*ROGUE ONE* IS PHENOMENAL!! (FIRST TIME WATCHING ROGUE ONE)

ROGUE ONE IS PHENOMENAL!! (FIRST TIME WATCHING ROGUE ONE: A STAR WARS STORY)
reaction & commentary
Now that I've completed the 3 Star Wars trilogies, it's finally time for me to check out the other Star Wars movies: starting with Rogue One. This film takes place right before the events of a New Hope and we everything leading up to it, following Jyn Erso, Cassian Andor, Chirrut Imwe, K2SO, Bodhi Rook, and Baze as they team up to save Jyn's father (Mads Mikkelson).
check out my film channel! ‪@yasminazineeddine‬
follow my socials:
ig: @yasminazineeddine
letterboxd: @yasminagoob
tik tok: @yasminazineeddine
twitter: @yasminaisbored

[@yasminareacts]

I had to cut out a lot of parts because of copyright claims but I hope you guys enjoy!! :)

[@baron7755]

I am so sorry you had to buy the ST, but you are welcome for Rogue One

[@KennyYoutubeMakesMeFeelGood]

That's okay of course no worries and I always enjoyed your reactions no matter what Yasmina:)

[@Mackampackam]

That edit at 16:58 which shows only your face lit up by the explosions on screen is amazing! And a great way to add video time without copyright claims. kzbin.info/www/bejne/n5qvd32MptaBbdUm58s

[@deanroddey2881]

Rogue One is really the most adult of all the Star Wars movies. It's interesting to think of how it would have been had it all been thusly oriented. Of course it would probably not have been what it was to me at 13 when it first came out, and it probably wouldn't have been an enormous hit at the time because adult sci-fi at that time was sort of a low point. But, as an adult, I can't help but think how it might have been, and how much more I'd probably enjoy the whole series if had gone this way.

[@domingocurbelomorales8635]

For me, this is one of the best SW films ever. The whole film is incredible, and the last 15 minutes a brutal rollercoaster (Vader OMG).

[@elbruces]

Honestly, this one really reminds me of certain old WW2 movies like "The Guns of Navarrone" or "The Dirty Dozen" where a ragtag combat unit has to go complete a crucial mission and most or all of them die never knowing whether their efforts would bear fruit. "Be careful not to choke on your aspirations" is the moment when Vader should have realized he was a father, because that's such a dad joke. They made a whole-ass movie to explain why the Death Star could be blown up with a single photon torpedo. And it's great.

[@kirkdarling4120]

LOL, from the night I left the theater, I was calling this movie "The Dirty Dozen Saves Private Ryan from the Guns of Navarone."

[@jerodast]

Proton torpedo. Photon torpedoes are in the other franchise :P (Which is funny because THEY don't use lasers. It's like each of them got to pick one kind of light to use but weren't allowed to have both.)

[@KthulhuXxx]

"I hope they don't kill the characters I like" About that....

[@Justanotherconsumer]

At least this movie makes it easy since there’s such… uniformity.

[@ronfehr7899]

Knowing what was coming next, I wasn't really surprised at what happened to the rebels.

[@Sephiroth144]

"I can't believe we saw Vader..." Oh ho, someone's in for a treat.

[@Heru3005]

Over the years since it's release, this ones gone from "Oh wow this was really good" to "Yeah, it's probably my favorite SW movie". And the sack on Gareth Edwards to kill off the entire main cast, holy crap.

[@andrew77961]

Same experience for me. I grew up on the OT and enjoyed Rogue One when it first came out but the more I’ve seen it the more I like it. It is now my favorite Star Wars movie.

[@anthonyleecollins9319]

I've read that he wrote it, based on how he thought the story should go, but he never expected the producers would actually allow him to do it that way.

[@hadoken95]

Yea from the best of the films to the best of the TV shows in Andor.

[@d.w.strangeman4963]

​@@andrew77961same here. Think if it wasn't for the nostalgia of the originals this would be my favourite. Said similar on other posts waiting to be bitch-slaped by all the fan boys/girls, but it never happened! Turns out a lot of people really like this one too. Doesn't hurt that we get to see Vader as the all powerful Sith we're supposed to fear, rather than the whining, obnoxious wimp that E 3 left us with!😁

[@bad-people6510]

Well, it's definitely my favorite DISNEY Star Wars movie.

