Pakistan Fiasco || NBF 404 || Dr Shadee Elmasry

[@dratinite]

A new follower(also Egyptian!) and I have to say I really appreciate your podcasts. I watch a lot of Islamic content creators both Arabic and English and you've became among my favorites.

[@RAMESHKOTIKALAPUDI]

The little girl is so cute! She looks intelligent and confident too.

[@iakmal]

Are u muslim?

[@Johnny86-v8t]

Allahumabarik

[@ssaftm]

I think people commenting in comment section have not watched the whole video he talks more about victims of massacre here 56:37 . Chill out guys he is a human a sheikh but also a human

[@V0ayger]

Yeah, no thanks "idk if they are martyrs" "They died anyway"

[@afnanrehan8782]

Not sure why the killing of over 100 Pakistanis was brushed off like this. The entire segment was based off of assumptions like it was just 'the latte crowd' or 'they didn't go to the capital' (both untrue btw) discrediting what happened and the circumstances under which these people were killed. The lights were switched off, protestors were attacked from every direction, and there was a complete social media blackout. Would this be taken more seriously if more people had died? Would it still be important if no one died and the 'government' was successfully overthrown? For a podcast that regularly discusses the affairs of the ummah, all we ask was for this issue to be given a little more thought and a lot more compassion.

[@ShiQ-gc5tx]

The “latte crowd” may have been a marginally correct description a few years ago but with the election results, you can safely say IK enjoys popular appeal across segments. His party governs a province that is about as far away from being a “latte crowd” as is possible. Dr Shadee, spare the time to look up the names and faces of those who were killed please.

[@PeopleTreey789]

The official twitter account of pti has reported that only 5 people have been killed.May Allah have mercy on them

[@yahya7394]

Everything sheikh said was true idk why you’re mad lol. And he said CAPITOL not capital (in reference to the USA capitol storming). Had the protests actually been successful and continued fighting then we’d be speak about the situation very differently. People day every single day do u want sheikh to cry over them ??

[@ShiQ-gc5tx]

@@yahya7394 capitol for Pakistanis is the National Assembly, the building on the D Chowk where PTI protesters attempted to assemble. and no, people don’t die everyday by being shot at by paramilitary and military snipers!

[@yahya7394]

@ so then fight back harder I don’t understand why you guys come here and then cry about a situation that’s already done, if the protestors are actually fighting more and making a change then we have a different narrative

[@shamon24]

Despite titling this talk “Pakistan fiasco” (itself a belittling title), Dr Shadee treated this grave event, now known as the Islamabad massacre, so lightly. I was truly shocked by this lack of compassion for the brown ummah, especially when the blood of the martyrs has probably not even dried.

[@ShiQ-gc5tx]

Agreed! We love Dr Shadee and other teachers but the one thing that I and several friends who have been horrified with the unfolding events, notice how little the big names are either unaware or choose to pass this by like any other event in the country…

[@ShiQ-gc5tx]

Shaykh, i’m happy the brother you were discussing with tried to give you the majority Pakistani perspective about the issue, but when riots erupted in the UK, you brought on people like Paul W to talk about it. Would have been nice to do something like that rather than brush it aside. It almost sounded like 100 people getting cut down by live fire was too little and Imran Khans fault for not “cutting” a deal on the inside. Politics aside, I did request Dua Maghfirah too. We are 240million majority Muslim country. Heartbreaking

[@picklenugget1960]

We can't expect Dr. Shadee to be updated on every political situation taking place in other nations. I'm sure he was just unaware of all the details. Even when the Bangladesh protests were going on, Shaykh had limited knowledge of it which is understandable considering he is not a political analyst or has any ties to the subcontinent. And since when was Pakistan considered the brown ummah? What about the rest of the Muslims in the subcontinent?

[@shamon24]

He appears on podcasts to discuss politics relating to the ummah so I expected at least more seriousness than this. Ignorance about a matter does not justify what honestly felt like a jeering commentary about the protesters and their grievances. I specifically mentioned brown ummah bc the jeering tone bordered on an arrogance towards Pakistanis. I’m not Pakistani btw.

