Rick S5 vs Shane S2 || The Walking dead

[@Marius-uz9cu]

An actual fair duel,the first one I've seen. Everyone just thinks that just becouse Rick survived more in the show he's better at a lot of things than shane,witch is not true. Great job!

[@lord-pulse8888]

well no Shane is dead so not much fight in him anymore rick is alive BIIIIGGG difference I'm sure u understand

[@tearsofamon]

@@lord-pulse8888 In an actual hand to hand combat Shane might have the upper hand. Rick could only kill him because he played games with his head and Shane at this point was mentally unstable and too far gone

[@concavekimono8036]

Only thing I didn't find fair was kill count, since Rick has a 3 season lead in that department and the show was years ahead at that point

[@miraculousmememaker2986]

@@lord-pulse8888 agreed, and I also think people forget who killed Shane...

[@poordude2175]

@@miraculousmememaker2986 Shane killed himself bro. Why do you think he put his gun on his waist holder and gave Rick a chance to lift his gun? He wanted Rick to harden there

[@DarckMaster998]

Season 5 Rick is a combine of Rick and Shane, he was unstopable, even Negan said that he wouldnt messed with that Rick

[@bogi-h]

rick s5 low-mid diffs shane but i think negan was mostly just joking bc of how rick looked

[@Im_Negan_]

Right ricks my b!tch

[@sansan445]

@@bogi-h not in a fair fight just because he survived alot more doesn't mean he is the better fighter

[@lold6d2]

yeah but Negan said that ironically to offend Rick

[@themanwhowalkeddead925]

he was making Rick think he wasn’t a good leader anymore.

[@OVK-Productions]

S5 Rick is way more ruthless let’s be honest, the dude legit bit someones neck out lmao

[@jackdouglas9163]

Tbh Shane would have done the same in that situation

[@Wijikata]

@@jackdouglas9163 tbf we could make a lot of assumptions and came with no clear winner so it’s better to stay with what really happened

[@H.K.5]

Shane shot an innocent man and left him to get eaten by walkers.

[@pooya4434]

@@H.K.5 so did Rick with the police officer in s5

[@LiterallySpikeSpiegel]

@@pooya4434 “Can’t go back, Bob.”

[@arkhamani5o147]

I don’t understand how people think Shane could beat Rick Shane couldn’t kill Rick even when he made a plan a was the man with the gun

[@Kindy__]

Thats iq battle witch got shane KEKW

[@Kindy__]

Rick can beat his ass

[@xavierhernandez2781]

Shane plan has failed tho but Rick kill him

[@jackdouglas9163]

Bro Shane beats Rick

[@Kindy__]

@@jackdouglas9163 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@dryl6101]

Shane was wayyyy ahead of his time for the apocalypse he adjusted almost right away and was honestly right alot of the time on how to do things. If he had not died so early because of internal conflict and emotions he wouldve been a star survivor, probably similar to a negan type

[@TipoIrritable]

And what happened when Negan fought with Rick? *Slices neck*

[@maskedninja6883]

But jealousy got him killed, jealousy gets you killed in the apocalypse

[@LuckySevens]

Shane adapted to the new world faster than everyone else, but he died before there was really any real conflict with other groups. Rick has been through it all and has faced countless groups of really dangerous people. He’s had to beat them in gunfights, hand to hand, and strategy. There’s no doubt in my mind that Shane was ready to take on those challenges and would’ve done just fine in a lot of those same situations that Rick has been in, but as it stands he died too early to know for sure. Rick definitely wins this one.

[@23jxrgee]

yo creo que te equivocas en un punto, shane no hubiera peleado con ningún grupo, el buscaba la supervivencia a toda costa, no encontrarse a nadie, no llevar más gente, nada de nada, rick es más de arriesgarse es por eso que es el mejor lider que vayan a tener

[@footedthread9315]

i take shane for himself and his potential, shane is the better rick

[@footedthread9315]

@AzogExT that would be interesting

[@hiro7489]

Shane only lost to Rick because he wanted rick to kill him. He wanted rick to do it to become the leader he needs to be. Shane was never gonna kill rick in that field.

