Rock INSCRIPTIONS debunk 7th century ISLAM! (#6)

[@arunraja3084]

God Bless Alfadi nd Jay U people R blessing to all, Have a wonderful journey, ur so accurate to minute details ,keep coming,middle east is so blessed because of u people.i am happy for my brothers nd sisters come on home .

[@xondeez757]

this video is easily refuted simply because the companions of muhammad lived after his death, most died between 660 and 700. so the reason why you wont find evidence from them is simply because the companions didnt allow the newer muslims to do anything muhmmad didnt do himself. the new muslims attempted to start new things but the companions stopped them every single time, its only when all of them died out is when the newer muslims started doing things the earlier muslims didnt do like carving rocks.

[@arunraja3084]

@@xondeez757 repent, brother come to Jesus there is no time, save urself God Bless u

[@dfwtransport2420]

@@arunraja3084 - Muslims worship the Lord of Abraham who is not part of a polytheistic Trinity. Jews and Muslims worship the one God who begets not nor was he begotten and there is none like unto him.

[@arunraja3084]

@@dfwtransport2420 repent, accept Jesus as ur Lord save urself come out of darkness brother there is no time try to read Bible and ask God for understanding take care

[@marisaanta4118]

@@xondeez757 given that there is no evidence at all of islamic existence in the 7th century it only supports Jays theory that Islam did not start the way Muslims believe it to.

[@tzadik36]

The upanishads say "Truth alone will triumph". If indeed so, then those who build their house on lies have much to worry about.

[@dsm5d723]

ALL said in words are "lies." India had the big math cycles embedded more deeply than other places.

[@xondeez757]

this video is easily refuted simply because the companions of muhammad lived after his death, most died between 660 and 700. so the reason why you wont find evidence from them is simply because the companions didnt allow the newer muslims to do anything muhmmad didnt do himself. the new muslims attempted to start new things but the companions stopped them every single time, its only when all of them died out is when the newer muslims started doing things the earlier muslims didnt do like carving rocks.

[@paladinhansen137]

@@dsm5d723 Are you hindu?

[@dsm5d723]

@@paladinhansen137 I am a born Jew, not or ever practicing, and not Bar Miztvahed. When I had my Y2K Bug contact with the Creator, MY people did what people do, to their own, and tried to steal my mind for their story. It was all very decausative, as though I was making them do it. Want to ask them now? A Kohelet I was dragged to confirmed my suspicions. In the one out of one in ten, they call Mysticism; if you need community, then it is theirs. I told them to get to the back of the line. My math, not the Rebbe's.

[@paladinhansen137]

@@dsm5d723 So Gematria/Isopsephy of Hebrew and Greek?. Its great stuff. 37 is my favorite number.

[@Speakers154]

This series is brilliant! Jay was born for this job. Thank God we have him to expose Islam's historicity.

[@_John_P]

@EveryIsnaad IsFabricated Mary is mentioned in the Quran, is the Quran wrong too? If it is, then it did not come from Allah.

[@sergiodeativo1470]

@EveryIsnaad IsFabricated stop being a troll

[@_John_P]

@John Wick The Quran mentions Jesus, is the Quran wrong too?

[@_John_P]

@John Wick It's Logic 101: If you accept the Quran came from Allah and the Quran talks about a person, but you don't believe that person existed, then you don't believe in the Quran either, and my acceptance of the Quran is completely irrelevant.

[@snowright1132]

@@_John_P There's a piece written in the New York Times, that Archaeologists have discovered an inscription carved into lime stone in Jerusalem dated to be 2000 yrs old, that say's "James son of Joseph brother of Jesus". It's the earliest rock inscription found thus far. Scholars take it as authentic.

[@TonyFelix-wc9qz]

God bless yourll brother's for this is a good subject that we have to be alert for

[@xondeez757]

this video is easily refuted simply because the companions of muhammad lived after his death, most died between 660 and 700. so the reason why you wont find evidence from them is simply because the companions didnt allow the newer muslims to do anything muhmmad didnt do himself. the new muslims attempted to start new things but the companions stopped them every single time, its only when all of them died out is when the newer muslims started doing things the earlier muslims didnt do like carving rocks.

[@scp3178]

Cool, the Star Wars - like intro. Another building block of destroying the "7th. century islam" myth. Thanks.

[@rabukkayeshua2479]

Horayyyy... the puzzles has a shape after all... Thank you Al Fadi & Jay... Carry on... Expose the dyno scams ☝✊🎖💐🥰

[@littleyeshayahou8455]

If only this was taught in all schools

[@mindscape1621]

@CNN is Fake News Armed military presence and showing proof how empires manipulate and rewrite history wouĺd help. WE CAN'T GO ON LIKE THIS ANYMORE!

[@xondeez757]

this video is easily refuted simply because the companions of muhammad lived after his death, most died between 660 and 700. so the reason why you wont find evidence from them is simply because the companions didnt allow the newer muslims to do anything muhmmad didnt do himself. the new muslims attempted to start new things but the companions stopped them every single time, its only when all of them died out is when the newer muslims started doing things the earlier muslims didnt do like carving rocks.

[@bngr_bngr]

Xon Deez is this the reason that the Qur'an is not complete and full of contradictions because most of the Companions died before the Qur'an was written down?

[@jijujvc1765]

God bless you brothers 🙏

[@xondeez757]

this video is easily refuted simply because the companions of muhammad lived after his death, most died between 660 and 700. so the reason why you wont find evidence from them is simply because the companions didnt allow the newer muslims to do anything muhmmad didnt do himself. the new muslims attempted to start new things but the companions stopped them every single time, its only when all of them died out is when the newer muslims started doing things the earlier muslims didnt do like carving rocks.

[@annemurphy9339]

The truth they share is amazing and leading many out of the darkness & deception of Islam.

[@asdsad7476]

Now the question is what is the alternative before that time that we can imaginary substitute for?

