Results after Releasing Stickman Trenches 1 Year Ago on Steam

[@zombiebadgr]

I bought Stickman Trenches and it is very fun and amazing, I just really enjoy playing it! Please keep updating this amazing game as it has so much more potential and I just can't wait for the new update!

[@notthatbad42]

This game needs barbed wire, it was such a big feature in WW1 that it is almost essential to the game. it should fit in well with everything else too: tanks could run it over, it would slow down and have a chance to kill infantry, you could maybe have a unit in one of the factions be good at removing it and another in a different faction ( maybe the Germans cause they’re good at engineering?) good at placing it (ex: cheaper if officer), these could be put as upgrades in the tech tree, or not, you could upgrade it to be tank resistant, you could have an officer or a tech upgrade make infantry more resistant to it,… the list goes on, the possibilities are near endless. Idk if you’re still planning on expanding the game way more or not, but if you are I think the next big direction this game could go, is meta-progression, depending on the results and settings of each match, you could get a certain currency that allows you to unlock things, like extra upgrades in the tech tree, units, abilities, or even whole factions, this gives you an extra reason to keep on playing: to unlock everything. either way, I think barbed wire would be fantastic, and I might be wrong, but I think a lot of people agree( I’ve seen a lot of suggestions for it) Thanks for reading this looong comment!

[@paulbenichou2604]

It would be good as well to do a “story” mode with battles where if you lose you go deeper in your territory ect it if you win you push the enemy

[@KalelIsAWierdPerson]

it has it in custom maps but for some reason, it isn't lethal.

[@BluePhoenix579]

sappers could easily destroy the barbed wire, but also be effective against the gunner/turret things

[@artemisthehunter8360]

you could mix this with engineers who can remove mines and wire

[@sinisterisrandom8537]

​@@paulbenichou2604I like this idea. The story progresses on your victories and your failures and adapts to it.

[@mrnexus2296]

Who here thinks he sould add it to mobile

[@HelalMoon235]

Been waiting for a year.

[@bonfireanimations51]

Me

[@danielleblauvelt6775]

ME ME ME ME

[@mariacindycopple7608]

Meee

[@alvinnguyen0918]

Me

[@Tom-f3q]

A fun feature would be that every country has its own unique ability or perk such as Germany having a group of stormtroopers charge when you reach the final trench or they could have an extra upgrade for the pill boxes to make them concrete or the British having a faster faster unit spawn rate or slightly lower cost

[@igorchoody3138]

Idea: Add bridges. The bridges could be build by the player/enemy when both the trench before and after the river is controlled, some maps could start with bridges already build, a bridge could be destroyed using artillery. If an engineer unit is ever added it could be responsible for building or repairing bridges.

[@Sethgames-q8j]

baron you launched this game when i turned 13 and today I'm 14 it's been a great year fo my life and your amazing game. thank you

[@DaBadMoonIsRisin]

Please, PLEASE add multiplayer! Also, for more updates, i think the ottoman empire would be really cool, with cavalry and the ability to make better defenses For italy, maybe a special bersagliere unit, and a buff in rough terrain. Last, a motorized vehicle being able to transport trooos quick and safe.

[@happerry4651]

I second the request for multiplayer.

[@Jhonatan_edwin]

Man yunno how much a server cost?

[@DaBadMoonIsRisin]

@@Jhonatan_edwin after talking to several other creaters (armchair historian and rattenreich game devs) i have realised😅

[@LeoLau-ip9bv]

@@DaBadMoonIsRisin steam pays for servers

[@DaBadMoonIsRisin]

@@LeoLau-ip9bv yes, but mp is still very expensive and time consuming to implement

[@GeneralDelta072]

The game is good, but it certainly could be better. Add some features when unlocking different things, more visual differences from upgrades, more unit types, more features, trench customizations, stuff like that. Main thing I want to see added, is when you unlock a new unit or ability, stuff from behind the HQ will spawn in such as, Buying tanks adds a vehicle workshop. Buying snipers adds a shooting range. Buying officers adds a map of a region along with little figures. Buying machine gunners adds an ammo stockpile. Buying flame troopers adds fuel tanks. Buying shotgunners adds an barracks. Buying stormtroopers adds an armory. Buying creeping barrages adds several artillery cannons far in the back.