[@uselesscasual2069]

@@footedthread9315bro no he isn’t Rick was smart enough to know what Shane was planning and put him down like a dog

[@thegodinme83]

The reason why Shane is hard to beat for people asking is because he knew how to survive when there no referee in the middle and Shane also knew how to get out of trouble if he ever had issue and the dude was crazy

[@TipoIrritable]

S5 Rick was way crazier

[@tearsofamon]

All their problems aside Rick, Shane and Daryl would be the most badass Trio ever, everybody would know their names and would be feared even by enemy communities

[@twinkthatloveslotrtrilogy7676]

They would take on Saviors alone

[@henrypain1664]

Season 5 Rick is one of the most ruthless characters of the show

[@Wilk32]

the most* (i think) like i don’t know who would come close probably only negan really

[@TipoIrritable]

Season 7 >

[@Stormertheboy]

If shane survived till sesson 5 he woulda been an absolute monster

[@endrygenere4823]

Esa comparación esta mal ,el rick de la temporada 2 con poca experiencia pudo ganarle a shane ,si el rick de la temporada 5 el cual hasta parece un asesino serial ,se enfrentará con shane ,shane moriría al instante

[@Xd-pm7db]

Pero Si el de la Temporada 2 le dio una paliza 😑

[@davidvelasco7997]

@@Xd-pm7db porque Rick no sabía cómo pelear y contenía su fuerza aparte era su amigo y no quería hacerle daño en ese entonces, ahora Rick en la 5ta temporada es un degenerado sanguinario que no le importó nada

[@Xd-pm7db]

@@davidvelasco7997 Bueno Igual los Dos Si Se Dieron Una Paliza Pero Fue Rick Quien intento dar el Primer Golpe Y Shane Lo "bloqueo" Si es que se puede decir asi

[@davidvelasco7997]

@@Xd-pm7db claro

[@emilianoXD4738]

@@davidvelasco7997 Por eso mismo, si shane no hubiera muerto y hubiera evoluciónado como rick, creeme que sería incluso tan peligroso como alpha o negan

[@tkdon2195]

si rick y shane hubieran mantenido su amistad en el apocalipsis zombie hubieran sido imparables ni el gobernador hubiera tenido oportunidad contra ellos

[@yehzz6411]

not even close season 5 rick is the most dangerous he has been season 2 Shane was not smart which lead to his death while rick in season 5 takes no chances doesn't hesitate to kill or do what needs to be done no matter how inhumane it is Shane doesn't measure up to this version of rick.

[@thegodinme83]

You do realize Rick wouldn’t have been like Shane if it wasn’t for shane right and he may not be smart but he has probably one of the best battle IQ in the show shane learn quickly while it took Rick like few episode just to become like shane and the sad thing was he was a cop cops and military personnel should know how to play the rules when there’s no referee in the middle which shane did

[@footedthread9315]

at the time shane was alive, they didn't deal with people (with shane there) He was also heavily held back by rick, Ricks only like shane in season 5, because his season 2 self isn't holding him back, like how shane was held back.

[@Marc93.]

S5 Rick is belongs among the Goatest Characters in Series history

[@pinkfloyd9759]

After biting that dude's throast off I would say that Rick will come out on top in any physical confrontation in TWD but we shouldn't forget Shane was already living in S5 when everyone was still in S2 so he would have been a beast by the time of S5.

[@Cswyr777]

Great video man! They grew up together and trained together, so it makes sense they would be equally matched.

[@parkourkhgcf3727]

Cswyr when the new video?:(

[@lupeviera9812]

Shane nunca fue buen líder ni supo vivir bien, solo se dejó llevar por la pasión y devoción que tenía a Lori y Carl. Mintió y abandonó a Rick. No se la jugaba por los suyos, si hasta Lori saco cojones para decir que iba a la ciudad cuando hablaron con Rick por radio, exponia a los demás a hacer el trabajo duro mientras el se pavoneaba por el campamento con su escopeta mandando a los otros. En cambio Rick desde que llegó se la jugó por todos incluso sacrificandose. Era un líder nato, único. Vale que Negan consiguió doblegarlo por un rato, hasta que le echo pelotas y lo venció. No digo que Shane no fuera luchador, solo que no supo serlo. El amor y los celos lo cegaron. Era muy egoista. Yo soy TeamRick forever. Se lo ganó. 😊👌