[@orunabho]

There are various wall painting ...painted during the Ummayad times...and they look christian than Islamic...telling us the Ummayad were a branch of Christians different from catholic Christians

[@shanewalsh7388]

Can the 7 people who disliked this video please put up a factual, reasonable video rebuttal of the material presented here. Thank you, and God bless 🙏🏽

[@dfwtransport2420]

When Muhammad, the Ishmaelite Prophet and comforter, started preaching Monotheism in Mecca, the pagans started murdering the early Muslims. The command from God through the Quran was non violence and no retaliation. Many early Muslims had to emigrate to Abyssinia to live under protection of the Christian King. He offered them asylum and we have Christian Records of the entire history. The King asked the Muslims to read verses of the Quran that had been revealed. There was no book... the Muslims read from memory. Just like today millions of Muslims have memorized the Quran and dont need a book. Later, when God revealed the verses for WAR, the Muslims were allowed to fight and kill those pagans and other non believers who attacked and killed them for their faith. Without context you cannot understand history. The history of the Muslim emigration to Christian Abyssinia is a great read and Christian proof of early Islam.

[@Michiganfan105]

@@dfwtransport2420 Literally not true at all. To make the statement that Allah ever forbid violence against the pagans and to not retaliate against them is absurd. The bloodshed in Mecca began with the Muslims. Sa'd ibn Abi Waqqas took a camel's jawbone and struck one of the Quaraysh tribesmen, splitting his head open. Muhammad was also apparently a military genius according to the Standard Islamic Narrative. His record in battle was 20 victories and only 1 loss, along with 7 stalemates. So to call Muhammad a man of peace is absolutely laughable. Muhammad was also not fighting wars for the reason of self-defense and for the protection of his people, he was fighting wars of conquest and the Standard Islamic Narrative backs those statements up as well. Islam is merely a product of its time, a time in history with constant bloodshed. The character of Muhammad would likely have had more of a peaceful, "turn the other cheek" personality had he been invented during a more peaceful time in history. Islam is the only religion that i can think of, and certainly the only major world religion, that spread primarily due to conquest as opposed to word of mouth.

[@jmch7788]

I think the summary paragraph at the very end had some wrong dates in it. You mentioned 610 and 640. But I think you meant 710 and 740.

[@themoonster5682]

There's also a date reference in the description of 640 AD (8th paragragh) that needs checking.

[@xondeez757]

this video is easily refuted simply because the companions of muhammad lived after his death, most died between 660 and 700. so the reason why you wont find evidence from them is simply because the companions didnt allow the newer muslims to do anything muhmmad didnt do himself. the new muslims attempted to start new things but the companions stopped them every single time, its only when all of them died out is when the newer muslims started doing things the earlier muslims didnt do like carving rocks.

[@jmch7788]

@@xondeez757 what about the coins?

[@simonhengle8316]

Fabulous 👍 please put it in writing

[@isaiahben-yahweh3245]

WOW, this is getting serious man. Islam is falling to pieces quite literally and this is only proving worse for that religion

[@fourtry]

Yupppp... GG

[@St705]

@Assad Khalif haha the rock is falling on islam and you guys are having a digital hajj, how are you going to kiss your black stone? By kissing the tv? Haha

[@St705]

@John Wick that is a remembrance for us , not a literal thing. You guys are told it is ok to have a prostitute- or as you try to hide it MUTAH MARRIAGE hahaha

[@nemesis1291]

@John Wick John Wick thinks that a carpenter makes carpets 😂🤦‍♂️

[@St705]

@@nemesis1291 nothing matters but the flying carpet Mohammed used to terrorize the Saudis

[@christoruan2395]

G-D bless you Sir Mr Al Fadi and Mr Jay Smith and all His children.

[@jijujvc1765]

Amen ✋️

[@xondeez757]

this video is easily refuted simply because the companions of muhammad lived after his death, most died between 660 and 700. so the reason why you wont find evidence from them is simply because the companions didnt allow the newer muslims to do anything muhmmad didnt do himself. the new muslims attempted to start new things but the companions stopped them every single time, its only when all of them died out is when the newer muslims started doing things the earlier muslims didnt do like carving rocks.

[@johnkeogh8163]

I am listening to this video and I am wondering when the shisim between Sunni and Shia took place after the death of someone who may not have existed?

[@prtauvers]

Good point - in this vid I do not think they argue that Mo did not exist…just that the formalized religion, based on a book and practices, took 100 years to crystallize. Not sure what this ‘proves’.

[@gilbertjones9157]

@john keogh I am wondering as well. Now after 740 (not sure the year) is when the Abbassides took power forcing the Ummyids to bolt for Andalusia. The Ummies are Arabs while the Abby are Persians (Sunni Arabs - Shia's Persians). The Shia's don't accept the Hadiths but it was under the Abbys that the Hadiths started to appear over a period of 100 years. The framework exists for that split but as the 'early years' of Islam are being revealed to be a mirage the split may also be based on something other than heat waves off the sand.

[@St705]

@John Wick all the answers are there. And it creates questions and doubts in your mind. Now do you look closely and calmly research or lash out like a wild donkey? Jesus is Lord, accept him and you will be saved.

[@St705]

@John Wick Genesis 16:12

[@xondeez757]

this video is easily refuted simply because the companions of muhammad lived after his death, most died between 660 and 700. so the reason why you wont find evidence from them is simply because the companions didnt allow the newer muslims to do anything muhmmad didnt do himself. the new muslims attempted to start new things but the companions stopped them every single time, its only when all of them died out is when the newer muslims started doing things the earlier muslims didnt do like carving rocks.

[@sgt.grinch3299]

God bless both of you. Islam is an educational and historical disorder.

[@Tibbs736]

Please do a video about St John of Damascus! He wrote lots about Islam

[@srebalanandasivam9563]

Pagan sites of worship existed as late as 780ad in the Negev desert (Yehuda Nevo) also the Abbasid Caliph al Mamun met the cult of Sin at harran as late as 830ad. So Islam was very fluid till 950ad is whats the conclusion.

[@srebalanandasivam9563]

@John Wick Have you read "crossroads to Islam" ?

[@xondeez757]

this video is easily refuted simply because the companions of muhammad lived after his death, most died between 660 and 700. so the reason why you wont find evidence from them is simply because the companions didnt allow the newer muslims to do anything muhmmad didnt do himself. the new muslims attempted to start new things but the companions stopped them every single time, its only when all of them died out is when the newer muslims started doing things the earlier muslims didnt do like carving rocks.

