Roy Keane and Gareth Southgate disagree over Nani Red Card | ITV Sport Retro

[@rhino916]

It was a different vibe watching Champions league on itv

[@Barry3326]

ITV home of Man Utd

[@AB-bc3vi]

Scenes

[@stevewood238]

5 minute build up to fucking huge games lol I did much prefer the sky/itv coverage to that of BT though

[@AbraarKhan123]

And you it’s going to be an advertisement break when that black and white thing pops up on the top right corner 😂

[@kendall_knows_best2872]

Rhino nothing better coming home from work forgetting it was on then flicking threw the 5 channels we had and seeing the game was on. Good times

[@zohebsadiq3028]

Roy Keane needs his own podcast

[@sammyod101]

LOL I can just imagine his reaction to someone suggesting that to him!

[@emmanuel-in-greece6954]

Nice idea in theory, but he doesn't seem like one to talk just for the sake of it.

[@timmcelroy2188]

@@sammyod101 "A podcast?! Do me a favour"

[@RyAn-sj7ck]

What a load of nonsense

[@Nickelodeon81]

He needs his own jail cell. Stupid thug.

[@joshm3059]

Bring back the Champions League on ITV.

[@joshsawyer5650]

Money says no

[@premierleagueisthebest8059]

Stop being such a thieving cheapskate and pay up you poor person.

[@joshsawyer5650]

Premier League is the best bt sport have sent in the cavalry

[@joshsawyer5650]

Premier League is the best jeez bet ur fun at parties

[@joshsawyer5650]

Premier League is the best I’ve got sky and bt u mug

[@personofinterest3062]

Gareth did good by growing his beard.

[@chelseawheatley7978]

When we had champions league on TV

[@Rodders0223]

When we had to listen to Chiles. Much better now.

[@estario]

@@Rodders0223 I didn't mind Chiles tbh. I enjoyed clive tyldesley commentary.

[@jordan4547]

Qwerty Qwertyson take Chiles over the crisp munching nonce any day

[@lxgann7361]

its still on tv its not on itv anymore👍

[@jamiemcintosh5197]

Yeah I hate it now. No cameras or other broadcasters showing the games. We only got the paper to read the next day

[@ABMultimediaDesigner]

This was good quality tv when you had European football

[@sc1788]

No it wasnt. ITV should have no sport. Adverts every 5 mins.

[@chrish2359]

S C It was free though. Plus Clive Tyldesley was a great UCL commentator.

[@muhammedsahil12]

S C yeah but it’s not like the ads came during the actual match

[@silentnight1805]

@@chrish2359 Clive Tyldesley. I miss that guy.

[@sugamgautam4318]

@@chrish2359 can't believe we went from Clive Tyldesley and itv to fucking Darren Fletcher and Bt sports. Bring ItV back ffs

[@horizoncomplete451]

Who is here when Roy Keane is destroying david de gea

[@the_only_1k704]

I'm sick of this gk I'd be swinging at him at half time💀

[@samuelbiswas615]

Lol

[@MichaelJ44]

Horizon Complete Typing “Lol” is stupid. Doesn’t benefit anything to the conversation

[@rohilthomson]

@@MichaelJ44 reprimanding someone for saying "lol" is stupid. Doesn't add anything to the conversation. Just let people live man this is the internet, not every comment thread needs to be an intellectual discourse of political standards. Sheesh.

[@MichaelJ44]

JUSTANOTHERWEEB Oh I’m sorry that comments should be related to the comment. Crucify me

[@footballnerd277]

Who's watching this after his rant on De Gea and Maguire? The only thing Roy Keane hates more than Man United fans, is Man United

[@jayaiyer2295]

No he loves united he cares for the club that’s y he gets so angry. He’s upset that they’re performances have been so underwhelming. If he doesn’t care about the club he wouldn’t care about results or performances

[@harrycartwright1922]

Football Nerd Why would hate Man United he played for them for 12 years?