[@leosarmiento4823]

The series "Andor" does stay true to the feel that was created by "Rogue One". I hold both productions as being some of the best live-action material to have been made to date. As long as you keep an open mind, you'll enjoy the popcorn chomping, summer rollercoaster flick, "Solo". Great reaction.

[@1237barca]

Solo is total trash unfortunately

[@sterlingarcher9208]

BEST movie in the entire Star Wars saga!

[@user-rq6lm2ob5i]

ANDOR THE BEST series

[@ofthenearfuture]

This is by far one of the best Star Wars things ever made, which I think can mostly be attributed to the director Garth Edwards... and that Vader reveal at the end is one of the characters best moments imo haha You should definitely watch Andor as well, also one of the best Star Wars shows

[@bobsavage3317]

👍 ANDOR

[@latech7671]

Based on how Andor Season 1 turned out I think we can say it is probably this good because of the entire team being it (for example Tony Gilroy as Writer and many more), because as I understand it, quite a few people who made Rogue One later made Andor. This is honestly one of the very few big movies where intensive reshoots actually didn't kill the product which is impressive

[@domingocurbelomorales8635]

In the rebel attack to Scarif, the red five pilot unfortunately died. And the rebellion chose later a new red five pilot... Luke Skywalker as we saw in episode IV and the rest.

[@dirtyhawkstv1575]

IMO Andor is the best written Star Wars material. It's gritty, grounded and emphasizes side characters. It's for adults.

[@qa1327]

19:30 I’ll take that bet… 20:18 you’re holding strong… 20:33 there’s definitely a crack… 20:56 still holding strong… 22:15 you win. Well done. This is a great movie. Enjoyed your reaction. Looking forward to your reaction to Solo and the Andor show.

[@thestupidnintendokid]

I like how literally every reaction to this movie starts out with "what are those lines? Oh, they're planet rings"

[@Jefwth1F]

Watch Andor. It's really good

[@declanArdmore]

Gareth Edwards and his creative team discovered some old film canisters while rummaging around the Lucasfilm warehouses. When he asked what they were, an employee said they were old Star Wars: Episode IV - A New Hope (1977) footage. The discovery led to the inclusion of unused Episode IV material featuring Red Leader and Gold Leader in this movie.

[@nadeeml9276]

Wonderful reaction!! Glad you liked the movie, it was such a pleasant surprise, great story for the most part, amazing action, fantastic characters and a great bridge to A New Hope. Btw, the show 'Andor' is, without exaggeration, THE BEST Star Wars show - and likely one of the best shows of 2022. Reading that youre probably like, suuuuure Nadeem, but no joke, completely serious, Andor is nothing short of AMAZING. No spoilers of course, but i CANNOT wait for you to watch it!

[@marcusanark2541]

Andor makes this movie so much better.

[@1237barca]

Andor is even better. The best Star Wars tv. The best Star Wars. The best tv. The best.

[@thomaspappalardo7589]

True. Andor was terrible and bored the hell out of me so much I turned it off and woke myself back up by watching Rogue One 🤣

[@1237barca]

@@thomaspappalardo7589 Andor is the best tv series ever made. Ppl who don’t like it have the attention span of a goldfish. The tic toc generation. Gross.

[@thomaspappalardo7589]

@@1237barca Every person who actually discussed the show said “it gets good by episode six.” If a show needs more than half a season to become engaging, then it’s only mediocre. Good writing should be apparent from start to finish. P.S. I abhor TikTok almost as much as pseudo-intellectuals such as yourself.

[@1237barca]

@@thomaspappalardo7589 the show is good from the first scene. If you are too dull to see the quality and you need bright lights and laser swords to entertain you…sorry.