[@Bruno_Finch]

Very good character analysis 👌

[@lupeviera9812]

@@Bruno_Finch Thank 😊👌

[@Deadmetro67]

Dude really gave Shane free points let’s be honest Shane wins in hand to hand combat but we all know the moment Rick gets ahead of the time especially S5, it’s usually done with. The moment you mess up with Rick and make a mistake it’s hard to come back, and Shane makes a lot more errors and mistakes in the show than people lead on

[@footedthread9315]

heh, Season 5 Rick is Shane

[@hammywoods]

Shit that was the coolest thing ever, like a movie in just a minute. Rick definitely wins, BUT if Shane ever survived later seasons he'd most likely win

[@footedthread9315]

i can agree with this, but if Shane lived, He'd destroy rick

[@skyistaken1605]

Rick wins because he is more emotionally stable

[@Xxsyanpes]

Categories like gun duel , weapons goes easily Shane He was the best gun teacher Even Back than Rick sawed

[@bogi-h]

argument doesnt really make sense because i can be smarter than a teacher but he could be better in teaching knowledge and experience to others

[@FriedPotatoesForLife]

Shane is brute strength vs Rick is endurance. Shane wins he is more pumped up than Rick is, Rick is weak but he never gives up

[@Karnage543]

Just imagine S5 Shane. 😱

[@ikrightt]

S5 Rick has the same brown t-shirt as Shane in S2.

[@Spooder_man921]

Can we get one for daryl vs rick or daryl vs Meryl? Keep up the great work

[@caldude13able]

If Shane had moved on from Lori and wasn't slowly unhinging, he would win hands down. Rick was a slow burner but saw that Shane was right all along and he hated that so I think either way for me it's Shane. Killing your number 2 and best friend is no joke, apocalypse no apocalypse

[@barisk4t4n4]

Shane even beat Rick S2 lol

[@_max78]

Rick S2 is weak

[@_max78]

@Badri Katanya Mah Ofcourse he is better in S9. But in S2 he is still weak

[@twinkthatloveslotrtrilogy7676]

No he didnt

[@arachnidsv2245]

Rick season 2 was a peace making ass person tryna reason with everyone even Shane after everything he has done plus Shane tried killing Rick that wasn’t the same attentions Rick had for Shane

[@troysponsler504]

What? When? Rick beat the shit out of Shane in season 2 in hand to hand and Shane had to ambush him to try to kill him

[@endrygenere4823]

Yo creo que shane esta sobrevalorado, el solo mató a dos personas que ni siquiera sabían defenderse, mientras que rick de la temporada 5 mató a el líder del grupo de terminus y al lider de los merodeadores arrancandole la garganta con sus propios dientes

[@thegodinme83]

I think Rick wins but the terminus group were overrated as well like Shane would be able to beat those guys if he was still alive and if not he’ll know how to get them out of trouble your forgetting that Rick wouldn’t have become like shane if it wasn’t for SHANE

[@tkdon2195]

yo creo que ambos destacan en diferentes aspectos por ejemplo shane en pelea mano a mano es superior a rick,y rick es mas de analizar la situacion algo que en un apocalipsis zombie es mas util. Todo dependeria de la situacion en que se ponga a ambos a enfrentarse para saber cual es mejor

[@RMasterZombie]

Shane cuerpo a cuerpo le ganaba a Rick fácilmente, cuando se pelean se ve claramente como Rick no pudo hacer nada, Rick pudo derribar a Shane solo por qué el estaba intentando matar a randalf y Rick le llegó por la espalda, así que decir que Shane solo le gana a gente que no sabe pelear es un mal argumento, aparte de que en ese momento de la serie casi todos tenían miedo a matar, y Shane lo hacía sin dudarlo.

