S Club 8 vs S Club 7

S Club 8 vs S Club 7 in Don't stop moving and Don't stop moving til sundown

[@rnbsteenstar]

I love both of them!

[@B3R3N1C3A]

i like this song

[@signer25]

Never heard of this S Club 8, but they curtainly have some talent I'll give them that. Nice combination you have here. Different style of music, they both seem to have from one another, but S Club 7 does have far more experience than that of 8. Still, 8 is more up to date with today's generation of music style likings. Hard to say which is better.

[@shaniasnavel]

I think they both are good but if I had to choose S Club 7 hands down. I grew up listening to them and always will.

[@LatinGirl18]

I like the both, but I LOVE S Club 7, I have been a S Club 7 fan since 5 years ago and I have only been a S Club 8 fan since a couple of months ago. S Club 7 are the originals!! The best!

[@mark1460]

S Club Juniors were put together to be the support act on the coming S Club 7 tour. They proved a very popular group and were signed up to support S Club 7's later tour.This time they had a name change(S Club 8) and started to release records of their own, Many making it into the top 5 of the charts. These days Frankie is about to relaunch her pop career with a girl band..whatch this space

[@ursexgodjj]

frankie n rochelle from s club 8 are in the new girl band the saturdays. saw them at girls aloud concert at 02. cheryl tweedy is fit

[@signer25]

That I didn't know. Thanks for letting me know. I just knew that S Club 7 lost a member, became S Club. I didn't know that S Club 7 was attempting to find youth to carry on the name only as S Club Juniors. Thanks for letting me know.

[@Profoundness]

They didn't copy them. They were initially created as a supporting act for one of S Club 7's tours, but the record label decided to sign them afterwards...

[@tobylane]

Well duh. One was international, mid-late twenties, experienced people who could learn, the other was formed as a gimmick as a one off who just about lasted longer than that. Both amazing for what they are.

[@Scubaline]

s club 7 fo lyf!!!!!!!! plz get back together and make your tv show again it was excelent!

[@BowMastah]

S club 7 chose 10 people in S club search. 1 kid had an arguement with the management so he left(they didn't show him on the search) and the other kid had to leave due to studies. The 8 remaining were called S club Juniors. After s club 7 broke up they changed their name to s club 8 because they were getting older.

[@ChocolateSmooth]

they are the kiddy version of SC7, they were original called SCjuniors

[@NitroMikeo]

Sclub juniors was in the U.K only, and they were a childs version of Sclub 7, they were originally called SClub 8 and changed their name to Sclub8. They wernt as popular and slowly faded away. SClub7 split and a few of them found enw fame.

[@TwistedStables]

S Club 7 was the best. S Club 8's songs were okay in the beginning (One Step Closer & Automatic High), but there are way more S Club 7 songs that were amazing.

[@brittwait]

i've been listening to s club 7 for ever. but i think s club 8 is good for their age group.

[@tiffanyclf]

Oh i see. Thanks! ^^

[@scram93309]

s club 8 sound like kids and i grew up on s club 7 and they are the best

[@ves22kit]

years ago, s club juniors were created to be like s club 7, but were later changed to s club 8, but after s club 7 (later called s club, after one of the guys left) split up, s club 8 came to be known as just s club

[@musicgirl4ever1]

S Club 8 are good but I've loved S Club 7 since they got together so they win my vote.

[@luke8979]

am I the only one who likes S club 8 better?

[@Regel2008]

Battle of the Bands: 1)S Club 7 v S Club 8 v American Juniors; Winners: S Club 7 & S Club 8 2)S Club 7 v S Club 8; Winner: S Club 7 Overall Winner: S Club 7

[@derek47]

S Club 7 has the best vocals and choreography

[@BowMastah]

I like this video, the only problem is you're comparing a music video with a live(sorta) performance. If you put them both up Don't stop moving music video vs Sundown music video, then we would have an appropriate winner.

[@orientpearlruby]

I just love s Club 7~

[@quirkykidsph]

judging by these videos, i'd say s club 7. i mean i wasn't a big fan of them but 7 were more well put and their songs really showcased their voices. this 8 is hyper synthed/etc.

[@jessie245]

S club 8 were changed to a band called "I dream" or something like that.