[@fatimaking184]

literally, equating pakistan as the whole brown ummah speaks for itself, chill out on the ustadth

[@Pkfirst786]

Pakistani army at the behest of UAE, aided by KSa and supported by us carried this out

[@muslim_first]

Imran Khan is supported by US whenever a major Chinese delegation arrives in Islamabad he calls for a protest

[@pakistanimuslim4431]

Pakistani army understand the great game of the region and are not nalaik like Imran Khan

[@Pkfirst786]

@ And the great game of Israel as well. No body in 77 years have stood up to this armed mafia, time will tell and this will not be sustained.

[@Pkfirst786]

@ Muslims should beware that the devil bigger than Israel is uae. So stop running to Dubai and investing in it if you remotely care about ummah

[@n.a.1397]

@@pakistanimuslim4431 They are bey ghayrat. Still mentally colonized.

[@Barkat90]

Ive been watching this podcasts for while. Disappointed with a lack of seriousness and empathy for the pakistan issue.

[@V0ayger]

JazakAllah for covering this issue dr shadee But hundreds are dead and you kept smiling through the whole thing, please show some respect

[@MuslimNL]

I’m not in favor for Nawaz Sharif. At the same time I’m against PTI including Imran Khan. They reap what they sow. Remember how under PTI the police fired on ulema and killed scholars of islam and others who demonstrated for islam (khatm-e-nabuwat)? I believe this is the result of the dua of Allama Khadim. Search for: Jalali dua Allama Khadim.

[@Johnny86-v8t]

Go do some research. It was 10-12 ppl

[@V0ayger]

@Johnny86-v8t Dumb patwari spotted

[@Johnny86-v8t]

@@V0ayger Cite your sources and evidence of "hundreds" being killed.

[@zainmustafa4711]

Was it gheebah in the start? About the dude who didn't say hi/hello etc

[@UFC--ty3mt]

Pls add timestamps 🙏

[@NM-md8se]

With all due respect, may Allah preserve our ummah in every place, but Pakistanis don't exactly have a history of unifying with the struggles of the Ummah. Over the years, I've heard Pakistanis call afghans beggars and terrorists, ignore the plight of Palestinians, yemenis, sudanese, and Syrians. When you don't have rahma for your brothers, exclude people from your all Urdu halaqas, develop masjid boards to exit non Pakistani imams, etc. Then it's really hard to ignore your separation. When non Muslim schools allow solidarity with Palestine, but pakistani run Islamic schools don't, you can't expect not to be tested.

[@aub3365]

I am a Pakistani but never new about that. OIC was founded by the efforts of Pakistan, but seeing it's failure, I can agree that we failed to contribute towards ummah. But InshaAllah, their will be a revival. Their is an increased trend of learning Arabic and Islamic sciences, which will inshaAllah strengthen our bond with the ummah.

[@mo.shaggy1392]

Never expected him to be on such a lighter front being this issue grave to the extent of innocent bloodshed!

[@Johnny86-v8t]

A failed coup

[@JavTheJoker]

I think Dr Shadee approached the pakistan topic in the wrong way to begin with, as he seemed annoyed by the comments thinking that he knew about it. Not making any excuses for his lack of empathy btw, he should've atleast shown some more sincerity on the matter.

[@nktcell]

Who is too busy being in love!?!?

[@honesty_provides_tranquility]

13:43 the mentioned 100-150 ppl get killed and he doesn’t even flinch To tag you post with Pakistan and then be ignorant to what is going on is beyond crass and insensitive Does this Guy have ADHD or isn’t able to confuse when someone speaking - rude

[@saltymangoparty]

In the sheikh's defense, he actually did flinch hard at 15:17 when he heard the number of people killed.

[@V0ayger]

@@saltymangoparty but didn't stop smiling

[@aimanismail4683]

When we talk about our martyrs we are not sad. Are we now looking at flinches per minute when evaluating how concerned someone is about something?

[@GhulamMustafa-pn2xi]

Asalaam alaykum wa rahmatullah shaykh, as a representation of the IT community. I just have to say is that we are pretty studious as technology evolve so we do as well with knowledge and certs. Also, the medical student is not gonna fix that printer problem.

[@zainmustafa4711]

Would have been a whole LOT better if Dr Shadee didn't touch this topic at all. He has literally belittled loss of so many human lives, obviously he did it unknowingly...but not necessay to poke one's nose in every matter

[@V0ayger]

@@zainmustafa4711 yeah he kept on making assumptions on the fly Imam Malik rahimahullah said: “It is from the insight of a man of knowledge that he says: ‘I don’t know’.”