[@srebalanandasivam9563]

@@xondeez757 Then in that case, the newer mumneen should have made images of Allah and Muhammed for veneration. There's no harm in issuing coins or inscriptions in the name of Allah atleast. There's something beyond the sunna which prevented early believers from engraving their faith.

[@satmat6566]

The followers of Jesus christ had been called "Christians" in the book of Acts of the Apostles and the epistle of Peter. The eye witnesses were still alive!!!

[@aaaabraham837]

DID YOU KNOW that the word 'christians' was first used as a derogatory word for the followers of Satan Paul in Antioch - NOT the followers of Jesus as they were known as Nazarenes.

[@xondeez757]

this video is easily refuted simply because the companions of muhammad lived after his death, most died between 660 and 700. so the reason why you wont find evidence from them is simply because the companions didnt allow the newer muslims to do anything muhmmad didnt do himself. the new muslims attempted to start new things but the companions stopped them every single time, its only when all of them died out is when the newer muslims started doing things the earlier muslims didnt do like carving rocks.

[@satmat6566]

@@xondeez757 biased and rubbish. as usual this is your theory, opinions, interpretations . What Muhammad fid not want to do

[@satmat6566]

@@xondeez757 rubbish and unscholarly and shameful to what muslims have railways claimed...

[@xondeez757]

@@satmat6566 its not rubbish, arabs were known to be oral people. 99% of them couldnt write and those who could were noble arabs, they never carved things on rocks.

[@Vankatraman]

I partly agree with you. My question is how muhmmad became a military commander without any previous training or family background traditions . He was said to be a shepherd in his young age. Then started meditation in hira caves. He lived peacefully with khadija for many years. He managed her business affairs . And suddenly after death of khadija he became a war lord . Married 11 wives along with many sexslaves. Got extraordinary sexuael power to sex with 11 wives during one night. It is clearly a fiction novel. It was created 100 years later and many stories attached to him. It seems reasonable that a simple man was turned into larger than life figure . All mopped up many years laters. Just like imageniray James Bond .

[@xondeez757]

this video is easily refuted simply because the companions of muhammad lived after his death, most died between 660 and 700. so the reason why you wont find evidence from them is simply because the companions didnt allow the newer muslims to do anything muhmmad didnt do himself, they were a oral people. the new muslims attempted to start new things but the companions stopped them every single time, its only when all of them died out is when the newer muslims started doing things the earlier muslims didnt do like carving rocks. he was a good commander because he was guided by God and gabriel had an army of angels who helped him whenever he needed it

[@Vankatraman]

@@xondeez757 military affairs in mature age are not possible because of enormous amount of physical stemina. More over managing an undiscipeled army is very hard task. Therefore fear of jannat and jahannum was created along with hard punishment.

[@olatidoyeolaniran5306]

What about the inscription on the tomb of Tombstone Of ʿAbāssa Bint Juraij, 71 AH / 691 CE in Cairo museum

[@universalflamethrower6342]

My 2 year old debunks Islam

[@dmt8091]

It shows your level of IQ is lower than that 2 year old. What can be said to a man that believe God come as a baby. Ask your son if he believes in the story!

[@nobleprince1238]

@@dmt8091 Sadly the son will NOT believe that Allah/Jubril blew into the v*g of Mary. A very absurd thing to read!

[@bringemyoungpbuh4123]

Do any Muslims even attempt to refute this? I have not heard a single Muslim attempt to answer these challenges.

[@muhammadsaeed1125]

Its boring bro. .when u are biased, u will end up with fools

[@bringemyoungpbuh4123]

@@muhammadsaeed1125 Can you address the claims instead of just retorting with an ad hominem?

[@dfwtransport2420]

In 638, Umar (the 2nd Caliph) traveled to Jerusalem in person to receive control of the city. The Muslim Caliphs and other leaders ruled Jerusalem by SHARIA for nearly 1,000 years. The Christians were so impressed with the Peace and Justice that was established that they enstrusted the keys of the Holy Sepulchre to a Muslim family. This was to bring Peace and Justice between all the different Christian factions of the Holy Land. To this day, the Muslims open and close the doors of Christianity's holiest Church, the Holy Sepulchre. You are welcome.///

[@bringemyoungpbuh4123]

@@dfwtransport2420 That is a story. Anyone can make up a story and pass it down. Is there any proof? Do you know what proof and evidence is? Apparently not.

[@lillotusplays]

jay smith's presentations are INSANE. in terms of what they imply and the ramifications and how unknown this all is.

[@ashokjain5681]

Bible in Genesis 16 verses 11 and 12 where God's angel foretells about Ishmael and his descendants to Hagar, his mother: The angel of the Lord also said to her: “You are now pregnant and you will give birth to a son. You shall name him Ishmael,[a] for the Lord has heard of your misery. 12 He will be a wild donkey of a man; his hand will be against everyone and everyone’s hand against him, and he will live in hostility toward[b] all his brothers.” So true to this day.

[@nobleprince1238]

STANDARD NARRATIVES...guys...it's ONE YEAR already! Save the date 06/08. Tweet, Comment...HOLEY ANNIVERSARY!!!

[@xondeez757]

this video is easily refuted simply because the companions of muhammad lived after his death, most died between 660 and 700. so the reason why you wont find evidence from them is simply because the companions didnt allow the newer muslims to do anything muhmmad didnt do himself, they were a oral people. the new muslims attempted to start new things but the companions stopped them every single time, its only when all of them died out is when the newer muslims started doing things the earlier muslims didnt do like carving rocks.

[@nobleprince1238]

@@xondeez757 Hahaha! Funny!! You should be an Islamic Scholar yourself. Miracle of Reinterpretation!!! What is your source about what the Sahaba permitted or disallowed?

[@xondeez757]

@@nobleprince1238 arabs were known to be oral people, thats why you dont find anything about them pre islam either.

[@nobleprince1238]

@@xondeez757 Still Funny! Oral people who had several variants Quran that had to be burned by Khalif Uthman ibn 'Affan? I know you are trying hard to defend your claim, but I'm sorry I will need real evidence - not contemplations

[@kingashutosh1]

So it was the Ismailis who first started calling themselves Muslims so that they could stand apart from Christians and Jews.. Interesting

[@jijujvc1765]

Hallelujah 👏

[@Bei-Abedan]

The word Muslim comes from the Jewish word Muslamai which was used by Rabbi Onkelos to refer to Noahites.