[@Carlos90889]

El líder del grupo de Terminus no era un luchador, era el equivalente de Olivia, solo contaba y organizaba todo, nunca se metía en líos. Hasta Glenn de la temporada 1 podría ganarle. Y tampoco puede jactarse de destruir Terminus, porque lo humillaron 2 veces, de no ser por Carol los restos de Rick y su grupo estarían flotando como mierda en algún inodoro de las instalaciones de Terminus. Y la infame mordida que tanto les gusta nombrar a los fanáticos de Rick, uso eso como último recurso, Joe lo estaba haciendo mierda, lo tenía contra las rejas al pobre de Rick, un gordo viejo.

[@endrygenere4823]

@@Carlos90889 solo a ti se te ocurre comparar ignorantemente a Gareth con Olivia , Gareth talvez no era un luchador pero era muy peligroso , es cierto que casi todo el grupo hubiera muerto sino fuera por Carol, pero yo dije que Rick fue el que terminó todo el problema asesinado a Gareth, además esa " infame " mordida de la que hablas, la cual le gusto a todos menos a ti porque eres un ignorante, Rick se volvió obligado a hacer eso porque el no es un personaje invencible como Jason Statham que puede matar facilmente a 15 hombres el solo, rick asesino a joe mordiendo su cuello como último recurso porque el grupo de joe los atacaron por sorpresa durante la noche y también los superaban en número, y Rick no se iba a quedar mirando sin hacer nada

[@davidvelasco8780]

No voy a criticar para nada, me gustó este video pero yo le vi pequeños errores en mi opinión, en la fuerza (Strength) para mi el punto se lleva Rick porque me da entender que Rick contiene su fuerza, ya que se le pudo ver golpeando a Tyreese descontrolado en la 4ta temporada OJO descontrolado si se lo hubiera visto a Rick descontrolado peleando con el gobernador hubiera ganado, obviamente en la 1era y 2da temporada no tenía fuerza, ahora imagínense en la 5ta aunque no se lo haya visto su fuerza porque se defendía con su magnum y con su machete mango rojo, en Colder tambien Rick se lleva el punto porque después de matar a su amigo Shane, Rick se vuelve mas frío mostrando desconfianza en las personas hasta la misma Andrea lo dijo "Rick esta frío", hasta noqueó a Aaron con una frialdad, en 1vs1 obviamente Rick con las estrategias que hace y más lo bestia que es en la 5ta temporada, y en More Brutal ambos están parejos pero aquí Rick demostró ser mas brutal y sanguinario. No es que sea un fanboy de Rick Grimes solo he considerado su evolución en la primera, segunda, tercera, cuarta y quinta temporada y es ahí que me puse analizar. Pero no olvidare que antes de que empezara todo el apocalipsis Rick y Shane eran mejores amigos. Buen video y la canción le queda 10 de 10

[@endrygenere4823]

Tienes toda la razón 👌

[@HAERTX370]

Demasiado Basado 👍

[@nicolaspacheco15]

Rick Grimes >>>

[@Carlos90889]

Te voy a corregir, porque estás diciendo cualquier cosa. Primero, el punto de fuerza para Shane está justificado. En su pelea contra Rick se puede ver lo contundentes que son los golpes de Shane, pega tan fuerte que varias veces mando a Rick al suelo en su combate. En cambio, Rick no podía hacerle nada a Shane, ya que este se tanqueaba con facilidad todos los golpes que le daba, y no se estaba conteniendo, Rick estaba enojado, harto de Shane, se quería desquitar y no pudo. En colder están casi parejos, aunque Rick es un poco más sádico por lo del tema de Joe y que le arrancó el cuello a mordidas. Y en 1v1 se divide en dos, combate armado y combate mano a mano, en el primer caso Rick es mejor que Shane, más rápido y certero, además de que tiene mucha experiencia haciendo estrategias, en cambio, Shane es mucho más bueno en lo que pelear mano a mano se trata, pega fuerte, es resistente, y sabe bloquear y esquivar, además de que usa llaves para inmovilizar, como hizo con Daryl.

