Roll for Sandwich EP 225 - 12/4/23

[@tvanddy]

I like how they gave you some leeway on greasy and you just went for the worst possible option. Because that's the true spirit of DnD.

[@Charizardtrainer6]

Gravy is probably the single funniest sauce you could have rolled with the make it greasy roll

[@divade]

Absolutely

[@saraschneider6781]

It's just thickened grease.🤣

[@Yammenkow]

When the gravy started sliding right off the grease I actually laughed right out loud. Amazing episode.

[@misterquark]

they didnt say sauce flip the grease you went ahead and did that to yourself, the committment to making this the worst possible experience is so impressive

[@everettehungerford2858]

I really feel like the McElboys left you enough wiggle room that you could have used mayo or olive oil, but you went hard! Respect.

[@Viniter]

I find it so funny that the sandwich that ended up getting greasy was the most middle-of-the-road ordinary sandwich. From hero to zero just like that!

[@saraschneider6781]

I think that's the first time a sandwich has gone from a 10 to a 0 with a single ingredient.

[@mpbx3003]

I really love the commitment to playing in the McElroy space here. It could've been done worse or better, but it was done as a solid nine.

[@Tailstraw_xD]

I GOT CHILLS, THEY'RE MULTIPLYIN'

[@caesarsalad77]

I mean, hell, you could have used bacon grease and just fried the sandwich in too much of it, but no, you took this one like a champ.

[@roeboatwade]

Honestly, that's what I'd envisioned!

[@heatherc9920]

What a hero. Putting up with that sensory nightmare for our entertainment!

[@legomojo]

Watching the gravy slide off the sandwich was the greatest thing I’ve ever seen. It brought me so much joy and the hardest laugh this shows ever gotten out of me.

[@dougiemcelroy]

I love this collab so much that I stick around for the non mcelroy stuff too. Great channel!

[@nathanielleon4163]

There were so many ways to make it greasy in a yummy way! This one was a gimmie!

[@robinsonlittle6422]

Honorable man! making it properly greasy!

[@Cyolx]

Thanks for being a good sport about the grease! I've also learned so much about different sandwich toppings/sauces. I'm enjoying myself and I hope you are too (when you're not rolling greasy 😂)

[@NuglessMacArthur]

Thank you for your sacrifice at the altar of our amusement

[@theWeaverofTales]

So brave of you to grease the outside. True dedication to the craft

[@KitDoctor]

good lord, that was hilarious watching your contorted facial expressions on this one. you were very brave - i also hate having gunk on my hands

[@QT-JME]

Way to keep to the spirit of the challenge! It's amazing how that one wild magic roll turned what would otherwise be a pretty good sandwich into a 0 lol.

[@joeeuston]

now this is what I came here for.... 10/10 watching experience

[@hankhowdy5228]

A second messy on the outside sandwich is crazy, especially when they left this one up to you

[@CaptIronfoundersson]

A perfectly average sammich turned evil by the power of grease.

[@toetotipthatsabart5048]

Absolute nightmare sandwich. I could feel the fucking GREASE!!!

[@crowdedsubwaystation]

Way to commit to the bit.

[@polken5418]

Mad respect for committing to the bit! You could have went easy on yourself but no, you literally slathered it in grease.

[@janedoe3043]

When I was young and the refrigerator was very bare I noticed a tub of Crisco. I had no idea what it was and thought maybe it was something sweet as it looked a little bit like frosting. One of the worst experiences of my life was taking a spoon and testing it. Why did you choose Crisco dude... Why not just bacon greese?!?!

[@cailinanne]

lol I love how you go for it with their crazy ideas 😂 I’m scared for the 2… I feel like it’s happened already and I haven’t gotten there yet. That was the only one I was like “MY BOYS NOOOOO”

[@3bugsinatrenchcoat]

i was having a bad day but now i am not. nothing cheers me up more than seeing you eat the worlds nastiest sammy

[@wardriveworley]

I would have toated the top bun in melted crisco. Still greasy, but way more palatable

[@nickhoule4027]

Last video you said the sandwich was kinda dry, so here you go!