[@xondeez757]

this video is easily refuted simply because the companions of muhammad lived after his death, most died between 660 and 700. so the reason why you wont find evidence from them is simply because the companions didnt allow the newer muslims to do anything muhmmad didnt do himself, they were a oral people. the new muslims attempted to start new things but the companions stopped them every single time, its only when all of them died out is when the newer muslims started doing things the earlier muslims didnt do like carving rocks.

[@Bei-Abedan]

@@xondeez757 But we only have Abbasid sources which say that and since Abbasids were a corrupt regime we can not trust what passed through their hands.

[@Bei-Abedan]

@mysotiras7 Are you familiar with הגרים in the bible? Thiese are the ones that the Targum of Rav Onkelos refers to as Muslamai.

[@garrett6076]

Where does Onkelos use that word?

[@Bei-Abedan]

@@garrett6076 שלמיא it is the Aramaic equivalent to the Hebrew name Meshullam meaning one who is perfect or in a covenant with God (other than the Jews). This word is used for example to refer to the Kenites and other types of Gerim in the Targum of Onkelos. So just look up any verse mentioning Kenites like for example Judges 1:16 and you should see the word there.

[@christineglenn319]

in spite of so many evidences yet people refuse to accept the truth. what will be the outcome of these people

[@p.mpareeth4450]

THEY WILL MGOM TO HELL,HAHA

[@JasonLovesJesus]

Not good news for Muslims, my lost Muslim friend flee from the false religion called Islam; and come to Christ Jesus our Lord for salvation. Matthew 11:28-30 Come unto me, all [ye] that labour and are heavy laden, and I will give you rest. Take my yoke upon you, and learn of me; for I am meek and lowly in heart: and ye shall find rest unto your souls. For my yoke [is] easy, and my burden is light.

[@xondeez757]

this video is easily refuted simply because the companions of muhammad lived after his death, most died between 660 and 700. so the reason why you wont find evidence from them is simply because the companions didnt allow the newer muslims to do anything muhmmad didnt do himself, they were a oral people. the new muslims attempted to start new things but the companions stopped them every single time, its only when all of them died out is when the newer muslims started doing things the earlier muslims didnt do like carving rocks.

[@JasonLovesJesus]

@@xondeez757 So according to you Muslims are disobeying their prophet because they are doing something he didn't want them to do. Good work you've just proven that Muslims throughout the world don't follow Muhammad.

[@prakashmasihmission4251]

AMEN glory to God our savior and Lord Almighty father Jesus Christ Yahweh everlasting God

[@orunabho]

What are the earliest writing of the Ummayad conquerors in Spain...anything that can tell us their Christians roots???

[@JohnSmith-pr1sm]

Hi, is there a way to get all the videos on USB or downloaded? Thanks

[@silverltc2729]

Prophets Daniyal, Irmiya, Yahya, Zakariya, Al-Yasa, Iliyas, Ya'qub, Isha'ya, and Syam. All prove that the name of God is Yahweh.

[@dsm5d723]

Give Him a name.

[@silverltc2729]

@@dsm5d723 YHWH. He is the "I AM".

[@dsm5d723]

@@silverltc2729 I get the sense that he has become an I AM A more than an I AM; gotta be the AMA. No offense, I must point to the Rendering Problem, as a Levite by birth and disposition. Numbers 3: 12, is it Matrix or is it Womb? Deuteronomy 14: 23-29 No inheritance for us, we belong to the Lord, or the Earth as it renders; our corrupt Rabbis fill themselves and take no care, seeking to escape mathematical judgement. I don't suppose a 3D decausative linear algebra would help with that. I have time, space, matter and energy computed, as does my Father. Nobody could teach me. ONLY Him. The Mark of Cain is the curse of the Peaceful Priest. Bitches love sacrifice. Beta males too.

[@xondeez757]

this video is easily refuted simply because the companions of muhammad lived after his death, most died between 660 and 700. so the reason why you wont find evidence from them is simply because the companions didnt allow the newer muslims to do anything muhmmad didnt do himself, they were a oral people. the new muslims attempted to start new things but the companions stopped them every single time, its only when all of them died out is when the newer muslims started doing things the earlier muslims didnt do like carving rocks.

[@silverltc2729]

@@xondeez757 and that is why the Qur'an isn't perfectly preserved. Many many Surahs went missing after the Battle of Badur because of reciters deaths. Islam is falling to pieces. It will only survive if all the Umma ban the internet and from talking about its preservation.

[@johanwhiz2632]

Did Quran predict it’s own demise??

[@yakovmatityahu]

Islam started small and will end small...according its own prophet.

[@maheshiyer3326]

Very interesting!

[@RoninofRamen]

The bit at the end says 610 to 640 when I'm sure it should say 710 to 740.

[@SojournerDidimus]

There's something wrong with your end title. The period of 610 - 640 AD should be 710 - 740 AD.

[@NomenNescio99]

The "Reductio ad absurdum" critique of the standard Islamic narrative is easier to do as is relies on the same source material as Muslims themselves use. But in the long run this critique of the historical truthfulness of Islam will probably be the more important method as it effectively removes the foundation for Islam. But the the academic world has so far been very reluctant to discuss anything that goes against SIN, however good reasons there may be to do so. I can't help but to think the rather large contributions to western academia from the gulf states could have something to do with this. How and what can be done to get materials such as coins or rock inscriptions to be more widely published in academic journals?