[@RangeGleasry]

A nurse practitioner has a PhD

[@terrymcginnis01]

Actually, Nurse Practitioner is title bestowed upon nurses who have earned a Master’s degree and completed additional clinical training that qualifies them to become certified in one or more specialties. Nurse Practitioners may prepare at the master’s level or they can earn a DNP degree. A Doctor of Nursing Practice (DNP) is a post-master’s degree, also known as a terminal degree. A DNP degree program prepares nurses for roles in advanced clinical practice and healthcare leadership. A DNP degree is on par with a Doctor of Philosophy, or a PhD degree in nursing, but the DNP focuses on nursing practice rather than research.

[@hamzak6437]

Idk why people overseas love imran khan and pti. What have they done in the province the control ? They came with the help of the establishment and dont have their support simple as that. They arent thr saviours you think they are

[@ShiQ-gc5tx]

Overseas? You serious? what happened in the Feb 8 election when the overseas didn’t even vote? whether you like it or not, iK enjoys massive popular appeal and now even more so because of his refusal to bend the knee to the junta.

[@thisismylongusernameonyoutube]

So the majority of Pakistanis who voted for Imran Khan came from abroad? Bass karo yaar!

[@noamansattar]

If they weren’t so good in the province they controlled, then they wouldn’t have been re elected in the same province. This is how we see it.

[@hamzak6437]

@@ShiQ-gc5tx please he has been the biggest ass kisser of them all, His interviews on bajwa establishment are online for all to see he only changed his tune when he was kicked out of power not because he had a change of heart lol

[@hamzak6437]

@@thisismylongusernameonyoutube You cant claim that what you won is right and what you lost was rigged, maybe pakistan didnt vote for him How do you know he enjoys a majority ?

[@tashifjilani1732]

4:20

[@hinatila]

PTIshoukd block GT Road and Motorway at Sawabi not allowing any movement to KP...Establishment will bent their knees

[@SHAHzbii-os3yc]

Dissappinted!! Sheikh looked non serious, lack of interest, wanted to get over it quick...People are killed here, fellow brethren in Faith, and you wanna joke 😒

[@V0ayger]

@@SHAHzbii-os3yc I love watching dr shadee , but yes, this came off as nothing but insensitive

[@publicpm8809]

Disappointed, brother you should either stay on what you understand or if you wanna talk then do proper research….u have no idea about the brutality going on in Pakistan by military

[@Hkhan23]

Nothin but facts? You sure about that brotha?

[@AliSidTex]

As a Pakistani Imran Khan supporter, I have to be honest, this guy is 100% right. The die hard supporters are the upper middle class english speakers. That's always been one problem with Pakistani political movements. Most of the working class are not involved at all.

[@ShiQ-gc5tx]

yeah right! by that reckoning, 70-75% of Pakistan, maybe more is upper class English speakers! please update yourself on the Feb 8 election REAL outcome and go have a look through the visuals of D Chowk .. these were ordinary men majorly from KPK but also from other parts of the country riding motorbikes, trucks, on foot, carrying knapsacks to the protest ...

[@naveedanjum6569]

Long live Pakistan army!

[@betelgeuse3287]

His wife is a barelvi, she used to be a pir, she even tried to use a bit of sectarianism(common for barelvis) to get support for the cause but the majority of pakistan and punjab which are barelvis abandoned her, most of their scholars are pro-regime. She did got support from deobandi dominated KPK province but the regime in Pakistan has become too strong and they didn't stand a chance.

[@muslim_first]

Most of Pakistan is hanafi school of thought from Sunni Islam

[@pakistanimuslim4431]

Most Pakistanis are hanafi

[@Fauji291-c9l]

There is no regime in Pakistan. It's a forceful takeover of the country by the criminal elite. Pakistan was never independent. It was hijacked from the outset but people like you will always spread the propaganda because you know what you are the urine of the ruling elite. You're nothing

[@betelgeuse3287]

​@@Fauji291-c9l"The term regime is often used critically to portray a leader as corrupt or undemocratic.While the term originally referred to any type of government, in modern usage it often has a negative connotation, implying authoritarianism or dictatorship. Merriam-Webster defines a regime simply as a form of government, while the Oxford English Dictionary defines it as "a government, especially an authoritarian one."" Source: Wikipedia. Not very bright are you ?

[@thamama-rh5oe]

Just shut up ya put everything on sunnis

[@KS-fp9vo]

Fake news