[@raybernal6829]

I personally think this is the best SW movie... As you said no plot armor but it makes sense since none of the main characters are in the OG trilogy... And yes Andor is the best SW content period... Great reaction Yasmina. ❤❤

[@blacksheep8427]

I love how much this film looks like the original trilogy. They did some great detail work on costumes and sets and props.

[@tigqc]

Best film of the prequels.

[@Hawksmoor42]

I think one of the things Rogue One did best was showing us the Darth Vader that the rest of the Star Wars galaxy fears. The hallway scene shows us why he strikes terror in people's hearts in a more visceral fashion than the OT did. I think that Andor did a similar thing for the Empire as a whole. We get to see more clearly the organization that inspired people to rebel against it. I really enjoy the depth they add to the universe of Star Wars.

[@Evil_Peter]

I didn't love this the first time I saw it. I was negative towards the concept as I didn't think it was a story that needed to be told and I didn't click with the characters until the third act. On consecutive viewings, partially helped by that I now already liked the characters, it's gotten better and better and I now consider it easily the best Star Wars movie outside the original trilogy. Probably on par with the best if I try to disregard my nostalgia. This movie also gets better by being connected to the show Andor, which is easily the best Star Wars show and probably the best written thing in Star Wars. A more serious and mature take on Star Wars that still manages to feel like it belongs. It's also nice that the properties that is made to fit directly together with the original trilogy is the best outside it. The prequel trilogy never came close to the originals and the sequels just did direct and serious harm to everything that came before (story, characters, in-universe logic, etc) so those are better to never think of again.

[@MrHojo1675]

Great reaction Yazmina....you definitely have to watch Andor..unfortunately you won't get many views because many in the Star Wars fandom can't appreciate star wars without jedis and light sabers..but it's the best star wars content i've seen to date. It's adult star wars., exquisite story, excellent dialog and acting...can't wait to watch with you..

[@ShortThe1st]

Yeah Scariff is honestly such a beautiful planet.

[@Calico_Jack_]

This is the best of the entire world. I have seen every one of the movies from the beginning, in theater and this one won my emotions. Thank you for doing this.

[@najhoant]

7:13 Donnie Yen actually ad-libbed that line, easily one of the funniest in the movie

[@charleshartley9597]

Throwing my .02 credits in as well, definitely watch Andor! It is an amazing show, up there with The Mandolorian. Its a different kind of show, intrigue, plotting, some action, but with such rich story development. One of the most tense scenes is just two people talking at a party (iykyk). Cheers!

[@jshizzle6866]

After I saw this in the theaters I jetted home to watch A New Hope. I was late for work the next day.😂 When you stated you wanted to watch the first movies. I thought well heres your motivation. The cg Leia was perfect.

[@MrGadfly772]

Now that you have seen Rogue One you need to watch the series "Andor" it is how Cassian Andor comes into the rebellion and it is the best thing that I have seen since "The Empire Strikes Back." Most people dismiss it, but they haven't seen it. If someone sees it, they love with it as it is so well written and acted. People are too harsh on this film. It is a fine movie and fits with the original trilogy in terms of quality much more than other Disney efforts.

[@christopherwatters6813]

Great reaction video, Yasmina! I love Rogue One- such a great Star Wars film! The characters are so likeable that it hurts to see them go. Madds Mikkelsen is truly one of the great actors of our time, Ben Mendelson makes a truly dislikeable villain, and that scene of Vader cutting the Rebels down is the stuff of my worst childhood nightmares!

[@jackson857]

I think you'll love Andor.

[@katxiii3660]