[@defenderoftruth3212]

How I earnestly wish that there is now an ORIGINAL ARAMAIC GOSPEL because I am dying inside to read it. I hope there is a translation in English. It's hard to read it in its original form in Aramaic. I don't know that language. I think Aramaic is much harder to read than Arabic. I believe that this Gospel is a book of spiritual guidance from God. Unlike the 4 make-believe gospels, their contents are purely biographies of Prophet jESUs (pbuh) but with a huge hole in the accounts of his life covering the primetime of his age. From what museum or library can we find the original ARAMAIC GOSPEL? Is there any original manuscript for it? I am urging Jay Smith and his cohorts to produce that book as soon as possible so that Muslims and Christians alike will be enlightened. -07-15-23

[@MU-we8hz]

There was a guy on Mels channel(Neakers Corner), who named himself John Wick. He once gave me a paper which in his eyes proved early Mecca and islam. I read the paper, the paper was about rock inscriptions. - before 690 the name Mohamed doesn't appear. The rock inscriptions before 690 always refer to "the prophet". - rock inscriptions before 690 show that the believers used to pray to this "the prophet" figure. They used to pray to him for intercession with God. That is a Christian thing to do, ask for intercession through Jesus Christ. Ain't that funny?

[@defenderoftruth3212]

According to Jay Smith the LETTERS OF PAUL are just MERE TAFSEER of the Old Testament and “other scriptures” (?). Tafseer means interpretation. If the letters of Paul are just mere tafseer, why is it they become the main core of the New Testament which comprised almost 90 percent of it. These should be written in a separate book. In the Islamic standard, no single tafseer is included in the Holy Qur’an. Hence, the letters of Paul must be written in a separate book. Jay Smith failed not elaborate as to what specific book or verse/s in the Old Testament that each letter is intended to for being a tafseer. He should have elaborated on the following letters of Paul: LETTERS OF PAUL TO THE DIFFERENT CHURCHES: 1). Romans - tafseer of what is it intended for? 2). Hebrews - tafseer of what is it intended for? 3). Corinthians - tafseer of what is it intended for? 4). Galatians - tafseer of what is it intended for? 5). Colossians - tafseer of what is it intended for? 6). Philippians - tafseer of what is it intended for? 7). Ephesians - tafseer of what is it intended for? 8). Thessalonians - tafseer of what is it intended for? LETTERS OF PAUL TO THE DIFFERENT INDIVIDUALS: 1). Timothy - tafseer of what is it intended for? 2). Titus - tafseer of what is it intended for? 3). Philemon - tafseer of what is it intended for? 4). James - tafseer of what is it intended for? 5). John - tafseer of what is it intended for? 6). Jude - tafseer of what is it intended for? 7). Peter - tafseer of what is it intended for? -08-11-23

[@defenderoftruth3212]

According to Jay Smith is that he believed that there is really ONE ORIGINAL GOSPEL. Since he cannot find it, he assumed that the gospel of John is already that book. But his is only mere assumption. He failed to make any clear evidence to show that his assumption is correct. Hence, he has to show manuscripts in Aramaic as evidence for his assumption that the gospel of John is the already real Gospel of Pophet jESUs (pbuh). By his hasty assumption, he undoubtedly discarded the gospels of Mark, Matthew and Luke into useless books which have no more meaning to the whole Christendom, and hence not fit to be used as the basis of the religiosity of the Christians. -08-06-23

[@secondone5870]

Islam in trouble seriously!

[@nobleprince1238]

Should have been in trouble since The Enlightenment, but terror prevented the secular humanists from damaging Islam.

[@p.mpareeth4450]

YES, THAT IS WHY PEOPLE THRONG INTO ISLAM DESPITE SUCH NEFARIOUS PROPAGANDA.

[@nobleprince1238]

@@p.mpareeth4450 I'm "sure" you've seen people throng into Islam on David Wood's channel. Have you also seen numerous Muslims on 100huntley? Keep deceiving yourself! Allah misguides the 'believers' and disbelievers.

[@orunabho]

Maybe the Arabs knows it....only shame is preventing them from accepting it....shame is more important to these people than truth.

[@xondeez757]

this video is easily refuted simply because the companions of muhammad lived after his death, most died between 660 and 700. so the reason why you wont find evidence from them is simply because the companions didnt allow the newer muslims to do anything muhmmad didnt do himself, they were a oral people. the new muslims attempted to start new things but the companions stopped them every single time, its only when all of them died out is when the newer muslims started doing things the earlier muslims didnt do like carving rocks.

[@orunabho]

@@xondeez757 oral people do not do trade. And then oral people do not write the Quran on animal skin and bones. Either way the original Quran, said to be edited by uthman, is not possible...a myth then. Anyway who is uthman to act as the editor...a prophet himself. There are holes in this narrative unfortunately

[@dennisclark8766]

Very interesting. I just wish he would SLOW down his speech.

[@muskyoxes]

"in contradistinction to the Christians" - I'm not aware of any early Christian rock inscriptions.

[@mmmcounts]

Have you looked into it?

[@muskyoxes]

@@mmmcounts I've seen a decent amount of Christian apologetics in general, i know about things like the early manuscript fragments and the mention in Tacitus. But nothing i saw mentioned anything on any rocks.

[@mmmcounts]

@@muskyoxes earlychurchhistory.org/arts/christian-inscriptions-in-roman-catacombs/

[@vironpayne3405]

Playing the devil's advocate, how many extrabiblical resources are there for sources for Christian practices with 100yrs from the crucifixtion of Jesus. There are histories that come after 133AD.

[@savior2899]

👍

[@dsm5d723]

I think I see the problem. You guys have a narrative to support, and it is good work you do. I am concerned with the whole picture, and ignoring any relevant North African sources will be the Achilles heel in your effort. Also, a bit much with the production value. If you have anyone doing the same multifactor analysis in North Africa, I would be glad to look at their work with an eye toward the Berber Rebellion and the allegedly egalitarian flavor of it. Are the Classic sources about here from the East? I think you may have to look again at the mosques there for patterns if no sources can be isolated to the area. I understand the non-literate and tribal nomadic traditions make this tedious work. Has anyone gone in and learned the languages and observed any oral remnants? Does Gibson do any focused analysis about this specifically?

[@xondeez757]

this video is easily refuted simply because the companions of muhammad lived after his death, most died between 660 and 700. so the reason why you wont find evidence from them is simply because the companions didnt allow the newer muslims to do anything muhmmad didnt do himself, they were a oral people. the new muslims attempted to start new things but the companions stopped them every single time, its only when all of them died out is when the newer muslims started doing things the earlier muslims didnt do like carving rocks. this is why western scholars find islamic things around 690 and beyond, the early muslims had no reason to write things on rocks because they were oral people.