[@noelrockz1]

Harry Cartwright he and SAF aren’t on good terms

[@lewanbroski504]

@@noelrockz1 doesn't mean he hates United itself he just doesn't agree with SAF

[@harrycartwright1922]

Noel S. Manuel Doesn’t mean he hates United

[@magikarpsplashy]

Keane wouldve given Nani a bollocking if he hadnt gone for that ball. Still wasnt over his fued with Fergie and it showed here

[@leakygussett4153]

Still wasn't and still isn't.

[@paddyanglais91]

2:24 in that closing monologue you can sense the pain

[@adriboy01]

Idk man, being a United fan I never understood what's the fuss about with this incident among our fans. It's dangerous play, a red card ain't that surprising.

[@magikarpsplashy]

@@adriboy01 even Mourinho said it was never a red card. Especially when De Jongs challenge on Alonso in the world cup final was 10 times worse and only got a yellow

[@gautierh2486]

Magikarp Splashy irrelevant

[@PantomimeHorse]

00:14 Roy Keane's eyes light up at the mention of 'brutality'

[@Iris_Studios]

Does he not think there’s other footballers on the pitch 😂😂 he’s got a point tbh haha

[@patrickmitchell3258]

😂😂 hes hilarious

[@Zero-wl7oe]

Damn right he is.

[@matthewgruter2937]

Ok so what about overhead kicks?

[@simonjrgensen6761]

@@matthewgruter2937 That's a red card if you actually kick someone in the face. Simple as that.

[@manu4eva999]

Might aswell not kick a ball then, there is other players on the pitch that might get kicked..stupid reasoning

[@wilabanodeniro9780]

0:21 on the left

[@Poecstasy]

The camera was quick with it too 😂

[@samvrs]

Was wondering that too😂

[@Aarwizzy]

If Roy Keane tells you it’s dangerous play, it’s dangerous play

[@capta1nnark546]

United fans when roy backs them: 'he knows his football' United fans when roy is against united: 'he just hates united'

[@Zero-wl7oe]

CAPTA1N STARK he’s pure honest.

[@peter9111]

0:21 the bag hahaha

[@handono5382]

hahaha wtf

[@flakecake9137]

Great banter

[@casinocasinocasino]

I was looking for this comment I knew I wasn’t the only one😂😂😂

[@kbgorman5138]

Just have a show of Roy Keane speaking for 1 hour every evening, 10/10 would watch

[@matthewdwan300]

Yeah But it was wrong in this instance

[@sanddsimpson6623]

no

[@domestosbleach7557]

I remember crying after this game as a child

[@sammyabdelhadi9438]

Me too. Felt really robbed here. We hammered them until that red card.

[@GoldonPopcorn]

Remember this game like it was yesterday was never a red

[@simonjrgensen6761]

100 % red. Learn the rules of the game boy. Keane is right on the money.

[@GoldonPopcorn]

Simon Jørgensen shut up pussy

[@Eafc_vinicius]

It is a red

[@Eafc_vinicius]

@@GoldonPopcorn shut the fuck up

[@IAmJonnariffic]

I still remember being SO angry when he was sent off. We were bossing the game. FURIOUS. Still think it was a yellow at worst.

[@kopthelotklopp1523]

Yeah man u were good in those days. Thing of the past.

[@dafyddcoleman4413]

Yellow at worst? Come on man.

[@fabiodanielmonteiro9168]

Arbeloa knew he deffo wasnt gonna get the ball, he went in knowing he'd get nani sent off. He put himself in danger, as nani didnt even see him . Bs till this day, we could've made a run that year

[@IAmJonnariffic]

Philip Brown Many more good days to come too.

[@IAmJonnariffic]

Dafydd Coleman That’s my honest opinion. There is no malicious intent. Nani was a diver and diva but it was never red.

[@danielkenderdine3668]

0:22 watch that bag lol am I the only one who noticed that

[@danielkenderdine3668]

I gotta quickly pause it at 0:22

[@jonahsparkes9781]

The bag in the background 🤣🤣🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣 0:20

[@rightsarentwrong5635]

I agree with Roy. I remember this red card. You can’t have your studs up at that height safely as evident by the Nani challenge. Not safe = dangerous play.