[@davidvelasco8780]

@@Carlos90889 Hola amigo, que tal, con todo respeto el vídeo trata sobre Rick Temporada 5 vs Shane Temporada 2, creo que en mi comentario principal me olvidé de aclarar que es una opinión personal bajo mi perspectiva de este versus, tengo que decir que yo no soy un sabelotodo de The Walking Dead. En tu comentario, el primer Párrafo estás comparando a Rick S2 vs Shane S2 es obvio que Shane se lleva al punto por las veces que fue CASI noqueado (Rick), pero ya Shane estaba descontrolado por lo que sus golpes ya eran demasiado fuertes con potencia (lo mismo de Rick S4 y Tyreese) en ese momento Shane quería matar a Rick. Sin embargo Rick puso Resistencia y el deseaba que Shane volviera a ser a como era antes pero TODA LA COMUNIDAD DE TWD sabemos que estaba corrompido, Rick lo que quería demostrar es que ahora el va a tomar decisiones, hay un punto cuando conversan Rick y Shane por lo de Lori Rick dice lo siguiente: "Cuando me di cuenta y me di cuenta muy rápido quería partirte la cara arrancarte los dientes, pero no lo hice me contuve" (algo así) y otro diálogo más después de la pelea "Si quieres matarme, no te bastará con una golpiza". Si nos enfocamos en Rick S5 vs Shane S2, Rick es superior a Shane en todos los sentidos Rick supo controlar la ira no dejó que ese sentimiento se apodere de él, cosa que Shane se dejó manipular pero salió perdiendo.

[@HeadHunterrYT]

Rick, guy bit a man's jugular out 🤣

[@turunen5515]

Rick and shane are both more brutal than each other???

[@Jasper30000]

Imagine a season 5 shane 💀💀

[@fandiTWD]

Omg💀💀☠️☠️

[@Chompenheimer]

Shane would win a gun duel, man was literally a police firearms trainer

[@sharpaloss]

i hate when ppl say shane was “ahead of his time” he had no desire to hold onto his humanity and made decisions based on his emotions without thinking about any potential benefits, and all of his actions had selfish intent

[@quonnellgreene6219]

“You decide” That’s such a cop out

[@gerardogomez2820]

Rick gana en todo, en especial si hablamos del de la temporada 5, el de la temporada 2 si era más débil que Shane

[@e.y.f.n]

Es que en eso sí te equivocas, por qué si es más fuerte Shane de la temporada 2 que el Rick de la misma temporada, entonces por qué lo venció Rick?

[@gerardogomez2820]

@@e.y.f.n Rick? Cuando lo mata ? Porque Shane literalmente ya se había rendido de intentar asesinarlo esa noche

[@e.y.f.n]

@@gerardogomez2820 crees que ya se había rendido?, Tarde o temprano iba a terminar matando a Rick, es por eso que Rick hizo lo que hizo, por qué como tal Rick no quería hacerlo.

[@davidvelasco7997]

En si Rick de la temporada 2 si era débil estaba por debajo de Shane pero a través con lo que ha pasado el tiempo aumentó su fuerza y la forma de analizar las cosas. Y si que se ha visto a Shane rendirse pues no aún así iba a matar a Rick, Shane tenía apuntado a Rick pero bajo la guardia al coger la Magnum de Rick.

[@davidvelasco7997]

Y aún así en esa temporada 5 era como más sanguinario, si era de matar lo hacía sin pensarlo dos veces.

[@y2theori]

if anyone here says that Rick loses im sorry but you are wrong. Shane literally planned Ricks whole demise had him at gunpoint and still got clapped. Rick clapped him at the start of the apocalypse. S5 rick that has been through a war with the governor and all the shit with Terminus easily stomps Shane.

[@Mochalatte69]

one thing for sure is that they are one of best characters in any show portrayed by two outstanding actors. Shane stole the show in season 2 especially the barn segment, and rick always puts 100% into his acting and emotions.

[@brent8169]

We saw Rick vs Shane tho, Rick got Shane to the point of using weapons bc he couldn’t beat him hand to hand

[@Sswineamer69]

I'd say gun duel would be Shane. Rick even said he was the best instructor he knew.