[@dsm5d723]

@@xondeez757 I am arguing not to debunk anything, but help to construct a new and inclusive narrative. If this points to more variability in the West and codification in the East, then that is my focus. Language is a big part, and if the mixing of Berber Tribal egalitarianism is a social factor, then including it is helpful. So, anything SOLID from the 640 period across Sinai? If not, are there any local Time Keepers of oral tradition left? Not easy work.

[@xondeez757]

@@dsm5d723 because this petra narrative is simply impossible who made up the companions? how did sunni and shia split happened if the ordinary narrative is false? how did arabia become united willingly? who were the army that attacked byzantine empire? who is khalid ibn walid if he never existed? who is the first 4 caliphs if the standard narrative is false? why are they buried in medina? why do they wilingly live in mecca if its just made up? the standard narrative makes more sense, petra was occupied by christian arabs called the ghassanids and there are roman documents talking about the battle between the muslims and them.

[@dsm5d723]

@@xondeez757 I am not a Muslim, but do tend to think in Islamic metaphysical terms. As for rigor in mathematical reasoning, I do find Gibson to be more data driven and less or even not at all polemical by comparison. I have no dog in the fight, to use my native idiom, and the Petra story does look like it holds water, in the mental math modeling, not the debunking of another's faith with stories. I would suggest you watch NJWildberger's videos on the Plimpton 322 Old Babylonian tablet, and how computation in the MIND was expressed in physical terms for a culture. Apply that to the Qiblas and hopefully you can see it as a viable marker of the fluidity mentioned, over time and space. If not, that is your mind. It is ALWAYS for God, in my way of living Submission to Nature, that we do math. We are of it.

[@nazeemsultan123]

Can somebody tell me how did Judas die according to the bible? Secondly, can somebody tell me if those men who crucified Jesus will be in heaven since they made the sacrifice posible.

[@chrisazure1624]

Judas hung himself. The passage about him falling is what happened to his body after he rotted. I wouldn't be able to answer the second question because I don't know the hearts of the men. Did they believe in Jesus as their savior? We don't know.

[@bobfisher1909]

Holes keep getting bigger, more you dig more Islam gets busted no wounder they don't want to cross the red line..

[@aaaabraham837]

Those holes were closed and answered by Muslims already...now Jay is trying his luck with you gullible Xtians...ha ha ha...but the HOLES OOO IN YOUR GOSPEL NARRATIVES are still as BIG as always.

[@joelabraham1680]

@@aaaabraham837 hope you enjoy your well deserved brothel in heaven

[@xondeez757]

this video is easily refuted simply because the companions of muhammad lived after his death, most died between 660 and 700. so the reason why you wont find evidence from them is simply because the companions didnt allow the newer muslims to do anything muhmmad didnt do himself, they were a oral people. the new muslims attempted to start new things but the companions stopped them every single time, its only when all of them died out is when the newer muslims started doing things the earlier muslims didnt do like carving rocks.

[@bobfisher1909]

@@aaaabraham837 , yip once a liar always a liar, all Islam does is lie to defend their redactor book.

[@bobfisher1909]

@@xondeez757 Is that why Uthman in 652 burnt all Quranic text lol, if there was no text then what did he burn according to your 37 Qurans, did he burn people because how does one burn oral words. After centuries of no Quran how can it be the same one as Muhammad's word for word which sits on clay tablets in Heaven? Why does Aisha the child bride quote a sheep ate the verse of breastfeeding which was under the pillow? Oral lol, there simply no evidence to back anything Islamic till the Dome of the Rock.. Prior is a giant black hole. If this Uthman wrote the new Quran and sent it out to every city controlled by Islam in 652 then where is it? This blows your garbage out of the water... Oh didn't Muhammad employ a scriber to write things down?

[@secondone5870]

BERIKUT DESKRIPSI DALAM BAHASA INDONESIA 👇 PRASASTI BATU TULIS JUGA MEMBANTAH KEBERADAAN ISLAM PADA ABAD KE-7 Seharusnya tidak mengejutkan bahwa kita sekarang menemukan bahwa PRASASTI BATU memberi tahu kita hal yang sama persis seperti yang dikatakan KOIN sebelumnya, bahwa tidak ada referensi pada 30.000 Prasasti tentang Muhammad sebelum 690 M, atau menyebutkan sebuah kota bernama Mekah, atau orang yang disebut Muslim, atau bahkan agama yang disebut Islam, dan tentu saja tidak ada referensi ke buku yang disebut Al-Qur'an! Apa yang disarankan oleh Prasasti Batu adalah bahwa 5 ide ini dimulai pada tahun 690 M dengan Abd al-Malik, yang memperkenalkannya pada koin, Protokol Khalifah dan di Kubah Batu. Berikut adalah urutan yang kami temukan di Prasasti Batu: Sebelum 690 M Tidak ada bukti apapun tentang Islam pada Prasasti, karena semua yang kita temukan adalah "pious formulae/rumus iman" 690-710 M Nama nabi Muhammad muncul, meskipun tidak jelas siapa orangnya, tetapi kemungkinan besar gelar "yang terpuji". 710-720 M = Ritual Muslim mulai muncul. Ini termasuk haji, 3 kali sholat, dan puasa. 720-730 M = Nama-nama 'Muslim' & 'Islam merujuk pada kelompok tertentu, yang bertentangan dengan agama Kristen. Tampaknya baru pada tahun 740 M dan kemudian segalanya mulai 'jatuh pada tempatnya', dan Islam akhirnya mulai terlihat seperti agama yang kita lihat sekarang ini... Kesimpulan: Baru pada tahun 730-an dan seterusnya ada bukti pengabdian luas kepada Muhammad sebagai nabi dan rasul, dan model Islam yang baru muncul seperti yang kita kenal sekarang, yang membuat Tradisi Islam menjadi sangat janggal, karena mereka bersikeras bahwa Islam telah sepenuhnya terbentuk sebelum Muhammad meninggal, dengan kata lain pada tahun 632 M, 100 tahun sebelumnya. Selain itu, karena Islam tidak ada berita selama 100 tahun seperti yang kita kenal sekarang dalam prasasti batu sebelum 730 M, ini akan menunjukkan bahwa Islam tidak ada sebagai agama yang nyata sampai lama setelah zaman Muhammad, yang meragukan apakah dia punya andil dalam asal usul Islam. Sama seperti koin, Prasasti Batu, yang merupakan artefak sebenarnya dari abad yang sama dan tempat kelahiran Islam, menunjukkan dengan sangat kuat bahwa tidak ada Islam pada awal itu, dan bahwa Tradisi abad ke-9 dan ke-10 sama sekali tidak secara historis benar, karena mereka memiliki orang yang salah di tempat yang salah, melakukan hal yang salah, pada waktu yang salah. © Pfander Center for Apologetics - AS, 2021 (48.710) Musik: Trailer Epik, oleh Rafael Krux, dari filmmusic-io Referensi 👇 Al Fadi dan Jay kzbin.info/www/bejne/mprVanl6eLCShZo