[@footballpicks1851]

Love you Roy but you’re wrong he has to go for the ball he’s just trying to control the ball out the air and the player comes very quickly with Nani not seeing him. My argument is if a ball is coming into the box the goalkeeper goes to punch the ball and he accidentally punches the ball and a players head at the same time it would be seen as an accident and wouldn’t get sent off, when in actual fact he is still endangering a player accidentally punching him.

[@kevintablet743]

Roy's not wrong and neither was the ref. Nani was charging in rushing for that ball naturally enough but his concentration in that moment is the ball, stopping it and preventing a goal Whether he knows the player is there is an irrelevance. There are 21 other players on the field, and 11 of them are coming after that ball on the opposition for a goal. Nani to control the ball puts his leg up at chest height and it makes contact with a player. That's pretty much it at that point. That player has an equal amount of opportunity as Nani does with that ball, and was heading it. Nani chose to use his leg instead of head and it brought the contact to the player. That is extremely dangerous play, therefore an automatic red card. You can definitely argue the yellow and on other occasions I've seen the yellow given, but I do think that that decision was a good call.

[@simonjrgensen6761]

Irrelevant what the intention is. It's dangerous play. When a player goes for the ball like Nani did then it's his responsibility. When you end up with you studs in the opponents chest then it's a straight red card. Simple as that.

[@kevintablet743]

@@simonjrgensen6761 yeah but its just that simple either. It really isnt Because right nani is aware of the ball and obviously aware of players, but at that moment is probably more dedicated towards the ball and stopping the run of play from their side to not let a goal be conceded. As well as that, it was a perfect moment to go on the counter. The leg as a way to control a ball is far more accurate then the head, which is why Nani opted for the leg to control and play the ball from first touch. He also probably thought I have space so I have more time. Unfortunately for him, at that same moment he has now made contact and clashed with another player. It's not simple. You can certainly say the yellow was actually a more understandable call based on nani's intent and circumstances. The red is the correct call, but it is both brave and at the same time harsh call.

[@Eafc_vinicius]

He still did a bad foul

[@petey3965]

Never a red.

[@billybob-fw3vr]

It was a red card.

[@Zubair292006]

It's a red card every time. No ambiguity whatsoever.

[@randoindabando9477]

@@Zubair292006 lmao no fucking way

[@jimbean1371]

Zubair Shehraz haha why have the majority of referees who gave their verdict on it said it was a yellow then because there was no malice whatsoever? It’s a yellow. It’s not serious foul play as he hasn’t used excessive force or brutality, high foot but no malice shown and therefore it’s a yellow. Check the IFAB laws and analyse it yourself. No need to argue with me or the many referees who have come out and said this themselves.

[@billybob-fw3vr]

Jim Bean unlucky it was a red card keep crying. Have your own opinion stop being a sheep and following other ppl. You can’t do flying karate kicks & not get sent off if you mean it or not..Dangerous play

[@IambiguousSegment]

Would be good if they actually showed us the red card to give some context.

[@Dunny2k]

Fucking hell remember watching this 7 years ago.

[@juanmanu9652]

Didn't realise Benny Hill was a football show host.

[@joshuacoombs1955]

funny thing is keane would have been pissed if he got sent off for this !!!

[@mathiasnorberg671]

He is always pissed off

[@simonjrgensen6761]

He just said he always asked himself if he gave the ref the opportunity to give him a red and this would be a situation where he would have.

[@pizzagateisreal]

So if someone goes for a overhead kick they should be sent off then as its dangerous play according to keanes logic

[@pizzagateisreal]

Seen loads of overhead kicks where a defender ducks out because they don't want to get kicked in the face. So it's unfair

[@Eafc_vinicius]

Man air kicked arbeloa in the air

[@pizzagateisreal]

@@Eafc_vinicius kzbin.info/www/bejne/bnioc2CKjrGAo7M

[@pizzagateisreal]

@@Eafc_vinicius i don't believe diaby got sent off for that and there are loads of e examples

[@pizzagateisreal]

@Shael Utah yeah yellow for both as intent should play a part, I'm saying kean is wrong not you. Keane thinks intent doesn't matter when it does

[@Collinzmusic]

This was entertaining. People discussing football with Passion. Great stuff.

