S Club - Alive Performance

S Club - Alive Performance

[@coreyhill681]

I love this group, very inspiring and teaches strategies to be optimistic and never give up, that's why I love this group, thank you for spreading great messages and keep it going

[@xxxxkukaixxxx]

But I love this version too! Rachel added some of her own flavor to this song, especially the 'there's a heaven for you and I' part in 3:00. :)

[@jeffrilicious]

rachel's vocals actually sounded just as good as jo's on this song...i would have never thought she had a voice that could hold some of jo's higher parts...especially at 3:18...prerecorded or not...lol

[@jrisien32]

yeah i love rach's version...she's the best! it's a refreshing change from always hearing jo's voice...but i do love jo! But rach just gives it more of a sexy feeling and makes it more of a sultry song then when jo sings it...they are all amazing!!! S CLUB 4 LIFE!!!

[@gaemlinsidoharthi]

There’s a heaven for you. There’s a heaven for me. There’s a heaven for you and me.

[@Gustava10]

Bring back the pop group musics!!!! Now it's only R&B,Hip Hop and Rock! I agree with Emilie!

[@blackvenomnicole]

Hannah is soo gorgeous! I love her.

[@nattyb45]

i heard everybody's in except Rachel and Hannah... they havent confirmed yet. I hope they say yes cause i remember listening to their music all day long when i was a kid and i never went to a concert... but this year i'll be living in France so i can go and see them in the UK! wooo

[@Gustava10]

I love this song!

[@LatinGirl18]

I like Jon's moves! And I like this song!! Rachel is really good!

[@Summer21.]

Yeah, I thought that Rachel was singing Jo's vocal parts of the song as well. I did know of her back problems and her slipped discs. Jon doing those moves, what a flexable , and cute man. Hehe. I love this song. Dazza xx :)

[@leosilva7525]

When you have 2 great options and you can't choose between them.

[@insane4DK]

This is when Jo had back problems so Rachel did the vocals here, but on the album it is Jo singing :)

[@devaalwine7224]

Work button factory Rachel

[@gordorules]

I miss S club!

[@Mightyblackcats]

this version rocks my socks!

[@SClub7and4Ever]

my too!! :D

[@jeffrilicious]

i noticed that too...watching older videos and performances and then ones closer to the disbanding...tina looks like she was over it and was just riding out the last leg of s club...probably cus she rarely sang lead...for more than a couple lines...'i'll be there" and 'stand by you' are counted in that...and 'stronger' too...out of as many albums they had...i'd be a little iffy about reuniting also...and less happy about just dancing in the back during live showings...lol

[@rephead]

Go Rachel!

[@xxxxkukaixxxx]

Personally no one could beat Jo for the high notes in 3:18. Even though I remembered I was pretty surprised to see Rachel pulling this off beautifully at that time. :D I was reading some of the comments here, and IMO, if Alive was to re-record by the second most powerful lead vocal, I would actually choose Tina. I remember watching the Carnival documentary and Tina could easily pull out such powerful and loud voices during warm-up (which was commented by Hannah as 'funny and extremely loud').

[@rephead]

found the mp3 yay!!

[@skulls16]

rachel is known for her good looks and jo is known for having a great singing voice...

[@skulls16]

yea

[@charlieluciano3994]

Rachel is so hot

[@cloverying8102]

rachel looks good

[@helena100lol]

poor Jo!

[@TyrekeCorrea]

I don't know. I mean, it was okay; Rachel's runs were interesting, but I like Jo's version better, because she hit her vocals with fuller voice.

[@skulls16]

the reason she sings more then the other girls is cuz she has a stronger voice.. all the girls have said that about jo.. ive heard it in interviews...

[@ZiPaD3doDAH]

I think during that time Jo (thats her name), had serious back problems so they had rachel sing Jo's parts.

[@satsujii]

she got to sing lead quitea few times in who do you think you are

[@skulls16]

i think so

[@Kelmurf313]

@ZiPaD3doDAH u mean mime......

[@AlexPenzance]

just u

[@wishdog]

most people don't

[@wishdog]

if they did it without the mics there would pretty much be no need for them to even be up there

[@PhilRocha]

I like Rache's version...

[@DragonMistEcstasy]

Same. She has a beautiful voice, unlike Jo.

[@ControleComPhil]

@@DragonMistEcstasyI believe Jo’s got a powerful voice. Her personality though…

[@DragonMistEcstasy]

​@@ControleComPhilpowerful yes. Beautiful, sadly no. Hence the distinction.

[@ControleComPhil]

@@DragonMistEcstasy that makes a hell lot of sense though

[@skulls16]

ok than...

[@moletfrog12]

um wheres jo?

[@skulls16]

tinas dancing like shes affraid to break a nail or something.. shes not moving around like the others r.

[@MorganaG16]

what happen with Jo and Paul? *-*

[@clairevenner868]

Jo had back problem and Paul left s club 7 and they rename s club

[@cmcd2513]

i agree, i like jos voice, but its too powerful for a group. I like rachel's more, its a softer but still powerful, just a different way

[@Fataltornado]

When Jon and Bradley do their moves, the back vocals still are the same as always, but I believe the main voices are real.

[@helena100lol]

at first i really liked tina because she was always dancing so lively but now in this video clip she barely moves! she's not dancing like she used to!

[@skulls16]

tina dances poorly in here.. she looks like she aint even trying...