Same-Sex judgement: Marriage not a fundamental right, CJI DY Chandrachud

The Chief Justice of India while delivering the verdict regarding the legal recognition of same-sex marriages in the country made key statements on the case and directed the Centre, state governments to ensure no discrimination against queer people on basis of their sexual orientation.
#samesexwedding #supremecourt #supremecourtofindia #cjidychandrachud #india #pride
► Subscribe to The Economic Times for the latest video updates. It's free! - kzbin.info...
► More Videos @ ETTV - economictimes.indiatimes.com/TV
► EconomicTimes.com
► For business news on the go, download ET app:
etapp.onelink.me/tOvY/Economi...
Follow ET on:
► Facebook - / economictimes
► Twitter - / economictimes
► LinkedIn - / economictimes
► Instagram - / the_economic_times
► Flipboard - flipboard.com/@economictimes
#news #latestnews #economictimes #ET #TheEconomicTimes #businessnews

[@kanishkadounkal7499]

We are proud of our honest chief justice Chanderchud sir.

[@dryash866]

He said he can't make a decision. ..that doesn't mean he banned that decision of not marrying

[@peacefull7279]

He is cowherd and pushing the ball in th Govs court.

[@chittisandy1987]

​@@dryash866that is just not to hurt their feelings

[@TedoR2011]

Looks like BJP Hamas and Klu Klux Clan will agree to this verdict.

[@atintripathi5948]

Oh how about Russia china and North Korea BJP has nothing to do CJI

[@rainb5987]

It's still good since the India Supreme Court recognizes the right of LGBT people to enter union.

[@allaboutpets946]

Marriage by the word has meaning more beyond just being partners. So, like others normal couples also have a right to protect their dignity. If there are legal issue for the other gender, an alternate term other than the word marriage can be thought of so that their interests are protected and the existing normal also do not feel intruded. Fight is more for the word "Marriage' than anything else. Just make an alternate arrangement rather than coming into conflict.

[@user-ok7nw3hd4k]

What a joke you are making, marriage as a term is used in regards to property being joined. Not just humans, epic fail.

[@hype5471]

The problem with a separate word to refer to the union between an alternative couple is that it will eventually be relegated to an inferior status. The concept of "separate but equal" is just that, a concept. It never translates into practice.

[@AyeshaMalik-shorts]

मेरा कमेंट उन भारतीय लोगों के लिए है जिन्होंने मेरा चेहरा देखकर मुझे हिम्मत दी और मेरे वीडियो को लाइक किया. आपके सम्मान और सहानुभूति के लिए धन्यवाद भारत

[@beinghuman6115]

Not upto the mark on judges for this decision as this is law and should not be political or parliament decision. If lbtq community want to marry their own choice why we stop their right. Its shameful or sin that we destroy human feeling. If you're not belong to lbgt community will you not marry? Marriage is between two persons love is love why we discriminate against? If you are straight you will be married a straight person and if they let them have their own right 💟

[@Prakhar_Kumar00]

Marriage by the word has meaning more beyond just being partners. So, like others normal couples also have a right to protect their dignity. If there are legal issue for the other gender, an alternate term other than the word marriage can be thought of so that their interests are protected and the existing normal also do not feel intruded. Fight is more for the word "Marriage' than anything else. Just make an alternate arrangement rather than coming into conflict. Marriage is a social construct my friend, not just about stopping someone's right, they are given the ight to come in a union with almost all the benefits of a marriage, what problem do you have in coming in a union? why is it more of a word play, then just fighting for rights, you've got your right ,be happy with it, don't fight for the name of marriage. Marriage is not just among two people, but a union is. then one day you'll start asking for rights for incest and as SC said its far-fetched.

[@aditya-ml6km]

Who is a husband or a wife in a same sex marriage?

[@Ancz7]

The Court did its best imo. Many legal rights were given and wills may be written down subjectively. That said, Judiciary can never change the word of the law. Basically, thank God Art. 16 doesn't use Gender 😂😂. The next opportunity for the Queer community would be the BJP UCC, where basic changes in the definition can resolve most of the problems. This should go bipartisan in five or so years.

[@Ancz7]

​@@Prakhar_Kumar00 In a liberal democracy, you have a right to protect your dignity as long as it doesn't take away from the freedom of others. The "dignity" of a heterosexual marriage is already recognised and adding all orientation would only add weight to its plurality. Anyway, Law is never the upholder of tradition, but the enforcer of freedom.