[@wil1x-p3u]

Yep

[@blocoes2757]

it would be fun to see how riflemen have shovals and there could be a map with no trenches and you have to build then and you can connect the trenches so the soldeirs dont get shot wilst goign to the front lines, plus also nice to see how officers can well be an officer and give orders so like when you attack a wistle sounds and the officer can make the soldeirs target a sertain area and when you are aiming artillery the officer has binoculers and when you cann it it gets out a small phone that is already in the trench to call it in and the artilery fires, plus for the artillery to not just be a cannon but actual artilery with a loading animation. lovely game tho

[@LeoLau-ip9bv]

50th like awsome

[@TheElmTree.]

I think that an engineer would be interesting. They could be slightly weaker than normal infantry but would have a shovel and the ability to place down barbed wire. They could dig little holes that can only fit 1 or 2 units inside of them but chances of getting shot are reduced and tanks would just drive over them. The engineer's shovel can also be used to dig up landmines, though this will take a couple of seconds and leave the engineer vulnerable. Only one barbed wire can be placed per engineer and each one would slow down enemies and hurt them a little, tanks would run them over and destroy them though.

[@thinkimpostergaming4626]

Man you give me hope of creating an even more fabulous game keep the development up

[@thinkimpostergaming4626]

can you please release a version on mobile as many like myself want to experience the game but can not play on computer

[@Wunhez]

Since there are mines maybe add mine sweeper I also think there should be different turrets such as antitank gun other than just a simple machine gun or even mortar and barracks which can spawn your units at the trench you built it at and passively spawn troops and stronger troops when upgraded

[@marathon2544]

There are some suggestions i could give you. 1. Adding a New Tech Tree for the Tanks that equiped them with Blades so they can clean up the Minefield and Take lesser Damage. 2. A New Unit called the Sapper that can disable the Mines, are Poor in Combat, but are more difficult to Hit. P.S: You could even use The Sappers as a builder. Something like the Miner in Stickwar where the Sapper Delivers you supplies to your HQ or getting used to reinforce your Trenches with some good stuff. Also you should require a Sapper to Upgrade or add new defenses on a Trench so you cannot make Teleport a simple Sandbag to a Helm's Deep with a Snip on your Finger anymore.

[@sealseal2124]

Can we have a boss event for April fools? Like some big prototype tank, like the never finished German K-Wagon, and we have to try and kill it in a time limit before it pushes our base, and it defends itself with infantry and such?

[@yashwanthtulugu1363]

You know what this game needs a artillery officer that can disable any artillery coming into the trench unless it is precision artillery and he can only disable the artillery that is aimed in his Trench and that will make artillery more balanced and you can still use precision artillery

[@nathanmisterek]

I love this game so much congratulations on everything Baron

[@masterrob2000]

its only $5. go buy it, give it 5 stars. even if you play once, its still worth it in gold to help support him.

[@Cowboy-vp2so]

Baron! i’m a big fan of your game, and wanted to offer my thoughts. firstly, when you as the developer who knows the game inside out have to give yourself a boost (aka “haha where did THOSE medals come from?”), the game is probably a little too hard for the average player. secondly, having a mod workshop is awesome and should increase replay ability. i would like to see customizable weapons both small to large, and chemical, vehicles, units, cosmetics, etc. thirdly, i think it’d be awesome for a map scale increase, with different tactical options for different parts of the same trench and would add another depth of strategy to the game. an example would be, the south side wants to attack but the north side needs to defend. lastly, multiplayer would be a fantastic addition. thanks for reading!

[@orangeshirtguy01]

totally agree

[@LucasBrackleys]

a Bulgarian faction could include longer cooldowns and more expensive infantry but they would have better aim and speed as Bulgaria was known for having a well trained army

[@GoldWillow64]

There should be a mine sweeper that is really slow but clears out all the mines

[@Kumik256]

Can’t wait for more viedos of this game. One thing that I would add is smoke and fire effects caused by artillery strikes.