Little fun fact about the big space battle over Scarif at the end: there's a few shots where you can see the Ghost flying around. The Ghost is the ship of Hera Syndulla, one of the main characters of Star Wars Rebels, and their base of operations for much of the show. And yeah, that Vader scene at the end is absolutely masterful. Just the breathing, and then the lightsaber, and you just know the fun is over for the rebels. And then he delivers on the hype by just mowing through them. They really make you feel the desperation of those rebel troops. But, you mentioned wanting to watch the shows, so here I go yapping. Andor is absolutely one of the best shows I've ever watched. Slower than most of the others, more focused on characters and story than just fight scenes, though there's some of those as well. Definitely worth seeing. The other live actions shows... less so. Mandalorian is definitely great, but season 3 fell off imo. Still worth a watch for sure (and I just see you already started it, so great). Obi Wan and BoBF shows are really mid, but they made BoBF kinda mandatory to watch, at least the last 2 episodes, before going into Mando season 3. At least they're both short, and the final 2 episodes of both are pretty fun to watch. Haven't seen Ahsoka yet (have to get my family up to speed on all the background). Don't know anything about the upcoming Acolyte show except that it's coming. From the trailer, it doesn't seem like it requires you to watch anything else first. The animated shows are pretty great. Clone Wars has a bunch of shitty episodes, but a lot of great ones too. Rebels can be kinda childish, but it's a solid show overall. Bad Batch has parts where it feels like the story doesn't really progress, but it's still solid fun to watch, and it gets more serious later on. Tales of the Jedi is short, but great. They have their weaknesses, but overall they're solid shows. Well written characters, generally good story (or story arcs in Clone Wars' case, less of an overarching story there), the fights are generally pretty good. Animation is great in the later Clone Wars seasons, as well as in Bad Batch and Tales. And Clone Wars and Rebels are imo kinda mandatory viewing for Ahsoka (hence why I haven't seen it yet, I'm catching my family up on Rebels still). No point in watching a show about Ahsoka and some Rebels characters without seeing Ahsoka's background and character development in Clone Wars, and getting to know the actual Rebels characters. That's what I think at least. As far as the animated shows go, Clone Wars comes first, then Tales of the Jedi, Rebels, and Bad Batch in whatever order you like. Bad Batch has a few callbacks to Rebels, but they're minor enough and explained enough that you don't need to watch Rebels first (at least not so far, final season is still airing). And there's a callback to Bad Batch in Tales, but that one really doesn't matter. More of a easter egg than anything else. Then there's also Star Wars Visions, which is just its own thing. And they recently released a trailer for Tales of the Empire, which definitely needs Mandalorian and (I think) Ahsoka, as well as Clone Wars, to know the characters it will be about. Even if you don't feel like reacting to all of it (Clone Wars and Rebels are pretty long), I do hope you watch them and enjoy them either way. I was always kinda hesitant to watch them, but I'm very happy my brother forced me to watch them with him. I already loved the movies, but I still don't think I would have been as invested in Star Wars if I hadn't watched the animated shows as well.

[@michael3349]

I saw this in theaters the day after Carrie Fisher died. Seeing Princess Leia at the end felt like a dagger to the heart, but in a good way (is that possible?). Easily the best of the Disney Star Wars movies. Great reaction. In fact, this might be a hot take, but if you combine this and "A New Hope" and considered it as one movie, I would rank it ahead of "Empire Strikes Back" as best in the franchise. Excellent characters, great story, loved the grittiness and "on-the-ground" war feel to it, and Darth Vader going full badass for the first time in any film is 🔥 Also, you gave your personal rankings of the first 6 Star Wars movies in your first two reaction videos, but I didn't see that in your sequel trilogy reactions. Are they ranked somewhere else, and if not, would you consider doing that at the end of the Solo reaction? P.S. hope you get a chance to come back north to see the eclipse!

[@pricemoore2022]

Awesome reaction of my favorite Star Wars movie!!!!!!!😊😊😊😊😊😊😊

[@granadosvm]

"You're one with the what?" 🤣 You made me laugh hard.

[@TheArtsofDoctorSeitan]

Solo is actually pretty great too. Not Rogue One great, but still pretty good.

[@Justanotherconsumer]

It’s a lot better than people claim, but it’s still… not amazing.

[@aikighost]

I honestly thought it was trash, made Han Solo lame.

[@martinjrgensen8234]

Only if you shut off your brain. It ruins Solo as a character.

[@user-hn1cx2hs8j]

Hope to see your reaction to Andor someday!

[@jonschneider5325]

Andor is the best Star Wars media out there period. Better than the movies, show ect. I know I’ll get hate for it but idc. I wish the attitude of that show would permeate to the rest of the IP.