[@user-qz3to7gd5l]

Does Christians and Islam support LGBTQ community??

[@ultimateriderofficial]

Absolutely not

[@Alfreddavid777]

No way

[@dryash866]

​@@Alfreddavid777no way bcoz u r not a homosexual. ..if u were a homosexual answer would ve been other wise

[@ultimateriderofficial]

@@dryash866 chhaka😂😂🤮

[@Alfreddavid777]

@@dryash866 it's not a Indian culture my friend

[@danalois8864]

Interesting. Divisions seem to be the order of the day rather than inclusion. What, pray tell me, would sane sex marriage take away from anyone?

[@sansinsearch]

ET team. What a sad choice of title chosen for this video. The choice of the title should have been more in favor of the positives that have come out in the interest of the Queer community. But your choice of title for this video seems to support the views and position of BJP....not surprisingly...by the times group.

[@Ancz7]

That was the main takeaway. There is a legal definition of "Marriage" drafted by the Parliament which prevents all "Unions" getting marital rights. The SC can't change that. I think the Queer community already had all the benifits of a "Union". The other things were clarifications already in use and recommendations. It is also Insane that Rt to form unions can be suspended in a National Emergency cause it actually refers to worker rights 😂😂.

[@notinterested8452]

The one true religion of India doesn't agree with the false dogma of incel or involuntary celebacy. Celebacy is the highest virtue in men. Voluntary celebacy followed by legal marrage and procreation ONLY no enjoyment whatever. The very ideal that life is about shallow enjoyment of the restless senses is Asura and not welcome to inhabit the holy land.

[@Prakhar_Kumar00]

bro, if our previous generation followed celebacy ,we wouldn't be here to say that, lmao

[@notinterested8452]

@@Prakhar_Kumar00 you're not my bro.

[@Prakhar_Kumar00]

well i believe in fraternity@@notinterested8452

[@frrajendranayak9479]

Men and women are equal in dignity but are different and complementary and reach at the fullness. A child who lacks mother or father will lack the full care of both parents. A man can't replace a woman and vice versa.

[@user-ok7nw3hd4k]

And nothing can replace those who embrace their ignorance. The LGBTQ community has a long recorded history in Ancient India due to the prevalence of the accepting Hindu spiritual traditions and cultures across the subcontinent, with a turbulent period following Islamic Turkic rule and Christian European colonialism that introduced homophobic and transphobic laws, thus criminalizing homosexuality and transsexuality.

[@PKorp-PriyankaKalyan]

No, child needs Feminity and Masculinity, not Man or Woman.

[@4happiness601]

May one of your child becomes lgbtq and let's see how you handle it.

[@jaiveeru5897]

​@@PKorp-PriyankaKalyanGo preach it to the process of evolution with millions of years of experience. Statistically biological females have a feminine element and men have masculine elements. Just because few woke idiots think of something it doesn't make it right. It would have been an easier battle if same sex couples fought for a label different than "marriage".. They tried to do too much too soon and ended up with nothing.

[@Yourbrother05]

May your child not be born or does after birth, see how you handle it😌

[@AnnieDavid-gb4bl]

Marriage is a holy sacrament for some religions. The Unity of two different genders, planning and arranging, then starting a family life, loving,sharing and caring each other, modifying certain manners, culture, rules and regulations boundaries to follow generation to generation, thus the way maintaining a safe and loving cultural background. When MY God created Man Adam, God perfectly made a Woman companion for Adam, and beautifully gave proper guidance to follow. We all have freedom to choose whatever we want to live in a safe and comfortable life without hurting others. Please be comfortable with what we have, who you are, rather than fighting with laws and Acts with more demands and benefits. We love you all as our own family members.

[@sudhakar7889]

God is still illusion and ambiguous. Your arguments falls down there itself.

[@AnnieDavid-gb4bl]

@@sudhakar7889 I corrected the statement as MY GOD. Thanks.

[@swarnadipmitra1095]

So somebody not recognising your god, for him or her you are still unmarried!!

[@betrue755]

Marriage is a holy sacrament. What is divorce?