[@lukewinterbottom-xr7px]

Hi my childhood

[@CommanderthornStudios]

Hi childhood I'm anxiety and depression

[@ThatsOneRat]

😂

[@Rusty5701]

@@ThatsOneRat no

[@NightOpsBravo]

Hello

[@SDSStevey-xl4cr]

Rust748 Wacha mean no

[@MavOss-nu9bk]

it needs modular trenches so you can locate ammo storage, command centers, artillery, and more different sections : ) also you can add mine clearing vehicles vehicles

[@Leoni_X]

Heres an idea: When a tank gets destroyed it has a 50/50 chance of dropping 3 to 6 guys (Depends on how big the tank is) with pistol!

[@CadeMartin-n3n]

Luv u❤ Idea: make trench systems, connected trenches that can be contested by both sides at once, cuz there’s multiple trenches

[@lalaomxr6485]

I really love how this game, the developers and the community are coming together! Keep going Baron!

[@beathanbsg3994]

I remember convincing my mom to buy this game about 1 year ago since u upload the video abt the game

[@ThadDePadua9928]

Wonderful, nostalgia vibes be kicking hard. ;-;

[@Countryballgaming21]

Maybe there should be a casual mode so players who just want a fun or even easier time they can enjoy like no poison gas, artillery, minefields, or machine guns should be omitted so casual players don’t get entire army’s get wiped out

[@Commanderneptune0]

i think a sapper would be a cool way to interact with the land mines and i think a cool idea for a unit that switch's weapons depending on what's going on ex they'll use a cross bow to lunch a grenade into the trench and when their in a trench they'll switch to there gun or a option to do a bayonet charge

[@vonDog]

What if we added trenches that have tracks that would allow us to summon an armored train to defend that trench and maybe act as a place for new units to spawn

[@Male_crocodile44]

You should add like a special grenade that can trigger enemy mines and also a mortar thing that u can buy for ur trench instead of the machine gun thing. Keep it up baran!

[@HunterBoucher]

You should add air support like helicopters planes etc. basically you should add a bunch of air units like fighters strike aircraft etc. and you should add a airfield for them to fuel repair etc

[@Aussie_Entertainer]

for removing mines, an engineer would be a good idea. for example after you have captured a trench you can send in an engineer to remove the mines. when they come close to a mine they stop moving for a few seconds then the mine disappears, and they repeat until all the mines are gone on the defending side. I don't know how hard that would be to code though.

[@adisappointedfbiagent449]

The game should have a sapper unit that can build barbed wire and defuse mines

[@crw662]

Great idea

[@nukerbob4992]

I think you should add something where you can send just a type of unit instead of leaving no defence

[@CouchPotato524]

Is there like a war campaign already, if not, why not have where you play through select randomly generated levels on your chosen front until you achieve the objective, and each front could have its own sort of twist to it

[@jamiehammy17]

Love the vids your doing really well hope you have a good day ❤

[@rafalwozniak5177]

oh and when the artilary shoots and it hits a place make like a hole that can make it harder for the team your fighting aghianst or even you because snipers can hide in those holes and when the artilary shoots and hits a trench the trench should have a hole in it or simpaly one part of the trench is seperated from the other part

[@alexfirda9909]

When a tank is destroyed the enginers will pop out

[@AW-ms5in]

I think you should add a special unit which is a raidio man who if you have him on the battlefield once in a while he'll summen a squad of renforcements to your trench.