[@peadarruane6582]

Haven't checked through the comments, so this has probably been mentioned, but one of the things that really brought that Star Wars feel to it, was the fact that Edwards used unused X-Wing clips from the original Trilogy, just polishing them up a bit, so that the attack on the shield gate felt really authentic.

[@jerodast]

Things that are always fun to hear halfway through a _Rogue One_ reaction: "Wow, I didn't think we'd actually see Vader!" and "I've really been meaning to watch the original trilogy again" 🤣🤣

[@mogg34y]

Absolutely brilliant 👏 I remember the pic dropping of the team on Yavin. I saw that pic and was more excited for that film 🎥 than the sequels!

[@armenianeric]

Rogue One is great. Andor is even better.

[@swish007]

it's kinda funny that vader goes in alone and rips through all those soldiers at the end of rogue one, and then after catching up with leia's ship he's just like "nah i'm tired, let the storm troopers handle it and I won't fight at all"

[@snorpenbass4196]

To be fair (ha!) to Annie, he had just realized he was above the one planet he loathed the most - Tatooine. I don't blame him for needing a moment.

[@Maya_Ruinz]

Definitely the best SW movie, Erso and Andor really bring that extra touch that SW has been missing.

[@MikeWood]

I watched this in the theater on the same day that Carrie Fisher passed away. Seeing Leia in the last scene got me in the feels. And it leading right into Episode for was really clever. I have watching this and Ep 4 back to back is a fun watch. :)

[@Samwise-tx7ub]

Hey Y! Great reaction! You are right to rate this movie so high. It's by far my favorite from all the other prequels or latest sequels. It ranks right up there with the first 2 Star Wars movie. In fact it's mention in the first movie that the plans where obtained at a high cost of lives so everyone had to die, but I never expected them to actually kill everyone (that's what really made this movie stand out to me). Fun fact, a lot of the scenes with the star fighters near the end of the movie was actually cut scenes from the very first Star War movie! Take care! XOXO

[@KennyYoutubeMakesMeFeelGood]

Thank you Yasmina :) Hope to see you at Star Wars one Very soon.. Been enjoying your reaction to mandalorian as well

[@cleeshay]

Great reaction to a great film. Real consequences for the leads give it so much gravity. I knew you'd really enjoy this one and think you will really appreciate Andor as well.

[@sjsampson5483]

Fun Fact: K2 is voiced by Alan Tudyk from Firefly and Resident Alien.

[@martinjrgensen8234]

And acted. He is in the mocap suit

[@marksullivan7766]

probably my favourite SW production since the original trilogy

[@carlperry75]

Great reaction to the best star wars movie from Disney,also Solo is underrated,it's great & u r gonna love it❤

[@keymack2477]

First time on your channel and I really enjoyed your reaction!! Loved "Rogue One" and I'm really looking forward to checking out your reactions to "The Mandalorian" and especially "Andor"! Solo is all right, but don't expect it to come near to this one.

[@shep4life]

This is one of my favorite Star Wars movie

[@bri_____]

14:33 OMG her facial expression killed me!😂😂

[@davidward9737]

Lol 22:36 the little girl scream of excitement to see a evil Sith Lord. Then you guys are screwed, this poo poo. 😂 comedy gold. I laughed so hard i had tears in my eyes.

[@kirkdarling4120]

I saw A New Hope in the first weekend of its release in 1977; I left the theater more elated than any movie I'd seen to that point. This was the first Star Wars movie that left me just as elated. That ending blending right into A New Hope was a surprise. But now, you _must_ watch Andor, which has some of the best writing of any Star Wars property. Solo is so-so. Not as bad as many say...it just came while so many of us still had a bad taste in our mouths from The Last Jedi.

[@doorofnight87]

I absolutely love Rogue One! It is such a brilliantly told and structured story that shows all the variety of people that were part of the Rebel Alliance and all the effort and sacrifices that went into fighting the Empire. It shows that the Rebels were so, so much more than the Hero Characters, but it also highlights the importance of Luke in the original trilogy because it is so clear that the Rebel Alliance has absolutely no answer for Darth Vader, so Luke IS still super important. Also, you should really watch Andor, which is a prequel series (Series 1 is out on Disney+, Series 2 just finished filming and will be out either towards the end of this year or sometime next) around Cassian Andor and how he became involved in the Rebel Alliance (season 1) and 2 will be how he came to be who he is at the start of this movie. The first season is absolutely and positively amazing, visually amazing, phenomenal storytelling.