[@CP4521]

We needed shane to live. Shane lives > They get to the prison > Shane kills andrew > Lori, TDog Live > Judith is born > Shane helps with the governor wars > The governor dies

[@phantomproductions7597]

I thought it was just breaking bad with these edits lol I love that it's Katey Perry too

[@RickyDooDah]

bro said “better show” 💀

[@endrygenere4823]

Algo que hay que decir es que cuando le dispararon a rick en el primer episodio y luego cuando comenzo el virus zombie ,shane encerró a rick en la habitación del hospital para que los caminantes no lo atacaran, shane fue el primer amigo de rick y si no se hubiera vuelto loco de seguro sería un lider como daryl

[@gabyn5091]

Rick wins gun duel? Shane was the certified weapons instructor or something wasn't he?

[@gsaucegaming6635]

You forgot to add one to Rick when most applied to him

[@idontknowwhattoputformyuse1104]

Imagine season 5 rick vs season 5 shane

[@napstersneaks999]

I really wished Shane survived as long as Daryl now. He would've replaced Rick while he's away (assuming there's a proper character development).

[@ThatWasLD]

They would’ve been a nasty duo

[@zackarydunker7324]

Rick, he literally bit someone's throat out!!!!!!

[@historywithphacanga4557]

s5 rick = s2 shane

[@swifttodeath]

Iconic moments goes to shane WHAT 😭😭😭

[@TheDarkKnight11106]

Shane definitely adapted quicker to the apocalypse than Rick, but i Rick would do anything to keep Carl and Judith and the rest of the group alive, whereas Shane could be pretty selfish sometimes

[@AbdouwakilnajibInoussa-xv6qv]

Si shane avais vécu plus longtemps il serait devenu le gars le plus fort de la séries. Rick lui a eu le temps de s'adapter . Donc pour moi Rick gagne

[@TheLastPatriot_1776]

Shane was on of the best TWD characters Rick will always be the GOAT

[@jentzennn9702]

Rick wins, respectfully you were just handing out free points to Shane.

[@IXCANADATV]

imagine they brought back Shane in the walking dead tho mane I miss this guy

[@werewolf7872]

Shane is better he doesn’t hesitate to make the tough call he’s stronger and has more power

[@23jxrgee]

estás equivocado, el estaba loco, esas decisiones difíciles que dices tú lo llevaron a su muerte, rick no dudo desde que shane murió.

[@fonfuten5126]

No way shane is equal to rick. Man lost with s2 rick 💀💀💀

[@goldfish1091]

Shane didn't get to fight rick stabbed him

[@geniusmp43]

POV give more points to Shane to satisfy my fanaticism 💀

[@realBOTRIP]

The best edit yet subscribed!

[@juliad4518]

I really wish Shane didn’t turn out to be the way he did because if he kept on with Rick through the seasons they would be unstoppable

[@dragonball51255]

What? Rick literally beat shane in s2 and even since then he was even more crazier ever since then proving to be more badass of a character

[@blackwalker6369]

Eres el mejor bro ♧

[@twdxr_]

Gracias bro

[@blackwalker6369]

No ati #TWDXR

[@reaperprince0]

Hand to hand combat to Shane? He got his ass whooped by Rick in S2 when Randall almost got shot.

[@RuzzyID]

Shane would win in Durability. He took countless hits from Rick in s2 who was still fairly strong, and kept moving like it was nothing.

[@Champ2477]

I love both but since day one I love Shane 💛

[@Wilk32]

moments of madness to rick, i don’t remember if it was season 4 5 or 6 but there was the red handled machete and when he killed those claimers

[@Kaeden45if]

i feel like rick would win because back in s2 shane was crazy he would shoot anyone who he didnt knew he didnt want anyone coming he had no mercy for anybody and then he made a interesting plan to kill rick but it didnt work and now rick gain more experience over the seasons.