[@danielkirchmaier1749]

Make a world map where you can fight for individual territories, where you can play as an individual nation (also give germans better fortifications ;D)

[@Nate_wright]

Can you make a upgrade or repair function for sandbags so if you lose sand bags you can buy them back or upgrade them I think it would be very good and it’ll finally cure my problems with this games Also can you add a sandbox mode it’d be really fun Thx whoever read this and I hope you have a great day (like so baron can see please)

[@Kermit_the_addict]

You guys need to add engineers and make it to were you can only make mines with engineers and engineers convert enemy mines to your mines engineers should also be able to make barbed wire and when leading a charge they can destroy barbed wire please read!🤞🏻 Yap: Also I’ve been watching you’re videos since I was 7 with my dad now I’m 15 my favorite was always Kingdoms and castles and raven field videos I never imagined actually playing them myself till 2 years ago

[@thinkimpostergaming4626]

Finally we have such good history game online after decades

[@hollow6276]

hey baron love ur vids i have been watching you for a long time i wish you a good day man

[@Tango-eq1we]

This game needs trench raiders melee troops maybe with a bit of RMG like some troops with frying pans, clubs, sabers, axes, or other melee weapons. And the helmets could be wrapped in barbed wire.

[@WinerVonGames]

I would love to see fog of war as an idea, so that you can't see the enemy in a foggy map

[@Heteredony_JJ]

A feature that would be superb would be the introduction of engineers to clear enemy minefields. Could be nice to have a specific unit to be an engineer very efficient and an upgrade tree which allowed to teach infantry or officers to also clear the minefields, both when the trench is still held by the enemy and to remove the mines when you conquer one. Very nice game, hope it grows a lot.

[@Colin-e2y]

Just and idea Barron New unit engineers they can be hurt by mines and if an engineer runs over a mine it disappears just an idea love the vids keep up the good work

[@lukeconstantineau4296]

I would love to see the flags that change colours when you take a trench be the flag of the nation that controls it, or controlled it last, and white if it has never been controlled. As a final note, I would love to see this game be able to be played on MacOS. Thanks so much for all your hard work and what a great game!

[@walexfeliz8373]

hello, i have owned this game from the beggining and have 3 copies of the game on different computers. I would like to say that this game is going in the right direction and all the things you have planned to add are amazing. i would also say that i might be one of the first tp have over 200 hours in the game.

[@emillaskowski7301]

I have 4 ideas. 1. New base wich would be a Trench with 2 MG nest's some radios, rations. 2. New MG model the stationary one max upgrade could be a Wooden MG Nest with some sandbags and barbed wire. 3. I would love seeing the soldiers use their bayonet's. 4. They use ammo clips example : They fire 5 times their clip is empty so they have to reload basic and when their clip is empty they could use the bayonet mounted on the rifle to shank their enemies (scallywags). Hope ya consider some of these. Edit: I have 1 more idea. 1. New model for artilerry it would be a Trench next to the HQ With like 3 Artilerry pieces wich would actually fire and eject shells :>. 2. Edit. 1. Engineer's wichhhhh could place down barbed wire and repair the trenches from artilerry fire.

[@elionice740]

A suggestion. The stick men can create a tunnel to go around the enemy trench, and make a new mechanic to surround the enemy trench, making the trench surrender, making them POWs

[@dylanherrera5395]

The stickmen need a bit of an outline, sometimes the contrast is too low, probably a small white one

[@Timehhss]

Idk if u have this but u should add a campaign, and add something to work for, and try to add replayibility

[@Leader_cameraman]

Sea/Ocean battles or land invasions or auto artillery bunkers like it auto fires

[@tonkitdrix4235]

Im not sure how complex it would be to add, but a custom character/troop creator, similar to TABS' Unit Creator, can definitely push the modding scene even further, allowing for more creativity, and just overall more chaotic battles.

[@CommanderSheen]

I’m ngl, baron is the one who taught me how to play it. I got on the day it realesed and got the demo. Baron taught me ALL about the game so, thank you! 🙏

[@eliaramouz2587]

I really can't believe one year has passed, this game has gone a long way, keep up the good work.

