructive. If you have an issue about someone then you should speak to them first and then come to a conclusion of understanding from what is right from wrong and the truth to falsehood.

[@PSNloversalu]

For many of us its fine if we dont talk about such sheikhs,,, but think about the people who might be misguided by such 'scholars'! Thats why we surely need to address such issues! Just dont go Sumun Bukmun Umyun Fahum Layarjiun!