[@Ese96Agboaye]

I miss the Champions League on ITV 😥

[@jkc2169]

Thought ITV had comments turned off?

[@stormtraitor6545]

Enjoy it while it lasts... 👀

Maybe theyve realised ITV will die if it doesnt start engaging with its online community more

[@youcefbelbina9970]

Damn I really miss champions league nights on itv

[@jagathwal9444]

From what I remember Nani extended his leg out (ever so slightly) towards Arbeloa when he felt the opposition player with his boot! For that reason I can see why the referee sent him off! I'm a lifelong United fan & am certain that United would have gone on to the latter stages of the competition had Nani not got sent off in this game! But we (as United fans) can't complain about this sending off. Keano in my opinion is up there as one of the best if not THE BEST United midfielder of all time, but he does seem a bit bitter in his assessment of the red card!

[@herakon5110]

0:20 who saw the bag being thrown in the air behind him😂😂😂

[@MrSpud900]

That’s what you find funny? 🤦‍♂️

[@herakon5110]

MrSpud900 I’m gonna try to find who asked?

[@MrSpud900]

Herakon lol still not funny

[@herakon5110]

@@MrSpud900 lol still no one asked

[@MrSpud900]

Herakon still no one finds your comment funny 😂😂

[@1979mattant]

Roy Keane is a strange thing with me, I'm a Newcastle fan and hated him as a player(but respected him), he also managed Sunderland but I love him as a pundit and think he's the best around, No nonsense or BS, He's straight to the point and is never wrong.

[@kinnexion]

He was wrong here, and he even received a warning from ITV because of how biased he was against United at the time. He still held a massive grudge against Fergie and United at the time. Now, he is a fantastic pundit, but back then, he was terrible because of his biased views

[@leebrown486]

I'm the same. Newcastle fan who I remember him starting it with shearer, being Sunderland manager more prominently and also some of the atrocious tackles he's done in his career. It's all set up for him to be one of my most disliked people in football and yet he views and talks about the game exactly as I like it. I can't help but enjoy him as a pundit, I wish more were like him.

[@1979mattant]

Paul Mcgregor Ok Paul

[@alexndr27]

How did Adrian ever get that job for the champions league 😄😄 MOTD2 was his calling.

[@bonnome2]

0:20 perfect photobomb

[@liamdunphy7496]

Chiles telling 3 footballers how the rules of football work

[@stephencooper5155]

Ridiculous, be like Southgate telling Chiles how to neck a pint smh

[@RTAC_1234]

Well, seeing as he had read the rules and evidently Dixon and Southgate hadn't then he was well-placed to do so.

[@thelad789]

That's our England manager chaps.

[@protajidoo2920]

0:19 there is a flynig black thing behind roy keane

[@Beans-On-Toast619]

0:21 the flying bag

[@jjahah4503]

I remember the thing in the top right it used to do my head in so much

[@wills.1978]

1:52 sad gareth playing with his pen after keane ate him alive

[@imaginezzy3673]

in all honesty, what does Roy actually mean when he says a player should be aware?!? when there's an air ball that you're going for, you'll need 100% focus on the ball to get it down or get the touch right. 100% focus, you can't even blink your eyes let alone check your shoulders. Nani was in full speed going for the ball, so was Arbeloa. Roy is right about awareness but the context to which he applied here is quite irrelevant

[@francisdubem5084]

I wish the champions league was still on Itv.

[@antizerooneonefour]

Everyone does

[@JakeJakeP]

Thank god adrian Chile’s isn’t on anymore

[@manurule12345]

Champions League is great full stop. BUT BT just somehow can't replicate the magic of it back when it was on ITV.

[@two8250]

I love Roy Keane man this guy kills it he is right aswell

[@Rockstar-bq5fm]

Haha recommendations are funny things, I imagine everyone watched Keans recent rant

[@phildean6884]

Ok to shut lee Dixon up on intent here we go. No referee in the world knows a players intentions. We are NOT mind readers. So IFAB CANNOT put intent on the laws of the game because there’s NO WAY to prove a players intentions.