[@PK2G]

Y does humans need law policies in evrythinv to live der lyf? Lets sum life live without d need of law n limitations policies😊

[@nishantamedhi1175]

Wah...ye ki na intellectual wali baat ....without law or constitution anybody can kill anybody ...anybody can take ur money nd go away ...law doesnt restrict u ...it gives u protection nd freedom sameas other person ...so that society doesnt become jungle raaj ...

[@dryash866]

@@nishantamedhi1175 law cannot withhold the nature of someone's birth and sexuality and their natural orientation

[@PK2G]

@@nishantamedhi1175 i didn say withdraw law policies completly lyk u refering money and killing lyf... but im saying dat lets sum of d life living not needed with law n limitation policies...

[@nishantamedhi1175]

@@dryash866 law is not withholding ....it is giving u recognition in the form of fundamental rights .....which are not permission but natural right which state can not violate .

[@notinterested8452]

​@@PK2Glet's use your use of the English language well misuse really as a good example of why your choice to call jihadi bhai and blame british leads to your own downfall.

[@apoorvs2789]

Cant find a clear statement where he says same sex marriage is not recognised... all heis talkingis positive for LGBTQIA+..... Is it only me?

[@Prakhar_Kumar00]

its diplomatic language brother, he inculcated the good points of both the sides in his judgements which could be taken together, and he agreed by the fact that, this sensitive issue to the society should be taken care of by the legislative, as its beyond the courts institution

[@ameetlibran9845]

Developed Nation has allowed Civil Partnerships proudly been more than Decades. I wonder what was so difficult for India to stop their Proud Discrimination practices.

[@user-jr6rg5uh3c]

Most of Indian population don't want it. That is only reason

[@ameetlibran9845]

@user-jr6rg5uh3c Moat of the Indian's want to Litter around the Streets & make Cities a Massive Dump, that doesn't make them right either. LGBTQ people are Honest People fighting for their own rights & I am sure this is not to much to ask for.

[@krish7199]

OUR Indian society have the right to recognise and derecognise something. Just because we are not recognising something does not mean we are against it. Implementation of such law will dilute the definition of men and women which would ultimately defeat the purpose of law! Law does not restrict LGBTQ+++ and whater bulls*t comes next, but it can choose to NOT give a recognition of a "marriage"

[@deepalil1085]

Partnership is different from marriage. They want all rights like heterosexuals but Indian laws need reforms.

[@ameetlibran9845]

It's a Loud & clear discrimination Proudly practiced in India. What else can we expect from a Nation who has Discrimination based on Caste Colour Religion... LGBT aren't even considered Human beings Sadly, forget about Equal Rights. PM should be ashamed, him visiting Western country for Trade but doesn't want to take any inspiration in terms of Equal rights.

[@balajikv1310]

Fantastic..good decisions by sc

[@A_common_guy]

*Bharatiya culture and tradition should always maintain it's purity* 🇮🇳🕉️

[@alas.i.am.]

bharatiya culture is accepting of the lgbt community 🏳️‍🌈❤️😊

[@dryash866]

Indian culture is with homosexuality ever

[@ultimateriderofficial]

@@dryash866 indian culture is never with homesexuality.

[@user-ok7nw3hd4k]

Something tells you you had better study the culture and traditions of India that include many ancient statues of individuals engaged in same sex situations.

[@user-ok7nw3hd4k]

@@dryash866 So many ancient statues and temples make your case here. It is only the British mind infection of Christianity that has people thinking as they do know, still their minds are ruled by British Christianity, sad they forget their own culture and past prior.

[@MrCJ-qz9dl]

I read that same-sex marriage is a "fundamental right". If you look at it that way, then you are asking taxpayers to *"fund a mental"* and immoral relationship. The term itself--same sex union--sounds contradictory.

[@mhdzakeriya252]

Win 🇮🇳 ❤

[@screendustchannel]

I have ten girlfriends is it possible to marry them all? Let me know friends

[@sudhakar7889]

Yes if you want to. But stupid laws don't want you to.

[@vartika8176]

Convert to Islam then you can marry your sister as well

[@betrue755]

10 gf F*ck boy detected!!!!