[@utrerana93]

ola alguien save como se llama la cancion que aparecia al principio o al final de la serie que aperecian cantando en una azotea y k salian las letras s club 7 si alguien lo save k me lo diga por favor.gracias

[@hafiezdaniel]

S CLUB UNITED!!! They are both gr8.. if ppl wanna blame someone, they shud blame 19. 19 manages them and 19 told them to lipsync. SC7 does lipsync too.. SC8 had to follw their orders... I knw this coz i was involved with a management before and i knw how they work..

[@punkgurl1211]

S club 8 is suppose to be the jr version of the orginal, for me i still like the original one....i never heard S club 8 until like last last May (2006)....

[@jinnybaby]

ich finde beide bands toll.

[@cardinalrefuge]

What? There was an audition process for S Club 8, formerly known as S Club Juniors, and S Club 7 were the judges. They picked the kids and that's how S Club Juniors/8 started.

[@Ohpls16]

I soo agree with u!.. dan nobody can EVER replaced them! these kids wanted to be as popular as them well i dont blame them, anyway if they do then make their own name.. and not by picking up names or NAME like S CLUB 7. theyre just the only 1 s club and nobody can EVERRRR EVEEEEEEEEERRRRRRR change that!

[@Hollywooddreamer18]

S Club 8 is a group that was created by S Club 7 for a support act while at a competition.

[@iaevilmonkey]

i dont no weather im fucked of my face and want a laugh but when the dude first speaks it sounds like his voice wud go good in a rap record ....lmao

[@TaylorTiara14]

without doubt, S club 7 is better.....never even hear of S club 8?? And don't stop moving by SC7 is so so so much more catchy than than don't stop moving till sundown. S Club 7 will always have a special place in my heart!

[@Sakura815]

S-club 7 will always be the best because they were the originals.

[@bassdudex06]

S Club 7 fan since age 12

[@poketninja]

i watched s club 7 when i was 5 ^-^;; i have now i have a britsh accent, i didnt know they were britsh unitil a while ago

[@BowMastah]

They dont need to learn anymore. They actually did pretty good. You cant perform a live performance especially since its a remix vs an official video. Plus the S Club era is already over. It died 3 years ago after S club 8 split up.

[@Regel2008]

Sorry about the comment that I did, just want to get this out of my head, I respect both groups, lets just put this thing in the past

[@bubblesdew6]

preety good i give it a four out of five ****

[@joespice1999]

i agree, didnt know 8 existed. rachel is HOT!!!!! jos cute. the rest, whatever. but 7 rocks as a band. miss them

[@lolipop245]

anyone of u noes how 2 make a video or slide???is it webcam?camara?handphone?or all?or others???

[@kani92]

S Club 7 by far. the songs are much more catchy

[@Alapaca123]

ive never seen it, was it good???

[@hollistrman]

i love s club 8

[@Irisea]

i agree

[@LadyTarasque]

oh.. one more thing.. if any song you were going to compare from S Club 8, I think "One Step Closer" would have been a far better choice in comparison than "Sundown"

[@XxIc3Bb3Xx]

that sundown song really gives me a whoossshh i dunno y lol its a good song but i prefer s-club 7 i think cuz ov the movie probably

[@meesh92]

both sclub 7 and sclub 8 are fairly good, there is no need to compare them.

[@mensfoody]

i love s club 7, s club 7 s club 7 s club 7

[@xstephaniie]

S CLUB 7 FTW.

[@Kirochi]

7 is the way. Period.

[@jrtennis19]

I definately prefer S Club 7 more than S Club 8 by far

[@courtmak]

i love hannah!!!! (spearritt of course)

[@LunarEclipse360]

well by what I've seen through this video (and since I've never heard of S Club 8) S Club 8 was basically made to replace S Club 7 and well...I don't think it worked out or people would actually be hearing about them. S Club 7 is better because they're the original

[@jessie245]

angelaeum already told me that...

[@munchkin9306]

idream thats an apple program right!?!?!?!

[@tht4hj]

Those girls where fourteen years old in this video, but they seem older with that clothes and that makeup.. :S

[@irismey]

Was that Britney Spears in this video? Please, let me know. I gotta know.

[@musicgirl4ever1]

Download Bring it all back by S Club 7 this week and it might get in the chart. If s Club 8 were called something else and had nothing to do with s club 7 they would be ok.