[@simoncoss3321]

I really like your videos - they are great. But i have to ask - if islam did not evolve until thr early 8th cebtury, what then are the mosques of Medina, Guangzhou and india that were built whole M9hammed was supposedly alive. Also - where is the join in the rise of the Arab empire between what we know as historical fact.and what you are saying is not. If we know the Ummayids came to power in 661 what does their history tell us about their predecessors - they must have had some?

[@xondeez757]

this video is easily refuted simply because the companions of muhammad lived after his death, most died between 660 and 700. so the reason why you wont find evidence from them is simply because the companions didnt allow the newer muslims to do anything muhmmad didnt do himself, they were a oral people. the new muslims attempted to start new things but the companions stopped them every single time, its only when all of them died out is when the newer muslims started doing things the earlier muslims didnt do like carving rocks. he is obviously stupid, he cant explain the mosque in medina and mecca, he cant explain how shia and sunnis split, he cant explain how the early conquest started when arabs were divided people, he cant explain the early sources from the romans about the commanders like umar and khalid.

[@michaelmooney7341]

How did th 7th century arabs conquers so much land and territory in 7th century? Bedouin riding camels?

[@iwasbehindyou]

Everyone here 🕋is You in a different cubic dimension of space time 🗝

[@garrett6076]

that really makes a lot of sense, thanks

[@iwasbehindyou]

@@garrett6076 Thank you for receiving this 💙 I am the First and the Last 💫 🫂♾🫂

[@dfwtransport2420]

Worship the God of Abraham, not the statue of a white guy !!

[@nobleprince1238]

Who is the God of Abraham?

[@valerossi823]

and whats actually eraly quran manuscript before 700 such us Birmingham Manuscript..? we now that 10 times the word islam mention in quran, are the verse that mention islam came after 690-710 too?

[@hetrodoxly1203]

The Birmingham 'Manuscript' is just two pages and it's about Jesus and possible predates Mohammed.

[@xavierbesnard9201]

obvious !

[@leedza]

I guess Islam is the spirit of Ishmael and Esau making its claim to the birthright. "a wild ass among men; his hand shall be against every man, and every man's hand against him. And he shall dwell over against all his brethren” (Genesis 16:12) “No dew from heaven for you, No fertile fields for you. 40 You will live by your sword, But be your brother's slave. Yet when you rebel,[b] You will break away from his control.” Genesis 27:39-40

[@MHLitu]

Show that coin which u Taking about that which u have..

[@BLNongbsap]

♥️✝️✝️✝️✝️✝️✝️✝️✝️✝️♥️

[@yvonnegonzales2973]

Muhammad face inscription

[@yvonnegonzales2973]

Muhammad face on the rock

[@kafira6640]

If you only had german subtitles.

[@hamsterbox4732]

kAfir a Warum, kannst du denn kein Englisch?

[@kafira6640]

@@hamsterbox4732 Ich kenne keinen, der das auf Deutsch tut, was er tut. Ich fänds gut und wichtig, wenn man das auch hier verbreiten könnte, besonders für die Muslime.

[@hamsterbox4732]

@@kafira6640 kennst du den Achso Kanal? Der greift manches von CP auf, oder auch Amir, der deutsch-Iraner Christ und KZbinr. Was sind andere deutsche Kanäle die sich mit Islamkritik beschäftigen?

[@kafira6640]

@@hamsterbox4732 Die kenne ich natürlich. Und es gibt noch ein paar, aber keiner macht diese archäologischen und geschichtlichen Sachen.

[@hamsterbox4732]

@@kafira6640 Geduld, das wird schon noch kommen. Die Deutschen sind halt ein wenig zeitlich hinterher, weil so viel auf englischen Kanälen veröffentlicht wird dass man Zeit braucht das durchzusieben... Schick doch dem Klaus einen Link, auch das was Sneakers Corner, Murat, Mel &Co bringen, die machen ja eigentlich ne Menge geschichtliche Quellenforschung, die Jay&co dann später aufgreifen. Auch Brubakers Varient Qur'an und natürlich Dan Gibson s Clips.

[@louisecordier9428]

Slow down, Jay!!! You talk too fast!!

[@dfwtransport2420]

How many Christians would worship Jesus if he was a black man ? 😂

[@nobleprince1238]

Do people worship Jesus because he wasn't a black man?

[@sheikhboyardee556]

I would be careful with that statement if I were you. Muhammad hated the color black which included Black people. Even today Muslims are catching Black people and making them slaves.

[@dfwtransport2420]

@@sheikhboyardee556 - We all know only Islam has been able to erase race, color and language to create a united people. In fact so many Black Americans are coming to Islam because they know Christianity will never be able to do that. Christianity is systemically racist.

[@nobleprince1238]

​@@dfwtransport2420 I doubt you've ever seen this video: "How Muhammad Ali Was Deceived by Islam (and Why Cassius Clay Was His Greatest Name)" - available on KZbin (or Google the quoted). Please let me know your honest thoughts when you've watched the clip. Thanks

[@arnoldsaunders7885]

He was not White European, yet he has a huge following in Europe.

[@Egyptian_muslim_1]

NASRANY.. The purpose of Islam is to know the true Creator 👉Allah👈. Not 3 different Gods as Nasrany claim Not idols as some people claim. Not animal as some people claim.