[@PMAccount-js5wz]

@@vartika8176 HELP

[@reardelt]

queers are only less than 1% of population. We should focus on infrastructure and build more mahamargs. We need to stop being distracted

[@deepdas1434]

Who told you that? They are 7-10% of India' s total population

[@Prakhar_Kumar00]

that will be majoritarianism,

[@reardelt]

@@Prakhar_Kumar00 Nothing wrong with majoritarianism. Democracy is all about majoritarianism. To become a PM, you need to majority of the vote. Tyranny is when you have a minority deciding over a majority. So it seems you like tyranny

[@reardelt]

@@deepdas1434 You are getting info from WhatsApp university. Are you saying 10 out of 100 students in your school are queer? Please think before you speak.

[@Prakhar_Kumar00]

@@reardelt Lmfao, bro. Understand democracy at its core. Majoritarianism is the failure of democratic principles. You have no fundamental knowledge of the words you're dealing with. Go study what it means by democracy, and what is the difference between democracy and majoritarianism, What are the few principles which democracy stands upon.

[@sudhakar7889]

Such spineless supreme court. What a shame!!

[@maiholiaw4927]

Why! Because the judgement doesn't go your way?

[@BestInterviewclips]

I mean I can only laugh about your awareness The duty of supreme court is to interpret constitution and laws They can't make laws They just interpreted marriage act It is duty of parliament to make a law on this if they wish not supreme courts And mind you this is the same justice Chandrachud who gave landmark judgement of right to privacy as fundamental right which made way for decriminalization of homosexuality Spineless supreme court bole yeh kya south ki film Chal rahi hai kya ki jo man mai aaya sahi galat direct Kar denge

[@shaileshkanake5377]

No its not..at least they have safeguarded the Queer Rights..in future you never know...😊

[@ameetlibran9845]

I agree with you, it's utterly Shamefull I.e in 2023 Law & Order of India doesn't have balls.

[@dryash866]

@@ameetlibran9845 can't agree more🥲and people who have rubber Balls started to celebrate as if it's an achievement😂 thing over here sc didn't ban marriages instead simply stated it should be decided by parliament infact

[@sandalbasotra5765]

Again the super court saved sense. Thank God. I hope the BJP prevails and saves us from nonsense.

[@meghanath5045]

Lol

[@dryash866]

Y r u super happy 😂what did u get out of it did supreme say it's not allowed to marry into same sex ?

[@ultimateriderofficial]

@@dryash866 is community bahut zyada bakwas kar raha hai.inko dhakke marke nikala Jaye aur terrorist ghosit kar dena chahiye

[@user-ok7nw3hd4k]

Yeah, two individuals who love each other are such a massive threat to your life, got it.

[@sandalbasotra5765]

Nature is not perfect. It makes some mistakes. 99.9% is always right. And glorified mistakes are nonsense. And where does this LGBTQ+++++++ STOPS.

[@fire-00-7]

Don't fall for western culture

[@ultimateriderofficial]

This lgbtq should be banned completely in india .

[@virtus8798]

U do realise Hinduism has been open to homosexuality and transgenders.

[@ultimateriderofficial]

@@virtus8798 Hinduism completely against lgbtq nonsense activity.manusmriti padhle aur punishment baaren main bhi padhle

[@rajeevidayakumar4468]

​@@virtus8798 they don't care about that bro, they just hate ppl and will say anything to show their hatred

[@dryash866]

For what ? Did the homosexuals rape you or killed you😂

[@ultimateriderofficial]

@@dryash866 bharat main ab chaake ki number badh gayi hai.kripya inko bharat se nikala Jaya aur America aur cannada bhej diya jaye

[@sachbol3912]

Bharat is Bharat , let not woke CJI mess this nations cultural fabric under the influence of foreign wokeism and some sections in this country still are remote controlled by foreign powers. Lets stay what is natural and not go against the grain. Can someone explain what happens when +ve and +ve charge wires are combined? Does it power our devices?

[@kshitijbhoge3349]

Go and do a little bit research on the Ancient Bharat yourself first (only if you’re an avid reader) . You will realise The Ancient Bharat has always been welcoming to the LGBTQ community until the British invaded us and instilled their homophobic laws upon us. Check the various sculptures of Khajuraho , Ajanta and ancient scriptures , you will realise what I’m saying. Only if y’all had that REAL academic touch. You people are simply jealous of people who study and are smart. And to make yourself feel better you call them “woke” , “liberal” and what not. I know you people have no shit to give about the actual history of our nation. You just want to hate because you could never love yourself.

[@betrue755]

😂😂wow,,,sounds cool. A cool fool