[@Wolfiededer]

We need a Russia for Entente and Austria-Hungary for the Central powers!! And Multiplayer

[@davidstears7037]

Yeah, I saw this coming as I was watching the series. Saying you weren't going to add a campaign on release, which is typically where players learn about unit types and what things do, all the fancy whistles and doodads, I kinda saw the early fall of nostalgia. Especially since you've essentially released an unfurnished, no guide, lower quality, less interactive (Albeit, with a new funky take on Stickman art style) version of a FREE GAME that already existed. You did well, and I congratulate you and respect you for it. Because you did good. But I wish I found this sooner and was able to give you helpful input before it all happened. But ya'know what? It still turned out great. So thank you for this game. I hope you were able to read this whole comment before thinking of it as rude or mean, it's not the intention. Dunno what I'd be playing right now if it wasn't Stickman Trenches. Lol

[@juliofp8778]

I always play with my friends when they come home, thanks for all those good moments =D

[@Gaming00358]

Would be nice if there was random artillery strikes that just spawned not from the player or the AI and mines would also be cool to just spawn in from time to

[@a.r.k.a.n.d.a.t.7344]

Need this on mobile, and actually maybe you can left the soldier dead body on the battlefield, it Will be great Overall the game is great²²

[@GeneralVader112sus-fn6vj]

You should add zeppelin and biplanes

[@nikolasgamesandvideos5775]

I made a video showing the mine when it wasn't released because you shown it on a tiktok video.

[@carking0138]

I bought this game close to release, and I thought it was great then, and I still think it's great! I don't know why people would think it's too difficult, and I also would like to say that the demo and another (mobile) game called "Trench Warfare 1917" inspired me to buy it.

[@sop1918]

Modded units would be cool, eg, someone could make a plane machine gun attack that could be downloaded and game modes, for example: Attack: you have 1 trench, enemy has the rest,enemy can not attack, you must push through and break defences Conquest: both teams get 5 mins to attack/defend and after taking/losing trench roles swap. Both teams start at middle of map Sappers to defuse mines, and tunnelling? Very expensive and takes 5 mins and men where you dig to enemy trench increasing survivability

[@amjadabk8007]

Feature suggestion: The mines are sick! But i feel like if the enemy gets too many mines its really hard to take over their trench thats why im suggesting a new way of clearing mines. Using artillery! Not it will artillery be used to kill ze enemy but also to clear out a way for your own soldiers to attack. Amazing game and i hope it becomes the best!

[@raghncrow8104]

WOW 2023 - 2024 1 - year

[@mysticmelon2009]

Baron I have a suggestion for a Molotov cocktail special ability or unit?

[@devangiwaranashiwar.2719]

I think he read the comments and read my comment and said this is a good idea to add more countries

[@Steelraven66]

I need this on mobile! I NEED THIS!!!

[@lordfaladar6261]

get rid of "friendly" mines with a purchase option like when you upgrade to mines,so a "downgrade" to remove them also maybe a bunker to make artillery not as lethal? another final upgrade to the trench that adds a bunker?

[@ingridsamuel3347]

I have a idea for a cool new unit, the engineer. A unit that, in his free time fixes sandbags.

[@scottlabelle3225]

imagine adding the canadian faction which can summon an airdrop of food that makes alot of enemy units leave their trench leaving them open to sniper fire

[@charliedonnelly5449]

In the near future could you add a barbed wire upgrade similar to the minefield up grade, that would have more of a fighting chance, but can be destroyed by artillery, and loving the videos 😎👍

[@BUMBUMDUMDUM]

From what I remember from previous videos you were going to add a specialized unit for each faction but the only one you added was the stormtroopers,maybe for France you could do a self loading rifleman because the RSC was the first widely adopted semi auto rifle and Maybe for Britain you could make the shotgunner specific for them, just some ideas no pressure

[@psyfan3]

I feel like the mines should do a little less damage to the infantry and a lot less to the tanks and there to be a chance for the mines to not explode when they get hit and also you can have enemies mines slowly disappear when you take the trench and maybe a special ability which you use medal to pay like maybe like a spring offence type ability for the Germans

[@jaju1d312]

Its been interesting watching the development from the start till now

[@AdwaithP-t7d]

hay man, this is one of your fans . I was thinking about some new units for the game. some of these can be air units like a ww1 by plain fighter aircraft or a two seater bomber plain or even a blimp. some of the ground unites are Grenade, riflemen with Bennett and rifle Grenades. you have to install Ammo and Resupply because it feels like the units have infinite amount of bullets and tanks should not move off map in endless mode and need more health and power full weapons because they are modern technology during ww1.