[@minesh6467]

Tbh Roy Keane was massively salty when Ferguson was in charge of United. When he was a pundit, he would always talk negatively about united regardless of whether it was right or wrong, because he had alot of bitterness towards Ferguson. That's just the truth

[@Istancapital]

Talk now lol

[@Istancapital]

Talk now lol

[@chippyjones894]

I remember my head of year quoting Roy Keane the day after this in assembly

[@alexgood1039]

Lee Dixon ‘give him the benefit of the doubt and give him a yellow’ - doesn’t know how laws work

[@icemandef]

Funny that they can't show footage of the incident because BT Sport now own the rights to it.

[@rickgonzalez7830]

"Does he think he's gonna have 20 yards to himself?" best point made for this being a red.

[@ronnyjrgensen9091]

Totally agree with Roy Keane

[@harryjoshua2679]

I love how Keane isn’t bias 1 tiny bit

[@callumwhite516]

There might be a reason as he hated fergie and he was stabbed in the back by United

[@harryjoshua2679]

CMW14 Games how was he stabbed in the back

[@callumwhite516]

LEE KING SNATCH listen to keanes reason why he left united

[@NickM88]

This was many years ago and Keano still hated Fergie and United at this point. He knows full well it wasn’t a red card

[@eddienerphy5788]

What did they disagree over? Southgate said it was unintentional Keane said that's irrelevant Southgated agreed

[@mericusta1988]

Nani not aware at first, but instead of pulling his leg, he pushes further. It was intentional. The ref got some balls to call it, and they were punished later, and not being assigned to big game for a year.

[@gungagalunga9040]

I wonder did Keane ever doubt he give the ref an opportunity to send him off after the Haaland tackle lol.

[@ksportz66]

I agree with Keane . not very often i do but Nani totally knew they player was there. What sealed it for me Nani went to ground clutching a stray leg as he realized what had happened. As RK said, he gave the referee a decision to make and there was no need

[@JoshM512]

Never in a million years was that a red card

[@IAMENZOLEWIS]

But the challenge on alonso in the school final was a yellow

[@mrr1645]

Out of that commentary team 1: England manager 2: Best football pundit out there 3: The commentator that takes the piss out of you on fifa

[@leocallaghan6336]

1:15 Keane looks at Southgate as if to say wtf is this man talking about

[@onlyweatherlol93]

Southgate was out of line suggesting it wasn't a red card... intent doesn't always matter! You can't have your foot that high and then kick into an opponent and expect to stay on the field.

[@stevewood238]

Any comment Keane made about United while Ferguson was in charge cant be taken seriously

[@MIKE-TYTHON]

Want more classic Roy Keane punditry

[@squirrel7t7]

This was Keanos' agree with every decision that goes against united phase. Was never a straight red

[@kendall_knows_best2872]

When it’s given people say it’s soft but when it ain’t people say I’ve seen those given 🤷🏼‍♂️

[@JPhilocypher]

I love Roy Keane but he was wrong about the red card he was still extremely bitter with Fergie at this point in time and that affected his opinion a lot with United.

[@arronwrightham3058]

One of the worst red cards I have ever seen a joke remember thinking that at the time shocking decision

[@thelad789]

It was a red. He actually meant it as well. He had half a second to pull out and he didn't. In the Prem that would have been a yellow as all the refs were scared of Ferguson but in Europe they don't care. United should have won the Champions League on about 4 occasions under him, not 2. One of them was this season and the other was in 2004.

[@hackle511]

@@thelad789 he meant it? You must be joking

[@alvinanis3006]

@@thelad789 Nah that was a yellow at best, not a straight red.

[@thelad789]

@@hackle511 He could have pulled out.

[@thelad789]

@@alvinanis3006 No way.

[@AL-np5br]

Keano just isn’t capable of heated conversation, he struggles to come to terms with other people having opinions

[@billybob-fw3vr]

Because when he knows he’s 100% right he’s not gonna listen to your bs.