[@xavierhernandez2781]

Rick is always the winner

[@mecicarecaoficial]

cara, literalmente o rick amassa o shane sem nenhuma dificuldade. shane é muito superestimado

[@MarinesOnTop]

S2 Rick literally had Shane on the floor that one episode so actually hand to hand combat goes to Rick

[@zocker4968]

Fair enough, but imagine if Shane could also evolve like Rick 😍

[@AngelDamMo333]

El Rick de la tem 5 si que era despiadado

[@Z3AL316]

Season 5 Rick would destroy season 2 Shane, Rick wouldn’t even argue he would just do what has to be done

[@TweekLudwig]

In my opinion? The "kill count" stat doesn't really count, if it was S2 for both, but S5 Rick existed in S2, then I'd see it as "fair", but I agree with everything else other than "1v1" because.. We know who won that in the end lmao

[@jkidd1982]

This is tough, but i would say season 2 Shane is still more dangerous than season 5 Rick. Coz Shane was wicked and short tempered. Rick just went bat shit crazy temporarily coz of his situation. Bot sexy af in that tight brown tee though🔥

[@WolfKissPrime]

Hey dude, you don't mind if I put it on tik tok

[@FancyCat229]

If it’s season 5 rick vs Shane in season 2 then idk Lets assume everything is like normal but Shane is suddenly alive again Rick wouldn’t be able to kill Kill because of the guilt IK he was cruel but he wouldn’t be mad at him probably shocked and Shane we all saw that he can’t kill Rick because he still thinks of him as his brother so idk

[@yusufyuce8942]

how many differences were there, how did he catch up?

[@andrey_everest0379]

Shane better

[@_max78]

Rick is more brutal

[@sametjwrld]

Super cool edit🥶 Shane Walsh💜✊

[@arunasrancevas6095]

Based Shane Walsh appreciator

[@shadowmomochiuchiha6839]

rick rocks shane

[@k125catu5]

Imagine Shane live in Season 5, maybe primed Rick would be to hard to challenge him.

[@TWDCadenEdits]

Rick Grimes wins High Diff. Also W edit! (But Strength goes to Rick).

[@TheBlackKakashi]

I got 24-16 Rick. If you’re using just season five Rick and not seasons 1-5 Rick. I can understand why it’s such a close battle.

[@nicokollar9131]

there is no way u called someone colder that s5 rick

[@Arierx]

if they fought i feel like s5 rick would do som crazy shi like how he bit that one dudes neck out

[@AngelDamMo333]

ojala shane ubiera vivido hasta la tem 5

[@hopelesslyoptimistic8231]

Don’t forget season 2 Rick was able to defeat Shane so Season 5 Rick would obliterate him.

[@nfhsnsbbh]

What is the song name??

[@anderunanueroca608]

Es que esta comparación es ridícula, se le da un bombo a Shane completamente innecesario fruto de los reels que se estan viendo. Quien ha visto TWD hasta el último capítulo de la serie sabe que no hay comparación posible porque Rick pulveriza a Shane. Es mas hasta Aaron de la temporada 11 destroza a Shane por dios….

[@parkurprosu31]

biq rick ruthless rick crazy rick iconic moments rick

[@gvoxedits]

Shane walsh neg diff

[@martinkramer5829]

Shane could barely beat a Season 2 Rick. Rick was in his prime in Season 5 and he had more power.

[@stoneminder]

I think Rick is way more 'cold-blooded' than Shane. Shane went nuts bcs of his probably the only friend's wife. I do get why he was so obsessed with Lori but that doesnt mean its something forgivable or justifiable. Shane was a selfish man, Rick knew he had slept with his wife all along yet he refrained himself while Shane was assaulting Lori both physically and mentally or scheming aganist. Winner? All-in-all Rick.

[@stoneminder]

Altough, it makes me happy and content thinking that he sacrificied himself in the end for the group, Rick and Lori-Carl. Both by the end of the season did understand that they will never be able to get along like in the old world. The world of Walking Dead really did uncover their realself.

[@go-ryan8119]

"Hand to hand combat" but rick knifed shane guts out

[@trizard3940]

If it was hand to hand Shane wins at extreme difficulty but if there's guns involved than rick wins at extreme difficulty

[@teari3picz724]

As much as I love Shane he would definitely lose to s5 Rick he just been through more and has more experience and Rick has shown he would do anything to survive and protect his family