[@Grace414]

s club is what S club juniors became after s club broke up. if you remeber s club whent on a surch for a band to be s club junior.

[@BowMastah]

s club 8 is awesome. THey should've played the real version of Sundown. Don't stop movin til sundown sucks. And a live performance vs a video isn't fair.

[@jessie245]

I didn't even know there was an s club 8.That just shows how much un successful they were.S CLUB 7 ROX!W00T!

[@HhOoRrSsEeGgAaLl]

They aren't a comeback. S club 7 made them, they had all these auditons and stuff and it came down to these 8. I think the older the singers are the better they are... look at S club 8 against American Juniors. Do you think its the experience?

[@gallafey]

I Liked S Club 7 & thought S club 8 wern't too bad ether but which better, S Club 7 or S Club 8, there's only one way find out FIIIIIGHHHT!

[@Pakistani1991]

S Club 7 and S Club 8 r the bst. U cnt decide which 1 of them r good bcoz both of them r good. Luv their dance, both of the groupz do nice dance and wish they cum bak.S Club 8copied S Club 7, first S Club 7 came then S Club 8. Giv them both 10 out of 10.

[@mspang001]

i so used to listening to s club 7 so i think s clube 7 is better

[@SilentFriction]

S Club 7 sang music that truly lifted the spirits of various youth and helped them develop confidence in themselves as opposed to others, now we can all agree S Club 8- or really just the pre-pubescent singers are singing complete rubbish. 7: Don't stop moving, find your own way to it. 8: Don't stop moving till sundown in the bigtown.

[@leetate]

same

[@sc8sundown]

S Club 8 are way better in my opinion! At least they can all sing!

[@MatthewMaliksi]

I nvr even new that there was an s club 8... But i like 7 better Go S Club 7!!!

[@naturelass]

i belive s-club 8 use to be s-club juniors untill either they added soem one or some people left anf other joined that or its a copy of s-club juniors but with 8 instead of 7

[@liljp123]

GO S CLUB 7!

[@TheRonnie149]

Hii S Club 8 vs Club 7 Rocks!

[@lilix57]

S club 8 100% J'adore

[@darrenalcira]

lol i didnt even know there was an s club 8 -.-

[@justxjayjay]

i mean an s club 8. i forgot the 8 sorry :/

[@BowMastah]

Yeah thats them. The look older now.

[@BowMastah]

S club 8 is great. I dont think you can compare a music video to a live(almost anyway) performance. Especially since that version of sundown is a remix. Now if you have Don't stop moving official video vs Sundown official video, then we have some real competition. I like the s club kids better.

[@BreyerGirl]

S Club 8

[@dinotehc]

It's S Club 7 which created the group S Club 8

[@zakkabil]

Bradley vs Frankie Jo vs Stacey

[@FredrikFlintstone]

s club 7. hands down.

[@danni811xx]

xhughsiex... I couldent agree with you more :P xo.

[@MapleStoryGrl]

no they spilt in 2004 i think..

[@milena1434]

la verdad a mi me gustaban ambos pero es qeu s club 8 era mas funky que 7 s club is more funky than 7 but 7 is more.....happy hahah

[@kamwrites]

The problem is, SC8 looks and sounds like kids trying to be adults. I find that a bit disturbing.

[@nickH2009]

s club=pop s club 8=techno pop pwns techno 4ever and always

[@NadeaAgus]

S CLUB 7!

[@PrimalWolf2006]

They're called S-Club Juniors not S-Club 8, and S-Club 7 changed their name to just plain S-Club.

[@chocolatequeen20000]

s club 8 were s club juniors until s club 7 broke up

[@micojoia]

Simple choice: SC7 loads of talent...SC8 who are they again?

[@OyeNacho]

Sclub 7 !!!! Yeah no more!

[@tiffanyclf]

sorry i don't know the facts. Can someone tell me why there isn't any S Club 7 or 8 anymore?

[@videodaniel8945]

Sclub 7 !

[@tiffanyclf]

you don't like them? But do you know why they split up?

[@illayacree]

S Club 8 just a techno band, but S Club 7 plays REAL music.

[@seraphis418]

s club 8 was chosen by s club 7 to replace them, but cmon who are we joking, who can replace s club 7