[@legocraft9172]

Hey man i think it would be nice in the brutal mode to not know the ennemys position. You would need scouts or spy planes to know when to rush or to prepare for one. You would of course have a cooldown because just rushing because you know they dont have anyone is a little easy. Maybe be able to send only half the guys in the trench so you can juke the other player? Keep defending soldiers while the others die in action and prepare for a counter attack.

[@Sensei_Foosball]

You should do more with the cosmetic features. You mentioned at the beginning of the video that they slow troops down, but you should make it to where troops can take cover behind them too. If someone were to make a map with a very large distance between tenches, imagine how much more intense and awesome it would be if troops took cover behind cosmetics while charging too. One more thing, the bobbing/breathing animations that the troops have while waiting is very distracting. If that animation were to be toned down I think it would mean a lot to the some of us it bothers. Maybe make it a toggle-able thing in settings.

[@kelpman7339]

I think you should add a feature where you can press a button somehwere near a trench you control and it will evenly spread out the current troops in the trench, or add manual adjustments to a soldiers location inside the trench

[@TheJimtanker]

It's wild that you recreated Trenches II.

[@overcraft9746]

alone that ur the devoloper makes it mega, but one thing that u could make is that like with an riflemen, u can say which rifle he is using so there is more varianty in the game but I dont say that really need to do that. Even if ur not gonna do that keep the updates up and keep making vids cause bove are amazing

[@Lookingsus]

We need a campaign

[@drewgamerkid1157]

i haven't played this but I've seen videos on it. i didn't realize you were one of the people making it. i knew that you made bot wars but didn't know that you made this. the game looks good i might buy it. also for the steam workshop i think a good thing that you can work on to allow modders to do easily is let them make new weapons or like you said new units. also new barriers and that kind of stuff. kind of like ravenfield has the unity modding system that allows there to be cool mods for the game like the extas collection for ravenfield or the modded maps that that Normandy map. that was just my thought on what type of mods should be possible. and i know it probably wont be easy to add things like that but i think it would be cool.

[@LivingFantastic]

Really enjoy this game! Would love a cavalry charge ability that functions like tanks

[@death_bull_7_428]

Fun idea: A game mode where you and your enemy have infinite money so the mode is just spamming Name ideas: rich mode, chaos mode Who wants this👇👇👇👇 👇👇👇👇

[@death_bull_7_428]

Yes I liked my own comment

[@Opwitherskeleton]

I wish he would make bot wars videos again

[@grilledcheeseonly]

What a crazy experience indeed!

[@hayleylampacher4565]

Baron ty so much for a king this game ty so much and I apritate it,it’s so funnn :D

[@LouisbertrandIvander-iw9mb]

I think you add plane like plane bomber that drop bomb in enemy trenches

[@ANormalPlaceOfficial-ysrv]

Send a minesweeper.

[@neofulcrum5013]

You did good Baron

[@gggdebeste5515]

Will we ever get multiplayer and cavalry in the future? No matter i still love the game and watching your game developing journey

[@wesleysebree3770]

a trench side affect. such that a troop could get sick and that over time that troop gets sick and they will stay sick as long as they stay in the trenches. or something like a troop or two will die as they go into the trench because of mud killing them. another idea is a moral mechanic to where some soldiers will panic and run from the trench or battle field if they see other soldiers (on there side) die. This would also mean that a commander would be more valuable and risky to have because they would improve the troops moral but when they die the troop moral will reach rock bottom and most of them will run.

[@landoningram4969]

ADD MULTIPLAYER ! Also the mines are OP the artillery should destroy the mines or on the tech tree infantry should get an “probably mine buff “ so that soldiers have a 50/50 chance on the mines going off