[@Wicked_Sushi]

A New Hope, The Empire Strikes Back, half of Return of the Jedi, Revenge of the Sith, and Rogue One. That's all I need.

[@KennyYoutubeMakesMeFeelGood]

Hi Yasmina Happy April !!! I really enjoyed your reaction to star wars Rogue one. Can't wait for to see your reaction to more star wars

[@KennyYoutubeMakesMeFeelGood]

@yasminareacts Ty Yasmina You're always the best !!! :)

[@valeraoneshot918]

Rogue One is the best Disney SW movie.

[@thomasroth461]

I love this Movie!!

[@snorpenbass4196]

I'll admit I cheered when the little frigate that could took out two Star Destroyers by ramming them - the Hammerhead-style ships date back 3000 years and were the workhorses of the Old Republic, before corruption and the Sith conspired to disarm them. They ranged from enormous ships bigger than Imperial Star Destroyers to tiny frigates (like seen here), and even a superdreadnought that was bigger than Vader's flagship the Executor.

[@Will-nn6ux]

I'm glad you did enjoy it. I think this one deserves an episode number as it is such a huge part of the overall story! As important as any of the others. Episode 3.5? 😂 Those heroes may not have been 'magical chosen ones' like Luke Skywalker etc, but they got the job done...

[@Mackampackam]

Well, since one can't get much closer to 4, maybe Episode 3.999 would be the appropriate number. (But that would be a slight spoiler, maybe. :-)

[@jerodast]

Honestly if the way episodes 8-9 turned out doesn't dispel the importance of being an "official Star Wars episode", I don't know what will. It's funny looking at reviews of this because a lot of them compare it unfavorably to 7, "well it was okay but it didn't recapture the magic like the Real New Star Wars Movie did..." How do they all feel about the sequel trilogy now, I wonder. This one has really stood the test of time. And I would argue this was already at a quality level above all the others but Empire, if you stripped away the Solo shock value and the Skywalker tease anticipation at the end of 7.

[@f4irb4nks57]

This movie is S tier

[@_Young_jedi]

May the force be with you

[@socalpaul487]

"Rogue One" is my 2nd favorite "Star Wars" movie. It's now the perfect lead-in to the original "Star Wars" (pre update would be preferred)

[@Bigrp13]

What's up Yas. I didn't have a lot of faith in this movie when it was announced. Boy was I wrong. It's probably my favorite Star Wars Movie by Disney with The Force Awakens being the next. Really Happy you enjoyed it. Can't wait for next video. Keep you the Fantastic Work. And May the Force be With You.😊😊👍👍❤❤

[@itoao]

Glad you watched this before you watched Andor. It will make more sense.

[@lumityforever]

14:06 Any and all clone wars fans reconized that sound almost instantly

[@kaygee2121]

Pleaseeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee watch Andor...it's phenomenal 💖

[@frankducky6130]

Great movie.

[@MrKevinFHaney]

Since 77 I have seen every Star wars movie in the theater , I even seen the clone wars anime movie introduction of Ahsoka Tano in the theater I have enjoyed every one of them all of them

[@77magakill]

It was a very great Star Wars Movie!!! I enjoyed it a lot!!

[@ronfehr7899]

This movie, having been released decades after the first movie in 1977, reqired that the face of Grand Moff Tarkin be computer generated, as Peter Cushing, who played the role, had already passed away. Anything below the neck was just an actor standing in as a replacement.

[@michaelhoward142]

You should definitely watch "Solo". It's worth watching, but don't expect another "Rogue One". If you don't watch it, you'll always wonder what it was like. LOVED this reaction and eagerly awaiting your next Mando. 🤗

[@johnmiller7682]

You totally have to watch Andor next.