[@ravensmadhouse75]

The Crisco just showed how Sadistic The McElroy Family & the dice can be.

[@ThatOneIrishFurry]

The first 0 of the season YIKES!

[@mowdownjoe]

I thought the cumin roll also sunk a sandwich down to 0...

[@adventuresinaardia]

Nope, didn’t go down that far

[@s.a.w5493]

Im sorry that I'm laughing so hard 😂

[@bassetts1899]

The McElroys really did you dirty on this one

[@alexschlessman5355]

Wow. Crisco. Thats so much

[@548Shen]

No spoilers.... but just..... NO! MY ENTIRE BODY REJECTS THIS EPISODE!

[@sethbacon7490]

My man didn't even get the butter flavored crisco... brutal

[@battlericky17]

That looked brutal, wash it down with a strong soda lol

[@Yes-os6tv]

I think it should have been greece-y since adding a whole box of olive salad would be chaotic

[@willowmcintire21]

In honor of its greasiness, I submit the alternate title of "The Randy Pitchford." (Shout-out to Civvie 11)

[@AaronMichaelLong]

I would have gone with bacon grease, though I admire your committment to the bit.

[@julz3884]

Technically could a deep fried it

[@phunkybarbie]

This feels inappropriate after the greasy nightmare but I totally agree with the you about bokchoy tasting tomatoey! Why is that? Umami flavor maybe?

[@robobeetlepanzer]

Here's hoping make it Greece-y works out better

[@strongaldweipemheiser]

damn bro i think you could have just poured some bacon grease over it 😭😭😭 didn't need to go right to the shortening

[@theWeaverofTales]

Ooh that knife is gorgeous, do you happen to know off-hand where you got it from?

[@SmartyPoohBear]

Never knew bok choy could be eaten raw.

[@hiimemily]

"I hate having slimy things on my hands." Real autism feels, that would make me inconsolably upset.

[@Tailstraw_xD]

YOU'RE HERE TOO?

[@ashleycook300]

They should be proud! They got you this time! Everything about that ssandwhich seems nice in practice, until you had to make it greesey.

[@paulper]

Hmmm… Wonder how it would have been with the buns seared with bacon grease

[@1BlueScreenOfDeath1]

impressive work, wild mcelroy table. a straight up 0/10.

[@oestranhomundodek]

I really hope you never get a 2 in the Wild Magic roll 😰

[@kaijew8930]

You went full on greasy Strangler on this sandwich.

[@meks039]

shouldve gone for olive oil. Simultaneously greasey and greece-y

[@nantwon]

surprised you didn't blanch the bok choy

[@WBF_III]

The HORROR

[@kingoberon]

I think I would have cooked the chicken in the lard maybe the carrots too

[@KiraBox1001]

oh NO

[@demetrinight5924]

With 19 being a usually good roll, I would have used sub oil to add flavor and seasoning to the sandwich. As a kid I ate a spoonful of shortening thinking it was frosting. (Because there was a frosted cake on the can) That was one of the most disgusting things I have ever tasted.

[@onetruegamer]

could have been so good if not for the grease

[@user-ow1bc4sx2r]

I frowned as you put the grease on the inside then turned that frown upside down as you continued to put it on the outside. This is maximum greasy

[@nicolehunt7548]

Seriously how many dice do you own? lol

[@merinawww]

You could have fried it in butter lmao WHY

[@austinsebben1402]

“Greasy” is so open ended, I thought you’d maybe fry all the ingredients when you got to this, or marinate them all in oil, definitely didn’t see this coming!

[@sharkofjoy]

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

[@isitatiger]

that was a horror

[@possumprince]

you could have used melted butter or olive oil...

[@GypsyxDarling]

🫡🫡🫡

[@spillfish4327]

As an autist my eyes have gone to hell

[@dorstos]

Everyday I yearn for dip it in the toilet.

[@nehpets216]

Fry it in Oil, seriously. That adds unneeded grease to it without being slimy. (Use twine or something to hold it together when frying)

[@Beeevaaa]

There were so many better ways to make it greasy D:

[@Jeevesie1988]

I was SURE you were gonna fry off some bacon and pour the grease on. This was so much worse. 🫠