[@Egyptian_muslim_1]

@mysotiras7 So.. Why you can't answer it.. I see you don't know your Gods

[@Egyptian_muslim_1]

@Eli Sheets So You worship 3 different Gods because parrot

[@Egyptian_muslim_1]

@Eli Sheets So You worship 3 different because strawman Is this your answer

[@Egyptian_muslim_1]

@Eli Sheets So easy. How many Gods do you worship.

[@Egyptian_muslim_1]

@Eli Sheets You don't worship 3 Gods. Because you worship 8 gods or more . So hard question to you 👉How many 👈

[@bhulbai27]

I feel bad for these muslims, theyre so gullible.

[@dfwtransport2420]

Why I am a Muslim. In my soul I always knew that God is ONE who begets not nor was he begotten and there is none like him to him. I told myself that if i find any Prophet or Holy Book that even said once that “God is ONE who begets not nor was he begotten and there is none like him to him” then I would believe in that Prophet and that Holy Book. I found ISLAM. Now even if somebody thought they could convince me that every iota of Islam is false, I would never be able to worship a polytheistic Trinity god. I worship the Lord of Abraham who begets not nor was he be gotten and there is none like onto him. - Cynthia Myers

[@MDIS]

8 Muslims unliked your video

[@RobertJohnson-un4ht]

Lol. Guys give it up with the BS. I hope people don’t take you guys serious. I don’t think any knowledgeable scholars would believe you guys.

[@gsandy5235]

You are trying to prove a negative. In other words, you're wasting your time.

[@ttt3258]

Did Muhammad really exist , Blogging Theology .. watch on youtube

[@nobleprince1238]

Is that an Islamic channel?

[@ttt3258]

He is a truthful man , that's what's Important

[@nobleprince1238]

@@ttt3258 Truthful? Do you know what Truth means? If you are reading a Hafs Quran, then I seriously doubt you know what Truth means...because the same reason why you read the Hafs Quran applies to why you think "He is a truthful man".

[@ttt3258]

@@nobleprince1238 just worship One God , and don't be Pagan

[@nobleprince1238]

@@ttt3258 Funny! The fact that you worship one God doesn't mean you are doing the right thing. 1. If you are truly worshipping one God, why do you pray towards the Kabba? Is that where God lives? 2. If you are truly worshipping one God, why are you better than Jehovah's witnesses who also worship one God? 3. Demons and the Satan also believe that there is one God, how are you better than them?

[@marjupsd3728]

THE NEW TESTAMENT PROVES THAT JESUS IS NOBODY'S GOD AND NOT THE GOD OF CHRISTIANS. AS LONG AS JESUS WAS ON THE WORLD, HE ONLY INTERACTED WITH THE PEOPLE OF ISRAEL. JESUS NEVER INTERACTED WITH CHRISTIANS. THERE ARE NO STORIES ABOUT CHRISTIANITY IN THE NEW TESTAMENT. JESUS WAS ONLY A PROPHET SENT TO THE PEOPLE OF ISRAEL. MATTHEW 15: 24 But he answered and said, I am not sent but unto the lost sheep of the house of ISRAEL. JESUS WAS BORN TO BE A LEADER WHO WILL SHEPHERD THE PEOPLE OF ISRAEL, NOT SHEPHERD CHRISTIANS. MATTHEW 2: 6 And thou Bethlehem, in the land of Juda, art not the least among the princes of Juda: for out of thee shall come a Governor, that shall rule my people ISRAEL. JESUS ONLY INTERACTED WITH THE PEOPLE OF ISRAEL, JESUS NEVER INTERACTED WITH CHRISTIANS. MARK 12: 29 And Jesus answered him, The first of all the commandments, Hear, O ISRAEL; The Lord our God is one Lord. JESUS IS THE SAVIOUR OF THE PEOPLE OF ISRAEL. JESUS IS NOT THE SAVIOUR OF CHRISTIANS. THERE IS NO VERSE IN THE NEW TESTAMENT THAT STATES THAT JESUS IS THE SAVIOUR OF CHRISTIANS. ACTS 5: 31 Him hath God exalted with his right hand to be a Prince and A SAVIOUR, for give repentance to ISRAEL, and forgiveness of sins. ACTS 13: 23 Of this man's seed hath God according to his promise raised unto ISRAEL A SAVIOUR, JESUS JESUS BE PRAYED AS KING OF ISRAEL, NOT AS KING OF CHRISTIANS. JOHN 12: 13 Took branches of palm trees, and went forth to meet him, and cried, Hosanna: Blessed is the King of ISRAEL that cometh in the name of the Lord. JESUS COMMANDED THE WORSHIP OF GOD, JESUS NEVER COMMANDED WORSHIP OF JESUS. MATTHEW 4: 10 Then saith Jesus unto him, Get thee hence, Satan: for it is written, Thou shalt worship the Lord thy God, and him only shalt thou serve. JESUS COMMANDED TO THE FOLLOW JESUS, JESUS NEVER COMMANDED WORSHIP OF JESUS. MATTHEW 8: 10 When Jesus heard it, he marvelled, Verily I say unto you, I have not found so great faith, no, not in ISRAEL. JOHN 8: 12 Then spake Jesus again unto them, saying, I am the light of the world: he that FOLLOWETH me shall not walk in darkness, but shall have the light of life. WITH EVIDENCE ABOVE, IT IS IMPOSSIBLE THAT JESUS IS THE GOD OF CHRISTIANS.

[@zoeashes6347]

I slam is crumbling. You are so desperate to slander?

[@zoeashes6347]

Just a spammer ... not worth any serious attention or reply

[@Jenni-tz3bq]

@@zoeashes6347 Agreed no point in discussing anything with these copy paste trolls. I do feel I have to quote one Bible verse though! "For God so loved the world that He gave His only begotten Son that whosoever believes in Him should not perish but have everlasting life".

[@aaaabraham837]

@@zoeashes6347 So you call your bible verses 'SLANDER' ...HA HA HA

[@aaaabraham837]

@@Jenni-tz3bq HA HA HA - WHAT A IDIOT YOU ARE. YOU call others copy and Past trolls for copy and pasting from your corrupted bibles and to put the cherry on top - YOU DO THE SAME...ha ha ha ...by choosing a FABRICATED VERSE where the word BEGOTTEN was thrown out by bible scholars ..ha ha ha..