[@ClutchSituation]

Underrated? Fans consistently consider it among the top three Star Wars films?

[@SeanBlader]

Now that you've seen Rogue One, you can watch Andor... and it's end credit scene after the last episode. And the number of CLOSE CALLS right at the end as they were trying to get the plans out... Holy crap.

[@mikebrown7799]

Hello Yasmina!😊 Yeah, you probably didn't expect everyone to die. But, of course this makes sense, as we never saw these characters in the original trilogy. Yeah this film and Solo are stand alone Star Wars films. Great reactions to this well made Star Wars film, Yasmina!!!!🎬👏👏👏👏

[@atlantamx3]

ANDORRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR!

[@quoniam426]

Now you understand why Vader's question to the ship's captain at the beginning of Episode IV is purely rhetorical...

[@GenXJen78]

It's funny that you mentioned Flynn Rider, because I was just watching something about Tangled.

[@MadcapMatt]

I don't know if you buy physical media but Andor, and Obi-Wan are both getting physical releases on April 30th.

[@Rabbits6ix]

Andor !!!!

[@MadcapMatt]

One of the only things i agree with using AI for is something that James Earl Jones agreed to do is allow Star Wars to use his voice for Vader in anything going forward. He recorded enough lines to have the ability to use it to voice Darth Vader for any future projects. He will always and forever be the one voice.

[@DaleESkywalker]

This should be good!

[@i.shuuya3231]

4½ stars? Wow you really liked it!

[@andyaguilera4367]

I might get a lot of crap for saying this but in my opinion this is the best movie in the franchise. It hits you hard by the sacrifice of each character especially because it was well executed. 👌

[@crossbones13]

"I really do need to re-watch it (The Original Trilogy)." I hope you can track down the original un-edited versions of the original Star Wars movies and watch those. That way you can expose yourself to both versions (unedited and updated).

[@jerodast]

We had the VHS special editions for most of my teen years and while I remember all the hubbub about the changes, in the end I came to realize they didn't they hurt much, and some of the effects were actually pretty nice (Cloud City improved IMO). So I kinda let it go. Not worth making a fuss about. Then today I just saw the clip of the "updated" throne room climax from Return of the Jedi. Good...god. Just why.

[@janmortensen9314]

The best SW movie in my opinion; written by 2 fans

[@hoodwinkiez]

Was actually Maldives Planet.

[@renwood999]

for me it the best star wars movie since the first trilogy

[@christopheryochum3602]

It was heroic, wasn't it! I saw "Star Wars" in a theater when I was younger. I watched the trilogy, then years later the prequels came out, which I never warmed to so much. A lot of technology going on, special effects, and recasting to show characters when they were younger. Then I saw this and was reminded throughout the movie of the selfless heroism of all the characters. This movie is heroic! One last thing ... I REALLY liked K-2SO. A lot of people like silly or cute, but his droll, sarcastic manner was hilarious and refreshing to me.

[@questionablehumor2800]

Scarif was filmed in the Seychelles, for your vacation plans

[@paulchaisson8301]

The first trailer for this film has Saw Gerrera as part of the ground forces of Scarif, and I want to see that version, to compare if nothing else.

[@kevinc3427]

This is the only newer Star Wars, movie or tv show, that actually feels like Star Wars. It's good, which is surprising.

[@greatsageequaltoheaven8115]

Wrong Andor is good too.

[@DarthTecolote]

Rogue One has become my favorite SW over the years. I hope you get a chance to watch Andor. It is by far the best SW that Disney has produced. Hope you get to watch it soon. Thank you for sharing your reaction and thoughts.

[@Mikesupr1]

I really wanted to applaud at the end of the movie when I was in theatre, but more than Vader and his droids i was so glad I saw Bail Organa again.

[@StoneUFO]

rogue one was fantastic

[@michaelschroeck2254]

12:46 I see so many people do a rah rah rah for Jin in this discussion, but to me Andor won that conversation. He did not kill her dad. And yeah she suddenly becomes dedicated to the cause . That’s convenient for her. He had struggled since he was a child. He clearly has the better argument.