[@AL-np5br]

Game of opinions

[@billybob-fw3vr]

A L but you make it sound like he can’t have his own.

[@AL-np5br]

billy bob incorrect I said he struggles to come to terms with other people having opinions. Nothing about him having his own

[@nathan9048]

Roy keane "players need to be more tough" *player is tough* Roy keane " its a red card its dangerous"

[@mrNortheastlad11]

Right but studs in the chest isn’t about being tough you fucking tool

[@smitachube6135]

Feking Langer. He should Have his own Roy Keane Show!

[@ytnsanw]

Keano would disagree with the wall in a padded cell...

[@Richard-fv7rq]

Keane always has a frown and looks so angry all the time!

[@lewisjevons52]

I don't even watch football. I just come here to watch Roy Keane argue.

[@jeromejenkins352]

Yellow only, never a red.

[@alexbruce2405]

More Roy Keane content would be great

[@donathandorko]

Keano defending the red card and arguing with Southgate. I'm surprised neither of them brought up a certain incident in the FA Cup semi final 1995.... Love Roy, but this is his worst assessment in his pundit career. Never EVER a red card.

[@kylemc0254]

If nani just stood there and let the ball pass roy would be going whats he doing contol it!! Get ur leg up!!

[@Meepmeep888]

Garett Southgate without a beard looks way more British

[@andrxw4523]

“He’s not aware of that player coming” Yes...so if someone crashes their car into a group of kids, but they’re “not aware of the kids” it’s not their fault if they die? He made a dangerous challenge that shouldn’t be made, player in the way or not. Red card.

[@SalmanK7an]

That's one absurd analogy 😂😂

[@andrxw4523]

Salman Khan well it works, it’s an extreme to explain it to slow people

[@fuglsang1236]

Am i the only one who Saw that backpack in The Window?

[@johndawhale3197]

Ooooooh Chiles...things are gonna get easier...ooooooh Chiles things'ill be brighter...

[@Courtroom_Shenanigans]

Haaaa

[@Rock-Steady]

Dixon got it spot on. Keane is and has been losing the plot for sometime. I loved him at UTD but I now do nothing but laugh at him since he left. Gary Neville runs ring around him when it come to the media side. Watch & learn Keano.

[@Ryanwestham]

I miss Andy Townsend

[@williamjones9509]

Good old days football on itv. But Adrian chiles is out of his depth

[@CameronGillespiee]

am i litteraly the only one who prefers ucl on bt rather than itv

[@deathbystereo-]

After this game fergie didn’t come out for an interview. Right away I said it’s cos it was his last chance as would retire. I ended up being correct

[@bobbymunyavi5357]

That wasn't a red card. Not sure what the debate was about.

[@ashleythomas4112]

It was though, mot much debate to be had really.

[@thealgeriantank2587]

Roy Keane is one of the most footballers I dislike, but I would pay money to see him taking about the game, or even better: Having His OWN SHOW... He's to think of this... Seriously.

[@FootkerSnooball]

Keane would be screaming at the ref if a red card was given to him or his teammate for this. He always talks & makes decisions based on his agenda's he was still bitter about hpw he left ManUtd and still is bitter towards Ferguson. He's always praised Ronaldo so he won't talk much about Ronaldo not being the "bravest person on the planet" like he did Nani, despite Nani learning it from the likes of Ronaldo himself. What he really meant was Nani is Portuguese.

[@henryaustin3860]

Idk why people loved champions league on here so much the presenter didn’t even know what he was doing

[@blkmlk3608]

Does he not think theres other footballers on the pitch Haha. Roy Keane is too raww

[@davidvarey5072]

They didn’t disagree

[@crypeton]

Roy Keane is the Gordom Ramsay of football

[@KrisVic91]

No dude. Keane is just an old school dude who spits brutal truth. Ramsey is a toddler who swears.

[@crypeton]

@@KrisVic91 I agree with you actually, but I was just making a joke

[@KrisVic91]

@@crypeton 👍